The conversion gradient at HIS4 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. I. Heteroduplex rejection and restoration of Mendelian segregation.

In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, some gene loci manifest gradients in the frequency of aberrant segregation in meiosis, with the high end of each gradient corresponding to a hotspot for DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). The slope of a gradient is reduced when mismatch repair functions fail to act upon heteroduplex DNA-aberrant segregation frequencies at the low end of the gradient are higher in the absence of mismatch repair. Two models for the role of mismatch repair functions in the generation of meiotic "conversion gradients" have been proposed. The heteroduplex rejection model suggests that recognition of mismatches by mismatch repair enzymes limits hybrid DNA flanking the site of a DSB. The restoration-conversion model proposes that mismatch repair does not affect the length of hybrid DNA, but instead increasingly favors restoration of Mendelian segregation over full conversion with increasing distance from the DSB site. In our experiment designed to distinguish between these two models, data for one subset of well repairable mismatches in the HIS4 gene failed to show restoration-type repair but did indicate reduction in the length of hybrid DNA, supporting the heteroduplex rejection model. However, another subset of data manifested restoration-type repair, indicating a relationship between Holliday junction resolution and mismatch repair. We also present evidence for the infrequent formation of symmetric hybrid DNA during meiotic DSB repair.     

Biochemical analysis of genetic recombination in eukaryotes.

Recent studies concerning molecular mechanisms of genetic recombination in eukaryotes are reviewed. Since many of these studies have focused on the testable predictions arising from the hybrid DNA theory of genetic recombination, this theory is summarised. Experiments to determine the time of meiotic crossing-over and the structure of the synaptonemal complex which facilitates meiotic crossing-over are described. Investigations of DNA nicking and repair events implicated in recombination are discussed. Properties of proteins which may facilitate hybrid DNA formation, and biochemical evidence for hybrid DNA formation are presented. Finally, a nuclease which has been implicated in gene conversion is described.     

A general method for identifying correct solutions in the quantitative analysis of gene conversion data

Past attempts to obtain values for meiotic parameters relating to hybrid DNA formation and the correction of mismatched bases in hybrid DNA have not given unique solutions unless various simplifying assumptions were made. A method is given for identifying correct sets of solutions after calculating the frequency of hybrid DNA formation at a heterozygous site and using the fact that closely linked sites within a locus have very similar hybrid DNA formation frequencies. The method is illustrated with simulated data and Sordaria fimicola data; it can also show up incorrect assumptions in analysis. A method is suggested for assessing the importance of double-strand gaps in producing conversions.     

Variation of gene conversion and intragenic recombination frequencies in the genome of Ascobolus immersus.

Summary Eighty mutants in 17 ascospore character genes were studied for their conversion patterns. The correlation between conversion pattern and mutagenic origin, previously found in genes b1 and b2 was extended to all the genes studied. Aberrant 4:4 asci were found in most genes irrespective of their conversion frequency. From gene to gene, the conversion frequency showed an almost 100 times variation. The frequency of intragenic recombination also showed sharp variation from gene to gene. The mean conversion frequency and the maximal intragenic recombination frequency were shown to be highly correlated in 5 genes for which these 2 values are known. This correlation was extended to 12 other genes in other Ascomycetes: Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Schizosaccharomyces pombe, Neurospora, and Sordaria. From this study it is concluded that, 1) the probability of hybrid DNA formation undergoes considerable changes according to the region of the genome; 2) the intragenic recombination frequency primarily reflects the frequency of hybrid DNA formation rather than the physical length of the gene; 3) for a given physical distance on the DNA, a similar fraction of the gene conversion events lead to recombination in the 5 Ascomycetes.     

Biased gene conversion and asymmetrical introgression between subspecies

Data from chromosomal in situ hybridization and restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) of ribosomal DNA (rDNA) obtained from the same individuals of two subspecies of the Australian grasshopper Caledia captiva, suggest the occurrence of biased exchange of DNA sequences in hybrid individuals. Thus, there are a disproportionate number of Torresian individuals that possess Moreton ribosomal RNA gene sequences. This bias correlates with the previously described pattern of asymmetrical introgression of Moreton rDNA into Torresian populations. The present findings demonstrate the potential effect of biased gene conversion on the frequencies of introduced gene variants.     

Gene Conversion at the Gray Locus of SORDARIA FIMICOLA: Fit of the Experimental Data to a Hybrid DNA Model of Recombination

A hybrid DNA (hDNA) model of recombination has been algebraically formulated, which allows the prediction of frequencies of postmeiotic segregation and conversion of a given allele and their probability of being associated with a crossing over. The model considered is essentially the "Aviemore model." In contrast to some other interpretations of recombination, it states that gene conversion can only result from the repair of heteroduplex hDNA, with postmeiotic segregation resulting from unrepaired heteroduplexes. The model also postulates that crossing over always occurs distally to the initiation site of the hDNA. Eleven types of conversion and postmeiotic segregation with or without associated crossover were considered. Their theoretical frequencies are given by 11 linear equations with ten variables, four describing heteroduplex repair, four giving the probability of hDNA formation and its topological properties and two giving the probability that crossing over occurs at the left or right of the converting allele. Using the experimental data of Kitani and coworkers on conversion at the six best studied gray alleles of Sordaria fimicola, we found that the model considered fit the data at a P level above or very close (allele h4) to the 5% level of sampling error provided that the hDNA is partly asymmetric. The best fitting solutions are such that the hDNA has an equal probability of being formed on either chromatid or, alternatively, that both DNA strands have the same probability of acting as the invading strand during hDNA formation. The two mismatches corresponding to a given allele are repaired with different efficiencies. Optimal solutions are found if one allows for repair to be more efficient on the asymmetric hDNA than on the symmetric one. In the case of allele g1, our data imply that the direction of repair is nonrandom with respect to the strand on which it occurs.     

The estimation of conversion parameters and the control of conversion in Ascobolus immersus

Summary Pasadena strains of Ascobolus immersus were used to study the controls of gene conversion. Formulae were derived for estimating conversion parameters according to different hybrid DNA models of recombination. Genetic factors influencing conversion were determined by using genetically different isolates and using alleles before and after they had undergone conversion. Conversion properties at particular sites were greatly affected by genetic factors very near to those sites: the nature of the mutations and factors elsewhere in the genome were much less important. These genetic factors and temperature both affected the frequency of hybrid DNA formation at particular sites, the efficiency of mispair correction and the relative frequencies of correction to wild-type or mutant. The effects of temperature on conversion parameters were usually complex.     

CYS3, a hotspot of meiotic recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Effects of heterozygosity and mismatch repair functions on gene conversion and recombination intermediates

We have examined meiotic recombination at the CYS3 locus. Genetic analysis indicates that CYS3 is a hotspot of meiotic gene conversion, with a putative 5'-3' polarity gradient of conversion frequencies. This gradient is relieved in the presence of msh2 and pms1 mutations, indicating an involvement of mismatch repair functions in meiotic recombination. To investigate the role of mismatch repair proteins in meiotic recombination, we performed a physical analysis of meiotic DNA in wild-type and msh2 pms1 strains in the presence or absence of allelic differences at CYS3. Neither the mutations in CYS3 nor the absence of mismatch repair functions affects the frequency and distribution of nearby recombination-initiating DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). Processing of DSBs is also similar in msh2 pms1 and wild-type strains. We conclude that mismatch repair functions do not control the distribution of meiotic gene conversion events at the initiating steps. In the MSH2 PMS1 background, strains heteroallelic for frameshift mutations in CYS3 exhibit a frequency of gene conversion greater than that observed for either marker alone. Physical analysis revealed no modification in the formation of DSBs, suggesting that this marker effect results from subsequent processing events that are not yet understood.     

Different pathways of homologous recombination are used for the repair of double-strand breaks within tandemly arranged sequences in the plant genome

Different DNA repair pathways that use homologous sequences in close proximity to genomic double-strand breaks (DSBs) result in either an internal deletion or a gene conversion. We determined the efficiency of these pathways in somatic plant cells of transgenic Arabidopsis lines by monitoring the restoration of the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) marker gene. The transgenes contain a recognition site for the restriction endonuclease I-SceI either between direct GUS repeats to detect deletion formation (DGU.US), or within the GUS gene to detect gene conversion using a nearby donor sequence in direct or inverted orientation (DU.GUS and IU.GUS). Without expression of I-SceI, the frequency of homologous recombination (HR) was low and similar for all three constructs. By crossing the different lines with an I-SceI expressing line, DSB repair was induced, and resulted in one to two orders of magnitude higher recombination frequency. The frequencies obtained with the DGU.US construct were about five times higher than those obtained with DU.GUS and IU.GUS, irrespective of the orientation of the donor sequence. Our results indicate that recombination associated with deletions is the most efficient pathway of homologous DSB repair in plants. However, DSB-induced gene conversion seems to be frequent enough to play a significant role in the evolution of tandemly arranged gene families like resistance genes.     

Efficient repair of DNA breaks in Drosophila: evidence for single-strand annealing and competition with other repair pathways

We show evidence that DNA double-strand breaks induced in the Drosophila germ line can be repaired very efficiently by the single-strand annealing (SSA) mechanism. A double-strand break was made between two copies of a 1290-bp direct repeat by mobilizing a P transposon. In >80% of the progeny that acquired this chromosome, repair resulted in loss of the P element and loss of one copy of the repeat, as observed in SSA. The frequency of this repair was much greater than seen for gene conversion using an allelic template, which is only approximately 7%. A similar structure, but with a smaller duplication of only 158 bp, also yielded SSA-like repair events, but at a reduced frequency, and gave rise to some products by repair pathways other than SSA. The 1290-bp repeats carried two sequence polymorphisms that were examined in the products. The allele nearest to a nick in the putative heteroduplex intermediate was lost most often. This bias is predicted by the SSA model, although other models could account for it. We conclude that SSA is the preferred repair pathway in Drosophila for DNA breaks between sequence repeats, and it competes with gene conversion by the synthesis-dependent strand annealing (SDSA) pathway.     

Strand specificity for UV-induced DNA repair and mutations in the Chinese hamster HPRT gene.

DNA excision repair modulates the mutagenic effect of many genotoxic agents. The recently observed strand specificity for removal of UV-induced cyclobutane dimers from actively transcribed genes in mammalian cells could influence the nature and distribution of mutations in a particular gene. To investigate this, we have analyzed UV-induced DNA repair and mutagenesis in the same gene, i.e. the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyl-transferase (hprt) gene. In 23 hprt mutants from V79 Chinese hamster cells induced by 2 J/m2 UV we found a strong strand bias for mutation induction: assuming that pre-mutagenic lesions occur at dipyrimidine sequences, 85% of the mutations could be attributed to lesions in the nontranscribed strand. Analysis of DNA repair in the hprt gene revealed that more than 90% of the cyclobutane dimers were removed from the transcribed strand within 8 hours after irradiation with 10 J/m2 UV, whereas virtually no dimer removal could be detected from the nontranscribed strand even up to 24 hr after UV. These data present the first proof that strand specific repair of DNA lesions in an expressed mammalian gene is associated with a strand specificity for mutation induction.     

The effects of mispair and nonpair correction in hybrid DNA on base ratios (G + C content) and total amounts of DNA

Base ratios and total DNA amounts can vary substantially between and within higher taxa and genera, and even within species. Gene conversion is one of several mechanisms that could cause such changes. For base substitutions, disparity in conversion direction is accompanied by an equivalent disparity in base ratio at the heterozygous site. Disparity in the direction of gene conversion at meiosis is common and can be extreme. For transitions (which give purine [R]/pyrimidine [Y] mispairs) and for transversions giving unlike R/R and Y/Y mispairs in hybrid DNA, this disparity could give slow but systematic changes in G + C percentage. For transversions giving like R/R and Y/Y mispairs, it could change AT/TA and CG/GC ratios. From the extent of correction direction disparity, one can deduce properties of repair enzymes, such as the ability (1) to excise preferentially the purine from one mispair and the pyrimidine from the other for two different R/Y mispairs from a single heterozygous site and (2) to excise one base preferentially from unlike R/R or Y/Y mispairs. Frame-shifts usually show strong disparity in conversion direction, with preferential cutting of the nonlooped or the looped-out strand of the nonpair in heterozygous h-DNA. The opposite directions of disparity for frame-shifts and their intragenic suppressors as Ascobolus suggest that repair enzymes have a strong, systematic bias as to which strand is cut. The conversion spectra of mutations induced with different mutagens suggest that the nonlooped strand is preferentially cut, so that base additions generally convert to mutant and deletions generally convert to wild-type forms. Especially in nonfunctional or noncoding DNA, this could cause a general increase in DNA amounts. Conversion disparity, selection, mutation, and other processes interact, affecting rates of change in base ratios and total DNA.      

Damage formation and repair efficiency in the p53 gene of cell lines and blood lymphocytes assayed by multiplex long quantitative polymerase chain reaction

We examined ultraviolet (UV) irradiation and cisplatin treatment damage formation and repair efficiency in the p53 tumor suppressor gene of various cultured cell lines and lymphocytes using a nonradioactive multiplex long quantitative polymerase chain reaction (QPCR) assay, which amplified a 7-kb fragment of the target gene and a 500-bp fragment of the template control to successfully increase the sensitivity and reliability of the assay. The multiplex long QPCR detected a lesion frequency of 0.63 lesions/10kb/10J/m(2) in the p53 gene of fibroblast cells. In addition, the multiplex long QPCR assay detected pronounced differences in the repair of UV damage in the p53 gene among repair-proficient CRL-1475 cells and repair-deficient XP-A and XP-C cells. The multiplex long QPCR assay was also evaluated as a sensitive assay for the detection of DNA damage induced by cisplatin. The data indicated that the lesion frequency in the p53 gene was 1.27-1.75 times higher in the H23 cisplatin-sensitive cell than in the H1435 cisplatin-resistant cell at the IC(70) dose. After 8-h and 24-h repair periods, only 13 and 75% of cisplatin-induced damage had been removed in the H23 cells, whereas these values were 92 and 100% in the H1435 cells. In addition, our data indicate that multiplex long QPCR is a sensitive method for validly estimating repair in freshly isolated lymphocytes. The results suggest that the current protocol of the multiplex long QPCR method can be used to assess the damage formation and repair efficiency of various agents at biologically relevant doses and to allow a more precise determination of gene-specific repair in disease susceptibility and drug resistance in epidemiological studies.     

The conversion gradient at HIS4 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. II. A role for mismatch repair directed by biased resolution of the recombinational intermediate.

Salient features of recombination at ARG4 of Saccharomyces provoke a variation of the double-strand-break repair (DSBR) model that has the following features: (1) Holliday junction cutting is biased in favor of strands upon which DNA synthesis occurred during formation of the joint molecule (this bias ensures that cutting both junctions of the joint-molecule intermediate arising during DSBR usually leads to crossing over); (2) cutting only one junction gives noncrossovers; and (3) repair of mismatches that are semirefractory to mismatch repair and/or far from the DSB site is directed primarily by junction resolution. The bias in junction resolution favors restoration of 4:4 segregation when such mismatches and the directing junction are on the same side of the DSB site. Studies at HIS4 confirmed the predicted influence of the bias in junction resolution on the conversion gradient, type of mismatch repair, and frequency of aberrant 5:3 segregation, as well as the predicted relationship between mismatch repair and crossing over.     

In vivo gene repair of point and frameshift mutations directed by chimeric RNA/DNA oligonucleotides and modified single-stranded oligonucleotides

Synthetic oligonucleotides have been used to direct base exchange and gene repair in a variety of organisms. Among the most promising vectors is chimeric oligonucleotide (CO), a double-stranded, RNA–DNA hybrid molecule folded into a double hairpin conformation: by using the cell’s DNA repair machinery, the CO directs nucleotide exchange as episomal and chromosomal DNA. Systematic dissection of the CO revealed that the region of contiguous DNA bases was the active component in the repair process, especially when the single-stranded ends were protected against nuclease attack. Here, the utility of this vector is expanded into Saccharomyces cerevisiae. An episome containing a mutated fusion gene encoding hygromycin resistance and eGFP expression was used as the target for repair. Substitution, deletion and insertion mutations were corrected with different frequencies by the same modified single-stranded vector as judged by growth in the presence of hygromycin and eGFP expression. A substitution mutation was repaired the most efficiently followed by insertion and finally deletion mutants. A strand bias for gene repair was also observed; vectors designed to direct the repair of nucleotide on the non-transcribed (non-template) strand displayed a 5–10-fold higher level of activity. Expanding the length of the oligo-vector from 25 to 100 nucleotides increases targeting frequency up to a maximal level and then it decreases. These results, obtained in a genetically tractable organism, contribute to the elucidation of the mechanism of targeted gene repair.     

Heterogeneity of nitrogen mustard-induced DNA damage and repair at the level of the gene in Chinese hamster ovary cells

We here present a general method to detect alkylation damage in specific genomic regions. Cells are treated with nitrogen mustard or dimethyl sulfate; the DNA is extracted and restricted, and the parental DNA is separated. Strand breaks are created at sites of N-alkylpurines by neutral depurination followed by alkaline hydrolysis. The DNA is then separated on alkaline agarose gels and transferred, and gene fragments are detected after hybridization with specific probes. Using this approach, we have examined damage formation and repair in the active genes dihydrofolate reductase and adenosine phosphoribosyltransferase, in a fragment containing the inactive c-fos gene and in a nontranscribed region downstream from the dihydrofolate reductase gene in Chinese hamster ovary cells. We find variations in the formation of nitrogen mustard adducts in these different regions. Nitrogen mustard adducts are preferentially repaired from the active genes as compared to the inactive gene and the noncoding region. However, we find no preferential damage or repair in these regions of the N7-methylpurines after dimethyl sulfate damage. Thus, there are significant differences in the repair mechanisms for two alkylating agents; this may implicate that there are important differences in the structural alterations in chromatin invoked by these agents. As a comparison to the studies of adduct levels in specific genomic regions, we have examined the overall genome, average adduct formation, and repair by these agents in the hamster cells. We used alkaline sucrose gradient sedimentation, and also a novel approach: quantitation of the DNA smears stained by ethidium bromide in the alkaline gels (used in the gene-selective repair analysis). Both these techniques gave similar data for adduct formation and repair; there was less initial damage formation and repair in the average genome than in specific genomic regions.     

Gene conversion adjacent to regions of double-strand break repair.

The repair of double-strand breaks and gaps can be studied in vegetative yeast cells by transforming the DNA with restriction enzyme-cut plasmids. Postulated models for this repair process require the formation of heteroduplex DNA on either side of the region of break or gap repair. We describe the use of restriction site mutations in the his3 gene to detect conversion events flanking but outside of a region of a double-strand break repair. The frequency with which a mutation was converted declined with increasing distance between the mutation and the edge of the gap repair region. The data are consistent with heteroduplex DNA tracts of at least several hundred base pairs adjacent to regions of double-strand break repair.     

Chromatin dynamics during cell cycle mediate conversion of DNA damage into chromatid breaks and affect formation of chromosomal aberrations: biological and clinical significance

The formation of diverse chromosomal aberrations following irradiation and the variability in radiosensitivity at different cell-cycle stages remain a long standing controversy, probably because most of the studies have focused on elucidating the enzymatic mechanisms involved using simple DNA substrates. Yet, recognition, processing and repair of DNA damage occur within the nucleoprotein complex of chromatin which is dynamic in nature, capable of rapid unfolding, disassembling, assembling and refolding. The present work reviews experimental work designed to investigate the impact of chromatin dynamics and chromosome conformation changes during cell-cycle in the formation of chromosomal aberrations. Using conventional cytogenetics and premature chromosome condensation to visualize interphase chromatin, the data presented support the hypothesis that chromatin dynamic changes during cell-cycle are important determinants in the conversion of sub-microscopic DNA lesions into chromatid breaks. Consequently, the type and yield of radiation-induced chromosomal aberrations at a given cell-cycle-stage depends on the combined effect of DNA repair processes and chromatin dynamics, which is cell-cycle-regulated and subject to up- or down-regulation following radiation exposure or genetic alterations. This new hypothesis is used to explain the variability in radiosensitivity observed at various cell-cycle-stages, among mutant cells and cells of different origin, or among different individuals, and to revisit unresolved issues and unanswered questions. In addition, it is used to better understand hypersensitivity of AT cells and to provide an improved predictive G2-assay for evaluating radiosensitivity at individual level. Finally, experimental data at single cell level obtained using hybrid cells suggest that the proposed hypothesis applies only to the irradiated component of the hybrid.     

Gene Conversion Tracts from Double-Strand Break Repair in Mammalian Cells

Mammalian cells are able to repair chromosomal double-strand breaks (DSBs) both by homologous recombination and by mechanisms that require little or no homology. Although spontaneous homologous recombination is rare, DSBs will stimulate recombination by 2 to 3 orders of magnitude when homology is provided either from exogenous DNA in gene-targeting experiments or from a repeated chromosomal sequence. Using a gene-targeting assay in mouse embryonic stem cells, we now investigate the effect of heterology on recombinational repair of DSBs. Cells were cotransfected with an endonuclease expression plasmid to induce chromosomal DSBs and with substrates containing up to 1.2% heterology from which to repair the DSBs. We find that heterology decreases the efficiency of recombinational repair, with 1.2% sequence divergence resulting in an approximately sixfold reduction in recombination. Gene conversion tract lengths were examined in 80 recombinants. Relatively short gene conversion tracts were observed, with 80% of the recombinants having tracts of 58 bp or less. These results suggest that chromosome ends in mammalian cells are generally protected from extensive degradation prior to recombination. Gene conversion tracts that were long (up to 511 bp) were continuous, i.e., they contained an uninterrupted incorporation of the silent mutations. This continuity suggests that these long tracts arose from extensive degradation of the ends or from formation of heteroduplex DNA which is corrected with a strong bias in the direction of the unbroken strand.