The ligation and flexibility of four-arm DNA junctions

Four-arm DNA branched junctions are stable analogs of Holliday recombination intermediates, constructed from oligonucleotides. The conformational flexibility of junctions can be estimated by ligating them together and determining the set of closed macrocyclic products that are obtained among the linked units. We have performed a series of these experiments, using pairs of sticky ends that flank each of the six angles of a four-arm junction. In every case, the ligated junctions are separated by 20 nucleotide pairs, about two turns of DNA. All expected short linear products, starting with dimers, are observed for all ligations. All ligations result in a macrocyclic series that begins with trimers. Thus, over the time scale of these reactions, the arms of this junction can form angles as low as 60°. The response of this junction to torsional stress has been tested in a companion experiment. A smaller version of this same four-arm junction has been oligomerized so that successive junctions are separated by 16 nucleotide pairs, approximately 1.5 turns of DNA. If junctions were as rigid as linear duplex DNA, this system would not be expected to form macrocycles until the continuous chain approaches the Shore–Baldwin limit, ca. 160 base pairs. However, macrocyclic closure is observed in a regular ligation ladder, starting from tetramers. Model building suggests that the most likely explanation for the observed closure is that the junction adopts two different conformations, which bend the continuous strand toward opposite grooves. The junction structures formed by these ligations represent fluctuations from equilibrium structures.     

Construction and analysis of monomobile DNA junctions

Immobile DNA junctions are complexes of oligomeric DNA strands that interact to yield branched structures in which the branch point cannot migrate. This is achieved by minimizing the sequence symmetry in the flanking arms, so that base pairs lock at the branch site. Here, we report the design, synthesis, and analysis of two semimobile junctions, structures in which a controlled extent of branch point migratory freedom is deliberately introduced. We have constructed two minimally symmetric four-arm semimobile junctions from synthetic deoxy 17-mers. These junctions, termed "monomobile", contain a single pair of base pairs (A-T or C-G) which can migrate at the site of branching, while the rest of the junction is immobile. We have demonstrated by gel electrophoresis techniques that these junctions form and that they have the predicted 1:1:1:1 stoichiometry. We have compared these junctions with the immobile junction on which they are based, by means of hydroxyl radical protection experiments. From these data, both migratory conformers can be seen to coexist in solution. The semimobile junction with the C-G base pair has the same crossover and stacking pattern observed for the immobile junction, while the junction with the A-T base pair has the opposite pattern. We conclude that crossover and stacking patterns are a direct consequence of the base pairs which flank the junction. In addition, the data indicate that the crossover pattern biases for these junctions are much greater than are the migratory biases.     

Anomalous gel migration of DNA oligomers containing multiple conformational junctions

We have previously shown that a short 16 base pair DNA oligomer can accommodate a B-Z conformational junction [Sheardy, R. D., & Winkle, S. A. (1989) Biochemistry 28, 720-725]. Results from 1H NMR studies indicated that only three base pairs were involved in the junction and that one of these base pairs was highly distorted. Being interested in the nature of this distortion, we constructed DNA oligomers which have the potential to contain multiple B-Z junctions for polyacrylamide electrophoretic studies. We report that the mobilities displayed by these molecules through acrylamide gels in the absence and presence of cobalt suggest that these molecules run shorter than they actually are. This anomalous migration may be due to structural/dynamic properties of the DNA helix manifested by the periodic distortions of the potential B-Z junctions.     

Effect of sequence on the structure of three-arm DNA junctions

We have investigated the geometry of a number of three-arm branched DNA molecules by measuring the relative electrophoretic mobilities of analogues of each junction in which one pair of arms is extended. In general, the mobilities of three species of three-arm junctions in which the duplex arms are extended pairwise differ in the presence of Mg2+. This effect is eliminated by the absence of Mg2+ or by an increase in temperature, leading us to conclude that the three-arm DNA junctions are not 3-fold symmetric, because of either preferential stacking or asymmetric kinking of the arms at the branch that occurs in the presence of Mg2+. The geometry of the junction is governed by the base sequence at the branch and 1 bp removed from the branch. The pairwise elongated analogues of junctions that contain identical base pairs at the branch or 1 bp from the branch show mobility differences; when both positions have the same sequence no mobility differences are detected even in the presence of Mg2+. Formation of a branch in three-arm DNA junctions can be seen to produce a strain or deformation that propagates about one turn of the helix from the branch, leading thymines in this region to become hyperreactive to osmium tetraoxide. Surprisingly, the effect is independent of the presence or absence of metal cations. The structure of the three-arm junction is thus quite different in character from that of four-arm junctions both in the presence and absence of high concentrations of metal cations.     

Resolution of Holliday junction analogs by T4 endonuclease VII can be directed by substrate structure

Endonuclease VII is an enzyme from bacteriophage T4 capable of resolving four-arm Holliday junction intermediates in recombination. Since natural Holliday junctions have homologous (2-fold) sequence symmetry, they can branch migrate, creating a population of substrates that have the branch point at different sites. We have explored the substrate requirements of endonuclease VII by using immobile analogs of Holliday junctions that lack this homology, thereby situating the branch point at a fixed site in the molecule. We have found that immobile junctions whose double-helical arms contain fewer than nine nucleotide pairs do not serve as substrates for resolution by endonuclease VII. Scission of substrates with 2-fold symmetrically elongated arms produces resolution products that are a function of the particular arms that are lengthened. We have confirmed that the scission products are those of resolution, rather than nicking of individual strands, by using shamrock junction molecules formed from a single oligonucleotide strand. A combination of end-labeled and internally labeled shamrock molecules has been used to demonstrate that all of the scission is due to coordinated cleavage of DNA on opposite sides of the junction, 3' to the branch point. Endonuclease VII is known to cleave the crossover strands of Holliday junctions in this fashion. The relationship of the long arms to the cleavage direction suggests that the portion of the enzyme which requires the minimum arm length interacts with the pair of arms containing the 3' portion of the crossover strands on the bound surface of the antiparallel junction.     

Base sequence criteria and Cartesian coordinates for stable B/Z and B/Z/B junctions in relaxed DNA.

It seems increasingly evident that if the Z form of DNA exists in the genome it must exist as short sections of alternating pyrimidine-purine sequences in the midst of very long sections of B-form DNA. We have determined the minimum length of a string of alternating CG base pairs that can go into the Z form in the middle of a long B form. Self-complimentary oligomers of the form T(M)(CG)(N)A(M) were synthesized. The conformation of the resulting duplex was determined in 6M aqueous NaCl solution by Raman scattering. We have found that 12 alternating CG base pairs is the minimum length required to form a stable Z form of DNA inside of a long B form section. Only the 4 center CG base pairs go into the Z form. These 4 CG base pairs in the Z form are flanked on each side by 4 CG base pairs in a non-Z (probably B) form as well as the ..TT.. ..AA.. sequences in the B form. We propose a model of the B/Z junction in which the double helix flips directly from the B form to the Z form so that there are no base pairs in the junction. In this model the B form is nucleated in the AT base pairs on each end and is propagated into the CG base pairs in the center. This model is supported by isotopic H/D exchange experiments that shows that the H/D exchange of the non-Z form CG base pairs is highly retarded and indicates that they remain in the B form. A Thermodynamic analysis of the concentration dependence of the melting point of the duplexes in both low and high salt, supports our model and rules out the possibility of hairpin formation. The enthalpy for the formation of a B/Z junction is determined to be about +16 kcal/junction. A comparison of these results with recent results on B/Z junctions in super-coiled DNA is given. Molecular modeling calculations permit us to obtain values for the coordinates and torsional angles of the oligomers showing both B/Z and B/Z/B junctions. The Cartesian coordinates for these oligomers as well as stereo figures of these models in color are available from the authors.     

Temperature-dependent CD and NMR studies on a synthetic oligonucleotide containing a B-Z junction at high salt

It is now accepted that two or more conformations may exist within the same DNA molecule, thereby generating conformational junctions. The presence of B-Z junctions between right- and left-handed DNA conformations has been detected in plasmids by a number of techniques. Preliminary characterization of the first example of a B-Z junction is a short DNA oligonucleotide has recently been reported [Sheardy, R. D. (1988) Nucleic Acids Res. 16, 1153-1167]. We report additional CD and NMR data that support the existence of the junction in this model oligomer. These studies indicate that only three base pairs are involved in the junction and only one of these is dramatically distorted. Furthermore, the NMR saturation-transfer experiments suggest the junction's internal motion is temperature dependent.     

The structure of the Holliday junction, and its resolution

The Holliday (four-way) junction is a critical intermediate in homologous genetic recombination. We have studied the structure of a series of four-way junctions, constructed by hybridization of four 80 nucleotide synthetic oligonucleotides. These molecules migrate anomalously slowly in gel electrophoresis. Each arm of any junction could be selectively shortened by cleavage at a unique restriction site, and we have studied the relative gel mobilities of species in which two arms were cleaved. The pattern of fragments observed argues strongly for a structure with two-fold symmetry, based on an X shape, the long arms of which are made from pairwise colinear association of helical arms. The choice of partners is governed by the base sequence at the junction, allowing a potential isomerization between equivalent structural forms. Resolvase enzymes can distinguish between these structures, and the resolution products are determined by the structure adopted, i.e., by the sequence at the junction. In the absence of cations, the helical arms of the junction are fully extended in a square configuration, and unstacking results in junction thymines becoming reactive to osmium tetroxide.     

Structure of Three-Way DNA Junctions 1. Non-Planar DNA Geometry

Abstract

Three-way junctions were obtained by annealing two synthetic DNA-oligomers. One of the strands contains a short palindrome sequence, leading to the formation of a hairpin with four base pairs in the stem and four bases in the loop. Another strand is complementary to the linear arms of the first hairpin-containing strand. Both strands were annealed to form a three-way branched structure with sticky ends on the linear arms. The branched molecules were ligated, and the ligation mixture was analysed on a two-dimensional gel in conditions which separated linear and circular molecules. Analysis of 2D-electrophoresis data shows that circular molecules with high mobility are formed. Formation of circular molecules is indicative of bends between linear arms. We estimate the magnitude of the angle between linear arms from the predominant size of the circular molecules formed. When the junction-to-junction distance is 20–21 bp, trimers and tetramers are formed predominately, giving an angle between linear arms as small as 60–90°. Rotation of the hairpin position in the three- way junction allowed us to measure angles between other arms, yielding similar values. These results led us to conclude that the three-way DNA junction possesses a non-planar pyramidal geometry with 60–90° between the arms. Computer modeling of the three-way junction with 60° pyramidal geometry showed a predominantly B-form structure with local distortions at the junction points that diminish towards the ends of the helices. The size distributions of circular molecules are rather broad indicating a dynamic flexibility of three-way DNA junctions.     

Assembly and characterization of five-arm and six-arm DNA branched junctions.

DNA branched junctions have been constructed that contain either five arms or six arms surrounding a branch point. These junctions are not as stable as junctions containing three or four arms; unlike the smaller junctions, they cannot be shown to migrate as a single band on native gels when each of their arms contains eight nucleotide pairs. However, they can be stabilized if their arms contain 16 nucleotide pairs. Ferguson analysis of these junctions in combination with three-arm and four-arm junctions indicates a linear increase in friction constant as the number of arms increases, with the four-arm junction migrating anomalously. The five-arm junction does not appear to have any unusual stacking structure, and all strands show similar responses to hydroxyl radical autofootprinting analysis. By contrast, one strand of the six-arm junction shows virtually no protection from hydroxyl radicals, suggesting that it is the helical strand of a preferred stacking domain. Both junctions are susceptible to digestion by T4 endonuclease VII, which resolves Holliday junctions. However, the putative helical strand of the six-arm junction shows markedly reduced cleavage, supporting the notion that its structure is largely found in a helical conformation. Branched DNA molecules can be assembled into structures whose helix axes form multiply connected objects and networks. The ability to construct five-arm and six-arm junctions vastly increases the number of structures and networks that can be built from branched DNA components. Icosahedral deltahedra and 11 networks with 432 symmetry, constructed from Platonic and Archimedean solids, are among the structures whose construction is feasible, now that these junctions can be made.     

Relative stabilities of DNA three-way, four-way and five-way junctions (multi-helix junction loops): unpaired nucleotides can be stabilizing or destabilizing.

Competition binding and UV melting studies of a DNA model system consisting of three, four or five mutually complementary oligonucleotides demonstrate that unpaired bases at the branch point stabilize three- and five-way junction loops but destabilize four-way junctions. The inclusion of unpaired nucleotides permits the assembly of five-way DNA junction complexes (5WJ) having as few as seven basepairs per arm from five mutually complementary oligonucleotides. Previous work showed that 5WJ, having eight basepairs per arm but lacking unpaired bases, could not be assembled [Wang, Y.L., Mueller, J.E., Kemper, B. and Seeman, N.C. (1991) Biochemistry, 30, 5667-5674]. Competition binding experiments demonstrate that four-way junctions (4WJ) are more stable than three-way junctions (3WJ), when no unpaired bases are included at the branch point, but less stable when unpaired bases are present at the junction. 5WJ complexes are in all cases less stable than 4WJ or 3WJ complexes. UV melting curves confirm the relative stabilities of these junctions. These results provide qualitative guidelines for improving the way in which multi-helix junction loops are handled in secondary structure prediction programs, especially for single-stranded nucleic acids having primary sequences that can form alternative structures comprising different types of junctions.     

Characterization and comparative structural features of the gene for human interstitial retinol-binding protein

We have cloned the gene for human interstitial retinol-binding protein (IRBP) and compared its nucleotide sequence with that of the corresponding cloned cDNA. The human IRBP gene is approximately 9.5 kilobase pairs (kbp) in length and consists of four exons separated by three introns. The introns are 1.6-1.9 kbp long. The gene is transcribed by photoreceptor and retinoblastoma cells into an approximately 4.3-kilobase mRNA that is translated and processed into a glycosylated protein of 135,000 Da. The amino acid sequence of human IRBP can be divided into four contiguous homology domains with 33-38% identity, suggesting a series of gene duplication events. In the gene, the boundaries of these domains are not defined by exon-intron junctions, as might have been expected. The first three homology domains and part of the fourth are all encoded by the first large exon, which is 3,180 base pairs long. The remainder of the fourth domain is encoded in the last three exons, which are 191, 143, and approximately 740 base pairs long, respectively. This unusual structure is shared with the bovine IRBP gene. A large (1.7 kbp) fragment appears to have been lost from the 3'-noncoding region of the last human exon. We conclude that the human and bovine genes have similar evolutionary histories.     

Resolution of tethered antiparallel and parallel holliday junctions by the Flp site-specific recombinase

Members of the integrase family site-specific recombinases (also called the tyrosine family) bring about recombination in two steps by exchanging pairs of single strands at a time. The product of the first exchange reaction is a four-way DNA junction, the Holliday intermediate. The conformational dynamics by which the recombination complex "isomerizes" from the Holliday-forming to the Holliday-resolving mode are not well understood. Experiments with the lambda Int and Escherichia coli XerC/XerD systems imply that the strand configurations at the branch point of the protein-free junction dictate the resolution mode in the protein-bound junction. We have examined the question of strand bias during resolution for the Flp system by using a series of synthetic Holliday junctions that are conformationally constrained by local sequences or by strand tethering. We have not observed a strong resolution bias in favor of the strands designed to assume the "crossed" configuration within the unbound junction. The resolution patterns with antiparallel junctions in a variety of substrate contexts reveal either parity in strand choice, or only modest disparity. On the other hand, the highly biased resolutions observed in the case of tethered parallel junctions can be explained by the non-equivalence in protein occupancy of the DNA arms of these substrates and/or inefficient conversion of cleavage events to recombinants at the tethered ends.     

Parallel symmetric immobile DNA junctions as substrates for E. coli RuvC Holliday junction resolvase

RuvC is a well-characterized Holliday junction resolvase from E. coli. The presence of symmetry in its preferred recognition sequence leads to ambiguity in the position of the crossover point in the junction, because a symmetric junction can undergo branch migration. Symmetric immobile junctions are junctions that contain such symmetric sites, but are prevented from migrating by their physical characteristics. RuvC activity had been analyzed previously by traditional symmetric immobile junctions, in which the helix axes are held antiparallel in a double-crossover motif. Bowtie junctions are branched four-arm molecules containing 5',5' and 3',3' linkages at their crossover points. A new type of symmetric immobile junction can be made by flanking the crossover point of a Bowtie junction with a symmetric sequence. The junction is immobile because mobility would lead to pairing between parallel, rather than antiparallel, nucleotide pairs. In contrast to conventional Holliday junctions and their analogues, the Bowtie junction assumes a parallel, rather than antiparallel, helical domain conformation, offering a new type of substrate for Holliday junction resolvases. Here, we report the digestion of Bowtie junctions by RuvC. We demonstrate that Bowtie junctions can function as symmetric immobile junctions in this system. We also show that RuvC cleaves antiparallel junctions much more efficiently than parallel junctions, where the protein can bind (and cleave) only one site at a time. These data suggest that the presence of two binding sites leads to communication between the two subunits of the enzyme to increase its activity.     

Characterization of nonconservative homologous junctions in mammalian cells.

Homologous recombination in mammalian cells between extrachromosomal molecules, as well as between episomes and chromosomes, can be mediated by a nonconservative mechanism. It has been proposed that the key steps in this process are the generation (by double-strand cleavage) of overlapping homologous ends, the creation of complementary single-strand ends (either by strand-specific exonuclease degradation or by unwinding of the DNA helix), and finally the creation of heteroduplex DNA by the annealing of the single-strand ends. We have analyzed in detail the structure of nonconservative homologous junctions and determined the contribution of each end to the formation of the junction. We have also analyzed multiple descendants from single recombination events. Two types of junctions were found. The majority (90%) of the junctions were characterized by a single crossover site. These crossover sites were distributed randomly throughout the junction. The remaining 10% of the junctions had mosaic patterns of parental markers. Furthermore, in 9 of 10 cases, multiple descendants from a single recombination event were identical. Thus, it appears that in most cases few parental markers were involved in junction formation. This finding suggests that nonconservative homologous junctions are mediated mainly by short heteroduplexes of a few hundred base pairs or less. These results are discussed in terms of the current models of nonconservative homologous recombination.     

Interaction of linear homologous DNA duplexes via Holliday junction formation.

Interaction of linear homologous DNA duplexes by formation of Holliday junctions was revealed by electrophoresis and confirmed by electron microscopy. The phenomenon was demonstrated using a model of five purified PCR products of different size and sequence. The double-stranded structure of interacting DNA fragments was confirmed using several consecutive purifications, S1-nuclease analysis, and electron microscopy. Formation of Holliday junctions depends on DNA concentration. A thermodynamic equilibrium between duplexes and Holliday junctions was shown. We propose that homologous duplex interaction is initiated by nucleation of several dissociated terminal base pairs of two fragments. This process is followed by branch migration creating a population of Holliday junctions with the branch point at different sites. Finally, Holliday junctions are resolved via branch migration to new or previously existing duplexes. The phenomenon is a new property of DNA. This type of DNA-DNA interaction may contribute to the process of Holliday junction formation in vivo controlled by DNA conformation and DNA-protein interactions. It is of practical significance for optimization of different PCR-based methods of gene analysis, especially those involving heteroduplex formation.     

An archaeal Holliday junction resolving enzyme from Sulfolobus solfataricus exhibits unique properties

The rearrangement and repair of DNA by homologous recombination often involves the creation of Holliday junctions, which must be cleaved by junction-specific endonucleases to yield recombinant duplex DNA products. Holliday junction resolving enzymes are a ubiquitous class of proteins with diverse structural and mechanistic characteristics. We have characterised an endonuclease (Hje) from the thermophilic crenarchaeote Sulfolobus solfataricus that exhibits a high degree of specificity for Holliday junctions via an apparently novel mechanism. Hje resolves four-way DNA junctions by the introduction of paired nicks in a reaction that is independent of the local nucleotide sequence, but is restricted solely to strands that are continuous in the stacked-X form of the junction. Three-way DNA junctions are cleaved only when the presence of a bulge in one strand allows the junction to stack in an analogous manner to four-way junctions. These properties differentiate Hje from all other known junction resolving enzymes.     

Construction of a DNA four-way junction: Design and NMR spectroscopy

In 1964 Holliday postulated the formation of cruciform structures (four-way junctions) in duplex DNA as intermediate in genetic recombination. Since then, many biochemical and biophysical investigations were directed at solving questions concerning structural details of stable four-way junctions. Thus far, NMR spectroscopy played a minor part in these investigations on account of the minimum size of the molecule (expressed as the number of nucleotide residues) that was thought necessary to produce a stable cruciform structure. Indeed, the smallest four-way junction studied thus far by NMR methods was built from four separate DNA strands, each containing 16 nucleotides, a total of 64. Obviously, with such a large structure one runs into assignment problems. We considered the possibility of constructing a stable four-way junction from a single strand of DNA. The underlying idea was to make use of our detailed knowledge of the building principles of stable minihairpin loops. These loops, containing only two nucleotides to bridge the gap between antiparallel strands, are maximally stable in DNA sequences like 5-d(-C-TT-G-), where C and G form a normal Watson-Crick base pair and the two T residues cross the minor groove to form the minihairpin loop. Three of such miniloops could in principle cap three arms of the cruciform. The fourth arm would have an open end. The problem to be solved is to find the minimum length that is required to insure stability of the three closed arms and of the fourth open arm. We were successful with a structure that has three short stems (four base pairs each) and an open-end stem consisting of eight base pairs, a total of 46 residues. NMR experiments, carried out on this molecule in the presence of Mg²⁺, showed details of folding which have never been observed before.     

Tertiary Motifs Revealed in Analyses of Higher-Order RNA Junctions

RNA junctions are secondary-structure elements formed when three or more helices come together. They are present in diverse RNA molecules with various fundamental functions in the cell. To better understand the intricate architecture of three-dimensional (3D) RNAs, we analyze currently solved 3D RNA junctions in terms of base-pair interactions and 3D configurations. First, we study base-pair interaction diagrams for solved RNA junctions with 5 to 10 helices and discuss common features. Second, we compare these higher-order junctions to those containing 3 or 4 helices and identify global motif patterns such as coaxial stacking and parallel and perpendicular helical configurations. These analyses show that higher-order junctions organize their helical components in parallel and helical configurations similar to lower-order junctions. Their sub-junctions also resemble local helical configurations found in three- and four-way junctions and are stabilized by similar long-range interaction preferences such as A-minor interactions. Furthermore, loop regions within junctions are high in adenine but low in cytosine, and in agreement with previous studies, we suggest that coaxial stacking between helices likely forms when the common single-stranded loop is small in size; however, other factors such as stacking interactions involving noncanonical base pairs and proteins can greatly determine or disrupt coaxial stacking. Finally, we introduce the ribo-base interactions: when combined with the along-groove packing motif, these ribo-base interactions form novel motifs involved in perpendicular helix-helix interactions. Overall, these analyses suggest recurrent tertiary motifs that stabilize junction architecture, pack helices, and help form helical configurations that occur as sub-elements of larger junction networks. The frequent occurrence of similar helical motifs suggest nature's finite and perhaps limited repertoire of RNA helical conformation preferences. More generally, studies of RNA junctions and tertiary building blocks can ultimately help in the difficult task of RNA 3D structure prediction.     

Nucleotide sequence structure and consistency of a developmentally regulated DNA deletion in Tetrahymena thermophila.

DNA deletion by site-specific chromosome breakage and rejoining occurs extensively during macronuclear development in the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila. We have sequenced both the micronuclear (germ line) and rearranged macronuclear (somatic) forms of one region from which 1.1 kilobases of micronuclear DNA are reproducibly deleted during macronuclear development. The deletion junctions lie within a pair of 6-base-pair direct repeats. The termini of the deleted sequence are not inverted repeats. The precision of deletion at the nucleotide level was also characterized by hybridization with a synthetic oligonucleotide matching the determined macronuclear (rejoined) junction sequence. This deletion occurs in a remarkably sequence-specific manner. However, a very minor degree of variability in the macronuclear junction sequences was detected and was shown to be inherent in the mechanism of deletion itself. These results suggest that DNA deletion during macronuclear development in T. thermophila may constitute a novel type of DNA recombination and that it can create sequence heterogeneity on the order of a few base pairs at rejoining junctions.