Predicting cancer rates in astronauts from animal carcinogenesis studies and cellular markers

The radiation space environment includes particles such as protons and multiple species of heavy ions, with much of the exposure to these radiations occurring at extremely low average dose-rates. Limitations in databases needed to predict cancer hazards in human beings from such radiations are significant and currently do not provide confidence that such predictions are acceptably precise or accurate. In this article, we outline the need for animal carcinogenesis data based on a more sophisticated understanding of the dose-response relationship for induction of cancer and correlative cellular endpoints by representative space radiations. We stress the need for a model that can interrelate human and animal carcinogenesis data with cellular mechanisms. Using a broad model for dose-response patterns which we term the "subalpha-alpha-omega (SAO) model", we explore examples in the literature for radiation-induced cancer and for radiation-induced cellular events to illustrate the need for data that define the dose-response patterns more precisely over specific dose ranges, with special attention to low dose, low dose-rate exposure. We present data for multiple endpoints in cells, which vary in their radiosensitivity, that also support the proposed model. We have measured induction of complex chromosome aberrations in multiple cell types by two space radiations, Fe-ions and protons, and compared these to photons delivered at high dose-rate or low dose-rate. Our data demonstrate that at least three factors modulate the relative efficacy of Fe-ions compared to photons: (i) intrinsic radiosensitivity of irradiated cells; (ii) dose-rate; and (iii) another unspecified effect perhaps related to reparability of DNA lesions. These factors can produce respectively up to at least 7-, 6- and 3-fold variability. These data demonstrate the need to understand better the role of intrinsic radiosensitivity and dose-rate effects in mammalian cell response to ionizing radiation. Such understanding is critical in extrapolating databases between cellular response, animal carcinogenesis and human carcinogenesis, and we suggest that the SAO model is a useful tool for such extrapolation.     

Effects of exposure to low-dose-rate (60)co gamma rays on human tumor cells in vitro

Cells of three asynchronously growing human tumor cell lines, PC3 (human prostate carcinoma), T98G and A7 (human glioblastomas), which have been shown previously to demonstrate low-dose hyper-radiosensitivity to low acute single doses, were irradiated with (60)Co gamma rays at low dose rates (2 cGy-1 Gy h(-1)). Instead of a dose-rate sparing response, these cell lines demonstrated an inverse dose-rate effect on cell survival at dose rates below 1 Gy h(-1), whereby a decrease in dose rate resulted in an increase in cell killing per unit dose. A hyper-radiosensitivity-negative cell line, U373MG, did not demonstrate an inverse dose-rate effect. Analysis of the cell cycle indicated that this inverse dose-rate effect was not due to accumulation of cells in G(2)/M phase or to other cell cycle perturbations. T98G cells in reversible G(1)-phase arrest also showed an inverse dose-rate effect at dose rates below 30 cGy h(-1) but a sparing effect as the dose rate was reduced from 60 to 30 cGy h(-1). We conclude that this inverse dose-rate effect in continuous exposures reflects the hyper-radiosensitivity seen in the same cell lines in response to very small acute single doses.     

Adaptive response and induced resistance

Cellular stress responses are upregulated following exposure to radiation and other DNA-damaging agents. Therefore radiation response can be dose dependent so that small acute exposures (and possibly exposures at very low dose rates?) are more lethal per unit dose than larger exposures above a threshold (typically 10-40 cGy) where induced radioprotection is triggered. We have termed these interlinked phenomena low-dose hypersensitivity (HRS) and induced radioresistance (IRR) as the dose increases. HRS/IRR has been recorded in cell-survival studies with yeast, bacteria, protozoa, algae, higher plant cells, insect cells, mammalian and human cells in vitro, and in studies on animal normal-tissue models in vivo. There is indirect evidence that cell survival-related HRS/IRR in response to single doses is a manifestation of the same underlying mechanism that determines the well-known adaptive response in the two-dose case and that it can be triggered by high- and low-LET radiations as well as a variety of other stress-inducing agents such as hydrogen peroxide and chemotherapeutic agents. Little is currently known about the precise nature of this underlying mechanism, but there is evidence that it operates by increasing the amount and rate of DNA repair, rather than by indirect mechanisms such as modulation of cell-cycle progression or apoptosis. Changed expression of some genes, only in response to low and not high doses, may occur within a few hours of irradiation and this would be rapid enough to explain the phenomenon of induced radioresistance although its specific molecular components have yet to be identified. Net cancer risk is a balance between cell transformation and cell kill. Our known low-dose cell-survival responses suggest that lethality may more than compensate for transformation at low radiation doses. However, adaptive reduction in sensitivity to radio-mutation has also been reported, which implies the existence also of enhanced mutation following very low single doses. So far this has not been confirmed, but provided the trigger dose for mutational protection was lower than the trigger dose for protection against cytotoxicity, cell killing would still dominate over at least the first 10 cGy of low-LET exposure. This would lead to a non-linear, threshold, dose-risk relationship and even provide some explanation for anecdotal reports of apparent 'health promoting' effects and lowered cancer risk from very low exposure to ionising radiation.     

Methodologies for predicting the expected combined stochastic radiobiological effects of different ionizing radiations and some applications

A methodology for predicting the expected combined stochastic radiobiological effects of sequential exposure to different ionizing radiations is used to arrive at a methodology for predicting the radiobiological effects of simultaneous exposure. Both methodologies require developing additive-damage dose-effect models. Additive-damage dose-effect models are derived assuming (a) each radiation comprised by the combined exposure produces initial damage called critical damage that could lead to the radiobiological effect of interest; (b) doses of different radiations that lead to the same level of radiobiological effect (or risk) can be viewed as producing the same amount of critical damage and being indistinguishable as far as the effects of subsequently administered radiation. Derived dose-effect functions that describe the risk per individual, conditional on radiation dose, are called risk functions. The methodologies allow the use of known radiation-specific risk functions to derive risk functions for combined effects of different radiations. The risk functions for combined exposure to different radiations are called global risk functions. For sequential exposures to different ionizing radiations, the global risk functions derived depend on how individual radiation doses are ordered. Global risk functions can also differ for sequential and simultaneous exposure. The methodologies are used to account for some previously unexplained radiobiological effects of combined exposure to high and low linear-energy-transfer radiations.     

Relative Biological Effectiveness of HZE Particles for Chromosomal Exchanges and Other Surrogate Cancer Risk Endpoints

The biological effects of high charge and energy (HZE) particle exposures are of interest in space radiation protection of astronauts and cosmonauts, and estimating secondary cancer risks for patients undergoing Hadron therapy for primary cancers. The large number of particles types and energies that makeup primary or secondary radiation in HZE particle exposures precludes tumor induction studies in animal models for all but a few particle types and energies, thus leading to the use of surrogate endpoints to investigate the details of the radiation quality dependence of relative biological effectiveness (RBE) factors. In this report we make detailed RBE predictions of the charge number and energy dependence of RBE’s using a parametric track structure model to represent experimental results for the low dose response for chromosomal exchanges in normal human lymphocyte and fibroblast cells with comparison to published data for neoplastic transformation and gene mutation. RBE’s are evaluated against acute doses of γ-rays for doses near 1 Gy. Models that assume linear or non-targeted effects at low dose are considered. Modest values of RBE (<10) are found for simple exchanges using a linear dose response model, however in the non-targeted effects model for fibroblast cells large RBE values (>10) are predicted at low doses <0.1 Gy. The radiation quality dependence of RBE’s against the effects of acute doses γ-rays found for neoplastic transformation and gene mutation studies are similar to those found for simple exchanges if a linear response is assumed at low HZE particle doses. Comparisons of the resulting model parameters to those used in the NASA radiation quality factor function are discussed.     

The induction of reciprocal translocations in mouse germ cells by chemicals and ionizing radiations. II. Combined effects of mitomycin C or thio-tepa with two doses of gamma-rays

The combined effects of mitomycin C (MMC) and thio-tepa (TT) with gamma-ray doses of 5 and 9 Gy on mouse stem cells were studied using the spermatocyte test. Both chemicals induced very low yields of translocations after single treatments. In combined treatments with a dose of 5 Gy, a subadditive effect of MMC and an additive effect of TT were found. Combined with a dose of 9 Gy the compounds potentiated the effect of radiations. Up to now, most of the chemicals tested have shown additive effects when combined with doses of the ascending part of the dose-response curve and potentiating effects when combined with doses of its descending part. This has been considered additional confirmation of the concept that depletion of any kind of spermatogonia is sufficient to modify the genetic response of stem cells. However, the subadditive and additive responses found could be considered evidence that common biological mechanisms can modulate the response to combined treatments of chemicals and ionizing radiations.     

Hypersensitivity to very-low single radiation doses: Its relationship to the adaptive response and induced radioresistance

There is now little doubt of the existence of radioprotective mechanisms, or stress responses, that are upregulated in response to exposure to small doses of ionizing radiation and other DNA-damaging agents. Phenomenologically, there are two ways in which these induced mechanisms operate. First, a small conditioning dose (generally below 30 cGy) may protect against a subsequent, separate, exposure to radiation that may be substantially larger than the initial dose. This has been termed the adaptive response. Second, the response to single doses may itself be dose-dependent so that small acute radiation exposures, or exposures at very low dose rates, are more effective per unit dose than larger exposures above the threshold where the induced radioprotection is triggered. This combination has been termed low-dose hypersensitivity (HRS) and induced radioresistance (IRR) as the dose increases. Both the adaptive response and HRS/IRR have been well documented in studies with yeast, bacteria, protozoa, algae, higher plant cells, insect cells, mammalian and human cells in vitro, and in studies on animal models in vivo. There is indirect evidence that the HRS/IRR phenomenon in response to single doses is a manifestation of the same underlying mechanism that determines the adaptive response in the two-dose case and that it can be triggered by high and low LET radiations as well as a variety of other stress-inducing agents such as hydrogen peroxide and chemotherapeutic agents although exact homology remains to be tested. Little is currently known about the precise nature of this underlying mechanism, but there is evidence that it operates by increasing the amount and rate of DNA repair, rather than by indirect mechanisms such as modulation of cell-cycle progression or apoptosis. Changed expression of some genes, only in response to low and not high doses, may occur within a few hours of irradiation and this would be rapid enough to explain the phenomenon of induced radioresistance although its specific molecular components have yet to be identified.     

Reduced methylation-induced mutagenesis in rat splenocytes in vivo by sub-chronic low dose exposure to N-metyl-N-nitrosourea

Estimates of genotoxic effects of mutagens at low and protracted doses are often based on linear extrapolation of data obtained at relatively high doses. To test the validity of such an approach, a comparison was made between the mutagenicity of N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU) in T-lymphocytes of the rat following two treatment protocols, i.e. sub-chronic exposure to a low dose (15–45 repeated exposures to 1 mg/kg of MNU) or acute exposure to a single high dose (15, 30 or 45 mg/kg of MNU). Mutation induction appeared dramatically lower following sub-chronic treatment compared to treatment with a single high exposure. Furthermore, DNA sequence analysis of the coding region of the hprt gene in MNU-induced mutants showed that acute high dose treatment causes mainly GC → AT base pair changes, whereas sub-chronic treatment results in a significant contribution of AT base pair changes to mutation induction. We hypothesize that O⁶-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase is saturated after acute treatments, while after sub-chronic treatment most O⁶-methylguanine is efficiently repaired. These data suggest (i) that risk estimations at low and protracted doses of MNU on the basis of linear extrapolation of effects measured at high dose are too high and (ii) that the protective effects of DNA repair processes are relatively strong at low sub-chronic exposure.     

Radiation-induced bystander effects and adaptive responses--the Yin and Yang of low dose radiobiology?

Our current knowledge of the mechanisms underlying the induction of bystander effects by low doses of high or low LET ionizing radiation is reviewed. The question of what actually constitutes a protective effect is discussed in the context of adaptive (often referred to as hormetic or protective) responses. Finally the review considers critically, how bystander effects may be related to observed adaptive responses or other seemingly protective effects of low doses exposures. Bystander effects induce responses at the tissue level, which are similar to generalized stress responses. Most of the work involving low LET radiation exposure discussed in the existing literature measures a death response. Since many cell populations carry damaged cells without being exposed to radiation (so-called "background damage"), it is possible that low doses exposures cause removal of cells carrying potentially problematic lesions, prior to exposure to radiation. This mechanism could lead to the production of "U-shaped" or hormetic dose-response curves. The level of adverse, adaptive or apparently beneficial response will be related to the background damage carried by the original cell population, the level of organization at which damage or harm are scored and the precise definition of "harm". This model may be important when attempting to predict the consequences of mixed exposures involving low doses of radiation and other environmental stressors.     

Effects of continuous low dose-rate irradiation: computer simulations

The effects of continuous low dose-rate irradiation are studied with a computer model that incorporates cell kinetics and the accumulation and repair of radiation damage. This theoretical approach independently explores the effects on survival curves of a phase block, inherited damage and proliferation by dying cells. The computer model is a Monte Carlo simulation which follows the evolution in time of the family trees of a growing cell population under continuous irradiation. The model uses as input the measured phase-specific survival curves for acute exposures and the cell kinetic parameters to generate survival curves for continuous low dose-rate irradiations. Cell survival curves for Chinese hamster lung cells (V79) for dose rates ranging from 15 to 500 cGy/h have been generated using various model assumptions. The model shows that for these cells a G2 block will maximize cell killing for an optimum dose rate near 75 cGy/h. The effect on survival curves of inherited damage, as well as that of the proliferation by dying cells, is shown to increase monotonically with decreasing dose rates, and to be quite large at low dose rates.     

Response of primary human fibroblasts exposed to solar particle event protons

Solar particle events (SPEs) present a major radiation-related risk for manned exploratory missions in deep space. Within a short period the astronauts may absorb doses that engender acute effects, in addition to the risk of late effects, such as the induction of cancer. Using primary human cells, we studied clonogenic survival and the induction of neoplastic transformation after exposure to a worst case scenario SPE. We simulated such an SPE with monoenergetic protons (50, 100, 1000 MeV) delivered at a dose rate of 1.65 cGy min?1 in a dose range from 0 to 3 Gy. For comparison, we exposed the cells to a high dose rate of 33.3 cGy min?1. X rays (100 kVp, 8 mA, 1.7 mm Al filter) were used as a reference radiation. Overall, we observed a significant sparing effect of the SPE dose rate on cell survival. High-dose-rate protons were also more efficient in induction of transformation in the dose range below 30 cGy. However, as dose accumulated at high dose rate, the transformation levels declined, while at the SPE dose rate, the number of transformants continued to increase up to about 1 Gy. These findings suggest that considering dose-rate effects may be important in evaluating the biological effects of exposure to space radiation. Our analyses of the data based on particle fluence showed that lethality and transforming potential per particle clearly increased with increasing linear energy transfer (LET) and thus with the decreasing energy of protons. Further, we found that the biological response was determined not only by LET but also type of radiation, e.g. particles and photons. This suggests that using γ or X rays may not be ideal for assessing risk associated with SPE exposures.     

Effects of Continuous Low Dose-Rate Irradiation: Computer Simulations

Abstract. The effects of continuous low dose-rate irradiation are studied with a computer model that incorporates cell kinetics and the accumulation and repair of radiation damage. This theoretical approach independently explores the effects on survival curves of a phase block, inherited damage and proliferation by dying cells. the computer model is a Monte Carlo simulation which follows the evolution in time of the family trees of a growing cell population under continuous irradiation. the model uses as input the measured phase-specific survival curves for acute exposures and the cell kinetic parameters to generate survival curves for continous low dose-rate irradiations. Cell survival curves for Chinese hamster lung cells (V79) for dose rates ranging from 15 to 500 cGy/h have been generated using various model assumptions. the model shows that for these cells a G₂ block will maximize cell killing for an optimum dose rate near 75 cGy/h. the effect on survival curves of inherited damage, as well as that of the proliferation by dying cells, is shown to increase monotonically with decreasing dose rates, and to be quite large at low dose rates.     

Differential responses of stress genes to low dose-rate gamma irradiation

In the past, most mechanistic studies of ionizing radiation response have employed very large doses, then extrapolated the results down to doses relevant to human exposure. It is becoming increasingly apparent, however, that this does not give an accurate or complete picture of the effects of most environmental exposures, which tend to be of low dose and protracted over time. We have initiated direct studies of low dose exposures, and using the relatively responsive ML-1 cell line, have shown that changes in gene expression can be triggered by doses of gamma-rays of 10 cGy and less in human cells. We have now extended these studies to investigate the effects on gene induction of reducing the rate of irradiation. In the ML-1 human myeloid leukemia cell line, we have found that reducing the dose rate over three orders of magnitude results in some protection against the induction of apoptosis, but still causes linear induction of the p53-regulated genes CDKN1A, GADD45A, and MDM2 between 2 and 50 cGy. Reducing the rate of exposure reduces the magnitude of induction of CDKN1A and GADD45A, but not the magnitude or duration of cell cycle delay. In contrast, MDM2 is induced to the same extent regardless of the rate of dose delivery. Microarray analysis has identified additional low dose-rate-inducible genes, and indicates the existence of two general classes of low dose-rate responders in ML-1. One group of genes is induced in a dose rate-dependent fashion, similar to GADD45A and CDKN1A. Functional annotation of this gene cluster indicates a preponderance of genes with known roles in apoptosis regulation. Similarly, a group of genes with dose rate-independent induction, such as seen for MDM2, was also identified. The majority of genes in this group are involved in cell cycle regulation. This apparent differential regulation of stress signaling pathways and outcomes in response to protracted radiation exposure has implications for carcinogenesis and risk assessment, and could not have been predicted from classical high dose studies.     

Nonmonotonous Changes in Metabolic Parameters of Tissues and Cells under Action of Ionizing Radiation on Animal

A nonmonotonous relationship between changes of metabolic parameters of tissues and cells of animal and radiation dose were discussed. Under acute irradiation of animals the nonmonotonous dose-response curve for metabolic parameters of tissues and cells were found. The nonmonotonous dose-response curves of metabolic and functional tissues and cells parameters were also revealed upon chronic irradiation of animals at a low dose-rate. The nonmonotonous shape of dose-response curves may be explained on the basis of nonmonotonous kind of the time-course of metabolic response after irradiation. Living cells were supposed to possess a fundamental property in response to action of different stress agents by nonmonotonous changes of cell metabolism. This response was damping in time oscillation of the value of metabolic parameters around the normal level. Amplitudes and periods of oscillations in these changes of metabolic parameters could be observed. In case of chronic irradiation at a low dose-rate the metabolic and functional parameters showed some modified oscillation during irradiation. The nonmonotonous type of changes in metabolic and functional parameters of tissue and cell by chronic low dose-rate irradiation threw some new light on the peculiarities of biological effects of chronic irradiation.     

Variability of the adaptive response to ionizing radiations in humans

Human lymphocytes exposed to low doses of ionizing radiations from incorporated tritiated thymidine ([3H]dThd) or from X-rays become less susceptible to the induction of chromatid aberrations by high doses of X-rays. This indicates that low doses of ionizing radiation can produce an effect similar to the adaptive response observed with alkylating agents in prokaryotes, animal and plant cells. To determine whether there is individual variability in the adaptive response to ionizing radiations we exposed human lymphocytes from 18 different healthy donors to 'adapting' doses of [3H]dThd (0.01 microCi/ml) or X-rays (0.01 Gy) and subsequently to a 'challenge' treatment of 0.75 Gy of X-rays delivered 2 h before fixation. Four of the 18 donors did not show an adaptive response; in some cases in these individuals a synergistic response of increased, rather than decreased, damage was found. Two of these 4 donors showed no adaptive response in 3 subsequent experiments separated by 4-month intervals. This suggests that the human population exhibits a heterogeneity in the adaptive response to ionizing radiations which might be, at least in part, genetically determined.     

The relative frequency of induced mutations recovered from Drosophila melanogaster gametogenic stages irradiated at different dose rates

Inseminated Drosophila females were exposed to radiation doses of approx. 2000 or 4000 R at dose rates ranging from 8 to 240 000 R/h. The observed frequencies of sex-linked lethal mutations induced in spermatozoa and oogonia suggest that dose-rate effects were absent in spermatozoa over the whole range and in oogonia up to 3000 R/h. There was a consistent increase in oogonial mutation frequency from 3000 to 240 000 R/h. These results are discussed in relation to the well-established dose-rate effects observed in the mouse.     

Differential modulation of specific gene expression following high- and low-LET radiations

Experiments were designed to examine the effects of radiation quality on specific gene expression within the first 3 h following radiation exposure in Syrian hamster embryo (SHE) cells. Preliminary work demonstrated the induction of c-fos and alpha-interferon genes following exposure to low-linear-energy-transfer (low-LET) radiations (X rays or gamma rays). More detailed experiments revealed induction of c-fos mRNA within the first 3 h following exposure to either X rays (75 cGy) or gamma rays (90 cGy). We could not detect induction of c-fos following exposure of SHE cells to fission-spectrum neutrons (high-LET) from the JANUS reactor administered at either high (12 cGy/min) or low (0.5 cGy/min) dose rates. Expression of alpha-interferon mRNA was similarly induced by low-LET radiations but only modestly by JANUS neutrons. The induction by gamma rays was dose-dependent, while induction by neutrons was specific for low doses and low dose rates. These experiments demonstrate the differential gene inductive response of cells following exposure to high- and low-LET radiations. These experiments suggest that these different qualities of ionizing radiation may have different mechanisms for inducing many of the cellular consequences of radiation exposure, such as cell survival and cell transformation.     

Effects of acute low doses of Gamma-radiation on erythrocytes membrane

It is believed that any dose of ionizing radiation may damage cells and that the mutated cells could develop into cancer cells. Additionally, results of research performed over the past century on the effects of low doses of ionizing radiation on biological organisms show beneficial health effects, called hormesis. Much less is known about the cellular response to low doses of ionizing radiation, such as those typical for medical diagnostic procedures, normal occupational exposures or cosmic-ray exposures at flight altitudes. Extrapolating from the effects observed at higher doses to predict changes in cells after low-dose exposure is problematic. We examined the biological effects of low doses (0.01–0.3 Gy) of γ-radiation on the membrane characteristics of erythrocytes of albino rats and carried out osmotic fragility tests and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR). Our results indicate that the lowest three doses in the investigated radiation range, i.e., 0.01, 0.025 and 0.05 Gy, resulted in positive effects on the erythrocyte membranes, while a dose of 0.1 Gy appeared to represent the limiting threshold dose of those positive effects. Doses higher than 0.1 Gy were associated with the denaturation of erythrocyte proteins.     

Interrelationships amongst radiation-induced genomic instability, bystander effects, and the adaptive response

Over the past two decades, our understanding of radiation biology has undergone a fundamental shift in paradigms away from deterministic "hit-effect" relationships and towards complex ongoing "cellular responses". These responses include now familiar, but still poorly understood, phenomena associated with radiation exposure such as bystander effects, genomic instability, and adaptive responses. All three have been observed at very low doses, and at time points far removed from the initial radiation exposure, and are extremely relevant for linear extrapolation to low doses; the adaptive response is particularly relevant when exposure is spread over a period of time. These are precisely the circumstances that are most relevant to understanding cancer risk associated with environmental and occupational radiation exposures. This review will provide a synthesis of the known, and proposed, interrelationships amongst low-dose cellular responses to radiation. It also will examine the potential importance of non-targeted cellular responses to ionizing radiation in setting acceptable exposure limits especially to low-LET radiations.