Studies on heteromorphic self-incompatibility systems: Physiological aspects of the incompatibility system of Primula obconica

Summary In Primula obconica, a species with a heteromorphic self-incompatibility system, the distinction between compatible and incompatible pollen tubes takes place on the stigma surface in thrum flowers, self tubes growing randomly over the papillar cells. No differences were seen between self and cross tube behaviour on the pin stigma surface, but self tubes were inhibited within the stigmatic tissue with differences in tube length evident after 24 h. The stigma surface bears a proteinaceous pellicle and binds the lectin Concanavalin A. Removal of the stigma removes the incompatibility barrier in mature gynoecia. Bud pollination shows that pollen tubes cannot grow in a normal manner on immature stigmas; the random growth of tubes over the stigma surface resembles that of mature thrum selfs. Fewer compatible tubes reach the style base of young gynoecia and smaller numbers of seeds are set than in mature flowers. Pin and thrum pollen grains germinate and grow in aqueous media, thrum tubes growing longer than pin. The presence of H₃BO₄ and CaCl₂ in the growth medium promotes tube elongation and lengths equivalent to compatible styles can be obtained. The pollen grains have proteinaceous materials in their walls which diffuse out on moistening. Prolonged washing in aqueous media removes these materials but the incompatibility reaction remains unchanged. Thus the incompatibility reaction is between pollen tubes and stigmatic tissue and differs from the homomorphic, sporophytic system where pollen wall proteins elicit the incompatibility response.     

Heterostyly and Pollen-tube Interactions in Luculia gratissima (Rubiaceae)

Observations on the floral biology of Luculia gratissima (Rubiaceae)showed that this species is distylous with complementary positioningof anthers and stigmas in the two floral forms. Unusual featuresof distyly in this species include the larger size of the corolla,the stigma surface and the stigmatic papillae in the thrum flowerscompared to the pin ones. Stigmatic surfaces have similar secretionsbut they appear more copious in thrum than pin. The floral dimorphismwas accompanied by a very effective self-incompatibility systemand no seed was set on selfing. Seed number per capsule on crossingwas significantly greater in thrum flowers compared to pin.Incompatible pollen tubes were inhibited within 24 h at thebase of the stigma/top of the style in both morphs. Amputationof this region of the gynoecium removed the self-incompatibilityreaction in thrum but not pin flowers. Pollination with a mixtureof compatible and incompatible pollen and sequential pollinationwith self followed by cross pollen showed that there were interactionsbetween the two types of pollen tube. The presence of compatibletubes was found to cause the excessive swelling of the pollen-tubetip of the incompatible ones. The incompatible tubes did notappear to have any effect on the growth of compatible ones. Luculia gratissima, distyly, floral biology, self-incompatibility, pollen-tube interactions     

Self-incompatibility inCrocus vernus subsp.vernus (Iridaceae)

Outcross, self- and mixed pollinations were performed inCrocus vernus subsp.vernus, a species with bicellular pollen, dry stigmas and hollow style. No differences were noted among the above pollinations concerning the germination of pollen and the growth of pollen tubes until the top of ovary. Within 45 min after pollinations 62% of pollen grains germinated. Pollen tubes penetrated the papilla cuticle extending along the papilla wall; on entry into stigmatic lobes they continued growth in the stylar secretion to ovarian locules. Here, however, self-pollen tubes failed to reach or to enter the ovule micropyle; while pollen tubes from either outcross- or mixed pollinations grew until fertilizing ovules. These observations gave evidence of a self-incompatibility system inCrocus, which appeared to be neutralized by mentor effect. The ovary as site of incompatibility response is discussed.     

Dry stigmas,water and self-incompatibility in Brassica

The evolution of dry stigmas has been accompanied by the development — in the pollen — of mechanisms for accessing water from the stigmatic epidermis. Development of self- and cross-pollen on the stigmatic surface has been examined in Brassica oleracea, focusing on the hydration of the grains. Unlike self-compatible (SC) Arabidopsis thaliana, pollen hydration of self-incompatible (SI) Brassica oleracea is preceded by a latent period of between 30–90 min, which is significantly shortened by inhibition of protein synthesis in the stigma. Physiological experiments, some with isolated pollen coatings, indicate that during the latent period signals passing from the pollen to the sigma are responsible for readying the stigmatic surface for penetration and — after self-pollination — activation of the SI system. The changes at the stigma surface include the expansion of the outer layer of the cell wall beneath the grain. This expansion does not occur following self-pollination, when coating-derived signals stimulate a stigmatic response which interrupts hydration and arrests grain development. Cell manipulation studies suggest that self grains are not inhibited metabolically, but are physiologically isolated from the subjacent stigmatic papilla. This focusing of the SI response at the pollen-stigma interface ensures that a single papilla can simultaneously accept cross-pollen and reject self-grains. The evolution of this highly efficient SI system is disussed in the perspective of pathogen-defence mechanisms known also to be located in epidermal cells.     

EFFECT OF FLORAL AGING ON THE GROWTH OF COMPATIBLE AND INCOMPATIBLE POLLEN TUBES IN LILIUM LONGIFLORUM

Compatible and incompatible pollen tube growth in detached styles of three Lilium longiflorum cultivare varies with the physiological age of the style. Before anthesis both compatible and incompatible pollen tubes grow, in 48 hr, only a fraction of the distance compatible tubes grow after anthesis. Incompatible pollen tubes are restricted to about half the distance of compatible tubes in the four days postanthesis, but thereafter increase up to or three-fourths or more the length of compatible tubes at the time of floral senescence. About 10 days after anthesis, growth of both types of pollen tubes decreases. The detached style method of pollen-tube cultivation is validated in the cultivar ‘Ace’ by seed set obtained following self-pollination in the 6- to 9-day interval and failure of seed set after either self- or cross-pollination after 9 days following anthesis. Also, in agreement with detached style data, self-pollination fails to produce seeds when attempted in bud stages or the five days following anthesis. Cross-pollinations are successful in this period. This material and technique appear well suited for study of the nature of the self-incompatibility reaction.     

The influence of RNA-synthesis inhibitors on in vivo pollen tube growth and the self-incompatibility reaction in Lilium longiflorum thunb

Summary Injection of 3 X 10^–4 g/ml acridine orange, 2 X 10^–5 g/ml actinomycin-D, or 1.34 X 10^–3 g/ml 6-methyl-purine in stigmatic exudate into the hollow styles of Lilium longiflorum immediately before, or 6 or 12 hr after pollination restricted compatible pollen tube growth to lengths typical of incompatible tubes. Treatment 24 hr after pollination resulted either in no effect on compatible tube growth or in a significant retardation of compatible tube growth but not to the length of tubes in incompatibly pollinated styles. Aqueous solutions of these inhibitors at the same concentrations injected into lily styles 6 or 12hr before pollination significantly stimulated incompatible pollen tube growth. These results suggest that RNA synthesis in the style is necessary for the self-incompatibility reaction and RNA synthesis in the pollen tube is required for compatible tube growth. The RNA synthesis in the pollen tube may be completed by 24 hr after pollination.Paper number 7439 of the Scientific Journal Series, Minn. Agr. Exp. Sta., St. Paul, Minn. The author gratefully acknowledges the support of the Graduate School, Univ. of Minn. and the United Bulb Co., Mount Clemens, Mich.     

ROLE OF CALCIUM IN THE CALLOSE RESPONSE OF SELF-POLLINATED BRASSICA STIGMAS

In Brassica oleracea, sporophytic self-incompatibility prevents germination of self pollen, or normal growth of self pollen tubes. After self-pollination, the papillae of stigmas synthesize callose. The role of Ca⁺⁺ in the formation of stigmatic callose was tested by adding compounds that interact with Ca⁺⁺ to suspensions of pollen that were known to induce callose formation in self stigmas. The calcium channel antagonist, lanthanum, and the calcium chelating agent, EGTA, reduced or abolished the callose response to self-pollen suspensions. In the presence of Ca⁺⁺, the calcium ionophore, A23187, induced callose in stigmatic papillae when added to pollen suspensions, or alone. Therefore, callose deposition in response to incompatible pollinations appears to be a calcium-dependent process. Pretreatment of pistils with 100 μm 2-deoxy-D-glucose abolished the callose response to self-pollination, while self pollen remained inhibited and cross pollen grew normally in treated pistils. Thus, callose formation in the stigma is not an essential part of the self-incompatibility mechanism preventing the growth of self pollen in Brassica.     

Self-incompatibility of Zinnia angustifolia HBK (compositae)

Summary Visible light and UV epifluorescence microscopy were used to assess self-incompatibility (SI) in Zinnia angustifolia clones. Pistils were fixed 24 h after pollination and stained either with aniline blue in lactophenol (visible light microscopy) or decolorized aniline blue (fluorescence microscopy). Percentage of florets with embryos 21 days following pollination (% embryo set) was used as a control. Embryo set following self- or incompatible cross-pollinations ranged from 0% to 9.9%, whereas compatible crosses yielded 55.5%–87.1% embryo set. Observations using visible light microscopy indicated pollen load and number of germinated grains were significantly higher for compatible compared to incompatible crosses, and both variables were positively correlated (r = 0.89–0.96) to % embryo set. Examinations with UV epifluorescence microscopy revealed pollen load was higher and little or no callose accumulated in stigmatic papillae following compatible crosses, whereas for incompatible crosses, pollen load was low and callose lenticules were deposited in stigmatic papillae; the correlation between pollen load and % embryo set was 0.89. The intensity of callose fluorescence of the pollen tube-papillae attachment sites was quantitatively measured via micro spectrofluorometry. Callose fluorescence intensity ranged from 47.9% to 62.6% for incompatible and from 6.4% to 9.9% for compatible crosses, and was negatively correlated (r= — 0.95) with % embryo set. Microscopal techniques permit rapid assessment of SI and may be used routinely when each observed or measured parameter is highly correlated to the incompatibility response.Publication no. 2898 of the Massachusetts Agricultural Experiment Station.     

Secretory Activity Is Rapidly Induced in Stigmatic Papillae by Compatible Pollen,but Inhibited for Self-Incompatible Pollen in the Brassicaceae

[In the Brassicaceae, targeted exocytosis to the stigmatic papillar plasma membrane under the compatible pollen grain is hypothesized to be essential for pollen hydration and pollen tube penetration. In contrast, polarized secretion is proposed to be inhibited in the stigmatic papillae during the rejection of self-incompatible pollen. Using transmission electron microscopy (TEM), we performed a detailed time-course of post-pollination events to view the cytological responses of the stigmatic papillae to compatible and self-incompatible pollinations. For compatible pollinations in Arabidopsis thaliana and Arabidopsis lyrata, vesicle secretion was observed at the stigmatic papillar plasma membrane under the pollen grain while Brassica napus stigmatic papillae appeared to use multivesicular bodies (MVBs) for secretion. Exo70A1, a component of the exocyst complex, has been previously implicated in the compatible pollen responses, and disruption of Exo70A1 in both A. thaliana and B. napus resulted in a loss of secretory vesicles/MVBs at the stigmatic papillar plasma membrane. Similarly, for self-incompatible pollinations, secretory vesicles/MVBs were absent from the stigmatic papillar plasma membrane in A. lyrata and B. napus; and furthermore, autophagy appeared to be induced to direct vesicles/MVBs to the vacuole for degradation. Thus, these findings support a model where the basal pollen recognition pathway in the stigmatic papilla promotes exocytosis to accept compatible pollen, and the basal pollen recognition pathway is overridden by the self-incompatibility pathway to prevent exocytosis and reject self-pollen.     

Overcoming Incompatibility in Brassica campestris L. by Carbon Dioxide, and Dark Fixation of the Gas by Self- and Cross-pollinated Pistils

Supplementing pollen suspension cultures with CO₂ (3–5per cent) caused a marked increase in germination and tube growthin vitro in Brassica campestris L. cv. toria. A weakening ofself-incompatibility by increased CO₂ levels from 3–5per cent was observed. The percentage of pollen tubes whichpenetrated the cuticle layer of stigmatic papilla cells in self-pollinatedpistils was high when CO₂ level was 5 per cent. Phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) carboxylase activity was greater in the pollengerminated in 4 per cent CO₂ as compared to air (0.03 per cent).A possible role of CO₂ for self-recognition and control of pollentube growth is proposed, proposed. Brassica campestris L., carbon dioxide, self-incompatibility, phosphoenol pyruvate carboxylase     

Localization of adenylate cyclase activity in Populus: its relation to pollen-pistil recognition and incompatibility

Summary Adenylate cyclase has been localized cytochemically in female and male parents as well as during the pollen-stigma interaction with an original technique employing strontium as the capture ion and adenyl imidodiphosphate as the specific substrate. The specificity of the reaction was checked by using several controls. No final specific reaction product was detected in unpollinated P. deltoides stigmas or in the P. deltoides or P. alba pollen grains used for compatible and incompatible pollinations. In the compatible cross between P. deltoides × P. deltoides, fine dense precipitates were observed in the dictyosomes and the plasma membrane and exterior to the exine of hydrated pollen grains adhering to the stigma surface. Labeling of the stigmatic pellicle was also observed after pollen adhesion and hydration. This was accompanied by a strong reactivity of the cell wall and plasmalemma of the stigma papillae at the sites of pollen tube germination on the stigma surface and at the sites of penetration of pollen tubes between adjacent papillae. In the incompatible cross between P. deltoides x P. alba, adenylate cyclase activity was still present but reduced at the stigma surface following adhesion, hydration, and germination of P. alba pollen. This activity was completely abolished after the penetration of pollen tubes between stigma papillae. These findings suggest that in Populus, adenylate cyclase activity is correlated to pollen adhesion, hydration, and germination at the stigma surface, and that the abolition of this enzyme activity could be one of the cellular events governing the gametophytic phenotype of incompatibility in the cross between P. deltoides and P. alba.     

Self-incompatibility and interspecific incompatibility: relationships in intra- and interspecific crosses of Zinnia elegans Jacq. and Z. angustifolia HBK (Compositae)

Summary Intraspecific and reciprocal interspecific crosses involving Zinnia angustifolia clones and Z. elegans lines showed that in both species, sporophytic self-incompatibility (SI) systems were present. Intensity of SI varied among clones and lines, and high self seed set was associated with a concomitant decrease in callose fluorescence in papillae and pollen tubes. Incomplete stigmatic inhibition of pollen germination and tube growth was observed in reciprocal interspecific crosses and associated with callose synthesis, suggesting S-gene activity. Seed set and progeny obtained following Z. angustifolia×Z. elegans matings was comparable to intraspecific compatible matings of Z. angustifolia although the rate of pollen tube growth through the style was slower. In Z. elegans × Z. angustifolia matings, additional prezygotic barriers were present and acted between pollen tube penetration of the stigma and syngamy. SI X SI interspecific incompatibility was essentially unilateral, with no embryos or progeny obtained when Z. elegans was the pistillate parent. It was hypothesized that nonfunctioning of Z. elegans × Z. angustifolia crosses was due to S-gene expression at the stigmatic surface and to other isolating mechanisms in the stylar or ovarian transmitting tissue.Scientific Article No. A-4448, Contribution No. 7439 of the Maryland Agricultural Experiment Station, Department of HorticultureA portion of this paper was presented in the report: Boyle TH, Stimart DP (1986) Incompatibility relationships in intra- and interspecific crosses of Z. elegans Jacq. and Z. angustifolia HBK (Compositae). In: Mulcahy D (ed) Biotechnology and ecology of pollen. Springer, New York     

Pollen tube growth following compatible and incompatible intraspecific pollinations in Petunia hybrida

The observation that both compatible and incompatible pollen tubes grow at identical speeds on the stigma in many plants with gametophytically controlled self-incompatibility (SI) systems has, in Petunia, been extended to cover all other facets of pollen behaviour on this tissue. On entry into the stylar transmitting tissue both types of tubes accelerate, but the compatible achieve a higher terminal velocity than do the incompatible, which eventually slow and stop. Grafting experiments show that the top 1 mm of the stylar tissue can play an important rôle in determining the future development of the pollen tube. Following mixed pollinations, proportionally too many compatible pollen tubes reach the ovary than would be expected from the results of pure compatible and incompatible pollinations indicating that incompatible pollen in some way helps prime the style for growth of compatible pollen tubes. This data is considered in terms of recent structural studies of these tissues, and related to the pollination conditions pertaining to Petunia populations in the field.Abbreviation SI self-incompatibility     

Intra- and interspecific reproductive barriers inCrocus (Iridaceae)

The reproductive system was studied inCrocus genus (Iridaceae) following intra- and interspecific pollination, by using light and scanning electron microscopy. The results suggest that the stigma-style tract of theCrocus pistil is a mere promoter of pollen tube growth, while intra- and interspecific discrimination of compatible and incompatible pollen occurs in the ovarian tract. Here, the transmitting tissue consists of special epidermal cells, whose granular or floccular secretions provide the selective medium for the growth of pollen tubes. The ovarian self-incompatibility (SI) is widespread within the genus, resulting in a partial or complete suppression of self-fertilization. Moreover, postzygotic SI mechanisms, as well as postzygotic mechanisms of unknown nature, seem to be recurrent and both are responsible for seed abortion. The interspecific ovarian incompatibility concerns only unrelated crosses; crosses between related fertile species succeed both in fertilization and seed-set.     

Self-incompatibility in a distylous species of Rubiaceae: is there a single incompatibility response of the morphs?

Heterostyly is a genetically controlled floral polymorphism usually associated with an incompatibility system. This set of features is known to occur in several angiosperm families, but some aspects of its biology has not been well studied. The present study investigates cellular aspects of the pollen–pistil interaction after compatible and incompatible pollinations of Psychotria nuda, to increase our knowledge of heteromorphic self-incompatibility (HetSI). The use of bright field, fluorescence and transmission electron microscopy methods allowed us to demonstrate that pollen tubes behave differently after incompatible and compatible pollinations. Pollen tubes were particularly distinct after incompatible pollinations of L- and S-morph flowers. Relative to compatible pollen tubes, incompatible L-morph tubes had a drastic reduction in cellular contents, but no cell rupture. Incompatible S-morph tubes exhibited dense cytoplasm in apical regions, as well as in other regions, accompanied by a rupture of the apex. These results support the hypothesis that L- and S-morph flowers have different incompatibility mechanisms during HetSI.     

Style-controlled wilting of the flower

Differences in rate of wilting in cross-, self-and unpollinated flowers of self-incompatiblePetunia hybrida L. clone W166H appeared to be significant. Wilting rate was fastest following cross-pollination and slowest in unpollinated flowers. The difference between wilting behaviour of cross- and self-pollinated flowers was not caused by rate of pollen tube growth and not by the incompatibility (recognition or rejection) reaction either. It is assumed, that, following pollination, the wilting reaction is only retarded after penetration of pollen tubes of the same genetic composition as the style (complete self-pollination). The number of viable pollen grains necessary to initiate a maximal wilting-rate of flowers following cross- and self-pollination is about 800, which means that a fifth of the stigmatic surface must be covered with living pollen grains. It is suggested that pollen tube penetration and injury of the style have a similar influence on the initiation of wilting.Wilting-rate following pollination is faster in young plants as compared with wilting in old plants. The wilting process of unpollinated and self-pollinated flowers started in the early morning and lasted till afternoon. Cross-pollinated flowers wilted independently of the hour of the day. The role of flower-wilting as a means of communication to the environment with regard to pollination of the style is discussed.