Membrane Topology and Insertion of Membrane Proteins: Search for Topogenic Signals

Integral membrane proteins are found in all cellular membranes and carry out many of the functions that are essential to life. The membrane-embedded domains of integral membrane proteins are structurally quite simple, allowing the use of various prediction methods and biochemical methods to obtain structural information about membrane proteins. A critical step in the biosynthetic pathway leading to the folded protein in the membrane is its insertion into the lipid bilayer. Understanding of the fundamentals of the insertion and folding processes will significantly improve the methods used to predict the three-dimensional membrane protein structure from the amino acid sequence. In the first part of this review, biochemical approaches to elucidate membrane protein topology are reviewed and evaluated, and in the second part, the use of similar techniques to study membrane protein insertion is discussed. The latter studies search for signals in the polypeptide chain that direct the insertion process. Knowledge of the topogenic signals in the nascent chain of a membrane protein is essential for the evaluation of membrane topology studies.     

Parallel topology of genetically fused EmrE homodimers

EmrE is a small H+-coupled multidrug transporter in Escherichia coli. Claims have been made for an antiparallel topology of this homodimeric protein. However, our own biochemical studies performed with detergent-solubilized purified protein support a parallel topology of the protomers. We developed an alternative approach to constrain the relative topology of the protomers within the dimer so that their activity can be assayed also in vivo before biochemical handling. Tandem EmrE was built with two identical monomers genetically fused tail to head (C-terminus of the first to N-terminus of the second monomer) with hydrophilic linkers of varying length. All the constructs conferred resistance to ethidium by actively removing it from the cytoplasm. The purified proteins bound substrate and transported methyl viologen into proteoliposomes by a proton-dependent mechanism. A tandem where one of the essential glutamates was replaced with glutamine transported only monovalent substrates and displayed a modified stoichiometry. The results support a parallel topology of the protomers in the functional dimer. The implications regarding insertion and evolution of membrane proteins are discussed.     

Reptilian reovirus utilizes a small type III protein with an external myristylated amino terminus to mediate cell-cell fusion

Reptilian reovirus is one of a limited number of nonenveloped viruses that are capable of inducing cell-cell fusion. A small, hydrophobic, basic, 125-amino-acid fusion protein encoded by the first open reading frame of a bicistronic viral mRNA is responsible for this fusion activity. Sequence comparisons to previously characterized reovirus fusion proteins indicated that p14 represents a new member of the fusion-associated small transmembrane (FAST) protein family. Topological analysis revealed that p14 is a representative of a minor subset of integral membrane proteins, the type III proteins N(exoplasmic)/C(cytoplasmic) (N(exo)/C(cyt)), that lack a cleavable signal sequence and use an internal reverse signal-anchor sequence to direct membrane insertion and protein topology. This topology results in the unexpected, cotranslational translocation of the essential myristylated N-terminal domain of p14 across the cell membrane. The topology and structural motifs present in this novel reovirus membrane fusion protein further accentuate the diversity and unusual properties of the FAST protein family and clearly indicate that the FAST proteins represent a third distinct class of viral membrane fusion proteins.     

Insertion of plastidic β-barrel proteins into the outer envelopes of plastids involves an intermembrane space intermediate formed with Toc75-V/OEP80

The insertion of organellar membrane proteins with the correct topology requires the following: First, the proteins must contain topogenic signals for translocation across and insertion into the membrane. Second, proteinaceous complexes in the cytoplasm, membrane, and lumen of organelles are required to drive this process. Many complexes required for the intracellular distribution of membrane proteins have been described, but the signals and components required for the insertion of plastidic β-barrel-type proteins into the outer membrane are largely unknown. The discovery of common principles is difficult, as only a few plastidic β-barrel proteins exist. Here, we provide evidence that the plastidic outer envelope β-barrel proteins OEP21, OEP24, and OEP37 from pea (Pisum sativum) and Arabidopsis thaliana contain information defining the topology of the protein. The information required for the translocation of pea proteins across the outer envelope membrane is present within the six N-terminal β-strands. This process requires the action of translocon of the outer chloroplast (TOC) membrane. After translocation into the intermembrane space, β-barrel proteins interact with TOC75-V, as exemplified by OEP37 and P39, and are integrated into the membrane. The membrane insertion of plastidic β-barrel proteins is affected by mutation of the last β-strand, suggesting that this strand contributes to the insertion signal. These findings shed light on the elements and complexes involved in plastidic β-barrel protein import.

Plastidic β-barrel proteins contain sequence-intrinsic signals for translocation and membrane insertion, the latter of which involves a complex formation with TOC75-V prior to the final membrane insertion.     

Membrane localization of small proteins in Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli synthesize over 60 poorly understood small proteins of less than 50 amino acids. A striking feature of these proteins is that 65% contain a predicted α-helical transmembrane (TM) domain. This prompted us to examine the localization, topology, and membrane insertion of the small proteins. Biochemical fractionation showed that, consistent with the predicted TM helix, the small proteins generally are most abundant in the inner membrane fraction. Examples of both N(in)-C(out) and N(out)-C(in) orientations were found in assays of topology-reporter fusions to representative small TM proteins. Interestingly, however, three of nine tested proteins display dual topology. Positive residues close to the transmembrane domains are conserved, and mutational analysis of one small protein, YohP, showed that the positive inside rule applies for single transmembrane domain proteins as has been observed for larger proteins. Finally, fractionation analysis of small protein localization in strains depleted of the Sec or YidC membrane insertion pathways uncovered differential requirements. Some small proteins appear to be affected by both Sec and YidC depletion, others showed more dependence on one or the other insertion pathway, whereas one protein was not affected by depletion of either Sec or YidC. Thus, despite their diminutive size, small proteins display considerable diversity in topology, biochemical features, and insertion pathways.     

Complete topology inversion can be part of normal membrane protein biogenesis

The topology of helical membrane proteins is generally defined during insertion of the transmembrane helices, yet it is now clear that it is possible for topology to change under unusual circumstances. It remains unclear, however, if topology reorientation is part of normal biogenesis. For dual topology dimer proteins such as the multidrug transporter EmrE, there may be evolutionary pressure to allow topology flipping so that the populations of both orientations can be equalized. We previously demonstrated that when EmrE is forced to insert in a distorted topology, topology flipping of the first transmembrane helix can occur during translation. Here, we show that topological malleability also extends to the C‐terminal helix and that even complete topology inversion of the entire EmrE protein can occur after the full protein is translated and inserted. Thus, topology rearrangements are possible during normal biogenesis. Wholesale topology flipping is remarkable given the physical constraints of the membrane and expands the range of possible membrane protein folding pathways, both productive and detrimental.     

Monotopic topology is required for lipid droplet targeting of ancient ubiquitous protein 1

Ancient ubiquitous protein 1 (AUP1) is a multifunctional protein, which acts on both lipid droplets (LDs) and the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membrane. Double localization to these two organelles, featuring very different membrane characteristics, was observed also for several other integral proteins, but little is known about the signals and mechanisms behind dual protein targeting to ER and LDs. Here we dissect the AUP1 targeting signals by analyses of localization and topology of several deletion and point mutants. We found that AUP1 is inserted into the membrane of the ER in a monotopic hairpin fashion, and subsequently transported to the hemi-membrane of LDs. A single domain localized in the N-terminal part of AUP1 enables its ER residence, the monotopic insertion, and the LD localization. Different specific residues within this multifunctional domain are responsible for achieving the complex spatial distribution pattern. A mutation of three amino acids, which changes AUP1 topology from hairpin to transmembrane, abolishes LD localization. These findings suggest that the cell is able to target a protein to multiple intracellular locations using a single domain.     

膜蛋白的拓扑学

膜蛋白的拓扑学是研究膜蛋白三维结构的出发点．利用融合蛋白和化学修饰等实验技术已确定了很多膜蛋白的拓扑学．对膜蛋白的转运与插膜的研究确定可能存在两类插膜元件．对已知拓扑学的膜蛋白的统计分析以及蛋白质工程的研究表明存在膜蛋白拓扑学的内正规则．目前已形成预测膜蛋白的拓扑学的比较可靠的策略,这在反向生物学上具有重要意义.但要进行三维结构的预测还有许多路要走．     

A six-membrane-spanning topology for yeast and Arabidopsis Tsc13p, the enoyl reductases of the microsomal fatty acid elongating system

The very long chain fatty acids are crucial building blocks of essential lipids, most notably the sphingolipids. These elongated fatty acids are synthesized by a system of enzymes that are organized in a complex within the endoplasmic reticulum membrane. Although several of the components of the elongase complex have recently been identified, little is known about how these proteins are organized within the membrane or about how they interact with one another during fatty acid elongation. In this study the topology of Tsc13p, the enoyl reductase of the elongase system, was investigated. The N and C termini of Tsc13p reside in the cytoplasm, and six putative membrane-spanning domains were identified by insertion of glycosylation and factor Xa cleavage sites at various positions. The N-terminal domain including the first membrane-spanning segment contains sufficient information for targeting to the endoplasmic reticulum membrane. Studies of the Arabidopsis Tsc13p protein revealed a similar topology. Highly conserved domains of the Tsc13p proteins that are likely to be important for enzymatic activity lie on the cytosolic face of the endoplasmic reticulum, possibly partially embedded within the membrane.     

Analysis of the topology of a membrane protein by using a minimum number of alkaline phosphatase fusions.

An approach to analyzing the topology of membrane proteins with alkaline phosphatase fusions is described. Precise fusions were constructed by using polymerase chain reaction at the C terminus of each hydrophilic region of the membrane protein. The disruption of topogenic signals is thereby minimized, and predictable anomalous results are avoided. The Escherichia coli MalG protein has been analyzed.     

Membrane assembly of the triple-spanning coronavirus M protein. Individual transmembrane domains show preferred orientation.

The M protein of mouse hepatitis virus strain A59 is a triple-spanning membrane protein which assembles with an uncleaved internal signal sequence, adopting an NexoCcyt orientation. To study the insertion mechanism of this protein, domains potentially involved in topogenesis were deleted and the effects analyzed in topogenesis were deleted and the effects analyzed in several ways. Mutant proteins were synthesized in a cell-free translation system in the presence of microsomal membranes, and their integration and topology were determined by alkaline extraction and by protease-protection experiments. By expression in COS-1 and Madin-Darby canine kidney-II cells, the topology of the mutant proteins was also analyzed in vivo. Glycosylation was used as a biochemical marker to assess the disposition of the NH2 terminus. An indirect immunofluorescence assay on semi-intact Madin-Darby canine kidney-II cells using domain-specific antibodies served to identify the cytoplasmically exposed domains. The results show that each membrane-spanning domain acts independently as an insertion and anchor signal and adopts an intrinsic preferred orientation in the lipid bilayer which corresponds to the disposition of the transmembrane domain in the wild-type assembled protein. These observations provide further insight into the mechanism of membrane integration of multispanning proteins. A model for the insertion of the coronavirus M protein is proposed.     

A guideline to proteome-wide α-helical membrane protein topology predictions

For current state-of-the-art methods, the prediction of correct topology of membrane proteins has been reported to be above 80%. However, this performance has only been observed in small and possibly biased data sets obtained from protein structures or biochemical assays. Here, we test a number of topology predictors on an "unseen" set of proteins of known structure and also on four "genome-scale" data sets, including one recent large set of experimentally validated human membrane proteins with glycosylated sites. The set of glycosylated proteins is also used to examine the ability of prediction methods to separate membrane from nonmembrane proteins. The results show that methods utilizing multiple sequence alignments are overall superior to methods that do not. The best performance is obtained by TOPCONS, a consensus method that combines several of the other prediction methods. The best methods to distinguish membrane from nonmembrane proteins belong to the "Phobius" group of predictors. We further observe that the reported high accuracies in the smaller benchmark sets are not quite maintained in larger scale benchmarks. Instead, we estimate the performance of the best prediction methods for eukaryotic membrane proteins to be between 60% and 70%. The low agreement between predictions from different methods questions earlier estimates about the global properties of the membrane proteome. Finally, we suggest a pipeline to estimate these properties using a combination of the best predictors that could be applied in large-scale proteomics studies of membrane proteins.     

Integration of membrane proteins into the endoplasmic reticulum requires GTP

We have examined the requirement for ribonucleotides and ribonucleotide triphosphate hydrolysis during early events in the membrane integration of two membrane proteins: the G protein of vesicular stomatitis virus and the hemagglutinin-neuraminidase (HN) glycoprotein of Newcastle disease virus. Both proteins contain a single transmembrane-spanning segment but are integrated in the membrane with opposite orientations. The G protein has an amino-terminal signal sequence and a stop-transfer sequence located near the carboxy terminus. The HN glycoprotein has a single sequence near the amino terminus that functions as both a signal-sequence and a transmembrane-spanning segment. Membrane insertion was explored using a cell-free system directed by transcribed mRNAs encoding amino-terminal segments of the two proteins. Ribosome-bound nascent polypeptides were assembled, ribonucleotides were removed by gel filtration chromatography, and the ribosomes were incubated with microsomal membranes under conditions of defined ribonucleotide content. Nascent chain insertion into the membrane required the presence of both the signal recognition particle and a functional signal recognition particle receptor. In the absence of ribonucleotides, insertion of nascent membrane proteins was not detected. GTP or nonhydrolyzable GTP analogues promoted efficient insertion, while ATP was comparatively ineffective. Surprisingly, the majority of the HN nascent chain remained ribosome associated after puromycin treatment. Ribosome-associated HN nascent chains remained competent for membrane insertion, while free HN chains were not competent. We conclude that a GTP binding protein performs an essential function during ribosome-dependent insertion of membrane proteins into the endoplasmic reticulum that is unrelated to protein synthesis.     

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer shows a close helix-helix distance in the transmembrane M13 procoat protein

During the membrane insertion process the major coat protein of bacteriophage M13 assumes a conformation in which two transmembrane helices corresponding to the leader sequence and the anchor region in the mature part of the protein coming into close contact with each other. Previous studies on the molecular mechanism of membrane insertion of M13 procoat protein have shown that this interaction between the two helices might drive the actual translocation process. We investigated the intramolecular distance between the two helices of the transmembrane procoat protein by measuring fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between the donor (Tyr) placed in one helix and the acceptor (Trp) placed in the other helix. Various mutant procoat proteins with differently positioned donor-acceptor pairs were generated, purified, and reconstituted into artificial lipid bilayers. The results obtained from the FRET measurements, combined with molecular modeling, show that the transmembrane helices are in close contact on the order of 1-1.5 nm. The present approach might be of general interest for determining the topology and the folding of membrane proteins.     

Import of hybrid forms of CYP11A1 into yeast mitochondria

Heterologous expression in yeast of mCYP11A1 fusions with different topogenic signals of yeast mitochondrial proteins for artificial channeling to different translocases of the inner membrane was used to gain insight in the mechanism of its topogenesis in mitochondria. To ensure insertion of the CYP11A1 domain into the inner mitochondrial membrane during the process of translocation, topogenic sequences containing transmembrane segments of Bcs1p(1-83), DLD(1-72), and full-sized AAC protein were used when constructing modified forms of CYP11A1, and the Su9(1-112) addressing signal was included to stimulate membrane insertion of CYP11A1 after its translocation to the matrix. Alternatively, to promote slippage of the hybrid molecules into the matrix, the hybrid of mCYP11A1 with the precursor of steroidogenic mitochondria matrix protein adrenodoxin (preAd) was designed. The extra sequences used for intramitochondrial sorting of CYP11A1 apparently ensured predicted topology of hybrid molecules in yeast mitochondria. All of the addressing sequences, containing transmembrane domains, provided effective insertion of the hybrid proteins AAC-mCYP11A1, Bcs1p(1-83)-mCYP11A1, DLD(1-72)-mCYP11A1 and Su9(1-116)-mCYP11A1 into the inner membrane. preAd-mCYP11A1 hybrid molecules were shown to be translocated across the inner membrane and tightly associated with the membrane on its matrix side but not membrane inserted. Measuring specific activities of hybrid proteins in the mitochondrial fractions upon addition of Ad and AdR showed that the hybrids predetermined for cotranslocational insertion of CYP11A1 into the inner membrane were more active in the reaction of cholesterol side-chain cleavage than those destined for insertion on the matrix side of the IM, the Ad-mCYP11A1 hybrid demonstrating only residual enzyme activity. The data obtained reinforce the proposal that complete transfer of the polypeptide chain into the matrix is not a necessary stage in its topogenesis, but rather persistent interaction of the polypeptide chain with the membrane during the process of translocation is of importance for heme binding, folding and membrane insertion.     

Tim22, the essential core of the mitochondrial protein insertion complex, forms a voltage-activated and signal-gated channel

The protein insertion complex of the mitochondrial inner membrane is crucial for import of the numerous multitopic membrane proteins with internal targeting signals. Little is known about the molecular mechanism of this complex, including whether it forms a real channel or merely acts as scaffold for protein insertion. We report the unexpected observation that Tim22 is the only essential membrane-integrated subunit of the complex. Reconstituted Tim22 forms a hydrophilic, high-conductance channel with distinct opening states and pore diameters. The channel is voltage-activated and specifically responds to an internal targeting signal, but not to presequences. Thus, a protein insertion complex can combine three essential functions, signal recognition, channel formation, and energy transduction, in one central component.     

Membrane topology of human ABC proteins

In this review, we summarize the currently available information on the membrane topology of some key members of the human ABC protein subfamilies, and present the predicted domain arrangements. In the lack of high-resolution structures for eukaryotic ABC transporters this topology is based only on prediction algorithms and biochemical data for the location of various segments of the polypeptide chain, relative to the membrane. We suggest that topology models generated by the available prediction methods should only be used as guidelines to provide a basis of experimental strategies for the elucidation of the membrane topology.     

Lipid composition of outer leaflet of chloroplast outer envelope determines topology of OEP7.

OEP7, a 6.7-kDa outer envelope protein of spinach chloroplasts inserts into the outer envelope of the organelle independent of a classical cleavable targeting signal. The insertion of OEP7 was studied to describe the determinants for association with, integration into, and orientation of the protein in the outer envelope of chloroplasts. The insertion of OEP7 into the membrane is independent of outer membrane channel proteins and can be reconstituted with the use of protein-free liposomes. In situ, the binding of OEP7 to the membrane surface is not driven by electrostatic interaction because reduction of phosphatidylglycerol or phosphatidylinositol did not reduce the association with the liposomes. The positively charged amino acids flanking the transmembrane domain at the C terminus are essential to retain the native N(in)-C(out) orientation during insertion into chloroplasts. OEP7 inserts with reversed orientation into liposomes containing the average lipid composition of the outer envelopes. The native like N(in)-C(out) orientation is achieved by reduction of the phoshpatidylglycerol concentration mimicking the composition of the outer leaflet of the outer envelope of chloroplasts. We conclude that the unique lipid composition of the outer leaflet due to lipid asymmetry of the outer envelope is essential for the correct topology of OEP7.     

Membrane insertion pathway of annexin B12: thermodynamic and kinetic characterization by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy and fluorescence quenching

Experimental determination of the free energy stabilizing the structure of membrane proteins in their native lipid environment is undermined by the lack of appropriate methods and suitable model systems. Annexin B12 (ANX) is a soluble protein which reversibly inserts into lipid membranes under mildly acidic conditions, which makes it a good experimental model for thermodynamic studies of folding and stability of membrane proteins. Here we apply fluorescence correlation spectroscopy for quantitative analysis of ANX partitioning into large unilamellar vesicles containing either 25% or 75% anionic lipids. Membrane binding of ANX results in changes of autocorrelation time and amplitude, both of which are used in quantitative analysis. The thermodynamic scheme describing acid-induced membrane interactions of ANX considers two independent processes: pH-dependent formation of a membrane-competent form near the membrane interface and its insertion into the lipid bilayer. Our novel fluorescence lifetime topology method demonstrates that the insertion proceeds via an interfacial refolded intermediate state, which can be stabilized by anionic lipids. Lipid titration measurements are used to determine the free energy of both transmembrane insertion and interfacial penetration, which are found to be similar, approximately -10-12 kcal/mol. The formation of the membrane-competent form, examined in a lipid saturation experiment, was found to depend on the local proton concentration near the membrane interface, occurring with pK = 4.3 and involving the protonation of two residues. Our results demonstrate that fluorescence correlation spectroscopy is a convenient tool for the quantitative characterization of the energetics of transmembrane insertion and that pH-triggered ANX insertion is a useful model for studying the thermodynamic stability of membrane proteins.     

Determining Membrane Protein Topology Using Fluorescence Protease Protection (FPP)

The correct topology and orientation of integral membrane proteins are essential for their proper function, yet such information has not been established for many membrane proteins. A simple technique called fluorescence protease protection (FPP) is presented, which permits the determination of membrane protein topology in living cells. This technique has numerous advantages over other methods for determining protein topology, in that it does not require the availability of multiple antibodies against various domains of the membrane protein, does not require large amounts of protein, and can be performed on living cells. The FPP method employs the spatially confined actions of proteases on the degradation of green fluorescent protein (GFP) tagged membrane proteins to determine their membrane topology and orientation. This simple approach is applicable to a wide variety of cell types, and can be used to determine membrane protein orientation in various subcellular organelles such as the mitochondria, Golgi, endoplasmic reticulum and components of the endosomal/recycling system. Membrane proteins, tagged on either the N-termini or C-termini with a GFP fusion, are expressed in a cell of interest, which is subject to selective permeabilization using the detergent digitonin. Digitonin has the ability to permeabilize the plasma membrane, while leaving intracellular organelles intact. GFP moieties exposed to the cytosol can be selectively degraded through the application of protease, whereas GFP moieties present in the lumen of organelles are protected from the protease and remain intact. The FPP assay is straightforward, and results can be obtained rapidly.