The circuitry of cargo flux in the ESCRT pathway

Meiosis-specific mammalian cohesin SMC1β is required for complete sister chromatid cohesion and proper axes/loop structure of axial elements (AEs) and synaptonemal complexes (SCs). During prophase I, telomeres attach to the nuclear envelope (NE), but in Smc1β^−/− meiocytes, one fifth of their telomeres fail to attach. This study reveals that SMC1β serves a specific role at telomeres, which is independent of its role in determining AE/SC length and loop extension. SMC1β is necessary to prevent telomere shortening, and SMC3, present in all known cohesin complexes, properly localizes to telomeres only if SMC1β is present. Very prominently, telomeres in Smc1β^−/− spermatocytes and oocytes loose their structural integrity and suffer a range of abnormalities. These include disconnection from SCs and formation of large telomeric protein–DNA extensions, extended telomere bridges between SCs, ring-like chromosomes, intrachromosomal telomeric repeats, and a reduction of SUN1 foci in the NE. We suggest that a telomere structure protected from DNA rearrangements depends on SMC1β.     

Tooth-derived stem cells: Update and perspectives

Tissue engineering is an emerging field of science that focuses on creating suitable conditions for the regeneration of tissues. The basic components for tissue engineering involve an interactive triad of scaffolds, signaling molecules, and cells. In this context,stem cells(SCs) present the characteristics of selfrenewal and differentiation capacity, which make them promising candidates for tissue engineering. Although they present some common markers, such as cluster of differentiation(CD)105, CD146 and STRO-1, SCs derived from various tissues have different patterns in relation to proliferation, clonogenicity, and differentiation abilities in vitro and in vivo. Tooth-derived tissues have been proposed as an accessible source to obtain SCs with limited morbidity, and various tooth-derived SCs(TDSCs) have been isolated and characterized, such as dental pulp SCs, SCs from human exfoliated deciduous teeth, periodontal ligament SCs, dental follicle progenitor cells, SCs from apical papilla, and periodontal ligament of deciduous teeth SCs. However, heterogeneity among these populations has been observed, and the best method to select the most appropriate TDSCs for regeneration approaches has not yet been established. The objective of this review is to outline the current knowledge concerning the various types of TDSCs, and discuss the perspectives for their use in regenerative approaches.     

Dammaradiene synthase, a squalene cyclase, from Dryopteris crassirhizoma Nakai

Ferns produce a variety of cyclic triterpene hydrocarbons in large amount. Squalene cyclases (SCs) are responsible enzymes for formation of cyclic triterpene hydrocarbon skeletons. Although more than ten bacterial SCs have been cloned and four of them characterized for their enzymatic products, the only example of a fern SC is ACH, from Adiantum capillus-veneris, which produces hydroxyhopane. To obtain a deeper understanding of the molecular evolution of SCs and the origin of the structural diversity of fern triterpenes, further cloning and characterization of SCs have been pursued. In this study, a SC cDNA, DCD, was cloned from Dryopteris crassirhizoma by homology-based RT-PCR. DCD contains a 2058-bp open reading frame that encodes a 685 amino acid polypeptide exhibiting 66% identity to the previously identified fern SC, ACH, and 35-40% identity to bacterial SCs. Heterologous expression of DCD in yeast established it to be a dammaradiene synthase affording dammara-18(28),21-diene, a tetracyclic triterpene hydrocarbon. Although neither this compound nor any derived metabolites have been previously reported from D. crassirhizoma, re-investigation of the leaflets demonstrated the presence of dammara-18(28),21-diene. DCD represents the first SC that produces a tetracyclic triterpene hydrocarbon.     

Clonal Characterization of Rat Muscle Satellite Cells: Proliferation,Metabolism and Differentiation Define an Intrinsic Heterogeneity

Satellite cells (SCs) represent a distinct lineage of myogenic progenitors responsible for the postnatal growth, repair and maintenance of skeletal muscle. Distinguished on the basis of their unique position in mature skeletal muscle, SCs were considered unipotent stem cells with the ability of generating a unique specialized phenotype. Subsequently, it was demonstrated in mice that opposite differentiation towards osteogenic and adipogenic pathways was also possible. Even though the pool of SCs is accepted as the major, and possibly the only, source of myonuclei in postnatal muscle, it is likely that SCs are not all multipotent stem cells and evidences for diversities within the myogenic compartment have been described both in vitro and in vivo. Here, by isolating single fibers from rat flexor digitorum brevis (FDB) muscle we were able to identify and clonally characterize two main subpopulations of SCs: the low proliferative clones (LPC) present in major proportion (∼75%) and the high proliferative clones (HPC), present instead in minor amount (∼25%). LPC spontaneously generate myotubes whilst HPC differentiate into adipocytes even though they may skip the adipogenic program if co-cultured with LPC. LPC and HPC differ also for mitochondrial membrane potential (ΔΨ_m), ATP balance and Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS) generation underlying diversities in metabolism that precede differentiation. Notably, SCs heterogeneity is retained in vivo. SCs may therefore be comprised of two distinct, though not irreversibly committed, populations of cells distinguishable for prominent differences in basal biological features such as proliferation, metabolism and differentiation. By these means, novel insights on SCs heterogeneity are provided and evidences for biological readouts potentially relevant for diagnostic purposes described.     

Integrated Copy Number and Expression Analysis Identifies Profiles of Whole-Arm Chromosomal Alterations and Subgroups with Favorable Outcome in Ovarian Clear Cell Carcinomas

Ovarian clear cell carcinoma (CCC) is generally associated with chemoresistance and poor clinical outcome, even with early diagnosis; whereas high-grade serous carcinomas (SCs) and endometrioid carcinomas (ECs) are commonly chemosensitive at advanced stages. Although an integrated genomic analysis of SC has been performed, conclusive views on copy number and expression profiles for CCC are still limited. In this study, we performed single nucleotide polymorphism analysis with 57 epithelial ovarian cancers (31 CCCs, 14 SCs, and 12 ECs) and microarray expression analysis with 55 cancers (25 CCCs, 16 SCs, and 14 ECs). We then evaluated PIK3CA mutations and ARID1A expression in CCCs. SNP array analysis classified 13% of CCCs into a cluster with high frequency and focal range of copy number alterations (CNAs), significantly lower than for SCs (93%, P < 0.01) and ECs (50%, P = 0.017). The ratio of whole-arm to all CNAs was higher in CCCs (46.9%) than SCs (21.7%; P < 0.0001). SCs with loss of heterozygosity (LOH) of BRCA1 (85%) also had LOH of NF1 and TP53, and LOH of BRCA2 (62%) coexisted with LOH of RB1 and TP53. Microarray analysis classified CCCs into three clusters. One cluster (CCC-2, n = 10) showed more favorable prognosis than the CCC-1 and CCC-3 clusters (P = 0.041). Coexistent alterations of PIK3CA and ARID1A were more common in CCC-1 and CCC-3 (7/11, 64%) than in CCC-2 (0/10, 0%; P < 0.01). Being in cluster CCC-2 was an independent favorable prognostic factor in CCC. In conclusion, CCC was characterized by a high ratio of whole-arm CNAs; whereas CNAs in SC were mainly focal, but preferentially caused LOH of well-known tumor suppressor genes. As such, expression profiles might be useful for sub-classification of CCC, and might provide useful information on prognosis.     

The Wilms Tumor Gene,Wt1, Is Critical for Mouse Spermatogenesis via Regulation of Sertoli Cell Polarity and Is Associated with Non-Obstructive Azoospermia in Humans

Azoospermia is one of the major reproductive disorders which cause male infertility in humans; however, the etiology of this disease is largely unknown. In the present study, six missense mutations of WT1 gene were detected in 529 human patients with non-obstructive azoospermia (NOA), indicating a strong association between WT1 mutation and NOA. The Wilms tumor gene, Wt1, is specifically expressed in Sertoli cells (SCs) which support spermatogenesis. To examine the functions of this gene in spermatogenesis, Wt1 was deleted in adult testis using Wt1^flox and Cre-ER^TM mice strains. We found that inactivation of Wt1 resulted in massive germ cell death and only SCs were present in most of the seminiferous tubules which was very similar to NOA in humans. In investigating the potential mechanism for this, histological studies revealed that the blood–testis barrier (BTB) was disrupted in Wt1 deficient testes. In vitro studies demonstrated that Wt1 was essential for cell polarity maintenance in SCs. Further studies found that the expression of cell polarity associated genes (Par6b and E-cadherin) and Wnt signaling genes (Wnt4, Wnt11) were downregulated in Wt1 deficient SCs, and that the expression of Par6b and E-cadherin was regulated by Wnt4. Our findings suggest that Wt1 is important in spermatogenesis by regulating the polarity of SCs via Wnt signaling pathway and that WT1 mutation is one of the genetic causes of NOA in humans.     

Hypoxia Increases Mouse Satellite Cell Clone Proliferation Maintaining both In Vitro and In Vivo Heterogeneity and Myogenic Potential

Satellite cells (SCs) are essential for postnatal muscle growth and regeneration, however, their expansion potential in vitro is limited. Recently, hypoxia has been used to enhance proliferative abilities in vitro of various primary cultures. Here, by isolating SCs from single mouse hindlimb skeletal myofibers, we were able to distinguish two subpopulations of clonally cultured SCs (Low Proliferative Clones - LPC - and High Proliferative Clones - HPC), which, as shown in rat skeletal muscle, were present at a fixed proportion. In addition, culturing LPC and HPC at a low level of oxygen we observed a two fold increased proliferation both for LPC and HPC. LPC showed higher myogenic regulatory factor (MRF) expression than HPC, particularly under the hypoxic condition. Notably, a different myogenic potential between LPC and HPC was retained in vivo: green fluorescent protein (GFP)+LPC transplantation in cardiotoxin-injured Tibialis Anterior led to a higher number of new GFP+muscle fibers per transplanted cell than GFP+HPC. Interestingly, the in vivo myogenic potential of a single cell from an LPC is similar if cultured both in normoxia and hypoxia. Therefore, starting from a single satellite cell, hypoxia allows a larger expansion of LPC than normal O₂ conditions, obtaining a consistent amount of cells for transplantation, but maintaining their myogenic regeneration potential.     

MEIOTIC F-BOX Is Essential for Male Meiotic DNA Double-Strand Break Repair in Rice

F-box proteins constitute a large superfamily in plants and play important roles in controlling many biological processes, but the roles of F-box proteins in male meiosis in plants remain unclear. Here, we identify the rice (Oryza sativa) F-box gene MEIOTIC F-BOX (MOF), which is essential for male meiotic progression. MOF belongs to the FBX subfamily and is predominantly active during leptotene to pachytene of prophase I. mof meiocytes display disrupted telomere bouquet formation, impaired pairing and synapsis of homologous chromosomes, and arrested meiocytes at late prophase I, followed by apoptosis. Although normal, programmed double-stranded DNA breaks (DSBs) form in mof mutants, foci of the phosphorylated histone variant γH2AX, a marker for DSBs, persist in the mutant, indicating that many of the DSBs remained unrepaired. The recruitment of Completion of meiosis I (COM1) and Radiation sensitive51C (RAD51C) to DSBs is severely compromised in mutant meiocytes, indicating that MOF is crucial for DSB end-processing and repair. Further analyses showed that MOF could physically interact with the rice SKP1-like Protein1 (OSK1), indicating that MOF functions as a component of the SCF E3 ligase to regulate meiotic progression in rice. Thus, this study reveals the essential role of an F-box protein in plant meiosis and provides helpful information for elucidating the roles of the ubiquitin proteasome system in plant meiotic progression.     

Noncanonical meiosis in the nematode <Emphasis Type="Italic">Caenorhabditis elegans</Emphasis> as a model for studying the molecular bases of the homologous chromosome synapsis,crossing over,and segregation

The nematode C. elegans is a classic study object of developmental biology and genetics, which is particularly suitable for studying the molecular bases of meiosis. Developing meiocytes are located in the threadlike gonads of C. elegans in linear gradient order of the stages of meiosis, which facilitates studying the order of intracellular events during meiosis. C. elegans has polycentric chromosomes. This causes a special order of events during meiosis, and as a consequence, meiosis in C. elegance differs from canonical meiosis of most eukaryotes. In the meiotic prophase I, all chromosomes carry single protein “pairing centers.” They are responsible for joining homologous chromosomes in pairs. This initiates the formation of synaptonemal complexes (SCs). Programmed double-stranded DNA breaks appear after initiation of the SC assembly, and they give rise to meiotic recombination. The initiation of meiotic recombination after the chromosome pairing distinguishes the C. elegans meiotic pattern from those in the absolute majority of eukaryotes studied. C. elegans has strict crossing over interference, which allows for the formation of one chiasma per bivalent. In the late prophase I, the polycentric centromeres are remodeled, one of the chromosome ends acquires a cuplike kinetochore, and during two meiotic divisions, chromosomes behave as monocentric. The study of meiosis in C. elegans allows for separate investigation of synapsis and recombination of homologous chromosomes and provides material for studying the evolution of meiosis.     

Cytogenetics, Geographical Distribution, Pollen Stainability and Fecundity of Santolina impressa (Asteraceae: Anthemideae)

Santolina impressa (2n = 2x = 18) is an endemic species of Portugal, with restricted geographical distribution. The present study aimed to explore its chromosomal variation in respect to chromosome morphology, meiotic behaviour, and effects on pollen stainability and fecundity. Its karyotype formula was found to be either 12m + 2m^sat + 2sm^sat + 2st (75% of the individuals) or 12m + 2m^sat + 3sm + 1sm^sat (25% of the individuals). Univalents were observed in 29.21% of the meiocytes. Chromosome fragments due to breakage in the chromosome arm were observed in 10 meiocytes only (11.23% of the meiocytes). Chains and rings of trivalents were observed in 14.60% of the meiocytes (one trivalent per meiocyte was observed). Chains and rings of quadrivalents were observed in 21.34% and 11.23% of the meiocytes, respectively, with a range of 0–1 per cell. Nine plants (40.90% of the total) with 2n = 2x = 18 + 2B showed a quadrivalent configuration in diakinesis. Twenty abnormal anaphases with delayed disjunction of the four non-homologous and the two homologous chromosomes were observed. Simple chromosome bridges without fragments and interchromosomal adhesions were observed in 35.95% of the anaphases analyzed. B chromosomes showed bivalent association in diakinesis and their segregation at anaphase I was normal. Pollen was found to be fertile (mean ± s.d. = 89.57 ± 47.14%); the effect of univalent frequency and frequency of abnormal anaphase I on pollen stainability was strong and statistically significant.     

Whey protein supplementation accelerates satellite cell proliferation during recovery from eccentric exercise

Human skeletal muscle satellite cells (SCs) are essential for muscle regeneration and remodeling processes in healthy and clinical conditions involving muscle breakdown. However, the potential influence of protein supplementation on post-exercise SC regulation in human skeletal muscle has not been well investigated. In a comparative human study, we investigated the effect of hydrolyzed whey protein supplementation following eccentric exercise on fiber type-specific SC accumulation. Twenty-four young healthy subjects received either hydrolyzed whey protein + carbohydrate (whey, n = 12) or iso-caloric carbohydrate (placebo, n = 12) during post-exercise recovery from 150 maximal unilateral eccentric contractions. Prior to and 24, 48 and 168 h post-exercise, muscle biopsies were obtained from the exercise leg and analyzed for fiber type-specific SC content. Maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) and serum creatine kinase (CK) were evaluated as indices of recovery from muscle damage. In type II fiber-associated SCs, the whey group increased SCs/fiber from 0.05 [0.02; 0.07] to 0.09 [0.06; 0.12] (p < 0.05) and 0.11 [0.06; 0.16] (p < 0.001) at 24 and 48 h, respectively, and exhibited a difference from the placebo group (p < 0.05) at 48 h. The whey group increased SCs/myonuclei from 4?% [2; 5] to 10?% [4; 16] (p?p < 0.001) and muscle soreness and CK increased (p < 0.001), irrespective of supplementation. In conclusion, whey protein supplementation may accelerate SC proliferation as part of the regeneration or remodeling process after high-intensity eccentric exercise.     

A Disintegrin and Metalloprotease 10 (ADAM10) Is Indispensable for Maintenance of the Muscle Satellite Cell Pool

Satellite cells (SCs) are muscle-specific stem cells that are essential for the regeneration of damaged muscles. Although SCs have a robust capacity to regenerate myofibers, the number of SCs decreases with aging, leading to insufficient recovery after muscle injury. We herein show that ADAM10 (a disintegrin and metalloprotease 10), a membrane-bound proteolytic enzyme with a critical role in Notch processing (S2 cleavage), is essential for the maintenance of SC quiescence. We generated mutant mice in which ADAM10 in SCs can be conditionally abrogated by tamoxifen injection. Tamoxifen-treated mutant mice did not show any apparent defects and grew normally under unchallenged conditions. However, these mice showed a nearly complete loss of muscle regeneration after chemically induced muscle injury. In situ hybridization and flow cytometric analyses revealed that the mutant mice had significantly less SCs compared with wild type controls. Of note, we found that inactivation of ADAM10 in SCs severely compromised Notch signaling and led to dysregulated myogenic differentiation, ultimately resulting in deprivation of the SC pool in vivo. Taken together, the present findings underscore the role of ADAM10 as an indispensable component of Notch signaling in SCs and for maintaining the SC pool.     

IL-6 induced STAT3 signalling is associated with the proliferation of human muscle satellite cells following acute muscle damage

Background

Although the satellite cell (SC) is a key regulator of muscle growth during development and muscle adaptation following exercise, the regulation of human muscle SC function remains largely unexplored. STAT3 signalling mediated via interleukin-6 (IL-6) has recently come to the forefront as a potential regulator of SC proliferation. The early response of the SC population in human muscle to muscle-lengthening contractions (MLC) as mediated by STAT3 has not been studied.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Twelve male subjects (21±2 y; 83±12 kg) performed 300 maximal MLC of the quadriceps femoris at 180°•s⁻¹ over a 55° range of motion with muscle samples (vastus lateralis) and blood samples (antecubital vein) taken prior to exercise (PRE), 1 hour (T1), 3 hours (T3) and 24 hours (T24) post-exercise. Cytoplasmic and nuclear fractions of muscle biopsies were purified and analyzed for total and phosphorylated STAT3 (p-STAT3) by western blot. p-STAT3 was detected in cytoplasmic fractions across the time course peaking at T24 (p<0.01 vs. PRE). Nuclear total and p-STAT3 were not detected at appreciable levels. However, immunohistochemical analysis revealed a progressive increase in the proportion of SCs expressing p-STAT3 with ∼60% of all SCs positive for p-STAT3 at T24 (p<0.001 vs. PRE). Additionally, cMyc, a STAT3 downstream gene, was significantly up-regulated in SCs at T24 versus PRE (p<0.05). Whole muscle mRNA analysis revealed induction of the STAT3 target genes IL-6, SOCS3, cMyc (peaking at T3, p<0.05), IL-6Rα and GP130 (peaking at T24, p<0.05). In addition, Myf5 mRNA was up-regulated at T24 (p<0.05) with no appreciable change in MRF4 mRNA.

Conclusions/Significant Findings

We demonstrate that IL-6 induction of STAT3 signaling occurred exclusively in the nuclei of SCs in response to MLC. An increase in the number of cMyc+ SCs indicated that human SCs were induced to proliferate under the control of STAT3 signaling.     

Chromosome pairing in meiosis of partially fertile wheat/rye hybrids

The normal course of meiosis depends on regular pairing of homologous chromosomes. In intergeneric hybrids, including those of wheat, there is no chromosome pairing because there are no homologs. In F₁ wheat/rye hybrids, pairing is largely prevented by the pairing homoeologous1 (Ph1) gene. In its presence, there are only rare instances of pairing; most chromosomes are univalent, and their orientation at metaphase I initiates different pathways of the meiotic cycle. The meiotic-like pathway includes a combination of the reductional and the equational + reductional steps at AI followed by the second division. The resulting gametes are mostly non-functional. The mitotic-like pathway involves equational division of univalents at AI and the absence of the second division. Any fertility of wheat/rye hybrids depends on the production of unreduced gametes arising from meiotic restitution (mitotic-like division). We examined the meiotic pairing in wheat/rye hybrids created from wheat lines with single rye chromosome substitutions and Ph1 present. This guaranteed F₁ meiosis with one pair of rye homologs. All hybrids formed bivalents, but proportions of meiocytes with bivalents varied. In the meiocytes where bivalents were present, there was a higher tendency for the meiotic-like pathway, while in meiocytes where bivalent pairing failed, the tendency was stronger for the mitotic-like pathway. Among the equationally dividing cells, we observed more than 90 % of meiocytes without bivalents, where rye homologs did not form bivalents, too. The data indicate a potential application of wheat/rye lines in producing genetic stocks of amphidiploids with designated genomic constitutions.     

Chiasma frequencies in the meiocytes from the anther diametrical zones in species from the genus <Emphasis Type="Italic">Capsicum</Emphasis> L.

A study of the chiasma frequencies in the meiocytes from three anther diametrical zones (free end, middle, and base) in plants from species of the genus Capsicum was carried out. It was found that the maximum values of the total chiasma frequencies were observed in the meiocytes from the anther free end compared to its middle zone and base. It was concluded that the peculiarities of the distribution of crossover events lengthwise along the anther were the result of its anatomic structure.     

Effects of elevated temperature on meiotic chromosome synapsis in Allium ursinum

Synaptonemal complex (SC) formation in microsporocytes of Allium ursinum is severely affected by exposure of plants to 35° C for 30 h or longer. In spread preparations made from fresh and freeze-conserved material it was found that a high proportion of meiocytes is arrested at leptotene and shows no synapsis at all. In another group of nuclei synaptonemal polycomplex-like structures do occur between converging axial elements at presumed rudimentary SC initiation sites. Axial elements are virtually always thickened at these sites which seem to involve primarily heterologous chromosomes. A third situation is seen in nuclei where two or more lateral elements are engaged in the formation of longer stretches of aberrant SCs. These feature surplus material filling the central space. It may be assumed that this abnormal condition precludes crossing over and hence may be one of several ways by which elevated temperatures cause the chiasma reduction described here for A. ursinum and reported for several other organisms in the literature.     

GLUCAN SYNTHASE-LIKE8 and STEROL METHYLTRANSFERASE2 Are Required for Ploidy Consistency of the Sexual Reproduction System in Arabidopsis

In sexually reproducing plants, the meiocyte-producing archesporal cell lineage is maintained at the diploid state to consolidate the formation of haploid gametes. In search of molecular factors that regulate this ploidy consistency, we isolated an Arabidopsis thaliana mutant, called enlarged tetrad2 (et2), which produces tetraploid meiocytes through the stochastic occurrence of premeiotic endomitosis. Endomitotic polyploidization events were induced by alterations in cell wall formation, and similar cytokinetic defects were sporadically observed in other tissues, including cotyledons and leaves. ET2 encodes GLUCAN SYNTHASE-LIKE8 (GSL8), a callose synthase that mediates the deposition of callose at developing cell plates, root hairs, and plasmodesmata. Unlike other gsl8 mutants, in which defects in cell plate formation are seedling lethal, cytokinetic defects in et2 predominantly occur in flowers and have little effect on vegetative growth and development. Similarly, mutations in STEROL METHYLTRANSFERASE2 (SMT2), a major sterol biosynthesis enzyme, also lead to weak cytokinetic defects, primarily in the flowers. In addition, SMT2 allelic mutants also generate tetraploid meiocytes through the ectopic induction of premeiotic endomitosis. These observations demonstrate that appropriate callose and sterol biosynthesis are required for maintaining the ploidy level of the premeiotic germ lineage and that subtle defects in cytokinesis may lead to diploid gametes and polyploid offspring.     

Meiotic Exchange without the Synaptinemal Complex

THE synaptinemal complex is a ribbonlike tripartite structure, normally restricted to the nucleus of meiocytes and located along the longitudinal axis of bivalent chromosomes¹. It consists of two dense lateral elements (about 400 Å in width) separated from the central element (about 250 Å in width) by spaces of about 400 Å (Fig. 1). Various functions have been proposed for it, primarily that it is intimately involved in meiotic exchange, either directly by promoting effective pairing between complementary nucleotide strands of homologous chromosomes^1–3 or indirectly by providing for the rough alignment of homologues before their more intimate association^4,5. In this view, the complex is an essential feature of the regular and extensive exchange process typical of meiosis. The firmest evidence in support of its role in exchange has been its concomitant presence in primary meiocytes whenever genetic or cytological evidence indicates that crossing-over is occurring¹. The presence of the complex in meiocytes which lack exchange and/or chiasmata, for example, the female of Bombyx mori⁶, intergeneric hybrids, haploid genomes and certain achiasmate male insects, as well as its presence in univalent X chromosomes of primary spermatocytes and in postmeiotic spermatids, has been interpreted as “the exceptions that prove, or at least refine, the rule¹.” Here, for the first time, we describe the converse situation, one in which high frequencies of meiotic exchange, as determined by genetic tests, are not accompanied by a detectable synaptinemal complex. This means that both pairing of homologues, which must precede exchange and the exchange process itself can occur in the meiocyte without the aid of the synaptinemal complex.