Improved secretory production of recombinant proteins by random mutagenesis of hlyB, an alpha-hemolysin transporter from Escherichia coli

Fusion proteins with an alpha-hemolysin (HlyA) C-terminal signal sequence are known to be secreted by the HlyB-HlyD-TolC translocator in Escherichia coli. We aimed to establish an efficient Hly secretory expression system by random mutagenesis of hlyB and hlyD. The fusion protein of subtilisin E and the HlyA signal sequence (HlyA(218)) was used as a marker protein for evaluating secretion efficiency. Through screening of more than 1.5 x 10(4) E. coli JM109 transformants, whose hlyB and hlyD genes had been mutagenized by error-prone PCR, we succeeded in isolating two mutants that had 27- and 15-fold-higher levels of subtilisin E secretion activity than the wild type did at 23 degrees C. These mutants also exhibited increased activity levels for secretion of a single-chain antibody-HlyA(218) fusion protein at 23 and 30 degrees C but unexpectedly not at 37 degrees C, suggesting that this improvement seems to be dependent on low temperature. One mutant (AE104) was found to have seven point mutations in both HlyB and HlyD, and an L448F substitution in HlyB was responsible for the improved secretion activity. Another mutant (AE129) underwent a single amino acid substitution (G654S) in HlyB. Secretion of c-Myc-HlyA(218) was detected only in the L448F mutant (AE104F) at 23 degrees C, whereas no secretion was observed in the wild type at any temperature. Furthermore, for the PTEN-HlyA(218) fusion protein, AE104F showed a 10-fold-higher level of secretion activity than the wild type did at 37 degrees C. This result indicates that the improved secretion activity of AE104F is not always dependent on low temperature.     

Analysis of the membrane organization of an Escherichia coli protein translocator, HlyB, a member of a large family of prokaryote and eukaryote surface transport proteins

Haemolysin B (HlyB) is essential for secretion of the 107 x 10(3) Mr haemolysin A protein from Escherichia coli and is a member of a family of highly conserved, apparently ATP-dependent surface proteins in many organisms. We have shown in this study that both HlyB and HlyD fractionate primarily with the cytoplasmic membrane of E. coli and are accessible to proteases after removal of the outer membrane. We have measured experimentally the topological organization of HlyB within the membrane by construction of fusions to beta-lactamase as a reporter. The predicted folding of HlyB, with a minimum of six transmembrane segments, does not always coincide with regions of highest average hydrophobicity. This suggests that HlyB may have a novel organization within the bilayer. From our data and comparative sequence analysis, we have been able to predict very similar topological models for the other members of the HlyB family.     

信号肽及化学通透剂对环糊精葡萄糖基转移酶胞外分泌的影响

【目的】研究不同的信号肽和化学通透剂对重组环糊精葡萄糖基转移酶(CGTase)胞外分泌的影响,提高CGTase的胞外分泌量。【方法】扩增地芽孢杆菌CHB1(Geobacillus sp.CHB1)的CGTase基因,构建带有地芽孢杆菌CHB1自身信号肽、Omp A、Pel B信号肽和不带信号肽的4种重组质粒;比较4种重组质粒对重组CGTase胞外分泌的影响,筛选最优的信号肽;考察甘氨酸、Triton X-100、SDS和Tween 80四种化学通透剂对重组CGTase胞外分泌的影响,确定最佳的化学通透剂及其浓度。【结果】Omp A信号肽介导的分泌效果最好,胞外酶活达到7.44 U/m L,分别是Pel B、CHB1信号肽的2.04倍和11.27倍,不带信号肽的重组质粒菌胞外检测不到酶活;携带Omp A信号肽的重组质粒菌发酵48 h,同时添加浓度为0.6%的甘氨酸和0.3%的Triton X-100,胞外酶活达最大到14.27 U/m L;SDS和Tween 80对该酶的胞外分泌具有明显的抑制作用。【结论】Omp A信号肽的介导效果最佳,同时添加浓度为0.6%和0.3%的甘氨酸和Triton X-100可以有效促进胞外分泌,为该重组酶的高效胞外分泌提供了一种有效的方法。     

Membrane fusion proteins of type I secretion system and tripartite efflux pumps share a binding motif for TolC in gram-negative bacteria

The Hly translocator complex of Escherichia coli catalyzes type I secretion of the toxin hemolysin A (HlyA). In this complex, HlyB is an inner membrane ABC (ATP Binding Cassette)-type transporter, TolC is an outer membrane channel protein, and HlyD is a periplasmic adaptor anchored in the inner membrane that bridges HlyB to TolC. This tripartite organization is reminiscent of that of drug efflux systems such as AcrA-AcrB-TolC and MacA-MacB-TolC of E. coli. We have previously shown the crucial role of conserved residues located at the hairpin tip region of AcrA and MacA adaptors during assembly of their cognate systems. In this study, we investigated the role of the putative tip region of HlyD using HlyD mutants with single amino acid substitutions at the conserved positions. In vivo and in vitro data show that all mutations abolished HlyD binding to TolC and resulted in the absence of HlyA secretion. Together, our results suggest that, similarly to AcrA and MacA, HlyD interacts with TolC in a tip-to-tip manner. A general model in which these conserved interactions induce opening of TolC during drug efflux and type I secretion is discussed.     

Identification and preliminary characterization of temperature-sensitive mutations affecting HlyB, the translocator required for the secretion of haemolysin (HlyA) from Escherichia coli

We have carried out a genetic analysis of Escherichia coli HlyB using in vitro(hydroxylamine) mutagenesis and regionally directed mutagenesis. From random mutagenesis, three mutants, temperature sensitive (Ts) for secretion, were isolated and the DNA sequenced: Glyl0Arg close to the N-terminus, Gly408Asp in a highly conserved small periplasmic loop region PIV, and Pro624Leu in another highly conserved region, within the ATP-binding region. Despite the Ts character of the Gly10 substitution, a derivative of HlyB, in which the first 25 amino acids were replaced by 21 amino acids of the Cro protein, was still active in secretion of HlyA. This indicates that this region of HlyB is dispensable for function. Interestingly, the Gly408Asp substitution was toxic at high temperature and this is the first reported example of a conditional lethal mutation in HlyB. We have isolated 4 additional mutations in PIV by directed mutagenesis, giving a total of 5 out of 12 residues substituted in this region, with 4 mutations rendering HlyB defective in secretion. The Pro624 mutation, close to the Walker B-site for ATP binding in the cytoplasmic domain is identical to a mutation in HisP that leads to uncoupling of ATP hydrolysis from the transport of histidine. The expression of a fully functional haemolysin translocation system comprising HlyC,A,B and D increases the sensitivity of E. coli to vancomycin 2.5-fold, compared with cells expressing HlyB and HlyD alone. Thus, active translocation of HlyA renders the cells hyperpermeable to the drug. Mutations in hlyB affecting secretion could be assigned to two classes: those that restore the level of vancomycin resistance to that of E. coli not secreting HlyA and those that still confer hypersensitivity to the drug in the presence of HlyA. We propose that mutations that promote vancomycin resistance will include mutations affecting initial recognition of the secretion signal and therefore activation of a functional transport channel. Mutations that do not alter HlyA-dependent vancomycin sensitivity may, in contrast, affect later steps in the transport process.     

A specific interaction between the NBD of the ABC-transporter HlyB and a C-terminal fragment of its transport substrate haemolysin A

A member of the family of RTX toxins, Escherichia coli haemolysin A, is secreted from Gram-negative bacteria. It carries a C-terminal secretion signal of approximately 50 residues, targeting the protein to the secretion or translocation complex, in which the ABC-transporter HlyB is a central element. We have purified the nucleotide-binding domain of HlyB (HlyB-NBD) and a C-terminal 23kDa fragment of HlyA plus the His-tag (HlyA1), which contains the secretion sequence. Employing surface plasmon resonance, we were able to demonstrate that the HlyB-NBD and HlyA1 interact with a K(D) of approximately 4 microM. No interaction was detected between the HlyA fragment and unrelated NBDs, OpuAA, involved in import of osmoprotectants, and human TAP1-NBD, involved in the export of antigenic peptides. Moreover, a truncated version of HlyA1, lacking the secretion signal, failed to interact with the HlyB-NBD. In addition, we showed that ATP accelerated the dissociation of the HlyB-NBD/HlyA1 complex. Taking these results together, we propose a model for an early stage of initiation of secretion in vivo, in which the NBD of HlyB, specifically recognizes the C terminus of the transport substrate, HlyA, and where secretion is initiated by subsequent displacement of HlyA from HlyB by ATP.     

A heterologous membrane protein domain fused to the C-terminal ATP-binding domain of HlyB can export Escherichia coli hemolysin.

The hydrophobic-rich NH2-terminal 34 amino acids of a tetracycline resistance determinant (TetC) were fused to the COOH-terminal 240 amino acids of the hemolysin transporter, HlyB, which contains a putative ATP-binding domain. This hybrid protein replaced the NH2-terminal 467-amino-acid portion of HlyB and could still export the Escherichia coli hemolysin (HlyA). Export by the hybrid protein was approximately 10% as efficient as transport by HlyB. Extracellular secretion of HlyA by the TetC-HlyB hybrid required HlyD and TolC. The extracellular and periplasmic levels of beta-galactosidase and beta-lactamase in strains that produced the hybrid were similar to the levels in controls. Thus, HlyA transport was specific and did not appear to be due to leakage of cytoplasmic contents alone. Antibodies raised against the COOH terminus of HlyB reacted with the hybrid protein, as well as HlyB. HlyB was associated with membrane fractions, while the hybrid protein was found mainly in soluble extracts. Cellular fractionation studies were performed to determine whether transport by the hybrid occurred simultaneously across both membranes like wild-type HlyA secretion. However, we found that HlyA was present in the periplasm of strains that expressed the TetC-HlyB hybrid. HlyA remained in the periplasm unless the hlyD and tolC gene products were present in addition to the hybrid.     

Energetically distinct early and late stages of HlyB/HlyD-dependent secretion across both Escherichia coli membranes.

The alternative secretion pathway which exports hemolysin across both Escherichia coli membranes into the surrounding medium is directed by an uncleaved C-terminal targeting signal and the membrane translocator proteins HlyD and HlyB. In order to identify stages and intermediates in this unconventional secretion process we have examined the effect of inhibition of the total proton motive force (delta P) and its components during the in vivo HlyB/HlyD-dependent export of a 22.4 kDa secretion competent HlyA C-terminal peptide (Actp). Secretion of Actp was severely inhibited by the proton ionophore carbonylcyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP), which collapses simultaneously membrane potential delta psi and the proton gradient delta pH, and also by valinomycin/K+, a potassium ionophore which disrupts delta psi. The inhibition of secretion by valinomycin/K+ was ameliorated by imposition of a pH gradient, the second component of the delta P, and selective depletion of delta pH by nigericin also blocked secretion. This indicates that, as in the secretion of beta-lactamase to the periplasm, HlyB/D-directed secretion requires delta P itself and not specifically one of its components. However, inhibition of HlyB/D-dependent secretion was only marked when CCCP, valinomycin/K+ or nigericin were present during the early stage of Actp secretion; at a later stage the secretion was not significantly inhibited. HlyB/D-dependent secretion appears therefore to share with conventional secretion across the cytoplasmic membrane an early requirement for delta P, but comprises in addition a late stage which does not require delta P, delta psi or delta pH. The translocation intermediate identified in the delta P-independent late stage of secretion was associated with the membrane fraction. Analysis of the protease accessibility of this intermediate in whole cells and spheroplasts showed that it was not in the periplasm, nor was it exposed on the cell surface or on the periplasmic faces of either the inner or outer membranes. This may reflect its close association with the inner membrane or a membrane translocation complex.     

Construction of a chimeric series of Bacillus cyclomaltodextrin glucanotransferases and analysis of the thermal stabilities and pH optima of the enzymes

The cyclomaltodextrin glucanotransferase (CGTase, EC 2.4.1.19) gene from the alkalophilic Bacillus sp. strain no. 17-1 was cloned in Escherichia coli. The cloned CGTase gene consisted of a single open reading frame which would encode a polypeptide of 713 amino acids, and the first 27 amino acid residues comprised a signal peptide. The nucleotide sequence and the amino acid sequence of this CGTase (CGTase 17-1) gene had strong homology with those of the CGTase (CGTase 38-2) gene previously cloned in our laboratory from the alkalophilic Bacillus sp. strain no. 38-2, although the enzymic properties of the CGTase 17-1 were distinct from those of the CGTase 38-2. To analyse those enzymic properties further, we constructed 12 chimeric CGTases using three restriction nuclease sites and compared the enzymic properties of the chimeric CGTases. The N-terminal part of the enzyme was important for heat stability, and the pH-activity profile was influenced by both the N- and the C-terminal parts. A third segment was less important for enzymic properties.     

Mutations at subsite −3 in cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Paenibacillus macerans</Emphasis> enhancing α-cyclodextrin specificity

A major disadvantage of cyclodextrin production is the limited cyclodextrin product specificity of cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase (CGTase). Here, we described mutations of Asp372 and Tyr89 at subsite −3 in the CGTase from Paenibacillus macerans strain JFB05-01. The results showed that Asp372 and Tyr89 played important roles in cyclodextrin product specificity of CGTase. The replacement of Asp372 by lysine and Tyr89 by aspartic acid, asparagine, lysine, and arginine resulted in a shift in specificity towards the production of α-cyclodextrin, which was most apparent for the mutants D372K and Y89R. Furthermore, the changes in cyclodextrin product specificity for the single mutants D372K and Y89R could be combined in the double mutant D372K/Y89R, which displayed a 1.5-fold increase in the production of α-cyclodextrin, with a concomitant 43% decrease in the production of β-cyclodextrin when compared to the wild-type CGTase. Thus, the D372K and Y89R single and double mutants were much more suitable for the industrial production of α-cyclodextrin than the wild-type enzyme. The enhanced α-cyclodextrin specificity of these mutants might be a result of stabilizing the bent conformation of the intermediate in the cyclization reaction.     

Coexpression of folding accessory proteins for production of active cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase of Bacillus macerans in recombinant Escherichia coli

Coexpression of folding accessory proteins, molecular chaperones, and human peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase (PPIase) increased production of active cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase (CGTase) of Bacillus macerans, which is otherwise mainly expressed as inclusion body in recombinant Escherichia coli. The best partner for soluble expression of CGTase was found to be human PPIase followed by coexpression of DnaK-DnaJ-GrpE together with GroEL-GroES. Such a significant enhancement by human PPIase coexpression seemed to be due to dual functions of chaperone and peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerization. Coexpression of GroEL-GroES or minichaperone alone did not influence the specific CGTase activity. For production of active CGTase in large amounts, a high cell density culture was achieved using a pH-stat fed-batch strategy. The optimized fed-batch fermentation resulted in dry cell weight of 103.4 g/L and CGTase activity of 1200 U/mL. Combination of human PPIase expression at a gene level and cell culture optimization at a process scale exerted a synergistic effect on the product yield of soluble CGTase expression in recombinant E. coli.     

The ndvA gene product of Rhizobium meliloti is required for beta-(1----2)glucan production and has homology to the ATP-binding export protein HlyB.

The ndvA locus of Rhizobium meliloti is homologous to and can substitute for the chvA locus of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. We have previously shown that an ndvA mutant exhibited reduced motility and formed small, white, empty nodules on alfalfa roots. Here we show that this ndvA mutant is defective in the production of the cyclic extracellular polysaccharide beta-(1----2)glucan, even though a 235,000-dalton protein intermediate, known to be involved in the synthesis of this molecule, is present and active in vitro. The DNA sequence of the ndvA locus revealed a single large open reading frame encoding a 67,100-dalton protein that was homologous to a number of bacterial ATP-binding transport proteins. The greatest degree of relatedness was seen with Escherichia coli HlyB, a protein involved in the export of hemolysin, and with the mdr gene product of mammalian cells, which is also homologous to HlyB and thought to be involved in export. Based on the overall symbiotic phenotype of ndvA mutants, the extensive homology between NdvA and HlyB, the fact that ndvA mutants retained an active 235,000-dalton membrane intermediate, and the absence of extracellular beta-(1----2)glucan, we propose that NdvA is involved in export of beta-(1----2)glucan from the cell and that this process is fundamentally important for normal alfalfa nodule development.     

Secretion of cyclodextrin glucanotransferase in E. coli using Bacillus subtilis lipase signal peptide and optimization of culture medium

The cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase (CGTase) of Paenibacillus pabuli US132 was fused to the secretive lipase signal peptide of B. subtilis. This leads to an efficient secretion of the recombinant enzyme into the culture medium of E. coli as an active and soluble form contrasting with the native construction leading to a periplasmic production. In order to enhance the yield of CGTase production, an experimental design methodology was applied for the optimization of the culture composition. Hence, the media components were submitted to preliminary screening using a Plakett-Burman design. The concentrations of the major operating ones were then optimized to enhance the secretion of CGTase using response surface methodology. The findings revealed that concentrations of 0.5% potato starch, 3% yeast extract, 3% tryptone, 1.5% casein hydrolysate, 0.5% NaCl, 0.2% KH2PO4, and 0.02% MgSO4 were the optimal conditions for CGTase production. The experimental value (9.43 U/mL) obtained for CGTase activity was very close to the predicted value (9.27 U/mL).     

Optimization of a heterologous signal peptide by site-directed mutagenesis for improved secretion of recombinant proteins in Escherichia coli

A heterologous signal peptide (SP) from Bacillus sp. G1 was optimized for secretion of recombinant cyclodextrin glucanotransferase (CGTase) to the periplasmic and, eventually, extracellular space of Escherichia coli. Eight mutant SPs were constructed using site-directed mutagenesis to improve the secretion of recombinant CGTase. M5 is a mutated SP in which replacement of an isoleucine residue in the h-region to glycine created a helix-breaking or G-turn motif with decreased hydrophobicity. The mutant SP resulted in 110 and 94% increases in periplasmic and extracellular recombinant CGTase, respectively, compared to the wild-type SP at a similar level of cell lysis. The formation of intracellular inclusion bodies was also reduced, as determined by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamyde gel electrophoresis, when this mutated SP was used. The addition of as low as 0.08% glycine at the beginning of cell growth improved cell viability of the E. coli host. Secretory production of other proteins, such as mannosidase, also showed similar improvement, as demonstrated by CGTase production, suggesting that the combination of an optimized SP and a suitable chemical additive leads to significant improvements of extracellular recombinant protein production and cell viability. These findings will be valuable for the extracellular production of recombinant proteins in E. coli.     

Site-saturation mutagenesis of mutant <Emphasis Type="SmallCaps">l</Emphasis>-asparaginase II signal peptide hydrophobic region for improved excretion of cyclodextrin glucanotransferase

The excretion of cyclodextrin glucanotransferase (CGTase) into the culture medium offers significant advantages over cytoplasmic expression. However, the limitation of Escherichia coli is its inability to excrete high amount of CGTase outside the cells. In this study, modification of the hydrophobic region of the N1R3 signal peptide using site-saturation mutagenesis improved the excretion of CGTase. Signal peptide mutants designated M9F, V10L and A15Y enhanced the excretion of CGTase three-fold and demonstrated two-fold higher secretion rate than the wild type. However, high secretion rate of these mutants was non-productive for recombinant protein production because it caused up to a seven-fold increase in cell death compared to the wild type. Our results indicated that the excretion of CGTase is highly dependent on hydrophobicity, secondary conformation and the type and position of amino acids at the region boundary and core segment of the h-region.     

The mechanism of secretion of hemolysin and other polypeptides from Gram-negative bacteria

In the secretion of polypeptides from Gram-negative bacteria, the outer membrane constitutes a specific barrier which has to be circumvented. In the majority of systems, secretion is two-step process, with initial export to the periplasm involving an N-terminal signal sequence. Transport across the outer membrane then involves a variable number of ancillary polypeptides including both periplasmic and outer membrane. While such ancillary proteins are probably specific for each secreted protein, the mechanism of movement across the outer membrane is unknown. In contrast to these systems, secretion of theE. coli hemolysin (HlyA) has several distinctive features. These include a novel targeting signal located within the last 50 or so C-terminal amino acids, the absence of any periplasmic intermediates in transfer, and a specific membrane-bound translocator, HlyB, with important mammalian homologues such as P-glycoprotein (Mdr) and the cystic fibrosis protein. In this review we discuss the nature of the HlyA targeting signal, the structure and function of HlyB, and the probability that HlyA is secreted directly to the medium through a trans-envelope complex composed of HlyB and HlyD.     

Molecular insights into the mechanism of ATP-hydrolysis by the NBD of the ABC-transporter HlyB

The ABC-transporter HlyB is a central element of the Type I protein secretion machinery, dedicated to export the E. coli toxin HlyA in a single step across the two membranes of the cell envelope. Here, we discuss recent insights into the structure and the mechanism of ATP-hydrolysis by the NBD of HlyB. Combining structural and biochemical data, we have suggested that substrate-assisted catalysis (SAC), but not general base catalysis, is responsible for ATP-hydrolysis in this NBD and might also operate in other NBDs. Finally, the implications and advantages of SAC are discussed in the context of ATP-induced dimerization of the NBDs.     

Anchorage of cyclodextrin glucanotransferase on the outer membrane of Escherichia coli

The gene encoding cyclodextrin glucanotransferase (CGTase) was successfully cloned from B. macerans by PCR. A recombinant plasmid pCS005 with a gene encoding the Lpp-OmpA-CGTase trifusion protein was constructed and transformed into E. coli for the surface display of CGTase. Results of immunoblotting analysis and protease accessibility on the fractionated cell membranes confirmed that the Lpp-OmpA-CGTase trifusion protein was successfully anchored on the outer membrane of E. coli. However, only 50% of the membrane-anchored trifusion proteins were displayed on the outer surface of E. coli with the remaining 50% un-translocated. The low efficiency of surface display is attributed to the large size of CGTase. Only a trace amount of CGTase activity was detected for both the whole cells and the cell debris fractions. Because the results of the protease accessibility study suggested that the trypsin-resistant conformation of CGTase was preserved in the membrane-anchored CGTase, we believe that the lack of enzyme activity is mainly due to the inaccessibility of the CGTase active site, near the N-terminus, for substrate molecules. It can be estimated that the critical size for surface display of protein in E. coli is approximately 70 kDa.     

Translocation and compartmentalization of Escherichia coli hemolysin (HlyA).

Hemolysin plasmids were constructed with mutations in hlyB, hlyD, or both transport genes. The localization of hemolysin activity and HlyA protein in these mutants was analyzed by biochemical and immunological methods. It was found that mutants defective in hlyB accumulated internal hemolysin, part of which was associated with the inner membrane and was degraded in the late logarithmic growth phase. In an HlyB+ HlyD- mutant, hemolysin was predominantly localized in the membrane compartment. Labeling of these Escherichia coli cells with anti-HlyA antibody indicated that part of HlyA, presumably the C-terminal end but not the pore-forming domains, was already transported to the cellular surface. This finding suggests that HlyB is able to recognize the C-terminal signal of the HlyA protein and to initiate its translocation across the membranes.     

Identification and preliminary characterization of temperature-sensitive mutations affecting HlyB,the translocator required for the secretion of haemolysin (HlyA) from Escherichia coli

We have carried out a genetic analysis of Escherichia coli HlyB using in vitro(hydroxylamine) mutagenesis and regionally directed mutagenesis. From random mutagenesis, three mutants, temperature sensitive (Ts) for secretion, were isolated and the DNA sequenced: Glyl0Arg close to the N-terminus, Gly408Asp in a highly conserved small periplasmic loop region PIV, and Pro624Leu in another highly conserved region, within the ATP-binding region. Despite the Ts character of the Gly10 substitution, a derivative of HlyB, in which the first 25 amino acids were replaced by 21 amino acids of the λ Cro protein, was still active in secretion of HlyA. This indicates that this region of HlyB is dispensable for function. Interestingly, the Gly408Asp substitution was toxic at high temperature and this is the first reported example of a conditional lethal mutation in HlyB. We have isolated 4 additional mutations in PIV by directed mutagenesis, giving a total of 5 out of 12 residues substituted in this region, with 4 mutations rendering HlyB defective in secretion. The Pro624 mutation, close to the Walker B-site for ATP binding in the cytoplasmic domain is identical to a mutation in HisP that leads to uncoupling of ATP hydrolysis from the transport of histidine. The expression of a fully functional haemolysin translocation system comprising HlyC,A,B and D increases the sensitivity of E. coli to vancomycin 2.5-fold, compared with cells expressing HlyB and HlyD alone. Thus, active translocation of HlyA renders the cells hyperpermeable to the drug. Mutations in hlyB affecting secretion could be assigned to two classes: those that restore the level of vancomycin resistance to that of E. coli not secreting HlyA and those that still confer hypersensitivity to the drug in the presence of HlyA. We propose that mutations that promote vancomycin resistance will include mutations affecting initial recognition of the secretion signal and therefore activation of a functional transport channel. Mutations that do not alter HlyA-dependent vancomycin sensitivity may, in contrast, affect later steps in the transport process.