Characteristics of the end-joining of DNA double-strand breaks by the ataxia-telangiectasia nuclear extract

A double-strand break was introduced in plasmid pZErO-2 at a specific site within the ccdB gene that is lethal to Escherichia coli cells and treated with nuclear extracts from human cells. The efficiency of rejoining was monitored by Southern blot analysis and the fidelity of rejoining was measured by expressing the ccdB gene after bacterial transformation. The efficiency of rejoining in the nuclear extract from an ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T) cell line was comparable to that from a control cell line. However, the accuracy of rejoining was much lower for the A-T cell extract than for the control cell extract. All mutations were deletions, most of which contained short direct repeats at the breakpoint junctions. The deletion spectrum caused by the A-T nuclear extract was distinct from that of the control extract. These results indicate that the ccdB gene is useful for analysis of mis-rejoining and that A-T cells have certain deficiencies in end-joining of double-strand breaks in DNA.     

AT细胞DNA双链断裂重接修复效率及其忠实性

用脉冲电场凝胶电泳和双标记基因质粒ＤＮＡ转染技术研究辐射敏感的毛细血管扩张性共济失调症患者皮肤成纤维细胞（ＡＴ５ＢＩＶＡ）和正常辐射抗性的人宫颈癌细胞（ＨｅＬａＳ３）ＤＮＡ双链断裂重接修复率及其忠实性。结果表明γ射线照射诱发ＤＮＡ双链断裂的产额和重接修复率,在两株细胞间无差别．而ＡＴ细胞对导入的限制性内切酶ＥｃｏＲＶ产生双链断裂质粒ＤＮＡ的重接修复忠实性显著低于ＨｅｌａＳ３ｔｅ胞,表明ＡＴ细胞易发生ＤＮＡ错误修复,这很可能就是ＡＴ细胞高度辐射敏感性的主要原因。     

ATM mediates repression of DNA end-degradation in an ATP-dependent manner

Ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM) is a PI3-kinase-like kinase (PIKK) associated with DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair and cell cycle control. We have previously reported comparable efficiencies of DSB repair in nuclear extracts from both ATM deficient (A-T) and control (ATM+) cells; however, the repair products from the A-T nuclear extracts contained deletions encompassing longer stretches of DNA compared to controls. These deletions appeared to result from end-joining at sites of microhomology. These data suggest that ATM hinders error-prone repair pathways that depend on degradation of DNA ends at a break. Such degradation may account for the longer deletions we formerly observed in A-T cell extracts. To address this possibility we assessed the degradation of DNA duplex substrates in A-T and control nuclear extracts under DSB repair conditions. We observed a marked shift in signal intensity from full-length products to shorter products in A-T nuclear extracts, and addition of purified ATM to A-T nuclear extracts restored full-length product detection. This repression of degradation by ATM was both ATP-dependent and inhibited by the PIKK inhibitors wortmannin and caffeine. Addition of pre-phosphorylated ATM to an A-T nuclear extract in the presence of PIKK inhibitors was insufficient in repressing degradation, indicating that kinase activities are required. These results demonstrate a role for ATM in preventing the degradation of DNA ends possibly through repressing nucleases implicated in microhomology-mediated end-joining.     

The use of integrating DNA vectors to analyse the molecular defects in ionising radiation-sensitive mutants of mammalian cells including ataxia telangiectasia

Integrating DNA vectors, encoding selectable recombinant genes, were used to assess rejoining and recombination in wild-type mammalian cells and their ionising radiation-sensitive mutants. To provide a simple model of an important radiation-induced lesion - the DNA double-strand break - the vectors were cut with restriction endonucleases at specific single sites. If these breaks were made in the coding sequence of a selectable gene, the fidelity of the rejoin/recombination process could be measured by survival of vector-transformed cells in selective medium. Rejoining was assessed using vectors without internal homologies, while recombination was measured using pairs of fragments or deletion vectors carrying homologous regions. Initial experiments were made with vectors carrying a single selectable gene but, to overcome potential artefacts, 2-gene vectors were then constructed where one gene acts as a linked marker and (unbroken) control for the other (broken) gene. Available data are reviewed to show that, compared to their respective wild-type counterparts: (1) an ataxia telangiectasia (A-T) cell line and the hamster irs1 mutant show a consistent reduction in the fidelity of rejoining double-strand breaks (while the hamster mutants irs2, irs3, xrs series, and EM9 show wild-type fidelity); (2) the hamster EM9 mutant shows a reduction in ability to recombine homologous vector fragments (while the A-T line and probably the xrs mutants show show wild-type abilities); and (3) the xrs mutants show a reduction in overall transformation frequency with vector DNA, whether broken or not, while the other mutants tested show approximately wild-type frequencies. A critical account of the techniques and data is given, together with speculations on the molecular nature of the processes which are defective in these mutants, leading to radiosensitivity.     

DNA-break repair, radioresistance of DNA synthesis, and camptothecin sensitivity in the radiation-sensitive irs mutants: comparisons to ataxia-telangiectasia cells

Induction and rejoining of DNA single-strand breaks (ssb) and double-strand breaks (dsb) after gamma-irradiation were measured, respectively, by alkaline and neutral sucrose gradient sedimentation methods. The radiosensitive mutants irs1, irs2, and irs3 showed no significant difference from wild-type V79 hamster cells in ability to rejoin either ssb or dsb, while the previously-described xrs-1 mutant showed the expected defect in rejoining dsb. The resistance of DNA synthesis to gamma-irradiation was measured in the 3 irs mutants and, for comparative purposes, in transformed human cell lines from normal and ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T) individuals. The irs2 mutant was found to be very similar in response to the A-T lines, showing a marked decrease in inhibition of DNA synthesis, compared to V79 cells, in both time-course and dose-response experiments. However, irs1 also had some decrease in inhibition at the higher doses used, while irs3 was similar to the wild-type V79 cells. Both irs1 and irs2 were found to be considerably more sensitive to the DNA topoisomerase I-inhibitor camptothecin, while irs3 was only slightly more sensitive than the parent V79 line. These data place the irs mutants in a similar category of radiosensitive phenotype to A-T cells, but we view this as only the beginning of a useful classification of this type of mutant. The irs2 mutant has the strongest links to A-T cells, through its sensitivity profile to DNA-damaging agents and radioresistant DNA synthesis, but irs1 in particular has other similarities to A-T.     

Multiple components are involved in the efficient joining of double stranded DNA breaks in human cell extracts.

We describe a rapid and efficient in vitro system for the rejoining of double stranded breaks in DNA based on extracts of human 293 cells. Using this system as an assay, we have separated the nuclear extract into several components involved in break rejoining. The unfractionated system can convert approx. 100% of the input DNA, linearized with a restriction enzyme, to high molecular weight material at low temperature (17 degrees C), and at the physiological temperature of 37 degrees C we have shown that competing activities in the extract can also act on the DNA template. We present the fractionation of the extract and the partial purification of a novel factor which will stimulate a crude rejoin activity and in addition increases the activity of purified DNA ligase I. We have also partially purified the break joining activity and show that the chromatographic properties do not directly correspond with the three DNA ligases previously described, indicating that the activity observed may not be due to a single enzyme species. By studying the rejoining of double stranded DNA breaks as a biochemical process, we have demonstrated that the efficient joining of such breaks requires factors in addition to DNA ligases.     

Repair of HZE-particle-induced DNA double-strand breaks in normal human fibroblasts

DNA damage generated by high-energy and high-Z (HZE) particles is more skewed toward multiply damaged sites or clustered DNA damage than damage induced by low-linear energy transfer (LET) X and gamma rays. Clustered DNA damage includes abasic sites, base damages and single- (SSBs) and double-strand breaks (DSBs). This complex DNA damage is difficult to repair and may require coordinated recruitment of multiple DNA repair factors. As a consequence of the production of irreparable clustered lesions, a greater biological effectiveness is observed for HZE-particle radiation than for low-LET radiation. To understand how the inability of cells to rejoin DSBs contributes to the greater biological effectiveness of HZE particles, the kinetics of DSB rejoining and cell survival after exposure of normal human skin fibroblasts to a spectrum of HZE particles was examined. Using gamma-H2AX as a surrogate marker for DSB formation and rejoining, the ability of cells to rejoin DSBs was found to decrease with increasing Z; specifically, iron-ion-induced DSBs were repaired at a rate similar to those induced by silicon ions, oxygen ions and gamma radiation, but a larger fraction of iron-ion-induced damage was irreparable. Furthermore, both DNA-PKcs (DSB repair factor) and 53BP1 (DSB sensing protein) co-localized with gamma-H2AX along the track of dense ionization produced by iron and silicon ions and their focus dissolution kinetics was similar to that of gamma-H2AX. Spatial co-localization analysis showed that unlike gamma-H2AX and 53BP1, phosphorylated DNA-PKcs was localized only at very specific regions, presumably representing the sites of DSBs within the tracks. Examination of cell survival by clonogenic assay indicated that cell killing was greater for iron ions than for silicon and oxygen ions and gamma rays. Collectively, these data demonstrate that the inability of cells to rejoin DSBs within clustered DNA lesions likely contributes to the greater biological effectiveness of HZE particles.     

8-OxoG retards the activity of the ligase III/XRCC1 complex during the repair of a single-strand break, when present within a clustered DNA damage site

Ionising radiation produces clustered DNA damage. Recent studies have established that the efficiency of excision of a lesion within clustered damage sites is reduced. This study presents evidence that the repair of clustered DNA damage is compromised, relative to that of the isolated lesions, since the lifetime of both lesions is extended by up to eight fold. Simple clustered damage sites, comprised of a single-strand break, one or five bases 3' or 5' to 8-oxoG on the opposite strand, were synthesised in oligonucleotides and repair carried out in XRS5 nuclear extracts. The rate of repair of the single-strand break within these clustered damage sites is reduced, mainly due to inhibition of the DNA ligase III/XRCC1 complex. The single-strand break, present as an isolated lesion, is repaired by short-patch base excision repair, however the mechanism of repair of the single-strand break within the clustered damage site is asymmetric. When the lesions are 5' to each other, the single-strand break is rejoined by short-patch repair whereas the rejoining of the single-strand break occurs by long-patch type repair when the lesions are 3' to one another. The retardation of DNA ligase III/XRCC1 complex, following addition of one base, is responsible for the initiation of long-patch base excision repair when the lesions are 3' to each other. The lesions within the cluster are processed sequentially, the single-strand break being repaired before excision of 8-oxoG, limiting the formation of double-strand breaks to <2%. Stalled processing of clustered DNA damage is suggested to have implications for mutation induction by radiation.     

Topoisomerase II activity in a DNA double-strand break repair deficient Chinese hamster ovary cell line

Topoisomerase II activity was measured in wild-type, Chinese hamster ovary K1 cells, and in the DNA double-strand break repair deficient xrs-6 cell line. Total topoisomerase II activity in a high salt, nuclear extract was found to be the same in both cell lines, as measured by decatenation of kinetoplast DNA networks and catenation of plasmid pBR322 DNA. While at low drug concentrations m-AMSA-induced enzyme cutting of nuclear DNA was 25% less in xrs-6 cells, the frequency of DNA breaks at high concentrations of the drug, and thus the frequency of the topoisomerase II enzyme, was the same in both cell lines. Despite the presence of equivalent enzyme levels in both cell lines, the xrs-6 cell line was 3 times more sensitive to drug-induced cytotoxicity. These results may be due to the fact that, as with X-radiation-induced DNA damage, xrs-6 cells are deficient in the capacity to rejoin topoisomerase II-induced DNA double-strand breaks.     

Impact of DNA ligase IV on the fidelity of end joining in human cells

A DNA ligase IV (LIG4)-null human pre-B cell line and human cell lines with hypomorphic mutations in LIG4 are significantly impaired in the frequency and fidelity of end joining using an in vivo plasmid assay. Analysis of the null line demonstrates the existence of an error-prone DNA ligase IV-independent rejoining mechanism in mammalian cells. Analysis of lines with hypomorphic mutations demonstrates that residual DNA ligase IV activity, which is sufficient to promote efficient end joining, nevertheless can result in decreased fidelity of rejoining. Thus, DNA ligase IV is an important factor influencing the fidelity of end joining in vivo. The LIG4-defective cell lines also showed impaired end joining in an in vitro assay using cell-free extracts. Elevated degradation of the terminal nucleotide was observed in a LIG4-defective line, and addition of the DNA ligase IV–XRCC4 complex restored end protection. End protection by DNA ligase IV was not dependent upon ligation. Finally, using purified proteins, we demonstrate that DNA ligase IV–XRCC4 is able to protect DNA ends from degradation by T7 exonuclease. Thus, the ability of DNA ligase IV–XRCC4 to protect DNA ends may contribute to the ability of DNA ligase IV to promote accurate rejoining in vivo.     

Abnormality in DNA-protein binding in ataxia-telangiectasia nuclear extracts

Anomalies in DNA replication, repair and recombination in ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T) point to a defect in structure or function of chromatin. In this study we have compared DNA-protein binding in nuclear extracts from control and A-T cells using two assay systems, filter-binding and DNA-accessibility. Interestingly, the extent of DNA protein binding over a range of protein concentration was significantly lower in A-T extracts. In addition the accessibility of the restriction enzyme Eco R1 to protein-bound plasmid was greater when A-T extracts were used. This is in keeping with the reduced binding observed in the filter-binding assay.     

Conversion of phosphoglycolate to phosphate termini on 3' overhangs of DNA double strand breaks by the human tyrosyl-DNA phosphodiesterase hTdp1

Mammalian cells contain potent activity for removal of 3'-phosphoglycolates from single-stranded oligomers and from 3' overhangs of DNA double strand breaks, but no specific enzyme has been implicated in such removal. Fractionated human whole-cell extracts contained an activity, which in the presence of EDTA, catalyzed removal of glycolate from phosphoglycolate at a single-stranded 3' terminus to leave a 3'-phosphate, reminiscent of the human tyrosyl-DNA phosphodiesterase hTdp1. Recombinant hTdp1, as well as Saccharomyces cerevisiae Tdp1, catalyzed similar removal of glycolate, although less efficiently than removal of tyrosine. Moreover, glycolate-removing activity could be immunodepleted from the fractionated extracts by antiserum to hTdp1. When a plasmid containing a double strand break with a 3'-phosphoglycolate on a 3-base 3' overhang was incubated in human cell extracts, phosphoglycolate processing proceeded rapidly for the first few minutes but then slowed dramatically, suggesting that the single-stranded overhangs gradually became sequestered and inaccessible to hTdp1. The results suggest a role for hTdp1 in repair of free radical-mediated DNA double strand breaks bearing terminally blocked 3' overhangs.     

Vector-mediated DNA double-strand break repair analysis in normal, and radiation-sensitive, Chinese hamster V79 cells

DNA double-strand break repair was assessed in 2 new radiation-sensitive V79 hamster cell lines (irs1 and irs2) by their ability to rejoin restriction endonuclease cuts in a transferred selectable SV40--E. coli gpt recombinant gene. The studied gene was carried in the vector pPMH16 which also contained a second selectable HSVtk-neo recombinant gene which acted as a control for DNA transformation. The parental V79 cells showed correct rejoining of KpnI and EcoRV double-strand breaks in approximately 18% and 36% of transformants respectively (correcting for the expression of undamaged gpt in neo+ transformants). irs1 shows a significantly reduced (approximately 3-fold) ability to rejoin correctly such double-strand scissions. However, irs2 rejoined such lesions as correctly as the V79 cells. The data are discussed in the context of the assay and the possible repair deficiencies of these radiosensitive mutant cells.     

Studies of c-myb gene regulation in MRL-lpr/lpr mice. Identification of a 5' c-myb nuclear protein binding site and high levels of binding factors in nuclear extracts of lpr/lpr lymph node cells

Lymph node T cells of MRL-lpr/lpr mice are characterized by the production of very large amounts of c-myb mRNA. To study the control of c-myb expression, a search was made for sites on the 5' c-myb gene which could bind regulatory proteins. DNase I digestion of nuclear chromatin uncovered four DNase I hypersensitive sites in the first intron of the c-myb gene, and a single site approximately 300 bp 5' to the initiation codon. Lambda exonuclease digestion of a 5'-myb fragment in the presence of nuclear extracts from either MRL-lpr/lpr PLN or EL-4 thymoma revealed stop sites approximately 300 bp 5' (-271 to -322) to the ATG initiation codon. DNase I footprint analysis demonstrated a guanine-cytosine enriched region of potential binding sites (-274 to -319) in the region of the stop sites and a fifth potential binding site closer to the initiation codon (-163 to -168). Specific gel shift bands were detected by a 5'-myb fragment (-346 to -155) with extracts from a number of different lymphoid cell lines and the appropriate specific and non-specific competitor DNA. The DNA giving rise to these gel shift bands encompassed the region defined by the stop site and footprinting studies. To determine whether or not the protein binding to the 5' c-myb gene at -274 to -319 was associated with increased c-myb mRNA, we studied nuclear extracts of several cell lines and compared the amount of binding to the amount of c-myb mRNA found on Northern analyses. Among the cell lines, there was a correlation between c-myb expression and the amount of the 5'-myb DNA binding protein. In addition, MRL-lpr/lpr lymph node cells had high c-myb expression and large amounts of the 5'-myb binding protein. This result suggests that the binding may play some role in the c-myb expression. Moreover, the most immature cell lines had the greatest amount of the binding factor, suggesting that its regulatory effect on c-myb expression might be important in early differentiation events.     

DNA double-strand break and chromosomal rejoining defects with misrejoining in Nijmegen breakage syndrome cells

NBS1-deficient cells exhibit pronounced radiosensitivity and defects in chromosome integrity after ionizing radiation (IR) exposure, yet show only a minor defect in DNA double-strand break (DSB) rejoining, leaving an as yet unresolved enigma as to the nature of the radiosensitivity of these cells. To further investigate the relationship between radiosensitivity, DSB repair, and chromosome stability, we have compared cytological and molecular assays of DSB misrejoining and repair in NBS1-defective, wild type, and NBS1-complemented cells after IR damage. Our findings suggest a subtle defect in overall DSB rejoining in NBS1-defective cells and uniquely also reveal reduced ability of NBS1-defective cells to rejoin correct ends of DSBs. In agreement with published results, one of two different NBS1-defective cell lines showed a slight defect in overall rejoining of DSBs compared to its complemented counterpart, whereas another NBS line did not show any difference from wild type cells. Significant defects in the correct rejoining of DSBs compared to their respective controls were observed for both NBS1-defective lines. The defect in DSB rejoining and the increased misrejoining detected at the molecular level were also reflected in higher levels of fragments and translocations, respectively, at the chromosomal level. This work provides both molecular and cytological evidence that NBS1-deficient cells have defects in DSB processing and reveals that these molecular events can be manifest cytologically.     

New mammalian cellular systems to study mutations introduced at the break site by non-homologous end-joining

The non-homologous end-joining (NHEJ) pathway is a mechanism to repair DNA double strand breaks, which can introduce mutations at repair sites. We constructed new cellular systems to specifically analyze sequence modifications occurring at the repair site. In particular, we looked for the presence of telomeric repeats at the repair junctions, since our previous work indicated that telomeric sequences could be inserted at break sites in germ-line cells during primate evolution. To induce specific DNA breaks, we used the I-SceI system of Saccharomyces cerevisiae or digestion with restriction enzymes. We isolated human and hamster cell lines containing the I-SceI target site integrated in a single chromosomal locus and we exposed the cells to a continuous expression of the I-SceI endonuclease gene. Additionally, we isolated human cell lines that expressed constitutively the I-SceI endonuclease and we introduced the target site on an episomal plasmid stably transfected into the cells. These strategies allowed us to recover repair junctions in which the I-SceI target site was modified at high frequency (100% in hamster cells and about 70% in human cells). Finally, we analyzed junctions produced on an episomal plasmid linearized by restriction enzymes. In all the systems studied, sequence analysis of individual repair junctions showed that deletions were the most frequent modifications, being present in more than 80% of the junctions. On the episomal plasmids, the average deletion length was greater than at intrachromosomal sites. Insertions of nucleotides or deletions associated with insertions were rare events. Junction organization suggested different mechanisms of formation. To check for the insertion of telomeric sequences, we screened plasmid libraries representing about 3.5 x 10(5) junctions with a telomeric repeat probe. No positive clones were detected, suggesting that the addition of telomeric sequences during double strand break repair in somatic cells in culture is either a very rare event or does not occur at all.     

X-ray sensitive mutants of Chinese hamster ovary cells defective in double-strand break rejoining

Six CHO mutants have previously been described as being sensitive to ionizing radiation and bleomycin treatment, with little or no cross sensitivity to UV-radiation (Jeggo and Kemp, 1983). Their ability to rejoin single- and double-strand breaks has been examined here. Using two techniques, gradient sedimentation and alkaline elution, no difference could be observed between wild-type and mutant strains in the initial number of single-strand breaks induced, the rate of rejoining, or the final level of single-strand breaks rejoined. Thus, a major inability to rejoin single-strand breaks is not the basis for sensitivity in these mutants. In contrast, all 6 mutants showed a decreased ability to rejoin the double-strand breaks induced by gamma-irradiation as measured by neutral elution. Rejoining of half of the breaks occurred in 37 min in wild-type cells and reached a maximum level of 72% after 2 h. All the mutants showed a decreased rate of rejoining, and the final level was 17% of that observed in the wild-type in the most defective mutant, and ranged from 35 to 69% in the other 5 mutants. These are the first mammalian cell mutants to be described with a defect in double-strand break rejoining.     

Interaction of a nuclear factor-1-like protein with the regulatory region of the human polyomavirus JC virus

We have initiated a study to identify host proteins which interact with the regulatory region of the human polyomavirus JC (JCV), which is associated with the demyelinating disease, progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy. We examined the interaction of nuclear proteins prepared from different cell lines with the JCV regulatory region by DNA binding gel retardation assays. Binding was detected with nuclear extracts prepared from human fetal glial cells, glioma cells, and HeLa cells. Little or no binding was detected with nuclear extracts prepared from human embryonic kidney cells. Competitive binding assays suggest that the nuclear factor(s) which interacted with the JCV regulatory region was different from those which interacted with the regulatory region of the closely related polyomavirus SV40. We found three areas in the JCV regulatory region protected from DNase I digestion: site A, located just upstream from the TATA sequence in the first 98-base pair (bp) repeat; site B, located upstream from the TATA sequence in the second 98-bp repeat; and site C, located just following the second 98-bp repeat. There were some differences in the ability of the nuclear factor(s) from the two brain cell lines and HeLa cells to completely protect the nucleotides within the footprint region. The results from the DNase I protective studies and competitive DNA binding studies with specific oligonucleotides, suggest that nuclear factor-1 or a nuclear factor-1-like factor is interacting with all three sites in the JCV regulatory region. In addition, the results suggest that the nuclear factor which interacts with the JCV regulatory region from human brain cell lines is different from the factor found in HeLa cells.