Evolution of the mitochondrial genetic code II. Reassignment of codon AUA from isoleucine to methionine

Summary The reassignment of codon AUA from isoleucine to methionine during mitochondrial evolution may be explained by the codon reassignment (capture) hypothesis without assuming direct replacement of isoleucine by methionine in mitochondrial proteins. According to this hypothesis, codon AUA would have disappeared from the reading frames of messenger RNA. AUA codons would have mutated mainly to AUU isoleucine codons because of constraints resulting from elimination of tRNA Ile with anticodon *CAU (in which *C is lysidine). Later, tRNA Met (CAU) would have undergone structural changes enabling it to pair with both AUG and AUA. AUA codons, formed by mutations of other codons, including AUG, would have reappeared and would have been translated as methionine.     

Identification and codon reading properties of 5-cyanomethyl uridine,a new modified nucleoside found in the anticodon wobble position of mutant haloarchaeal isoleucine tRNAs

Most archaea and bacteria use a modified C in the anticodon wobble position of isoleucine tRNA to base pair with A but not with G of the mRNA. This allows the tRNA to read the isoleucine codon AUA without also reading the methionine codon AUG. To understand why a modified C, and not U or modified U, is used to base pair with A, we mutated the C34 in the anticodon of Haloarcula marismortui isoleucine tRNA (tRNA₂^Ile) to U, expressed the mutant tRNA in Haloferax volcanii, and purified and analyzed the tRNA. Ribosome binding experiments show that although the wild-type tRNA₂^Ile binds exclusively to the isoleucine codon AUA, the mutant tRNA binds not only to AUA but also to AUU, another isoleucine codon, and to AUG, a methionine codon. The G34 to U mutant in the anticodon of another H. marismortui isoleucine tRNA species showed similar codon binding properties. Binding of the mutant tRNA to AUG could lead to misreading of the AUG codon and insertion of isoleucine in place of methionine. This result would explain why most archaea and bacteria do not normally use U or a modified U in the anticodon wobble position of isoleucine tRNA for reading the codon AUA. Biochemical and mass spectrometric analyses of the mutant tRNAs have led to the discovery of a new modified nucleoside, 5-cyanomethyl U in the anticodon wobble position of the mutant tRNAs. 5-Cyanomethyl U is present in total tRNAs from euryarchaea but not in crenarchaea, eubacteria, or eukaryotes.     

Codon reading patterns in Drosophila melanogaster mitochondria based on their tRNA sequences: a unique wobble rule in animal mitochondria.

Mitochondrial (mt) tRNA(Trp), tRNA(Ile), tRNA(Met), tRNA(Ser)GCU, tRNA(Asn)and tRNA(Lys)were purified from Drosophila melanogaster (fruit fly) and their nucleotide sequences were determined. tRNA(Lys)corresponding to both AAA and AAG lysine codons was found to contain the anticodon CUU, C34 at the wobble position being unmodified. tRNA(Met)corresponding to both AUA and AUG methionine codons was found to contain 5-formylcytidine (f(5)C) at the wobble position, although the extent of modification is partial. These results suggest that both C and f(5)C as the wobble bases at the anticodon first position (position 34) can recognize A at the codon third position (position 3) in the fruit fly mt translation system. tRNA(Ser)GCU corresponding to AGU, AGC and AGA serine codons was found to contain unmodified G at the anticodon wobble position, suggesting the utilization of an unconventional G34-A3 base pair during translation. When these tRNA anticodon sequences are compared with those of other animal counterparts, it is concluded that either unmodified C or G at the wobble position can recognize A at the codon third position and that modification from A to t(6)A at position 37, 3'-adjacent to the anticodon, seems to be important for tRNA possessing C34 to recognize A3 in the mRNA in the fruit fly mt translation system.     

Conflict between translation initiation and elongation in vertebrate mitochondrial genomes

The strand-biased mutation spectrum in vertebrate mitochondrial genomes results in an AC-rich L-strand and a GT-rich H-strand. Because the L-strand is the sense strand of 12 protein-coding genes out of the 13, the third codon position is overall strongly AC-biased. The wobble site of the anticodon of the 22 mitochondrial tRNAs is either U or G to pair with the most abundant synonymous codon, with only one exception. The wobble site of Met-tRNA is C instead of U, forming the Watson-Crick match with AUG instead of AUA, the latter being much more frequent than the former. This has been attributed to a compromise between translation initiation and elongation; i.e., AUG is not only a methionine codon, but also an initiation codon, and an anticodon matching AUG will increase the initiation rate. However, such an anticodon would impose selection against the use of AUA codons because AUA needs to be wobble-translated. According to this translation conflict hypothesis, AUA should be used relatively less frequently compared to UUA in the UUR codon family. A comprehensive analysis of mitochondrial genomes from a variety of vertebrate species revealed a general deficiency of AUA codons relative to UUA codons. In contrast, urochordate mitochondrial genomes with two tRNA(Met) genes with CAU and UAU anticodons exhibit increased AUA codon usage. Furthermore, six bivalve mitochondrial genomes with both of their tRNA-Met genes with a CAU anticodon have reduced AUA usage relative to three other bivalve mitochondrial genomes with one of their two tRNA-Met genes having a CAU anticodon and the other having a UAU anticodon. We conclude that the translation conflict hypothesis is empirically supported, and our results highlight the fine details of selection in shaping molecular evolution.     

Identification and characterization of a tRNA decoding the rare AUA codon in Haloarcula marismortui

Annotation of the complete genome of the extreme halophilic archaeon Haloarcula marismortui does not include a tRNA for translation of AUA, the rare codon for isoleucine. This is a situation typical for most archaeal genomes sequenced to date. Based on computational analysis, it has been proposed recently that a single intron-containing tRNA gene produces two very similar but functionally different tRNAs by means of alternative splicing; a UGG-decoding tRNA(TrpCCA) and an AUA-decoding tRNA(IleUAU). Through analysis of tRNAs from H. marismortui, we have confirmed the presence of tRNA(TrpCCA), but found no evidence for the presence of tRNA(IleUAU). Instead, we have shown that a tRNA, currently annotated as elongator methionine tRNA and containing CAU as the anticodon, is aminoacylated with isoleucine in vivo and that this tRNA represents the missing isoleucine tRNA. Interestingly, this tRNA carries a base modification of C34 in the anticodon different from the well-known lysidine found in eubacteria, which switches the amino acid identity of the tRNA from methionine to isoleucine and its decoding specificity from AUG to AUA. The methods described in this work for the identification of individual tRNAs present in H. marismortui provide the tools necessary for experimentally confirming the presence of any tRNA in a cell and, thereby, to test computational predictions of tRNA genes.     

Methionine on the rise: how mitochondria changed their codon usage

The tRNA specific for methionine (tRNA^Met) of human mitochondria contains a formyl‐cytosine at the wobble position of the anticodon to facilitate its binding to AUG, AUA and (in one instance) to AUU. In this issue of The EMBO Journal, Haag et al identify a two‐step enzyme pathway facilitating the modification of the tRNA. Sequential reactions of the methyltransferase NSUN3 and the dioxygenase ALKBH1/ABH1 are important to render the tRNA as able to recognize the non‐canonical methionine codons AUA and AUUs, a property critical for efficient protein synthesis in human mitochondria.     

Nucleotide sequences of animal mitochondrial tRNAs(Met) possibly recognizing both AUG and AUA codons.

To elucidate the role of modified nucleosides of tRNA in mitochondrial translation systems, especially with regard to their codon recognition, we purified mitochondrial tRNAs(Met) isolated from liver of frog, chicken and rat, and determined their nucleotide sequences. All of these tRNAs(Met) were found to possess 5-formylcytidine in the first letter of the anticodon, which is known to be prerequisite for bovine mt tRNA(Met) to decode AUA codon as well as AUG codon. These tRNA possesses two pseudeuridines in similar positions, and only chicken tRNA(Met) had ribothymidine at the first position of the T-loop, which is always found in the usual tRNAs. Considering that AUA codon is used as five times frequently as AUG codon in these animal mitochondrial genomes, it is deduced that 5-formylcytidine at the wobble position is essential for the recognition of both AUA and AUG codons.     

NSUN3 and ABH1 modify the wobble position of mt‐tRNAMet to expand codon recognition in mitochondrial translation

Mitochondrial gene expression uses a non‐universal genetic code in mammals. Besides reading the conventional AUG codon, mitochondrial (mt‐)tRNA^Met mediates incorporation of methionine on AUA and AUU codons during translation initiation and on AUA codons during elongation. We show that the RNA methyltransferase NSUN3 localises to mitochondria and interacts with mt‐tRNA^Met to methylate cytosine 34 (C34) at the wobble position. NSUN3 specifically recognises the anticodon stem loop (ASL) of the tRNA, explaining why a mutation that compromises ASL basepairing leads to disease. We further identify ALKBH1/ABH1 as the dioxygenase responsible for oxidising m⁵C34 of mt‐tRNA^Met to generate an f⁵C34 modification. In vitro codon recognition studies with mitochondrial translation factors reveal preferential utilisation of m⁵C34 mt‐tRNA^Met in initiation. Depletion of either NSUN3 or ABH1 strongly affects mitochondrial translation in human cells, implying that modifications generated by both enzymes are necessary for mt‐tRNA^Met function. Together, our data reveal how modifications in mt‐tRNA^Met are generated by the sequential action of NSUN3 and ABH1, allowing the single mitochondrial tRNA^Met to recognise the different codons encoding methionine.     

The RNA acetyltransferase driven by ATP hydrolysis synthesizes N4-acetylcytidine of tRNA anticodon

The wobble base of Escherichia coli elongator tRNA(Met) is modified to N(4)-acetylcytidine (ac(4)C), which is thought to ensure the precise recognition of the AUG codon by preventing misreading of near-cognate AUA codon. By employing genome-wide screen of uncharacterized genes in Escherichia coli ('ribonucleome analysis'), we found the ypfI gene, which we named tmcA (tRNA(Met) cytidine acetyltransferase), to be responsible for ac(4)C formation. TmcA is an enzyme that contains a Walker-type ATPase domain in its N-terminal region and an N-acetyltransferase domain in its C-terminal region. Recombinant TmcA specifically acetylated the wobble base of E. coli elongator tRNA(Met) by utilizing acetyl-coenzyme A (CoA) and ATP (or GTP). ATP/GTP hydrolysis by TmcA is stimulated in the presence of acetyl-CoA and tRNA(Met). A mutation study revealed that E. coli TmcA strictly discriminates elongator tRNA(Met) from the structurally similar tRNA(Ile) by mainly recognizing the C27-G43 pair in the anticodon stem. Our findings reveal an elaborate mechanism embedded in tRNA(Met) and tRNA(Ile) for the accurate decoding of AUA/AUG codons on the basis of the recognition of wobble bases by the respective RNA-modifying enzymes.     

Taurine-containing uridine modifications in tRNA anticodons are required to decipher non-universal genetic codes in ascidian mitochondria

Variations in the genetic code are found frequently in mitochondrial decoding systems. Four non-universal genetic codes are employed in ascidian mitochondria: AUA for Met, UGA for Trp, and AGA/AGG(AGR) for Gly. To clarify the decoding mechanism for the non-universal genetic codes, we isolated and analyzed mitochondrial tRNAs for Trp, Met, and Gly from an ascidian, Halocynthia roretzi. Mass spectrometric analysis identified 5-taurinomethyluridine (τm(5)U) at the anticodon wobble positions of tRNA(Met)(AUR), tRNA(Trp)(UGR), and tRNA(Gly)(AGR), suggesting that τm(5)U plays a critical role in the accurate deciphering of all four non-universal codes by preventing the misreading of pyrimidine-ending near-cognate codons (NNY) in their respective family boxes. Acquisition of the wobble modification appears to be a prerequisite for the genetic code alteration.     

Mutation and selection on the anticodon of tRNA genes in vertebrate mitochondrial genomes

The H-strand of vertebrate mitochondrial DNA is left single-stranded for hours during the slow DNA replication. This facilitates C-->U mutations on the H-strand (and consequently G-->A mutations on the L-strand) via spontaneous deamination which occurs much more frequently on single-stranded than on double-stranded DNA. For the 12 coding sequences (CDS) collinear with the L-strand, NNY synonymous codon families (where N stands for any of the four nucleotides and Y stands for either C or U) end mostly with C, and NNR and NNN codon families (where R stands for either A or G) end mostly with A. For the lone ND6 gene on the other strand, the codon bias is the opposite, with NNY codon families ending mostly with U and NNR and NNN codon families ending mostly with G. These patterns are consistent with the strand-specific mutation bias. The codon usage biased towards C-ending and A-ending in the 12 CDS sequences affects the codon-anticodon adaptation. The wobble site of the anticodon is always G for NNY codon families dominated by C-ending codons and U for NNR and NNN codon families dominated by A-ending codons. The only, but consistent, exception is the anticodon of tRNA-Met which consistently has a 5'-CAU-3' anticodon base-pairing with the AUG codon (the translation initiation codon) instead of the more frequent AUA. The observed CAU anticodon (matching AUG) would increase the rate of translation initiation but would reduce the rate of peptide elongation because most methionine codons are AUA, whereas the unobserved UAU anticodon (matching AUA) would increase the elongation rate at the cost of translation initiation rate. The consistent CAU anticodon in tRNA-Met suggests the importance of maximizing the rate of translation initiation.     

Binding of the anticodon domain of tRNA(fMet) to Escherichia coli methionyl-tRNA synthetase

A stem and loop RNA domain carrying the methionine anticodon (CAU) was designed from the tRNA(fMet) sequence and produced in vitro. This domain makes a complex with methionyl-tRNA synthetase (Kd = 38(+/- 5) microM; 25 degrees C, pH 7.6, 7 mM-MgCl2). The formation of this complex is dependent on the presence of the cognate CAU anticodon sequence. Recognition of this RNA domain is abolished by a methionyl-tRNA synthetase mutation known to alter the binding of tRNA(Met).     

A deviant genetic code in the green alga-derived plastid in the dinoflagellate Lepidodinium chlorophorum

We here report a deviant genetic code, in which AUA is read as methionine (Met) instead of isoleucine (Ile), in the green alga-derived plastid in the dinoflagellate Lepidodinium chlorophorum. Although L. chlorophorum cDNA sequences of 11 plastid-encoded genes were deposited in the GenBank database, the non-canonical usage of AUA in this dinoflagellate plastid has been overlooked prior to this study. We compared 11 plastid-encoded genes of L. chlorophorum with the corresponding genes of 17 green algal plastids. Intriguingly, AUA often occurred in the L. chlorophorum sequences at codon positions that are predominantly occupied by Met amongst the green algal sequences. Coincidentally, the L. chlorophorum sequences utilized few AUA codons at the positions predominantly occupied by Ile amongst the green algal sequences. These observations clearly indicated that both AUA and AUG encode Met, while AUU and AUC encode Ile, in the L. chlorophorum plastid. Despite the rapidly-evolving nature of L. chlorophorum plastid-encoded genes, our statistical tests incorporating the deviant code suggest no significant difference in amino acid composition among the L. chlorophorum plastid and the green algal plastids considered in this study. Finally, the possible evolutionary events required for the reassignment of AUA from Ile to Met in Lepitodinium plastids were discussed.     

Modification of orthogonal tRNAs: unexpected consequences for sense codon reassignment

Breaking the degeneracy of the genetic code via sense codon reassignment has emerged as a way to incorporate multiple copies of multiple non-canonical amino acids into a protein of interest. Here, we report the modification of a normally orthogonal tRNA by a host enzyme and show that this adventitious modification has a direct impact on the activity of the orthogonal tRNA in translation. We observed nearly equal decoding of both histidine codons, CAU and CAC, by an engineered orthogonal M. jannaschii tRNA with an AUG anticodon: tRNA^Opt. We suspected a modification of the tRNA^Opt_AUG anticodon was responsible for the anomalous lack of codon discrimination and demonstrate that adenosine 34 of tRNA^Opt_AUG is converted to inosine. We identified tRNA^Opt_AUG anticodon loop variants that increase reassignment of the histidine CAU codon, decrease incorporation in response to the histidine CAC codon, and improve cell health and growth profiles. Recognizing tRNA modification as both a potential pitfall and avenue of directed alteration will be important as the field of genetic code engineering continues to infiltrate the genetic codes of diverse organisms.