The role of macrophages in the generation of T helper cells. V. Evidence for differential activation of short-lived T1 and long-lived T2 lymphocytes by the macrophage factors GRF and NMF.

The generation of T helper cells in vitro requires macrophages or macrophage-derived factors such as genetically related macrophage factor (GRF) or nonspecific macrophage factor (NMF). However, there is a basic difference of T helper cell induction when using particulate antigens. The present study demonstrates that this difference is based on the activation of two different T cell subsets. GRF activates short-lived 'T1' cells which amplify the induction of T2 cells, which are the helper cell precursors. Thus, the genetic restriction of T helper cell induction seen with soluble antigen or GRF lies on the level of macrophage or GRF interaction with T1 cells. NMF (or macrophages) and particulate antigens directly activate the helper cell precursor (T2) indicating no requirement for T1-T2 cooperation. The direct activation of the helper cell precursor with particulate antigens does not require histocompatible macrophages or NMF from histocompatible macrophages. The present results may explain some of the discrepancies reported in the literature concerning the genetic requirements and specificity of T cell activation.     

T cell induction of membrane IL 1 on macrophages

We have studied the role of T cells in the induction of a membrane-associated form of interleukin 1 (mIL 1) in murine macrophages. T helper cell clones and a T cell hybridoma induced macrophages to express mIL 1 after an antigen-specific, Ia-restricted interaction. Induction of mIL 1 was proportional to antigen concentration and was increased in the early course of the response in macrophages pretreated in culture with interferon-gamma. mIL 1 activity was detectable 4 hr after interaction with T cells. mIL 1 induction was inhibited by antibodies to either class II molecules or the T cell receptor. Two pathways of T cell-mediated mIL 1 induction could be defined. In the first, T cells, whose protein synthesizing capacity was completely eliminated by pretreatment with the irreversible protein synthesis inhibitor emetine, induced levels of mIL 1 expression indistinguishable from controls. In the second, T cells stimulated by paraformaldehyde-fixed macrophages in the presence of concanavalin A or antigen secreted a soluble factor that induced macrophage mIL 1 expression. Thus, it appears that T cells may induce macrophages to express mIL 1 both by direct cell-cell contact mediated through binding of T cell receptor to the Ia/antigen complex, and through the release of a lymphokine after activation. This lymphokine does not appear to be IL 2, IFN-gamma, BSF-1, or CSF-1.     

The induction in vitro of immunological tolerance in T lymphocytes: an inhibitory role of macrophages.

Hapten-reactive helper T cells were generated in the spleen of C57BL/6 mice primed with sulfanilated syngeneic IgG (S-MGG). Specific immunological tolerance was induced in vitro in these helper T cells, when spleen cell suspension was passed through Sephadex G-10 column to remove adherent cells and cultured in the presence of soluble S-MGG for 21 to 24 hours. On the other hand, tolerance was not inducible in unfractionated, primed spleen cells. When G-10-passed spleen cells were added to the culture dishes containing phagocytic, adherent cells of the spleen, tolerance was no more inducible in these reconstituted cell population. From these experimental results, it was concluded that macrophages played an interfering role in tolerance induction. The experimental data were also discussed in terms of macrophage function in the recognition of antigen by T lymphocytes.     

Generation of T helper cells in vitro. IV. F1 T helper cells primed with antigen-pulsed parental macrophages are genetically restricted in their antigen-specific helper activity.

A sequential culture technique for the in vitro induction and subsequent assay of T helper cells is employed to examine the histocompatibility requirements for antigen recognition by murine T helper cells. F1 T cells are primed in vitro with antigen-pulsed parental strain macrophages and tested for antigen-specific helper activity in cultures containing anti-Thy 1.2 serum and C treated spleen cells from hapten-primed parental or F1 mice. A semiallogenieic system is used and appropriate controls are included to avoid possible complicating effects of allogeneic interactions. The results indicate that F1 T helper cells preferentially stimulate carrier-specific anti-hapten plaque-forming cell responses in spleen cells which are H-2 identical with the macrophage used initially to prime the T cells. Parental spleen cell cultures do not respond to F1 T helper cells which were primed with the other parental strain macrophage. Supplementing this culture with macrophages which are histocompatible with those used to prime the F1T cells is sufficient to restore T helper cell activity. Thus, the genetic restriction described here is between the primed T cell and the macrophage used to elicit secondary responses and not between the T cell and B cell. The results in this semiallogeneic system, however, do not rule out the possibility of additional allogeneic genetic restrictions in the subsequent interaction of T cells with B cells.     

Is genetically related macrophage factor (GRF) a soluble immune response (Ir) gene product?

The possibility that the antigen-presenting "macrophages" interacting with helper cells either directly or via the intermediary action of a soluble factor consisting of Ia antigen and a fragment of immunogen, termed GRG (genetically related factor), are a site of Ir gene action was investigated by using the synthetic polypeptide antigen (T,G)-A--L. It was found that T cells from (responder x nonresponder) F1 mice were stimulated by responder "macrophages" or GRF derived from these cells but not by the nonresponder macrophages of GRF from these cells. This suggests that the defect in helper cell induction in nonresponders is at the level of the presenting cell and that the macrophage factor GRF is a soluble Ir gene product. This conclusion was supported by the observation that there was normal presenting cell and GRF function in nonresponders, mouse strains such as CBA that yield helper cells and helper factor with (T,G)-A--L and have defects elsehwere.     

Antigen processing and presentation by macrophages

The classical macrophage is one of the most important cells involved in presenting antigen to helper T cells, because of its ability to regulate its expression of Ia molecules and to encounter and process particulate and soluble antigens. We have summarized in this report studies examining the handling by macrophages of two different antigens, the bacteria Listeria monocytogenes and the protein hen egg white lysozyme (HEL). The purpose was to identify potential sources of immunogenic peptides. Presentation of Listeria required an intracellular processing stage sensitive to lysosomotropic drugs. The Listeria required internalization and processing, after which immunogenic molecules were recognized by T cells on the macrophage surface. Metabolic studies showed that Listeria-derived peptides were released by macrophages that had phagocytosized the bacteria. The release of these peptides was a temperature-dependent process, unaffected by inhibiting lysosomal catabolism by treatment with chloroquine. Listeria-derived peptides were also detected on the surface of the macrophage. These peptides behaved like integral membrane proteins, some of which persisted for at least 24 hr at the macrophage surface. When tested for immunogenicity, the released peptides were very weakly immunogenic. The membrane-associated peptides alone could not stimulate Listeria-specific T cells, but could be reprocessed by additional macrophages and subsequently stimulate the T cells. A defined antigen system using HEL-specific T-cell hybridomas was used to examine the processing of HEL. Presentation of HEL required a chloroquine-sensitive intracellular processing stage. In examining two T-cell hybridomas, a differential requirement for antigen processing was determined.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Antigen presentation to human T lymphocytes. II. Requirements for Mac-120+ macrophages and responsiveness to interleukin 2

To investigate mechanisms by which antigen, macrophages, and interleukin 2 (IL2) participate in the induction of secondary T-cell proliferative responses, trinitrophenyl (TNP) was presented in three distinct modes: (i) TNP-modified peripheral blood mononuclear cells (TNP-PBMC), (ii) TNP-PBMC cell sonicates, and (iii) TNP-ovalbumin (TNP-OVA). Stimulators were depleted of Mac-120+ macrophages using Mac-120 monoclonal antibody plus complement. TNP-Mac-120 macrophages stimulated primed T cells nearly as well as TNP-unfractionated macrophages (which were about 40% Mac-120+). In contrast, although greater than 70% DR+, Mac-120- macrophages plus either TNP-OVA or TNP-PBMC sonicate elicited minimal responses compared to unfractionated macrophages plus antigen. After 21-28 days of in vitro priming, macrophage-depleted T cells were not stimulated to proliferate by either IL2 alone or sonicates alone. IL2 plus TNP-PBMC sonicates, however, stimulated significant proliferation. Furthermore, this response was considerably greater than that to IL2 plus either TNP-T cell sonicates or TNP-mouse spleen sonicates. Thus, the Mac-120+ macrophage population may have an important antigen-presenting and/or accessory function in the stimulation of primed T cells by soluble or particulate antigen, although it is unnecessary for responses to intact TNP-Ia+ PBMC. In addition, the data suggest that Ia+ sonicates alone may suffice for induction of IL2 responsiveness, but not for endogenous IL2 production and subsequent proliferation by primed T cells.     

Gallium arsenide exposure impairs processing of particulate antigen by macrophages: modification of the antigen reverses the functional defect

Gallium arsenide (GaAs), a semiconductor used in the electronics industry, causes systemic immunosuppression in animals. The chemical's impact on macrophages to process the particulate antigen, sheep red blood cells (SRBC), for a T cell response in culture was examined after in vivo exposure of mice. GaAs-exposed splenic macrophages were defective in activating SRBC-primed lymph node T cells that could not be attributed to impaired phagocytosis. Modified forms of SRBC were generated to examine the compromised function of GaAs-exposed macrophages. SRBC were fixed to maintain their particulate nature and subsequently delipidated with detergent. Delipidation of intact SRBC was insufficient to restore normal antigen processing in GaAs-exposed macrophages. However, chemically exposed cells efficiently processed soluble sheep proteins. These findings suggest that the problem may lie in the release of sequestered sheep protein antigens, which then could be effectively cleaved to peptides. Furthermore, opsonization of SRBC with IgG compensated for the macrophage processing defect. The influence of signal transduction and phagocytosis via Fcgamma receptors on improved antigen processing could be dissociated. Immobilized anti-Fcgamma receptor antibody activated macrophages to secrete a chemokine, but did not enhance processing of unmodified SRBC by GaAs-exposed macrophages. Restoration of normal processing of particulate SRBC by chemically exposed macrophages involved phagocytosis through Fcgamma receptors. Hence, initial immune responses may be very sensitive to GaAs exposure, and the chemical's immunosuppression may be averted by opsonized particulate antigens.     

Generation of thymus-derived helper cells by macrophage-associated antigen

A double cell transfer system was used to investigate the efficacy of macrophage bound antigen in generating carrier-reactive helper T cells. Macrophage bound antigen was found to be three orders of magnitude more potent than soluble antigen in T cell priming. The results are discussed with reference to the involvement of macrophages or related cells in the normal processes of immune induction.     

Specific binding of T lymphocytes to macrophages. II. Role of macrophage-associated antigen.

Peritoneal exudate lymphocytes from immune guinea pigs that bind in vitro to autologous antigen-pulsed macrophages were allowed to proliferate for 1 week to give a population markedly enriched in antigen-specific T cells. This enriched population was then studied with regard to its binding to fresh autologous antigen-pulsed macrophages. Specific binding was not inhibited by a large excess of antigen in the media (5000-fold greater than the amount of antigen associated with the macrophages) either soluble or bound to Sepharose beads, or by coating the antigen-pulsed macrophags with antibody to the exogenous antigen, by reacting a second layer of antibody to the heterologous antibody, or by haptenating the antigen and treating the hapten-antigen macrophage complex with excess anti-hapten antibody. Results of treating antigen-pulsed macrophages with the proteolytic enzymes trypsin and pronase indicate that exogenous antigen is on the macrophage surface, but the experiments failed to prove that the removable antigen is essential for binding. The simplest interpretation of these results is that the T cell receptor is not specific for native exogenous antigen.     

Nonphagocytic dendritic cells are effective accessory cells for anti-mycobacterial responses in vitro

The accessory cell requirements for a given T cell response may be examined in vitro by using highly purified lymph node T cells. We have examined the capacity of different antigen-presenting cells to stimulate proliferation of Mycobacterium tuberculosis-primed T cells when the antigenic challenge is either soluble or particulate in nature. By titrations of cell number and antigen concentration, it was shown that dendritic cells are not only extremely efficient at presenting soluble mycobacterial antigen compared with various macrophage populations, but also that they are capable of presenting whole mycobacteria. Because phagocytosis of mycobacteria does not occur with these cells, we suggest that processing of antigen by dendritic cells may be initiated at the plasma membrane. Because macrophages are not essential for this in vitro response, a role for dendritic cells in antibacterial immunity in vivo is implicated.     

Antigen presentation to Th1 but not Th2 cells by macrophages results in nitric oxide production and inhibition of T cell proliferation: interferon-gamma is essential but insufficient

The induction and role of nitric oxide (NO) during antigen presentation by macrophages to T helper (Th) cell subsets was examined. When cultured with Th1 clones, macrophage APC produced NO only in the presence of cognate Ag, which in turn suppressed T cell proliferation. IFN-gamma production by the activated Th1 cells was essential for the induction of NO. Th2 cells presented with the same cognate Ag did not induce NO production and proliferated uninhibited. Coactivation of Th1 and Th2 cells specific for the same Ag indicated that Th2 cells did not inhibit NO production, but were sensitive to NO induced by stimulated Th1 cells. Antigenic activation of Th2 cells in the presence of rIFN-gamma resulted in NO-mediated inhibition of proliferation. Th2 cells provided only a cell-associated cofactor, whereas Th1 cells secreted a soluble cofactor for IFN-gamma as well, i.e., TNF-alpha. Finally, a role for IFN-gamma and NO during immune responses was studied in spleen cells obtained from immunized IFN-gamma(-/-) mice. NO production and subsequent inhibition of Ag-specific proliferation ex vivo was observed only after the addition of rIFN-gamma. These studies suggest an IFN-gamma-dependent regulatory role for NO during Ag-specific Th cell activation involving macrophages, with obvious implications for Th subset-dependent immune responses in general.     

Helper cell factors restore antibody responses of allogeneic bone marrow chimeras: evidence for ineffective cellular interactions

We investigated the nature of deficient antibody responses to SRBC in stable, fully allogeneic bone marrow chimeras. No evidence for a suppressor cell-mediated mechanism was found. Chimera spleens possessed adequate numbers of antigen-reactive B cells to produce a normal antibody response. Using separated chimera cell populations and soluble helper factors, we assessed the functional capabilities of chimera B cells, T cells, and macrophages. Our data suggest that the failure of allogeneic chimeras to produce antibody is not the result of impaired B cell, T cell, or macrophage function, but rather that it is due in ineffective cellular interactions that normally result in the generation of helper factors. In vitro stimulation of chimera macrophages with LPS, and of chimera spleen cells with Con A, resulted in the release of soluble helper factors that were capable of fully restoring chimera B cell responses.     

MHC control of T lymphocyte-macrophage interactions

Identity at the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) of primed T cells and macrophages was essential for the development of a T cell proliferative response to Purified Protein Derivative of tuberculin (PPD) in the presence of macrophage-associated antigen and potential allogeneic effects were eliminated by the use of one-way fetal liver chimeras as a T cell source. By contrast, such MHC restriction could not be shown for the T cell—macrophage interaction when antigen was present in soluble form.It was found that the proliferative response of primed (responder × nonresponder) F₁ T cells to the Ir-gene controlled antigen, TNP-18 [Glu-Tyr-Lys (TNP) (Glu-Tyr-Ala)₅], could only be restored by responder macrophages with bound antigen, while both responder and nonresponder macrophages reconstituted the response to soluble TNP-18. Supernatants from cultured responder or nonresponder macrophages could at least partially replace viable macrophages in the latter case.These results argue for two distinct antigen presentation mechanisms, depending on the physical state of the antigen rather than its chemical nature: one involves recognition of antigen in association with MHC-coded determinants and shows H-2 restriction, while the other, mediated by soluble factors and antigen, does not.     

Selective protection of murine thymic helper T cells from glucocorticosteroid inhibition by macrophage-derived mediators

We investigated the in vitro effects of dexamethasone (DEX) on the functional capacities of virgin murine T cells cultured in the absence and presence of adjuvant-stimulated macrophages or factors derived from them. Immunologically mature thymocytes, isolated on the basis of their inability to bind peanut agglutinin (PNA^? thymocytes), were used as virgin T cells. Treatment of PNA^? thymocytes with DEX for 24 hr in vitro eliminated their subsequent capacity to function as helper cells for primary humoral responses, to proliferate when stimulated by plant mitogens or allogeneic cells, or to generate T-cell-mediated cytotoxic responses. However, when PNA^? thymocytes were pretreated with DEX in combination with either adjuvant-activated macrophages or their culture supernatants, which contained Interleukin 1, the capacity of the T cells to subsequently express helper activity was preserved. The macrophage products, however, did not prevent DEX from inhibiting the capacities of PNA^? thymocytes to proliferate in response to plant mitogens or alloantigens or to generate cytotoxic effector cells; thus, protection was selective. The data indicate that, prior to activation, helper T cells are distinguished by their capacity to become steroid resistant in response to macrophage products. Although T-cell proliferative and cytotoxic responses have been reported to be protected from DEX inhibition by Interleukin 2, our results suggest that macrophages prevent steroid effects on virgin helper T cells by Interleukin-1-dependent mechanisms that do not involve Interleukin 2. While we have not delineated the biochemical pathways of protection, we show that the acquisition of DEX resistance by helper T cells cannot be attributed to the polyclonal induction of helper activity by macrophage factors.     

Haplotype preference in lymphocyte differentiation. II. F1 hybrid helper T cells generated with antigen-bearing parental macrophages can cooperate with B lymphocytes of either parent.

Carrier-specific helper T cells were generated in F₁ hybrid mice by either conventional immunization procedures or by repeated immunizations with antigen-bearing macrophages derived from either F₁ or parental donors. The F₁ helper T cells generated in these various ways were then analyzed for their capacities to help hapten-primed B lymphocytes derived from each of the two parental strains as well as from F₁ donors in the development of secondary anti-hapten antibody responses. These analyses were conducted using two different types of in vivo assay systems as well as a totally in vitro system. Under all circumstances, helper T cells from F₁ mice, primed either in conventional fashion or with antigen bearing parental or F₁ macrophages, were capable of interacting effectively with B lymphocytes of each parent and of F₁ origin. Moreover, in the case of F₁ helper cells primed with antigen-bearing parental macrophages, there was no evidence of preferential helper activity for parental B lymphocytes corresponding to the type of macrophage used for sensitization; this was true irrespective of whether in vivo or in vitro assay systems were employed. The relevance of these findings and others which are either similar to, or discordant with, them to the general question of genetic restrictions in macrophage-T lymphocyte interactions is discussed.     

Antigen-specific B cells efficiently present low doses of antigen for induction of T cell proliferation

Previous experiments suggested a role for specific B cells in the induction of antigen (SRBC)-specific T cell proliferation. Two models were proposed: in the first, B cells directly presented antigen to T cells; alternatively, B cells secreted antibody, which opsonized antigen for presentation by macrophages. Experiments to distinguish between these possibilities are presented here. Three lines of evidence support the conclusion that antigen is presented directly by specific B cells. First, nonimmune splenic adherent cells (SAC), which efficiently induced proliferation of appropriately primed T cells to antigens such as OVA and GAT, were unable to induce SRBC-specific proliferation. Secondly, a slope analysis of the logarithmic plot of T cell proliferation vs the number of irradiated B cells suggested that two cells were limiting within the presenting population. The addition of IL 1 or SAC reduced the slope to 1 (although in serum-free conditions, the addition of IL 1, but not SAC, reduced the slope of the line). Specificity of the B cells for the antigen continued to be required in the presence of exogenous IL 1 or SAC. These results suggested that presentation by specific B cells and the amount of IL 1 were the limiting requirements for the induction of SRBC-specific T cell proliferation. The third line of evidence was the demonstration of a restricted interaction between T cells and B cells. The addition of irradiated, allogeneic SRBC-specific B cells to T cell lines and syngeneic SAC failed to support proliferative responses. We further show that a GAT-specific T cell clone was triggered to proliferate by either SAC or B cells, but that antigen-specific B cells were necessary at low doses of antigen. This finding is important in two respects. First, the T cell clone previously has been shown to act as a helper; secondly, when low doses of antigen are used, the requirement for priming of the B cells to the specific antigen is true for a soluble, as well as a particulate, antigen. We propose that at low (physiologic) doses of antigen, presentation to secondary T cells takes place mainly at the surface of antigen-specific B cells. At high doses of antigen,h presentation can also be accomplished by nonspecific cells such as other B cells, macrophages, or dendritic cells.     

Evaluation of Ia+ tumor cell lines and peritoneal exudate macrophages as accessory cells: differential requirements for the activation of certain T cell functions

Several Ia+ (BC3A, TA3, D1B) or Ia-inducible (WEHI-3, P388D1) tumor lines were tested for accessory cell function for the activation of antigen-specific T cell proliferation and for the induction of T helper cells that help B cells in antibody production. All lines were able to induce antigen-specific T cell proliferation in an MHC-restricted way, but none activated T helper cells to soluble antigens under all conditions tested. In comparison, starch-induced peritoneal exudate macrophages induced T cell proliferation as well as T cell help. Some of the lines tested induced nonspecific suppressor cells that were Ly-2-positive and partially or completely inhibited antibody responses. The induction of suppressor cells, however, is not the reason for the failure of the tumor lines to activate T helper cells. These data indicate that antigen-specific T cell proliferation and helper activity do not necessarily correlate.     

In vitro induction of polyclonal killer T cells with 2-mercaptoethanol and the essential role of macrophages in this process.

Killer T cells against allogeneic and syngeneic tumor cells were generated in vitro by the addition of 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) to the murine spleen cell culture in the absence of any antigenic stimulation. The maximum activity of T cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) induced with 2-ME was observed on day 4 of culture and the induction of CMC was completely inhibited by the addition of inhibitor of DNA synthesis, hydroxyurea, or cytosin arabinoside. CMC induced with 2-ME was specifically inhibited by the addition of unlabeled target cells to the 51Cr-release assay system. These results indicated that killer T cells were generated in the presence of 2-ME as a result of nonspecific polyclonal activation of precursors into cytotoxic effector cells and that they recognized target cells with antigen-specific recognition receptors. Spleen cells deprived of adherent cells showed impaired induction of CMC with 2-ME. The addition of peritoneal exudate macrophages to splenic T cells restored this response. The result indicated that macrophages were essential for the induction of CMC with 2-ME. The possibility that the function of macrophages was mediated by soluble factor(s) released from macrophages was demonstrated by the separate culture of splenic T cells and macrophages in double-chambered, Marbrook-type vessels and by the addition of supernatants from macrophage cultures to splenic T cells. 2-ME and soluble factor(s) released from macrophages seemed to be required for the activation of precursors into killer cells.     

The role of macrophages in thymocyte mitogenesis.

The thymic lymphocytes of CBA/J mice respond to the mitogen Concanavalin A (Con A) only in the presence of adherent cells of the monocyte-macrophage series. Depletion of adherent cells abrogates the response, and macrophage-rich population of cells restore it. The need for macrophages and mitogen is completely provided by irradiated splenic macrophages which have been exposed to Con A and washed free of the soluble mitogen. The mitogenmacrophage effect in this case is apparently not due to soluble factors. Even more striking than the effect of macrophages on fresh cultures of thymic lymphocytes is their ability to restimulate quiescent cells 72 hr after their first stimulation with Con A. The quiescent cells respond immediately and quantitatively to Con A in the presence of fresh macrophages. This stimulation, like that of fresh thymocytes, is also controlled by a lymphokine ("costimulator") produced by mixing macrophages, mitogen, ant T lymphocytes. Our data suggest a model in which two signals are required for mitogenesis. First, the interaction of macrophage, T cell, and mitogen elicits a soluble costimulator, which is itself not mitogenic. Secondly, in the presence of costimulator, the mitogen (either soluble, or, more efficiently, bound to macrophages) induces a proliferative response in the T cell.