Transport of oppositely charged lipophilic probe ions in lipid bilayer membranes having various structures

Summary A comparative study of the charge transport kinetics of oppositely charged lipophilic probe ions in lipid bilayer membranes of varying composition was carried out by using the charge pulse technique. The ions investigated were the chemical analogs tetraphenylborate, tetraphenylarsonium and tetraphenylphosphonium. Membrane structural aspects investigated were the type of solvent used in membrane formation, sterol content, and the nature of the principal lipid. The overall results indicate that the character of the transport process involving positive lipophilic probes is, in contrast to positively charged carrier complexes, very similar to that deduced in previous studies of negative lipophilic ions. The major effect on transport of lipophilic ions of both signs using differentn-alkane solvents appears to be due to changes in the thickness of the membrane hydrocarbon region. Positive ion transport is relatively sensitive to the inclusion of sterols of several types in both monoolein and lecithin membranes, as compared with negative ion transport, suggesting that a combination of sterol-induced dipolar field and fluidity changes are involved. Results involving several variations in lipid structure, with the possible exception of hydrocarbon tail saturation, when interpreted in terms of dipolar field changes deduced under the assumption of charge independent fluidity effects, are consistent with monolayer surface potential measurements.     

Ion repulsion within membranes.

The adsorption of hydrophobic ions such as tetraphenylborate to thin lipid membranes is known to saturate at approximately 0.1 ion/(nm)2. This saturation can be quantitatively explained by electrostatic repulsion between the ions if they are treated as discrete, mobile particles that adsorb within the lipid at least partially removed from the aqueous phases. The electrochemical potential of the ions as a function of their surface density can be expressed as a virial expansion, which in principle exactly describes the equilibrium properties of the physical model. The first few terms of the virial expansion are calculated and an approximation is considered for higher-order terms. The model has only two adjustable parameters, the depth of the adsorption sites into the lipid and the adsorption constant in the absence of repulsion. The mobile, discrete charge model can give much better fits to the equilibrium data for tetraphenylborate adsorbed at up to 0.1 ion/(nm)2 to membranes and monolayers. (Andersen et al., 1978) than those obtainable from either the smeared charge or hexagonal lattice models.     

Influence of dolichyl phosphate on permeability and stability of bilayer lipid membranes

The ionic permeability coefficients, ionic transference numbers, activation energy of ion transport and breakdown voltage of bilayer lipid membranes made from dioleoylphosphatidylcholine or its mixtures with dolichyl 12-phosphate have been studied. The electrical measurements showed that dolichyl phosphate in phospholipid bilayers decreases membrane permeability, changes membrane ionic selectivity and increases membrane stability. These results are discussed in light of the aggregation behavior and the intramolecular clustering of a dolichyl phosphate molecule in phospholipid membranes. From our data we suggest that the hydrophilic part of dolichyl phosphate molecules regulates their behavior in membranes.     

Effect of surface ionization of dimyristoylphosphatidic acid vesicle membranes on the main phase-transition enthalpy and temperature

The main phase transition of phospholipid bilayers is a property expressed by the order-disorder conformational change of the lipid tails. Nevertheless, with ionizable phospholipids, changes in the surface charge have large effects on the membrane properties. The free energy of a charged phospholipid membrane depends on the degree of ionization, area per phospholipid molecule, and the temperature. Here, the effect of surface electrostatic charges on the temperature and the enthalpy of the main phase transition of dimyristoylphosphatidic acid vesicle membranes is analyzed. A simple equation is presented that describes the relationship among the surface charge density, the phase-transition temperature, the surface area ratio between solid and liquid membranes, and the excess enthalpy. The theory indicated that the pH-induced shift in the excess enthalpy is attributable to the change in the surface area ratio between the solid and liquid membranes.     

Kinetics of transport of hydrophobic ions through lipid membranes including diffusion polarization in the aqueous phase

Previous interpretations of the kinetics of transport of hydrophobic ions through membranes have been based on one of three limiting assumptions. Either diffusion in the aqueous phase was taken to be rapid, or ionic motion was constrained to the membrane or a steady state was presumed to be established within the membrane. We present a general treatment of the coupled diffusion process through both the aqueous phase and the membrane; our theory contains the previous results as limiting cases. It is applied to voltage jump-current relaxation experiments on black lipid membranes in the presence of dipicrylamine or sodium tetraphenylborate. We have attempted to establish the rate of desorption from the membrane. For the system phosphatidylserine/tetraphenylborate, the rate of desorption and the rate of translocation were found to be comparable.     

Fluorescence spectroscopy of planar black lipid membranes Probe adsorption and quantum yield determination

A technique is described for the examination of fluorescence in planar black lipid membranes. Special attention has been devoted to the elimination of light scattered from the border regions of the membrane and from the numerous small lenses of hydrocarbon solvent which can form in certain types of black film. Fluorescence spectra of 1-anilino-8-naphthalene sulphonate (ANS) are reported for phospholipid and monoglyceride membranes. The adsorption of the fluorescent probe has been measured by a thermodynamic method and the quantum yield of the probe in the membrane has been determined. Both the emission spectrum and the quantum yield of ANS in black films agree well with the respective data obtained from measurements on sonicated aqueous dispersions of the lipid.     

Supported phospholipid/alkanethiol biomimetic membranes: insulating properties.

A novel model lipid bilayer membrane is prepared by the addition of phospholipid vesicles to alkanethiol monolayers on gold. This supported hybrid bilayer membrane is rugged, easily and reproducibly prepared in the absence of organic solvent, and is stable for very long periods of time. We have characterized the insulating characteristics of this membrane by examining the rate of electron transfer and by impedance spectroscopy. Supported hybrid bilayers formed from phospholipids and alkanethiols are pinhole-free and demonstrate measured values of conductivity and resistivity which are within an order of magnitude of that reported for black lipid membranes. Capacitance values suggest a dielectric constant of 2.7 for phospholipid membranes in the absence of organic solvent. The protein toxin, melittin, destroys the insulating capability of the phospholipid layer without significantly altering the bilayer structure. This model membrane will allow the assessment of the effect of lipid membrane perturbants on the insulating properties of natural lipid membranes.     

The structure of a model membrane in relation to the viscoelastic properties of the red cell membrane

The molecular arrangement within a lamellar structure composed of human erythrocyte lipids is determined. The 45 A thick lipid layer, in water, is filled in the interior with a liquid-like configuration of the hydrocarbon chains of phospholipid molecules and is covered on both sides by their hydrophilic polar groups. Cholesterol is located so that part of its steroid nucleus is between the polar groups of the phospholipid molecules while the rest of the molecule extends into the inner hydrocarbon layer. This lipid leaflet would be expected to have the mechanical properties of a purely liquid surface, as other authors have shown for the "black" lipid membranes. Data are presented which demonstrate that the intact erythrocyte membrane is a tough viscoelastic substance with a Young''s modulus of 10⁶–10⁸ dynes/cm² and a viscosity of 10⁷–10¹⁰ poises. The parameters and the kinetics of membrane breakdown are incompatible with the model system of pure lipid. Caution must be exercised in applying various data on the model systems to intact membranes.     

Effects of hydrostatic pressure on lipid bilayer membranes. I. Influence on membrane thickness and activation volumes of lipophilic ion transport.

Measurements of membrane capacitance, Cm, were performed on lipid bilayers of different lipidic composition (diphytanoyl phosphatidylcholine PPhPC, dioleoyl phosphatidylcholine DOPE, glycerylmonooleate GMO) and containing n-decane as solvent. In the same membranes, the absorption of the lipophilic ions dipicrylamine (DPA-) and tetraphenylborate (TPhB-), and the kinetics of their translocation between the two membrane faces have been studied. The data were obtained from charge pulse relaxation measurements. Upon increasing pressure the specific capacity Cm increased in a fully reversible and reproducible way reflecting a thinning of the membrane that is attributed to extrusion of n-decane from the black membrane area. High pressure decreased the rate constant, ki, for lipophilic ion translocation. After correcting for changes in the height of the energy barrier for translocation due to membrane thinning the pressure dependence of ki yields an apparent activation volume for translocation of approximately 14 cm3/mol both for DPA- and TPhB-. Changes in lipophilic ion absorption following a step of pressure developed with a rather slow time course due to diffusion limitations in solution. The stationary concentration of membrane absorbed lipophilic ions increased with pressure according to an apparent volume of absorption of about -10 cm3/mol. The relevance of the results for the interpretation of the effects of pressure on nerve membrane physiology is discussed.     

Modification of ion transport in lipid bilayer membranes in the presence of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid. II. Suppression of tetraphenylborate conductance and changes of interfacial potentials.

It has been shown that the blocking of negatively charged tetraphenylborate ion transport in phosphatidylcholine (PC)-cholesterol membranes by the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) is dominated by suppression of TPhB- diffusion across the membrane interior, rather than by the decrease of adsorption of TPhB- ions at the membrane surface. The blocking effect can be associated with the decrease of electric potential inside the membrane with respect to that of the aqueous medium, this decreases being proportional to the concentration of 2,4-D in the aqueous solution. It has been estimated that 25 - 30% of the total 2,4-D-induced change of the potential difference is between the plane of absorption of TPhB- and the aqueous solution, and the remaining fraction is between the membrane interior and the absorption plane. The results of this study support the dipolar hypothesis of 2,4-D action in lipid membranes. These conclusions are further supported by measurements changes of electric potential difference across air/water and air/lipid monolayer/water interfaces. It has been found that the electric potential of the nonpolar side of the interface decreases in the presence of neutral molecules of 2,4-D and that this effect becomes more prominent in presence of electrolyte. We have confirmed that PC-cholesterol monolayer cannot be considered as a model for half of the bilayer membrane because of the disagreement between the changes of the interfacial potential difference of PC-cholesterol monolayers and those determined from studied of transport of positive and negative ions across bilayer membranes. In contract, we have found close agreement between the 2,4-D-induced changes of electric potential of the lipid hydrocarbon region in glycerolmonooleate (GMO) membranes and GMO monolayers. We suggest that the action of 2,4-D in lipid membranes is not associated with the changes of orientation of dipoles of lipids constituting the membranes, but rather with a layer of 2,4-D molecules absorbed at the nonpolar/polar membrane boundary.     

Membrane interactions and metal ion effects on bilayer permeation of the lipophilic ion modulator DP-109

DP-109, a lipophilic bivalent metal ion modulator currently under preclinical development for neurodegenerative disorders, was designed to have membrane-associated activity, thereby restricting its action to the vicinity of cell membranes. We describe the application of a colorimetric phospholipid/polydiacetylene (PDA) biomimetic membrane assay in elucidating DP-109 membrane interactions and penetration into lipid bilayers. In this membrane model, visible quantifiable color changes were monitored in studying membrane interactions. The colorimetric data identified a biphasic concentration-dependent interaction, with a break point around the critical micelle concentration (CMC) of DP-109. The kinetics and colorimetric dose-response profile of DP-109 indicate that the compound inserts into the lipid bilayers rather than being localized at the bilayer surface. Analysis of interactions of DP-109 with phospholipid/PDA vesicles in which ionic gradients were imposed indicates that membrane activity of DP-109 is strongly affected by electrochemical gradients imposed by K+ and Zn2+. The ionic gradient effects suggest that the insertion of DP-109 into the membrane may depend on the membrane potential.     

The mechanism of action of DNP on phospholipid bilayer membranes

Summary The weak acid 2,4-dinitrophenol (DNP) acts as an uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation in biological systems and, in consonance with the Mitchell hypothesis, also enhances the conductance of phospholipid bilayer membranes. Several models have been proposed in the literature to explain the molecular mechanism by which DNP exerts its electrical effects on the model membranes, none of which accounts for all of the data, and all of which ignore the possibility that the anion of DNP is also binding to the surface of the bilayer and modifying the charge density. Experimental evidence is presented in this report which suggests that when a bilayer membrane is formed from a neutral lipid, DNP does in fact adsorb to its surface and produce a substantial negative surface potential. When this phenomenon is taken into account, the model proposed by Lea and Croghan and by Finkelstein is capable of describing all of the effects of DNP on bilayer membranes. In this model, the permeant species is a negatively charged complex formed from the undissociated acid and its anion.     

Functional foldamers that target bacterial membranes: The effect of charge,amphiphilicity and conformation

By varying the molecular charge, shape and amphiphilicity of a series of conformationally distinct diarylureas it is possible to control the levels of phospholipid membrane lysis using membranes composed of bacterial lipid extracts. From the data obtained, it appears as though the lysis activity observed is not due to charge, conformation or amphiphilicity in isolation, but that surface aggregation, H-bonding and other factors may also play a part. The work provides evidence that this class of foldamer possesses potential for optimisation into new antibacterial agents.     

How Lipid Headgroups Sense the Membrane Environment: An Application of 14N NMR

The orientation of lipid headgroups may serve as a powerful sensor of electrostatic interactions in membranes. As shown previously by ²H NMR measurements, the headgroup of phosphatidylcholine (PC) behaves like an electrometer and varies its orientation according to the membrane surface charge. Here, we explored the use of solid-state ¹⁴N NMR as a relatively simple and label-free method to study the orientation of the PC headgroup in model membrane systems of varying composition. We found that ¹⁴N NMR is sufficiently sensitive to detect small changes in headgroup orientation upon introduction of positively and negatively charged lipids and we developed an approach to directly convert the ¹⁴N quadrupolar splittings into an average orientation of the PC polar headgroup. Our results show that inclusion of cholesterol or mixing of lipids with different length acyl chains does not significantly affect the orientation of the PC headgroup. In contrast, measurements with cationic (KALP), neutral (Ac-KALP), and pH-sensitive (HALP) transmembrane peptides show very systematic changes in headgroup orientation, depending on the amount of charge in the peptide side chains and on their precise localization at the interface, as modulated by varying the extent of hydrophobic peptide/lipid mismatch. Finally, our measurements suggest an unexpectedly strong preferential enrichment of the anionic lipid phosphatidylglycerol around the cationic KALP peptide in ternary mixtures with PC. We believe that these results are important for understanding protein/lipid interactions and that they may help parametrization of membrane properties in computational studies.     

Electrostatic binding of proteins to membranes. Theoretical predictions and experimental results with charybdotoxin and phospholipid vesicles.

We previously applied the Poisson-Boltzmann equation to atomic models of phospholipid bilayers and basic peptides to calculate their electrostatic interactions from first principles (Ben-Tal, N., B. Honig, R. M. Peitzsch, G. Denisov, and S. McLaughlan. 1996. Binding of small basic peptides to membranes containing acidic lipids. Theoretical models and experimental results. Biophys. J. 71:561-575). Specifically, we calculated the molar partition coefficient, K (the reciprocal of the lipid concentration at which 1/2 the peptide is bound), of simple basic peptides (e.g., pentalysine) with phospholipid vesicles. The theoretical predictions agreed well with experimental measurements of the binding, but the agreement could have been fortuitous because the structure(s) of these flexible peptides is not known. Here we use the same theoretical approach to calculate the membrane binding of two small proteins of known structure: charybdotoxin (CTx) and iberiotoxin (IbTx); we also measure the binding of these proteins to phospholipid vesicles. The theoretical model describes accurately the dependence of K on the ionic strength and mol % acidic lipid in the membrane for both CTx (net charge +4) and IbTx (net charge +2). For example, the theory correctly predicts that the value of K for the binding of CTx to a membrane containing 33% acidic lipid should decrease by a factor of 10(5) when the salt concentration increases from 10 to 200 mM. We discuss the limitations of the theoretical approach and also consider a simple extension of the theory that incorporates nonpolar interactions.     

Influence of surface potentials on the mitochondrial H+ pump and on lipid-phase transitions.

It has been shown that the surface potential of lipid membranes, as well as of mitochondria, can be shifted more positive by absorption of alkylbiguanides. Both phospholipid vesicles and natural membranes respond in an analogous way to this shift. Ion activities at the immediate membrane surface are influenced by sign and magnitude of the surface charge. Corresponding effects on ion transport and on fluorescence-probe binding can be observed. The mitochondrial H+ pump is inhibited when the surface charge is shifted more positive. In contrast,the absolute charge density determines the temperature of the ordered-fluid transition. The latter is increased by biguanides, suggesting that the membrane is rendered more rigid. The experiments make obvious that physical relations derived from model systems apply equally well to lipid-containing natural membranes.     

Fabrication and electromechanical characterization of freestanding asymmetric membranes

All biological cell membranes maintain an electric transmembrane potential of around 100 mV, due in part to an asymmetric distribution of charged phospholipids across the membrane. This asymmetry is crucial to cell health and physiological processes such as intracell signaling, receptor-mediated endocytosis, and membrane protein function. Experimental artificial membrane systems incorporate essential cell membrane structures, such as the phospholipid bilayer, in a controllable manner in which specific properties and processes can be isolated and examined. Here, we describe an approach to fabricate and characterize planar, freestanding, asymmetric membranes and use it to examine the effect of headgroup charge on membrane stiffness. The approach relies on a thin film balance used to form a freestanding membrane by adsorbing aqueous phase lipid vesicles to an oil-water interface and subsequently thinning the oil to form a bilayer. We validate this lipid-in-aqueous approach by analyzing the thickness and compressibility of symmetric membranes with varying zwitterionic 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC) and anionic 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-(1′-rac-glycerol) sodium salt (DOPG) content as compared with previous lipid-in-oil methods. We find that as the concentration of DOPG increases, membranes become thicker and stiffer. Asymmetric membranes are fabricated by controlling the lipid vesicle composition in the aqueous reservoirs on either side of the oil. Membrane compositional asymmetry is qualitatively demonstrated using a fluorescence quenching assay and quantitatively characterized through voltage-dependent capacitance measurements. Stable asymmetric membranes with DOPC on one side and DOPC-DOPG mixtures on the other were created with transmembrane potentials ranging from 15 to 80 mV. Introducing membrane charge asymmetry decreases both the thickness and stiffness in comparison with symmetric membranes with the same overall phospholipid composition. These initial successes demonstrate a viable pathway to quantitatively characterize asymmetric bilayers that can be extended to accommodate more complex membranes and membrane processes in the future.     

Domain formation by a Rhodococcus sp. biosurfactant trehalose lipid incorporated into phosphatidylcholine membranes

The study of the interaction of biosurfactants with biological membranes is of great interest in order to gain insight into the molecular mechanisms of their biological actions. In this work we report on the interaction of a bacterial trehalose lipid produced by Rhodococcus sp. with phosphatidylcholine membranes. Differential scanning calorimetry measurements show a good miscibility of the glycolipid in the gel state and immiscibility in the fluid state, suggesting domain formation. These domains have been visualized and characterized, for the first time, by scanning force microscopy. Incorporation of trehalose lipid into phosphatidylcholine membranes produces a small shift of the antisymmetric stretching band toward higher wavenumbers, as shown by FTIR, which indicates a weak increase in fluidity. The CO stretching band shows that incorporation of trehalose lipid increases the proportion of the dehydrated component in mixtures with the three phospholipids at temperatures below and above the gel to liquid-crystalline phase transition. This dehydration effect is also supported by data on the phospholipid PO stretching bands. Small-angle X-ray diffraction measurements show that in the samples containing trehalose lipid the interlamellar repeat distance is larger than in those of pure phospholipids. These results are discussed within the frame of trehalose lipid domain formation, trehalose lipid/phospholipid interactions and its relevance to membrane-related biological actions.     

Influence of surface potentials on the mitochondrial H+ pump and on lipid-phase transitions

It has been shown that the surface potential of lipid membranes, as well as of mitochondria, can be shifted more positive by absorption of alkylbiguanides. Both phospholipid vesicles and natural membranes respond in an analogous way to this shift. Ion activities at the immediate membrane surface are influenced by sign and magnitude of the surface charge. Corresponding effects on ion transport and on fluorescence-probe binding can be observed. The mitochondrial H⁺ pump is inhibited when the surface charge is shifted more positive. In contrast, the absolute charge density determines the temperature of the ordered-fluid transition. The latter is increased by biguanides, suggesting that the membrane is rendered more rigid. The experiments make obvious that physical relations derived from model systems apply equally well to lipid-containing natural membranes.     

Neutral fluorescence probe with strong ratiometric response to surface charge of phospholipid membranes.

We report on dramatic differences in fluorescence spectra of 4'-dimethylamino-3-hydroxyflavone (probe F) studied in phospholipid membranes of different charge (phosphatidyl glycerol, phosphatidylcholine (PC), their mixture and the mixture of PC with a cationic lipid). The effect consists in variations of relative intensities at two well-separated band maxima at 520 and 570 nm belonging to normal (N*) and tautomer (T*) excited states of flavone chromophore. Based on these studies we propose a new approach to measure electrostatic potential at the surface layer of phospholipid membranes, which is based on potential-dependent changes of bilayer hydration and involves very sensitive and convenient ratiometric measurements in fluorescence emission.