Hypermutable minisatellites,a human affair?

Minisatellites are a class of highly polymorphic GC-rich tandem repeats. They include some of the most variable loci in the human genome, with mutation rates ranging from 0.5% to >20% per generation. Structurally, they consist of 10- to 100-bp intermingled variant repeats, making them ideal tools for dissecting mechanisms of instability at tandem repeats. Distinct mutation processes generate rare intra-allelic somatic events and frequent complex conversion-like germline mutations in these repeats. Furthermore, turnover of repeats at human minisatellites is controlled by intense recombinational activity in DNA flanking the repeat array. Surprisingly, whereas other mammalian genomes possess minisatellite-like sequences, hypermutable loci have not been identified that suggest human-specific turnover processes at minisatellite arrays. Attempts to transfer minisatellite germline instability to the mouse have failed. However, yeast models are now revealing valuable information regarding the mechanisms regulating instability at these tandem repeats. Finally, minisatellites and tandem repeats provide exquisitely sensitive molecular tools to detect genomic insults such as ionizing radiation exposure. Surprisingly, by a mechanism that remains elusive, there are transgenerational increases in minisatellite instability.     

Two modes of germline instability at human minisatellite MS1 (locus D1S7): complex rearrangements and paradoxical hyperdeletion

Minisatellite MS1 (locus D1S7) is one of the most unstable minisatellites identified in humans. It is unusual in having a short repeat unit of 9 bp and in showing somatic instability in colorectal carcinomas, suggesting that mitotic replication or repair errors may contribute to repeat-DNA mutation. We have therefore used single-molecule polymerase chain reaction to characterize mutation events in sperm and somatic DNA. As with other minisatellites, high levels of instability are seen only in the germline and generate two distinct classes of structural change. The first involves large and frequently complex rearrangements that most likely arise by recombinational processes, as is seen at other minisatellites. The second pathway generates primarily, if not exclusively, single-repeat changes restricted to sequence-homogeneous regions of alleles. Their frequency is dependent on the length of uninterrupted repeats, with evidence of a hyperinstability threshold similar in length to that observed at triplet-repeat loci showing expansions driven by dynamic mutation. In contrast to triplet loci, however, the single-repeat changes at MS1 exclusively involve repeat deletion, and can be so frequent--as many as 0.7-1.3 mutation events per sperm cell for the longest homogeneous arrays--that alleles harboring these long arrays must be extremely ephemeral in human populations. The apparently impossible existence of alleles with deletion-prone uninterrupted repeats therefore presents a paradox with no obvious explanation.     

Multiple levels of single-strand slippage at cetacean tri- and tetranucleotide repeat microsatellite loci.

Between three and six tri- and tetranucleotide repeat microsatellite loci were analyzed in 3720 samples collected from four different species of baleen whales. Ten of the 18 species/locus combinations had imperfect allele arrays, i.e., some alleles differed in length by other than simple integer multiples of the basic repeat length. The estimate of the average number of alleles and heterozygosity was higher at loci with imperfect allele arrays relative to those with perfect allele arrays. Nucleotide sequences of 23 different alleles at one tetranucleotide repeat microsatellite locus in fin whales, Balaenoptera physalus, and humpback whales, Megaptera novaeangliae, revealed sequence changes including perfect repeats only, multiple repeats, and partial repeats. The relative rate of the latter two categories of mutation was estimated at 0.024 of the mutation rate involving perfect repeats only. It is hypothesized that single-strand slippage of partial repeats may provide a mechanism for counteracting the continuous expansion of microsatellite loci, which is the logical consequence of recent reports demonstrating directional mutations. Partial-repeat mutations introduce imperfections in the repeat array, which subsequently could reduce the rate of single-strand slippage. Limited computer simulations confirmed this predicted effect of partial-repeat mutations.     

Dynamics of 5S rDNA in the tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) genome: repeat units,inverted sequences,pseudogenes and chromosome loci

In higher eukaryotes, the 5S ribosomal DNA (5S rDNA) is organized in tandem arrays with repeat units composed of a coding region and a non-transcribed spacer sequence (NTS). These tandem arrays can be found on either one or more chromosome pairs. 5S rDNA copies from the tilapia fish, Oreochromis niloticus, were cloned and the nucleotide sequences of the coding region and of the non-transcribed spacer were determined. Moreover, the genomic organization of the 5S rDNA tandem repeats was investigated by fluorescence IN SITU hybridization (FISH) and Southern blot hybridization. Two 5S rDNA classes, one consisting of 1.4-kb repeats and another one with 0.5-kb repeats were identified and designated 5S rDNA type I and type II, respectively. An inverted 5S rRNA gene and a 5S rRNA putative pseudogene were also identified inside the tandem repeats of 5S rDNA type I. FISH permitted the visualization of the 5S rRNA genes at three chromosome loci, one of them consisting of arrays of the 5S rDNA type I, and the two others corresponding to arrays of the 5S rDNA type II. The two classes of the 5S rDNA, the presence of pseudogenes, and the inverted genes observed in the O. niloticus genome might be a consequence of the intense dynamics of the evolution of these tandem repeat elements.     

Human minisatellite alleles detectable only after PCR amplification.

We present evidence that a proportion of alleles at two human minisatellite loci is undetected by standard Southern blot hybridization. In each case the missing allele(s) can be identified after PCR amplification and correspond to tandem arrays too short to detect by hybridization. At one locus, there is only one undetected allele (population frequency 0.3), which contains just three repeat units. At the second locus, there are at least five undetected alleles (total population frequency 0.9) containing 60-120 repeats; they are not detected because these tandem repeats give very poor signals when used as a probe in standard Southern blot hybridization, and also cross-hybridize with other sequences in the genome. Under these circumstances only signals from the longest tandemly repeated alleles are detectable above the nonspecific background. The structures of these loci have been compared in human and primate DNA, and at one locus the short human allele containing three repeat units is shown to be an intermediate state in the expansion of a monomeric precursor allele in primates to high copy number in the longer human arrays. We discuss the implications of such loci for studies of human populations, minisatellite isolation by cloning, and the evolution of highly variable tandem arrays.     

Minisatellites show rare and simple intra-allelic instability in the mouse germ line

Minisatellites provide very informative systems for analyzing processes of tandem repeat DNA turnover in humans. The mouse genome also contains authentic minisatellites, but none has yet been found to show high levels of instability. Indirect evidence using minisatellite variant repeat mapping by PCR in Mus musculus subspecies suggested that mouse minisatellites mutate at a rate below 10(-3) per gamete and mainly by intra-allelic events. This is in sharp contrast to the complex interallelic mutations observed at high frequency at some human loci. To define more directly the turnover mechanisms and rates of instability at one of the most variable mouse minisatellites (MMS80), we used size-enrichment small-pool PCR (SESP-PCR) to recover de novo mutant alleles from sperm DNA from homozygous BALB/cJ mice and from strain DHA heterozygotes. The sperm mutation rate at MMS80 was extremely low, at or below 5 x 10(-6) per sperm. Comparison of progenitor and mutant allele structures showed that these rare mutants had arisen by simple and primarily, if not exclusively, intra-allelic mutation events. These results suggest a fundamental difference in turnover mechanisms at minisatellites between mice and human.     

A Phylogenetic Perspective on Sequence Evolution in Microsatellite Loci

We examined the evolution of the repeat regions of three noncoding microsatellite loci in 58 species of the Polistinae, a subfamily of wasps that diverged over 140 million years ago. A phylogenetic approach allows two new kinds of approaches to studying microsatellite evolution: character mapping and comparative analysis. The basic repeat structure of the loci was highly conserved, but was often punctuated with imperfections that appear to be phylogenetically informative. Repeat numbers evolved more rapidly than other changes in the repeat region. Changes in number of repeats among species seem consistent with the stepwise mutation model, which is based on slippage during replication as the main source of mutations. Changes in repeat numbers can occur even when there are very few tandem repeats but longer repeats, especially perfect repeats led to greater rates of evolutionary change. Species phylogenetically closer to the one from which we identified the loci had longer stretches of uninterrupted repeats and more different motifs, but not longer total repeat regions. The number of perfect repeats increased more often than it decreased. However, there was no evidence that some species have consistently greater numbers of repeats across loci than other species have, once ascertainment bias is eliminated. We also found no evidence for a population size effect posited by one form of the directionality hypothesis. Overall, phylogenetic variation in repeat regions can be explained by adding neutral evolution to what is already known about the mutation process. The life cycle of microsatellites appears to reflect a balance between growth by slippage and degradation by an essentially irreversible accumulation of imperfections. Received: 13 April 1999 / Accepted: 8 September 1999     

Complex mutations in a high proportion of microsatellite loci from the protozoan parasite Plasmodium falciparum

Microsatellite loci are generally assumed to evolve via a stepwise mutational process and a battery of statistical techniques has been developed in recent years based on this or related mutation models. It is therefore important to investigate the appropriateness of these models in a wide variety of taxa. We used two approaches to examine mutation patterns in the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum: (i) we examined sequence variation at 12 tri-nucleotide repeat loci; and (ii) we analysed patterns of repeat structure and heterozygosity at 114 loci using data from 12 laboratory parasite lines. The sequencing study revealed complex patterns of mutation in five of the 12 loci studied. Alleles at two loci contain indels of 24 bp and 57 bp in flanking regions, while in the other three loci, blocks of imperfect microsatellites appear to be duplicated or inserted; these loci essentially consist of minisatellite repeats, with each repeat unit containing four to eight microsatellites. The survey of heterozygosity revealed a positive relationship between repeat number and microsatellite variability for both di- and trinucleotides, indicating a higher mutation rate in loci with longer repeat arrays. Comparisons of levels of variation in different repeat types indicate that the mutation rate of dinucleotide-bearing loci is 1.6-2.1 times faster than trinucleotides, consistent with the lower mean number of repeats in trinucleotide-bearing loci. However, despite the evidence that microsatellite arrays themselves are evolving in a manner consistent with stepwise mutation model in P. falciparum, the high frequency of complex mutations precludes the use of analytical tools based on this mutation model for many microsatellite-bearing loci in this protozoan. The results call into question the generality of models based on stepwise mutation for analysing microsatellite data, but also demonstrate the ease with which loci that violate model assumptions can be detected using minimal sequencing effort.     

Genomic structure and sequence variation of a 3.3-kb repeat DNA element of the kangaroo rat, Dipodomys ordii

The genomic structure and sequence variation of a 3.3-kb repeat DNA element, representing 5% of the genome of the kangaroo rat Dipodomys ordii, has been investigated. Most of the repeats are arranged in tandem arrays of 50 kb or more. Thirteen randomly selected genomic clones have been mapped with twelve restriction enzymes. The frequency of sequence divergence in the genomic clones is 0.5%. The clone maps and the genomic structure studies have permitted the characterization of a number of variant members of the 3.3-kb repeat family. The genomic organization of the repeat resembles that for repeated DNAs found in large tandem arrays or satellites.     

Genesis of a fungal non-self recognition repertoire

Conspecific allorecognition, the ability for an organism to discriminate its own cells from those of another individual of the same species, has been developed by many organisms. Allorecognition specificities are determined by highly polymorphic genes. The processes by which this extreme polymorphism is generated remain largely unknown. Fungi are able to form heterokaryons by fusion of somatic cells, and somatic non self-recognition is controlled by heterokaryon incompatibility loci (het loci). Herein, we have analyzed the evolutionary features of the het-d and het-e fungal allorecognition genes. In these het genes, allorecognition specificity is determined by a polymorphic WD-repeat domain. We found that het-d and het-e belong to a large gene family with 10 members that all share the WD-repeat domain and show that repeats of all members of the family undergo concerted evolution. It follows that repeat units are constantly exchanged both within and between members of the gene family. As a consequence, high mutation supply in the repeat domain is ensured due to the high total copy number of repeats. We then show that in each repeat four residues located at the protein/protein interaction surface of the WD-repeat domain are under positive diversifying selection. Diversification of het-d and het-e is thus ensured by high mutation supply, followed by reshuffling of the repeats and positive selection for favourable variants. We also propose that RIP, a fungal specific hypermutation process acting specifically on repeated sequences might further enhance mutation supply. The combination of these evolutionary mechanisms constitutes an original process for generating extensive polymorphism at loci that require rapid diversification.     

Tandemly repeated DNA: why should anyone care?

Recent excitement over SNPs has tended to obscure the real advantages of studying tandemly repeated loci. In this commentary, I make the case for studying tandem repeats, concentrating on two major arguments. Firstly, tandemly repeated loci are unrivalled as a source of detailed mechanistic information in studies of variation and mutation, and are highly informative reporters of genomic instability in studies of induced mutation. Secondly, changes at many tandem repeats have important functional consequences, and in addition to examples of "strong" single-gene effects such as those at the triplet repeat disease loci, there may well be a much larger number of loci at which subtler functional effects remain to be discovered.     

Stable minihairpin structures forming at minisatellite DNA isolated from yellow fin sea bream Acanthopagrus latus

The lengths of simple repeat sequences are generally unstable or polymorphic (highly variable with respect to the numbers of tandem repeats). Previously we have isolated a family of minisatellite DNA (GenBank accession AF422186) that appears specifically and abundantly in the genome of yellow fin sea bream Acanthopagrus latus but not in closely-related red sea bream Pagrus major, and found that the numbers of tandem arrays in the homologous loci are polymorphic. This means that the minisatellite sequence has appeared and propagated in A. latus genome after speciation. In order to understand what makes the minisatellite widespread within the A. latus genome and what causes the polymorphic nature of the number of tandem repeats, the structural features of single-stranded polynucleotides were analyzed by electrophoresis, chemical modification, circular dichroism (CD), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and electron microscopy. The results suggest that a portion of the repeat unit forms a stable minihairpin structure, and it can cause polymerase pausing within the minisatellite DNA.     

Tandemly Repeated Sequence Families in Micronuclear DNA of the Ciliate Stylonychia pustulata1

One third of a collection of cloned Stylonychia pustulata micronuclear DNA PstI fragments were found to be of a similar size, consistent with their being members of a repetitious sequence family with a repeat size of about 160 base pairs. Cross-hybridization experiments confirmed that these small cloned fragments are related by sequence homology. Hybridization of the cloned repetitious sequences to PstI digested micronuclear DNA revealed a “ladder” of bands (step size = 160 base pairs), indicating that the repeats are found in tandem arrays. This is the first demonstration of highly repetitious, tandemly repeated sequences in a ciliated protozoan.     

Hypervariable 3′ UTR region of plant LTR-retrotransposons as a source of novel satellite repeats

The repetitive sequence PisTR-A has an unusual organization in the pea (Pisum sativum) genome, being present both as short dispersed repeats as well as long arrays of tandemly arranged satellite DNA. Cloning, sequencing and FISH analysis of both PisTR-A variants revealed that the former occurs in the genome embedded within the sequence of Ty3/gypsy-like Ogre elements, whereas the latter forms homogenized arrays of satellite repeats at several genomic loci. The Ogre elements carry the PisTR-A sequences in their 3′ untranslated region (UTR) separating the gag-pol region from the 3′ LTR. This region was found to be highly variable among pea Ogre elements, and includes a number of other tandem repeats along with or instead of PisTR-A. Bioinformatic analysis of LTR-retrotransposons mined from available plant genomic sequence data revealed that the frequent occurrence of variable tandem repeats within 3′ UTRs is a typical feature of the Tat lineage of plant retrotransposons. Comparison of these repeats to known plant satellite sequences uncovered two other instances of satellites with sequence similarity to a Tat-like retrotransposon 3′ UTR regions. These observations suggest that some retrotransposons may significantly contribute to satellite DNA evolution by generating a library of short repeat arrays that can subsequently be dispersed through the genome and eventually further amplified and homogenized into novel satellite repeats.     

Molecular analysis of a polymorphic domain of alpha satellite from the human X chromosome.

Alpha satellite DNA, a diverse family of tandemly repeated DNA sequences located at the centromeric region of each human chromosome, is organized in a highly chromosome-specific manner and is characterized by a high frequency of restriction-fragment-length polymorphism. To examine events underlying the formation and spread of these polymorphisms within a tandem array, we have cloned and sequenced a representative copy of a polymorphic array from the X chromosome and compared this polymorphic copy with the predominant higher-order repeat form of X-linked alpha satellite. Sequence data indicate that the polymorphism arose by a single base mutation that created a new restriction site (for HindIII) in the sequence of the predominant repeat unit. This variant repeat unit, marked by the new HindIII site, was subsequently amplified in copy number to create a polymorphic domain consisting of approximately 500 copies of the variant repeat unit within the X-linked array of alpha satellite. We propose that a series of intrachromosomal recombination events between misaligned tandem arrays, involving multiple rounds of either unequal crossing-over or sequence conversion, facilitated the spread and fixation of this variant HindIII repeat unit.     

Mutation rate in human microsatellites: influence of the structure and length of the tandem repeat.

In 10,844 parent/child allelic transfers at nine short-tandem-repeat (STR) loci, 23 isolated STR mismatches were observed. The parenthood in each of these cases was highly validated (probability >99.97%). The event was always repeat related, owing to either a single-step mutation (n=22) or a double-step mutation (n=1). The mutation rate was between 0 and 7 x 10(-3) per locus per gamete per generation. No mutations were observed in three of the nine loci. Mutation events in the male germ line were five to six times more frequent than in the female germ line. A positive exponential correlation between the geometric mean of the number of uninterrupted repeats and the mutation rate was observed. Our data demonstrate that mutation rates of different loci can differ by several orders of magnitude and that different alleles at one locus exhibit different mutation rates.     

The centromere region of Arabidopsis thaliana chromosome 1 contains telomere-similar sequences.

We describe the structure of an Arabidopsis thaliana genomic clone containing two classes of repetitive DNA elements derived from the centromere region of chromosome 1. One class is comprised of tandem arrays of a highly reiterated repeat containing degenerate telomere sequence motifs. Adjacent to these telomere-similar repeats we found a dispersed repetitive element reiterated approximately five times in the A. thaliana genome. The nucleotide sequence of the dispersed repeat is unusual, being extremely AT-rich and composed of numerous, overlapping repeat motifs.     

Extensive Amplification and Transposition of a Novel Repetitive Element, Xstir, Together with Its Terminal Inverted Repeat in the Evolution of Xenopus

A DNA fragment containing short tandem repeat sequences (approximately 86-bp repeat) was isolated from a Xenopus laevis cDNA library. Southern blot and in situ hybridization analyses revealed that the repeat was highly dispersed in the genome and was present at approximately 1 million copies per haploid genome. We named this element Xstir (Xenopus short tandemly and invertedly repeating element) after its arrangement in the genome. The majority of the genomic Xstir sequences were digested to monomer and dimer sizes with several restriction enzymes. Their sequences were found to be highly homogeneous and organized into tandem arrays in the genome. Alignment analyses of several known sequences showed that some of the Xstir-like sequences were also organized into interspersed inverted repeats. The inverted repeats consisted of an inverted pair of two differently modified Xstirs separated by a short insert. In addition, these were framed by another novel inverted repeat (Xstir-TIR). The Xstir-TIR sequence was also found at the ends of tandem Xstir arrays. Furthermore, we found that Xstir-TIR was linked to a motif characterizing the T2 family which belonged to a vertebrate MITE (miniature inverted-repeat transposable element) family, suggesting the importance of Xstir-TIR for their amplification and transposition. The present study of 11 anuran and 2 urodele species revealed that Xstir or Xstir-like sequences were extensively amplified in the three Xenopus species. Genomic Xstir populations of X. borealis and X. laevis were mutually indistinguishable but significantly different from that of X. tropicalis. Received: 5 April 2000 / Accepted: 3 August 2000     

The spread of sequence variants in Rattus satellite DNAs

The genus Rattus has two related families of satellite DNA: Satellite I consists of tandem arrays of a 370 base pair repeat unit which is a dimer of two 185 base pair portions (a, b) which are about 60% homologous. Satellite I' consists of tandem arrays of a 185 base pair repeat unit (a') which is about 85% homologous to a and 60% homologous to b. R. norvegicus contains only satellite I but R. rattus contains both satellites I and I'. We examined certain aspects of satellite DNA evolution by comparing the spacing at which variant repeat units of each satellite have spread among non-variant repeat units in these two species. With but one exception, in R. rattus, 15 different variant repeat units have spread among non-variant repeat units of satellite I, with a spacing equal to the length of the (a,b) dimer. Similarly, fourteen different variant repeat units of the monomeric satellite I' have mixed among non-variant repeat units with a spacing equal to the length of the (a') monomer. These results suggest that a mechanism involving homologous interaction among satellite sequences could account for the spread of variant family members. We also found that a sequence variant present in certain portions of the dimeric repeat unit of satellite I is more efficiently amplified (or less efficiently corrected) than variants occurring in other regions. This was not true for the monomeric repeat unit of satellite I'.     

Evolution of Repeated Sequence Arrays in the D-Loop Region of Bat Mitochondrial DNA

Analysis of mitochondrial DNA control region sequences from 41 species of bats representing 11 families revealed that repeated sequence arrays near the tRNA-Pro gene are present in all vespertilionine bats. Across 18 species tandem repeats varied in size from 78 to 85 bp and contained two to nine repeats. Heteroplasmy ranged from 15% to 63%. Fewer repeats among heteroplasmic than homoplasmic individuals in a species with up to nine repeats indicates selection may act against long arrays. A lower limit of two repeats and more repeats among heteroplasmic than homoplasmic individuals in two species with few repeats suggests length mutations are biased. Significant regressions of heteroplasmy, θ and π, on repeat number further suggest that repeat duplication rate increases with repeat number. Comparison of vespertilionine bat consensus repeats to mammal control region sequences revealed that tandem repeats of similar size, sequence and number also occur in shrews, cats and bighorn sheep. The presence of two conserved protein-binding sequences in all repeat units indicates that convergent evolution has occurred by duplication of functional units. We speculate that D-loop region tandem repeats may provide signal redundancy and a primitive repair mechanism in the event of somatic mutations to these binding sites.