Regulation of Newly Evolved Enzymes. III Evolution of the ebg Repressor during Selection for Enhanced Lactase Activity

The evolution of lactose utilization by lacZ deletion strains of E. coli occurs via mutations in the ebg genes. We show that one kind of mutation in the regulatory gene ebgR results in a repressor which retains the ability to repress synthesis of ebg enzymes, but which permits 4.5-fold more ebg enzyme synthesis during lactose induction than does the wild-type repressor. A comparison between the growth rate of various ebg+ strains on lactose and the amount of ebg enzyme synthesized by these strains shows that the rate of enzyme synthesis permitted by the wild-type repressor is insufficient for growth on lactose as a sole carbon source by a cell with the most active ebg lactase yet isolated. We conclude, therefore, that the evolution of lactose utilization requires both a structural and a regulatory mutation.     

On the Evolution of New Metabolic Functions in Diploid Organisms

Evolution of lactose utilization via the ebg system of Escherichia coli requires both structural gene (ebgA) and regulatory gene (ebgR) mutations. Because evolution of new metabolic functions in diploids might be subject to constraints not present in haploid organisms, merodiploid strains carrying a wild-type and an evolved ebgA allele, or a wild-type and an evolved ebgR allele were constructed. I show that heterozygosity at ebgA does not significantly affect the selective advantage of the evolved ebgA allele; whereas heterozygosity at ebgR eliminates the selective advantage of the evolved ebgR allele. It is suggested that, in diploid organisms, evolution of new functions for systems under negative control would be very difficult.     

Polarity suppressors increase expression of the wild-type tryptophan operon of Escherichia coli

Three new polarity suppressors, selected to relieve the polar effect of nonsense mutations in the tryptophan (trp) and lactose (lac) operons of Escherichia coli, increase expression distal to nonsense mutations in both operons to a greater extent than suA. These suppressors relieve the polarity created by amber, ochre and frameshift mutations with equal efficiency.Two of the three polarity suppressors elevate enzyme synthesis in the wildtype trp operon two- and fivefold, respectively. The increase in enzyme levels is in each case correlated with increased levels and rates of synthesis of structural gene trp messenger RNA. Since expression of all genes is elevated, these findings suggest the existence of a site early in the wild-type trp operon that affects the extent of operon expression. We located the site affected by these two polarity suppressors between the operator and the first structural gene, trpE. Although the third polarity suppressor also relieves mutational polarity efficiently, it has no detectable effect on expression of the wild-type trp operon.     

Experimental Evolution of a New Enzymatic Function. II. Evolution of Multiple Functions for EBG Enzyme in E. COLI

The evolution of ebgo enzyme of Escherichia coli, an enzyme which is unable to hydrolyze lactose, lactulose, lactobionate, or galactose-arabinoside effectively, has been directed in successive steps so that the evolved enzyme is able to hydrolyze these galactosides effectively. I show that in order for a strain of E. coli with a lacZ deletion to evolve the ability to use lactobionate as a carbon source, a series of mutations must occur in the ebg genes, and that these mutations must be selected in a particular order. The ordered series of mutations constitutes an obligatory evolutionary pathway for the acquisition of a new function for ebgo enzyme. A comparison of newly evolved strains with parental strains shows that when ebg enzyme acquires a new function, its old functions often suffer; but that in several cases old functions are either unaffected or are improved. I conclude that divergence of functions catalyzed by an enzyme need not require gene duplication.     

Regulation of Newly Evolved Enzymes. IV. Directed Evolution of the EBG Repressor

In Escherichia coli, the wild-type repressor of ebg (evolved beta-galactosidase) enzyme synthesis, specified by the ebgR+ gene, responds very weakly to lactulose (fructose-beta-D-galactopyranoside). Selection for a functional repressor that responds strongly to lactulose as an inducer reveals the existence of ebgR+L mutants, which occur spontaneously at a frequency of about 2 X 10(-10) . EBGR+L mutants are pleiotropic in that they specify ebg repressor with a greatly increased response to lactulose, lactose, galactose-arabinoside and methyl-galactoside as inducers. Selection of ebgR+L mutants is discussed within the framework of directed evolution of a regulatory function.     

Isolation of mutant promoters in the Escherichia coli galactose operon using local mutagenesis on cloned DNA fragments

We have worked out a system to obtain mutations that map in the promoter region of the Escherichia coli galactose operon. In order to easily detect small changes in gal promoter activity, we constructed a plasmid containing an operon fusion in which the lactose operon structural genes were controlled by the galactose operon promoter region. In cells harbouring this plasmid, even modest variations in the expression of the lac genes could be detected on MacConkey lactose indicator plates.Enrichment for mutations that map in the promoter segment of the galactose operon was achieved by mutagenesis in vitro of a small fragment of DNA covering the promoter region. After insertion of the mutagenized gal promoter fragment into the gal-lac fusion plasmid, lac^?1 cells were transformed and screened for an altered Lac⁺ phenotype on indicator plates. Several mutants were isolated due to lesions mapping in the small fragment covering the galactose promoter. In these mutants, the level of β-galactosidase was between 15 and 50% of the wild-type level.The mutant promoters were subsequently reinserted into a plasmid containing the intact galactose operon. Cells harbouring such plasmids, reconstituted with mutant galactose promoters, contained decreased levels of galactokinase that paralleled the decreases in β-galactosidase. The biochemical properties of these mutants are reported in the accompanying paper (Busby et al., 1982).     

A kinetic model for interaction of regulatory proteins and RNA polymerase with the control region of the lac operon of Escherichia coli.

The proposed model deals with kinetic aspects of the interaction of repressor, CRP and RNA polymerase with the control region of the lactose operon and is formulated as a system of linear differential equations. Several variants of the model are considered. They differ in the assumed mechanisms which limit expression of the operon (due to diffusion of the molecules of polymerase to the promoter and/or due to a specific interaction of polymerase and promoter) and in the existence or non-existence of an indirect interaction between the molecules of repressor and CRP, when they are bound to the control region. An analysis of the model provides a unified interpretation for several phenomena connected with regulation of the lactose operon, in particular, for the dependence of expression on concentrations of regulatory proteins and for different patterns of expression in vivo and in vitro for a class of promoter mutations.     

A high-resolution electron microscopy study of nucleosomes from simian virus 40 chromatin

The DNA sequence changes of 31 mutations altering the attenuation control mechanism of the histidine operon are presented. These mutations are discussed in terms of a model for operon regulation that involves a his leader peptide gene whose translation regulates formation of alternative stem-loop structures in the his leader messenger RNA. Three suppressible mutations generate nonsense codons (ochre and UGA) in the his leader peptide gene, demonstrating that translation of this gene is essential for operon expression. Eight mutations presumably reduce the efficiency of translation initiation of the his leader peptide gene, causing reduced levels of operon expression. Five of these mutations directly alter the leader peptide gene initiator codon (AUG). Three mutations alter sequences just in front of the initiator codon and presumably alter the ribosome recognition site. Fourteen mutations reduce the stability of the his leader mRNA stem-loop structures that are alternatives to the attenuator stem. The properties of these mutations provide support for the role of these stem-loop structures in preventing formation of the attenuator stem. Finally, we show that mutations that alter the attenuator stem suppress hisO mutations. This lends support to the proposal that these hisO mutations cause reduced levels of operon expression due to excessive attenuator stem formation. The properties of these 31 mutations provide substantial support for the model of his operon regulation described in this paper.     

Regulation of Newly Evolved Enzymes II. the EBG Repressor

The ebg (evolved β-galactosidase) regulatory locus has been mapped. The map order is argG–ebgA–ebgR–tolC–metC , and there is 1.6% recombination between ebgR and ebgA . Studies with ebgR^-/ebgR⁺ merdiploids have shown that ebgR^- is recessive, and it is concluded that the synthesis of ebg enzyme is under negative control.     

Galactose Metabolism by Streptococcus mutans

The galK gene, encoding galactokinase of the Leloir pathway, was insertionally inactivated in Streptococcus mutans UA159. The galK knockout strain displayed only marginal growth on galactose, but growth on glucose or lactose was not affected. In strain UA159, the sugar phosphotransferase system (PTS) for lactose and the PTS for galactose were induced by growth in lactose and galactose, although galactose PTS activity was very low, suggesting that S. mutans does not have a galactose-specific PTS and that the lactose PTS may transport galactose, albeit poorly. To determine if the galactose growth defect of the galK mutant could be overcome by enhancing lactose PTS activity, the gene encoding a putative repressor of the operon for lactose PTS and phospho-β-galactosidase, lacR, was insertionally inactivated. A galK and lacR mutant still could not grow on galactose, although the strain had constitutively elevated lactose PTS activity. The glucose PTS activity of lacR mutants grown in glucose was lower than in the wild-type strain, revealing an influence of LacR or the lactose PTS on the regulation of the glucose PTS. Mutation of the lacA gene of the tagatose pathway caused impaired growth in lactose and galactose, suggesting that galactose can only be efficiently utilized when both the Leloir and tagatose pathways are functional. A mutation of the permease in the multiple sugar metabolism operon did not affect growth on galactose. Thus, the galactose permease of S. mutans is not present in the gal, lac, or msm operons.     

Isolation and characterization of the newly evolved ebg beta-galactosidase of Escherichia coli K-12.

The ebg beta-galactosidase of Escherichia coli K-12 strain LC110 has been purified and characterized. Strain LC110 is a Lac+ revertant of a mutant with a deletion of the lacZ beta-galactosidase gene. Its new ebg beta-galactosidase activity was shown to be due to a discrete protein, immunologically unrelated to lacZ beta-galactosidase. Its kinetics of action conformed to those of a simple conventional enzyme. With o-nitrophenyl-beta-D-galactoside as substrate, the Vmax was 11,200 nmol/min per mg of enzyme, the Km was 5 mM, and the activation energy was 12,400 cal/mol. Corresponding values for lacZ beta-galactosidase of wild-type E. coli K-12 were 350,000 nmol/min per mg of enzyme, 1.3 mM, and 8,000 cal/mol. A series of sugars has been examined as competitive inhibitors of ebg beta-galactosidase. Kinetic analyses suggest that ebg beta-galactosidase has a particularly high affinity for galactosamine and gamma-galactonolactone, binds galatose more tightly than lactose, and shows a general preference for monosaccharides rather than beta-galactosides. We conclude that the ebg beta-galactosidase may have arisen by modification of a gene involved with the metabolism of a monosaccharide, possibly a 2-amino sugar.     

Integrative Food-Grade Expression System Based on the Lactose Regulon of Lactobacillus casei

The lactose operon from Lactobacillus casei is regulated by very tight glucose repression and substrate induction mechanisms, which made it a tempting candidate system for the expression of foreign genes or metabolic engineering. An integrative vector was constructed, allowing stable gene insertion in the chromosomal lactose operon of L. casei. This vector was based on the nonreplicative plasmid pRV300 and contained two DNA fragments corresponding to the 3′ end of lacG and the complete lacF gene. Four unique restriction sites were created, as well as a ribosome binding site that would allow the cloning and expression of new genes between these two fragments. Then, integration of the cloned genes into the lactose operon of L. casei could be achieved via homologous recombination in a process that involved two selection steps, which yielded highly stable food-grade mutants. This procedure has been successfully used for the expression of the E. coli gusA gene and the L. lactis ilvBN genes in L. casei. Following the same expression pattern as that for the lactose genes, β-glucuronidase activity and diacetyl production were repressed by glucose and induced by lactose. This integrative vector represents a useful tool for strain improvement in L. casei that could be applied to engineering fermentation processes or used for expression of genes for clinical and veterinary uses.     

Identification of the protein acetyltransferase (Pat) enzyme that acetylates acetyl-CoA synthetase in Salmonella enterica

Post-translational modification of proteins is an efficient way cells use to control the activity of structural proteins, gene expression regulatory proteins, and enzymes. In eukaryotes, the Sir2-dependent system of protein acetylation/deacetylation controls a number of processes that affect cell longevity. Sir2 proteins have NAD⁺-dependent protein deacetylase activity and are found in all forms of life. Although the identity of the acetyltransferases that partner with Sir2 enzymes is known in eukaryotes, the identity of the prokaryotic acetyltransferases is not. We report the identification of the gene of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium LT2 encoding the major protein acetyltransferase (Pat) enzyme that, in concert with the CobB sirtuin of this bacterium, regulates the activity of the central metabolic enzyme acetyl-coenzyme A synthetase (Acs). The Pat enzyme uses acetyl-CoA as substrate to modify residue Lys609 of Acs. The Pat/CobB system of S. enterica should serve as the paradigm to further investigate the contributions of this system to the physiology of prokaryotes.     

A mutant Ebg enzyme that converts lactose into an inducer of the lac operon.

Lactose is not itself an inducer of the lac operon, nor is it converted to an inducer by ebg+ beta-galactosidase of Escherichia coli. We report here the isolation of a mutant Ebg beta-galactosidase which is capable of converting lactose into an inducer of the lac operon.     

DNA Sequence Analysis of Artificially Evolved Ebg Enzyme and Ebg Repressor Genes

The ebg system has been used as a model to study the artificial selection of new catalytic functions of enzymes and of inducer specificities of repressors. A series of mutant enzymes with altered catalytic specificities were previously characterized biochemically as were the changes in inducer specificities of mutant, but fully functional, repressors. The wild type ebg operon has been sequenced, and the sequence differences of the mutant enzymes and repressors have been determined. We now report that, contrary to our previous understanding, ebg enzyme contains 180-kD alpha-subunits and 20-kD beta-subunits, both of which are required for full activity. Mutations that dramatically affect substrate specificity and catalytic efficiency lie in two distinct regions, both well outside of the active site region. Mutations that affect inducer specificity of the ebg repressor lie within predicted sugar binding domains. Comparisons of the ebg beta-galactosidase and repressor with homologous proteins of the Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae lac operons, and with the galactose operon repressor, suggest that the ebg and lac operons diverged prior to the divergence of E. coli from Klebsiella. One case of a triple substitution as the consequence of a single event is reported, and the implications of that observation for mechanisms of spontaneous mutagenesis are discussed.     

Use of lac operon fusions to isolate Escherichia coli mutants with altered expression of the fumarate reductase system in response to substrate and respiratory controls.

Strains of $\text{E}\text{.}\text{coli}$ with fusions between the $\text{lac}$ structural genes and the promoter region of the fumarate reductase system were constructed from a parental strain deleted in the native $\text{lac}$ operon. Like fumarate reductase in wild-type cells, β-galactosidase in these fusion strains is inducible by fumarate, but only under anaerobic conditions. From one of these strains, three classes of mutants altered in the expression of the hybrid operon were isolated. By anaerobic selection for growth on lactose in the absence of fumarate, mutants that synthesize β-galactosidase constitutively both aerobically and anaerobically were obtained. By aerobic selection for growth on lactose in the presence of fumarate, mutants that are inducible in the enzyme both aerobically and anaerobically and mutants that are inducible in the enzyme only aerobically were obtained. The regulatory behaviors of the mutants studied suggest that substrate and respiratory control of the expression of the fumarate reductase complex are mechanistically connected.     

Bistable behavior in a model of the lac operon in Escherichia coli with variable growth rate

This work is a continuation from another study previously published in this journal. Both the former and the present works are dedicated to investigating the bistable behavior of the lac operon in Escherichia coli from a mathematical modeling point of view. In the previous article, we developed a detailed mathematical model that accounts for all of the known regulatory mechanisms in this system, and studied the effect of inducing the operon with lactose instead of an artificial inducer. In this article, the model is improved to account, in a more detailed way, for the interaction of the repressor molecules with the three lac operators. A recently discovered cooperative interaction between the CAP molecule (an activator of the lactose operon) and Operator 3 (which influences DNA folding) is also included in this new version of the model. The growth rate dependence on the rate of energy entering the bacteria (in the form of transported glucose molecules and of metabolized lactose molecules) is also considered. A large number of numerical experiments is carried out with this improved model. The results are discussed in regard to the bistable behavior of the lactose operon. Special attention is paid to the effect that a variable growth rate has on the system dynamics.