Restimulation of cytolytic T-lymphocytes in long-term mixed leukocyte cultures. 1. Physical and proliferative characteristics of cytolytic T-lymphocytes restimulated at low cell density.

Some physical and proliferative characteristics of cytolytic thymus-derived lymphocytes (CTL) have been investigated in long-term mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC). Velocity sedimentation analysis of MLC cells restimulated by homologous alloantigens at low responding cell density indicated that a shift from large cycling CTL to much smaller (probably non-cycling) CTL occurred between the third and sixth day in secondary cultures. This change in physical characteristics as a function of growth phase was accompanied by a parallel change in the responsiveness of secondary MLC cells to a further alloantigenic stimulus; restimulated Day 3 secondary cells gave rise to a transient CTL response (peaking after 2–3 days) whereas the response of restimulated Day 6 secondary cells increased for 4 days and reached much higher peak levels. Repeated stimulation of MLC cells under the latter conditions led to dramatic increases in both CTL activity and viable cell number. In particular, four sequential restimulations at 7-day intervals resulted in a calculated absolute increase of approximately 500,000-fold in both parameters. Cells derived from such extensive proliferation retained their original lytic specificity and were uniquely T cells as determined by surface markers. These results raise interesting questions regarding the extent and regulation of CTL proliferation in MLC.     

Differential expression of the repertoire in in vitro and in vivo responses to minor alloantigens

The response to multiple minor alloantigens in the secondary mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) between mouse strains that are identical at the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) generally yields effector cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) which show cross-reactive killing of most or all third-party mouse strains which also share MHC haplotypes. We have investigated the clonal diversity of CTL responses in vivo versus in vitro by examination of such cross-reactions, using CTL effector cells derived from a primary response, an in vivo secondary response, and an in vitro secondary MLC. CTL from these three responses were assayed on a panel of H-2' targets. Restimulation of antigen-primed spleen cells in vitro yielded CTL which were strongly cross-reactive on all targets, whereas the in vivo responses were much less so. We conclude that the set of clones which become cytotoxic effectors in vivo is much less diverse than the set which is primed on a first encounter with antigen and that powerful constraints must therefore operate on the specificity of in vivo responses to non-MHC antigens.     

The cell-mediated lympholysis-inducing capacity of highly purified human monocytes and T lymphocytes in primary and secondary mixed leukocyte cultures

In this study the capacity of T cells and monocytes to induce cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) in primary and secondary MLC was investigated. The T lymphocytes were enriched by rosetting with sheep red blood cells (E) and further purified by sedimentation at unit gravity, which completely removed the contaminating monocytes. In addition, a highly purified monocyte population was obtained by 1 X G sedimentation of the non-E rosette-forming cells. These purified T cells have a poor CML-inducing capacity in primary and secondary MLC. In contrast, monocytes were very effective in inducing CML in both primary and secondary MLC. Induction of CML by monocytes in primary MLC was inhibited by heterologous anti-Ia-like antisera, indicating that the induction of CML by monocytes was related to the presence of HLA-DR (Ia-like) antigens on these cells.     

Comparison of immune responsiveness in mice after single or multiple donor-specific transfusions

Immune responsiveness was compared in B6AF1 mice after one, two, three, or four donor-specific DBA/2 blood transfusions (DST). Ten days after the last transfusion, the spleen cells of transfused mice were assayed for direct lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity, for the ability to respond in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) and cell-mediated lymphocytotoxic (CML) assays to DBA/2 and C3H/He antigens, and for the ability to inhibit the MLC and CML response of normal B6AF1 to DBA/2 and C3H/He antigens. Immune responsiveness was also tested in B6AF1 2 to 80 days after a single DBA/2 DST. The MLC response of transfused mice was specifically suppressed to the blood donor after both single and multiple transfusions. The CML response to DBA/2 was suppressed after a single DST, but returned to normal after multiple transfusions. Spleen cells from transfused mice did not inhibit the MLC response of normal B6AF1 mice to DBA/2 or C3H/He antigens after one or two transfusions regardless of time tested, but were able to inhibit the response to both stimulators after three or more transfusions. The MLC response remained specifically suppressed to the blood donor for as long as 80 days after a single DST, while the CML response was suppressed up to 50 days after transfusion, but had returned to normal by 80 days.     

The mechanism of cell-mediated cytotoxicity. II. The apparent biochemical requirements for cytolysis are influenced by the source and frequency of murine cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) were generated in allogeneic mixed-lymphocyte cultures (MLC) with the responder cells from immunized mice (secondary (II°) MLC.) These CTL could be maintained as proliferating cells for 2 to 4 weeks by culturing in a medium with T-cell growth factor (TCGF) activity and were 10 to 30 times as active as effectors obtained directly from immunized mice or those generated in primary (I°) MLC. Cytolysis by CTL from II° MLC was refractory to inhibition by azide, cyanide, or cycloheximide in contrast to previous reports that these agents were inhibitory. However, cytolysis by CTL from II° MLC was sensitive to azide when sufficient normal spleen cells were added to reduce the apparent CTL frequency to approximate that of the less active populations. Cycloheximide (Cx) partially inhibited cytolysis by CTL from immune spleen cells as shown earlier by others. However, CTL from II° MLC remained refractory to Cx even when diluted with normal spleen cells. These data show that CTL populations from various sources have both qualitative and quantitative differences that may alter their apparent biochemical requirements for CML. These considerations must be taken into account when attempting to define the minimal requirements for CTL-mediated killing.     

The suppressive effect of a supernate from concanavalin A-activated human lymphocytes: effects of concanavalin A-activated lymphocytes and their supernates on cytotoxic and mixed lymphocyte reactions.

The effects of Concanavalin A-treated human peripheral blood lymphocytes and their supernatants were evaluated on the MLC reaction and on the generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes assessed by cell-mediated lympholysis (CML). Experiments were performed with both allogeneic and xenogenic sensitization. It was found that Con A-activated cells suppressed the MLC and CML reactions in allogeneic and xenogeneic systems. On the other hand, the SIRS-like supernate was able to suppress the MLC reaction and blastogenesis, but had no suppressive effect on the generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes. We found no difference in the magnitude of suppression, whether or not Con A-activated lymphocytes were syngeneic to the responder cells. This finding suggests that there is no requirement for allogeneic restriction in the interaction between suppressor and suppressed cells, and demonstrates a soluble human suppressor substance capable of suppressing some cell-mediated reactions.     

Genetics of cell-mediated lympholysis in man.

Cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) was studied in a family containing two siblings in who genetic recombinaiton had occurred in the HLA comples. In one sibling, recombination occurred between the HLA-A locus and the HLA-B locus. In the second sibling recombination occurred between the HLA-B locus and the HLA-D locus. Strong CML activity was generated in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) when stimulator and responder cells differed in HLA-A, B, and D antigens. MLC involving HLA-D differences alone did not generate CML. Weak, but definite CML activity was generated during MLC with cells differing at HLA-A and HLA-B but sharing HLA-D. HLA-B antigens were good targets for lysis in all combinations studied. HLA-A antigens were poor targets in some but not in all combinations. However, combinations where HLA-A antigens seemed to be good targets could have involved HLA-B differences due to polymorphism of HLA-B7 antigens each inherited from a different parent. HLA-D antigens did not serve as targets for lysis. In three cell experiments, excellent CML activity was generated when responder cells were stimulated by HLA-D antigens and by HLA-A and B antigens present on separate stimulator cells.     

Inhibition of murine suppressor cell function by progesterone

The effects of progesterone on murine suppressor cell function generated in allogeneic MLCs were investigated. BALB/c splenic lymphocytes stimulated in vitro with C3H/He cells significantly suppressed the proliferative response of BALB/c lymphocytes in a secondary MLC. This suppression was highly specific for the sensitizing alloantigens since the suppressor cells had no effect on the proliferative response of BALB/c lymphocytes to third-party alloantigens. In addition, BALB/c lymphocytes stimulated with syngeneic cells were observed to nonspecifically suppress the MLC response to a lesser extent. One to 10 micrograms/ml progesterone added at initiation to suppressor cell generating cultures diminished the ability of both alloantigen specific and nonspecific suppressor cell populations to suppress the proliferative response of homologous lymphocytes to alloantigens. Experiments with pyrilamine, an antihistamine, which blocks cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) generation, suggests that progesterone has a direct inhibitory effect on suppressor cell function independent of its ability to block CTL induction. The effects of progesterone on suppressor cells were not due to shifts in peak response time in MLC or induction of radiosensitive cells in progesterone-treated cultures. Estradiol at doses between 5 and 10 micrograms/ml, and cortisol at dose of 1 microgram/ml, also significantly inhibited suppressor cell function. These results suggest that the steroid hormone milieu within the placenta may effect the activity of allogeneic or nonspecific suppressor cell activity.     

Cytolytic T lymphocyte responses to metabolically inactivated stimulator cells. II. Effect of a soluble "costimulator" factor(s) in primary and secondary mixed leukocyte culture

The ability of a concanavalin A-stimulated spleen cell supernatant (“costimulator”) to overcome the effects of impaired CD and LD antigen presentation by metabolically inactivated stimulator spleen cells was examined in the primary and secondary cytolytic T lymphocyte (T_c) response. (i) Cells inactivated by ultraviolet irradiation or mild glutaraldehyde treatment, which were unable to stimulate primary cytolytic activity on their own, generated near maximal responses in the presence of costimulator. The 30-fold lower efficiency of splenic membrane fragments as antigen in primary MLC with the supernatant indicated that the damage to immunogenicity caused by membrane isolation was not equivalent to that caused by uv light and glutaraldehyde, as has previously been assumed. (ii) Comparison of the relative effects of antigen and costimulator demonstrated that costimulator played the dominant regulatory role in primary MLC, increasing sensitivity to suboptimal antigen doses 10- to 30-fold; neither antigen nor the supernatant appeared preferentially to control the strength of the secondary response. (iii) Metabolically inactivated adult and untreated neonatal spleen cells failed to release costimulator activity in response to concanavalin A. However, the ability of the neonatal cells to induce a primary cytolytic response suggested that costimulator production by the stimulator cells themselves is not essential for primary T_c activation, and supports the hypothesis that the lack of primary immunogenicity of inactivated spleen cells reflects their failure to induce costimulator production by the responder population.     

Induction of an antibody response in vitro against synthetic antigens in guinea pigs. I. Culture and assay conditions

Guinea pig spleen and lymph node cells were found to produce anti-2,4-dinitrophenyl (Dnp) oligolysine PFC in vivo against 2,4-dinitrophenyl-β-alanyl glycyl glycyl (Dagg-SRBC) but not against trinitrophenyl-SRBC target indicator cells. Furthermore, when sensitized spleen cells or their purified B-cell fractions were cocultured with primed peritoneal exudate lymphocytes (PEL) but not splenic T cells they were able to generate a secondary PFC response in vitro to the synthetic antigens, Dnp oligolysines. PFC were not induced in vitro if these same cultures were pulsed with short-chain peptides (five lysines) or the complex antigen, dinitrophenyl-bovine γ-globulin (DnpBGG). Con A was able to substitute for PEL in triggering spleen cells to mount a secondary in vitro PFC response to homologous Dnp oligolysines. More importantly, the Con A-aided spleen cell cultures were not induced above background values when challenged in vitro with heterologous Dnp oligolysines. This study suggests that spleen cells may lack a nonspecific signal for the development of a secondary in vitro PFC response.     

Immunologic unresponsiveness of mouse spleen sensitized to allogenic tumors.

CS7BL/6 mice were sensitized with an ip injection of allogeneic P-815 mastocytoma cells. Fifteen days later the spleen cells of the tumor allosensitized mice were cultured and tested for their responsiveness to mitogens and alloantigens, and for their ability to generate cytotoxic cells in vitro. The results indicate that 15 day tumor-sensitized spleen cells are hypo-responsive in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) with DBA/2 or AKR as stimulating spleen cells. The cells which are hypo-responsive in MLC can proliferate in response to mitogens and they also can generate cytotoxic cells in vitro. MLC reactivity recovers in about 2–3 months which is $\text{1}\text{1}\text{2}\text{–2}\text{1}\text{2}$ months after the mice have rejected their tumors. The mechanism of MLC hypo-responsiveness was investigated. The results suggest the presence of a suppressor cell which does not appear to be a macrophage or a B-cell. The suppressor cell can be separated from the cytotoxic cell and therefore appears to be a noncytotoxic T-cell.     

Generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes in mixed lymphocyte reactions II. Importance of private and publicH-2 alloantigens on the expression of cytotoxicity

MLC were established to test for the generation of specific cytotoxic effector cells in CML. The target cell used to assay for CML in the five combinations tested was of a differentH-2 haplotype from the stimulating cell population. Cytotoxicity was observed against this target only when it shared private alloantigens (antigens that are specific for theH-2D andH-2K region of differentH-2 haplotypes) with the stimulating cell population. Very weak or no Cytotoxicity was found when such alloantigens were not shared, although cross-reactive publicH-2 specificities were. These findings indicate that T cells display a cytotoxic potential against privateH-2 antigens in a primary response in vitro and are not capable of responding to publicH-2 specificities to the same level.BSS balanced salt solution - CML cell-mediated lympholysis - GPC guinea pig complement - ¹²⁵IUdR ¹²⁵I-iodo-deoxyuridine - MLC mixed lymphocyte culture - SE standard error     

Cell-mediated lympholysis by fetal and neonatal lymphocytes in sheep and man

The occurrence of cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) was studied in the fetal lamb at 70 to 138 days of gestation and in the human fetus at 12 to 23 weeks of gestation, and also at the time of full-term birth in both species. The fetal lymphocytes were sensitized in mixed-lymphocyte culture (MLC) to prepare effector cells for CML. Concanavalin A-induced cells were used as target cells. No fetal capacity for CML was demonstrable during those periods of intrauterine life studied, despite the occurrence of clear MLC responses. At the time of full-term birth. CML by lamb lymphocytes was on average only one-seventh of the adult response. In man, neonatal lymphocytes may occasionally show a CML of the same magnitude as the adult lymphocytes, although on average the neonatal CML capacity was about half that in the adult.     

Functional significance of the Fc receptor on mixed lymphocyte culture-activated T blasts.

Fc receptor (FcR)-carrying blast cells were separated from nonFcR blast cells after priming in primary mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) by erythrocyte-antibody rosetting and by 1-g velocity sedimentation. Both types of blast cells were cytotoxic to relevant allogeneic target cells in vitro. The FcR-positive and FcR-negative blasts were then plated on a feeder layer syngeneic to the primary MLC responder cells. After feeder layer culture both types of cells reverted into secondary small lymphocytes. When restimulated with the original stimulator cells, both types of secondary lymphocytes produced the relevant secondary cell-mediated lysis responses. Thus no functionally dissimilar subclasses of secondary T lymphocytes can be distinguished in the MLC-stimulated T-cell population on the basis of the FcR.     

Macrophages suppress CTL generation in rat mixed leukocyte cultures.

The generation of CTL in rat MLC was actively suppressed by a cell population present in spleen cell preparations from normal rats. These suppressor cells were characterized by using a variety of cell fractionation techniques. Suppressor cells were removed by passage of spleen cells through nylon wool columns or by treatment with carbonyl iron. Suppressive activity was present in the mononuclear cell fraction of spleen cells obtained by Ficoll-Hypaque density gradient centrifugation. After velocity sedimentation at unit gravity, enrichment of suppressive activity was demonstrated in the fractions containing large cells as compared to the fractions containing small cells. Populations rich in macrophages were shown to have similar suppressive activity upon CTL induction in MLC. These studies suggest that macrophages present in normal rat spleen cell preparations account for the difficulty in generating CTL in MLC prepared with rat cells.     

T cell memory for the cytotoxic response to hapten-modified target cells.

This study describes the development of memory and cytotoxic murine T cells against syngeneic haptne N equals[N-(3-nitro-4-hydroxy-5-iodophenyl-acetyl)-Beta-alanylglycylglycyl] associated antigen. Memory activity in this system had the following characteristics. a) In vitro challenged cells primed in vivo resulted in an augmented cytotoxic response compared to cells primed in vitro. b) The augmented cytotoxic response in vitro was antigen-specific for both target cells in the lytic reaction and stimulator cells in the secondary response. c) Memory activity was long lasting (at least 2 months). d) Memory cells were not cytotoxic. e) Memory activity as well as the cytotoxic cells generated in a secondary response in vitro were T cell dependent, These findings are consistent with the results of others who have investigated T cell dependent memory in other cell-mediated reactions.     

Immunologic functions of isolated human lymphocyte subpopulations. IV. Stimulation of MLC and CML by human T cells.

Surface immunoglobulin positive and immunoglobulin negative human lymphocyte populations were obtained by immunoabsorbent column chromatography. Both cell populations were effective as stimulating and target cells in allogeneic MLC and CML reactions. The immunoglobulin negative population was further depleted of both EAC rosette forming cells and nylon wool adherent cells. The resulting highly purified T cell population was also able to stimulate allogeneic cells in MLC, and induce the generation of specifically cytotoxic killer cells in CML.     

Generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vitro. VI. Effect of cell density on response in mixed leukocyte cultures.

Reexposure of day 14 murine mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) populations to the original irradiated allogeneic stimulating spleen cells has previously been found to result in the ratpid generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) associated with a net increase in cultured cell number. Under the experimental conditions used, day 5 MLC cells appeared unable to respond to the allogeneic stimulus. In order to characterize further the development of the potential for anamnestic reactivity during the course of MLC, C57BL/6 spleen cells were incubated with irradiated (1000 rads) DBA/2 spleen cells (primary MLC) for up to 3 weeks. At various time intervals after the onset of the primary MLC, the surviving cells were collected and reexposed, at varying cell concentrations, to irradiated DBA/2 spleen cells (secondary MLC). At daily intervals thereafter, CTL activity was assessed using a quantitative 51Cr-release assay system. A paradoxic effect of responding cell concentration on generation of CTL activity was observed; relatively greater increase in CTL activity was observed as the concentration of responding cells was decreased over a 100-fold range. This effect was more pronounced with responding cells reexposed to antigen after primary MLC for 20 days, but was observed even with normal cells. The apparent unresponsiveness of day 5 MLC cells to alloantigen restimulation could be overcome by simple dilution of responding cells. Cytotoxic activity at the time of restimulation with antigen seems to be a major factor determining the magnitude of the secondary response. Since intact cells bearing alloantigens are required for the generation of CTL in MLC, residual cytotoxic cells reduce the effective antigenic stimulus by destroying stimulating cells. This effect of concentration of responding cells on generation of CTL in MLC complicates interpretation of experiments investigating the role of "inhibitor" and "helper" cell in cell-mediated immune responses occurring in vitro. Under optimal conditions, the highest CTL activity and the largest increase in total cell number was observed 4 days after restimulation of day 10 MLC cells. On a per cell basis, the lytic activity was up to 4 times greater than that observed at the peak of a primary response, and the number of viable cells recovered was nearly 20 times higher than that at the onset. Such secondary MLC are thus a convenient source of lymphoid cells selected primarily on the basis of proliferation induced by alloantigens.     

Antigen-specific receptors on antibody-forming cells expressing light and heavy chain determinants.

There has been controversy in the past about whether or not antibody-forming cells have antigen-specific receptors. Evidence is presented here which clearly demonstrates that some antibody-forming cells possess receptors while others show no evidence of receptors. Moreover, in this report the receptors are characterized in terms of their light and heavy chain immunoglobulin determinants. Receptors were found on ~50% of the direct PFC 6 days after one injection of sheep red blood cells (SRBC). On Day 4 of the secondary response only 20–33% of the direct PFC were found to possess receptors. Receptors could not be detected on indirect PFC in either the primary or secondary response. Results similar to the above were observed for the primary and secondary anti-hapten response to 3-nitro-4-hydroxy-5-iodophenyl acetic acid coupled to diphtheria toxoid (NIP-TOX). The receptors on the antibody-forming cells were shown to possess a class-specific heavy chain determinant (TgM) as well as two allotypic determinants, one a product of the a locus on the heavy chain and the other a product of the b locus on the light chain. The antigen-binding receptors were modulated to cap formation by antibody directed toward either light or heavy chain immunoglobulin determinants. The antigen-binding activity of the receptors was completely destroyed by trypsin.     

Expression of interleukin-2 receptor on blood lymphocytes stimulated with allogeneic lymphocytes or autologous tumor cells

Summary The kinetics of interleukin-2 receptor (IL-2R) expression and the [³H]dT incorporation of blood lymphocytes after the first and the second stimulation with allogeneic leukocytes (primary and secondary MLC) or with the autologous tumor cells (primary and secondary MLTC) were compared. The expression of IL-2R paralleled the induction of DNA synthesis. The proportion of IL-2R⁺ cells of the unprimed donors peaked earlier in the secondary MLC as compared to the primary MLC (on days 3 and 5 respectively). In MLC of alloimmunized healthy individuals and in the MLTC of cancer patients the highest proportions of IL-2R⁺ cells were detected between days 2 and 3 after both the first and second stimulations. Thus the first in vitro stimulation in the MLTC showed similar kinetics to those of the secondary MLC of unprimed individuals and to the primary MLC response of the allo-immunized individuals. The findings in the MLTC substantiate the hypothesis that cancer patients can be sensitized to their own tumors. The kinetics of the appearance of the IL-2R together with the characteristics of the IL-2-propagated cultures provide useful information for the strategy of expansion of auto-tumor reactive lymphocyte populations.