From fixed to FRAP: measuring protein mobility and activity in living cells

Experiments with fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) started 30 years ago to visualize the lateral mobility and dynamics of fluorescent proteins in living cells. Its popularity increased when non-invasive fluorescent tagging became possible with the green fluorescent protein (GFP). Many researchers use GFP to study the localization of fusion proteins in fixed or living cells, but the same fluorescent proteins can also be used to study protein mobility in living cells. Here we review the potential of FRAP to study protein dynamics and activity within a single living cell. These measurements can be made with most standard confocal laser-scanning microscopes equipped with photobleaching protocols.     

Genetic tags for labelling live cells: gap junctions and beyond

The availability of green fluorescent protein (GFP) as a tracer for observing proteins in living cells has revolutionized cell biology and spurred an intensive search for GFP variants with novel characteristics, additional autofluorescent proteins and alternative techniques of protein labelling. Two recent studies - one on tagging with tetracysteine motifs and labelling with biarsenic fluorophores of different colours, and the other on GFP tagging and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) - show how membrane channels are added and removed from gap junctions by using different fluorescent tags to distinguish between newly synthesized and older protein populations.     

mEosFP-based green-to-red photoconvertible subcellular probes for plants

Photoconvertible fluorescent proteins (FPs) are recent additions to the biologists' toolbox for understanding the living cell. Like green fluorescent protein (GFP), monomeric EosFP is bright green in color but is efficiently photoconverted into a red fluorescent form using a mild violet-blue excitation. Here, we report mEosFP-based probes that localize to the cytosol, plasma membrane invaginations, endosomes, prevacuolar vesicles, vacuoles, the endoplasmic reticulum, Golgi bodies, mitochondria, peroxisomes, and the two major cytoskeletal elements, filamentous actin and cortical microtubules. The mEosFP fusion proteins are smaller than GFP/red fluorescent protein-based probes and, as demonstrated here, provide several significant advantages for imaging of living plant cells. These include an ability to differentially color label a single cell or a group of cells in a developing organ, selectively highlight a region of a cell or a subpopulation of organelles and vesicles within a cell for tracking them, and understanding spatiotemporal aspects of interactions between similar as well as different organelles. In addition, mEosFP probes introduce a milder alternative to fluorescence recovery after photobleaching, whereby instead of photobleaching, photoconversion followed by recovery of green fluorescence can be used for estimating subcellular dynamics. Most importantly, the two fluorescent forms of mEosFP furnish bright internal controls during imaging experiments and are fully compatible with cyan fluorescent protein, GFP, yellow fluorescent protein, and red fluorescent protein fluorochromes for use in simultaneous, multicolor labeling schemes. Photoconvertible mEosFP-based subcellular probes promise to usher in a much higher degree of precision to live imaging of plant cells than has been possible so far using single-colored FPs.     

AtTRB1, a telomeric DNA‐binding protein from Arabidopsis,is concentrated in the nucleolus and shows highly dynamic association with chromatin

AtTRB1, 2 and 3 are members of the SMH (single Myb histone) protein family, which comprises double‐stranded DNA‐binding proteins that are specific to higher plants. They are structurally conserved, containing a Myb domain at the N‐terminus, a central H1/H5‐like domain and a C‐terminally located coiled‐coil domain. AtTRB1, 2 and 3 interact through their Myb domain specifically with telomeric double‐stranded DNA in vitro, while the central H1/H5‐like domain interacts non‐specifically with DNA sequences and mediates protein–protein interactions. Here we show that AtTRB1, 2 and 3 preferentially localize to the nucleus and nucleolus during interphase. Both the central H1/H5‐like domain and the Myb domain from AtTRB1 can direct a GFP fusion protein to the nucleus and nucleolus. AtTRB1–GFP localization is cell cycle‐regulated, as the level of nuclear‐associated GFP diminishes during mitotic entry and GFP progressively re‐associates with chromatin during anaphase/telophase. Using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching and fluorescence loss in photobleaching, we determined the dynamics of AtTRB1 interactions in vivo. The results reveal that AtTRB1 interaction with chromatin is regulated at two levels at least, one of which is coupled with cell‐cycle progression, with the other involving rapid exchange.     

Monomeric CFTR in plasma membranes in live cells revealed by single molecule fluorescence imaging

The cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) is a cAMP-regulated chloride channel. There is indirect and conflicting evidence about whether CFTR exists in cell membranes as monomers, dimers, or higher order oligomers. We measured fluorescence intensities and photobleaching dynamics of distinct fluorescent spots in cells expressing functional CFTR-green fluorescent protein (GFP) chimeras. Intensity analysis of GFP-labeled CFTR in live cells showed single-component distributions with mean intensity equal to that of purified monomeric GFP, indicating monomeric CFTR in cell membranes. Fluorescent spots showed single-step photobleaching, independently verifying that CFTR is monomeric. Results did not depend on whether GFP was added to the CFTR N terminus or fourth extracellular loop or on whether CFTR chloride conductance was stimulated by cAMP agonists. Control measurements with a CFTR chimera containing two GFPs showed two-step photobleaching and a single-component intensity distribution with mean intensity twice that of monomeric GFP. These results provide direct evidence for monomeric CFTR in live cells.     

GFP-labelled Rubisco and aspartate aminotransferase are present in plastid stromules and traffic between plastids

Plastid stromules are membrane-bound protrusions of the plastid envelope that contain soluble stroma. Stromules are often found connecting plastids within a cell and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) experiments have demonstrated that green fluorescent protein (GFP) can move between plastids via these connections. In this report, the ability of endogenous plastid proteins to travel through stromules was investigated. The motility of GFP-labelled plastid aspartate aminotransferase and the Rubisco small subunit was studied in stromules by FRAP. Both fusion proteins assemble into protein complexes that appear to behave similarly to their endogenous counterparts. In addition, both enzymes are capable of trafficking between plastids via stromules.     

Nuclear aggresomes form by fusion of PML-associated aggregates

Nuclear aggregates formed by proteins containing expanded poly-glutamine (poly-Q) tracts have been linked to the pathogenesis of poly-Q neurodegenerative diseases. Here, we show that a protein (GFP170*) lacking poly-Q tracts forms nuclear aggregates that share characteristics of poly-Q aggregates. GFP170* aggregates recruit cellular chaperones and proteasomes, and alter the organization of nuclear domains containing the promyelocytic leukemia (PML) protein. These results suggest that the formation of nuclear aggregates and their effects on nuclear architecture are not specific to poly-Q proteins. Using GFP170* as a model substrate, we explored the mechanistic details of nuclear aggregate formation. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching and fluorescence loss in photobleaching analyses show that GFP170* molecules exchange rapidly between aggregates and a soluble pool of GFP170*, indicating that the aggregates are dynamic accumulations of GFP170*. The formation of cytoplasmic and nuclear GFP170* aggregates is microtubule-dependent. We show that within the nucleus, GFP170* initially deposits in small aggregates at or adjacent to PML bodies. Time-lapse imaging of live cells shows that small aggregates move toward each other and fuse to form larger aggregates. The coalescence of the aggregates is accompanied by spatial rearrangements of the PML bodies. Significantly, we find that the larger nuclear aggregates have complex internal substructures that reposition extensively during fusion of the aggregates. These studies suggest that nuclear aggregates may be viewed as dynamic multidomain inclusions that continuously remodel their components.     

Localization of peroxisomal matrix proteins by photobleaching

The distribution of some enzymes between peroxisomes and cytosol, or a dual localization in both these compartments, can be difficult to reconcile. We have used photobleaching in live cells expressing green fluorescent protein (GFP)-fusion proteins to show that imported bona fide peroxisomal matrix proteins are retained in the peroxisome. The high mobility of the GFP-fusion proteins in the cytosol and absence of peroxisomal escape makes it possible to eliminate the cytosolic fluorescence by photobleaching, to distinguish between exclusively cytosolic proteins and proteins that are also present at low levels in peroxisomes. Using this technique we found that GFP tagged bile acid-CoA:amino acid N-acyltransferase (BAAT) was exclusively localized in the cytosol in HeLa cells. We conclude that the cytosolic localization was due to its carboxyterminal non-consensus peroxisomal targeting signal (-SQL) since mutation of the -SQL to -SKL resulted in BAAT being efficiently imported into peroxisomes.     

Direct Transfer of Viral and Cellular Proteins from Varicella-Zoster Virus-Infected Non-Neuronal Cells to Human Axons

Varicella Zoster Virus (VZV), the alphaherpesvirus that causes varicella upon primary infection and Herpes zoster (shingles) following reactivation in latently infected neurons, is known to be fusogenic. It forms polynuclear syncytia in culture, in varicella skin lesions and in infected fetal human ganglia xenografted to mice. After axonal infection using VZV expressing green fluorescent protein (GFP) in compartmentalized microfluidic cultures there is diffuse filling of axons with GFP as well as punctate fluorescence corresponding to capsids. Use of viruses with fluorescent fusions to VZV proteins reveals that both proteins encoded by VZV genes and those of the infecting cell are transferred in bulk from infecting non-neuronal cells to axons. Similar transfer of protein to axons was observed following cell associated HSV1 infection. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) experiments provide evidence that this transfer is by diffusion of proteins from the infecting cells into axons. Time-lapse movies and immunocytochemical experiments in co-cultures demonstrate that non-neuronal cells fuse with neuronal somata and proteins from both cell types are present in the syncytia formed. The fusogenic nature of VZV therefore may enable not only conventional entry of virions and capsids into axonal endings in the skin by classical entry mechanisms, but also by cytoplasmic fusion that permits viral protein transfer to neurons in bulk.     

Existence of periplasmic barriers preventing green fluorescent protein diffusion from cell to cell in the cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120

When deprived of combined nitrogen, the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena PCC 7120 relies on intercellular cooperation involving two cell types: nitrogen-fixing heterocysts and photosynthetic vegetative cells. Heterocysts send fixed nitrogen to vegetative cells over long distances along the filament, receiving a reduced carbon source from them. These intercellular exchanges might involve a continuous periplasm along the filament or cytoplasm-to-cytoplasm conduits or both. In the present study, the green fluorescent protein (GFP) was fused to a twin-arginine translocation signal sequence, which exported GFP to the periplasm of either a heterocyst using the heterocyst-specific promoters PhepA and PpatB or to the periplasm of vegetative cells using the vegetative cell-specific promoter PrbcL. Using the techniques of FRAP (fluorescence recovery after photobleaching) and FLIP (fluorescence loss in photobleaching), we found no evidence for intercellular diffusion of GFP through the periplasm, either from a heterocyst to vegetative cells or vice versa, or among vegetative cells. GFP could diffuse within the periplasm of the producing cell, but the diffusion stopped at the cell border. GFP diffusion could occur between two dividing cells before septum closure. This study indicates that barriers exist at the periplasmic space to prevent free GFP diffusion across cell border along the filament.     

Diffusion of green fluorescent protein in three cell environments in Escherichia coli

Surprisingly little is known about the physical environment inside a prokaryotic cell. Knowledge of the rates at which proteins and other cell components can diffuse is crucial for the understanding of a cell as a physical system. There have been numerous measurements of diffusion coefficients in eukaryotic cells by using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) and related techniques. Much less information is available about diffusion coefficients in prokaryotic cells, which differ from eukaryotic cells in a number of significant respects. We have used FRAP to observe the diffusion of green fluorescent protein (GFP) in cells of Escherichia coli elongated by growth in the presence of cephalexin. GFP was expressed in the cytoplasm, exported into the periplasm using the twin-arginine translocation (Tat) system, or fused to an integral plasma membrane protein (TatA). We show that TatA-GFP diffuses in the plasma membrane with a diffusion coefficient comparable to that of a typical eukaryotic membrane protein. A previous report showed a very low rate of protein diffusion in the E. coli periplasm. However, we measured a GFP diffusion coefficient only slightly smaller in the periplasm than that in the cytoplasm, showing that both cell compartments are relatively fluid environments.     

Continuous translocation of Rac2 and the NADPH oxidase component p67(phox) during phagocytosis

In this study, the translocation of the NADPH oxidase components p67(phox) and Rac2 was studied during phagocytosis in living cells. For this purpose, green fluorescent protein (GFP)-tagged versions of these proteins were expressed in the myeloid cell line PLB-985. First, the correct localization of p67GFP and GFP-Rac2 was shown during phagocytosis of serum-treated zymosan by wild-type PLB-985 cells and PLB-985 X-CGD (chronic granulomatous disease) cells, which lack expression of flavocytochrome b(558). Subsequently, these constructs were used for fluorescence recovery after photobleaching studies to elucidate the turnover of these proteins on the phagosomal membrane. The turnover of p67GFP and GFP-Rac2 proved to be very high, indicating a continuous exchange of flavocytochrome b(558)-bound p67GFP and GFP-Rac2 for cytosolic, free p67GFP and GFP-Rac2. Furthermore, the importance of an intact actin cytoskeleton for correct localization of these proteins was investigated by disrupting the actin cytoskeleton with cytochalasin B. However, cytochalasin B treatment of PLB-985 cells did not alter the localization of p67GFP and GFP-Rac2 once phagocytosis was initiated. In addition, the continuous exchange of flavocytochrome b(558)-bound p67GFP and GFP-Rac2 for cytosolic p67GFP and GFP-Rac2 was still intact in cytochalasin B-treated cells, indicating that the translocation of these proteins does not depend on a rearrangement of the actin cytoskeleton.     

High-order photobleaching of green fluorescent protein inside live cells in two-photon excitation microscopy

Combination of green fluorescent protein (GFP) and two-photon excitation fluorescence microscopy (TPE) has been used increasingly to study dynamic biochemical events within living cells, sometimes even in vivo. However, the high photon flux required in TPE may lead to higher-order photobleaching within the focal volume, which would introduce misinterpretation about the fine biochemical events. Here we first studied the high-order photobleaching rate of GFP inside live cells by measuring the dependence of the photobleaching rate on the excitation power. The photobleaching rate under one- and two-photon excitation increased with 1-power and 4-power of the incident intensity, respectively, implying the excitation photons might interact with excited fluorophore molecules and increase the probability of photobleaching. These results suggest that in applications where two-photon imaging of GFP is used to study dynamic molecular process, photobleaching may ruin the imaging results and attention should be paid in interpreting the imaging results.     

Diffusion of green fluorescent protein in the aqueous-phase lumen of endoplasmic reticulum

The endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is the major compartment for the processing and quality control of newly synthesized proteins. Green fluorescent protein (GFP) was used as a noninvasive probe to determine the viscous properties of the aqueous lumen of the ER. GFP was targeted to the ER lumen of CHO cells by transient transfection with cDNA encoding GFP (S65T/F64L mutant) with a C-terminus KDEL retention sequence and upstream prolactin secretory sequence. Repeated laser illumination of a fixed 2-micrometers diameter spot resulted in complete bleaching of ER-associated GFP throughout the cell, indicating a continuous ER lumen. A residual amount (<1%) of GFP-KDEL was perinuclear and noncontiguous with the ER, presumably within a pre- or cis-Golgi compartment involved in KDEL-substrate retention. Quantitative spot photobleaching with a single brief bleach pulse indicated that GFP was fully mobile with a t1/2 for fluorescence recovery of 88 +/- 5 ms (SE; 60x lens) and 143 +/- 8 ms (40x). Fluorescence recovery was abolished by paraformaldehyde except for a small component of reversible photobleaching with t1/2 of 3 ms. For comparison, the t1/2 for photobleaching of GFP in cytoplasm was 14 +/- 2 ms (60x) and 24 +/- 1 ms (40x). Utilizing a mathematical model that accounted for ER reticular geometry, a GFP diffusion coefficient of 0.5-1 x 10(-7) cm2/s was computed, 9-18-fold less than that in water and 3-6-fold less than that in cytoplasm. By frequency-domain microfluorimetry, the GFP rotational correlation time was measured to be 39 +/- 8 ns, approximately 2-fold greater than that in water but comparable to that in the cytoplasm. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching using a 40x lens was measured (at 23 degrees C unless otherwise indicated) for several potential effectors of ER structure and/or lumen environment: t1/2 values (in ms) were 143 +/- 8 (control), 100 +/- 13 (37 degrees C), 53 +/- 13 (brefeldin A), and 139 +/- 6 (dithiothreitol). These results indicate moderately slowed GFP diffusion in a continuous ER lumen.     

Photobleaching recovery and anisotropy decay of green fluorescent protein GFP-S65T in solution and cells: cytoplasmic viscosity probed by green fluorescent protein translational and rotational diffusion.

The green fluorescent protein (GFP) was used as a noninvasive probe to quantify the rheological properties of cell cytoplasm. GFP mutant S65T was purified from recombinant bacteria for solution studies, and expressed in CHO cell cytoplasm. GFP-S65T was brightly fluorescent in solution (lambda ex 492 nm, lambda em 509 nm) with a lifetime of 2.9 ns and a rotational correlation time (tc) of 20 ns. Recovery of GFP fluorescence after photobleaching was complete with a half-time (t1/2) in aqueous saline of 30 +/- 2 ms (5-micron diameter spot), giving a diffusion coefficient of 8.7 x 10(-7) cm2/s. The t1/2 was proportional to solution viscosity and was dependent on spot diameter. In contrast to fluorescein. GFP photobleaching efficiency was not affected by solution O2 content, triplet state quenchers, singlet oxygen scavengers, and general radical quenchers. In solutions of higher viscosity, an additional, rapid GFP recovery process was detected and ascribed to reversible photobleaching. The t1/2 for reversible photobleaching was 1.5-5.5 ms (relative viscosity 5-250), was independent of spot diameter, and was unaffected by O2 or quenchers. In cell cytoplasm, time-resolved microfluorimetry indicated a GFP lifetime of 2.6 ns and a tc of 36 +/- 3 ns, giving a relative viscosity (cytoplasm versus water) of 1.5. Photobleaching recovery of GFP in cytoplasm was 82 +/- 2% complete with a t1/2 of 83 +/- 6 ms, giving a relative viscosity of 3.2. GFP translational diffusion increased 4.7-fold as cells swelled from a relative volume of 0.5 to 2. Taken together with measurements of GFP translation and rotation in aqueous dextran solutions, the data in cytoplasm support the view that the primary barrier to GFP diffusion is collisional interactions between GFP and macromolecular solutes.     

Dynamics and mobility of nuclear envelope proteins in interphase and mitotic cells revealed by green fluorescent protein chimeras

Understanding how membrane proteins are targeted to and retained within the nuclear envelope (NE) and the fate of these proteins during NE disassembly/reassembly in mitosis is central for insight into the function of the NE in nuclear organization and dynamics. To address these issues we have attached green fluorescent protein (GFP) to a well-characterized protein of the inner nuclear membrane, lamin B receptor, believed to be one of the major chromatin docking protein in the NE. We have used this construct in a variety of applications, including dual-color GFP time-lapse imaging, to investigate the mechanisms underlying protein targeting to the NE and NE breakdown and reassembly during mitosis. In this review, we present a summary of the results from such studies and discuss the photobleaching and imaging methodology on which they were derived.     

Green fluorescent protein photobleaching: a model for protein damage by endogenous and exogenous singlet oxygen

Characterization of protein damage during photosensitization of chlorin e6-treated cells was performed using the green fluorescent protein (GFP). The GFP-chromophore damage caused by singlet oxygen was studied in COS 7 kidney cells and E. coli bacteria following light irradiation. Electron spin resonance (ESR) revealed the generation of endogenous singlet oxygen (1O2) by photoactivated GFP, an effect similar to that produced by the exogenous photosensitizer chlorin e6. A light dose-dependent photobleaching effect of GFP was pronounced at low pH or upon photosensitization with chlorin e6. However, the 1O2 quenchers beta-carotene and sodium azide minimized GFP photo-bleaching. Gel electrophoresis of photosensitized GFP followed by fluorescence multi-pixel spectral imaging revealed the binding of chlorin e6 to GFP, affecting the photobleaching efficacy. Fluorescence multi-pixel spectral imaging of GFP-transfected COS 7 cells demonstrated the presence of GFP in the cytoplasm and nucleus, while chlorin e6 was found to be concentrated in the perinuclear vesicles. Exposure of the cells to light induced GFP photobleaching in the close vicinity of chlorin e6 vesicles. We conclude that photoactivated GFP generates endogenous 1O2, inducing chromophore damage, which can be enhanced by the cooperation of exogenous chlorin e6.     

Reversible photobleaching of enhanced green fluorescent proteins

Color variants of green fluorescent protein (GFP) are increasingly used for multicolor imaging, fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET), and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP). Here we show that experimental settings commonly used in these imaging experiments may induce an as yet uncharacterized reversible photobleaching of fluorescent proteins, which is more pronounced at acidic pH. Whereas the reversible photobleaching spectrum of eCFP corresponds to its absorption spectrum, reversible photobleaching spectra of yellow variants resemble absorption spectra of their protonated states. Fluorescence intensities recover spontaneously with time constants of 25-58 s. The recovery of eCFP can be further accelerated by illumination. The resulting steady-state fluorescence reflects a variable equilibrium between reversible photobleaching, spontaneous recovery, and light-induced recovery. These processes can cause significant artifacts in commonly applied imaging techniques, photobleach-based FRET determinations, and FRAP assays.     

Characterization of the activity of a plastid-targeted green fluorescent protein in Arabidopsis.

In Arabidopsis thaliana the PALE CRESS (PAC) gene product is required for both chloroplast and cell differentiation. Transgenic Arabidopsis plants expressing a translational fusion of the N-terminal part of the PAC protein harboring the complete plastid-targeting sequence and the green fluorescent protein (GFP) exhibit high GFP fluorescence. Detailed analyses based on confocal imaging of various tissues and cell types revealed that the PAC-GFP fusion protein accumulates in chloroplasts of mature stomatal guard cells. The GFP fluorescence within the guard cell chloroplasts is not evenly distributed and appears to be concentrated in suborganellar regions. GFP localization studies demonstrate that thin tubular projections emanating from chloroplasts and etioplasts often connect the organelles with each other. Furthermore, imaging of non-green and etiolated tissue further revealed that GFP fluorescence is present in proplastids, etioplasts, chromoplasts, and amyloplasts. Even photobleaching of carotenoid-free plastids does not affect PAC-GFP accumulation in the organelles of the guard cells indicating that the protein translocation machinery is functional in all types of plastids. The specific accumulation of GFP in guard cell chloroplasts, their tubular connections, the translocation of the precursor polypeptide into the different types of organelles, as well as the use of a plastid-targeted GFP protein as a versatile marker is discussed in the context of previously described observations.