Lettuce mosaic virus pathogenicity determinants in susceptible and tolerant lettuce cultivars map to different regions of the viral genome

Full-length infectious cDNA clones were constructed for two isolates (LMV-0 and LMV-E) of Lettuce mosaic virus (LMV), a member of the genus Potyvirus. These two isolates differ in pathogenicity in susceptible and tolerant-resistant lettuce cultivars. In susceptible plants, LMV-0 induces mild mosaic symptoms, whereas LMV-E induces severe stunting, leaf deformation, and a necrotic mosaic. In plants carrying either of the two probably allelic recessive resistance genes mol1 or mol2, LMV-0 is restricted partially to the inoculated leaves. When a systemic invasion does occur, however, symptoms fail to develop. LMV-E overcomes the protection afforded by the resistance genes, resulting in systemic mosaic symptoms. Analysis of the behavior of recombinants constructed between the two virus isolates determined that the HC-Pro protein of LMV-E causes the severe stunting and necrotic mosaic induced by this isolate in susceptible cultivars. In contrast, the ability to overcome mol resistance and induce symptoms in the resistant-tolerant cultivars was mapped to the 3' half of the LMV-E genome. These results indicate that the ability to induce severe symptoms and to overcome the protection afforded by the recessive genes mol1 or mol2 are independent phenomena.     

Cytopathology of Mature Ovaries from Lettuce Plants Infected by Lettuce Mosaic Potyvirus

The location of lettuce mosaic potyvirus (LMV) in mature ovaries of lettuce plants ( Lactuca sativa ) was studied by conventional thin-section electron microscopy and immunogold cytochemistry. Flexuous filamentous particles and inclusion bodies characteristic of LMV infection were observed in the integumentary tapetum, integument and ovary wall of the mature ovary but not in the embryo sac.     

Cytopathology of Anthers and Pollen From Lettuce Plants Infected by Lettuce Mosaic Virus

Thin sections of mature anthers and pollen grains from three lettuce (Lactuca sativa) plants infected with lettuce mosaic potyvirus (LMV) were studied by immunogold labelling. Labelled LMV particles were present externally on the exine of pollen grains from all plants, but were observed internally in the pollen grains from only one plant. Within mature pollen grains the virus particles were associated with the cytoplasmic bundle inclusions typical of infection by potyviruses. The tapetal plasmodium and the epidermal and endothecial layers of mature anthers from all infected plants also contained labelled virus particles, together with pinwheel and bundle inclusions.     

Transposition of the maize autonomous element Activator in transgenic Nicotiana plumbaginifolia plants

The maize autonomous transposable element Ac was introduced into haploid Nicotiana plumbaginifolia via Agrobacterium tumefaciens transformation of leaf disks. All the regenerated transformants (R0) were diploid and either homozygous or heterozygous for the hygromycin resistance gene used to select primary transformants. The Ac excision frequency was determined using the phenotypic assay of restoration of neomycin phosphotransferase activity and expression of kanamycin resistance among progeny seedlings. Some of the R0 plants segregated kanamycin-resistant seedlings in selfed progeny at a high frequency (34 to 100%) and contained one or more transposed Ac elements. In the primary transformants Ac transposition probably occurred during plant regeneration or early development. Other R0 transformants segregated kanamycin-resistant plants at a low frequency (≤ 4%). Two transformants of this latter class, containing a unique unexcised Ac element, were chosen for further study in the expectation that their kanamycin resistant progeny would result from independent germinal transposition events. Southern blot analysis of 32 kanamycin-resistant plants (R1 or R2), selected after respectively one or two selfings of these primary transformants, showed that 27 had a transposed Ac at a new location and 5 did not have any Ac element. Transposed Ac copy number varied from one to six and almost all transposition events were independent. Southern analysis of the R2 and R3 progeny of these kanamycin-resistant plants showed that Ac continued to transpose during four generations, and its activity increased with its copy number. The frequency of Ac transposition, from different loci, remained low (≤ 7%) from R0 to R3 generations when only one Ac copy was present. The strategy of choosing R0 plants that undergo a low frequency of germinal excision will provide a means to avoid screening non-independent transpositions and increase the efficiency of transposon tagging.     

Multiple resistance phenotypes to Lettuce mosaic virus among Arabidopsis thaliana accessions

With the aim to characterize plant and viral factors involved in the molecular interactions between plants and potyviruses, a Lettuce mosaic virus (LMV)-Arabidopsis thaliana pathosystem was developed. Screening of Arabidopsis accessions with LMV isolates indicated the existence of a large variability in the outcome of the interaction, allowing the classification of Arabidopsis accessions into seven susceptibility groups. Using a reverse genetic approach, the genome-linked protein of LMV, a multifunctional protein shown to be involved in viral genome amplification and movement of potyviruses, was established as the viral determinant responsible for the ability to overcome the resistance of the Niederzenz accession to LMV-0. Preliminary genetic analyses from F2 and recombinant inbred lines available between susceptible and resistant Arabidopsis accessions revealed the existence of at least three resistance phenotypes to LMV with different genetic bases. One dominant resistance gene, designated LLM1, involved in blocking the replication or cell-to-cell movement of the LMV-0 isolate in the Columbia accession, was mapped to chromosome I and shown to be linked to the marker nga280. At the same time, genetic analyses of segregating F2 populations were consistent with the restriction of the systemic movement of the LMV-AF199 isolate in Columbia being controlled by two dominant genes and with the complete resistance to all tested LMV isolates of the Cape Verde islands (Cvi) accession being conferred by a single recessive resistance gene. Sequencing of the eukaryotic translation initiation factor 4E genes from the different LMV-resistant Arabidopsis accessions showed that these factors are not directly involved in the characterized resistance phenotypes.     

Transposition of the maize autonomous element Activator in transgenic Nicotiana plumbaginifolia plants

The maize autonomous transposable element Ac was introduced into haploid Nicotiana plumbaginifolia via Agrobacterium tumefaciens transformation of leaf disks. All the regenerated transformants (R0) were diploid and either homozygous or heterozygous for the hygromycin resistance gene used to select primary transformants. The Ac excision frequency was determined using the phenotypic assay of restoration of neomycin phosphotransferase activity and expression of kanamycin resistance among progeny seedlings. Some of the R0 plants segregated kanamycin-resistant seedlings in selfed progeny at a high frequency (34 to 100%) and contained one or more transposed Ac elements. In the primary transformants Ac transposition probably occurred during plant regeneration or early development. Other R0 transformants segregated kanamycin-resistant plants at a low frequency ( 4%). Two transformants of this latter class, containing a unique unexcised Ac element, were chosen for further study in the expectation that their kanamycin resistant progeny would result from independent germinal transposition events. Southern blot analysis of 32 kanamycin-resistant plants (R1 or R2), selected after respectively one or two selfings of these primary transformants, showed that 27 had a transposed Ac at a new location and 5 did not have any Ac element. Transposed Ac copy number varied from one to six and almost all transposition events were independent. Southern analysis of the R2 and R3 progeny of these kanamycin-resistant plants showed that Ac continued to transpose during four generations, and its activity increased with its copy number. The frequency of Ac transposition, from different loci, remained low ( 7%) from R0 to R3 generations when only one Ac copy was present. The strategy of choosing R0 plants that undergo a low frequency of germinal excision will provide a means to avoid screening non-independent transpositions and increase the efficiency of transposon tagging.     

The eukaryotic translation initiation factor 4E controls lettuce susceptibility to the Potyvirus Lettuce mosaic virus

The eIF4E and eIF(iso)4E cDNAs from several genotypes of lettuce (Lactuca sativa) that are susceptible, tolerant, or resistant to infection by Lettuce mosaic virus (LMV; genus Potyvirus) were cloned and sequenced. Although Ls-eIF(iso)4E was monomorphic in sequence, three types of Ls-eIF4E differed by point sequence variations, and a short in-frame deletion in one of them. The amino acid variations specific to Ls-eIF4E(1) and Ls-eIF4E(2) were predicted to be located near the cap recognition pocket in a homology-based tridimensional protein model. In 19 lettuce genotypes, including two near-isogenic pairs, there was a strict correlation between these three allelic types and the presence or absence of the recessive LMV resistance genes mo1(1) and mo1(2). Ls-eIF4E(1) and mo1(1) cosegregated in the progeny of two separate crosses between susceptible genotypes and an mo1(1) genotype. Finally, transient ectopic expression of Ls-eIF4E restored systemic accumulation of a green fluorescent protein-tagged LMV in LMV-resistant mo1(2) plants and a recombinant LMV expressing Ls-eIF4E degrees from its genome, but not Ls-eIF4E(1) or Ls-eIF(iso)4E, accumulated and produced symptoms in mo1(1) or mo1(2) genotypes. Therefore, sequence correlation, tight genetic linkage, and functional complementation strongly suggest that eIF4E plays a role in the LMV cycle in lettuce and that mo1(1) and mo1(2) are alleles coding for forms of eIF4E unable or less effective to fulfill this role. More generally, the isoforms of eIF4E appear to be host factors involved in the cycle of potyviruses in plants, probably through a general mechanism yet to be clarified.     

Plum pox potyvirus resistance associated to transgene silencing that can be stabilized after different number of plant generations

Nicotiana benthamiana plants were transformed with a fragment of the plum pox potyvirus (PPV) genome that encodes the nuclear inclusion a (NIa) and b (NIb) proteins and the N-terminus of the capsid protein (NIa–NIb–CP*). Lines transformed with this PPV genomic fragment harboring mutations in the GDD replicase-motif were also obtained. Plants of NIaΔV lines that carry a GDD to VDD mutation in the PPV transgene, were immune to PPV infection. The resistance was highly specific, since it was only partially overcome by a PPV strain different to that from which the transgene was derived, and no resistance was observed after inoculation with a second potyvirus. PPV was not able to replicate in protoplasts isolated from NIaΔV transgenic plants, indicating that the resistance was functional at the single cell level. Only a fraction of plants from lines transformed with the NIa–NIb–CP* fragment harboring a GDD to ADD mutation (NIaΔA lines), were resistant to PPV infection. This same phenotype was observed in plants expressing the wild-type construction (NIaΔ), although the progeny of some non-infected plants seemed to be completely resistant to PPV, independently of the allelic status of the parental plant. In all cases, the resistance phenotype correlated positively with low levels of transgene mRNA accumulation, suggesting that it was mainly due to a gene silencing mechanism. Our results show that, although the transgene was not silenced in all R1 plants from some individual lines, a stable silenced status could be reached in the following generations.     

Extreme resistance to cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) in transgenic tomato expressing one or two viral coat proteins

For the production of broad commercial resistance to cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) infection, tomato plants were transformed with a combination of two coat protein (CP) genes, representing both subgroups of CMV. The CP genes were cloned from the CMV-D strain and Italian CMV isolates (CMV-22 of subgroup I and CMV-PG of subgroup II) which have been shown to produce severe disease symptoms. Four plant transformation vectors were constructed: pMON18774 and pMON18775 (CMV-D CP), pMON18831 (CMV-PG CP) and pMON18833 (CMV-22 CP and CMV-PG CP). Transformed R0 plants were produced and lines were selected based on the combination of three traits: CMV CP expression at the R0 stage, resistance to CMV (subgroup I and/or II) infection in growth chamber tests in R1 expressing plants, and single transgene copy, based on R1 segregation. The results indicate that all four vector constructs generated plants with extremely high resistant to CMV infection. The single and double gene vector construct produced plants with broad resistance against strains of CMV from both subgroups I and II at high frequency. The engineered resistance is of practical value and will be applied for major Italian tomato varieties. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Cytopathology of Lettuce Mosaic Virus-infected Lettuce Seeds and Seedlings

The ultrastructure of lettuce mosaic potyvirus (LMV)-infected lettuce seeds and seedlings was studied by transmission electron microscopy. Conventional thin-section electron microscopy and immunogold cytochemistry were both successfully employed to study the location of LMV in embryonic and non-embryonic seed parts. LMV particle aggregates and cytoplasmic “pinwheel” inclusions characteristic of potyviruses were observed throughout the embryonic tissues (radicle, hypocotyl and cotyledon) of infected lettuce seeds and seedlings, and also in the non-embryonic endosperm layer. LMV particles, but not inclusions, were also located in the non-embryonic pericarp layer.     

Expression of Multiple Virus-derived Resistance Determinants in Transgenic Plants Does Not Lead to Additive Resistance Properties

Plants can be protected against infection by potyviruses by expressing different portions of potyviral genomes as transgenes. This strategy has proven effective with several potyvirus genes, including the Nla, Nlb, and coat protein coding regions. Given the effectiveness of separate potyvirus coding regions as determinants of resistance, we tested the hypothesis that combinations of potyvirus coding regions would provide additively greater protection of plants against potyviruses. For this, we compared transgenic plant lines that expressed either the coat protein (CP) or the Nla+Nlb+coat protein (NNC) coding regions from tobacco vein mottling virus (TVMV). We found that plants that carry the NNC gene combination were invariably less resistant to TVMV than were lines that contain a CP gene alone. Additionally, we found that NNC lines displayed virtually no resistance to tobacco etch virus (TEV), in contrast to the CP lines. We conclude that combining more than one virus-derived resistance determinant in a single construct is detrimental to the production of virus-resistant plants.     

The Response of Lettuce Cultivars against Two Lettuce mosaic virus isolates,One Able to Systemically Infect the Resistant Cultivar Salinas 88

The response of seven lettuce cultivars to two geographically different Lettuce mosaic virus (LMV) isolates (LMV‐A, LMV‐T) was statistically evaluated based on infection rate, virus accumulation and symptom severity in different time trials. LMV‐A is characterized by the ability to systemically infect cv. Salinas 88 (mo1²‐carrying resistant cultivar), and inducing mild mosaic symptoms. Among lettuce cultivars, Varamin (a native cultivar) similar to cv. Salinas showed the most susceptibility to both LMV isolates, whereas another native cultivar, Varesh, was tolerant to the virus with minimal viral accumulation and symptom scores, significantly different from other cultivars at P < 0.05. LMV‐A systemically infects all susceptible lettuce cultivars more rapidly and at a higher rate than LMV‐T. This isolate accumulated in lettuce cultivars at a significantly higher level, determined by semiquantitative ELISA and induced more severe symptoms than LMV‐T isolate at 21 dpi. This is the first evidence for a LMV isolate with ability to systemically infect mo1²‐carrying resistant cultivar of lettuce from Iran. In this study, accumulation level of LMV showed statistically meaningful positive correlation with symptom severity on lettuce plants. Based on the results, three evaluated parameters differed considerably by lettuce cultivar and virus isolate.     

Resistance phenotypes of transgenic tobacco plants expressing different cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) coat protein genes

Tobacco plants expressing a transgene encoding the coat protein (CP) of a subgroup I strain of cucumber mosaic cucumovirus (CMV), I17F, were not resistant to strains of either subgroup I or II. In contrast, the expression of the CP of a subgroup II strain, R, conferred substantial resistance, but only towards strains of the same subgroup. When protection was observed, the levels of resistance were similar when plants were inoculated with either virions or viral RNA, but resistance was more effective when plants were inoculated with viruliferous aphids. Resistance was not dependent on inoculum strength and was expressed as a recovery phenotype not yet described for plants expressing a CMV CP gene. Recovery could be observed either early in infection (less than one week after inoculation) or later (4 to 5 weeks after inoculation). In plants showing early recovery, mild symptoms were observed on the inoculated leaves, and in some cases symptoms developed on certain lower systemically infected leaves, but the upper leaves were symptomless and virus-free. Late recovery corresponded to the absence of both symptoms and virus in the upper leaves of plants that were previously fully infected. Northern blot analyses of resistant plants suggested that a gene silencing mechanism was not involved in the resistance observed.     

Complete resistance to pepper mild mottle tobamovirus mediated by viral replicase sequences partially depends on transgene homozygosity and is based on a gene silencing mechanism

We have previously distinguished two different types of resistance response, complete and delayed, to the pepper mild mottle tobamovirus (PMMoV) in Nicotiana benthamiana plants transformed with the 54kDa region of the viral replicase gene. The present study was undertaken to assess a potential relationship between transgene dose and the type of resistance observed in the 54kDa transgenic plants. By genetic and molecular analysis, we demonstrated that complete resistance against PMMoV infection was strictly correlated with homozygosity of the transgene in the R1 and R2 generation plants. Progeny hemizygous for the TDNA locus showed delayed resistance, but none of the progeny exhibited the complete resistance response. Thus, the resistance to PMMoV varied in a gene dosagedependent manner. However, a limited number of individuals of the R2 progeny from homozygous plants displayed complete resistance, while the remaining plants showed delayed resistanc; the ratio between the two resistance responses was roughly similar to the ratio observed in either the R2 progeny from hemizygous plants or the original R1 generation plants. R2 homozygous plants displaying complete resistance contained undetectable levels of 54kDa mRNA, although the transgene was accurately transcribed in these plants. These results suggest that transgene homozygosity is a necessary but not a sufficient condition to confer complete resistance to PMMoV by a gene silencing mechanism.     

Engineered resistance against plant virus diseases

The development of genetic engineering techniques has enabled the production of transgenic plants that are resistant to viral diseases. Expressing the coat protein (CP) gene of a virus in Iransgenic plants confers resistance against the virus from which the gene was isolated, and to other closely related strains and viruses. This approach has been demonstrated to be effective in conferring protection against viruses from different virus groups including alfalfa mosaic virus, cucumovirus. ilarvirus, potex-virus, potyvirus, tobamovirus and tobravirus. The data available indicate that several factors may affect the efficiency of the protection obtained including the level of the CP in the transgenic plants, the plant in which the CP gene is expressed and enviromental conditions. These and other aspects of coat protein mediated resistance are discussed.