Theory of tunable pH-sensitive vesicles of anionic and cationic lipids or anionic and neutral lipids

The design of vesicles that become unstable at an easily tuned value of pH is of great interest for targeted drug delivery. We present a microscopic theory for two forms of such vesicles. A model of lipids introduced by us previously is applied to a system of ionizable anionic lipid and permanently charged cationic lipid. We calculate the pH at which the lamellar phase becomes unstable with respect to an inverted hexagonal one, a value that depends continuously on the system composition. Identifying this instability with that displayed by unilamellar vesicles undergoing fusion, we obtain very good agreement with the recent experimental data of Hafez, Ansell, and Cullis, (2000, Biophys. J. 79:1438-1446) on the pH at which fusion occurs versus vesicle composition. We explicate the mechanism in terms of the role of the counterions. This understanding suggests that a system of a neutral, nonlamellar-forming lipid stabilized by an anionic lipid would serve equally well for preparing tunable, pH-sensitive vesicles. Our calculations confirm this. Further, we show that both forms of vesicle have the desirable feature of exhibiting a regime in which the pH at instability is a rapidly varying function of the vesicle composition.     

Membrane-active peptides for non-viral gene therapy: making the safest easier

Non-viral gene therapy uses engineered nanoparticles in the virus size range for the cell-targeted delivery of therapeutic nucleic acids. A diverse range of macromolecules are suitable for constructing such 'artificial viruses'. However, proteins, either man-made or from natural sources, are especially convenient for mimicking the viral functions critical for gene transfer. Cell penetration is a critical step for the delivery of nucleic acids in sufficient amounts and hence for reaching satisfactory transgene expression levels. Membrane-active peptides have shown great promise because of their positive role in cross-membrane transport and intracellular trafficking, and they have been incorporated into different artificial viruses. In this review, we will discuss the biological properties of these peptides together with the newest rational approaches designed to optimize their application.     

Membrane-active peptides: Binding,translocation, and flux in lipid vesicles

Recently, new and improved methods have been developed to measure translocation of membrane-active peptides (antimicrobial, cytolytic, and amphipathic cell-penetrating peptides) across lipid bilayer membranes. The hypothesis that translocation of membrane-active peptides across a lipid bilayer is determined by the Gibbs energy of insertion of the peptide into the bilayer is re-examined in the light of new experimental tests. The original hypothesis and its motivation are first revisited, examining some of the specific predictions that it generated, followed by the results of the initial tests. Translocation is understood as requiring two previous steps: binding and insertion in the membrane. The problem of peptide binding to membranes, its prediction, measurement, and calculation are addressed. Particular attention is given to understanding the reason for the need for amphipathic structures in the function of membrane-active peptides. Insertion into the membrane is then examined. Hydrophobicity scales are compared, and their influence on calculations is discussed. The relation between translocation and graded or all-or-none peptide-induced flux from or into lipid vesicles is also considered. Finally, the most recent work on translocation is examined, both experimental and from molecular dynamics simulations. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Interfacially Active Peptides and Proteins. Guest Editors: William C. Wimley and Kalina Hristova.     

Membrane-active antimicrobial peptides and human placental lysosomal extracts are highly active against mycobacteria

Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), the causative agent of tuberculosis, manifests discreet strategies to subvert host immune responses, which enable the pathogen to survive and multiply inside the macrophages. This problem is further worsened by the emergence of multidrug resistant mycobacterial strains, which make most of the anti-tuberculous drugs ineffective. It is thus imperative to search for and design better therapeutic strategies, including employment of new antibiotics. Recently, naturally produced antimicrobial molecules such as enzymes, peptides and their synthetic analogs have emerged as compounds with potentially significant therapeutical applications. Although, many antimicrobial peptides have been identified only very few of them have been tested against mycobacteria. A major limitation in using peptides as therapeutics is their sensitivity to enzymatic degradation or inactivity under certain physiological conditions such as relatively high salt concentration. Here, we show that NK-2, a peptide representing the cationic core region of the lymphocytic effector protein NK-lysin, and Ci-MAM-A24, a synthetic salt-tolerant peptide derived from immune cells of Ciona intestinalis, efficiently kill Mycobacterium smegmatis and Mycobacterium bovis-BCG. In addition, NK-2 and Ci-MAM-A24 showed a synergistic killing effect against M. smegmatis, no cytotoxic effect on mouse macrophages at bactericidal concentrations, and were even found to kill mycobacteria residing inside the macrophages. We also show that human placental lysosomal contents exert potent killing effect against mycobacteria under acidic and reducing growth conditions. Electron microscopic studies demonstrate that the lysosomal extract disintegrate bacterial cell membrane resulting in killing of mycobacteria.     

Membrane-active properties of α-MSH analogs: aggregation and fusion of liposomes triggered by surface-conjugated peptides

Reaction of the melanotropin hormone analogs [Nle⁴,D-Phe⁷]-α-MSH and [Nle⁴,D-Phe⁷]-α-MSH(4-10), which were extended at their N-terminus by a thiol-functionalized spacer arm, with preformed liposomes containing thiol-reactive (phospho)lipid derivatives resulted in the aggregation of the vesicles and in a partial leakage of their inner contents. This aggregation/leakage effect, which was only observed when the peptides were covalently conjugated to the surface of the liposomes, was correlated with the fusion of the vesicles as demonstrated by the observed decrease in resonance energy transfer between probes in a membrane lipid mixing assay. A limited fusion was confirmed by monitoring the mixing of the liposome inner contents (formation of 1-aminonaphthalene-3,6,8-trisulfonic acid/p-xylene bis(pyridinium bromide) complex). The membrane-active properties of the peptides could be correlated with changes in the fluorescence emission spectra of their tryptophan residue, which suggested that after their covalent binding to the outer surface of the liposomes they can partition within the core of the bilayers. A blue shift of 10 nm was observed for [Nle⁴,D-Phe⁷]-α-MSH which was correlated with an increase in fluorescence anisotropy and with changes in the accessibility of the coupled peptide as assessed by the quenching of fluorescence of its tryptophan residue by iodide (Stern-Volmer plots). These results should be related to the previously described capacity of α-MSH, and analogs, to interact with membranes and with the favored conformation of these peptides which, via a β-turn, segregate their central hydrophobic residues into a domain that could insert into membranes and, as shown here, trigger their destabilization.     

Membrane-active properties of alpha-MSH analogs: aggregation and fusion of liposomes triggered by surface-conjugated peptides.

Reaction of the melanotropin hormone analogs [Nle(4),D-Phe(7)]-alpha-MSH and [Nle(4),D-Phe(7)]-alpha-MSH(4-10), which were extended at their N-terminus by a thiol-functionalized spacer arm, with preformed liposomes containing thiol-reactive (phospho)lipid derivatives resulted in the aggregation of the vesicles and in a partial leakage of their inner contents. This aggregation/leakage effect, which was only observed when the peptides were covalently conjugated to the surface of the liposomes, was correlated with the fusion of the vesicles as demonstrated by the observed decrease in resonance energy transfer between probes in a membrane lipid mixing assay. A limited fusion was confirmed by monitoring the mixing of the liposome inner contents (formation of 1-aminonaphthalene-3,6,8-trisulfonic acid/p-xylene bis(pyridinium bromide) complex). The membrane-active properties of the peptides could be correlated with changes in the fluorescence emission spectra of their tryptophan residue, which suggested that after their covalent binding to the outer surface of the liposomes they can partition within the core of the bilayers. A blue shift of 10 nm was observed for [Nle(4),D-Phe(7)]-alpha-MSH which was correlated with an increase in fluorescence anisotropy and with changes in the accessibility of the coupled peptide as assessed by the quenching of fluorescence of its tryptophan residue by iodide (Stern-Volmer plots). These results should be related to the previously described capacity of alpha-MSH, and analogs, to interact with membranes and with the favored conformation of these peptides which, via a beta-turn, segregate their central hydrophobic residues into a domain that could insert into membranes and, as shown here, trigger their destabilization.     

Phosphatidylglycerol and sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol: anionic membrane lipids and phosphate regulation

Photosynthetic membranes of organisms from cyanobacteria to seed plants are characterized by the neutral galactolipids and the anionic glycerolipids sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol and phosphatidylglycerol. Recent findings have brought new insights into the biosynthesis of the anionic membrane lipids, the evolutionary origin of the enzymes involved in this process, and the importance of phosphatidylglycerol and sulfoquinovosyldiacylgycerol in photosynthesis. Photosynthetic membranes require a defined level of anionic membrane lipids for proper function, and phosphatidylglycerol and sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol can substitute for each other to a certain extent. A defined level of phosphatidylglycerol is, however, indispensable for photoautotrophic growth. On the other hand, sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol plays a conditionally important role in enabling photosynthetic organisms to survive the phosphate-limiting conditions frequently encountered in natural habitats.     

Interaction of enkephalin peptides with anionic model membranes

According to the model for passive transport across the membranes, the total flow of permeant molecules is related to the product of the water-membrane partition coefficient and the diffusion coefficient, and to the water-membrane interfacial barrier. The effect of membrane surface charge on the permeability and interaction of analgesic peptide ligands with model membranes was investigated. A mixture of zwitterionic phospholipids with cholesterol was used as a model membrane. The lipid membrane charge density was controlled by the addition of anionic 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylserine. Two classes of highly potent analgesic peptides were studied, c[D-Pen²,D-Pen⁵]enkephalin (DPDPE) and biphalin, a dimeric analog of enkephalin. The effect of increased surface charge on the permeability of the zwitterionic DPDPE is a relatively modest decrease, that appears to be due to a diminished partition coefficient. On the other hand the binding of the dicationic biphalin ligands to membranes increases proportionally with increased negative surface charge. This effect translates into a significant reduction of biphalin permeability by reducing the diffusion of the peptide across the bilayer. These experiments show the importance of electrostatic effects on the peptide-membrane interactions and suggest that the negative charge naturally present in cell membranes may hamper the membrane transport of some peptide drugs, especially cationic ones, unless there are cationic transporters present.     

Uniform preparations of large unilamellar vesicles containing anionic lipids

A general procedure for the preparation of large unilamellar vesicles of selected sizes has been developed. The procedure consists of dissolving the lipid in organic solvent, washing with mild acid, removing the solvent, adding salt (0.15 M KCl) solution, and adjusting the pH (raising it to about pH 10 and lowering it immediately to pH 7.55). The procedure takes less than 30 min. The resulting unilamellar vesicles are of a single size with a rather low standard deviation. The sizes of these preparations range between 150 and 1000 nm in diameter. Sizes and polydispersities were measured to within 1-2% by photon correlation spectroscopy. Vesicle size varies with the phospholipid structure, the composition of the phospholipid mixture, the ionic strength of the medium, the alkyl chain composition, the cholesterol content of the phospholipid mixture, and the timing of the pH adjustment procedure. Uniform preparations of vesicles have been obtained from the dioleoyl esters of phosphatidic acid, phosphatidylglycerol, phosphatidylethanolamine, and phosphatidylserine, from diphytanyl ethers of glycolipid sulfate, phosphatidylglycerol, phosphatidylglycerol phosphate, and phosphatidylglycerol sulfate, from bovine liver phosphatidylinositol, from Escherichia coli phosphatidylethanolamine, from membrane lipid extracts from E. coli and Holabacterium cutirubrum, and from dodecanesulfonate-alkanol mixtures and free oleic acid. The preparation of unilamellar vesicles from oleic acid is novel, and the size range is 600-3000 nm; the preparations are relatively uniform. Vesicles of phospholipids in which sucrose and trehalose replace salt as the impermeant do not differ significantly from those prepared in pentaerythritol.     

Tunable pH-sensitive liposomes composed of mixtures of cationic and anionic lipids

The pH-dependent fusion properties of large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs) composed of binary mixtures of anionic and cationic lipids have been investigated. It is shown that stable LUVs can be prepared from the ionizable anionic lipid cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHEMS) and the permanently charged cationic lipid N,N-dioleoyl-N, N-dimethylammonium chloride (DODAC) at neutral pH values and that these LUVs undergo fusion as the pH is reduced. The critical pH at which fusion was observed (pH(f)) was dependent on the cationic lipid-to-anionic lipid ratio. LUVs prepared from DODAC/CHEMS mixtures at molar ratios of 0 to 0.85 resulted in vesicles with pH(f) values that ranged from pH 4.0 to 6.7, respectively. This behavior is consistent with a model in which fusion occurs at pH values such that the DODAC/CHEMS LUV surface charge is zero. Related behavior was observed for LUVs composed of the ionizable cationic lipid 3alpha-[N-(N',N'-dimethylaminoethane)-carbamoyl] cholesterol hydrochloride (DC-Chol) and the acidic lipid dioleoylphosphatidic acid (DOPA). Freeze-fracture and (31)P NMR evidence is presented which indicates that pH-dependent fusion results from a preference of mixtures of cationic and anionic lipid for "inverted" nonbilayer lipid phases under conditions where the surface charge is zero. It is concluded that tunable pH-sensitive LUVs composed of cationic and anionic lipids may be of utility for drug delivery applications. It is also suggested that the ability of cationic lipids to adopt inverted nonbilayer structures in combination with anionic lipids may be related to the ability of cationic lipids to facilitate the intracellular delivery of macromolecules.     

Interaction of enkephalin peptides with anionic model membranes.

According to the model for passive transport across the membranes, the total flow of permeant molecules is related to the product of the water-membrane partition coefficient and the diffusion coefficient, and to the water-membrane interfacial barrier. The effect of membrane surface charge on the permeability and interaction of analgesic peptide ligands with model membranes was investigated. A mixture of zwitterionic phospholipids with cholesterol was used as a model membrane. The lipid membrane charge density was controlled by the addition of anionic 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylserine. Two classes of highly potent analgesic peptides were studied, c[D-Pen(2),D-Pen(5)]enkephalin (DPDPE) and biphalin, a dimeric analog of enkephalin. The effect of increased surface charge on the permeability of the zwitterionic DPDPE is a relatively modest decrease, that appears to be due to a diminished partition coefficient. On the other hand the binding of the dicationic biphalin ligands to membranes increases proportionally with increased negative surface charge. This effect translates into a significant reduction of biphalin permeability by reducing the diffusion of the peptide across the bilayer. These experiments show the importance of electrostatic effects on the peptide-membrane interactions and suggest that the negative charge naturally present in cell membranes may hamper the membrane transport of some peptide drugs, especially cationic ones, unless there are cationic transporters present.     

On the role of anionic lipids in charged protein interactions with membranes

We investigate the role of anionic lipids in the binding to, and subsequent movement of charged protein groups in lipid membranes, to help understand the role of membrane composition in all membrane-active protein sequences. We demonstrate a small effect of phosphatidylglycerol (PG) lipids on the ability of an arginine (Arg) side chain to bind to, and cross a lipid membrane, despite possessing a neutralizing charge. We observe similar membrane deformations in lipid bilayers composed of phosphatidylcholine (PC) and PC/PG mixtures, with comparable numbers of water and lipid head groups pulled into the bilayer hydrocarbon core, and prohibitively large ~20 kcal/mol barriers for Arg transfer across each bilayer, dropping by just 2-3 kcal/mol due to the binding of PG lipids. We explore the causes of this small effect of introducing PG lipids and offer an explanation in terms of the limited membrane interaction for the choline groups of PC lipids bound to the translocating ion. Our calculations reveal a surprising lack of preference for Arg binding to PG lipids themselves, but a small increase in interfacial binding affinity for lipid bilayers containing PG lipids. These results help to explain the nature of competitive lipid binding to charged protein sequences, with implications for a wide range of membrane binding domains and cell perturbing peptides.     

How lipids influence the mode of action of membrane-active peptides

The human, multifunctional peptide LL-37 causes membrane disruption by distinctly different mechanisms strongly dependent on the nature of the membrane lipid composition, varying not only with lipid headgroup charge but also with hydrocarbon chain length. Specifically, LL-37 induces a peptide-associated quasi-interdigitated phase in negatively charged phosphatidylglycerol (PG) model membranes, where the hydrocarbon chains are shielded from water by the peptide. In turn, LL-37 leads to a disintegration of the lamellar organization of zwitterionic dipalmitoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) into disk-like micelles. Interestingly, interdigitation was also observed for the longer-chain C18 and C20 PCs. This dual behavior of LL-37 can be attributed to a balance between electrostatic interactions reflected in different penetration depths of the peptide and hydrocarbon chain length. Thus, our observations indicate that there is a tight coupling between the peptide properties and those of the lipid bilayer, which needs to be considered in studies of lipid/peptide interaction. Very similar effects were also observed for melittin and the frog skin peptide PGLa. Therefore, we propose a phase diagram showing different lipid/peptide arrangements as a function of hydrocarbon chain length and LL-37 concentration and suggest that this phase diagram is generally applicable to membrane-active peptides localized parallel to the membrane surface.     

How lipids influence the mode of action of membrane-active peptides

The human, multifunctional peptide LL-37 causes membrane disruption by distinctly different mechanisms strongly dependent on the nature of the membrane lipid composition, varying not only with lipid headgroup charge but also with hydrocarbon chain length. Specifically, LL-37 induces a peptide-associated quasi-interdigitated phase in negatively charged phosphatidylglycerol (PG) model membranes, where the hydrocarbon chains are shielded from water by the peptide. In turn, LL-37 leads to a disintegration of the lamellar organization of zwitterionic dipalmitoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) into disk-like micelles. Interestingly, interdigitation was also observed for the longer-chain C18 and C20 PCs. This dual behavior of LL-37 can be attributed to a balance between electrostatic interactions reflected in different penetration depths of the peptide and hydrocarbon chain length. Thus, our observations indicate that there is a tight coupling between the peptide properties and those of the lipid bilayer, which needs to be considered in studies of lipid/peptide interaction. Very similar effects were also observed for melittin and the frog skin peptide PGLa. Therefore, we propose a phase diagram showing different lipid/peptide arrangements as a function of hydrocarbon chain length and LL-37 concentration and suggest that this phase diagram is generally applicable to membrane-active peptides localized parallel to the membrane surface.     

The influence of proteins and peptides on the phase properties of lipids

This paper reviews model membrane studies on the modulation of the macroscopic structure of lipids by lipid-protein interactions, with particular emphasis on the gramicidin molecule. This hydrophobic peptide has three main effects on lipid polymorphism: (1) in lysophosphatidylcholine it triggers a micellar to bilayer transition, (2) in phosphatidylethanolamine it lowers the bilayer to hexagonal H_II phase transition temperature and (3) in phosphatidylcholine and other bilayer preferring lipids it is able to induce the formation of an H_II phase. From experiments in which the gramicidin molecule was chemically modified it can be concluded that the tryptophan residues play a determining role in the peptide-induced changes in polymorphism. The experimental data lead to the proposal that gramicidin molecules have a tendency to self-associate, possibly mediated by tryptophan-tryptophan interactions and organize into tubular structures such as found in the H_II phase.     

Interaction of human substantia nigra neuromelanin with lipids and peptides

Neuromelanin was isolated from human substantia nigra using different procedures. In the pigment isolated by any of these procedures a peptide component covalently bound to the melanic structure was found, as shown by treatment with reagents known to eliminate noncovalently bound proteins. The amino acid content of such a peptide component was reproducible and corresponded to approximately 15% of the neuromelanin weight. Neuromelanin also showed the ability to absorb specifically lipid molecules, approximately 20% of its weight, and among these lipids cholesterol was identified, constituting approximately 5% of the total lipid mixture. A synthetic melanin, incubated with putamen homogenate, bound tissue peptides with an amino acid content quite close to that of neuromelanin. The same synthetic melanin adsorbed a lower amount of lipids from the putamen homogenate compared with neuromelanin. The sulfur content of neuromelanin was also reproducible even using different isolation procedures. A nonpigmented tissue like corpus callosum was used as a control and extracted by the method used for neuromelanin isolation; a total elimination of tissue components was found, thus demonstrating the capability of the reported procedures to isolate neuromelanin alone. The presence of a peptide component in the neuromelanin structure and the selective affinity for lipid molecules suggest new aspects of the functional role and metabolic pathway of neuromelanin.     

Role of lipids in the interaction of antimicrobial peptides with membranes

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) take part in the immune system by mounting a first line of defense against pathogens. Recurrent structural and functional aspects are observed among peptides from different sources, particularly the net cationicity and amphipathicity. However, the membrane seems to be the key determinant of their action, either as the main target of the peptide action or by forming a barrier that must be crossed by peptides to target core metabolic pathways. More importantly, the specificity exhibited by antimicrobial peptides relies on the different lipid composition between pathogen and host cells, likely contributing to their spectrum of activity. Several mechanisms of action have been reported, which may involve membrane permeabilization through the formation of pores, membrane thinning or micellization in a detergent-like way. AMPs may also target intracellular components, such as DNA, enzymes and even organelles. More recently, these peptides have been shown to produce membrane perturbation by formation of specific lipid-peptide domains, lateral phase segregation of zwitterionic from anionic phospholipids and even the formation of non-lamellar lipid phases. To countermeasure their activity, some pathogens were successful in developing effective mechanisms of resistance to decrease their susceptibility to AMPs. The functional and integral knowledge of such interactions and the clarification of the complex interplay between molecular determinants of peptides, the pathogen versus host cells dichotomy and the specific microenvironment in which all these elements convene will contribute to an understanding of some elusive aspects of their action and to rationally design novel therapeutic agents to overcome the current antibiotic resistance issue.     

Specificity of amphiphilic anionic peptides for fusion of phospholipid vesicles.

We have synthesized five amphiphilic anionic peptides derived from E5 peptide [Murata, M., Takahashi, S., Kagiwada, S., Suzuki, A., Ohnishi, S. 1992. Biochemistry 31:1986-1992. E5NN and E5CC are duplications of the N-terminal and the C-terminal halves of E5, respectively, and E5CN is an inversion of the N- and the C-terminal halves. E5P contains a Pro residue in the center of E5 and E8 has 8 Glu residues and 9 Leu residues. We studied fusion of dioleoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC) large unilamellar vesicles assayed by fluorescent probes. The peptides formed alpha-helical structure with different degrees; E5NN, E5CN, and E8 with high helical content and E5CC and E5P with low helical content. These peptides bound to DOPC vesicles at acidic pH in proportion to the helical content of peptide. The peptides caused leakage of DOPC vesicles which increased with decreasing pH. The leakage was also proportional to the helicity of peptide. Highly helical peptides E5NN, E5CN, and E8 caused hemolysis at acidic pH but not at neutral pH. The fusion activity was also dependent on the helicity of peptides. In fusion induced by an equimolar mixture of E5 analogues and K5 at neutral pH, E8, E5NN, and E5CN were most active but E5CC did not cause fusion. In fusion induced by E5-analogue peptides alone, E5CN was active at acidic pH but not at neutral pH. Other peptides did not cause fusion. Amphiphilic peptides also appear to require other factors to cause fusion.