Target sites of aluminum phytotoxicity

The primary phytotoxic effect of aluminum (Al) is confined to the root apex. It is a matter of debate whether the primary injury of Al toxicity is apoplastic or symplastic. This review paper summarizes our current understanding of the spatial and metabolic sites of Al phytotoxicity. At tissue level, the meristematic, distal transition, and apical elongation zones of the root apex are most sensitive to Al. At cellular and molecular level, many cell components are implicated in Al toxicity including DNA in nucleus, numerous cytoplastic compounds, the plasma membrane, and the cell wall. Although it is difficult to distinguish the primary targets from the secondary effects so far, understanding of the target sites of Al toxicity is helpful for elucidating the mechanisms by which Al exerts its deleterious effects on root growth.This work was partly supported by fund from the Huoyingdong Foundation, Education Ministry of China and Natural Science Foundation of China (Contact No. 30170548).     

The Role of the Plasma Membrane in the Response of Plant Roots to Aluminum Toxicity

Al³⁺, the predominant form of solubilized aluminum at pH values below 5.0, has been shown to exert a profound inhibitory effect on root elongation. Al is known to accumulate at the root apex. The plasma membrane represents the first potential target for Al toxicity, due to its pronounced binding to phospholipids. Al appears to alter both the structure and functions of the plasma membrane, and a great deal of research has been conducted concerning the interactions between Al and the plasma membrane. In this review, recent findings regarding the interactions between Al and the plasma membrane are described, specifically findings involving Al-induced alterations in the structure and function of the plasma membrane.Key Words: acid soil, aluminum, plasma membrane, tolerance, toxicity     

Nitric oxide exacerbates Al-induced inhibition of root elongation in rice bean by affecting cell wall and plasma membrane properties

Aluminum (Al) toxicity is one of the most widespread problems for crop production on acid soils, and nitric oxide (NO) is a key signaling molecule involved in the mediation of various biotic and abiotic stresses in plants. Here we found that exogenous application of the NO donor sodium nitroprusside (SNP) exacerbated the inhibition of Al-induced root growth in rice bean [Vigna umbellata (Thunb.) Ohwi & Ohashi ‘Jiangnan’, Fabaceae]. This was accompanied by an increased accumulation of Al in the root apex. However, Al treatments had no effect on endogenous NO concentrations in root apices. These results indicate that a change in NO concentration is not the cause of Al-induced root growth inhibition and the adverse effect of SNP on Al-induced root growth inhibition should result from increased Al accumulation. Al could significantly induce citrate efflux but SNP had no effects on citrate efflux either in the absence or presence of Al. On the other hand, SNP pretreatment significantly increased Al-induced malondialdehyde accumulation and Evans Blue staining, indicating an intensification of the disruption of plasma membrane integrity. Furthermore, SNP pretreatment also caused greater induction of pectin methylesterase activity by Al, which could be the cause of the increased Al accumulation. Taken together, it is concluded that NO exacerbates Al-induced root growth inhibition by affecting cell wall and plasma membrane properties.     

Magnesium enhances aluminum-induced citrate secretion in rice bean roots (Vigna umbellata) by restoring plasma membrane H+-ATPase activity

We demonstrated that magnesium (Mg) can alleviate aluminum (Al) toxicity in rice bean [Vigna umbellata (Thunb.) Ohwi & Ohashi] more effectively than is expected from a non-specific cation response. Micromolar concentrations of Mg alleviated the inhibition of root growth by Al but not by lanthanum, and neither strontium nor barium at the micromolar level alleviates Al toxicity. Aluminum also induced citrate efflux from rice bean roots, and this response was stimulated by inclusion of 10 microM Mg in the treatment solution. The increase in the Al-induced citrate efflux by Mg paralleled the improvement in root growth, suggesting that the ameliorative effect of Mg might be related to greater citrate efflux. Vanadate (an effective H+-ATPase inhibitor) decreased the Al-induced citrate efflux, while addition of Mg partly restored the efflux. Mg addition also increased the activity of Al-reduced plasma membrane H+-ATPase, as well as helping to maintain the Mg and calcium contents in root apices. We propose that the addition of Mg to the toxic Al treatment helps maintain the tissue Mg content and the activity of the plasma membrane H+-ATPase. These changes enhanced the Al-dependent efflux of citrate which provided extra protection from Al stress.     

Molecular mapping of genes conferring aluminum tolerance in rice (Oryza sativa L.)

Crop productivity on acid soil is restricted by multiple abiotic stress factors. Aluminum (Al) tolerance seems to be a key to productivity on soil with a pH below 5.0, but other factors such as Mn toxicity and the deficiency of P, Ca and Mg also play a role. The development of Al-tolerant genotypes of rice is an urgent necessity for improving crop productivity in developing countries. Inhibition of root growth is a primary and early symptom of Al toxicity. The present study was conducted to identify genetic factors controlling the aluminum tolerance of rice. Several parameters related to Al tolerance, most importantly the relative root growth under Al stress versus non-stress conditions, were scored in 188 F₃ selfed families from a cross between an Al-tolerant Vietnamese local variety, Chiembau, and an Al-susceptible improved variety, Omon269–65. The two varieties are both Oryza sativa ssp. indica, but showed a relatively high level of DNA polymorphism, permitting the assembly of an RFLP map consisting of 164 loci spanning 1,715.8 cM, and covering most of the rice genome. A total of nine different genomic regions on eight chromosomes have been implicated in the genetic control of root and shoot growth under aluminum stress. By far the greatest effects on aluminum tolerance were associated with the region near WG110 on chromosome 1. This region does not seem to correspond to most of the genes that have been mapped for aluminum tolerance in other species, nor do they correspond closely to one another. Most results, both from physiological studies and from molecular mapping studies, tend to suggest that aluminum tolerance is a complex multi-genic trait. The identification of DNA markers (such as WG110) that are diagnostic for aluminum tolerance in particular gene pools provides an important starting point for transferring and pyramiding genes that may contribute to the sustainable improvement of crop productivity in aluminum-rich soils. The isolation of genes responsible for aluminum tolerance is likely to be necessary to gain a comprehensive understanding of this complex trait. Received: 29 March 2000 / Accepted: 16 August 2000     

Aluminum stress signaling in plants

Aluminum (Al) toxicity is a major constraint for crop production in acidic soil worldwide. When the soil pH is lower than 5, Al³⁺ is released to the soil and enters into root tip cell ceases root development of plant. In acid soil with high mineral content, Al is the major cause of phytotoxicity. The target of Al toxicity is the root tip, in which Al exposure causes inhibition of cell elongation and cell division, leading to root stunting accompanied by reduced water and nutrient uptake. A variety of genes have been identified that are induced or repressed upon Al exposure. At tissue level, the distal part of the transition zone is the most sensitive to Al. At cellular and molecular level, many cell components are implicated in the Al toxicity including DNA in nucleus, numerous cytoplastic compounds, mitochondria, the plasma membrane and the cell wall. Although it is difficult to distinguish the primary targets from the secondary effects so far, understanding of the target sites of the Al toxicity is helpful for elucidating the mechanisms by which Al exerts its deleterious effects on root growth. To develop high tolerance against Al stress is the major goal of plant sciences. This review examines our current understanding of the Al signaling with the physiological, genetic and molecular approaches to improve the crop performance under the Al toxicity. New discoveries will open up new avenues of molecular/physiological inquiry that should greatly advance our understanding of Al tolerance mechanisms. Additionally, these breakthroughs will provide new molecular resources for improving the crop Al tolerance via molecular-assisted breeding and biotechnology.Key words: aluminum, toxicity, tolerance, signal transduction, plants     

Aluminum ions alter the function of non-specific phospholipase C through the changes in plasma membrane physical properties

The first indication of the aluminum (Al) toxicity in plants growing in acidic soils is the cessation of root growth, but the detailed mechanism of Al effect is unknown. Here we examined the impact of Al stress on the activity of non-specific phospholipase C (NPC) in the connection with the processes related to the plasma membrane using fluorescently labeled phosphatidylcholine. We observed a rapid and significant decrease of labeled diacylglycerol (DAG), product of NPC activity, in Arabidopsis seedlings treated with AlCl₃. Interestingly, an application of the membrane fluidizer, benzyl alcohol, restored the level of DAG during Al treatment. Our observations suggest that the activity of NPC is affected by Al-induced changes in plasma membrane physical properties.     

Cell membrane integrity,callose accumulation,and root growth in aluminum-stressed sorghum seedlings

Aluminum stress usually reduces plant root growth due to the accumulation of Al in specific zones of the root apex. The objectives of this study were to determine the localization of Al in the root apex of Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moech. and its effects on membrane integrity, callose accumulation, and root growth in selected cultivars. Seedlings were grown in a nutrient solution containing 0, 27, or 39 μM Al³⁺ for 24, 48, and 120 h. The Al stress significantly reduced root growth, especially after 48 and 120 h of exposure. A higher Al accumulation, determined by fluorescence microscopy after staining with a Morin dye, occurred in the root extension zone of the sensitive cultivar than in the tolerant cultivar. The membrane damage and callose accumulation were also higher in the sensitive than resistant cultivar. It was concluded that the Al stress significantly reduced root growth through the accumulation of Al in the root extension zone, callose accumulation, and impairment of plasma membrane integrity.     

铝对荞麦根系的影响

以荞麦为试材,用五种剂量的铝进行土培,发现低浓度(0.435+0.6gAl3+/kg土)的铝能增加荞麦的总根长、根尖数和根系活力,减小根平均直径,降低根质膜透性,对荞麦生长有一定的促进作用;高浓度的铝(0.435+1.2gAl3+/kg土)会使荞麦的根变短、变粗、侧根减少,根系活力下降,根质膜透性升高,明显不利于荞麦的生长发育。     

Interaction between iron plaque and root border cells ameliorates aluminum toxicity of Oryza sativa differing in aluminum tolerance

Root border cells (RBCs), which are generated during plant growth and surround the root cap, and iron plaque (IP), ubiquitously formed on the root surfaces of rice, are known to alleviate aluminum (Al) toxicity. To verify the interactive effects of IP and RBCs on ameliorating Al toxicity, two rice cultivars differing in Al resistance were used to compare Al tolerance between cultivars. Additionally, root elongation, Al uptake and RBCs viability were measured as indicators of the effects of Al. The amounts of DCB-extractable Fe and Al on the root surfaces were much higher in the presence of IP than the absence. IP presence significantly decreased Al-induced inhibition of root elongation and Al contents in roots and root tips. The removal of RBCs from the root tips caused a more severe inhibition of root elongation and a higher Al accumulation in rice roots and root tips. Furthermore, root growth inhibition and Al contents in roots and root tips were significantly lower in roots with a combination of IP and RBCs than in roots with IP or RBCs only. The formation of IP on the root surface maintained higher RBCs viability and depressed mucilage exudation in an Al-tolerant rice cultivar. The results suggest that both IP and RBCs ameliorate Al toxicity, and IP has a greater capacity for Al resistance. The combination of IP and RBCs exhibited a synergistic effect associated with Al resistance.     

铝胁迫对橡胶苗生理和叶绿素荧光特性的影响

热带酸性土壤中铝毒非常普遍,其对橡胶树生长的影响尚不清楚.采用盆栽砂培试验研究了铝离子对橡胶苗生理和叶绿素荧光特性的影响.结果表明:当铝浓度高于200 mmol·L^-1时,橡胶苗细胞质膜透性、叶片游离脯氨酸和可溶性糖含量显著提高,相对含水量、过氧化氢酶和过氧化物酶活性、叶片叶绿素a含量、叶绿素最大荧光、PSⅡ最大光化学效率、PSⅡ潜在活性、光化学淬灭系数、非光化学淬灭系数和光合电子传递速率显著降低;当铝离子浓度低于100 mmol·L^-1时,不同处理间橡胶苗生理和叶绿素荧光特性差异较小或不明显.说明橡胶树是较为耐铝的植物,铝离子对橡胶苗造成伤害的阈值在100～200 mmol·L^-1;超过这一浓度,会造成橡胶苗不可逆的伤害.     

Cu2O纳米颗粒对小麦根系形态及遗传毒性的影响

为了阐明Cu₂O纳米颗粒(NPs)暴露对植物根系的毒性效应,本研究以小麦品种‘周麦18’为材料,采用水培试验方法,研究了10、50、100和200 mg·L^-1浓度的Cu₂O-NPs对小麦幼苗生长、根系活性、形态结构及细胞遗传学毒性的影响。结果表明: 不同浓度的Cu₂O-NPs降低了小麦幼苗的根芽长度、鲜重、根活性和根冠比,增加了初生根的数量;随着Cu₂O-NPs浓度的升高,幼苗根伸长区缩短、根系变硬变脆、根径增加、根冠变大;100 mg·L^-1浓度的Cu₂O-NPs处理下,小麦根尖有丝分裂指数显著降低,根尖细胞形状不规则化、质壁分离、细胞出现空泡化、细胞核核膜模糊、核内染色体异常。在水培条件下,Cu₂O-NPs对小麦幼苗具有一定的遗传学毒性效应,从而影响小麦幼苗的生长发育和根系形态结构。     

Effects of low pH and aluminum stresses on common beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) differing in low-phosphorus and photoperiod responses

Using common beans differing greatly in the response to photoperiod and low-phosphorus (P) stress, we investigated their responses to acidity and aluminum (Al)toxicity and the relationship between Al tolerance and organic acid exudation under Al or low P stress. A genotype Ginshi was found to be sensitive to low pH treatment. When exposed to pH 4.5, serious curvature in the root tips of cv. Ginshi was observed; however, it was completely corrected by the application of 5 or 10 μmol/L AlCl3; increasing calcium (Ca) could ameliorate Al toxicity, but it could not correct root curvature at pH 4.5. Common beans showed significant differences in both root growth and Al tolerance, and the varieties from the Andes were more tolerant to Al toxicity than those from the Mesoamerican origin. In the presence of 50 μmol/L AlCl3,all the common bean genotypes exuded citrate, and a significant difference in the amounts of citrate was observed among genotypes. The genotypes originated in the Mesoamerica tended to release more citrate than other origins in the presence of Al. The P-inefficient genotype DOR364 exuded more citrate than the P-efficient genotype G19833 in the presence of 50 μmol/L AlCl3, whereas no organic acids were detected in root exudates under low-P stress. A reduction of citrate exudation in the DOR364, but a slight increase of citrate exudation in the G19833, was observed under Al stress after they were exposed to 6-d P starvation. These results suggest that different low-P or Al tolerance in common beans might not be associated with organic acid exudation.     

Effect of aluminium on lipid peroxidation, superoxide dismutase, catalase, and peroxidase activities in root tips of soybean (Glycine max)

Inhibition of root elongation and modification of membrane properties are sensitive responses of plants to aluminium. The present paper reports on the effect of AI on lipid peroxidation and activities of enzymes related to production of activated oxygen species. Soybean seedlings (Glycine max L. cv. Sito) were precultured in solution culture for 3–5 days and then treated for 1–72 h with Al (AICI₃) concentrations ranging from 10 to 75 μM at a constant pH of 4.1. In response to Al supply, lipid peroxidation in the root tips (< 2 cm) was enhanced only after longer durations of treatment. Aluminium-dependent increase in lipid peroxidation was intensified by Fe²⁺ (FeSO₄). A close relationship existed between lipid peroxidation and inhibition of root-elongation rate induced by Al and/or Fe toxicity and/or Ca deficiency. Besides enhancement of lipid peroxidation in the crude extracts of root tips due to Al, the activities of superoxide dismutase (EC 1.15.1.1) and peroxidase (EC 1.11.1.7) increased, whereas catalase (EC 1.11.1.6) activity decreased. This indicates a greater generation of oxygen free radicals and related tissue damage. The results suggest that lipid peroxidation is part of the overall expression of Al toxicity in roots and that enhanced lipid peroxidation by oxygen free radicals is a consequence of primary effects of Al on membrane structure.     

Magnesium is more efficient than calcium in alleviating aluminum rhizotoxicity in soybean and its ameliorative effect is not explained by the Gouy-Chapman-Stern model

The mechanistic basis for cation amelioration of Al rhizotoxicity in soybean was investigated through a series of studies comparing protective effects of Ca and Mg against Al inhibition of root elongation in a background 0.8 mM CaSO4 solution (pH 4.3). A modified Gouy-Chapman-Stern model was used to evaluate the effect of cations on electrical potential and Al3+ activity at root plasma membrane surfaces. Activities of Al3+ up to 4.6 microM in the background solution inhibited soybean tap root elongation by more than 80%. There was little or no response in root elongation when Ca and Mg were added to background solutions in the absence of AL: When added to Al-toxic solutions in the micromolar concentration range, Mg was 100-fold more effective than Ca in alleviating Al toxicity, whereas both cations were equally effective when added in the millimolar concentration range. The protective effect of micromolar additions of Mg on root elongation was specific for Al and it failed to alleviate La rhizotoxicity. In contrast to wheat, Mg amelioration of Al toxicity to soybean root elongation at low Mg concentration could not be explained by changes in potential and Al3+ activity at the root plasma membrane surfaces as predicted by a Gouy-Chapman-Stern model. These results suggest that Mg is not acting as an indifferent cation when present at low concentration and implies the involvement of a mechanism other than pure electrostatic effects at the root surface.     

Effect of aluminium on plant growth and metabolism

Aluminium toxicity is one of the major factors that limit plant growth and development in many acid soils. Root cells plasma membrane, particularly of the root apex, seems to be a major target of Al toxicity. However, strong interaction of Al3+, the main Al toxic form, with oxygen donor ligands (proteins, nucleic acids, polysaccharides) results in the inhibition of cell division, cell extension, and transport. Although the identification of Al tolerance genes is under way, the mechanism of their expression remains obscure.     

Cu2+对拟南芥根的局部毒性及诱导DNA损伤和细胞死亡

该文探讨了不同浓度的Cu²⁺胁迫对拟南芥(Arabidopsis thaliana)根生长、活性氧(ROS)积累、抗氧化酶活性、质膜完整性和细胞活性的影响, 通过分根实验初步分析了Cu²⁺毒性效应的影响范围。结果表明, Cu²⁺胁迫可显著抑制拟南芥主根伸长, 诱导ROS积累及DNA损伤, 促发抗氧化酶活性升高, 破坏质膜完整性, 且Cu²⁺浓度越高, 毒性效应越明显, 在高浓度Cu²⁺胁迫下细胞活性显著降低。分析各参数之间的关系, 表明ROS的积累与超氧化物歧化酶(SOD)、过氧化氢酶(CAT)、过氧化物酶(POD)及抗坏血酸过氧化物酶(APX)的活性呈显著正相关; ROS积累与DNA损伤、质膜完整性、细胞活性之间具有显著的近线性关系。分根实验结果表明, 只有在添加重金属Cu²⁺(75 μmol·L^–1)一侧培养基中的根生长受抑制, 并出现ROS积累、细胞死亡, 暗示Cu²⁺对拟南芥根系的局部毒性效应可能是由于ROS的局部性积累导致受胁迫根系一侧的细胞死亡所引起的。     

Aluminum-induced alterations in lipid composition of microsomal membranes from an aluminum-resistant and an aluminum-sensitive cultivar of Triticum aestivum

We have studied the effect of aluminum (Al) on the lipid composition of microsomal membranes isolated from 5-mm root tips of an Al-resistant (T 741) and an Al-sensitive (Katepwa) cultivar of Triticum aestivum L. Exposure of both genotypes to 10 and 50 μ M AeCl₃ for 1 day had no effect on lipid composition; however, decreases in phospholipids and increases in monogalactosyl diacylglycerols, free sterols, free fatty acids and triacylglycerols were observed with prolonged exposure (3 days) to 5O μ M AlCe₃. Several genotype-specific changes were also observed under these conditions. The content of digalactosyl diacylglycerols increased by 66.7% in Katepwa. but decreased slightly in PT 741. Thus, the ratio of rnonogalactosyl diacylglycerols to digalactosyl diacylglycerols increased by 46.2% in PT 741, but decreased by 21.3% in Katepwa. Genotype-specific differences were also observed in steryl lipids. Treatment with Al induced a 70.2% increase in sterylglucosides and a 23.3% increase in acylated sterylglucosides in Katepwa. In contrast, a 18.9% decrease in acylated sterylglucosides and no changes in sterylglucosides were observed in PT 741. Our limited understanding of the effect of membrane composition on membrane structure and function makes it difficult to predict how these changes relate to Al toxicity and resistance. While it is possible that many changes reflect the toxic effects of Al, we believe that changes observed only in the Al-resistant genotype could contribute to continuous growth in the face of Al stress.     

Effects of low pH and aluminum stresses on common beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) differing in low-phosphorus and photoperiod responses

Using common beans differing greatly in the response to photoperiod and low-phosphorus (P) stress, we investigated their responses to acidity and aluminum (Al) toxicity and the relationship between Al tolerance and organic acid exudation under Al or low P stress. A genotype Ginshi was found to be sensitive to low pH treatment. When exposed to pH 4.5, serious curvature in the root tips of cv. Ginshi was observed; however, it was completely corrected by the application of 5 or 10 μmol/L AlCl₃; increasing calcium (Ca) could ameliorate Al toxicity, but it could not correct root curvature at pH 4.5. Common beans showed significant differences in both root growth and Al tolerance, and the varieties from the Andes were more tolerant to Al toxicity than those from the Mesoamerican origin. In the presence of 50 μmol/L AlCl₃, all the common bean genotypes exuded citrate, and a significant difference in the amounts of citrate was observed among genotypes. The genotypes originated in the Mesoamerica tended to release more citrate than other origins in the presence of Al. The P-inefficient genotype DOR364 exuded more citrate than the P-efficient genotype G19833 in the presence of 50 μmol/L AlCl₃, whereas no organic acids were detected in root exudates under low-P stress. A reduction of citrate exudation in the DOR364, but a slight increase of citrate exudation in the G19833, was observed under Al stress after they were exposed to 6-d P starvation. These results suggest that different low-P or Al tolerance in common beans might not be associated with organic acid exudation.     

Aluminum enhancement of plant growth in acid rooting media. A case of reciprocal alleviation of toxicity by two toxic cations

The generally rhizotoxic ion Al³⁺ often enhances root growth at low concentrations. The hypothesis that Al³⁺ enhances growth by relieving H⁺ toxicity was tested with wheat seedlings ( Triticum aestivum L.). Growth enhancement by Al³⁺ only occurred under acidic conditions that reduced root elongation. Al³⁺ increased cell membrane electrical polarity and stimulated H⁺ extrusion. Previous investigations have shown that Al³⁺ decreases solute leakage at low _pH and that the alleviation of H⁺ toxicity by cations appears to be a general phenomenon with effectiveness dependent upon charge (C³⁺>C²⁺>C^l+). Alleviation of one cation toxicity by another toxic cation appears to be reciprocal so that Al³⁺ toxicity is relieved by H⁺. It has been argued previously that this latter phenomenon accounts for the apparent toxicity of ALOH²⁺ and Al(OH)⁺₂. Reduction of cell-surface electrical potential by the ameliorative cation may reduce the cell-surface activity of the toxic cation.