pH-Dependent membrane interactions of diphtheria toxin: A genetic approach

A genetic approach is described for exploring the mechanism by which diphtheria toxin undergoes pH-dependent membrane insertion and transfer of its enzymic A fragment into the cytoplasm of mammalian cells. The cloned toxin expressed inEscherichia coli is secreted to the periplasmic space, where it is processed normally and folds into a native structure. When bacteria synthesizing the toxin are exposed to pH 5, they die rapidly. The toxin undergoes a conformational change that is believed to allow it to be inserted into the bacterial inner membrane and form channels, which proves lethal for the cell. The membrane insertion event mimics the process by which the toxin inserts into the endosomal membrane of mammalian cells, leading to release of the enzymic A fragment into the cytoplasm. The observation of pH-dependent bacterial lethality provides the basis for a positive genetic selection method for mutant forms of the toxin that are altered in ability to undergo membrane insertion or pore formation.     

Characterization of a full-length, active-site mutant of diphtheria toxin.

A full-length recombinant mutant of diphtheria toxin containing serine in place of a crucial active-site glutamate has been purified and characterized. The serine substitution caused a minor structural alteration in the toxin as measured by trypsinolysis. ADP-ribosyltransferase activity and cytotoxicity of the mutant were both decreased by approximately 500-fold. A similar reduction in cytotoxicity was found when the enzymic fragments of both the wild-type and mutant toxins were introduced into the cytosol of fibroblasts by osmotically lysing pinosomes. The mutation did not alter the binding of the toxin to cell surface receptors and had no apparent effect on membrane translocation. The results suggest that the decreased cytotoxicity of the mutant is solely due to the reduced ADP-ribosyltransferase activity.     

The rotational diffusion of the acetylcholine receptor in Torpeda marmorata membrane fragments studied with a spin-labelled alpha-toxin: importance of the 43 000 protein(s)

The rotational diffusion of the acetylcholine (ACh) receptor in subsynaptic membrane fragments from Torpedo marmorata electric organ was investigated with a spin-labelled alpha-bungarotoxin. A toxin with two spin labels was first synthesized; the conventional electron spin resonance spectrum (e.s.r.) of this toxin bound to the receptor indicated: (1) a complete immobilization of the probes; and (2) a strong spin-spin interaction that was not, or barely, seen in solution. The modification of the degree of spin-spin interaction is taken as an indication of a toxin conformational change accompanying its binding to the ACh-receptor. To avoid spin-spin interaction a single-labelled toxin was made and used to follow the rotational diffusion of the receptor by saturation transfer e.s.r. (ST-e.s.r.). With native membranes a high immobilization of the ACh-receptor was noticed. Reduction of the membranes by dithiothreitol had little effect on this motion. Only extraction of the 43 000 protein(s) by pH 11 treatment was able to enhance the rotational diffusion of the ACh-receptor protein (rotational correlation time by ST-e.s.r. in the 0.5 - 1 X 10(-4) s range) and to allow its lateral diffusion in the plane of the membrane fragments (observed by electron microscopy after freeze-etching or negative staining).     

Interaction of diphtheria toxin fragments A, B and protein crm 45 with liposomes

Diphtheria toxin, its fragments A, B and the protein serologically related to toxin, crm 45, have been studied for their hydrophobicity using the method of charge shift electrophoresis. These molecules were then assayed for liposome interaction. The results have shown that the diphtheria toxin B fragment behaves as an amphiphatic protein because it contains a hydrophobic domain located in that portion of the B chain which remains in protein crm 45. Toxin fragment A is hydrophilic. Incubation of protein crm 45 or toxin fragment B with preformed liposomes leads to association of these proteins with lipid vesicles. Fragment A does not interact with liposomes. Binding of protein crm 45 with lipid vesicles is dependent on time and temperature. Protein crm 45 is unidirectionally associated with liposomes, its enzymic fragment A directed outside the liposome. Fragment B or protein crm 45, upon binding with liposomes, does not affect the permeability of the vesicles.     

Reevaluation of the Role of Gangliosides as Receptors for Tetanus Toxin

Binding of tetanus toxin to rat brain membranes was of lower affinity and capacity when binding was determined in 150 mM NaCl, 50 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.4) than in 25 mM Tris-acetate (pH 6.0). Binding under both conditions was reduced by treating the membranes with neuraminidase. Pronase treatment, however, reduced toxin binding only in the Tris-saline buffer (pH 7.4). In addition, the concentration of gangliosides required to inhibit toxin binding was 100-fold higher in Tris-saline compared to Tris-acetate buffer. The toxin receptors in the membranes were analyzed by ligand blotting techniques. Membrane components were dissolved in sodium dodecyl sulfate, separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, and transferred to nitrocellulose sheets, which were overlaid with 125I-labeled toxin. Tetanus toxin bound only to material that migrated in the region of the dye front and was extracted with lipid solvents. Gangliosides isolated from the lipid extracts or other sources were separated by TLC on silica gel and the chromatograms were overlaid with labeled tetanus toxin. The toxin bound to areas where the major rat brain gangliosides migrated. When equimolar amounts of different purified gangliosides were applied to the chromatogram, binding of the toxin was in the order GD1b approximately equal to GT1b approximately equal to GQ1b greater than GD2 greater than GD3 much greater than GD1a approximately equal to GM1. Thus, the toxin appears to have the highest affinity for gangliosides with a disialyl group linked to the inner galactosyl residue. When binding of tetanus toxin to transfers and chromatograms was determined in the Tris-saline buffer (pH 7.4), the toxin bound to the same components but the extent of binding was markedly reduced compared with the low-salt and -pH conditions. Our results indicate that the interaction of tetanus toxin with rat brain membranes and gangliosides is greatly reduced under more physiological conditions of salt and pH and raise the possibility that other membrane components such as sialoglycoproteins may be receptors for the toxin under these conditions.     

Entry of diphtheria toxin-protein A chimeras into cells

Fusion proteins consisting of diphtheria toxin and a duplicated Fc-binding domain of protein A were made in vitro after amplification of the DNA template by the polymerase chain reaction. The fusion proteins bound avidly to Vero cells coated with antibodies. A fusion protein containing full-length diphtheria toxin was toxic at lower concentrations than diphtheria toxin alone, apparently due to more efficient binding. The enzymatic part of the fusion protein was translocated across the surface membrane upon exposure to low pH. Like authentic diphtheria toxin, the fusion protein formed cation selective channels at low pH. Excess amounts of unlabeled diphtheria toxin inhibited formation of pronase-protected fragments derived from radiolabeled fusion protein. Furthermore, conditions that down-regulate the diphtheria toxin receptors reduced the sensitivity of the cells to the fusion protein, supporting the notion that authentic diphtheria toxin receptors are required. At temperatures below 18 degrees C the toxicity of the fusion protein was strongly reduced, whereas there was no temperature block for authentic diphtheria toxin. Brefeldin A protected Vero cells against the fusion protein but not against diphtheria toxin. The results indicate that the diphtheria toxin receptor is required for efficient toxin translocation even under conditions where the toxin is bound by an alternate binding moiety, and they suggest that the intracellular routing of the fusion protein is different from that of diphtheria toxin.     

On the role of polysialoglycosphingolipids as tetanus toxin receptors. A study with lipid monolayers

Lipid monolayers of different compositions were used to study the interaction of tetanus toxin with membrane lipids and to evaluate the role of polysialoglycosphingolipids as membrane receptors. At neutral pH, the toxin binds to dioleoylglycerophosphocholine monolayers and inserts into the phospholipid layer. This effect is potentiated by acidic phospholipids without an apparent preference for a single class of phospholipids. Polysialoglycosphingolipids further increase the fixation and penetration of tetanus toxin in lipid monolayers, but no specific requirement for a particular ganglioside was identified. The ganglioside effect is abolished in the presence of other nervous tissue lipids: cerebrosides and glycosphingolipid sulfates are partially responsible for this effect. The penetration of tetanus toxin in the lipid monolayer is pH dependent. It increases with lowering pH, it is facilitated by acidic phospholipids and by glycosphingolipid sulfates and it is mediated both by hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions as deduced from an analysis of the effect of ionic strength. Fragment B of tetanus toxin the low-pH-driven lipid interaction of the toxin. On the basis of the present findings, the possible role of polysialoglycosphingolipids in the neurospecific binding of tetanus toxin is discussed.     

Lipid interaction of tetanus neurotoxin. A calorimetric and fluorescence spectroscopy study.

The interaction of Tetanus toxin with phospholipid vesicles containing gangliosides (GD1a, GD1b or GT1b) or phosphatidic acid has been investigated at neutral or acidic pH. Change in the thermotropic properties of the vesicles occurred only after addition of the toxin at acidic pH, and led to surface binding or membrane insertion of the protein, dependent on the physical state of the membrane. Most remarkably, toxin addition at acidic pH to dipalmitoyl-phosphatidylcholine vesicles containing GT1b ganglioside, caused formation of ganglioside microdomains on the vesicle surface.     

Diphtheria toxin at low pH depolarizes the membrane, increases the membrane conductance and induces a new type of ion channel in Vero cells.

Receptor-dependent translocation of diphtheria toxin across the surface membrane of Vero cells was studied using patch clamp techniques. Translocation was induced by exposing cells with surface-bound toxin to low pH. Whole cell current and voltage clamp recordings showed that toxin translocation was associated with membrane depolarization and increased membrane conductance. The conductance increase was voltage independent, with a reversal potential of approximately 15 mV. This value was unaffected by changing the Cl- gradient across the membrane and microfluorometric measurements showed that the cytosolic Ca2+ concentration was only marginally elevated by the translocation. The conductance increase is thus mainly due to monovalent cations. Exposing outside-out and cell-attached patches with bound toxin to low pH induced a new type of ion channel in the membrane. The channel current was inward at negative membrane potentials and the single channel conductance was approximately 30 pS. This value is about three times larger than for receptor-independent channels induced by diphtheria toxin or toxin fragments in artificial lipid membranes.     

Interaction of diphtheria toxin with model membranes

Low pH is believed to trigger membrane penetration by diphtheria toxin in vivo. The effect of pH upon the binding of the toxin to unilamellar model membrane vesicles was determined by using a fluorescence quenching assay. A series of studies were undertaken to determine the effect of lipid composition upon the binding of lipids to the toxin. The binding of toxin to various small unilamellar vesicles of zwitterionic or anionic lipids was similar in extent and was accompanied by deep penetration of the toxin into the fatty acyl chains, in agreement with previous studies. However, the transition pH, which is the pH at and below which toxin binding becomes significant, depended upon the fraction of anionic lipids, being highest with model membranes composed totally of anionic lipids (pH 5.8) and lowest with membranes composed of zwitterionic lipids (pH 5.2). Except for vesicle charge, the transition pH was independent of the nature of the lipid polar groups used. High ionic strength, which had no effect on the transition pH with zwitterionic vesicles, was found to shift the transition pH with totally anionic vesicles to pH 5.2. This suggests that both direct protein-lipid electrostatic interactions and the ionic double layer, which gives rise to a low local pH around anionic vesicles, contribute to the shift in the transition pH. The effect of lipid composition upon the kinetics and strength of binding was also examined. At low pH, binding was rapid and tight. Binding to vesicles containing 20 wt % anionic phosphatidylglycerol was faster and tighter than binding to vesicles of zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Lipid interaction of diphtheria toxin and mutants with altered fragment B. 1. Liposome aggregation and fusion

The interaction of diphtheria toxin and its cross-reacting mutants crm 45,228 and 1001 with small unilamellar vesicles has been followed by a turbidity assay, electron microscopy, fluorescence energy transfer and membrane permeability. All toxins at pH lower than 6 induce the aggregation and fusion of liposomes containing negatively charged phospholipids; crm 45 and crm 1001 are less potent than diphtheria toxin. Isolated diphtheria toxin fragment B is very effective while isolated fragment A is ineffective. Liposome fusion induced by the toxins at low pH occurs without release of the internal content implying that fusion does not involve vesicle breakage and resealing. The pH dependence of the membrane interaction of diphtheria toxin monitored by turbidity is in close agreement with that monitored by fluorescence energy transfer. It shows that diphtheria toxin can alter the lipid bilayer structure in the pH interval 5-6. This pH range occurs in endosomes and suggests that histidyl and carboxyl residues are likely to be involved in the conformational change of diphtheria toxin triggered by acidic pH.     

Domain III of Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1Ie Toxin Plays an Important Role in Binding to Peritrophic Membrane of Asian Corn Borer

The insecticidal IE648 toxin is a truncated Cry1Ie protein with increased toxicity against Asian corn borer (ACB). Cry toxins are pore-forming toxins that disrupt insect midgut cells to kill the larvae. However, the peritrophic membrane (PM) is an important barrier that Cry toxins must cross before binding to midgut cells. Previously, it was shown that Cry toxins are able to bind and accumulate in the PM of several lepidopteran insects. Binding of IE648 toxin to PM of ACB was previously reported and the goal of the current work was the identification of the binding region between Cry1Ie and the PM of ACB. Homologous competition binding assays showed that this interaction was specific. Heterologous competition binding assays performed with different fragments corresponding to domain I, domain II and domain III allowed us to identify that domain III participates in the interaction of IE648 with the PM. Specifically, peptide D3-L8 (corresponding to Cry1Ie toxin residues 607 to 616), located in an exposed loop region of domain III is probably involved in this interaction. Ligand blot assays show that IE648 interact with chitin and PM proteins with sizes of 30, 32 and 80 kDa. The fact that domain III interacts with proteins of similar molecular masses supports that this region of the toxin might be involved in PM interaction. These data provide for the first time the identification of domain III as a putative binding region between PM and 3D-Cry toxin.     

Energetics of diphtheria toxin membrane insertion and translocation: calorimetric characterization of the acid pH induced transition

The pH and temperature stabilities of diphtheria toxin and its fragments have been studied by high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry. These studies demonstrate that the pH-induced conformational transition associated with the mechanism of membrane insertion and translocation of the toxin involves a massive unfolding of the toxin molecule. At physiological temperatures (37 degrees C), this process is centered at pH 4.7 at low ionic strength and at pH 5.4 in the presence of 0.2 M NaCl. At pH 8, the thermal unfolding of the nucleotide-bound toxin is centered at 58.2 degrees C whereas that of the nucleotide-free toxin is centered at 51.8 degrees C, indicating that nucleotide binding (ApUp) stabilizes the native conformation of the toxin. The unfolding profile of the toxin is consistent with two transitions most likely corresponding to the A fragment (Tm = 54.5 degrees C) and the B fragment (Tm = 58.4 degrees C), as inferred from experiments using the isolated A fragment. These two transitions are not independent, judging from the fact that the isolated A fragment unfolds at much lower temperatures (Tm = 44.2 degrees C) and that the B fragment is insoluble in aqueous solutions when separated from the A fragment. Interfragment association contributes an extra -2.6 kcal/mol to the free energy of stabilization of the A fragment. Whereas the unfolding of the entire toxin is irreversible, the unfolding of the A fragment is a reversible process. These findings provide a thermodynamic basis for the refolding of the A fragment after reexposure to neutral pH immediately following translocation across the lysosomal membrane.     

Biological Activity of Heated Diphtheria Toxin

Diphtheria toxin splits into two fragments when heated at 100 C for 10 min in a phosphate buffer. The separated fragments have molecular weights of 24,000 and 39,000, respectively. These molecular weights are similar to those of the A and B fragments found in diphtheria toxin preparations after thiol reduction. Since the separation of toxin into fragments is not complete, it is likely that only nicked toxin molecules having a cleaved peptide bond are split by heating. When toxin is suspended in phosphate buffer at pH 6.4, the B-like fragment precipitates, but at pH 7.8 it does not. Heated toxin is unable to intoxicate sensitive cells or cause a necrodermal response in animals. Fragment A produced by heating is active in inhibiting cell-free protein synthesis. It is able to intoxicate both HeLa and L cells when the uptake of the fragment is facilitated by addition of polyornithine to the cultures. Fragment B produced by heating is involved with binding to the cell surface. It is able to delay the action of toxin on KB cell cultures preincubated with fragment B.     

Lipid interaction of diphtheria toxin and mutants with altered fragment B. 2. Hydrophobic photolabelling and cell intoxication

The membrane insertion of diphtheria toxin and of its B chain mutants crm 45, crm 228 and crm 1001 has been followed by hydrophobic photolabelling with photoactivatable phosphatidylcholine analogues. It was found that diphtheria toxin binds to the lipid bilayer surface at neutral pH while at low pH both its A and B chains also interact with the hydrocarbon chains of phospholipids. The pH dependence of photolabelling of the two protomers is different: the pKa of fragment B is around 5.9 while that of fragment A is around 5.2. The latter value correlates with the pH of half-maximal intoxication of cells incubated with the toxin in acidic mediums. These results suggest that fragment B penetrates into the bilayer first and assists the insertion of fragment A and that the lipid insertion of fragment B is not the rate-controlling step in the process of membrane translocation of diphtheria toxin. crm 45 behaves as diphtheria toxin in the photolabelling assay but, nonetheless, it is found to be three orders of magnitude less toxic than diphtheria toxin on acid-treated cells, suggesting that the 12-kDa COOH-terminal segment of diphtheria toxin is important not only for its binding to the cell receptor but also for the membrane translocation of the toxin. It is suggested that crm 1001 is non-toxic because of a defect in its membrane translocation which occurs at a lower extent and at a lower pH than that of the native toxin; as a consequence crm 1001 may be unable to escape from the endosome lumen into the cytoplasm before the fusion of the endosome with lysosomes.     

The acid-triggered entry pathway of Pseudomonas exotoxin A

In this study we examined the pH requirements and reversibility of early events in the Pseudomonas toxin entry pathway, namely, membrane binding, insertion, and translocation. At pH 7.4, toxin binding to vesicles and insertion into the bilayer are very inefficient. Decreasing the pH greatly increases the efficiencies of these processes. Acid-treated toxin exhibits pH 7.4 binding and insertion levels. This indicates that hydrophobic regions that become exposed upon toxin acidficiation become buried again when the pH is raised to 7.4. In contrast, the change in toxin conformation that occurs upon membrane binding is irreversible. Returning samples to pH 7.4, incubation with excess toxin, or dilution with buffer up to 1000-fold leads to very little loss of bound toxin. Bound toxin exhibits an extremely high susceptibility to trypsin compared to free toxin (at both pH 4 and pH 7.4). At pH 4, membrane-associated toxin slowly proceeds to a trypsin-protected state; neutralization halts this process. At low pH, toxin was found to bind and insert into DMPC vesicles very efficiently at temperatures both above and below 23 degrees C, the lipid melting point. With fluid targets, the proportion of bound toxin that was photolabeled from within the bilayer peaked rapidly and then decreased with time. With frozen targets, the efficiency of photolabeling peaked but then remained fairly constant.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Transport of diphtheria toxin fragment A across mammalian cell membranes.

The role of the hydrophobic region of diphtheria toxin B moiety in fragment A membrane traversal has been studied using crm45. This molecule, a serologically related diphtheria toxin protein, contains a normal enzymic fragment A and the hydrophobic domain of the toxin B chain but lacks a C-terminal polypeptide needed for specific cell binding. Relatively high concentrations of crm45 are required to inhibit protein synthesis in cells however, after the loss of its hydrophobic region crm45, which still contains an active fragment A, becomes almost non-toxic. It seems thus that the non-polar peptide found in crm45 or toxin facilitates the transport of the hydrophilic fragment A across the plasma membrane.     

Membrane Interaction of botulinum neurotoxin A translocation (T) domain. The belt region is a regulatory loop for membrane interaction

The translocation of the catalytic domain through the membrane of the endosome to the cell cytoplasm is a key step of intoxication by botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT). This step is mediated by the translocation (T) domain upon endosome acidification, although the mechanism of interaction of the T domain with the membrane is still poorly understood. Using physicochemical approaches and spectroscopic methods, we studied the interaction of the BoNT/A T domain with the membrane as a function of pH. We found that the interaction with membranes does not involve major secondary or tertiary structural changes, as reported for other toxins like diphtheria toxin. The T domain becomes insoluble around its pI value and then penetrates into the membrane. At that stage, the T domain becomes able to permeabilize lipid vesicles. This occurs for pH values lower than 5.5, in agreement with the pH encountered by the toxin within endosomes. Electrostatic interactions are also important for the process. The role of the so-called belt region was investigated with four variant proteins presenting different lengths of the N-extremity of the T domain. We observed that this part of the T domain, which contains numerous negatively charged residues, limits the protein-membrane interaction. Indeed, interaction with the membrane of the protein deleted of this extremity takes place for higher pH values than for the entire T domain. Overall, the data suggest that acidification eliminates repulsive electrostatic interactions between the T domain and the membrane, allowing its penetration into the membrane without triggering detectable structural changes.     

Characterization of Curaremimetic Neurotoxin Binding Sites on Cellular Membrane Fragments Derived from the Rat Pheochromocytoma PC 12

Studies were conducted on the properties of 125I-labeled alpha-bungarotoxin binding sites on cellular membrane fragments derived from the PC12 rat pheochromocytoma. Two classes of specific toxin binding sites are present at approximately equal densities (50 fmol/mg of membrane protein) and are characterized by apparent dissociation constants of 3 and 60 nM. Nicotine and d-tubocurarine are among the most potent inhibitors of high-affinity toxin binding. The affinity of high-affinity toxin binding sites for nicotinic cholinergic agonists is reversibly or irreversibly decreased, respectively, on treatment with dithiothreitol or dithiothreitol and N-ethylmaleimide. The nicotinic receptor affinity reagent bromoacetylcholine irreversibly blocks high-affinity toxin binding to PC12 cell membranes that have been treated with dithiothreitol. Two polyclonal antisera raised against the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor from Electrophorus electricus inhibit high-affinity toxin binding. These detailed studies confirm that curaremimetic neurotoxin binding sites on the PC12 cell line are comparable to toxin binding sites from neural tissues and to nicotinic acetylcholine receptors from the periphery. Because toxin binding sites are recognized by anti-nicotinic receptor antibodies, the possibility remains that they are functionally analogous to nicotinic receptors.     

Lipid and phase specificity of α-toxin from S. aureus

The pore forming toxin Hla (α-toxin) from Staphylococcus aureus is an important pathogenic factor of the bacterium S. aureus and also a model system for the process of membrane-induced protein oligomerisation and pore formation. It has been shown that binding to lipid membranes at neutral or basic pH requires the presence of a phosphocholine-headgroup. Thus, sphingomyelin and phosphatidylcholine may serve as interaction partners in cellular membranes. Based on earlier studies it has been suggested that rafts of sphingomyelin are particularly efficient in toxin binding. In this study we compared the oligomerisation of Hla on liposomes of various lipid compositions in order to identify the preferred interaction partners and conditions. Hla seems to have an intrinsic preference for sphingomyelin compared to phosphatidylcholine due to a higher probability of oligomerisation of membrane bound monomer. We also can show that increasing the surface density of Hla-binding sites enhances the oligomerisation efficiency. Thus, preferential binding to lipid rafts can be expected in the cellular context. On the other hand, sphingomyelin in the liquid disordered phase is a more favourable binding partner for Hla than sphingomyelin in the liquid ordered phase, which makes the membrane outside of lipid rafts the more preferred region of interaction. Thus, the partitioning of Hla is expected to strongly depend on the exact composition of raft and non-raft domains in the membrane.