Amounts of Nuclear DNA and Internal Morphology of Gibberellin- and Abscisic Acid-deficient Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) Seeds During Maturation, Imbibition and Germination

Using X-ray photography and flow cytometry, the internal morphologyand DNA replication activity of wild type (wt), GA- (gib-1 )and ABA-deficient (sit^w ) tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.cv. Moneymaker) mutant seeds were studied. During seed formation,from 30 to 45 d after pollination (DAP) the endosperm becomessolid and the seed starts to gain desiccation tolerance. Atthis time significant changes occur in the amounts of DNA inradicle tip cells. At 30 DAP, radicle tip cells of the threegenotypes manifest about 60% of 2C, 30% of 4C and 10% of 8Camounts of DNA. Upon maturation (45 DAP onwards), most cellsin the seeds of the three genotypes arrest in the G₁phase ofthe cell-cycle with 2C amounts of DNA. However, a relativelyhigh proportion of cells with 4C amounts of DNA was detectedin the radicle tip cells ofsit^w compared with wild type andgib-1. At the well-matured stage (60 DAP), there were about 2% ofseeds with free space in wild type andgib-1 , and about 13%insit^w . At the over-matured stage (75 DAP), even more seedswith free space were found insit^w , whereas no increase in theproportion of the seeds with free space was detected in theother two genotypes. In -1.0 MPa PEG-6000 with or without 10µM GA₄₊₇, no germination occurred in well-matured wildtype andgib-1 seeds, whether or not they were dried after harvest.However,sit^w seeds were able to germinate both in over-maturefruit and in -1.0 MPa PEG-6000. Priming of dried seeds in -1.0MPa PEG induced a large amount of free space in almost all seedsof the three genotypes, and nuclear DNA synthesis in the radicletip cells of wild type andsit^w seeds. However, PEG priming offresh (non-dried) seeds had no effect on the amount of freespace and 2C/4C DNA ratios in wild type orgib-1 seeds, but didinduce free space in about 20–25% ofsit^w seeds and provoked4C signals insit^w seeds. Removal of the endosperm and testaopposite the radicle tip of seeds resulted in root protrusion,the induction of free space and an increase of 4C DNA signalsin the three genotypes. It is concluded that ABA is crucialfor the efficient arrest of tomato embryo radicle tip cellsin G₁phase upon maturation, whereas GAs play an important rolein re-initiating 4C DNA levels upon germination. Dormancy; flow cytometry; free space; Lycopersicon esculentum ; maturation; priming; seed; tomato     

Vacuolar H+-ATPase Is Expressed in Response to Gibberellin during Tomato Seed Germination

Completion of germination (radicle emergence) by gibberellin (GA)-deficient (gib-1) mutant tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) seeds is dependent upon exogenous GA, because weakening of the endosperm tissue enclosing the radicle tip requires GA. To investigate genes that may be involved in endosperm weakening or embryo growth, differential cDNA display was used to identify mRNAs differentially expressed in gib-1 seeds imbibed in the presence or absence of GA₄₊₇. Among these was a GA-responsive mRNA encoding the 16-kD hydrophobic subunit c of the V₀ membrane sector of vacuolar H⁺-translocating ATPases (V-ATPase), which we termed LVA-P1. LVA-P1 mRNA expression in gib-1 seeds was dependent on GA and was particularly abundant in the micropylar region prior to radicle emergence. Both GA dependence and tissue localization of LVA-P1 mRNA expression were confirmed directly in individual gib-1 seeds using tissue printing. LVA-P1 mRNA was also expressed in wild-type seeds during development and germination, independent of exogenous GA. Specific antisera detected protein subunits A and B of the cytoplasmic V₁ sector of the V-ATPase holoenzyme complex in gib-1 seeds only in the presence of GA, and expression was localized to the micropylar region. The results suggest that V-ATPase plays a role in GA-regulated germination of tomato seeds.     

Nuclear replication activities during imbibition of abscisic acid- and gibberellin-deficient tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) seeds

The role of cis-abscisic acid (ABA) and gibberellins (GAs) in the induction of cell-cycle activities has been studied during imbibition and subsequent germination of tomato seeds. Using flow cytometry, nuclear replication activity was investigated in embryo root tips isolated from seeds of the ABA-deficient mutant sit ^w , the GA-deficient mutant gib-1, and the wild-type (MM) tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv. Moneymaker) upon imbibition in water, 10 μM GA₄₊₇, 5 μM ABA or 5 μM ABA+10 μM GA₄₊₇. The nuclei of fully matured dry MM, sit ^w and gib-1 seeds predominantly showed 2C DNA signals, indicating that the cell-cycle activity of most root-tip cells had been arrested at the G₁ phase of nuclear division. However, ABA-deficient sit ^w seeds contained a significantly higher amount of G₂ cells (4C DNA) compared with the other genotypes, suggesting that, during maturation, cell-cycle activity in sit ^w seeds is less efficiently arrested in G₁. Upon imbibition in water, an induction of the 4C signal, indicating nuclear replication, was observed in the root tip cells of both MM and sit ^w embroys. The augmentation in the 4C signal occurred before visible germination. Gib-1 seeds did not show cell-cycle activity and did not germinate in water. Upon imbibition in GA₄₊₇, both cell-cycle activity and subsequent germination were enhanced in MM and sit ^w seeds, and were induced in gib-1. In ABA, the germination of MM and sit ^w seeds was inhibited while nuclear replication of these seeds was not affected. It is concluded that GA influences germination by acting upon processes that precede cell-cycle activation, while ABA affects growth by acting upon processes that follow cell-cycle activation.     

Vacuolar H(+)-ATPase is expressed in response to gibberellin during tomato seed germination

Completion of germination (radicle emergence) by gibberellin (GA)-deficient (gib-1) mutant tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) seeds is dependent upon exogenous GA, because weakening of the endosperm tissue enclosing the radicle tip requires GA. To investigate genes that may be involved in endosperm weakening or embryo growth, differential cDNA display was used to identify mRNAs differentially expressed in gib-1 seeds imbibed in the presence or absence of GA(4+7). Among these was a GA-responsive mRNA encoding the 16-kD hydrophobic subunit c of the V(0) membrane sector of vacuolar H(+)-translocating ATPases (V-ATPase), which we termed LVA-P1. LVA-P1 mRNA expression in gib-1 seeds was dependent on GA and was particularly abundant in the micropylar region prior to radicle emergence. Both GA dependence and tissue localization of LVA-P1 mRNA expression were confirmed directly in individual gib-1 seeds using tissue printing. LVA-P1 mRNA was also expressed in wild-type seeds during development and germination, independent of exogenous GA. Specific antisera detected protein subunits A and B of the cytoplasmic V(1) sector of the V-ATPase holoenzyme complex in gib-1 seeds only in the presence of GA, and expression was localized to the micropylar region. The results suggest that V-ATPase plays a role in GA-regulated germination of tomato seeds.     

A Role for the Surrounding Fruit Tissues in Preventing the Germination of Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) Seeds : A Consideration of the Osmotic Environment and Abscisic Acid

During tomato seed development the endogenous abscisic acid (ABA) concentration peaks at about 50 d after pollination (DAP) and then declines at later stages (60-70 DAP) of maturation. The ABA concentration in the sheath tissue immediately surrounding the seed increases with time of development, whereas that of the locule declines. The water contents of the seed and fruit tissues are similar during early development (20-30 DAP), but decline in the seed tissues between 30 and 40 DAP. The water potential and the osmotic potential of the embryo are lower than that of the locular tissue after 35 DAP also. Seeds removed from the fruit at 30, 35, and 60 DAP and placed ex situ on 35 and 60 DAP sheath and locular tissue are prevented from germinating. Development of 30 DAP seeds is maintained or promoted by the ex situ fruit tissue with which they are in contact. Their germination is inhibited until subsequent transfer to water, and germination is normal, i.e. by radicle protrusion, and viable seedlings are produced, compared with 30 DAP seeds transferred directly to water; more of these seeds germinate, but by hypocotyl extension, and seedling viability is very poor. Isolated seeds at 35 and 60 DAP re-placed in contact with fruit tissues only germinate when transferred to water after 7 d. At 30 DAP, isolated seeds are insensitive to ABA at physiological concentrations in that they germinate as if on water, albeit by hypocotyl extension. At higher concentrations germination occurs by radicle protrusion. Osmoticum prevents germination, but there is some recovery upon subsequent transfer to water. Seeds at 35 DAP are very sensitive to ABA and exhibit little or no germination, even upon transfer to water. The response of the isolated seeds to osmoticum more closely approximates that to incubation on the ex situ fruit tissues than does their response to ABA. This is also the case for isolated 60 DAP seeds, whose germination is not prevented by ABA, but only by the osmoticum; these seeds are inhibited when in contact with ex situ fruit tissues also. It is proposed that the osmotic environment within the tissues of the tomato fruit plays a greater role than endogenous ABA in preventing precocious germination of the developing seeds.     

Expression of an expansin is associated with endosperm weakening during tomato seed germination

Expansins are extracellular proteins that facilitate cell wall extension, possibly by disrupting hydrogen bonding between hemicellulosic wall components and cellulose microfibrils. In addition, some expansins are expressed in non-growing tissues such as ripening fruits, where they may contribute to cell wall disassembly associated with tissue softening. We have identified at least three expansin genes that are expressed in tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) seeds during germination. Among these, LeEXP4 mRNA is specifically localized to the micropylar endosperm cap region, suggesting that the protein might contribute to tissue weakening that is required for radicle emergence. In gibberellin (GA)-deficient (gib-1) mutant seeds, which germinate only in the presence of exogenous GA, GA induces the expression of LeEXP4 within 12 hours of imbibition. When gib-1 seeds were imbibed in GA solution combined with 100 microM abscisic acid, the expression of LeEXP4 was not reduced, although radicle emergence was inhibited. In wild-type seeds, LeEXP4 mRNA accumulation was blocked by far-red light and decreased by low water potential but was not affected by abscisic acid. The presence of LeEXP4 mRNA during seed germination parallels endosperm cap weakening determined by puncture force analysis. We hypothesize that LeEXP4 is involved in the regulation of seed germination by contributing to cell wall disassembly associated with endosperm cap weakening.     

小花草玉梅种子萌发过程中常见内源激素含量的变化及萌发机制

植物内源激素在调节种子休眠和萌发过程中具有极其重要的作用。本研究运用反式高效液相色谱(RP-HPLC)与紫外检测器联用的方法对小花草玉梅干种子、吸胀种子和露白种子中的赤霉素GAs、脱落酸ABA、玉米素ZT和生长素IAA含量进行了检测,旨在研究植物内源激素水平在种子萌发过程中的变化是否直接关系着小花草玉梅种子在光照或黑暗条件下的萌发能力。结果显示,种子吸胀过程中,光照促进了ZT同时抑制了ABA的积累,并且ZT对ABA萌发抑制作用的解除也受光的促进,露白种子中的ABA/ZT,ABA/GAs和(ABA+IAA)/(GAs+ZT)水平在黑暗条件下高于光照条件,上述均是导致光照条件下种子萌发率较高的重要原因;相对于干种子,IAA含量在种子吸胀初期急速下降,(ABA+IAA)/(GAs+ZT)在种子萌发过程中有所降低,而ABA/GAs却表现出明显的上升趋势;各激素水平所受光照的影响均在种子开始露白时显著减弱,另外,吸胀第9天是小花草玉梅种子萌发过程中激素变化的一个关键的时间节点。总之,种子萌发并非直接关系着GA含量的升高和ABA含量的降低。因光照直接促进了小花草玉梅种子的萌发,本研究认为高寒草甸充...     

Effect of Water Stress, Seed Coat Restraint, and Abscisic Acid upon Different Germination Capabilities of Two Tomato Lines at Low Temperature

Two tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) lines with greatly different capabilities to germinate at 10°C were compared with respect to sensitivity to experimental treatments which affect the water status of the embryo. Germination rates and final percentages could be drastically changed (at 25°C) by (a) removing the mechanical constraint from the radicle tip, (b) imposing water stress by an osmoticum, (c) stress hardening of the seeds through osmotic pretreatment, and (d) inhibiting embryo expansion by abscisic acid (ABA). All treatments showed a similar difference in germination vigor between the two lines indicating that cold sensitivity is in fact a matter of water relations rather than of phase transitions in membrane lipids. Inhibition of germination by ABA was completely abolished by removing the mechanical constraint from the radicle tip. Osmotic stress of −3 bar which quantitatively replaced this constraint in inhibiting germination also restored the sensitivity to ABA. It is concluded that all these treatments act on the balance between the hydraulic extension force of the embryo radicle and the opposing force of the seed layers covering the radicle tip. The difference in cold sensitivity between the two seed lines resides either in the osmotic potential or the pressure potential of the germinating embryo.     

Hormonal Regulation of Dormancy in Developing Sorghum Seeds

The role of abscisic acid (ABA) and gibberellic acid (GA) in determining the dormancy level of developing sorghum (Sorghum bicolor [L.] Moench.) seeds from varieties presenting contrasting preharvest sprouting behavior (Redland B2, susceptible; IS 9530, resistant) was investigated. Panicles from both varieties were sprayed soon after pollination with fluridone or paclobutrazol to inhibit ABA and GA synthesis, respectively. Fluridone application to the panicles increased germinability of Redland B2 immature caryopses, whereas early treatment with paclobutrazol completely inhibited germination of this variety during most of the developmental period. Incubating caryopses in the presence of 100 [mu]M GA4+7 overcame the inhibitory effect of paclobutrazol, but also stimulated germination of seeds from other treatments. IS 9530 caryopses presented germination indices close to zero until physiological maturity (44 d after pollination) in control and paclobutrazol-treated particles. However, fluridone-treated caryopses were released from dormancy earlier than control and paclobutrazol-treated caryopses. Incubation in the presence of GA4+7 stimulated germination of caryopses from all treatments. Our results support the proposition that a low dormancy level (which is related to a high preharvest sprouting susceptibility) is determined not only by a low embryonic sensitivity to ABA, but also by a high GA content or sensitivity.     

Dormancy and Germination of Abscisic Acid-Deficient Tomato Seeds : Studies with the sitiens Mutant

The role of abscisic acid (ABA) in the dormancy induction of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) seeds was studied by comparison of the germination behavior of the ABA-deficient sitiens mutant with that of the isogenic wild-type genotype. Freshly harvested mutant seeds, in contrast to wild-type seeds, always readily germinate and even exhibit viviparous germination in overripe fruits. Crosses between mutant and wild-type and self-pollination of heterozygous plants show that in particular the ABA fraction of embryo and endosperm is decisive for the induction of dormancy. After-ripened wild-type seeds fully germinate in water but are more sensitive toward osmotic inhibition than mutant seeds. Germination of both wild-type and mutant seeds is equally sensitive toward inhibition by exogenous ABA. ABA content of mature wild-type seeds is about 10-fold the level found in mutant seeds. Nevertheless, it is argued that the differences in dormancy between the seeds of both genotypes are not a result of actual ABA levels in the mature seeds or fruits but a result of differences in ABA levels during seed development. It is hypothesized that the high levels of ABA that occur during seed development in wild-type seeds induce an inhibition of cell elongation of the radicle that can still be observed after long periods of dry storage.     

Substrate water potential constraints on germination of the strangler fig Ficus aurea (Moraceae)

Palms are the most common support hosts for strangler fig (Ficus aurea) in the tropical dry forest. At Hummingbird Cay Tropical Field Station in the Bahamas, viable F. aurea seeds scattered on open soil germinate within 6 d in the laboratory at 27C in light or darkness. To test the hypothesis that water relations between seed and substrate can restrict the site of F. aurea establishment, fig seeds were imbibed in mannitol solutions with water potential (psi) from 0 MPa to -2.0 MPa. At psi > -1.0 MPa, germination ranges from 70 to 90%. Below -1.0 MPa, germination drops under 4%. Seedling growth rate slows linearly with decreasing psi, due to reduced cell enlargement in the radicle. Sensitivity of F. aurea seeds to psi stress is similar to that of mesophytic crops with "threshold' psi of -1.2 to -1.5 MPa, below which germination and/or seedling growth stops. F. aurea shows no evidence of xerophytic adaptation in germination physiology. In the field, psi of humus in palm leaf bases does not drop below -1.0 to -1.1 MPa, while humus in terrestrial sites reaches psi F. aurea germination and seedling growth is met by humus in palm leaf bases, not by terrestrial sites. In dry forests, this restricts F. aurea establishment to the crown of palm trees.     

The Use of Abscisic Acid to Synchronize Carrot Seed Germination Prior to Fluid Drilling

Abscisic acid (ABA) was used as a reversible block to the progressof carrot seed germination in a practical seed treatment. Pre-treatingseeds with 10^–4M ABA solution at 15 °C for 12 d gave93% germination of viable seeds on subsequent transfer to waterbefore radicle lengths became too long for fluid drilling. Thiscompared with only 31 % without pre-treatment ABA pretreatment significantly increased the synchrony of carrotseed germination and did not affect final percentage germinationor early seedling growth rates. Seedling emergence from ABA-treatedgerminating seeds was earlier and more uniform than from untreatedgerminating seeds and seedlings from both these treatments emergedbefore those from ungerminated seeds Daucus carota L., carrot, germination, seed treatment, fluid drilling, abscisic acid, radicle extension     

短命植物独行菜种子萌发过程对低温的耐受特性

以独行菜（Lepidium apetalum）为材料,研究了其种子在萌发过程中耐受低温的特性,并对耐受低温的机制作了初步的探讨。结果表明：1.萌发至I、II、III期的独行菜种子经过冷诱导处理后,对零下低温-5℃、-10℃胁迫具有较强的耐受性,这种耐受性随萌发发展相对有所降低。2.独行菜种子萌发过程中胚根生长速度明显受到低温抑制,但也仍然能够生长。3.适当时间的低温层积能使独行菜萌发势显著提高,对终萌发率影响不大;过长时间的低温层积会使独行菜种子萌发势和最终萌发率降低。4.独行菜种子在4℃条件下不能萌发,但4℃层积2d的种子经25℃处理6h以上后,可耐受4℃低温而萌发,且萌发率随25℃处理时间增加而升高。如果25℃处理时间少于5h则不能在4℃低温下萌发。经4℃层积10d、再经25℃萌发处理1h的独行菜种子就能在4℃低温下萌发。综合分析认为独行菜种子不能耐受4℃低温萌发,原因可能是在露白前存在一个关键的生理阶段,在4℃胁迫逆境中不能越过这个阶段,该阶段之前与之后的萌发过程都能耐受4℃低温,因此对低温胁迫有良好的耐受性。这为探索早春短命植物耐受低温萌发的机制提供了新的思路。     

外源信号物质对肉苁蓉种子萌发与吸器形成的影响

研究氟草敏（norflurazon）、氟啶酮（fluridone）、GR24、赤霉素（GA3）4种外源信号物质对肉苁蓉种子萌发的影响,以及2,6-二甲氧基-对-苯醌（2,6-DMBQ）、5,8-二羟基萘醌（5,8-DHNQ）、阿魏酸（ferulic acid）3种外源信号物质对萌发的肉苁蓉种子吸器形成的影响,结果表明：氟草敏、氟啶酮、GR24对肉苁蓉种子的萌发均具有明显的促进作用,其中氟草敏作用最为显著,处理168h后肉苁蓉种子开始萌发,萌发率最高达65%;2,6-DMBQ对肉苁蓉种子吸器形成具有显著的促进作用,处理48h后肉苁蓉种子开始形成吸器,吸器形成率最高达50%。     

Class I chitinase and beta-1,3-glucanase are differentially regulated by wounding,methyl jasmonate,ethylene, and gibberellin in tomato seeds and leaves

Class I chitinase (Chi9) and beta-1,3-glucanase (GluB) genes are expressed in the micropylar endosperm cap of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) seeds just before radicle emergence through this tissue to complete germination. In gibberellin (GA)-deficient mutant (gib-1) seeds, expression of Chi9 and GluB mRNA and protein is dependent upon GA. However, as expression occurs relatively late in the germination process, we investigated whether the genes are induced indirectly in response to tissue wounding associated with endosperm cap weakening and radicle protrusion. Wounding and methyl jasmonate (MeJA) induced Chi9 expression, whereas ethylene, abscisic acid, sodium salicylate, fusicoccin, or beta-aminobutyric acid were without effect. Chi9 expression occurred only in the micropylar tissues when seeds were exposed to MeJA or were wounded at the chalazal end of the seed. Expression of Chi9, but not GluB, mRNA was reduced in germinating seeds of the jasmonate-deficient defenseless1 tomato mutant and could be restored by MeJA treatment. Chi9 expression during germination may be associated with "wounding" from cell wall hydrolysis and weakening in the endosperm cap leading to radicle protrusion, and jasmonate is involved in the signaling pathway for this response. Among these treatments and chemicals (other than GA), only MeJA and wounding induced a low level of GluB expression in gib-1 seeds. However, MeJA, wounding, and particularly ethylene induced both genes in leaves, whereas GA induced only Chi9 in leaves. Although normally expressed simultaneously during tomato seed germination, Chi9 and GluB genes are regulated distinctly and tissue specifically by hormones and wounding.     

Mechanical Resistance of the Seed Coat and Endosperm during Germination of Capsicum annuum at Low Temperature

Decoated pepper (Capsicum annuum L. cv Early Calwonder) seeds germinated earlier at 25°C, but not at 15°C, compared to coated seeds. The seed coat did not appear to impose a mechanical restriction on pepper seed germination. Scarification of the endosperm material directly in front of the radicle reduced the time to germination at both 15°C and 25°C.

The amount of mechanical resistance imposed by the endosperm on radicle emergence before germination was measured using the Instron Universal Testing Machine. Endosperm strength decreased as imbibition time increased. The puncture force decreased faster when seeds were imbibed at 25°C than at 15°C. The reduction in puncture force corresponded with the ability of pepper seeds to germinate. Most radicle emergence occurred at 15°C and 25°C after the puncture force was reduced to between 0.3 and 0.4 newtons.

Application of gibberellic acid₄₊₇ (100 microliters per liter) resulted in earlier germination at 15°C and 25°C and decreased endosperm strength sooner than in untreated seeds. Similarly, high O₂ concentrations had similar effects on germination earliness and endosperm strength decline as did gibberellic acid₄₊₇, but only at 25°C. At 15°C, high O₂ concentrations slowed germination and endosperm strength decline.

     

生长素调控种子的休眠与萌发

植物种子的休眠与萌发,是植物生长发育过程中的关键阶段,也是生命科学领域的研究热点。种子从休眠向萌发的转换是极为复杂的生物学过程,由外界环境因子、体内激素含量及信号传导和若干关键基因协同调控。大量研究表明,植物激素脱落酸(Abscisic acid, ABA)和赤霉素(Gibberellin acid, GA)是调控种子休眠水平,决定种子从休眠转向萌发的主要内源因子。ABA与GA在含量和信号传导两个层次上的精确平衡,确保了植物种子能以休眠状态在逆境中存活,并在适宜的时间启动萌发程序。生长素(Auxin)是经典植物激素之一,其对向性生长和组织分化等生物学过程的调控已有大量研究。但最近有研究证实,生长素对种子休眠有正向调控作用,这表明生长素是继ABA之后的第二个促进种子休眠的植物激素。本文在回顾生长素的发现历程、阐释生长素体内合成途径及信号传导通路的基础上,重点综述了生长素通过与ABA的协同作用调控种子休眠的分子机制,并对未来的研究热点进行了讨论和展望。     

聚乙二醇模拟水分胁迫对沙地樟子松种子萌发影响研究

以引种区沙地樟子松种子为材料,观测了聚乙二醇(PEG)模拟水分胁迫对沙地樟子松种子萌发的影响.结果表明,不同浓度PEG处理胁迫对种子的萌发均有一定的延缓作用;种子的发芽率、发芽指数和发芽势随胁迫强度的增加呈现明显下降趋势.30%PEG处理的种子在试验结束后仍未能萌发,表明樟子松种子的萌发的临界PEG水分胁迫值小于30%,相当于-1.20MPa的水势.种子发芽后胚根和胚轴的生长亦受到PEG模拟水分胁迫,当PEG浓度为10%时(相当于-0.2MPa水势),胚根、胚轴的长度都较短,说明樟子松种子的胚根、胚轴的生长对PEG模拟干旱胁迫更敏感;但胚根/胚芽的比值随PEG模拟水分胁迫的强度增加而增加,表明樟子松种子萌发后对水分胁迫具有较强的适应性.由此可见,干旱胁迫影响引种区沙地樟子松种子的萌发可能是导致沙地樟子松人工林不能天然更新的因素之一.