Studies on the mechanism of transplantation tolerance: I. Do suppressor cells play a role in the induction and maintenance of neonatal transplantation tolerance?

Neonatal transplantation tolerance was induced in CBA (H-2^k) mice to A (H-2^a) mice by injection of (CBA × A)F₁ spleen cells. Animals carrying an A-skin test allograft for more than 4 months without any visible sign of rejection were considered to be permanently tolerant. Permanently tolerant CBA mice were given normal syngeneic spleen cells to abrogate the state of tolerance. Abrogation of tolerance was greatly facilitated by antithymocyte serum (ATS) treatment of tolerant mice prior to the normal syngeneic cell transfer. Survival of A allografts on normal, adult, ATS-treated CBA mice was significantly prolonged (and in many cases “adult” tolerance was achieved) by transfer of spleen cells of syngeneic mice made permanently tolerant at neonatal age. The possible role of the F₁-cell “contamination” in the tolerance-inducing effect of the transferred “tolerant” spleen cells was excluded. The results indicate that ATS-sensitive suppressor cells play a definite role in the induction, maintenance, and transfer of neonatally induced transplantation tolerance.     

Activation of T and B thymus cells to recognize histocompatibility antigens

Lethally irradiated (A × CBA) F₁ or (A × C57BL/6) F₁ mice were injected with 10⁷ A strain thymus cells in attempts to activate donor cells to recognize CBA or C57BL/6 histocompatibility antigens, respectively. Activation could be revealed by injecting activated thymus cells (day 5 irradiated F₁ hybrid spleen cells) into corresponding unirradiated F₁ hybrid hosts. The alloantibody titers formed by these cells and the antirecognition structure (anti-RS) antibody titers induced by them were similar to those observed after injection of normal parental strain spleen cells, indicating that thymus cells had become endowed with recognition structures (RS). Alloantibodies, but no anti-RS antibodies, were present in the serum of F₁ mice given activated thymus cells treated with anti-θ and complement. It, therefore, appeared that activated thymus cells contained sufficient B cells differentiated into antibody-forming cells to give a measurable alloantibody response. On the other hand, receptors responsible for anti-RS antibody induction presumably were located on T cells. Specificity and restriction of antigenic recognition were revealed by negative results obtained when activated thymus cells were injected into F₁ hosts not containing the antigens against which activation had been directed.     

Effect of allogeneic cell interaction and graft-versus-host reaction on the antibody response to Escherichia coli 0127 antigen.

The influence of allogeneic cell interaction and GVH reaction on the immune response to Escherichia coli antigen was investigated. Addition of CBA/J spleen cells to cultures of nu/nu spleen cells stimulated a significant increase in the nude PFC response to SRBC but had no significant effect on the immune response to E. coli antigen. Similarly, the induction of a GVH reaction in F₁ mice by the injection of parental spleen cells also had no significant effect on the immune response to the bacterial antigen. These results suggest that the immune response to E. coli is not affected by products of thymus-derived cells.     

Induction of immune complex glomerulonephritis in F1 hybrid mice: superiority of cortisone-resistant parental thymocytes over spleen cells

Severe immune complex glomerulonephritis developed in (C57B1/10ScSn × DBA/2) F₁ hybrid mice after the injection of various dosages of cortisone-resistant thymus cells from DBA/2 donors. In contrast, significantly lower incidences of glomerulonephritis were induced when the same numbers of DBA/2 spleen cells were injected. The low nephritogenic capacity of spleen cells can be explained by their high content of B cells, assuming that parental B cells are not required for the induction of the disease. As T cells themselves are unable to produce humoral antibodies, the administration of parental cortisone-resistant thymus cells may enable B cells of the F₁ recipients to form the 7S antibodies deposited in the glomerular immune complexes.     

Studies on antireceptor antibody and on alloantibody formation

Semiallogeneic and allogeneic immunization protocols were used to clarify the origin of two antibody activities: (a) those directed at alloantigens and (b) those directed at receptors for alloantigens. In a first variant of semiallogeneic immunization, parental strain spleen cells were injected into F₁ hybrid hosts where they could not be rejected; both antireceptor antibody and alloantibody activities appeared, persisting for over 10 weeks. When the host was irradiated, no antireceptor antibody was formed, indicating the F₁ origin of this activity. In the second variant of semiallogeneic immunization, F₁ spleen cells were injected into parental hosts. Here the antireceptor antibody, while reaching high titers, even in hosts presensitized to antigens of the donor, soon disappeared, presumably due to the rejection of inoculated cells. It was concluded that in both variants of semiallogeneic situations, antireceptor antibodies were formed by F₁ cells, whereas alloantibodies were formed by parental cells. In allogeneic immunizations, four activities were found in serum —two directed at alloantigens (one set from each partner) and two directed at receptors for alloantigens (one set from each partner) —indicating that lymphoid cells of any origin can function as producers of antibodies to alloreceptors, in strict analogy to their potential as producers of antibody to alloantigens.     

Mechanisms involved in the antibody-mediated suppression of tuberculin-type delayed hypersensitivity: II. The sensitivity of tolerance induction to cyclophosphamide pretreatment and splenectomy,and the demonstration of active suppression

The induction of tuberculin-type delayed hypersensitivity, as measured by skin test, can be specifically inhibited by administration of antibody during sensitization. The cellular mechanisms involved in this tolerance were investigated in CAP₁ mice, using chicken conalbumin as antigen. Tolerance was prevented when mice were treated with Cyclophosphamide 2 days before sensitization and suppression. However, it was not affected by splenectomy 7 or 21 days before sensitization. This tolerance could be transferred to normal CAF₁ mice with spleen cells, but not with thymocytes, when taken from donor mice 21 to 28 days after sensitization and tolerance induction. Production of these cells in the donors required both antibody and antigen. The cells responsible for the transfer were B cells, as shown by their sensitivity to rabbit anti-mouse-immunoglobulin serum and complement. In addition to B cells, serum from tolerant mice also could transfer suppression at 21 to 28 days. We conclude that sensitizing mice, and treating them with specific immunosuppressive antiserum, induces the recipients to make suppressor B cells and suppressive humoral factors, which are involved in arresting the induction of tuberculin-type delayed hypersensitivity.     

A gene locus affecting tolerance to BGG in mice.

A genetic analysis was made of the ease of tolerance induction to bovine γ-globulin (BGG) in DBA/2, BALB/c, F₁ and backcross generation mice. Like parental DBA/2 mice, the F₁ generation of BALB/c × DBA/2 becomes tolerant when treated with 2 mg BGG. A backcross of this F₁ to DBA/2 parents produced mice that all became tolerant to this dose of BGG. A backcross of F₁ mice to BALB/c parents produced 50% offspring tolerized by the same dose of BGG and 50% resistant to tolerance induction.The data suggest a single autosomal locus affecting tolerance induction. Data presented elsewhere suggest that the locus affects macrophage function. We propose that this locus be called tolerance (symbol Tol-l) and the two alleles be (Tol-l^a (DBA/2 type) and Tol-l^b (BALB/c type) with Tol-l^a being dominant.     

Differential effect of hybrid resistance on the localization of virus-immune effector T cells to spleen and brain

The hybrid resistance (Hr) effect operates in the lymphocytic choriomeningitis (LCM) in vivo transfer model to inhibit both the level of cytotoxicity T lymphocyte (CTL) generation in spleen and the induction of inflammation in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). The effect is seen when LCM virus-immune T cells that are homozygous for H-2D ^b are injected into virus-infected, immunosuppressed recipients that are heterozygous for this allele, or into radiation chimeras that express an appropriate F₁ phenotype. Evidence that Hr to T -cell transfer is cell-dose-dependent and tends to diminish with age was found in both chimeric and normal F₁ mice. Inhibition of the capacity of injected T cells to cause meningitis is a more sensitive measure of Hr than is the further stimulation of CTL effectors in recipient lymphoid tissue. The injection of large numbers of H-2^b virus-immune T cells into (H-2 ^k X H-2 ^bF₁H-2 ^k) virus-infected recipients did not induce any cellular extravasation into CSF, though potent H-2^b-restricted CTL effectors were generated in recipient spleen. Evidence of minimal inflammatory process was found in one experiment where these chimeras were given a comparable dose of (H-2 ^b X H-2 ^d)F₁ immune spleen cells. Development of this Tcell-mediated immunopathological process depends essentially on the expression of the appropriate H-2 restriction element on radiation-resistant host cells which, in this case, presumably constitute part of the physiological barrier between blood and CSF.     

Immunosuppressive effect of graft-versus-host reaction

GVHR was elicited in adult F₁ hybrids by iv injection of parental spleen cells. The F₁ hybrids were then immunized with θ-AKR antigen. Plaque-forming cells (PFC) producing antibodies lytic for AKR thymocytes were enumerated in spleens of experimental animals using the method of cytolysis in agar-gel. The number of PFC found in spleens of animals grafted with parental cells was significantly lower than the number in spleens of animals grafted with syngeneic cells. The degree of suppression of immune response to θ-AKR depended on: (1) the duration of GVHR at the time of immunization, (2) the parental strain and the number of parental cells grafted to evoke GVHR, and (3) the source of cells grafted. Thymus and bone marrow cells when grafted together showed a synergistic effect in suppression of the host's immune response. Immunosuppression of the response to θ-AKR seems to be a more sensitive indicator of GVHR in adult F₁ hybrids than splenomegaly, which is commonly used as a means of assessment of GVHR. The possible role of immunosuppression in the pathogenesis of GVHR is briefly discussed.     

Haplotype preference in lymphocyte differentiation. II. F1 hybrid helper T cells generated with antigen-bearing parental macrophages can cooperate with B lymphocytes of either parent.

Carrier-specific helper T cells were generated in F₁ hybrid mice by either conventional immunization procedures or by repeated immunizations with antigen-bearing macrophages derived from either F₁ or parental donors. The F₁ helper T cells generated in these various ways were then analyzed for their capacities to help hapten-primed B lymphocytes derived from each of the two parental strains as well as from F₁ donors in the development of secondary anti-hapten antibody responses. These analyses were conducted using two different types of in vivo assay systems as well as a totally in vitro system. Under all circumstances, helper T cells from F₁ mice, primed either in conventional fashion or with antigen bearing parental or F₁ macrophages, were capable of interacting effectively with B lymphocytes of each parent and of F₁ origin. Moreover, in the case of F₁ helper cells primed with antigen-bearing parental macrophages, there was no evidence of preferential helper activity for parental B lymphocytes corresponding to the type of macrophage used for sensitization; this was true irrespective of whether in vivo or in vitro assay systems were employed. The relevance of these findings and others which are either similar to, or discordant with, them to the general question of genetic restrictions in macrophage-T lymphocyte interactions is discussed.     

Induction of tolerance to parental marrow grafts in F1 hybrid mice. Evidence for recognition of self-antigens

Lethally irradiated (C57BL/6xC3H)F1 mice are able to acutely reject parental C57BL/6 but not C3H marrow grafts, a phenomenon called hybrid resistance (HR). In attempts to inactivate this rejection mechanism we found that parental spleen cells activated with LPS are very potent in inducing tolerance to a subsequent C57BL/6 marrow graft. Tolerance is likely due to elimination of effector cells responsible for graft rejection as adoptive transfer of spleen cells from normal into tolerized mice reconstitutes responsiveness. Evidence is presented that the Ag on LPS-activated spleen cells responsible for induction of unresponsiveness are expressed on both C57BL/6 and (C57BL/6xC3H)F1 cells. This suggests that the HR effector cells recognize autoantigens. In support of this, induction of tolerance to C57BL/6 parental marrow grafts leads to a concomitant dramatic increase in endogenous CFU-spleen after a dose of gamma-irradiation. Moreover, elimination of the cells responsible for HR by injection of anti-ASGM1 antibody results in a similar increase of endogenous CFU-spleen after irradiation. It is concluded that HR is a reflection of autoimmunity, able to limit the proliferation of syngeneic marrow stem cells.     

ABILITY OF THYMIC LYMPHOCYTES TO ALTER CFU KINETICS IN RADIATION CHIMERAS

It is known that the poor colony-forming ability of B6 bone marrow transplanted into B6D2F₁ hybrids can be improved if B6 lymphocytes are given in addition. It was recently reported that the augmenting lymphocytes decrease the doubling time of differentiating hemopoietic cells. to determine whether thymus cells alter the self-renewal of CFUs in this parent F₁ combination, retransplan-tation and ³H-thymidine ‘suicide’ were employed as methods to determine the cell-division rate. We have observed that in the presence of thymocytes, parental bone marrow cells are seeded more efficiently in the spleen, and the lag phase of the CFUs growth curve is shortened. However, thymic lymphocytes do not increase the slope of the exponential growth phase of CFUs.     

Diminution by vesicular stomatitis virus of acute graft vs host mortality in mice.

Preincubation of parental spleen cells with vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) in vitro reduces their subsequent ability to cause lethal GVH disease in irradiated F₁ hybrid recipients. Antibody to VSV is needed to protect the irradiated mice against the virus. Protection is afforded even to the acute GVH induced by spleen cells presensitized to the other parent. No reduction of the late-occurring GVH mortality is obtained with VSV, even though this late GVH is mediated by T cells as it is completely abolished by pretreatment of BM with anti-Thy 1.2 + C. The results suggest that the known ability of VSV to replicate in activated T cells may be used selectively to inhibit certain unwanted immune reactions in vivo.     

Cooperation of nonsyngeneic tolerant lymphocytes: genetic restriction.

We have used a previously devised in vivo experimental model to investigate the ability of mouse thymus-dependent (T) and bone marrow-derived (B) lymphocytes to cooperate in immune (humoral) rejection of rat Yoshida ascites sarcoma (YAS). Because of conflicting reports in the literature concerning the effectiveness of T-B cooperation across major histocompatibility complex (MHC) barriers, we explored the interaction of T and B lymphocytes from mutually tolerant animals. Tolerance was achieved by establishing radiation chimeras of B6 → B6D2F₁ and D2 → B6D2F₁ constitutions. Chimeras' erythrocytes and spleen cells were shown by serological analysis to be the donor type. When the chimera was to serve as the tumor host or B-cell source, it was thymectomized prior to irradiation and reconstitution (TIR). Tolerance was evaluated by noting the inability of chimeric spleen cells to effect graft-versus-host damage upon injection into TIR host-type mice and the markedly reduced anti-host-type reactivity in short-term [³H]thymidine-uptake tests. Successful cooperation, manifested by YAS rejection, was seen whenever donor T and host B lymphocytes were syngeneic. Parental (P) T cells enabled F₁ TIR mice to reject YAS, but the reciprocal was not true: F₁ donor T cells did not cooperate with B cells in parental TIR mice. However, when the host B lymphocytes were tolerant P cells, i.e., in a P → F₁ TIR chimera, injected F₁ T lymphocytes did cooperate successfully. The final test of allogeneic T and B cells gave the clear-cut negative answer that, even when tolerant mice are used as sources of lymphocytes, cooperation does not occur. These results therefore confirm that T and B lymphocytes must at least share one MHC haplotype in order to cooperate.     

Immunological and genetic requirements for the parental hemopoietic takeover reaction in adult,H-2-incompatible parent-F1 hybrid parabiosis

Parabiosis of adult DBA/2J (H-2 ^d ) mice with adult (DBA/2J× CSH/HeJ)F₁ (H-2 ^d /H-2 ^k ) mice results in survival beyond 100 days in 44% of such pairs, induction ofin situ unresponsiveness to C3H/HeJ skin, and the complete takeover of the erythroid system of the F₁ by parental cells. However, in vitro responsiveness to C3H/HeJ cells remains. Dye exclusion cytotoxicity assays establish the absence ofF ₁ lymphoid cells in the spleens and bone marrow of both partners. The parental takeover of the erythroid system of the F₁ partner requires immune recognition of the hybrid's alloantigens, because this takeover is not seen with tolerant parental cells. PartialH-2 differences (on the C3H background) influence both survival and the takeover reaction when incorporated into parabioses with DBA/2J partners. When only theK andI subregions ofH-2 were targets of the parental response, 58% of parabionts survived, with complete parental hemopoietic takeover. When onlyH-2D was the target, 83% of parabionts survived, with incomplete hemopoietic takeover. Changing the non-H-2 background of the F₁ target did not significantly affect survival or takeover, while substituting a differentH-2 ^d parental strain (BALB/c) eliminated survival altogether.Thus the parabiont takeover reaction encompasses the lymphoid and hemopoietic systems, requires immunorecognition of the target alloantigens, and seems to require a strongH-2 difference for its induction.     

Influence of the H-2 u haplotype on immune function in F1 hybrid mice

Recently we reported that antigen-primed T cells from (H-2 ^u × H-2 ^s)F₁ and (H-2 ^u × H-2 ^q)F₁ mice responded poorly in vitro to antigen in the context of antigen-presenting cells of the non-H-2 ^u parent. It was suggested that this effect might be due to unbalanced expression of parental antigens in the F₁ hybrid with the result that the non-H-2^u A antigens were greatly reduced or absent in these mice. If this were the case, non-H-2^u Ia-A cells might be expected to stimulate a mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) when cultured with Fl responder cells. When tested, (SJL × PL)F₁ responder cells reacted strongly to SJL stimulator cells. There was no significant reaction to PL stimulator cells. The use of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) congenic mice showed the stimulatory antigens to be associated with the MHC. The MLR could be blocked significantly by monoclonal A-specific antibody of the appropriate specificity. When a monoclonal antibody reactivewith a private epitope associated with A^s was used to probe for the presence of A^s on the surface of (SJL × PL)F₁ spleen cells, no antigen could be detected, indicating loss or alteration of this antigen. These findings suggest that an alteration of the expression of the parental A^s molecule may be responsible for this phenomenon.Abbreviations used in this paper APC antigen-presenting cells - BSS balanced salt solution - CTL cytotoxic T lymphocyte - IL-2 interleukin-2 - MHC major histocompatibility complex - MLR mixed lymphocyte reaction - T₂ suppressor T lymphocyte     

Resistance of neonatal tolerance in mice to abrogation by normal immunocytes

The mechanisms of neonatally induced tolerance in CAF₁ mice to bovine serum albumin were investigated with cell transfer experiments and primary interaction between radiolabeled antigen and antisera for antibody measurements. Adoptive transfer of normal syngeneic splenocytes, of thymocytes, or of thymus-bone marrow cell combinations did not break this tolerance though proved effective for breaking irradiation-caused tolerance. Similar transfer of spleen cells taken from immunized mice did abrogate neonatal tolerance; but spleen cells transferred from immunized mice that subsequently also had been desensitized did not, even though they could provide nontolerant recipients with anamnestic responses. Neither allogeneic nor xenogeneic spleen cells broke the tolerance.Thus, the neonatal tolerance studied appears to suppress primary immunologic response but not an anamnestic response. It appears more likely to be an active suppressive phenomenon than one of clone loss.     

Cytotoxicity of autosensitized lymphocytes restricted to the H-2K end of targets

Lymphocytes from rodents cultured on syngeneic fibroblasts become cytotoxic against syngeneic but not against allogeneic target cells. We investigated whether known antigens are involved in the phenomenon and the data indicate that H-2 antigens must be shared between sensitizing fibroblasts and responder lymphocytes to generate autocytotoxic cells. Furthermore, the cytotoxicity of autosensitized lymphocytes is restricted to target cells identical with respect to theK and/orI regions. F₁ hybrid lymphocytes cultured on parental fibroblasts develop cytotoxicity towards sensitizing cells. In contrast, parental lymphocytes cultured on F₁ hybrid fibroblasts will not damage the F₁ cells, although they are cytotoxic against both syngeneic and allogeneic parental cells. In addition, parental or F₁ hybrid lymphocytes cultured on parental fibroblasts are not cytotoxic against F₁ hybrid target cells. Fibroblasts heterozygous for theK end only, are also resistant to the cytotoxic action of such lymphocytes. Thus it seems that H-2 antigens, specifically theK end, antigens have a significant role in the phenomenon of autosensitization.     

Lymphotoxin and interferon production by rossette-separated human peripheral blood leukocytes.

When normal (CBA × DBA)F₁ spleen cells are cultured for 4 days in polyacrylamide vessels, clones of cytotoxic lymphocytes (CLs) are generated. The specificity of these apparently spontaneous CL clones has been investigated by assaying cells from individual clones against pairs of different target cells. CL clones were found to discriminate between the two parental strain splenic blasts, between splenic blasts and syngeneic tumour cells, and between two F₁ splenic blasts induced with different mitogens (LPS and PHA). The CL clones generated spontaneously in culture also discriminate between semisyngeneic targets [DBA blasts and (CBA × DBA)F₁ blasts]. Significant cross-reactivity however, was detected when CL clones were assayed against normal P815 targets and TNP-modified P815 targets.     

Inheritance of cell size in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) and its relationship to the vernalization loci

Reduced cell size is an important adaptive feature in plant response to environmental stresses. The objectives of the present study were to determine the inheritance and location of genes controlling cell size and to establish the relationship between cell size, low-temperature (LT) tolerance, and growth habit as determined by the Vrn loci in wheat. Guard cell length was measured in F₁, F₂, andF₂-derived F₃ populations from parents ranging widely in cell size and in the Chinese Spring/ Cheyenne (CS/CNN) chromosome substitution series. The cell size of F₁ hybrids was similar to the parental midpoint and the F₂ frequency distribution was symmetrical about the mean indicating that cell size was determined by additive gene action with little or no dominance. It appears that there are several genes involved since none of the F₂ progeny had a cell size as large or as small as the parental mean range. The cell size of the homozygous spring and winter lines from F₂-derived F₃ populations fell into two distinct groups that were related to plant growth habit. Large cell size was associated with the spring-habit alleles (Vrn-A1) and small cell size was associated with the winter-habit alleles (vrn-A1) on chromosome 5A. Analyses of the CS/CNN chromosome substitution series showed that CNN chromosomes 5A and 5B both reduced cell size without changing the growth habit, indicating that growth habit per se does not determine cell size. The group-5 chromosomes therefore appear to carry homoeologous alleles with major effects on cell size in wheat. This places cell-size control and many other low-temperature (LT) tolerance associated characters in close proximity to the vrn region of the group-5 chromosomes. Received: 17 August 2000 / Accepted: 20 November 2000