Yeast Intrachromosomal Recombination: Long Gene Conversion Tracts Are Preferentially Associated with Reciprocal Exchange and Require the Rad1 and Rad3 Gene Products

A yeast intrachromosomal recombination system based on an inverted repeat has been designed to examine mitotic gene conversion tract length and the association of crossing over with gene conversion as a function of the conversion tract length. Short conversion tracts are found to be preferentially noncrossover while conversion tracts longer than 1.16 kb show a 50% association with crossover. Mutation in the excision repair gene RAD1 leads to a reduction in conversion tracts of at least 1.16 kb and a reduction in crossovers associated with conversion, regardless of the length of the conversion tract. Mutation in the excision repair gene RAD3, which encodes a DNA helicase, also leads to a reduction in conversion tracts of at least 1.16 kb, but has no effect on the frequency of associated crossovers. The roles of RAD1 and RAD3 in recombination are discussed.     

Length and Distribution of Meiotic Gene Conversion Tracts and Crossovers in Saccharomyces Cerevisiae

We have measured gene conversion tract length in strains of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae containing three to six restriction site heterozygosities in a 9-kb interval. Tetrads containing a conversion were identified genetically by nonmendelian segregation of a marker in the middle of the interval. Gene conversions accompanied by a crossover have a tract length of 1.4 kb +/- 0.7 kb, which is indistinguishable from a tract length of 1.6 +/- 0.8 for conversions without an associated exchange. Among tetrads identified first as having a crossover in the interval, the average gene conversion tracts were apparently significantly shorter (0.71 +/- 1). We provide evidence that this apparent difference is due to the method of measuring conversion tracts and does not reflect a real difference in tract length. We also provide evidence that the number and position of restriction site markers alters the apparent distribution of the conversion tracts. More than ninety percent of the conversion tracts spanning three or more sites were continuous.     

High-Resolution Mapping of Two Types of Spontaneous Mitotic Gene Conversion Events in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Gene conversions and crossovers are related products of the repair of double-stranded DNA breaks by homologous recombination. Most previous studies of mitotic gene conversion events have been restricted to measuring conversion tracts that are <5 kb. Using a genetic assay in which the lengths of very long gene conversion tracts can be measured, we detected two types of conversions: those with a median size of ∼6 kb and those with a median size of >50 kb. The unusually long tracts are initiated at a naturally occurring recombination hotspot formed by two inverted Ty elements. We suggest that these long gene conversion events may be generated by a mechanism (break-induced replication or repair of a double-stranded DNA gap) different from the short conversion tracts that likely reflect heteroduplex formation followed by DNA mismatch repair. Both the short and long mitotic conversion tracts are considerably longer than those observed in meiosis. Since mitotic crossovers in a diploid can result in a heterozygous recessive deleterious mutation becoming homozygous, it has been suggested that the repair of DNA breaks by mitotic recombination involves gene conversion events that are unassociated with crossing over. In contrast to this prediction, we found that ∼40% of the conversion tracts are associated with crossovers. Spontaneous mitotic crossover events in yeast are frequent enough to be an important factor in genome evolution.     

Meiotic recombination within the centromere of a yeast chromosome

In order to examine the frequency of nonreciprocal recombination (gene conversion) within the centromere of the yeast chromosome, we constructed strains that contained heterozygous restriction sites in the conserved centromere sequences of chromosome III in addition to heterozygous markers flanking the centromere. One of these markers was the selectable URA3 gene, which was inserted less than one kb from the centromere. We found that meiotic conversion of the URA3 gene occurred at normal frequency (about 2% of unselected tetrads) and that more than one-third of these convertants coconverted the markers within the centromere. In addition, we observed tetrads in which conversion events extended through the centromere to include a marker on the opposite side from URA3. We conclude that meiotic conversion events occur within the centromere at rates similar to other genomic sequences.     

Analysis of spontaneous gene conversion tracts within and between mammalian chromosomes

In the present study, we report the first characterization of gene conversion tract length, continuity and fidelity for pathways of gene targeting, ectopic and intrachromosomal homologous recombination using the same locus and mammalian somatic cell type. In this isogenic cell system, the vast majority of recombinants (> 97%) are generated by homologous recombination and display a high degree of fidelity in the gene conversion process. Individual gene conversion tracts are highly likely to involve single, independent recombination events and proceed through a heteroduplex DNA intermediate. In all recombination pathways, gene conversion tracts are long, extending up to ∼ 2 kb. Most gene conversion tracts are continuous in favor of donor region sequences, but in a small fraction of recombinants (15%), discontinuous gene conversion tracts are observed. In most cases, the recombination donor sequence is unaltered, although in two cases of intrachromosomal recombination, both recombination donor and recipient sequences bear gene conversion tracts. Overall, gene conversion events are similar, both qualitatively and quantitatively, for homologous recombination within and between mammalian chromosomes.     

The Behavior of Insertions near a Site of Mitotic Gene Conversion in Yeast

In yeast, coincident gene conversion events involving the LEU1 and TRP5 loci (16 cM apart) occur at frequencies that are far greater than is expected for two independent acts of recombination. When a large plasmid (pJM53) is placed between these genes so that a direct repeat is produced, there is frequent loss of the insert among coincident convertants. Previous results strongly suggest that this is due to a separate, intrachromosomal exchange between the direct repeats rather than to excision from an extensive region of heteroduplex DNA. In this paper, we extend our genetic and molecular analysis to a plasmid insertion (pKSH) which replaces rather than duplicates the chromosomal material. The relative stabilities of pKSH and pJM53 are compared among coincident Leu+Trp+ convertants and convertants involving only one locus (LEU1). The pKSH insertion is significantly more stable in the latter which constitute a large majority of the selectable recombinants. In the former, both insertions are lost with high frequency. These results are used to argue that, while most mitotic conversion does not result from long intermediates, coincident convertants may arise from either multiple intermediates or extensive heteroduplex regions.     

Sgs1 regulates gene conversion tract lengths and crossovers independently of its helicase activity

RecQ helicases maintain genome stability and suppress tumors in higher eukaryotes through roles in replication and DNA repair. The yeast RecQ homolog Sgs1 interacts with Top3 topoisomerase and Rmi1. In vitro, Sgs1 binds to and branch migrates Holliday junctions (HJs) and the human RecQ homolog BLM, with Top3alpha, resolves synthetic double HJs in a noncrossover sense. Sgs1 suppresses crossovers during the homologous recombination (HR) repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). Crossovers are associated with long gene conversion tracts, suggesting a model in which Sgs1 helicase catalyzes reverse branch migration and convergence of double HJs for noncrossover resolution by Top3. Consistent with this model, we show that allelic crossovers and gene conversion tract lengths are increased in sgs1Delta. However, crossover and tract length suppression was independent of Sgs1 helicase activity, which argues against helicase-dependent HJ convergence. HJs may converge passively by a "random walk," and Sgs1 may play a structural role in stimulating Top3-dependent resolution. In addition to the new helicase-independent functions for Sgs1 in crossover and tract length control, we define three new helicase-dependent functions, including the suppression of chromosome loss, chromosome missegregation, and synthetic lethality in srs2Delta. We propose that Sgs1 has helicase-dependent functions in replication and helicase-independent functions in DSB repair by HR.     

Multiple heterologies increase mitotic double-strand break-induced allelic gene conversion tract lengths in yeast.

Spontaneous and double-strand break (DSB)-induced allelic recombination in yeast was investigated in crosses between ura3 heteroalleles inactivated by an HO site and a +1 frameshift mutation, with flanking markers defining a 3.4-kbp interval. In some crosses, nine additional phenotypically silent RFLP mutations were present at approximately 100-bp intervals. Increasing heterology from 0.2 to 1% in this interval reduced spontaneous, but not DSB-induced, recombination. For DSB-induced events, 75% were continuous tract gene conversions without a crossover in this interval; discontinuous tracts and conversions associated with a crossover each comprised approximately 7% of events, and 10% also converted markers in unbroken alleles. Loss of heterozygosity was seen for all markers centromere distal to the HO site in 50% of products; such loss could reflect gene conversion, break-induced replication, chromosome loss, or G2 crossovers. Using telomere-marked strains we determined that nearly all allelic DSB repair occurs by gene conversion. We further show that most allelic conversion results from mismatch repair of heteroduplex DNA. Interestingly, markers shared between the sparsely and densely marked interval converted at higher rates in the densely marked interval. Thus, the extra markers increased gene conversion tract lengths, which may reflect mismatch repair-induced recombination, or a shift from restoration- to conversion-type repair.     

Mitotic gene conversion can be as important as meiotic conversion in driving genetic variability in plants and other species without early germline segregation

In contrast to common meiotic gene conversion, mitotic gene conversion, because it is so rare, is often ignored as a process influencing allelic diversity. We show that if there is a large enough number of premeiotic cell divisions, as seen in many organisms without early germline sequestration, such as plants, this is an unsafe position. From examination of 1.1 million rice plants, we determined that the rate of mitotic gene conversion events, per mitosis, is 2 orders of magnitude lower than the meiotic rate. However, owing to the large number of mitoses between zygote and gamete and because of long mitotic tract lengths, meiotic and mitotic gene conversion can be of approximately equivalent importance in terms of numbers of markers converted from zygote to gamete. This holds even if we assume a low number of premeiotic cell divisions (approximately 40) as witnessed in Arabidopsis. A low mitotic rate associated with long tracts is also seen in yeast, suggesting generality of results. For species with many mitoses between each meiotic event, mitotic gene conversion should not be overlooked.

Gene conversion associated with meiosis has long been a focus of attention in population genomics, but mitotic conversion has been relatively overlooked as it was thought to be rare. Analysis in plants suggests that this could be a mistake; long tract lengths and multiple mitoses in species lacking germline sequestration suggest that mitotic conversion, although rare per mitosis, should not be ignored.     

Contractions and expansions of CAG/CTG trinucleotide repeats occur during ectopic gene conversion in yeast,by a MUS81-independent mechanism

CAG/CTG trinucleotide repeat tracts expand and contract at a high rate during gene conversion in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. In order to characterize the mechanism responsible for such rearrangements, we built an experimental system based on the use of the rare cutter endonuclease I-SceI, to study the fate of trinucleotide repeat tracts during meiotic or mitotic (allelic or ectopic) gene conversion. After double-strand break (DSB) induced meiotic recombination, (CAG)(98) and (CAG)(255) are rearranged in 5% and 52% of the gene conversions, respectively, with similar proportions of contractions and expansions. No evidence of a meiotic hot spot activity associated with trinucleotide repeats could be found. When gene conversion is induced by a DSB during mitotic growth of the cells, no rearrangement of the repeat tracts is detected when the donor sequence is allelic to the recipient site of the DSB. However, when the donor sequence is at an ectopic location, frequent contractions and expansions of the repeat tract are found. No crossing-over associated with gene conversion could be detected. Mutants for the MUS81 gene, involved in the resolution of recombination intermediates, show a frequency of rearrangements identical with that of the wild-type strain. We concluded that trinucleotide repeat rearrangements occur frequently during ectopic but not during allelic recombination, by a mechanism that does not require crossover formation.     

Association of Disomic Chromosome Loss with Ems-Induced Conversion in Yeast

Experimental tests with the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae of a previously proposed model suggesting a causal relationship between disomic chromosome loss (n + 1 → n) and centromere-adjacent mitotic gene conversion were performed. Disomic haploid cells heteroallelic at two loci on the left arm of chromosome III were exposed to ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) under nonlethal conditions; EMS-induced prototrophic gene convertants were selected and tested for coincident chromosome loss. The principal results are: (1) The frequency of chromosome loss among EMS-induced gene convertants selected to arise near the centromere is markedly enhanced over basal levels and remains constant, independent of EMS exposure. There is little such enhancement among EMS-induced convertants selected to arise far from the centromere. (2) Chromosome loss is almost completely associated with induced conversion of the centromere-proximal allele at the centromere-adjacent heteroallelic locus. This result is identical to (and confirms) results found previously for spontaneous loss-associated conversion. (3) The conversion polarity at the centromere-adjacent locus among unselected (nonloss-associated) induced or spontaneous mitotic convertants is identical to that among meiotic convertants and markedly favors the contromere-distal allele. These findings are wholly consistent with, and strengthen, the hypothesis that structural involvement of centromeric regions in nearby recombinational events may interfere with proper segregational function and lead to mitotic chromosome loss.     

Association of Chromosome Loss with Centromere-Adjacent Mitotic Recombination in a Yeast Disomic Haploid

Experiments designed to characterize the association between disomic chromosome loss and centromere-adjacent mitotic recombination were performed. Mitotic gene convertants were selected at two heteroallelic sites on the left arm of disomic chromosome III and tested for coincident chromosome loss. The principal results are: (1) Disomic chromosome loss is markedly enhanced (nearly 40-fold) over basal levels among mitotic gene convertants selected to arise close to the centromere; no such enhancement is observed among convertants selected to arise relatively far from the centromere. (2) Chromosome loss is primarily associated with proximal allele conversion at the centromere-adjacent site, and many of these convertants are reciprocally recombined in the adjacent proximal interval. (3) Partial aneuploid exceptions provisionally identified as carrying left arm telocentrics have been found. A testable model is proposed suggesting that centromere involvement in genetic recombination may precipitate segregational disfunction leading to mitotic chromosome loss.     

P-Element-Induced Male Recombination and Gene Conversion in Drosophila

A P-element insertion flanked by 13 restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) marker sites was used to examine male recombination and gene conversion at an autosomal site. The great majority of crossovers on chromosome arm 2R occurred within the 4-kb region containing the P element and RFLP sites. Of the 128 recombinants analyzed, approximately two-thirds carried duplications or deletions flanking the P element. These rearrangements are described in more detail in the accompanying report. In a parallel experiment, we examined 91 gene conversion tracts resulting from excision of the same autosomal P element. We found the average tract length was 1463 bp, which is essentially the same as found previously at the white locus. The distribution of conversion tract endpoints was indistinguishable from the distribution of crossover points among the nonrearranged male recombinants. Most recombination events can be explained by the ``hybrid element insertion' model, but, for those lacking a duplication or deletion, a second step involving double-strand gap repair must be postulated to explain the distribution of crossover points.     

The Effects of Insertions on Mammalian Intrachromosomal Recombination

We examined the effects of insertion mutations on intrachromosomal recombination. A series of mouse L cell lines carrying mutant herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (tk) heteroalleles was generated; these lines differed in the nature of their insertion mutations. In direct repeat lines with different large insertions in each gene, there was a 20-fold drop in gene conversion rate and only a five-fold drop in crossover rate relative to the analogous rates in lines with small insertions in each gene. Surprisingly, in direct repeat lines carrying the same large insertion in each gene, there was a larger drop in both types of recombination. When intrachromosomal recombination between inverted repeat tk genes with different large insertions was examined, we found that the rate of gene conversion dropped five-fold relative to small insertions, while the rate of crossing over was unaffected. The differential effects on conversion and crossing over imply that gene conversion is more sensitive to insertion mutation size. Finally, the fraction of gene conversions associated with a crossover increased from 2% for inverted repeats with small insertions to 18% for inverted repeats with large insertions. One interpretation of this finding is that during intrachromosomal recombination in mouse cells long conversion tracts are more often associated with crossing over.     

Molecular Analysis of Recombination Events in Drosophila

The locations of crossover junctions and gene conversion tracts, isolated in the rosy gene of Drosophila melanogaster, were determined using DNA sequencing and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Frequent DNA sequence polymorphisms between the parental genes served as unselected genetic markers. All conversion tracts were continuous, and half of the reciprocal crossover events had conversion tracts at the crossover junction. These experiments have also identified the sequence polymorphisms responsible for altered gene expression in two naturally occurring rosy variants.     

Long,interrupted conversion tracts initiated by cog in Neurospora crassa.

Multiple polymorphisms distinguish Emerson and Lindegren strains of Neurospora crassa within the histidine-3 gene and in its distal flank. Restriction site and sequence length polymorphism in a set of 14 PCR products covering this 6.9-kb region were used to identify the parental origin of DNA sequence information in prototrophic progeny of crosses heterozygous for auxotrophic mutations in his-3 and the silent sequence differences. Forty-one percent of conversion tracts are interrupted. Where the absence of rec-2+ permits activity of the recombination hotspot cog, conversion appears to originate at cog and conversion tracts are up to 5.9 kb long. The chromosome bearing cog(L), the dominant allele that confers a high frequency of recombination, is almost invariably the recipient of information. In progeny from crosses heterozygous rec-2/rec-2+, conversion tracts are much shorter, most are not initiated at cog and either chromosome seems equally likely to be converted. Although 32% of his-3 prototrophs have a crossover that may be associated with conversion, it is suggested that the apparent association between conversion and crossing over at this locus may be due to confounding of coincidental events rather than to a mechanistic relationship.     

High Throughput Sequencing Reveals Alterations in the Recombination Signatures with Diminishing Spo11 Activity

Spo11 is the topoisomerase-like enzyme responsible for the induction of the meiosis-specific double strand breaks (DSBs), which initiates the recombination events responsible for proper chromosome segregation. Nineteen PCR-induced alleles of SPO11 were identified and characterized genetically and cytologically. Recombination, spore viability and synaptonemal complex (SC) formation were decreased to varying extents in these mutants. Arrest by ndt80 restored these events in two severe hypomorphic mutants, suggesting that ndt80-arrested nuclei are capable of extended DSB activity. While crossing-over, spore viability and synaptonemal complex (SC) formation defects correlated, the extent of such defects was not predictive of the level of heteroallelic gene conversions (prototrophs) exhibited by each mutant. High throughput sequencing of tetrads from spo11 hypomorphs revealed that gene conversion tracts associated with COs are significantly longer and gene conversion tracts unassociated with COs are significantly shorter than in wild type. By modeling the extent of these tract changes, we could account for the discrepancy in genetic measurements of prototrophy and crossover association. These findings provide an explanation for the unexpectedly low prototroph levels exhibited by spo11 hypomorphs and have important implications for genetic studies that assume an unbiased recovery of prototrophs, such as measurements of CO homeostasis. Our genetic and physical data support previous observations of DSB-limited meioses, in which COs are disproportionally maintained over NCOs (CO homeostasis).     

Physical Lengths of Meiotic and Mitotic Gene Conversion Tracts in Saccharomyces Cerevisiae

Physical lengths of gene conversion tracts for meiotic and mitotic conversions were examined, using the same diploid yeast strain in all experiments. This strain is heterozygous for a mutation in the URA3 gene as well as closely linked restriction site markers. In cells that had a gene conversion event at the URA3 locus, it was determined by Southern analysis which of the flanking heterozygous restriction sites had co-converted. It was found that mitotic conversion tracts were longer on the average than meiotic tracts. About half of the tracts generated by spontaneous mitotic gene conversion included heterozygous markers 4.2 kb apart; none of the meiotic conversions included these markers. Stimulation of mitotic gene conversion by ultraviolet light or methylmethanesulfonate had no obvious effect on the size or distribution of the tracts. Almost all conversion tracts were continuous.     

Efficient combination of large DNA in vitro: in gel site specific recombination (IGSSR) of PAC fragments containing alpha satellite DNA and the human HPRT gene locus.

In an attempt to combine a cloned genomic copy of a selectable gene with different cloned centromeric sequences to develop mammalian artificial chromosomes (MAC) we used site specific recombination mediated by purified Cre recombinase acting on the loxP sequence in PAC vector DNA. A new method was required to purify highly concentrated, virtually 100% intact PAC DNA which could be stored for a long period. Here we show the efficient linking of linearized PACs containing alpha satellite DNA from chromosomes X and 17 with sizes of 125 and 140 kb, respectively, to a 95 kb restriction fragment derived from a 175 kb PAC containing the intact human HPRT gene locus.     

Mechanisms of Gene Conversion in Saccharomyces Cerevisiae

In red-white sectored colonies of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, derived from mitotic cells grown to stationary phase and irradiated with a light dose of x-rays, all of the segregational products of gene conversion and crossing over can be ascertained. Approximately 80% of convertants are induced in G1, the remaining 20% in G2. Crossing over, in the amount of 20%, is found among G1 convertants but most of the crossovers are delayed until G2. About 20% of all sectored colonies had more than one genotype in one or the other sector, thus confirming the hypothesis that conversion also occurs in G2. The principal primary event in G2 conversion is a single DNA heteroduplex. It is suggested that the close contact that this implies carries over to G2 when crossing over and a second round of conversion occurs.