Isolated EF-loop III of calmodulin in a scaffold protein remains unpaired in solution using pulsed-field-gradient NMR spectroscopy

Calmodulin (CaM) is a trigger calcium-dependent protein that regulates many biological processes. We have successfully engineered a series of model proteins, each containing a single EF-hand loop but with increasing numbers of Gly residues linking the EF-hand loop to a scaffold protein, cluster of differentiation 2 (CD2), to obtain the site-specific calcium-binding ability of a protein with EF-hand motifs without the interference of cooperativity. Loop III of calmodulin with two Gly linkers in CD2 (CaM-CD2-III-5G) has metal affinities with K(d) values of 1.86 x 10(-4) and 5.8 x 10(-5) M for calcium and lanthanum, respectively. The oligomeric states of the CD2 variants were examined by pulsed-field-gradient nuclear magnetic resonance (PFG NMR). The diffusion coefficient values of CD2 variants are about 11.1 x 10(-7) cm(2)/s both in the presence and absence of metal ions, which are the same as that of wild-type CD2. This suggests that the isolated EF-loop III of calmodulin inserted in the scaffold protein is able to bind calcium and lanthanum as a monomer, which is in contrast to the previous observation of the EF-hand motif. Our results imply that additional factors that reside outside of the EF-loop III may contribute to the pairing of EF-hand motifs of calmodulin. This result is of interest as it opens up the way for studying the ion-binding properties of isolated EF-hands, which in turn can answer important questions about the properties of EF-hands, the large and important group of calcium-binding signaling proteins.     

A grafting approach to obtain site-specific metal-binding properties of EF-hand proteins

The EF-hand calcium-binding loop III from calmodulin was inserted with glycine linkers into the scaffold protein CD2.D1 at three locations to study site-specific calcium binding properties of EF-hand motifs. After insertion, the host protein retains its native structure and forms a 1:1 metal-protein complex for calcium and its analog, lanthanum. Tyrosine-sensitized Tb3+ energy transfer exhibits metal binding and La3+ and Ca2+ compete for the metal binding site. The grafted EF-loop III in different environments has similar La3+ binding affinities, suggesting that it is largely solvated and functions independently from the host protein.     

Engineering new metal specificity in EF-hand peptides

Peptides (33-34 amino acids long) corresponding to the helix-turn-helix (EF-hand) motif of the calcium binding site I of Paramecium tetraurelia calmodulin have been synthesized. The linear sequence was unable to acquire a native-like conformation and calcium binding. However, incorporation of a well-positioned disulfide bond bridging the two putative helical regions greatly improved the ordered structure and binding properties. Analyzed by electrospray mass spectrometry, circular dichroism and time-resolved laser-induced fluorescence, such a disulfide-stabilized peptide is shown to acquire a calcium-dependent helical conformation and exhibits native-like affinity for calcium, terbium and europium ions with 30+/-1, 3.5+/-0.6 and 0.6+/-0.1 microM dissociation constants, respectively. Comparable affinities were calculated within the biological construct comprising the entire domain I of Arabidopsis taliana calmodulin. Single sequence mutation (Glu25Asp) in the binding loop of the peptide abolishes calcium affinity, but preserves lanthanide affinity, showing that metal selectivity can be modulated by specific mutations. Such disulfide-stabilized peptides represent useful models to engineer metal specificity in new calmodulin proteins, facilitating the development of new systems to monitor metal pollution in biosensors and to increase metal binding capability of bacterial and plant cells in bioremediation techniques.     

Conformational and metal-binding properties of androcam, a testis-specific, calmodulin-related protein from Drosophila

Androcam is a testis-specific protein of Drosophila melanogaster, with 67% sequence identity to calmodulin and four potential EF-hand calcium-binding sites. Spectroscopic monitoring of the thermal unfolding of recombinant calcium-free androcam shows a biphasic process characteristic of a two-domain protein, with the apo-N-domain less stable than the apo-C-domain. The two EF hands of the C-domain of androcam bind calcium cooperatively with 40-fold higher average affinity than the corresponding calmodulin sites. Magnesium competes with calcium binding [Ka(Mg) approximately 3 x 10(3) M(-1)]. Weak calcium binding is also detected at one or more N-domain sites. Compared to apo-calmodulin, apo-androcam has a smaller conformational response to calcium and a lower alpha-helical content over a range of experimental conditions. Unlike calmodulin, a tryptic cleavage site in the N-domain of apo-androcam remains trypsin sensitive in the presence of calcium, suggesting an altered calcium-dependent conformational change in this domain. The affinity of model target peptides for androcam is 10(3)-10(5) times lower than for calmodulin, and interaction of the N-domain of androcam with these peptides is significantly reduced. Thus, androcam shows calcium-induced conformational responses typical of a calcium sensor, but its properties indicate calcium sensitivity and target interactions significantly different from those of calmodulin. From the sequence differences and the altered calcium-binding properties it is likely that androcam differs from calmodulin in the conformation of residues in the second calcium-binding loop. Molecular modeling supports the deduction that there are significant conformational differences in the N-domain of androcam compared to calmodulin, and that these could affect the surface, conferring a different specificity on androcam in target interactions related to testis-specific calcium signaling functions.     

Calcium and lanthanide affinity of the EF-loops from the C-terminal domain of calmodulin

To obtain site-specific information about individual EF-hand motifs, the EF-hand Ca(2+)-binding loops from site III and site IV of calmodulin (CaM) were inserted separately into a non-Ca(2+)-binding cell adhesion protein, domain 1 of CD2 (denoted as CaM-CD2-III-5G-52 and CaM-CD2-IV-5G-52). Structural analyses using various spectroscopic methods have shown that the host protein CD2 retains its native structure after the insertion of the 12-residue loops. The Tb(3+) fluorescence enhancement upon formation of a Tb(3+)-protein complex and the direct competition by La(3+) and Ca(2+) suggest that native Ca(2+)-binding pockets are formed in both engineered proteins. Moreover, as revealed by NMR, both Ca(2+) and La(3+) specifically interact with the residues at the grafted EF-loop. The CaM-CD2-III-5G-52 has stronger affinities to Ca(2+), Tb(3+) and La(3+) than CaM-CD2-IV-5G-52, indicating differential intrinsic metal-binding affinities of the EF-loops.     

Synthetic fragments of calmodulin calcium-binding site III. A test of the acid pair hypothesis

The acid pair hypothesis describing the interaction of calcium with the helix-loop-helix conformation of EF hands in calmodulin and related proteins predicts that these calcium-binding sites will have increased affinity for calcium if the anionic amino acid dentates in the loop region which interact directly with the cation are paired on the axial vertices of the resulting octahedral arrangement of chelating residues about the cation. As a test of this hypothesis, synthetic 33 residue analogs of bovine brain calmodulin calcium-binding site III have been prepared by the solid-phase method and analyzed for calcium affinity. The native sequence has a Kd of 735 microM for calcium and contains three anionic ligands which assume the +x, +y, and -z coordinates of the octahedral arrangement about the cation, thus precluding any pairing of the anionic ligands. This dissociation constant is 26 times weaker than that obtained from a synthetic analog of the sequentially homologous calcium-binding site III of rabbit skeletal TnC (Kd = 28 microM) which has four anionic ligands paired on the x and z axes. An analog of calmodulin site III with substitutions in the chelating residues at positions 1, 3, 5, 7, 9, and 12 of the 12-residue loop region to make these positions identical to those of rabbit skeletal troponin C site III decreased the calcium dissociation constant of the calmodulin peptide to 19 microM, similar to the troponin C peptide. Two synthetic analogs of calmodulin site III which contain three anionic ligands with two ligands paired on the x axis and two on the z axis have a Kd for calcium of 524 and 59 microM, respectively. This study provides strong support for and a better definition of the acid pair hypothesis and further demonstrates the usefulness of synthetic calcium-binding fragments in delineating the mechanism of calcium regulation of calmodulin and related proteins.     

Calcium binding proteins. Elucidating the contributions to calcium affinity from an analysis of species variants and peptide fragments

This paper describes the sequence homology of calcium-binding proteins belonging to the troponin C superfamily. Specifically, this similarity has been examined for 276 twelve-residue calcium-binding loops. It has been found that, in the calcium-binding loop, several residues appear invariant, regardless of the species of origin or the affinity of the protein. These residues are Asp at position 1 (+X of the coordinating position of the calcium), Asp or Asn at position 3 (+Y), Gly at position 6, Ile at position 8, and Glu at position 12 (-Z). It has also been found that conservation of certain residues can vary in similar sites in similar proteins. For example, position 3 (+Y) in site 3 of troponin C is always an Asn, whereas in calmodulin the residue is always Asp. This study also examined the calcium-binding affinities of peptide fragments comprising the loop, helix-loop, loop-helix, and helix-loop-helix. These were compared with larger enzymatic or chemically generated protein fragments in an effort to understand the various contributions to the calcium-binding affinity of a single-site versus a two-site domain as found in troponin C and calmodulin. Based on free energy differences, it was found that a 34-residue helix-loop-helix peptide represents about 60% of the binding affinity found in the intact protein. Cooperativity with a second calcium binding site accounted for the remaining 40% of the affinity.     

Structural basis for prokaryotic calcium- mediated regulation by a Streptomyces coelicolor calcium binding protein

The important and diverse regulatory roles of Ca²⁺ in eukaryotes are conveyed by the EF-hand containing calmodulin superfamily. However, the calcium-regulatory proteins in prokaryotes are still poorly understood. In this study, we report the three-dimensional structure of the calcium-binding protein from Streptomyces coelicolor, named CabD, which shares low sequence homology with other known helix-loop-helix EF-hand proteins. The CabD structure should provide insights into the biological role of the prokaryotic calcium-binding proteins. The unusual structural features of CabD compared with prokaryotic EF-hand proteins and eukaryotic sarcoplasmic calcium-binding proteins, including the bending conformation of the first C-terminal α-helix, unpaired ligand-binding EF-hands and the lack of the extreme C-terminal loop region, suggest it may have a distinct and significant function in calcium-mediated bacterial physiological processes, and provide a structural basis for potential calcium-mediated regulatory roles in prokaryotes.     

Identification of a dimeric intermediate in the unfolding pathway for the calcium-binding protein S100B

The S100 proteins comprise 25 calcium-signalling members of the EF-hand protein family. Unlike typical EF-hand signalling proteins such as calmodulin and troponin-C, the S100 proteins are dimeric, forming both homo- and heterodimers in vivo. One member of this family, S100B, is a homodimeric protein shown to control the assembly of several cytoskeletal proteins and regulate phosphorylation events in a calcium-sensitive manner. Calcium binding to S100B causes a conformational change involving movement of helix III in the second calcium-binding site (EF2) that exposes a hydrophobic surface enabling interactions with other proteins such as tubulin and Ndr kinase. In several S100 proteins, calcium binding also stabilizes dimerization compared to the calcium-free states. In this work, we have examined the guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl)-induced unfolding of dimeric calcium-free S100B. A series of tryptophan substitutions near the dimer interface and the EF2 calcium-binding site were studied by fluorescence spectroscopy and showed biphasic unfolding curves. The presence of a plateau near 1.5 M GuHCl showed the presence of an intermediate that had a greater exposed hydrophobic surface area compared to the native dimer based on increased 4,4-dianilino-1,1′-binaphthyl-5,5′-disulfonic acid fluorescence. Furthermore, ¹H-¹⁵N heteronuclear single quantum coherence analyses as a function of GuHCl showed significant chemical shift changes in regions near the EF1 calcium-binding loop and between the linker and C-terminus of helix IV. Together these observations show that calcium-free S100B unfolds via a dimeric intermediate.     

Long-range effects on calcium binding and conformational change in the N-domain of calmodulin

Proteins within the EF-hand protein family exhibit different conformational responses to Ca(2+) binding. Calmodulin and other members of the EF-hand protein family undergo major changes in conformation upon binding Ca(2+). However, some EF-hand proteins, such as calbindin D9k (Clb), bind Ca(2+) without a significant change in conformation. Here, we investigate the effects of replacement of a leucine at position 39 of the N-terminal domain of calmodulin (N-Cam) with a phenylalanine derived from Clb. This variant is studied alone and in the context of other mutations that affect the conformational properties of N-Cam. Strikingly, the introduction of Phe39, which is distant from the calcium binding sites, leads to a significant enhancement of Ca(2+) binding affinity, even in the context of other mutations which trap the protein in the closed form. The results yield novel insights into the evolution of EF-hand proteins as calcium sensors versus calcium buffers.     

Interleukin-11 binds specific EF-hand proteins via their conserved structural motifs

Interleukin-11 (IL-11) is a hematopoietic cytokine engaged in numerous biological processes and validated as a target for treatment of various cancers. IL-11 contains intrinsically disordered regions that might recognize multiple targets. Recently we found that aside from IL-11RA and gp130 receptors, IL-11 interacts with calcium sensor protein S100P. Strict calcium dependence of this interaction suggests a possibility of IL-11 interaction with other calcium sensor proteins. Here we probed specificity of IL-11 to calcium-binding proteins of various types: calcium sensors of the EF-hand family (calmodulin, S100B and neuronal calcium sensors: recoverin, NCS-1, GCAP-1, GCAP-2), calcium buffers of the EF-hand family (S100G, oncomodulin), and a non-EF-hand calcium buffer (α-lactalbumin). A specific subset of the calcium sensor proteins (calmodulin, S100B, NCS-1, GCAP-1/2) exhibits metal-dependent binding of IL-11 with dissociation constants of 1–19 μM. These proteins share several amino acid residues belonging to conservative structural motifs of the EF-hand proteins, ‘black’ and ‘gray’ clusters. Replacements of the respective S100P residues by alanine drastically decrease its affinity to IL-11, suggesting their involvement into the association process. Secondary structure and accessibility of the hinge region of the EF-hand proteins studied are predicted to control specificity and selectivity of their binding to IL-11. The IL-11 interaction with the EF-hand proteins is expected to occur under numerous pathological conditions, accompanied by disintegration of plasma membrane and efflux of cellular components into the extracellular milieu.     

Modulating the affinity and the selectivity of engineered calmodulin EF-Hand peptides for lanthanides

A set of engineered peptides (33 amino acids long) corresponding to the helix-turn-helix (EF-Hand) motif of the metal-binding site I of the protein calmodulin from paramecium tetraurelia have been synthesized. A disulfide bridge has been introduced in the native sequence in order to stabilize a native-like conformation. The calcium-binding carboxylate residues in positions 20, 22, 24, and 31 were mutated into other amino acids and the influence of such mutations on the binding affinity of the peptides for calcium and lanthanides have been studied. It was shown that the binding affinity for terbium ions can be modulated with dissociation constants ranging from 40 nmolar to 40 mmolar. The study of the influence of the mutations on the terbium affinity showed that the residue in position 24 played a key role on the capability of the peptides to bind lanthanides and that the affinity could be enhanced by mutations on non-coordinating positions. Such peptides with high affinity for lanthanides may facilitate the development of new highly sensitive biosensors to monitor the metal pollution in the environment.     

An interaction-based analysis of calcium-induced conformational changes in Ca2+ sensor proteins.

Calcium sensor proteins translate transient increases in intracellular calcium levels into metabolic or mechanical responses, by undergoing dramatic conformational changes upon Ca2+ binding. A detailed analysis of the calcium binding-induced conformational changes in the representative calcium sensors calmodulin (CaM) and troponin C was performed to obtain insights into the underlying molecular basis for their response to the binding of calcium. Distance difference matrices, analysis of interresidue contacts, comparisons of interhelical angles, and inspection of structures using molecular graphics were used to make unbiased comparisons of the various structures. The calcium-induced conformational changes in these proteins are dominated by reorganization of the packing of the four helices within each domain. Comparison of the closed and open conformations confirms that calcium binding causes opening within each of the EF-hands. A secondary analysis of the conformation of the C-terminal domain of CaM (CaM-C) clearly shows that CaM-C occupies a closed conformation in the absence of calcium that is distinct from the semi-open conformation observed in the C-terminal EF-hand domains of myosin light chains. These studies provide insight into the structural basis for these changes and into the differential response to calcium binding of various members of the EF-hand calcium-binding protein family. Factors contributing to the stability of the Ca2+-loaded open conformation are discussed, including a new hypothesis that critical hydrophobic interactions stabilize the open conformation in Ca2+ sensors, but are absent in "non-sensor" proteins that remain closed upon Ca2+ binding. A role for methionine residues in stabilizing the open conformation is also proposed.     

Conformation and structural transitions in the EF-hands of calmodulin

Calcium plays a key role in cellular signal transduction. Calmodulin, a protein binding four calcium ions, is found in all eukaryotic cells and is believed to activate such processes. The calcium binding loop found in this protein, the canonical EF-hand, is also found in a large number of other proteins such as troponins, parvalbumins, calbindins etc. Earlier analysis of the amino acid sequences of these proteins with a view of understanding evolution of protein families and signaling mechanisms have provided extensive evidence for a characteristic double gene duplication event in this family of proteins. These analyses have been extended here to the three dimensional structures and the biophysical properties of the sequence segments of calmodulin EF-hands. The clear evolutionary history that shows up in sequences is not reflected as clearly in the conformation of individual EF-hands, which may be a consequence of the much higher conservation pressure on the structure. Some evidence for the proposed gene duplication is implicit in the apo-holo structural transitions of the EF-hands. The profile of amino acid properties that might be significant for calcium binding, however, clearly reflects the gene duplication. These profiles might also provide insightful information on the calcium affinity of the EF-hand motifs and the nature of amino acid residues that constitute them.     

A 1.3-A structure of zinc-bound N-terminal domain of calmodulin elucidates potential early ion-binding step

Calmodulin (CaM) is a 16.8-kDa calcium-binding protein involved in calcium-signal transduction. It is the canonical member of the EF-hand family of proteins, which are characterized by a helix-loop-helix calcium-binding motif. CaM is composed of N- and C-terminal globular domains (N-CaM and C-CaM), and within each domain there are two EF-hand motifs. Upon binding calcium, CaM undergoes a significant, global conformational change involving reorientation of the four helix bundles in each of its two domains. This conformational change upon ion binding is a key component of the signal transduction and regulatory roles of CaM, yet the precise nature of this transition is still unclear. Here, we present a 1.3-Å structure of zinc-bound N-terminal calmodulin (N-CaM) solved by single-wavelength anomalous diffraction phasing of a selenomethionyl N-CaM. Our zinc-bound N-CaM structure differs from previously reported CaM structures and resembles calcium-free apo-calmodulin (apo-CaM), despite the zinc binding to both EF-hand motifs. Structural comparison with calcium-free apo-CaM, calcium-loaded CaM, and a cross-linked calcium-loaded CaM suggests that our zinc-bound N-CaM reveals an intermediate step in the initiation of metal ion binding at the first EF-hand motif. Our data also suggest that metal ion coordination by two key residues in the first metal-binding site represents an initial step in the conformational transition induced by metal binding. This is followed by reordering of the N-terminal region of the helix exiting from this first binding loop. This conformational switch should be incorporated into models of either stepwise conformational transition or flexible, dynamic energetic state sampling-based transition.     

An altered mode of calcium coordination in methionine-oxidized calmodulin

Oxidation of methionine residues in calmodulin (CaM) lowers the affinity for calcium and results in an inability to activate target proteins fully. To evaluate the structural consequences of CaM oxidation, we used infrared difference spectroscopy to identify oxidation-dependent effects on protein conformation and calcium liganding. Oxidation-induced changes include an increase in hydration of α-helices, as indicated in the downshift of the amide I′ band of both apo-CaM and Ca²⁺-CaM, and a modification of calcium liganding by carboxylate side chains, reflected in antisymmetric carboxylate band shifts. Changes in carboxylate ligands are consistent with the model we propose: an Asp at position 1 of the EF-loop experiences diminished hydrogen bonding with the polypeptide backbone, an Asp at position 3 forms a bidentate coordination of calcium, and an Asp at position 5 forms a pseudobridging coordination with a calcium-bound water molecule. The bidentate coordination of calcium by conserved glutamates is unaffected by oxidation. The observed changes in calcium ligation are discussed in terms of the placement of methionine side chains relative to the calcium-binding sites, suggesting that varying sensitivities of binding sites to oxidation may underlie the loss of CaM function upon oxidation.     

Molecular Tuning of an EF-Hand-like Calcium Binding Loop : Contributions of the Coordinating Side Chain at Loop Position 3

Calcium binding and signaling orchestrate a wide variety of essential cellular functions, many of which employ the EF-hand Ca²⁺ binding motif. The ion binding parameters of this motif are controlled, in part, by the structure of its Ca²⁺ binding loop, termed the EF-loop. The EF-loops of different proteins are carefully specialized, or fine-tuned, to yield optimized Ca²⁺ binding parameters for their unique cellular roles. The present study uses a structurally homologous Ca²⁺ binding loop, that of the Escherichia coli galactose binding protein, as a model for the EF-loop in studies examining the contribution of the third loop position to intramolecular tuning. 10 different side chains are compared at the third position of the model EF-loop with respect to their effects on protein stability, sugar binding, and metal binding equilibria and kinetics. Substitution of an acidic Asp side chain for the native Asn is found to generate a 6,000-fold increase in the ion selectivity for trivalent over divalent cations, providing strong support for the electrostatic repulsion model of divalent cation charge selectivity. Replacement of Asn by neutral side chains differing in size and shape each alter the ionic size selectivity in a similar manner, supporting a model in which large-ion size selectivity is controlled by complex interactions between multiple side chains rather than by the dimensions of a single coordinating side chain. Finally, the pattern of perturbations generated by side chain substitutions helps to explain the prevalence of Asn and Asp at the third position of natural EF-loops and provides further evidence supporting the unique kinetic tuning role of the gateway side chain at the ninth EF-loop position.     

The DxDxDG motif for calcium binding: multiple structural contexts and implications for evolution

Calcium ions regulate many cellular processes and have important structural roles in living organisms. Despite the great variety of calcium-binding proteins (CaBPs), many of them contain the same Ca(2+)-binding helix-loop-helix structure, referred to as the EF-hand. In the canonical EF-hand, the loop contains three calcium-binding aspartic acid residues, which form the DxDxDG sequence motif, and is flanked by two alpha-helices. Recently, other CaBPs containing the same motif, but lacking one or both helices, have been described. Here, structural motif searches were used to analyse the full diversity of structural context in the known set of DxDxDG-containing CaBPs, including those where the structural resemblance of a given DxDxDG motif to that of EF-hands had not been noted. The results obtained indicate that the EF-hand represents but one, among many, structural context for the DxDxDG-like Ca(2+)-binding loops. While the structural similarity of the binuclear calcium-binding sites in anthrax protective antigen and human thrombospondin suggests that they are homologous, evolutionary relationships for mononuclear sites are harder to discern. The possible scenarios for the evolution of DxDxDG motif-containing calcium-binding loops in a variety of non-homologous proteins suggested loop transplant as a mechanism perhaps responsible for much of the diversity in structural contexts of present day DxDxDG-type CaBPs. Additionally, while it can be shown that existence of a DxDxDG sequence is not enough to confer a conformation suitable for calcium binding, local convergent evolution may still have a role. The analysis presented here has consequences for the prediction of calcium binding from sequence alone.     

Characterization of a helix-loop-helix (EF hand) motif of silver hake parvalbumin isoform B.

Parvalbumins are a class of calcium-binding proteins characterized by the presence of several helix-loop-helix (EF-hand) motifs. It is suspected that these proteins evolved via intragene duplication from a single EF-hand. Silver hake parvalbumin (SHPV) consists of three EF-type helix-loop-helix regions, two of which have the ability to bind calcium. The three helix-loop-helix motifs are designated AB, CD, and EF, respectively. In this study, native silver hake parvalbumin isoform B (SHPV-B) has been sequenced by mass spectrometry. The sequence indicates that this parvalbumin is a beta-lineage parvalbumin. SHPV-B was cleaved into two major fragments, consisting of the ABCD and EF regions of the native protein. The 33-amino acid EF fragment (residues 76-108), containing one of the calcium ion binding sites in native SHPV-B, has been isolated and studied for its structural characteristics, ability to bind divalent and trivalent cations, and for its propensity to undergo metal ion-induced self-association. The presence of Ca2+ does not induce significant secondary structure in the EF fragment. However, NMR and CD results indicate significant secondary structure promotion in the EF fragment in the presence of the higher charge-density trivalent cations. Sedimentation equilibrium analysis results show that the EF fragment exists in a monomer-dimer equilibrium when complexed with La3+.