In vivo gene electrotransfer into skeletal muscle: effects of plasmid DNA on the occurrence and extent of muscle damage

BACKGROUND: Understanding the mechanisms underlying gene electrotransfer muscle damage can help to design more effective gene electrotransfer strategies for physiological and therapeutical applications. The present study investigates the factors involved in gene electrotransfer associated muscle damage. METHODS: Histochemical analyses were used to determine the extent of transfection efficiency and muscle damage in the Tibialis anterior muscles of Sprague-Dawley male rats after gene electrotransfer. RESULTS: Five days after gene electrotransfer, features of muscle degeneration and regeneration were consistently observed, thus limiting the extent of transfection efficiency. Signs of muscle degeneration/regeneration were no longer evident 21 days after gene electrotransfer except for the presence of central myonuclei. Neither the application of electrical pulses per se nor the extracellular presence of plasmid DNA per se contributed significantly to muscle damage (2.9 +/- 1.0 and 2.1 +/- 0.7% of the whole muscle cross-sectional area, respectively). Gene electrotransfer of a plasmid DNA, which does not support gene expression, increased significantly muscle damage (8.7 +/- 1.2%). When plasmid DNA expression was permitted (gene electrotransfer of pCMV-beta-galactosidase), muscle damage was further increased to 19.7 +/- 4.5%. Optimization of cumulated pulse duration and current intensity dramatically reduced gene electrotransfer associated muscle damage. Finally, mathematical modeling of gene electrotransfer associated muscle damage as a function of the number of electrons delivered to the tissue indicated that pulse length critically determined the extent of muscle damage. CONCLUSION: Our data suggest that neither the extracellular presence of plasmid DNA per se nor the application of electric pulses per se contributes significantly to muscle damage. Gene electrotransfer associated muscle damage mainly arises from the intracellular presence and expression of plasmid DNA.     

Importance of association between permeabilization and electrophoretic forces for intramuscular DNA electrotransfer

Gene transfer using electrical pulses is a rapidly expanding field. Many studies have been performed in vitro to elucidate the mechanism of DNA electrotransfer. In vivo, the use of efficient procedures for DNA electrotransfer in tissues is recent, and the question of the implied mechanisms is largely open. We have evaluated the effects of various combinations of square wave electric pulses of variable field strength and duration, on cell permeabilization and on DNA transfection in the skeletal muscle in vivo. One high voltage pulse of 800 V/cm, 0.1 ms duration (short high pulse) or a series of four low voltage pulses of 80 V/cm, 83 ms duration (long low pulses) slightly amplified transfection efficacy, while no significant permeabilization was detected using the (51)Cr-EDTA uptake test. By contrast, the combination of one short high pulse followed by four long low pulses led to optimal gene transfer efficiency, while inducing muscle fibers permeabilization. These results are consistent with additive effects of electropermeabilization and DNA electrophoresis on electrotransfer efficiency. Finally, the described new combination, as compared to the previously reported use of repeated identical pulses of intermediate voltage, leads to similar gene transfer efficiency, while causing less permeabilization and thus being likely less deleterious. Thus, combination of pulses of various strengths and durations is a new procedure for skeletal muscle gene transfer that may represents a clear improvement in view of further clinical development.     

Influence of Plasmid Concentration on DNA Electrotransfer In Vitro Using High-Voltage and Low-Voltage Pulses

DNA electrotransfer in vivo for gene therapy is a promising method. For further clinical developments, the efficiency of the method should be increased. It has been shown previously that high efficiency of gene electrotransfer in vivo can be achieved using high-voltage (HV) and low-voltage (LV) pulses. In this study we evaluated whether HV and LV pulses could be optimized in vitro for efficient DNA electrotransfer. Experiments were performed using Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. To evaluate the efficiency of DNA electrotransfer, two different plasmids coding for GFP and luciferase were used. For DNA electrotransfer experiments 50 μl of CHO cell suspension containing 100, 10 or 1 μg/ml of the plasmid were placed between plate electrodes and subjected to various combinations of HV and LV pulses. The results showed that at 100 μg/ml plasmid concentration LV pulse delivered after HV pulse increased neither the percentage of transfected cells nor the total transfection efficiency (luciferase activity). The contribution of the LV pulse was evident only at reduced concentration (10 and 1 μg/ml) of the plasmid. In comparison to HV (1,200 V/cm, 100 μs) pulse, addition of LV (100 V/cm, 100 ms) pulse increased transfection efficiency severalfold at 10 μg/ml and fivefold at 1 μg/ml. At 10 μg/ml concentration of plasmid, application of four LV pulses after HV pulse increased transfection efficiency by almost 10-fold. Thus, these results show that contribution of electrophoretic forces to DNA electrotransfer can be investigated in vitro using HV and LV pulses.     

Optimizing hyaluronidase dose and plasmid DNA delivery greatly improves gene electrotransfer efficiency in rat skeletal muscle

Transfection of rat skeletal muscle in vivo is a widely used research model. However, gene electrotransfer protocols have been developed for mice and yield variable results in rats. We investigated whether changes in hyaluronidase pre-treatment and plasmid DNA delivery can improve transfection efficiency in rat skeletal muscle. We found that pre-treating the muscle with a hyaluronidase dose suitable for rats (0.56 U/g b.w.) prior to plasmid DNA injection increased transfection efficiency by >200% whereas timing of the pre-treatment did not affect efficiency. Uniformly distributing plasmid DNA delivery across the muscle by increasing the number of plasmid DNA injections further enhanced transfection efficiency whereas increasing plasmid dose from 0.2 to 1.6 µg/g b.w. or vehicle volume had no effect. The optimized protocol resulted in ~80% (CI95%: 79–84%) transfected muscle fibers with a homogenous distribution. We also show that transfection was stable over five weeks of regular exercise or inactivity. Our findings show that species-specific plasmid DNA delivery and hyaluronidase pre-treatment greatly improves transfection efficiency in rat skeletal muscle.     

In Vivo Imaging of Far-red Fluorescent Proteins after DNA Electrotransfer to Muscle Tissue

DNA electrotransfer to muscle tissue yields long-term, high levels of gene expression; showing great promise for future gene therapy. We want to characterize the novel far-red fluorescent protein Katushka as a marker for gene expression using time domain fluorescence in vivo imaging. Highly efficient transgenic expression was observed after DNA electrotransfer with 100-fold increase in fluorescent intensity. The fluorescent signal peaked 1 week after transfection and returned to background level within 4 weeks. Katushka expression was not as stable as GFP expression, which was detectable for 8 weeks. Depth and 3D analysis proved that the expression was located in the target muscle. In vivo bio-imaging using the novel Katushka fluorescent protein enables excellent evaluation of the transfection efficacy, and spatial distribution, but lacks long-term stability.     

Long-term,high level in vivo gene expression after electric pulse-mediated gene transfer into skeletal muscle

Gene delivery to skeletal muscle is a promising strategy for the treatment of muscle disorders and for the local or systemic secretion of therapeutic proteins. However, current DNA delivery technologies have to be improved. We report very efficient luciferase gene transfer into muscle fibres obtained through the delivery of squarewave electric pulses of moderate field strength (100–200 V/cm) and of long duration (20 ms) to muscle previously injected with plasmid DNA. This intramuscular ‘electrotransfer’ method increases reporter gene expression by more than 100 times. It is noteworthy that this expression remains high and stable for at least 9 months. Moreover, intramuscular electrotransfer strongly decreases the interindividual variability usually observed after plasmid DNA injection into muscle fibres. Therefore, DNA electrotransfer in muscle possesses broad potential applications in gene therapy and for physiological, pharmacological and developmental studies.     

Use of Collagen Gel as a Three-Dimensional In Vitro Model to Study Electropermeabilization and Gene Electrotransfer

Gene electrotransfer is a promising nonviral method that enables transfer of plasmid DNA into cells with electric pulses. Although many in vitro and in vivo studies have been performed, the question of the implied gene electrotransfer mechanisms is largely open. The main obstacle toward efficient gene electrotransfer in vivo is relatively poor mobility of DNA in tissues. Since cells are mechanically coupled to their extracellular environment and act differently compared to standard in vitro conditions, we developed a three-dimensional (3-D) in vitro model of CHO cells embedded in collagen gel as an ex vivo model of tissue to study electropermeabilization and different parameters of gene electrotransfer. For this purpose, we first used propidium iodide to detect electropermeabilization of CHO cells embedded in collagen gel. Then, we analyzed the influence of different concentrations of plasmid DNA and pulse duration on gene electrotransfer efficiency. Our results revealed that even if cells in collagen gel can be efficiently electropermeabilized, gene expression is significantly lower. Gene electrotransfer efficiency in our 3-D in vitro model had similar dependence on concentration of plasmid DNA and pulse duration comparable to in vivo studies, where longer (millisecond) pulses were shown to be more optimal compared to shorter (microsecond) pulses. The presented results demonstrate that our 3-D in vitro model resembles the in vivo situation more closely than conventional 2-D cell cultures and, thus, provides an environment closer to in vivo conditions to study mechanisms of gene electrotransfer.     

Muscle transfection and permeabilization induced by electrotransfer or pluronic® L64: Paired study by optical imaging and MRI

Background

Muscle transfection by electrotranfer is an efficient currently used procedure. Recently, the block copolymer pluronic L64 has been reported to improve muscle transfection. Both procedures are known to permeabilize muscle fibres. Relation between muscle transfection and permeabilization by electrotransfer and L64 was investigated herein.

Methods

Muscle transfection was evaluated by optical detection of the luciferase reporter gene activity. Muscle permeabilization was evaluated by the uptake of the T1 contrast agent gadolinium-Dotarem (Gd-DOTA) using Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Histological examination of muscle sections was also performed.

Results

Electrotransfer and L64 (at a 0.25% concentration) similarly improved muscle transfection, although the interindividual variability was higher for pluronic. On the same animals, the permeabilized volume to the Gd-DOTA was significantly increased after electrotransfer, and L64 from 0.1% to 1%. The concentration of the Gd-DOTA in the permeabilized volume was significantly increased after electrotransfer and L64 at 0.5% and 1%. By histological observation, the inflammation was maximum at day 3 after electrotransfer or L64 injection, and mostly reversed after 7 days. The permeabilized volume and the transfection level correlated for the set of all the conditions tested. However, no significant correlation was observed between Gd-DOTA concentration and transfection.

General significance

It is possible to use successively on the same animals MRI and optical imaging for paired studies of muscle transfection and permeabilization. Permeabilization is possibly not related to gene transfer but it indicates membrane modification related to transfection by the electrotransfer or co-injection of DNA with the L64.     

The Role of Electrophoresis in Gene Electrotransfer

Gene electrotransfer is an established method for gene delivery which uses high-voltage pulses to increase the permeability of a cell membrane and enables transfer of genes. Poor plasmid mobility in tissues is one of the major barriers for the successful use of gene electrotransfer in gene therapy. Therefore, we analyzed the effect of electrophoresis on increasing gene electrotransfer efficiency using different combinations of high-voltage (HV) and low-voltage (LV) pulses in vitro on CHO cells. We designed a special prototype of electroporator, which enabled us to use only HV pulses or combinations of LV + HV and HV + LV pulses. We used optimal plasmid concentrations used in in vitro conditions as well as lower suboptimal concentrations in order to mimic in vivo conditions. Only for the lowest plasmid concentration did the electrophoretic force of the LV pulse added to the HV pulse increase the transfection efficiency compared to using only HV. The effect of the LV pulse was more pronounced for HV + LV, while for the reversed sequence, LV + HV, there was only a minor effect of the LV pulse. For the highest plasmid concentrations no added effect of LV pulses were observed. Our results suggest that there are different contributing effects of LV pulses: electrophoretically increased contact of DNA with the membrane and increased insertion of DNA into permeabilized cell membrane and/or translocation due to electrophoretic force, which appears to be the dominant effect.     

Intramuscular plasmid DNA electrotransfer: biodistribution and degradation

We have studied radiolabelled plasmid DNA biodistribution and degradation in the muscle at different times after injection, with or without electrotransfer using previously defined conditions. Radiolabelled plasmid progressively left the muscle and was degraded as soon as 5 min after plasmid injection, with or without electrotransfer. Autoradiography showed that the major part of injected radioactivity was detected in the interfibrilar space of a large proportion of the muscle. Large zones of accumulation of radioactivity, which seems to be contained in some fibres (more than 20 microm), were identified as soon as 5 min after electrotransfer. Such structures were never observed on slices of non-electrotransferred muscles. However, these structures were not frequent and probably lesional. The surprising fact is that despite the amount of intact plasmid having been greatly reduced between 5 min and 3 h after injection, the level of transfection remains unchanged whether electric pulses were delivered 20 s or 3 h after injection. Such a behavior was similarly observed when injecting 0.3, 3 or 30 microg of plasmid DNA. Moreover, the transfection level was correlated to the amount of plasmid DNA injected. These results suggest that as soon as it is injected, plasmid DNA is proportionally partitioned between at least two compartments. While a major part of plasmid DNA is rapidly cleared and degraded, the electrotransferable pool of plasmid DNA represents a very small part of the amount injected and belongs to another compartment where it is protected from endogenous DNAses.     

Plasmid DNA electrotransfer for intracellular and secreted proteins expression: new methodological developments and applications

In vivo electrotransfer is a physical method of gene delivery in various tissues and organs, relying on the injection of a plasmid DNA followed by electric pulse delivery. The importance of the association between cell permeabilization and DNA electrophoresis for electrotransfer efficiency has been highlighted. In vivo electrotransfer is of special interest since it is the most efficient non-viral strategy of gene delivery and also because of its low cost, easiness of realization and safety. The potentiality of this technique can be further improved by optimizing plasmid biodistribution in the targeted organ, plasmid structure, and the design of the encoded protein. In particular, we found that plasmids of smaller size were electrotransferred more efficiently than large plasmids. It is also of importance to study and understand kinetic expression of the transgene, which can be very variable, depending on many factors including cellular localization of the protein, physiological activity and regulation. The most widely targeted tissue is skeletal muscle, because this strategy is not only promising for the treatment of muscle disorders, but also for the systemic secretion of therapeutic proteins. Vaccination and oncology gene therapy are also major fields of application of electrotransfer, whereas application to other organs such as liver, brain and cornea are expanding. Many published studies have shown that plasmid electrotransfer can lead to long-lasting therapeutic effects in various pathologies such as cancer, blood disorders, rheumatoid arthritis or muscle ischemia. DNA electrotransfer is also a powerful laboratory tool to study gene function in a given tissue.     

Numerical optimization of gene electrotransfer into muscle tissue

Background  

Electroporation-based gene therapy and DNA vaccination are promising medical applications that depend on transfer of pDNA into target tissues with use of electric pulses. Gene electrotransfer efficiency depends on electrode configuration and electric pulse parameters, which determine the electric field distribution. Numerical modeling represents a fast and convenient method for optimization of gene electrotransfer parameters. We used numerical modeling, parameterization and numerical optimization to determine the optimum parameters for gene electrotransfer in muscle tissue.     

Changing the Direction and Orientation of Electric Field During Electric Pulses Application Improves Plasmid Gene Transfer in vitro

Gene electrotransfer is a physical method used to deliver genes into the cells by application of short and intense electric pulses, which cause destabilization of cell membrane, making it permeable to small molecules and allows transfer of large molecules such as DNA. It represents an alternative to viral vectors, due to its safety, efficacy and ease of application. For gene electrotransfer different electric pulse protocols are used in order to achieve maximum gene transfection, one of them is changing the electric field direction and orientation during the pulse delivery. Changing electric field direction and orientation increase the membrane area competent for DNA entry into the cell. In this video, we demonstrate the difference in gene electrotransfer efficacy when all pulses are delivered in the same direction and when pulses are delivered by changing alternatively the electric field direction and orientation. For this purpose tip with integrated electrodes and high-voltage prototype generator, which allows changing of electric field in different directions during electric pulse application, were used. Gene electrotransfer efficacy is determined 24h after pulse application as the number of cells expressing green fluorescent protein divided with the number of all cells. The results show that gene transfection is increased when the electric field orientation during electric pulse delivery is changed.Download video file.^{(27M, mov)}     

Electrically induced DNA uptake by cells is a fast process involving DNA electrophoresis.

Simian Cos-1 cells were transfected electrically with the plasmid pCH110 carrying the beta-galactosidase gene. The efficiency of transfection was determined by a transient expression of this gene. When the plasmid was introduced into a cell suspension 2 s after pulse application, the transfection efficiency was shown to be less than 1% as compared with a prepulse addition of DNA. Addition of DNAase to suspension immediately after a pulse did not decrease transfection efficiency, thus the time of DNA translocation was estimated to be less than 3 s. The use of electric treatment medium, in which the postpulse colloid-osmotic cell swelling was prevented, did not affect the transfection efficiency. These results contradict both assumptions of free DNA diffusion into cell through the long-lived pores and of involvement of osmotic effects in DNA translocation. Transfection of cells in monolayer on a porous film allowed creation of the spatial asymmetry of cell-plasmid interaction along the direction of electric field applied. A pulse with a polarity inducing DNA electrophoresis toward the cells resulted in the 10-fold excess of transfection efficiency compared with a pulse with reverse polarity. Ficoll (10%) which increases medium viscosity or Mg2+ ions (10 mM) which decrease the effective charge of DNA, both reduced transfection efficiency 2-3-fold. These results prove a significant role of DNA electrophoresis in the phenomenon considered. The permeability of cell membranes for an indifferent dye was shown to increase noticeably if the cells were pulsed in the presence of DNA. This indicates a possible interaction of DNA translocated with the pores in an electric field, that results in pore expansion.     

Functional in vivo gene transfer into the myofibers of adult skeletal muscle

The postmitotic nature and longevity of skeletal muscle fibers permit stable expression of any transfected gene. Direct in vivo injection of plasmid DNA, in both adult and regenerating muscles, is a safe, inexpensive, and easy approach. Here we present an optimized electroporation protocol based on the use of spatula electrodes to transfer cDNA in vivo into the adult myofibers of an anatomically defined muscle, which could be functionally characterized. In our hands, about 80% of adult myofibers were transfected in vivo by different plasmids for GFP fusion proteins or for beta-galactosidase. The luciferase activity increased several orders of magnitude when compared to standard DNA delivery. In an anatomical defined muscle, the wide gene transfer was comparable to or better than that of retrovirus delivery, that recently has been shown to be prone to severe side-effects in human clinical studies. Furthermore, with our method the tissue damage was greatly decreased. Thus, the present work describes in vivo functional electrotransfer of genes in adult skeletal muscle fibers by a protocol that is of great potential for gene therapy, as well as for basic research.     

新型非病毒三元复合DNA载体的研究

基因治疗是未来临床医学最具潜力的治疗方式,目前阻碍临床基因治疗发展的主要因素是缺乏安全和高效的基因载体,因此研究理想的非病毒转基因载体具有重要的意义.构建了由质粒DNA(D)-抗DNA抗体(A)-阳离子脂质体(C)组成的三元复合纳米基因载体(DAC),研究表明,三组分在磷酸缓冲液中可通过分子组装形成复合纳米胶束,DAC在细胞培养中表现出显著高效的基因表达,DAC在血管平滑肌细胞中的基因转染效率比不含抗DNA抗体的二元组合(DC)高4倍,比不含阳离子脂质体的二元组合(DA)约高11倍.激光共聚焦荧光显微观察证明,DAC细胞摄取量和DNA进入细胞核的量均明显高于对照组,而DC二元组合(不含抗DNA抗体)的DNA很少进入细胞核,细胞在DAC存在下生长正常.未发现细胞毒性.研究结果提示,DAC的作用机理主要是三元复合胶束中DNA的装载量比二元载体大得多,抗DNA抗体与阳离子脂质体的协同作用明显有利于DNA被细胞摄取和胞吞,从而提高了基因的转染和表达.     

Electroporation in combination with a plasmid vector containing SV40 enhancer elements results in increased and persistent gene expression in mouse muscle

Gene transfer into muscle upon injection of plasmid DNA is feasible but occurs with low frequency. However, by using electroporation after injection of plasmid DNA into mouse muscle it has been demonstrated that gene expression can be increased more than 150-fold. In this communication, we have used this technique in combination with plasmids containing a tandem repeat of three 72-bp DNA elements from the SV40 enhancer to study gene expression. Our results show that the combination of electroporation and a plasmid vector carrying these DNA elements results in increased and more persistent gene expression of the luciferase reporter gene in BALB/c mouse muscle. At 14 days after gene delivery, the gene expression was 16-fold higher in muscles injected and electroporated with the plasmid carrying the SV40 enhancers than with control plasmid. We have also studied the effects of the vehicle in which the plasmid was delivered, and the DNase inhibitor aurintricarboxylic acid (ATA), on gene expression. By combining ATA with 150 mM sodium phosphate buffer we were able to obtain a 2-fold increase in gene expression compared to delivery of the plasmid in physiological saline. These results are of importance for the development of efficient delivery techniques for naked DNA.     

Tertiary-Amine Functionalized Polyplexes Enhanced Cellular Uptake and Prolonged Gene Expression

Ultrasound (US) has been found to facilitate the transport of DNA across cell membranes. However, the transfection efficiency is generally low, and the expression duration of the transfected gene is brief. In this study, a tertiary polycation, Poly(2-(dimethylamino) ethyl methacrylate) (PDMAEMA), was used as a carrier for US-mediated gene transfection. Its in-vitro and in-vivo effects on the transfection efficiency and the expression duration were evaluated. A mixture of pCI-neo-luc and PDMAEMA was transfected to cultured cells or mouse muscle by exposure to 1-MHz pulse US. A strong expression of luciferase was found 10 days after the transfection in vitro regardless of US exposure. However, effective transfection only occurred in the US groups in vivo. The transfection ability depended on the weight ratio of PDMAEMA to DNA, and was different for the in-vitro and in-vivo conditions. Lower weight ratios, e.g., 0.25, exhibited better in-vivo expression for at least 45 days.