Responses of the model legume Medicago truncatula to the rhizobial exopolysaccharide succinoglycan

Many species of rhizobial bacteria can invade their plant hosts and induce development of symbiotic nitrogen-fixing nodules only if they are able to produce an acidic exopolysaccharide (EPS) with certain structural and molecular weight characteristics.^1–3 Sinorhizobium meliloti that produces the functional form of the exopolysaccharide succinoglycan induces formation of invasion structures called infection threads in the root hair cells of its plant hosts alfalfa and Medicago truncatula. However, S. meliloti mutants that cannot produce succinoglycan are not able to induce infection thread formation, resulting in an early arrest of nodule development and in nitrogen starvation of the plant. Mounting evidence has suggested that succinoglycan acts as a signal to these host plants to permit the entry of S. meliloti. Now, our microarray screen and functional category analysis of differentially-expressed genes show that M. truncatula plants inoculated with wild type S. meliloti receive a signal to increase their translation capacity, alter their metabolic activity and prepare for invasion, while those inoculated with a succinoglycan-deficient mutant do not receive this signal, and also more strongly express plant defense genes.Key words: nitrogen fixation, nodule, succinoglycan, microarray, legume, rhizobial bacteria, Sinorhizobium meliloti, Medicago truncatula, infection thread, root hair     

Rhizobium meliloti exopolysaccharide Mutants Elicit Feedback Regulation of Nodule Formation in Alfalfa

Nodule formation by wild-type Rhizobium meliloti is strongly suppressed in younger parts of alfalfa (Medicago sativum L.) root systems as a feedback response to development of the first nodules (G Caetano-Anollés, WD Bauer [1988] Planta 175: 546-557). Mutants of R. meliloti deficient in exopolysaccharide synthesis can induce the formation of organized nodular structures (pseudonodules) on alfalfa roots but are defective in their ability to invade and multiply within host tissues. The formation of empty pseudonodules by exo mutants was found to elicit a feedback suppression of nodule formation similar to that elicited by the wild-type bacteria. Inoculation of an exo mutant onto one side of a split-root system 24 hours before inoculation of the second side with wild-type cells suppressed wild-type nodule formation on the second side in proportion to the extent of pseudonodule formation by the exo mutants. The formation of pseudonodules is thus sufficient to elicit systemic feedback control of nodulation in the host root system: infection thread development and internal proliferation of the bacteria are not required for elicitation of feedback. Pseudonodule formation by the exo mutants was found to be strongly suppressed in split-root systems by prior inoculation on the opposite side with the wild type. Thus, feedback control elicited by the wild-type inhibits Rhizobium-induced redifferentiation of host root cells.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">tolC</Emphasis> mutant of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Sinorhizobium meliloti</Emphasis> strain CXM1-188 fails to establish effective symbiosis with alfalfa

The TolC mutant Tr63 of Sinorhizobium meliloti was generated by random Tn5 mutagenesis in the effective strain CXM1-188. The mutant did not produce fluorescent halos in UV light on the LB medium containing Calcofluor white, which suggests that modification occurred in the production of exopolysaccharide EPS1. Mutant Tr63 also manifested nonmucoidness both on minimal and low-phosphate MOPS media, and this was most likely connected with the absence of the second exopolysaccharide of S. meliloti (EPS2). The mutant was defective in symbiosis with alfalfa and formed on roots of host plants Medicago sativa and M. truncatula white round Fix^? nodules or nodules of irregular shape. These nodules possessed the structure usually described for nodules of EPS1 mutants. According to the data of sequencing a DNA fragment of the mutant adjacent to the transposon, Tr63 contained a Tn5 insertion in gene SMc02082 located on the S. meliloti chromosome. This gene encodes the protein sharing homology with the TolC protein, a component of a type I secretion system responsible for the export of protein toxins and proteases in Gram-negative bacteria. The presence of proteins ExsH (endoglycanase of EPS1) and protein ExpE1 (essential for excretion of EPS2), which are known to be exported by the type I secretion system, was tested in cultural supernatants of mutant Tr63 and the parental strain by polyclonal antiserum analysis. It was ascertained that secretory proteins ExsH and ExpE1 are absent in the culture medium of mutant Tr63. The TolC protein of S. meliloti is assumed to be involved in the excretion of proteins ExsH and ExpE1.     

Enhanced nodule initiation on alfalfa by wild-typeRhizobium meliloti co-inoculated withnod gene mutants and other bacteria

Nodule formation on alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) roots was determined at different inoculum dosages for wild-typeRhizobium meliloti strain RCR2011 and for various mutant derivatives with altered nodulation behavior. The number of nodules formed on the whole length of the primary roots was essentially constant regardless of initial inoculum dosage or subsequent bacterial multiplication, indicative of homeostatic regulation of total nodule number. In contrast, the number of nodules formed in just the initially susceptible region of these roots was sigmoidally dependent on the number of wild-type bacteria added, increasing rapidly at dosages above 5·10³ bacteria/plant. This behavior indicates the possible existence of a threshold barrier to nodule initiation in the host which the bacteria must overcome. When low dosages of the parent (10³ cells/plant) were co-inoculated with 10⁶ cells/plant of mutants lacking functionalnodA, nodC, nodE, nodF ornodH genes, nodule initiation was increased 10- to 30-fold. Analysis of nodule occupancy indicated that these mutants were able to help the parent (wild-type) strain initiate nodules without themselves occupying the nodules. Co-inoculation withR. trifolii orAgrobacterium tumefaciens cured of its Ti plasmid also markedly stimulated nodule initiation by theR. meliloti parent strain. Introduction of a segment of the symbiotic megaplasmid fromR. meliloti intoA. tumefaciens abolished this stimulation.Bradyrhizobium japonicum and a chromosomal Tn5 nod^- mutant ofR. meliloti did not significantly stimulate nodule initiation when co-inoculated with wild-typeR. meliloti. These results indicate that certainnod gene mutants and members of theRhizobiaceae may produce extracellular signals that supplement the ability of wild-typeR. meliloti cells to induce crucial responses in the host.Abbreviations EH emergent root hairs - kb kilobase - RDU relative distance unit - RT root tip This is journal article No. 188-87 of the Ohio Agricultural Research and Development Center     

Nodules Initiated by Rhizobium meliloti Exopolysaccharide Mutants Lack a Discrete, Persistent Nodule Meristem

Infection of alfalfa with Rhizobium meliloti exo mutants deficient in exopolysaccharide results in abnormal root nodules that are devoid of bacteria and fail to fix nitrogen. Here we report further characterization of these abnormal nodules. Tightly curled root hairs or shepherd's crooks were found after inoculation with Rm 1021-derived exo mutants, but curling was delayed compared with wild-type Rm 1021. Infection threads were initiated in curled root hairs by mutants as well as by wild-type R. meliloti, but the exo mutant-induced threads aborted within the peripheral cells of the developing nodule. Also, nodules elicited by Rm 1021-derived exo mutants were more likely to develop on secondary roots than on the primary root. In contrast with wild-type R. meliloti-induced nodules, the exo mutant-induced nodules lacked a well defined apical meristem, presumably due to the abortion of the infection threads. The relationship of these findings to the physiology of nodule development is discussed.     

Succinoglycan Is Required for Initiation and Elongation of Infection Threads during Nodulation of Alfalfa by Rhizobium meliloti

Rhizobium meliloti Rm1021 must be able to synthesize succinoglycan in order to invade successfully the nodules which it elicits on alfalfa and to establish an effective nitrogen-fixing symbiosis. Using R. meliloti cells that express green fluorescent protein (GFP), we have examined the nature of the symbiotic deficiency of exo mutants that are defective or altered in succinoglycan production. Our observations indicate that an exoY mutant, which does not produce succinoglycan, is symbiotically defective because it cannot initiate the formation of infection threads. An exoZ mutant, which produces succinoglycan without the acetyl modification, forms nitrogen-fixing nodules on plants, but it exhibits a reduced efficiency in the initiation and elongation of infection threads. An exoH mutant, which produces symbiotically nonfunctional high-molecular-weight succinoglycan that lacks the succinyl modification, cannot form extended infection threads. Infection threads initiate at a reduced rate and then abort before they reach the base of the root hairs. Overproduction of succinoglycan by the exoS96::Tn5 mutant does not reduce the efficiency of infection thread initiation and elongation, but it does significantly reduce the ability of this mutant to colonize the curled root hairs, which is the first step of the invasion process. The exoR95::Tn5 mutant, which overproduces succinoglycan to an even greater extent than the exoS96::Tn5 mutant, has completely lost its ability to colonize the curled root hairs. These new observations lead us to propose that succinoglycan is required for both the initiation and elongation of infection threads during nodule invasion and that excess production of succinoglycan interferes with the ability of the rhizobia to colonize curled root hairs.     

Derivatives of Rhizobium meliloti strains carrying a plasmid of Rhizobium leguminosarum specifying hydrogen uptake and pea-specific symbiotic functions

pIJ1008, a Rhizobium leguminosarum plasmid which determines hydrogen uptake ability and symbiotic functions in pea was transferable to three of seven natural isolates of R. meliloti tested. In these three strains, pIJ1008 was maintained stably with the respective sym megaplasmid indigenous to each R. meliloti strain. These strains carrying both plasmids nodulated alfalfa but not pea. By reisolation and examination of the strains from alfalfa nodule tissue, it was shown that pIJ1008 continued to be maintained but that pea-nodulation ability was suppressed.In one strain of R. meliloti which carries a 200 kb cryptic plasmid (in addition to a megaplasmid), the transfer and selection for pIJ1008 resulted in the loss of the cryptic plasmid.In three separate plant growth experiments, alfalfa nodules induced by each of the R. meliloti strain carrying both sym plasmids were assayed for hydrogen uptake activity. The average activity was 40-, 3.5-and 2-fold higher than with the respective pIJ1008-free strains. However, this higher activity was not accompanied by an increase in plant biomass or nitrogen content of shoots.C.B.R.I. Contribution Number: 1478     

Symbiotic effectiveness of Rhizobium meliloti at low root temperature

Laboratory, growth chamber and field experiments were conducted to select among 226 isolates of Rhizobium meliloti for the ability to grow, nodulate alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) and support N₂-dependent plant growth between 9° and 12°C. There was wide variation in the abilities of R. meliloti isolates to grow and form nodules at 10°C. Culture doubling times (t_d) varied from 1 to 155h, and the number of nodules formed on alfalfa in growth pouches in 2 weeks varied from 0 to 3.8 nodules per plant. Nodulation occurred at 9°C, but there was no significant N₂-dependent plant growth at this temperature. However, several isolates of R. meliloti had the ability to nodulate alfalfa and produce N₂-dependent growth at root temperatures between 10° and 12°C root temperature than did 14 other isolates tested. In field experiments, inoculation with strain NRG-34 resulted in greater nodule numbers, nodule weight, proportion of nodules occupied by the inoculant strain and plant weight than did inoculation with a commercial strain (NRG-185). These results permitted selection of a strain with better low-temperature competitive abilities than the currently available commercial strains.     

Rhizobium meliloti nodulation genes allow Agrobacterium tumefaciens and Escherichia coli to form pseudonodules on alfalfa.

Regions of the Rhizobium meliloti symbiotic plasmid (20 to 40 kilobase pairs long) containing nodulation (nod) genes were transferred to Agrobacterium tumefaciens or Escherichia coli by conjugation. The A. tumefaciens and E. coli transconjugants elicited root hair curling and the formation of ineffective pseudonodules on inoculated alfalfa plants. A tumefaciens elicited pseudonodules formed at a variable frequency, ranging from 15 to 45%, irrespective of the presence of the Ti plasmid. These pseudonodules developed characteristic nodule meristems, and in some nodules, infection threads were found within the interior of nodules. Infrequently, infection threads penetrated deformed root hairs, but these threads were found only in a minority of nodules. There was no evidence of bacterial release from the infection threads. In addition to being found within threads, agrobacteria were also found in intercellular spaces and within nodule cells that had senesced . In the latter case, the bacteria appeared to invade the nodule cells independently of infection threads and degenerated at the same time as the senescing host cells. No peribacteroid membranes enclosed any agrobacteria , and no bacteroid differentiation was observed. In contrast to the A. tumefaciens-induced pseudonodules , the E. coli-induced pseudonodules were completely devoid of bacteria; infection threads were not found to penetrate root hairs or within nodules. Our results suggest that relatively few Rhizobium genes are involved in the earliest stages of nodulation, and that curling of root hairs and penetration of bacteria via root hair infection threads are not prerequisites for nodule meristem formation in alfalfa.     

A block in the endocytosis of Rhizobium allows cellular differentiation in nodules but affects the expression of some peribacteroid membrane nodulins

A transposon-induced mutant (T8-1) of Bradyrhizobium japonicum (61A76) was unable to develop into the nitrogen-fixing endosymbiotic form, the bacteroid. Comparison between this mutant and T5-95, an ineffective (non-nitrogen fixing, Fix^-) mutant, confirmed that the process of bacteroid development is a distinct phase of differentiation of the endosymbiont and is independent of nitrogen fixation activity. The T8-1 mutant was able to induce normal-size nodules which differentiated two plant cell types and contained numerous infection threads. However, the infected cells were devoid of bacteroids. Electron microscopy revealed that the ends of the infection threads were broken down in a normal manner once the thread had penetrated the cells, but the mutant was not internalized by endocytosis. The lack of peribacteroid membrane (PBM) in nodules induced by this mutant was correlated with a reduced level of expression of plant genes coding for PBM nodulins. These genes were expressed in the T5-95 mutant, showing that the low expression in T8-1 was not due to the lack of nitrogen fixation. One of the PBM nodulins, nodulin-26, was found at normal levels in the nodules which lack PBM, suggesting that there are at least two developmental stages in PBM biosynthesis. These data suggest that a coordination of plant and Rhizobium gene expression is required for the release and internalization of bacteria into the PBM compartments of infected cells of nodules.author for correspondence     

Morphogenesis of lucerne root nodules incited by Rhizobium meliloti in the presence of combined nitrogen

Combined light and transmission electron microscopy were used to examine the effect of nitrate on the development of root nodules in lucerne (alfalfa, Medicago sativa L.) following induction by the nitrogen-fixing symbiont, Rhizobium meliloti. The timing of NO ₃ ^- addition was varied in order to study its effect on all of the recognized morphogenetic steps of nodule formation. Roots of plants inoculated in the presence of 18 mM NO ₃ ^- had straight root hairs which were devoid of adherent rhizobia and infection threads, and developed no nodules. However, nodules were formed on roots if 18 mM NO ₃ ^- was added 5 d after inoculation. At this time, the initiation of nodule primordia had already commenced in the root cortex. The histology and ultrastructure of young nodules which had developed for 5 d in the absence of NO ₃ ^- and another 5 d in the presence of 18 mM NO ₃ ^- resembled nodules developing under N-free conditions, except that in the infection threads within the infection zone of the nodule 1) some bacteria tended to loose their normal shape and gain more electron density, indicating premature degradation, and 2) the matrix of the infection threads was abnormally enlarged. In the presence of high NO ₃ ^- levels in the medium, lysis and degeneration of the bacteria released from the infection threads were observed in the infection and bacteroid zones of developing nodules, indicative of premature senescence. On the other hand, the nodule meristems continued to proliferate even after 12 d of exposure of 18 mM NO ₃ ^- . This was the only morphogenetic step of root nodulation which was insensitive to levels of combined nitrogen that completely prevented infection if present at the time of inoculation. These data indicate that all of the recognized steps of root nodule morphogenesis in which the bacteria play a key role are sensitive to the inhibitory effect of combined nitrogen.     

Regulation of Nodulation by Rhizobium meliloti 102F15 on Its Mutant Which Forms an Unusually High Number of Nodules on Alfalfa

A mutant (WL3A150) of Rhizobium meliloti 102F51 that elicits an unusually high number of nodules on its host, alfalfa (Medicago sativa), supports the idea that the host may rely on early bacteroid development in the nodule or on metabolites produced in the infection thread as one of the signals to control further nodulation. This mutant was initially isolated because of its Fix⁻ phenotype. It consistently formed many more nodules than all the other Fix⁻ mutants isolated from strain 102F51 (a total of 11 mutants). Nodules formed by this mutant were small and white and were indistinguishable in appearance from nodules formed by the other Fix⁻ mutants. An ultrastructural study of the nodules, however, showed that this mutant, although forming numerous infection threads, failed to develop into bacteroids. The ability of the mutant to form an unusually high number of nodules coulde be suppressed in a time-dependent manner by the presence of the wild type.     

The Rhizobium meliloti early nodulation genes (nodABC) are nitrogen-regulated: Isolation of a mutant strain with efficient nodulation capacity on alfalfa in the presence of ammonium

Summary The presence of combined nitrogen in the soil suppresses the formation of nitrogen-fixing root nodules by Rhizobium. We demonstrate that bacterial genes determining early nodulation functions (nodABC) as well as the regulatory gene nodD3 are under nitrogen (NH ₄ ⁺ ) control. Our results suggest that the gene product of nodD3 has a role in mediating the ammonia regulation of early nod genes. The general nitrogen regulatory (ntr) system as well as a chromosomal locus mutated in Rhizobium meliloti were also found to be involved in the regulation of nod gene expression. A R. meliloti mutant with altered sensitivity to ammonia regulation was isolated, capable of more efficient nodulation of alfalfa than the wild-type strain in the presence of 2 mM ammonium sulfate.     

Microscopic studies of cell divisions induced in alfalfa roots by Rhizobium meliloti

We have used spot-inoculation and new cytological procedures to observe the earliest events stimulated in alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) roots by Rhizobium meliloti. Roots were inoculated with 1–10 nl of concentrated bacteria, fixed in paraformaldehyde, and after embedding and sectioning stained with a combination of acridine orange and DAPI (4-6-diamidino-2-phenylindole hydrochloride). Normal R. meliloti provoke cell dedifferentiation and mitosis in the inner cortex of the root within 21–24 h after inoculation. This activation of root cells spreads progressively, leading to nodule formation. In contrast, the R. meliloti nodA and nodC mutants do not stimulate any activation or mitosis. Thus the primary and earliest effect of Rhizobium nod gene action is plant cellular activation. A rapid, whole-mount visualization by lactic acid shows that the pattern of nodule form varies widely. Some R. meliloti strains were found to be capable of stimulating on alfalfa roots both normal nodules and a hybrid structure intermediate between a nodule and a lateral root.     

Localization of acid phosphatase activity in the apoplast of pea (Pisum sativum L.) root nodules grown under phosphorus deficiency

ACPase activity was localized in the apoplast of pea root nodules under phosphorus deficiency. Pea plants (Pisum sativum L. cv. Sze ciotygodniowy) where inoculated with Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae 248 and were cultured on nitrogen-free medium with phosphate (−N/+P) or phosphate-deficient (−N/−P) one. In comparison with control nodules, P-deficient nodules showed the increase of ACPase activity in plant cell walls and the infection threads. The increase in bacterial ACPase activity under P-deficiency may reflect higher demand for inorganic phosphorus that is necessary for bacteria multiplication within the infection threads. The increase of ACPase activity in nodule apoplast under P stress may enlarge the availability of phosphate for plant and bacteria.     

Rhizobium fix genes mediate at least two communication steps in symbiotic nodule development

To identify bacterial genes involved in symbiotic nodule development, ineffective nodules of alfalfa (Medicago sativa) induced by 64 different Fix-mutants of Rhizobium meliloti were characterized by assaying for symbiotic gene expression and by morphological studies. The expression of leghemoglobin and nodulin-25 genes from alfalfa and of the nifHD genes from R. meliloti were monitored by hybridizing the appropriate DNA probes to RNA samples prepared from nodules. The mutants were accordingly divided into three groups. In group I none of the genes were expressed, in group II only the plant genes were expressed and in group III all three genes were transcribed. Light and electron microscopical analysis of nodules revealed that nodule development was halted at different stages in nodules induced by different group I mutants. In most cases nodules were empty lacking infection threads and bacteroids or nodules contained infection threads and a few released bacteroids. In nodules induced by a third mutant class bacteria were released into the host cells, however the formation of the peribacteroid membrane was not normal. On this basis we suggest that peribacteroid membrane formation precedes leghemoglobin and nodulin-25 induction, moreover, after induction of nodulation by the nod genes at least two communication steps between the bacteria and the host plants are necessary for the development of the mature nodule. By complementing each mutant of group I with a genomic R. meliloti library made in pLAFRl, four new fix loci were identified, indicating that several bacterial genes are involved in late nodule development.     

Two classes of Rhizobium meliloti infection mutants differ in exopolysaccharide production and in coinoculation properties with nodulation mutants

Summary Symbiotic mutants of Rhizobium meliloti were isolated following Tn5 mutagenesis. Besides four nodulation mutants (Nod^-) unable to induce nodule formation on alfalfa, five infection mutants (Inf^-), which induce the formation of root nodules without detectable infection threads or bacteroids, were obtained. The Inf^- mutants were subdivided into two classes. One class contains mutants which fail to synthesize acidic exopolysaccharide (EPS^-). The other class is comprised of mutants which produce excess amounts of acidic exopolysaccharide (EPS^*). ¹³C nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy of the exopolysaccharide isolated from one of the latter type of Inf^- mutant, 101.45, revealed that the side chain of the repeating octosaccharide unit lacks the terminal pyruvate residue. Complementing cosmids were isolated for all Inf^- mutants. In the case of the Inf^- EPS^- mutants the complementing cosmids contain DNA segments which overlap and are part of megaplasmid 2. For two mutants the mutations were found to map on a 7.8 kb EcoRI fragment. In the case of the Inf^- EPS^* mutants the complementing cosmids carry chromosomal DNA. The mutations of two Inf^- EPS^* mutants were localized on a 6.4 kb EcoRI fragment. Coinoculation of alfalfa plants with Nod^- and Inf^- EPS^- mutants resulted in effective symbiosis. The nodules appeared wild type and fixed nitrogen. In constrast, coinoculations with Nod^- mutants and the Inf^- EPS^* mutant 101.45 did not result in the formation of effective nodules.     

Analysis of the Rhizobium meliloti exoH/exoK/exoL fragment: ExoK shows homology to excreted endo-β-1,3-1,4-glucanases and ExoH resembles membrane proteins

Nucleotide sequencing of a 4.15 kb DNA fragment from megaplasmid 2 of Rhizobium meliloti 2011 revealed the location of the genes exoH, exoK and exoL. The putative proteins encoded by these genes have molecular weights of 41, 30, and 44 kDa, respectively. The hydrophobicity profile of the ExoH amino acid sequence resembles that of transmembrane proteins. The predicted exoL gene product does not contain hydrophobic regions, indicating a cytoplasmic localization. The exoK gene product is characterized by a putative signal peptide and exhibits significant homology to endo-β-1,3 1,4-glucanases of bacilli and Clostridium thermocellum. R. meliloti exoK mutants induced pink nodules and synthesized a reduced amount of exopolysaccharide (EPS). Colonies of this mutant showed a delay in the appearance of the Calcofluor white fluorescence. In addition, the formation of the characteristic halo was strongly delayed. R. meliloti exoL and exoH mutants induced pseudonodules. The exoH, but not the exoL mutant, synthesized an EPS that could be precipitated by cetyl pyridinium chloride (CPC) and also by ethanol. Plasmid integration mutagenesis revealed promoter regions preceding exoH, exoK and exoL.