Kinetics of Cruciform Formation and Stability of Cruciform Structure in Superhelical DNA

Abstract

This is a study of the kinetics of formation of a cruciform structure from the longest palindromic sequence in plasmid pA03 DNA. DNA was prepared so as to be free of cruciforms even in topoisomers whose negative superhelicity was great enough to induce cruciform formation. Samples of such DNA were incubated at various temperatures, the incubation time varying over a wide range. Then the state was frozen by chilling. Two-dimensional electrophoretic analysis made it possible to estimate the fraction of molecules that got the cruciform structure during incubation. Precautions were taken for electrophoresis conditions to rule out any spontaneous conformational changes within the palindromic region. The relaxation time at the midpoint of the transition ranged from 30 min at 30 C to 50 hrs at 20 C, both in 0.1SSC. An increase in the negative superhelical density by 0.01 led to a 500-fold reduction of the relaxation time at 30 C but had little effect at 20 C. The probability of cruciform formation has been examined as a function of temperature. It has been shown that the cruciform state is no longer the predominant one at elevated temperatures: the cruciformation probability drops to an insignificant value for all of the topoisomers involved. Data have been obtained suggesting that the cruciform formation at the major palindromic site is not the only structural transition possible in pA03 DNA.     

Formation of cruciform structures in pAO3 plasmid DNA on increasing superhelical density

The dependence of the crusiciform structure formation on superhelical density was studied by means of high resolution gel-electrophoresis. A short pAO3 DNA plasmid (1683 b. p.) which is a quarter of the ColE1 DNA plasmid and contains the main palindrome of ColE1 DNA was used. The excellent resolution of all topoisomers of pAO3 DNA in gel-electrophoresis made it possible to observe a sharp abruption in the pattern of pAO3 DNA topoisomers separation. The two-dimensional gel-electrophoresis data showed that observed abruption is caused by a sharp decrease of writhing in the molecules with superhelical density--sigma approximately equal to 0,05. An analysis of S1-nuclease digestion products of DNA with different superhelical density was accomplished and these data showed that a sharp structural transition in supercoiled DNA pAO3 is caused by formation of a cruciform structure in the main palindrome.     

The absence of cruciform structures from pAO3 plasmid DNA in vivo

We extracted pAO3 plasmid DNA from E. coli cells, having "frozen" the transition between cruciform and double-helical conformations in DNA. The characteristic feature of the DNA isolation procedure is that all steps were carried out at temperature between 0 and 4 C and no phenol deproteinization was used, since it has been discovered that phenol destabilizes cruciform structures in pAO3 DNA. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis has revealed no cruciform structures in the pAO3 DNA preparations obtained this way, although the superhelical density of DNA was sufficient for them. Cruciform structures are absent from intracellular pAO3 DNA at all growth stages of the bacterial culture: stationary and logarithmic, and under the induction of pAO3 DNA replication in chloramphenicol-treated cells.     

The relaxation time for a cruciform structure in superhelical DNA

We have calculated the relaxation time of a cruciform structure in superhelical DNA as a function of the superhelix density for palindromic regions of different lengths. The relaxation time has a sharp maximum at the superhelix density which corresponds to the equilibrium transition point between the cruciform structure and the regular double helix. This maximal value is shown to depend dramatically on the length of the palindromic region.     

Detection of cruciform extrusion in DNA by temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis

Repetitive sequences in DNA molecules, some of which are palindromic, tend to form stable cruciforms. These are frequently located in promoter regions of a specific operon and origin of replication. Temperature gradient gel electrophoresis can be used to distinguish among various supercoiled DNA topoisomers and to ascertain whether or not the cruciform motif has been extruded. In the current study, this technique is implemented for the first time to address the role of temperature in cruciform extrusion from plasmids.     

Influence of DNA sequence and supercoiling on the process of cruciform formation

We have studied some of the effects of DNA sequence and negative superhelicity on the rate of cruciform formation. Replacing the sequence AATT at the center of a perfect 68 base-pair palindromic sequence with the sequence CCCGGG decreases the rate of cruciform formation by a factor of at least 100. The logarithm of the rate constant of cruciform formation was found to increase linearly with linking difference. For the 68 base-pair perfect palindrome in a 4400 base-pair plasmid, each additional negative superhelical turn increased the rate of cruciform formation by a factor of 1.6. These results are consistent with a mechanism in which cruciform formation is initiated by the formation of a single-stranded bubble, 10 base-pairs in length, near the center of the palindromic sequence. In addition, we have examined the effect of introducing an asymmetric insertion into the palindromic sequence.     

Thermodynamics of the ColE1 cruciform. Comparisons between probing and topological experiments using single topoisomers

The sensitivity of the ColE1 cruciform to four enzyme and chemical probes of secondary structure has been studied as a function of plasmid topology. Purified topoisomers of pColIR515 have been probed with S1 nuclease, Bal31 nuclease, phage T4 endonuclease VII or osmium tetroxide, and site-specific reaction quantified. Closely similar profiles of reactivity as a function of linking difference were obtained for each probe. Electrophoresis of the pure topoisomers on polyacrylamide/agarose gels revealed a discontinuity in migration as a function of linking difference. Above a threshold linking difference, topoisomers exhibit pronounced reduction in mobility. The linking difference at which this band shift is found correlates precisely with that required for site-specific reaction with the four probes. We conclude that both probing and topological methods are valuable in the study of cruciform structure in supercoiled DNA. The band shift has been measured with accuracy to allow the calculation of the twist change that accompanies the transition, corresponding to delta Tw = -3.2 +/- 0.1. Using this value together with the critical linking difference we calculate a free energy of formation for this structure delta G = 18.4 +/- 0.5 kcal mol-1 (1 kcal = 4.184 kJ).     

Relationship between superhelical density and cruciform formation in plasmid pVH51

The relative stability of the cruciform state at the large inverted repeat of plasmid pVH51 is measured. At physiological superhelical densities, the cruciform state is present in a high percentage of the plasmid molecules. Investigation of the relationship between negative superhelical density and cruciform prevalence reveals a sharp transition from an undetectable level to a relatively stable state. This transition occurs over the negative superhelical density range of 0.046 to 0.066. Estimates of the free energy contribution to cruciform formation resulting from loss of negative superhelical turns suggest that about 22 kcal/mol are required to generate the cruciform structure at this site in pVH51.     

Interaction of a protein from rat liver nuclei with cruciform DNA.

We constructed a synthetic cruciform DNA which closely resembles Holliday junctions, a DNA structure formed during recombination or following the transition from interstrand to intrastrand base pairing in palindromic DNA sequences. We identified and partially purified a protein from rat liver that specifically binds to this cruciform DNA molecule and does not bind to single-stranded or double-stranded DNAs of the same sequence. This protein also binds to the cruciform structure formed by a 70 bp palindromic sequence cloned in plasmid pUC18. No detectable nucleolytic activity is associated with the rat liver cruciform-binding protein, in contrast to all cruciform-recognizing proteins known so far.     

Flanking AT-rich sequences may lower the activation energy of cruciform extrusion in supercoiled DNA

In the absence of flanking AT-rich segments, cruciform transition energies of DNA palindromic sequences of random base composition are high and mainly dependent upon the base-stacking and -pairing parameters of the palindromic segment. When AT-rich sequences adjoin palindromes, the transition energy of cruciform extrusion is significantly lowered. An inverse relationship exists between the length of the AT-rich stretch and the cruciform transition energy. Long stretches lower the transition energies more than short stretches. At physiological salt and temperature conditions, equilibrium between cruciform extrusion and absorption for the inverted repeat sequences IRS-B and IRS-C of pBR322 derived plasmids is reached in less than five minutes.     

The effect of supercoil and temperature on the recognition of palindromic and non-palindromic regions in phi X174 replicative form DNA by S1 and Bal31

The effect of supercoil and temperature on the topology of phi X174 replicative form (RF) DNA was studied using single-strand specific endonucleases S1 and Bal31 as probes for cruciform extrusion and other structural perturbations of the B-helix. Both enzymes were found to recognize specifically and reproducibly over 30 sites, most of which were cleaved by both enzymes independent of the superhelicity of the genome. A negative superhelical density exceeding 0.06 stabilized a transition in the DNA conformation that generated several new cleavage sites for Bal31. The underlying structures appeared to be only transiently stable and were lost from in vitro supercoiled DNA during brief incubation at 65 degrees C. They were generally absent from in vivo supercoiled RF DNA of equal superhelicity as a consequence of the extraction and storage procedure. Mapping of the cleavage sites suggested that they were preferentially located near the beginnings and ends of genes and that the structural basis for at least some of them was the extrusion of relatively small palindromes into the cruciform state. Insertion of a short synthetic palindromic sequence into the phi X174 genome generated a supercoil-dependent, temperature-sensitive secondary structure that was cleaved in the Bal31 but not the S1 reaction, further supporting the hypothesis that even small cruciforms with stem size of 7 or less base pairs may be transiently stable. Subjecting supercoiled RF DNA to the typical S1 reaction conditions induced a topological shift that diminished all but one of the supercoil-induced Bal31 recognition sites and promoted the formation of one major new site.     

Cruciform extrusion in plasmids bearing the replicative intermediate configuration of a poxvirus telomere

The transition from lineform DNA to cruciform DNA (cruciformation) within the cloned telomere sequences of the Leporipoxvirus Shope fibroma virus (SFV) has been studied. The viral telomere sequences have been cloned in recombination-deficient Escherichia coli as a 322 base-pair, imperfect palindromic insert in pUC13. The inverted repeat configuration is equivalent to the arrangement of the telomere structures observed within viral DNA replicative intermediates. A major cruciform structure in the purified recombinant plasmid has been identified and mapped using, as probes, the enzymes AflII, nuclease S1 and bacteriophage T7 endonuclease I. It was extruded from the central axis of the cloned viral inverted repeat and, by unrestricted branch migration, attained a size commensurate with the superhelical density of the plasmid molecule at native superhelical densities. This major cruciform extrusion event was the only detectable duplex DNA perturbation, induced by negative superhelical torsion, in the insert viral sequences. No significant steady-state pool of extruded cruciform was identified in E. coli. However, the identification of a major deletion variant generated even in the recombination-deficient E. coli strain DB1256 (recA recBC sbcB) suggested that the cruciform may be extruded transiently in vivo. The lineform to cruciform transition has been further characterized in vitro using two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis. The transition was marked by a high energy of formation (delta Gf = 44 kcal/mol), and an apparently low activation energy that enabled facile transitions at physiological temperatures provided there was sufficient torsional energy. By comparing cruciformation in a series of related bidirectional central axis deletions of the telomeric insert, it has been concluded that the presence of extrahelical bases in the terminal hairpin structures contributes substantially to the high delta Gf value. Also, viral sequences flanking the extruded cruciform were shown to influence the measured delta Gf value. Several general features of poxvirus telomere structure that would be expected to influence the facility of cruciform extrusion are discussed along with the implications of the observed cruciform transition event on the replicative process of poxviruses in vivo.     

Theoretical model of the B-Z transition in DNA with an arbitrary sequence

A statistical-mechanical model is suggested that makes it possible to describe the B-Z transition in DNA with an arbitrary sequence of nucleotides. The key point consists in allowance for the fact that each base pair can assume one of the two states with different energies. One of these states corresponds to the standard Z-form with purines in the syn conformation and pyrimidines in the anti conformation. However, in natural DNA sequences such standard base-pair conformations should be interrupted by energetically unfavorable conformations (syn for pyrimidines and anti for purines). Open regions and cruciform structures are also allowed for in the model. The probabilities of formation of the Z-form stretches, open regions and cruciform structures have been calculated for different values of parameters for pBR322 and pAO3 DNA.     

Effect of magnesium on cruciform extrusion in supercoiled DNA.

Recently, it was reported that Mg2+greatly facilitates cruciform extrusion in the short palindromes of supercoiled DNA, thereby allowing the formation of cruciform structures in vivo. Because of the potential biological importance of this phenomenon, we undertook a broader study of the effect of Mg2+on a cruciform extrusion in supercoiled DNA. The method of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis was used to detect the cruciform extrusion both in the absence and in the presence of these ions. Our results show that Mg2+shifts the cruciform extrusion in the d(CCC(AT)16GGG) palindrome to a higher, rather than to a lower level of supercoiling. In order to study possible sequence-specific properties of the short palindromes for which the unusual cruciform extrusion in the presence Mg2+was reported, we constructed a plasmid with a longer palindromic region. This region bears the same sequences in the hairpin loops and four-arm junction as the short palindrome, except that the short stems of the hairpins are extended. The extension allowed us to overcome the limitation of our experimental approach which cannot be used for very short palindromes. Our results show that Mg2+also shifts the cruciform extrusion in this palindrome to a higher level of supercoiling. These data suggest that cruciform extrusion in the short palindromes at low supercoiling is highly improbable. We performed a thermodynamic analysis of the effect of Mg2+on cruciform extrusion. The treatment accounted for the effect of Mg2+on both free energy of supercoiling and the free energy of cruciform structure per se. Our analysis showed that although the level of supercoiling required for the cruciform extrusion is not reduced by Mg2+, the ions reduce the free energy of the cruciform structure.     

A structural transition in d(AT)n.d(AT)n inserts within superhelical DNA

We have constructed plasmids carrying d(AT)n.d(AT)n inserts of different lengths. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis patterns show that an increase in the negative superhelicity of these DNAs brings about a structural transition within the inserts, resulting in a reduction of the superhelical stress. However, this reduction corresponds to the expected values neither for cruciform nor the Z form. Those DNA topoisomers in which the structural transition had occurred proved to be specifically recognizable by single-strand-specific endonuclease S1, with the cleavage site situated at the centre of the insert. These data, as well as kinetic studies, suggest that the cloned d(AT)n.d(AT)n sequences adopt a cruciform rather than the Z-form structure. We discuss plausible reasons of the discrepancy between the observed superhelical stress release and that expected for the transition of the insert to the cruciform state.     

The physical chemistry of cruciform structures in supercoiled DNA molecules

Inverted repeat DNA sequences extrude cruciform structures when present in negatively supercoiled molecules, stabilised by the release of torsional stress brought about by the negative twist change. We have revealed the presence of cruciform structures by means of enzyme and chemical probing experiments and topological band shift methods. The geometry of cruciform structures has been studied from two points of view. The unpairing of bases in the loop region has been investigated using bisulphite modification, with the result that the central four nucleotides have single-stranded character, and the next pair have only partially single-stranded nature. Gel electrophoretic studies of a pseudo-cruciform structure indicate that the cruciform junction introduces a pronounced bend into the molecule. The dependence of the formation of the ColE1 cruciform upon DNA supercoiling shows that it has a free energy of formation of 18.4 +/- 0.5 kcal mole-1. The kinetics of the extrusion process are complex. Most sequences extrude slowly with considerable temperature coefficients, but the detailed properties are strongly sequence-dependent. One synthetic inverted repeat sequence which we have studied in detail has an Arrhenius activation energy of 42.4 +/- 3.2 kcal mole-1. We discuss possible mechanistic pathways for the extrusion process.     

Effect of base composition at the center of inverted repeated DNA sequences on cruciform transitions in DNA

We have analyzed the effect of base composition at the center of symmetry of inverted repeated DNA sequences on cruciform transitions in supercoiled DNA. For this we have constructed two series of palindromic DNA sequences: one set with differing center and one set with differing center and arm sequences. The F series consists of two 96-base pair perfect inverted repeats which are identical except for the central 10 base pairs which consist of pure AT or GC base pairs. The S series was constructed such that the overall base composition of the inverted repeats was identical but in which the positioning of blocks of AT- and GC-rich sequences varied. The rate of cruciform formation for the inverted repeats in plasmid pUC8 was dramatically influenced by the 8-10 base pairs at the center of the inverted repeat. Inverted repeats with 8-10 AT base pairs in the center were kinetically much more active in cruciform formation than inverted repeats with 8-10 GC base pairs in the center. These experiments show a dominant influence of the center sequences of inverted repeats on the rate of cruciform formation.