Mass spectrometry-based quantification and spatial localization of small organic acid exudates in plant roots under phosphorus deficiency and aluminum toxicity

Low-molecular-weight organic acid (OA) extrusion by plant roots is critical for plant nutrition, tolerance to cations toxicity, and plant–microbe interactions. Therefore, methodologies for the rapid and precise quantification of OAs are necessary to be incorporated in the analysis of roots and their exudates. The spatial location of root exudates is also important to understand the molecular mechanisms directing OA production and release into the rhizosphere. Here, we report the development of two complementary methodologies for OA determination, which were employed to evaluate the effect of inorganic ortho-phosphate (Pi) deficiency and aluminum toxicity on OA excretion by Arabidopsis roots. OA exudation by roots is considered a core response to different types of abiotic stress and for the interaction of roots with soil microbes, and for decades has been a target trait to produce plant varieties with increased capacities of Pi uptake and Al tolerance. Using targeted ultra-performance liquid chromatography coupled with high-resolution tandem mass spectrometry (UPLC-HRMS/MS), we achieved the quantification of six OAs in root exudates at sub-micromolar detection limits with an analysis time of less than 5 min per sample. We also employed targeted (MS/MS) matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry imaging (MSI) to detect the spatial location of citric and malic acid with high specificity in roots and exudates. Using these methods, we studied OA exudation in response to Al toxicity and Pi deficiency in Arabidopsis seedlings overexpressing genes involved in OA excretion. Finally, we show the transferability of the MALDI-MSI method by analyzing OA excretion in Marchantia polymorpha gemmalings subjected to Pi deficiency.     

The role of organic acids in the short- and long-term aluminum tolerance in maize seedlings (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Zea mays</Emphasis> L.)

Aluminum (Al) affects numerous physiological processes in plants. However, Al tolerance mechanisms mediated by increased synthesis of organic acids (OAs) have been outlined recently. In this study, we examined the role of OAs in the short (1–8 h) and long-term (4 days) Al tolerance in maize seedlings. Exposure to Al stress for 4 days results in a rapid inhibition of root growth. Al induced morphological changes in the maize roots, especially at a higher solution of Al concentration (1,000 μM Al). The increase in Al accumulation in roots, including strongly elevated levels of Al accumulated in root cell walls suggests that Al tolerance in maize is mediated in part by higher accumulation of Al in the roots. The enhanced citrate exudation, which was only observed at 1,000 μM Al may lead to detoxification of Al by formation of OA–Al complexes in the root apoplast. This mechanism has been suggested to play a significant role in Al resistance response in maize. The short-term responses underlying internal detoxification via OA-chelators were also investigated. Succinate, malate, citrate and total root OA contents decreased markedly, 2 h after the Al exposure. At 4 and 8 h time points, OA contents increased or remained unchanged, except for that of malate which decreased. The level of OAs in shoots, on the other hand, showed alterations that were less pronounced in response to Al. Specifically, the citrate and total OA concentrations significantly increased at 4 h, but showed a pronounced decrease at the 8 h time point. Based on our findings, we propose that multiple responses, including Al exclusion by Al accumulation in root cells and citrate efflux, may contribute towards higher Al resistance in maize. The rapid OA changes in responses to short-term Al treatment may not be responsible for Al tolerance. However, increased OA synthesis observed in this study may be involved in diminishing the stress triggered by Al. The molecular aspects underlying Al resistance mechanism via Al-induced expression of the enzymes catalyzing OA synthesis and metabolism remain to be elucidated.     

Phosphorus and aluminum interactions in soybean in relation to aluminum tolerance. Exudation of specific organic acids from different regions of the intact root system

Aluminum (Al) toxicity and phosphorus (P) deficiency often coexist in acid soils that severely limit crop growth and production, including soybean (Glycine max). Understanding the physiological mechanisms relating to plant Al and P interactions should help facilitate the development of more Al-tolerant and/or P-efficient crops. In this study, both homogeneous and heterogeneous nutrient solution experiments were conducted to study the effects of Al and P interactions on soybean root growth and root organic acid exudation. In the homogenous solution experiments with a uniform Al and P distribution in the bulk solution, P addition significantly increased Al tolerance in four soybean genotypes differing in P efficiency. The two P-efficient genotypes appeared to be more Al tolerant than the two P-inefficient genotypes under these high-P conditions. Analysis of root exudates indicated Al toxicity induced citrate exudation, P deficiency triggered oxalate exudation, and malate release was induced by both treatments. To more closely mimic low-P acid soils where P deficiency and Al toxicity are often much greater in the lower soil horizons, a divided root chamber/nutrient solution approach was employed to impose elevated P conditions in the simulated upper soil horizon, and Al toxicity/P deficiency in the lower horizon. Under these conditions, we found that the two P-efficient genotypes were more Al tolerant during the early stages of the experiment than the P-inefficient lines. Although the same three organic acids were exuded by roots in the divided chamber experiments, their exudation patterns were different from those in the homogeneous solution system. The two P-efficient genotypes secreted more malate from the taproot tip, suggesting that improved P nutrition may enhance exudation of organic acids in the root regions dealing with the greatest Al toxicity, thus enhancing Al tolerance. These findings demonstrate that P efficiency may play a role in Al tolerance in soybean. Phosphorus-efficient genotypes may be able to enhance Al tolerance not only through direct Al-P interactions but also through indirect interactions associated with stimulated exudation of different Al-chelating organic acids in specific roots and root regions.     

微生物铝毒和耐铝机制的研究现状

铝是地球上含量最为丰富的金属元素 ,在酸性条件下 ,主要以Al3 存在。Al3 作为一种严重的环境毒剂 ,已经在众多模式生物中所证明。近年来 ,许多生物学家已日益注意到铝毒和耐铝性在环境科学与生命科学领域的重要性。结合研究工作 ,综述了微生物铝毒害和耐铝的机制。微生物通过①增强分泌有机酸与Al3 螯合 ,②超表达Mg2 通道蛋白 ,增强细胞转运吸收Mg2 ,③通过线粒体ATPase和液泡ATPase协同作用将Al3 隔离于液泡内 ,以及④通过氧化胁迫改变、调节Al3 毒害和耐铝性 ,减缓Al3 对细胞的毒害。     

植物地上部对铝毒的生理响应及其耐性

全世界50％以上潜在的可耕地属于酸性土壤,铝毒害是酸性土壤上植物生长最有害因素之一。近年来,为了阐明植物铝毒害及其耐性,前人已进行了大量的研究,并有一些综述性文章发表。然而,大多数文章主要综述铝对植物根系的影响及其耐性,因为根生长受抑是最早的铝毒害症状之一和溶液培养时最容易辨认的铝毒害症状。为此,本文综述了铝对植物地上部光合作用、光保护系统、水分利用效率、含水量、碳水化合物含量、矿质营养、有机酸和氮代谢的影响,并对富铝植物的解铝毒机制（铝与小分子有机酸螯合和把铝隔离在对铝不敏感的表皮细胞和液泡内）进行了综述。本文还对植物耐铝遗传学和分子生物学及今后需要研究的问题进行了讨论。     

Aluminium tolerance and high phosphorus efficiency helps Stylosanthes better adapt to low-P acid soils

Backgrond and Aims

Stylosanthes spp. (stylo) is one of the most important pasture legumes used in a wide range of agricultural systems on acid soils, where aluminium (Al) toxicity and phosphorus (P) deficiency are two major limiting factors for plant growth. However, physiological mechanisms of stylo adaptation to acid soils are not understood.

Methods

Twelve stylo genotypes were surveyed under field conditions, followed by sand and nutrient solution culture experiments to investigate possible physiological mechanisms of stylo adaptation to low-P acid soils.

Key Results

Stylo genotypes varied substantially in growth and P uptake in low P conditions in the field. Three genotypes contrasting in P efficiency were selected for experiments in nutrient solution and sand culture to examine their Al tolerance and ability to utilize different P sources, including Ca-P, K-P, Al-P, Fe-P and phytate-P. Among the three tested genotypes, the P-efficient genotype ‘TPRC2001-1’ had higher Al tolerance than the P-inefficient genotype ‘Fine-stem’ as indicated by relative tap root length and haematoxylin staining. The three genotypes differed in their ability to utilize different P sources. The P-efficient genotype, ‘TPRC2001-1’, had superior ability to utilize phytate-P.

Conclusions

The findings suggest that possible physiological mechanisms of stylo adaptation to low-P acid soils might involve superior ability of plant roots to tolerate Al toxicity and to utilize organic P and Al-P.Key words: Stylosanthes, phosphorus, P efficiency, organic P, Al toxicity, acid soil     

The Physiology, Genetics and Molecular Biology of Plant Aluminum Resistance and Toxicity

Aluminum (Al) toxicity is the primary factor limiting crop production on acidic soils (pH values of 5 or below), and because 50% of the world’s potentially arable lands are acidic, Al toxicity is a very important limitation to worldwide crop production. This review examines our current understanding of mechanisms of Al toxicity, as well as the physiological, genetic and molecular basis for Al resistance. Al resistance can be achieved by mechanisms that facilitate Al exclusion from the root apex (Al exclusion) and/or by mechanisms that confer the ability of plants to tolerate Al in the plant symplasm (Al tolerance). Compelling evidence has been presented in the literature for a resistance mechanism based on exclusion of Al due to Al-activated carboxylate release from the growing root tip. More recently, researchers have provided support for an additional Al-resistance mechanism involving internal detoxification of Al with carboxylate ligands (deprotonated organic acids) and the sequestration of the Al-carboxylate complexes in the vacuole. This is a field that is entering a phase of new discovery, as researchers are on the verge of identifying some of the genes that contribute to Al resistance in plants. The identification and characterization of Al resistance genes will not only greatly advance our understanding of Al-resistance mechanisms, but more importantly, will be the source of new molecular resources that researchers will use to develop improved crops better suited for cultivation on acid soils.     

Aluminum stress signaling in plants

Aluminum (Al) toxicity is a major constraint for crop production in acidic soil worldwide. When the soil pH is lower than 5, Al³⁺ is released to the soil and enters into root tip cell ceases root development of plant. In acid soil with high mineral content, Al is the major cause of phytotoxicity. The target of Al toxicity is the root tip, in which Al exposure causes inhibition of cell elongation and cell division, leading to root stunting accompanied by reduced water and nutrient uptake. A variety of genes have been identified that are induced or repressed upon Al exposure. At tissue level, the distal part of the transition zone is the most sensitive to Al. At cellular and molecular level, many cell components are implicated in the Al toxicity including DNA in nucleus, numerous cytoplastic compounds, mitochondria, the plasma membrane and the cell wall. Although it is difficult to distinguish the primary targets from the secondary effects so far, understanding of the target sites of the Al toxicity is helpful for elucidating the mechanisms by which Al exerts its deleterious effects on root growth. To develop high tolerance against Al stress is the major goal of plant sciences. This review examines our current understanding of the Al signaling with the physiological, genetic and molecular approaches to improve the crop performance under the Al toxicity. New discoveries will open up new avenues of molecular/physiological inquiry that should greatly advance our understanding of Al tolerance mechanisms. Additionally, these breakthroughs will provide new molecular resources for improving the crop Al tolerance via molecular-assisted breeding and biotechnology.Key words: aluminum, toxicity, tolerance, signal transduction, plants     

The combined treatment of Mn and Al alleviates the toxicity of Al or Mn stress alone in barley

Aluminum (Al) and manganese (Mn) toxicity commonly coexists in acid soil, so the crop cultivars suitable for planting in acid soil should show high tolerance to both elements simultaneously. However, it is still not clear if the toxicity of Mn and Al on plant growth is antagonistic or synergistic, and the plants with Al tolerance are also tolerant to Mn toxicity. In this study, three barley genotypes (one Tibetan wild and two cultivated), differing in Al tolerance, were characterized for growth and physiological responses to Al or Mn toxicity as well as the combined treatment of the two toxic elements. Interestingly, it has been found that the combined treatment of both metals was less affected in comparison with Al or Mn treatment alone, in terms of plant growth, Al or Mn concentration in plant tissues, and photosynthetic parameters, indicating antagonistic interaction of Al and Mn for their effect on plant growth and physiological traits. The results also showed that there was a dramatic difference among barley genotypes in Mn toxicity tolerance and XZ16 showed much higher tolerance than other two genotypes. High Mn tolerance is mainly described to less Mn uptake and lower Mn concentration in plants, and Mn tolerance is independent of Al tolerance.     

Molecular and physiological strategies to increase aluminum resistance in plants

Aluminum (Al) toxicity is a primary limitation to plant growth on acid soils. Root meristems are the first site for toxic Al accumulation, and therefore inhibition of root elongation is the most evident physiological manifestation of Al toxicity. Plants may resist Al toxicity by avoidance (Al exclusion) and/or tolerance mechanisms (detoxification of Al inside the cells). The Al exclusion involves the exudation of organic acid anions from the root apices, whereas tolerance mechanisms comprise internal Al detoxification by organic acid anions and enhanced scavenging of free oxygen radicals. One of the most important advances in understanding the molecular events associated with the Al exclusion mechanism was the identification of the ALMT1 gene (Al-activated malate transporter) in Triticum aestivum root cells, which codes for a plasma membrane anion channel that allows efflux of organic acid anions, such as malate, citrate or oxalate. On the other hand, the scavenging of free radicals is dependent on the expression of genes involved in antioxidant defenses, such as peroxidases (e.g. in Arabidopsis thaliana and Nicotiana tabacum), catalases (e.g. in Capsicum annuum), and the gene WMnSOD1 from T. aestivum. However, other recent findings show that reactive oxygen species (ROS) induced stress may be due to acidic (low pH) conditions rather than to Al stress. In this review, we summarize recent findings regarding molecular and physiological mechanisms of Al toxicity and resistance in higher plants. Advances have been made in understanding some of the underlying strategies that plants use to cope with Al toxicity. Furthermore, we discuss the physiological and molecular responses to Al toxicity, including genes involved in Al resistance that have been identified and characterized in several plant species. The better understanding of these strategies and mechanisms is essential for improving plant performance in acidic, Al-toxic soils.     

Organic acid exudation induced by phosphorus deficiency and/or aluminium toxicity in two contrasting soybean genotypes

Experiments in nutrient solution were conducted to investigate the exudation of organic acids (OAs) induced by phosphorus deficiency (–P) and/or aluminium toxicity (+Al) in two contrasting soybean genotypes as related to internal OA concentration and related enzyme activities. Baxi 10 (BX10), a known P‐efficient soybean (Glycine max[L] Merr.) genotype, was shown to be more resistant to +Al than a P‐inefficient genotype Bendi 2 (BD2), indicating the potential of selecting soybean cultivars with dual resistance to –P and +Al. The two contrasting genotypes were further characterized for root exudation and formation of oxalate, malate and citrate and their related enzyme activities in response to –P, +Al or both combined. –P significantly induced malate and oxalate exudation from both soybean genotypes, although the P‐efficient BX10 tended to excrete much more oxalate than the P‐inefficient BD2. The +Al treatment triggered citrate efflux from both genotypes, with BX10 having a much greater efflux rate than BD2. Interestingly, –P did not appear to induce citrate exudation, whereas +Al had no obvious effect on malate or oxalate exudation from the two genotypes. The exudation of OAs was generally diminished under the coupled stress of –P and +Al in comparison with either single stress, implying a possible antagonistic effect of the two stresses on OA exudation. Root malate content was negatively correlated with its exudation in BX10 but positively in BD2. A similar tendency was observed for oxalate content and exudation only with less magnitude. Determination of six related enzymes, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC), phosphoenolpyruvate phosphatase (PEPP), malate enzyme (ME), isocitrate dehydrogenase (ICDH), malate dehydrogenase (MDH), and pyruvate kinase (PK), in the root tips showed that their activities were not significantly altered during the early stage of treatments (2 and 4 days) whereas at 14 days after stress imposition, the activities of PEPC, PEPP, ME and ICDH were generally enhanced for both genotypes. However, the activity of these enzymes did not appear to be correlated with OA exudation or formation. This study clearly demonstrates that OA exudation is differentially induced by –P and +Al in soybean plants, with specific induction of oxalate and malate by –P and citrate by +Al. The lack of a close relationship between OA exudation and internal concentration or enzyme activities may suggest that the regulation of OA formation and exudation by –P and/or +Al could be imposed at different stages.     

低磷和铝毒胁迫条件下菜豆有机酸的分泌与累积

以水培方式研究了低磷、铝毒胁迫条件下,不同菜豆基因型根系有机酸的分泌及其在植穆不同部位的累积,结果表明,低磷,铝毒胁迫诱导菜豆有机酸的分泌与累积存在显著的基因差异。低磷、铝毒胁迫诱导菜豆主要分泌柠檬酸、酒石酸和乙酸,其中,50μmol/LAl^3 诱导柠檬酸分泌量最高;低磷（小于20μmol/LH2PO4^－）胁迫诱导柠榨菜酸分泌量显著高于高磷处理,但低磷处理之间差异不明显,铝毒胁迫诱导菜豆有机酸的分泌与累积显著高于低磷胁迫处理,低磷,铝毒胁迫植株不同部位有机酸的含量为叶片大小根系,低磷,铝毒胁迫时,G842菜豆型柠檬酸有机酸分泌总量显著高于273、AFR和ZPV,其干重和磷吸收明明显于大G273,AFR和ZPV,且铝吸收量小于G273,AFR和ZPV,说明,G482菜豆基因型对低磷,铝毒的适应能力强于G273,AFR和ZPV基因型,菜豆有机酸,,尤其柠檬酸的分泌是其适应低磷、铝毒胁迫的重要生理反应。     

The Carbon Cost of Protecting the Root Apex from Soil Acidity: A Theoretical Framework

There is an assumption in much recent literature that secreted organic anions (OAs) protect the root meristem from Al toxicity by complexation of Al ions. In fact, several possible mechanisms exist by which common OA might afford some degree of protection. Plants can excrete OA which undergo chemical association with protons (hereafter referred to as protonation) in the soil and increase rhizosphere pH. The cost in reduced carbon relative to protons consumed, C:H⁺, ranges from 2–6. The efficiency of this mechanism can be enhanced in the presence of soil organisms which can oxidise the OA that remain dissociated at soil pH to CO₂ and H₂O, thereby consuming protons which associate with lower pK functional groups (pK 1.2 to ~ 4). For fully dissociated organic acids the C:H⁺ ratio decreases to the range 1–3. The C cost to plants is further minimised if MnO₂ is the terminal electron acceptor rather than O₂, resulting in C:H⁺<1. OA might also complex or chelate Al. Complexes of Al³⁺ with oxalate appear to be effective, with some C:H⁺≤1. However, citrate complexation appears to be more stable in pure solutions and might offer the additional benefit of enhanced P acquisition. Our assessment is that the most efficient strategy for a plant to employ to protect itself from Al toxicity is to increase pH near the root apex by secreting OA into soil where the microbial oxidation of reduced C could be coupled with the reduction of MnO₂. This would consume 0.2–0.67 mole of C per H⁺, which is the order of magnitude better than the C:H⁺ ratio of 2–6 that would occur if only protonation of OA was to be relied upon. These mechanisms have implications for the effectiveness of programs aimed at selecting cultivars for resistance to acidic soils.     

Plant improvement for tolerance to aluminum in acid soils – a review

Development of acid soils that limit crop production is an increasing problem worldwide. Many factors contribute to phytotoxicity of these soils, however, in acid soils with a high mineral content, aluminum (Al) is the major cause of toxicity. The target of Al toxicity is the root tip, in which Al exposure causes inhibition of cell elongation and cell division, leading to root stunting accompanied by reduced water and nutrient uptake. Natural variation for Al tolerance has been identified in many crop species and in some crops tolerance to Al has been introduced into productive, well-adapted varieties. Aluminum tolerance appears to be a complex multigenic trait. Selection methodology remains a limiting factor in variety development as all methods have particular drawbacks. Molecular markers have been associated with Al tolerance genes or quantitative trait loci in Arabidopsis and in several crops, which should facilitate development of additional tolerant varieties. A variety of genes have been identified that are induced or repressed upon Al exposure. Most induced genes characterized so far are not specific to Al exposure but are also induced by other stress conditions. Ectopic over-expression of some of these genes has resulted in enhanced Al tolerance. Additionally, expression of genes involved in organic acid synthesis has resulted in enhanced production of organic acids and an associated increase in Al tolerance. This review summarizes the three main approaches that have been taken to develop crops with Al tolerance: recurrent selection and breeding, development of Al tolerant somaclonal variants and ectopic expression of transgenes to reduce Al uptake or limit damage to cells by Al.     

Overexpression of an Arabidopsis magnesium transport gene, AtMGT1, in Nicotiana benthamiana confers Al tolerance

Aluminium (Al) toxicity is the most important limiting factor for crop production in acid soil environments worldwide. In some plant species, application of magnesium (Mg(2+)) can alleviate Al toxicity. However, it remains unknown whether overexpression of magnesium transport proteins can improve Al tolerance. Here, the role of AtMGT1, a member of the Arabidopsis magnesium transport family involved in Mg(2+) transport, played in Al tolerance in higher plants was investigated. Expression of 35S::AtMGT1 led to various phenotypic alterations in Nicotiana benthamiana plants. Transgenic plants harbouring 35S::AtMGT1 exhibited tolerance to Mg(2+) deficiency. Element assay showed that the contents of Mg, Mn, and Fe in 35S::AtMGT1 plants increased compared with wild-type plants. Root growth experiment revealed that 100 microM AlCl(3) caused a reduction in root elongation by 47% in transgenic lines, whereas root growth in wild-type plants was inhibited completely. Upon Al treatment, representative transgenic lines also showed a much lower callose deposition, an indicator of increased Al tolerance, than wild-type plants. Taken together, the results have demonstrated that overexpression of ATMGT1 encoding a magnesium transport protein can improve tolerance to Al in higher plants.     

Signal transduction and biotechnology in response to environmental stresses

Providing sufficient food to burgeoning population from the steadily shrinking arable land seems to be very difficult in near future and is one of the foremost challenges for plant scientists. In addition, there are several biotic and abiotic stresses which frequently encounter crop plants during various stages of life cycle, resulting in considerable yield losses. Environmental stresses, including drought, flooding, salinity, temperature (both low and high), high radiation, and xenobiotics induce toxicity, membrane damage, excessive reactive oxygen species (ROS) production, reduced photosynthesis, and altered nutrient acquisition. Several indigenous defence mechanisms (physiological and molecular) are triggered in plants on exposure to environmental cues. Enhancement of resistance of crop plants to environmental stresses has been the topic of prime interest for agriculturalists and plant scientists since long. Development of water and salinity stress-tolerant crops through genetic engineering provides an avenue towards the reclamation of farmlands that have been lost due to salinity and lack of irrigation water/rainfall. Understanding the complexity of stress tolerance mechanisms in orthodox or model plants at the genetic and molecular levels improves feasibility of enhancing tolerance of sensitive crop plants.     

Effect of phosphate on aluminium-inhibited growth and signal transduction pathways in Coffea arabica suspension cells

In acid soils, aluminium (Al) toxicity and phosphate (Pi) deficiency are the most significant constraints on plant growth. Al inhibits cell growth and disrupts signal transduction processes, thus interfering with metabolism of phospholipase C (PLC), an enzyme involved in second messenger production in the cell. Using a Coffea arabica suspension cell model, we demonstrate that cell growth inhibition by Al toxicity is mitigated at a high Pi concentration. Aluminium-induced cell growth inhibition may be due to culture medium Pi deficiency, since Pi forms complexes with Al, reducing Pi availability to cells. Phosphate does not mitigate inhibition of PLC activity by Al toxicity. Other enzymes of the phosphoinositide signal transduction pathway were also evaluated. Aluminium disrupts production of second messengers such as inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate (IP₃) and phosphatidic acid (PA) by blocking PLC activity; however, phospholipase D (PLD) and diacylglycerol kinase (DGK) activities are stimulated by Al, a response probably aimed at counteracting Al effects on PA formation. Phosphate deprivation also induces PLC and DGK activity. These results suggest that Al-induced cell growth inhibition is not linked to PLC activity inhibition.