Genome-wide copy number profiling on high-density bacterial artificial chromosomes, single-nucleotide polymorphisms, and oligonucleotide microarrays: a platform comparison based on statistical power analysis.

Recently, comparative genomic hybridization onto bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) arrays (array-based comparative genomic hybridization) has proved to be successful for the detection of submicroscopic DNA copy-number variations in health and disease. Technological improvements to achieve a higher resolution have resulted in the generation of additional microarray platforms encompassing larger numbers of shorter DNA targets (oligonucleotides). Here, we present a novel method to estimate the ability of a microarray to detect genomic copy-number variations of different sizes and types (i.e. deletions or duplications). We applied our method, which is based on statistical power analysis, to four widely used high-density genomic microarray platforms. By doing so, we found that the high-density oligonucleotide platforms are superior to the BAC platform for the genome-wide detection of copy-number variations smaller than 1 Mb. The capacity to reliably detect single copy-number variations below 100 kb, however, appeared to be limited for all platforms tested. In addition, our analysis revealed an unexpected platform-dependent difference in sensitivity to detect a single copy-number loss and a single copy-number gain. These analyses provide a first objective insight into the true capacities and limitations of different genomic microarrays to detect and define DNA copy-number variations.     

Diffusion limitation: a possible source for the occurrence of doughnut patterns on DNA microarrays

Doughnut shaped hybridization patterns on DNA microarrays are mainly allocated to spotting or drying artifacts. The present study reports on results obtained from four different approaches that when combined generate a better view on the occurrence of these patterns. This study points out that doughnuts are not only formed during the spotting and drying process, but the hybridization process itself can be considered as an important cause. A combination of computer simulations, theoretical, optical, and experimental techniques shows how ring-shaped hybridization patterns occur when diffusion-limited conditions are present during the hybridization process. The theoretical assumptions as well as the simulations indicate that, for the basic geometry of a microarray hybridization experiment, a large amount of binding molecules reach the spot from the sides (and not from above the spot), leading to a preferential binding on the rims of the spot. These patterns seem to occur especially during hybridization with short oligonucleotides that have a very high binding probability and fast hybridization kinetics. Longer target DNA molecules lead to a more evenly distributed intensity signal. Furthermore, the diffusion-limited conditions also lead to pronounced hybridization intensity patterns on the scale of a whole spot block, where larger intensities are obtained on the edges of the block compared with the spots laying in the center of the block.     

The development of a DNA microarray-based assay for the characterization of commercially formulated microbial products

Commercially formulated bioproducts containing a complex consortia of bacteria as an active ingredient pose a significant challenge for regulatory agencies and companies seeking to assess the safety and efficacy of these bioproducts. The main challenge stems from how to characterize the bacterial composition of these products, for which there is presently a lack of suitable methods. A prototype DNA microarray composed of oligonucleotide probes for functional genes, virulence factors, and taxonomic genes for a number of bacterial species was developed to examine the utility of microarray technology as a molecular tool for characterizing consortia bioproducts. The genomic DNA from four different products was extracted by two methods and examined with the microarray prototype and by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE). Although the identity of the consortial species remains unknown, the microarray assay provided unique and reproducible hybridization patterns for all four products, and agreed with the fingerprints generated by DGGE. The ability to differentiate between a variety of consortia products demonstrates that DNA microarrays have the potential to be a powerful tool in monitoring complex microbial communities.     

Dimensional analysis in mathematical biology. II

The application of dimensional analysis in biology is further illustrated by functional equations composed of dimensionless numbers and dealing with renal physiology, lung physiology and plant leaf shape. Dimensional variables and dimensionless numbers are examined from the viewpoint of numerical invariant properties of a certain physical system. Utilization of the method for problems such as design of an artificial kidney is considered briefly. A tabulation of variables useful in biology is given, with suggestions for a number of new dimensional entities. A continuation of the list of dimensionless invariants from Part I (Bull. Math. Biophysics,23, 355–376, 1961) is provided and includes terms pertaining to general physiology, geometric growth, metabolism, ecological interactions, muscle kinetics and other areas. It is pointed out that use of dimensionless ratios (similarity criteria) makes possible a direct comparison of form or shape factors and relative growth ratios with a variety of physical ratios, through the use of functional equations containing only dimensionless entities. Organismal similarity during growth and development, and between genetically related species, may be analyzed in terms of “automodel” or “self-similar” systems governed by certain dimensionless invariants. Tables of biological variables and dimensionless groupings are included.     

Analysis of crucial factors resulting in microarray hybridization failure

The factors that affect the formation and stability of DNA/DNA duplexes are complicated and still mostly unknown. In this study attempts were made to look for the crucial factor affecting hybridization failure in DNA microarray assays. A comprehensive range of factors were investigated simultaneously using a 25-mer oligonucleotide Potyvirus microarray. These included steric hindrance, direct/indirect labelling types, distance of a probe to the fluorescent labelling end, target (the DNA fragment used to hybridize with microarray probes) strand types either single strand or double strand, probes without mismatch and with different numbers of mismatch nucleotides (up to 36%) and different mismatch locations (5' end, centre and 3' end), probe GC content and T(m), secondary structures of probes and targets, different target lengths (0.277 kb to ~1.3 kb) and concentrations (0.1-30 nM). The results showed that whilst most of these known factors were unlikely to be the main causes of failed hybridization, there was strong evidence suggesting that the viral amplicon target structure is the most crucial factor. However, computing predicted target secondary structures by Mfold showed no correlation with the hybridization results. One explanation is that the predicted target secondary structures are different from the real structures. Here we postulate that the real target structure might be a combination of secondary structures resulting in a three-dimensional structure from exposure to three types of sub-structures: (1) a completely exposed linear structure to allow probes access for the successful hybridization and showing strong fluorescent signals; (2) a partially exposed structure to allow unstable binding and showing weak fluorescent signals; (3) a closed structure resulting in failed hybridization. These results are very important for microarray based studies as they not only provide an explanation for some current controversial results, but also provide potential resolution for the future studies. Due to the lack of available software for predicting the true target structure, development of microarrays should conduct an initial oligonucleotide probe selection procedure and those probes with capacity to hybridize with the target should be considered for the microarray development.     

Single-nucleotide polymorphism analysis by hybridization protection assay on solid support

The clinical need for high-throughput typing methods of single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) has been increasing. Conventional methods do not perform well enough in terms of speed and accuracy to process a large number of samples, as in clinical testing. We report a new DNA microarray method that uses hybridization protection assay (HPA) by acridinium-ester-labeled DNA probes. Probes were immobilized on the bottom of streptavidin-coated microtiter plates by streptavidin-biotin binding. We studied aldehyde dehydrogenase 2 (ALDH2) genotyping using two probes, discriminating A/G polymorphism. We also designed four probes to type the Alzheimer's disease-related gene ApoE, which has three genotypes (ApoE2, 3, and 4) determined by two SNP loci (C/T polymorphism). SNP analysis of the ALDH2 gene or the ApoE gene from human genome samples by solid-phase HPA was successful. Unlike other methods, the microarray by HPA does not require a washing step and can be completed within 30min. It also has advantages in discriminating one-base mismatch in targets. These characteristics make it a good candidate for practical SNP analysis of disease-related genes or drug-metabolizing enzymes in large numbers of samples.     

Dramatic increase in signal by integration of polymerase chain reaction and hybridization on surface of DNA microarray

The cumbersome process required for diagnosis by DNA microarray can be simplified by simple extraction of nucleic acid from cells and by integration of liquid-phase polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and hybridization on the surface of a microarray slide. An unexpected benefit was the large (five- to sixfold) increase in detection signal that also is translated into an increase in sensitivity and the confidence level of diagnosis. The large increase in the detection signal appears to be due to participation of PCR primers as well as to extension of the immobilized capture probes during the hybridization process. The reason for the large increase in signal is not clear in view of only one round of DNA synthesis during the hybridization step. The integrated process correctly identified various genotypes of human papillomavirus (HPV) in the infected clinical human cervical specimens with specificity and efficiency. The process described in this article saves labor, time, and cost and should be applicable for automation of diagnosis by DNA microarray.     

Regeneration of comparative genomic hybridization oligonucleotide microarrays with dimethylurea

Reuse of materials in DNA hybridization-based methods has been known since the advent of Southern membranes. Array-based comparative genomic hybridization is essentially Southern hybridization with multiple probes immobilized on a solid surface. We show that comparative genomic hybridization microarrays fabricated with maskless array synthesizer technology can be used up to four times with the application of 1,3-dimethylurea as an array-stripping agent. We reproducibly detected chromosomal aberrations (0.6-22.4Mb in size) in four hybridization rounds using regenerated microarray slides. We also demonstrated that regenerated arrays can detect smaller alterations (16-200kbp), such as common copy number variants, as well as complex aberration profiles in tumor DNA.     

DNA microarrays on nanoscale-controlled surface

We have developed new surface to ensure a proper spacing between immobilized biomolecules. While DNA microarray on this surface provided each probe DNA with ample space for hybridization with incoming target DNAs, the microarray showed enhanced discrimination efficiency for various types of single nucleotide polymorphism. The high discrimination efficiency holds for all tested cases (100:<1 for internal mismatched cases; 100:<28 for terminal mismatched ones). In addition, by investigating influence of hybridization temperature and washing condition on the fluorescence intensity and the discrimination efficiency with and without controlled mesospacing, it was observed that the nanoscale-controlled surface showed good discrimination efficiency in a wide range of temperature (37–50°C), and hybridization behavior on the surface was in agreement with the solution one. Intriguingly, it was found that washing process after the hybridization was critical for the high discrimination efficiency. For the particular case, washing process was so efficient that only 30 s washing was sufficient to reach the optimal discrimination ratio.     

Conditions to ensure competitive hybridization in two-color microarray: a theoretical and experimental analysis

We derived a theoretical model that explains certain biases observed in the two-color microarray hybridization experiments reported in the literature. We show that true competition is achieved only when the hybridization kinetics of the two differentially labeled probes are the same. If the hybridization kinetics of the two differentially labeled probes is different, which can occur when the labeling and hybridization conditions for the two probes are dissimilar, then differential expression observed becomes a function of the amount of the target (i.e., DNA spotted on the slide). We use this model to validate the microarray methodology by determining the differential expression of four select Arabidopsis genes and two human genes (beta-actin and GAPDH) as a function of the amount of target arrayed. We show through both modeling and experiments that the rate constants for Cy5- and Cy3-labeled probes are the same under our exrimental conditions. Therefore, the target concentrations need not greatly exceed the probe concentration. It is obvious from the data presented that a simple treatment of an individual hybridization rate calculation does notfully describe what is occuring in today's complex, multispecies experiments. The method of validation is easily implemented to ensure data reliability by two-color microarray.     

Estimation of relative allele frequencies of single-nucleotide polymorphisms in different populations by microarray hybridization of pooled DNA

Single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are considered useful polymorphic markers for genetic studies of polygenic traits. A new practical approach to high-throughput genotyping of SNPs in a large number of individuals is needed in association study and other studies on relationships between genes and diseases. We have developed an accurate and high-throughput method for determining the allele frequencies by pooling the DNA samples and applying a DNA microarray hybridization analysis. In this method, the combination of the microarray, DNA pooling, probe pair hybridization, and fluorescent ratio analysis solves the dual problems of parallel multiple sample analysis, and parallel multiplex SNP genotyping for association study. Multiple DNA samples are immobilized on a slide and a single hybridization is performed with a pool of allele-specific oligonucleotide probes. The results of this study show that hybridization of microarray from pooled DNA samples can accurately obtain estimates of absolute allele frequencies in a sample pool. This method can also be used to identify differences in allele frequencies in distinct populations. It is amenable to automation and is suitable for immediate utilization for high-throughput genotyping of SNP.     

A highly specific microarray method for point mutation detection

Improvements of microarray techniques for genotyping purposes have focused on increasing the reliability of this method. Here we report the development of a genotyping method where a microarray was spotted with stemloop probes, especially designed to optimize the hybridization specificity of complementary DNA sequences. This accurate method was used to screen for four common disease-causing mutations involved in a neurological disorder called Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT). Healthy individuals' and patients' DNA were amplified and labeled by PCR and hybridized on microarray. The spot signal intensities were 81 to 408 times greater for perfect compared with mismatched target sequences, differing by only one nucleotide (discrimination ratio) for healthy individual "homozygous" DNA. On the other hand, "heterozygous" mutant DNA samples gave rise to signal intensity ratios close to 1, as expected. The genotypes obtained by this method were perfectly consistent with those determined by direct PCR sequencing. Cross-hybridization rates were very low, resulting in further multiplexing improvements. In this study, we also demonstrated the feasibility of real-time hybridization detection of labeled synthetic oligonucleotides with concentrations as low as 2.5 nM.     

On the origins of tandemly repeated genes: Does histone gene copy number inDrosophila reflect chromosomal location?

Widely regarded beliefs aboutDrosophila histone gene copy numbers and developmental requirements have been generalized from fairly limited data since studies on histone gene arrangements and copy numbers have been largely confined to a single species,D. melanogaster. Histone gene copy numbers and chromosomal locations were examined in three species:D. melanogaster, D. hydei andD. hawaiiensis. Quantitative whole genome blot analysis of DNA from diploid tissues revealed a tenfold variability in histone gene copy numbers for these three species. In situ hybridization to polytene chromosomes showed that the histone DNA (hDNA) chromosomal location is different in all three species. These observations lead us to propose a relationship between histone gene reiteration and chromosomal position.     

A DNA microarray-based methylation-sensitive (MS)-AFLP hybridization method for genetic and epigenetic analyses

We previously developed a PCR-based DNA fingerprinting technique named the Methylation Sensitive (MS)-AFLP method, which permits comparative genome-wide scanning of methylation status with a manageable number of fingerprinting experiments. The technique uses the methylation sensitive restriction enzyme Not I in the context of the existing Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphism (AFLP) method. Here we report the successful conversion of this gel electrophoresis-based DNA fingerprinting technique into a DNA microarray hybridization technique (DNA Microarray MS-AFLP). By performing a total of 30 (15×2 reciprocal labeling) DNA Microarray MS-AFLP hybridization experiments on genomic DNA from two breast and three prostate cancer cell lines in all pairwise combinations, and Southern hybridization experiments using more than 100 different probes, we have demonstrated that the DNA Microarray MS-AFLP is a reliable method for genetic and epigenetic analyses. No statistically significant differences were observed in the number of differences between the breast-prostate hybridization experiments and the breast-breast or prostate-prostate comparisons.Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available in the online version of this article at Communicated by M. Johnston     

An investigation of enumeration and DNA partitioning in Bacillus subtilis L-form bacteria

R.N. WATERHOUSE, E.J. ALLAN, F. AMIJEE, V.J. UNDRILL AND L.A. GLOVER. 1994. Cell numbers of two morphogenic forms of Bacillus subtilis (the cell-walled parental and the derived stable cell wall-deficient L-form) have been compared by two methods: DNA hybridization (i.e. deduced genome numbers) and viable cell counts (i.e. number of colony-forming units (cfu)). The DNA hybridization method was shown to be a reliable and reproducible method for estimating genome numbers. Comparison of different L-form populations showed that the two methods of enumeration gave different values, with the deduced genome numbers much higher (by several orders of magnitude) than cell numbers deduced from viable cell counts. In contrast, when a culture of the cell-walled form was enumerated, the discrepancy between the two methods was low (by a factor of about 6) The combination of a high number of L-form genomes detected by DNA hybridization and a relatively low number of cfu was thought to be a consequence of a diminished co-ordination between the DNA replication and cell division processes in L-form bacteria. This suggestion was further substantiated by assessing the stability of plasmid pPL608 in a transformed B. subtilis L-form cell line, where even in the presence of continued kanamycin selection, 25% of the population lost kanamycin resistance. The results are discussed with particular reference to cell division in cell wall-deficient, stable L-form bacteria.     

Rapid, high fidelity analysis of simple sequence repeats on an electronically active DNA microchip

We describe a method for the discrimination of short tandem repeat (STR) alleles based on active microarray hybridization. An essential factor in this method is electronic hybridization of the target DNA, at high stringency, in <5 min. High stringency is critical to avoid slippage of hybrids along repeat tracts at allele-specific test sites in the array. These conditions are attainable only with hybridization kinetics realized by electronic concentration of DNA. A sandwich hybrid is assembled, in which proper base stacking of juxtaposed terminal nucleotides results in a thermodynamically favored complex. The increased stability of this complex relative to non-stacked termini and/or base pair mismatches is used to determine the identification of STR alleles. This method is capable of simultaneous and precise identification of alleles containing different numbers of repeats, as well as mutations within these repeats. Given the throughput capabilities of microarrays our system has the potential to enhance the use of microsatellites in forensic criminology, diagnostics and genetic mapping.     

Relationship between genome similarity and DNA-DNA hybridization among closely related bacteria

DNA-DNA hybridization has been established as an important technology in bacterial species taxonomy and phylogenetic analysis. In this study, we analyzed how the efficiency with which the genomic DNA from one species hybridizes to the genomic DNA of another species (DNA-DNA hybridization) in microarray analysis relates to the similarity between two genomes. We found that the predicted DNA-DNA hybridization based on genome sequence similarity correlated well with the experimentally determined microarray hybridization. Between closely related strains, significant numbers of highly divergent genes (<55% identity) and/or the accumulation of mismatches between conserved genes lowered the DNA-DNA hybridization signal, and this reduced the hybridization signals to below 70% for even bacterial strains with over 97% 16S rRNA gene identity. In addition, our results also suggest that a DNA-DNA hybridization signal intensity of over 40% indicates that two genomes at least shared 30% conserved genes (>60% gene identity). This study may expand our knowledge of DNA-DNA hybridization based on genomic sequence similarity comparison and further provide insights for bacterial phylogeny analyses.