The interaction of alphavirus E1 protein with exogenous domain III defines stages in virus-membrane fusion

Alphaviruses such as Semliki Forest virus (SFV) are enveloped viruses that infect cells through a low-pH-triggered membrane fusion reaction mediated by the transmembrane fusion protein E1. E1 drives fusion by insertion of its hydrophobic fusion loop into the cell membrane and refolding to a stable trimeric hairpin. In this postfusion conformation, the immunoglobulin-like domain III (DIII) and the stem region pack against the central core of the trimer. Membrane fusion and infection can be specifically inhibited by exogenous DIII, which binds to an intermediate in the E1 refolding pathway. Here we characterized the properties of the E1 target for interaction with exogenous DIII. The earliest target for DIII binding was an extended membrane-inserted E1 trimer, which was not detectable by assays for the stable postfusion hairpin. DIII binding provided a tool to detect this extended trimer and to define a series of SFV fusion-block mutants. DIII binding studies showed that the mutants were blocked in distinct steps in fusion protein refolding. Our results suggested that formation of the initial extended trimer was reversible and that it was stabilized by the progressive fold-back of the DIII and stem regions.     

Mutational analysis of the zippering reaction during flavivirus membrane fusion

The current model of flavivirus membrane fusion is based on atomic structures of truncated forms of the viral fusion protein E in its dimeric prefusion and trimeric postfusion conformations. These structures lack the two transmembrane domains (TMDs) of E as well as the so-called stem, believed to be involved in an intra- and intermolecular zippering reaction within the E trimer during the fusion process. In order to gain experimental evidence for the functional role of the stem in flavivirus membrane fusion, we performed a mutagenesis study with recombinant subviral particles (RSPs) of tick-borne encephalitis virus, which have fusion properties similar to those of whole infectious virions and are an established model for viral fusion. Mutations were introduced into the stem as well as that part of E predicted to interact with the stem during zippering, and the effect of these mutations was analyzed with respect to fusion peptide interactions with target cells, E protein trimerization, trimer stability, and membrane fusion in an in vitro liposome fusion assay. Our data provide evidence for a molecular interaction between a conserved phenylalanine at the N-terminal end of the stem and a pocket in domain II of E, which appears to be essential for the positioning of the stem in an orientation that allows zippering and the formation of a structure in which the TMDs can interact as required for efficient fusion.     

Structural requirements for low-pH-induced rearrangements in the envelope glycoprotein of tick-borne encephalitis virus.

The exposure of the flavivirus tick-borne encephalitis (TBE) virus to an acidic pH is necessary for virus-induced membrane fusion and leads to a quantitative and irreversible conversion of the envelope protein E dimers to trimers. To study the structural requirements for this oligomeric rearrangement, the effect of low-pH treatment on the oligomeric state of different isolated forms of protein E was investigated. Full-length E dimers obtained by solubilization of virus with the detergent Triton X-100 formed trimers at low pH, whereas truncated E dimers lacking the stem-anchor region underwent a reversible dissociation into monomers without forming trimers. These data suggest that the low-pH-induced rearrangement in virions is a two-step process involving a reversible dissociation of the E dimers followed by an irreversible formation of trimers, a process which requires the stem-anchor portion of the protein. This region contains potential amphipathic alpha-helical and conserved structural elements whose interactions may contribute to the rearrangements which initiate the fusion process.     

The domain I-domain III linker plays an important role in the fusogenic conformational change of the alphavirus membrane fusion protein

The alphavirus Semliki Forest virus (SFV) infects cells through a low-pH-dependent membrane fusion reaction mediated by the virus fusion protein E1. Acidic pH initiates a series of E1 conformational changes that culminate in membrane fusion and include dissociation of the E1/E2 heterodimer, insertion of the E1 fusion loop into the target membrane, and refolding of E1 to a stable trimeric hairpin conformation. A highly conserved histidine (H3) on the E1 protein was previously shown to promote low-pH-dependent E1 refolding. An SFV mutant with an alanine substitution at this position (H3A) has a lower pH threshold and reduced efficiency of virus fusion and E1 trimer formation than wild-type SFV. Here we addressed the mechanism by which H3 promotes E1 refolding and membrane fusion. We identified E1 mutations that rescue the H3A defect. These revertants implicated a network of interactions that connect the domain I-domain III (DI-DIII) linker region with the E1 core trimer, including H3. In support of the importance of these interactions, mutation of residues in the network resulted in more acidic pH thresholds and reduced efficiencies of membrane fusion. In vitro studies of truncated E1 proteins demonstrated that the DI-DIII linker was required for production of a stable E1 core trimer on target membranes. Together, our results suggest a critical and previously unidentified role for the DI-DIII linker region during the low-pH-dependent refolding of E1 that drives membrane fusion.     

Membrane interactions of the tick-borne encephalitis virus fusion protein E at low pH

Membrane fusion of the flavivirus tick-borne encephalitis virus is triggered by the mildly acidic pH of the endosome and is mediated by envelope protein E, a class II viral fusion protein. The low-pH trigger induces an oligomeric rearrangement in which the subunits of the native E homodimers dissociate and the monomeric subunits then reassociate into homotrimers. Here we provide evidence that membrane binding is mediated by the intermediate monomeric form of E, generated by low-pH-induced dissociation of the dimer. Liposome coflotation experiments revealed that association with target membranes occurred only when liposomes were present at the time of acidification, whereas pretreating virions at low pH in the absence of membranes resulted in the loss of their ability to stably attach to liposomes. With the cleavable cross-linker ethylene glycolbis(succinimidylsuccinate), it was shown that a truncated soluble form of the E protein (sE) could bind to membranes only when the dimers were free to dissociate at low pH, and binding could be blocked by a monoclonal antibody that recognizes the fusion peptide, which is at the distal tip of the E monomer but is buried in the native dimer. Surprisingly, analysis of the membrane-associated sE proteins revealed that they had formed trimers. This was unexpected because this protein lacks a sequence element in the C-terminal stem-anchor region, which was shown to be essential for trimerization in the absence of a target membrane. It can therefore be concluded that the formation of a trimeric form of sE is facilitated by membrane binding. Its stability is apparently maintained by contacts between the ectodomains only and is not dependent on sequence elements in the stem-anchor region as previously assumed.     

Site-directed antibodies against the stem region reveal low pH-induced conformational changes of the Semliki Forest virus fusion protein

The E1 envelope protein of the alphavirus Semliki Forest virus (SFV) is a class II fusion protein that mediates low pH-triggered membrane fusion during virus infection. Like other class I and class II fusion proteins, during fusion E1 inserts into the target membrane and rearranges to form a trimeric hairpin structure. The postfusion structures of the alphavirus and flavivirus fusion proteins suggest that the "stem" region connecting the fusion protein domain III to the transmembrane domain interacts along the trimer core during the low pH-induced conformational change. However, the location of the E1 stem in the SFV particle and its rearrangement and functional importance during fusion are not known. We developed site-directed polyclonal antibodies to the N- or C-terminal regions of the SFV E1 stem and used them to study the stem during fusion. The E1 stem was hidden on neutral pH virus but became accessible after low pH-triggered dissociation of the E2/E1 heterodimer. The stem packed onto the trimer core in the postfusion conformation and became inaccessible to antibody binding. Generation of the E1 homotrimer on fusion-incompetent membranes identified an intermediate conformation in which domain III had folded back but stem packing was incomplete. Our data suggest that E1 hairpin formation occurs by the sequential packing of domain III and the stem onto the trimer core and indicate a tight correlation between stem packing and membrane merger.     

Structure of a flavivirus envelope glycoprotein in its low-pH-induced membrane fusion conformation

Enveloped viruses enter cells via a membrane fusion reaction driven by conformational changes of specific viral envelope proteins. We report here the structure of the ectodomain of the tick-borne encephalitis virus envelope glycoprotein, E, a prototypical class II fusion protein, in its trimeric low-pH-induced conformation. We show that, in the conformational transition, the three domains of the neutral-pH form are maintained but their relative orientation is altered. Similar to the postfusion class I proteins, the subunits rearrange such that the fusion peptide loops cluster at one end of an elongated molecule and the C-terminal segments, connecting to the viral transmembrane region, run along the sides of the trimer pointing toward the fusion peptide loops. Comparison with the low-pH-induced form of the alphavirus class II fusion protein reveals striking differences at the end of the molecule bearing the fusion peptides, suggesting an important conformational effect of the missing membrane connecting segment.     

Characterization of a structural intermediate of flavivirus membrane fusion

Viral membrane fusion proceeds through a sequence of steps that are driven by triggered conformational changes of viral envelope glycoproteins, so-called fusion proteins. Although high-resolution structural snapshots of viral fusion proteins in their prefusion and postfusion conformations are available, it has been difficult to define intermediate structures of the fusion pathway because of their transient nature. Flaviviruses possess a class II viral fusion protein (E) mediating fusion at acidic pH that is converted from a dimer to a trimer with a hairpin-like structure during the fusion process. Here we show for tick-borne encephalitis virus that exposure of virions to alkaline instead of acidic pH traps the particles in an intermediate conformation in which the E dimers dissociate and interact with target membranes via the fusion peptide without proceeding to the merger of the membranes. Further treatment to low pH, however, leads to fusion, suggesting that these monomers correspond to an as-yet-elusive intermediate required to convert the prefusion dimer into the postfusion trimer. Thus, the use of nonphysiological conditions allows a dissection of the flavivirus fusion process and the identification of two separate steps, in which membrane insertion of multiple copies of E monomers precedes the formation of hairpin-like trimers. This sequence of events provides important new insights for understanding the dynamic process of viral membrane fusion.     

Structure of respiratory syncytial virus fusion glycoprotein in the postfusion conformation reveals preservation of neutralizing epitopes

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) invades host cells via a type I fusion (F) glycoprotein that undergoes dramatic structural rearrangements during the fusion process. Neutralizing monoclonal antibodies, such as 101F, palivizumab, and motavizumab, target two major antigenic sites on the RSV F glycoprotein. The structures of these sites as peptide complexes with motavizumab and 101F have been previously determined, but a structure for the trimeric RSV F glycoprotein ectodomain has remained elusive. To address this issue, we undertook structural and biophysical studies on stable ectodomain constructs. Here, we present the 2.8-Å crystal structure of the trimeric RSV F ectodomain in its postfusion conformation. The structure revealed that the 101F and motavizumab epitopes are present in the postfusion state and that their conformations are similar to those observed in the antibody-bound peptide structures. Both antibodies bound the postfusion F glycoprotein with high affinity in surface plasmon resonance experiments. Modeling of the antibodies bound to the F glycoprotein predicts that the 101F epitope is larger than the linear peptide and restricted to a single protomer in the trimer, whereas motavizumab likely contacts residues on two protomers, indicating a quaternary epitope. Mechanistically, these results suggest that 101F and motavizumab can bind to multiple conformations of the fusion glycoprotein and can neutralize late in the entry process. The structural preservation of neutralizing epitopes in the postfusion state suggests that this conformation can elicit neutralizing antibodies and serve as a useful vaccine antigen.     

Mutations in the Parainfluenza Virus 5 Fusion Protein Reveal Domains Important for Fusion Triggering and Metastability

Paramyxovirus membrane glycoproteins F (fusion protein) and HN, H, or G (attachment protein) are critical for virus entry, which occurs through fusion of viral and cellular envelopes. The F protein folds into a homotrimeric, metastable prefusion form that can be triggered by the attachment protein to undergo a series of structural rearrangements, ultimately folding into a stable postfusion form. In paramyxovirus-infected cells, the F protein is activated in the Golgi apparatus by cleavage adjacent to a hydrophobic fusion peptide that inserts into the target membrane, eventually bringing the membranes together by F refolding. However, it is not clear how the attachment protein, known as HN in parainfluenza virus 5 (PIV5), interacts with F and triggers F to initiate fusion. To understand the roles of various F protein domains in fusion triggering and metastability, single point mutations were introduced into the PIV5 F protein. By extensive study of F protein cleavage activation, surface expression, and energetics of fusion triggering, we found a role for an immunoglobulin-like (Ig-like) domain, where multiple hydrophobic residues on the PIV5 F protein may mediate F-HN interactions. Additionally, destabilizing mutations of PIV5 F that resulted in HN trigger-independent mutant F proteins were identified in a region along the border of F trimer subunits. The positions of the potential HN-interacting region and the region important for F stability in the lower part of the PIV5 F prefusion structure provide clues to the receptor-binding initiated, HN-mediated F trigger.     

Small-Molecule Inhibitors of Dengue-Virus Entry

Flavivirus envelope protein (E) mediates membrane fusion and viral entry from endosomes. A low-pH induced, dimer-to-trimer rearrangement and reconfiguration of the membrane-proximal “stem" of the E ectodomain draw together the viral and cellular membranes. We found stem-derived peptides from dengue virus (DV) bind stem-less E trimer and mimic the stem-reconfiguration step in the fusion pathway. We adapted this experiment as a high-throughput screen for small molecules that block peptide binding and thus may inhibit viral entry. A compound identified in this screen, 1662G07, and a number of its analogs reversibly inhibit DV infectivity. They do so by binding the prefusion, dimeric E on the virion surface, before adsorption to a cell. They also block viral fusion with liposomes. Structure-activity relationship studies have led to analogs with submicromolar IC₉₀s against DV2, and certain analogs are active against DV serotypes 1,2, and 4. The compounds do not inhibit the closely related Kunjin virus. We propose that they bind in a previously identified, E-protein pocket, exposed on the virion surface and although this pocket is closed in the postfusion trimer, its mouth is fully accessible. Examination of the E-trimer coordinates (PDB 1OK8) shows that conformational fluctuations around the hinge could open the pocket without dissociating the trimer or otherwise generating molecular collisions. We propose that compounds such as 1662G07 trap the sE trimer in a “pocket-open" state, which has lost affinity for the stem peptide and cannot support the final “zipping up" of the stem.     

Purification and crystallization reveal two types of interactions of the fusion protein homotrimer of Semliki Forest virus

The fusion proteins of the alphaviruses and flaviviruses have a similar native structure and convert to a highly stable homotrimer conformation during the fusion of the viral and target membranes. The properties of the alpha- and flavivirus fusion proteins distinguish them from the class I viral fusion proteins, such as influenza virus hemagglutinin, and establish them as the first members of the class II fusion proteins. Understanding how this new class carries out membrane fusion will require analysis of the structural basis for both the interaction of the protein subunits within the homotrimer and their interaction with the viral and target membranes. To this end we report a purification method for the E1 ectodomain homotrimer from the alphavirus Semliki Forest virus. The purified protein is trimeric, detergent soluble, retains the characteristic stability of the starting homotrimer, and is free of lipid and other contaminants. In contrast to the postfusion structures that have been determined for the class I proteins, the E1 homotrimer contains the fusion peptide region responsible for interaction with target membranes. This E1 trimer preparation is an excellent candidate for structural studies of the class II viral fusion proteins, and we report conditions that generate three-dimensional crystals suitable for analysis by X-ray diffraction. Determination of the structure will provide our first high-resolution views of both the low-pH-induced trimeric conformation and the target membrane-interacting region of the alphavirus fusion protein.     

Functions of the stem region of the Semliki Forest virus fusion protein during virus fusion and assembly

Membrane fusion of the alphaviruses is mediated by the E1 protein, a class II virus membrane fusion protein. During fusion, E1 dissociates from its heterodimer interaction with the E2 protein and forms a target membrane-inserted E1 homotrimer. The structure of the homotrimer is that of a trimeric hairpin in which E1 domain III and the stem region fold back toward the target membrane-inserted fusion peptide loop. The E1 stem region has a strictly conserved length and several highly conserved residues, suggesting the possibility of specific stem interactions along the trimer core and an important role in driving membrane fusion. Mutagenesis studies of the alphavirus Semliki Forest virus (SFV) here demonstrated that there was a strong requirement for the E1 stem in virus assembly and budding, probably reflecting its importance in lateral interactions of the envelope proteins. Surprisingly, however, neither the conserved length nor any specific residues of the stem were required for membrane fusion. Although the highest fusion activity was observed with wild-type E1, efficient fusion was mediated by stem mutants containing a variety of substitutions or deletions. A minimal stem length was required but could be conferred by a series of alanine residues. The lack of a specific stem sequence requirement during SFV fusion suggests that the interaction of domain III with the trimer core can provide sufficient driving force to mediate membrane merger.     

Molecular determinants of antiviral potency of paramyxovirus entry inhibitors

Hendra virus (HeV) and Nipah virus (NiV) constitute the Henipavirus genus of paramyxoviruses, both fatal in humans and with the potential for subversion as agents of bioterrorism. Binding of the HeV/NiV attachment protein (G) to its receptor triggers a series of conformational changes in the fusion protein (F), ultimately leading to formation of a postfusion six-helix bundle (6HB) structure and fusion of the viral and cellular membranes. The ectodomain of paramyxovirus F proteins contains two conserved heptad repeat regions, the first (the N-terminal heptad repeat [HRN]) adjacent to the fusion peptide and the second (the C-terminal heptad repeat [HRC]) immediately preceding the transmembrane domain. Peptides derived from the HRN and HRC regions of F are proposed to inhibit fusion by preventing activated F molecules from forming the 6HB structure that is required for fusion. We previously reported that a human parainfluenza virus 3 (HPIV3) F peptide effectively inhibits infection mediated by the HeV glycoproteins in pseudotyped-HeV entry assays more effectively than the comparable HeV-derived peptide, and we now show that this peptide inhibits live-HeV and -NiV infection. HPIV3 F peptides were also effective in inhibiting HeV pseudotype virus entry in a new assay that mimics multicycle replication. This anti-HeV/NiV efficacy can be correlated with the greater potential of the HPIV3 C peptide to interact with the HeV F N peptide coiled-coil trimer, as evaluated by thermal unfolding experiments. Furthermore, replacement of a buried glutamic acid (glutamic acid 459) in the C peptide with valine enhances antiviral potency and stabilizes the 6HB conformation. Our results strongly suggest that conserved interhelical packing interactions in the F protein fusion core are important determinants of C peptide inhibitory activity and offer a strategy for the development of more-potent analogs of F peptide inhibitors.     

Structural characterization of an early fusion intermediate of influenza virus hemagglutinin

The hemagglutinin (HA) envelope protein of influenza virus mediates viral entry through membrane fusion in the acidic environment of the endosome. Crystal structures of HA in pre- and postfusion states have laid the foundation for proposals for a general fusion mechanism for viral envelope proteins. The large-scale conformational rearrangement of HA at low pH is triggered by a loop-to-helix transition of an interhelical loop (B loop) within the fusion domain and is often referred to as the "spring-loaded" mechanism. Although the receptor-binding HA1 subunit is believed to act as a "clamp" to keep the B loop in its metastable prefusion state at neutral pH, the "pH sensors" that are responsible for the clamp release and the ensuing structural transitions have remained elusive. Here we identify a mutation in the HA2 fusion domain from the influenza virus H2 subtype that stabilizes the HA trimer in a prefusion-like state at and below fusogenic pH. Crystal structures of this putative early intermediate state reveal reorganization of ionic interactions at the HA1-HA2 interface at acidic pH and deformation of the HA1 membrane-distal domain. Along with neutralization of glutamate residues on the B loop, these changes cause a rotation of the B loop and solvent exposure of conserved phenylalanines, which are key residues at the trimer interface of the postfusion structure. Thus, our study reveals the possible initial structural event that leads to release of the B loop from its prefusion conformation, which is aided by unexpected structural changes within the membrane-distal HA1 domain at low pH.     

A conserved region in the F(2) subunit of paramyxovirus fusion proteins is involved in fusion regulation

Paramyxoviruses utilize both an attachment protein and a fusion (F) protein to drive virus-cell and cell-cell fusion. F exists functionally as a trimer of two disulfide-linked subunits: F(1) and F(2). Alignment and analysis of a set of paramyxovirus F protein sequences identified three conserved blocks (CB): one in the fusion peptide/heptad repeat A domain, known to play important roles in fusion promotion, one in the region between the heptad repeats of F(1) (CBF(1)) (A. E. Gardner, K. L. Martin, and R. E. Dutch, Biochemistry 46:5094-5105, 2007), and one in the F(2) subunit (CBF(2)). To analyze the functions of CBF(2), alanine substitutions at conserved positions were created in both the simian virus 5 (SV5) and Hendra virus F proteins. A number of the CBF(2) mutations resulted in folding and expression defects. However, the CBF(2) mutants that were properly expressed and trafficked had altered fusion promotion activity. The Hendra virus CBF(2) Y79A and P89A mutants showed significantly decreased levels of fusion, whereas the SV5 CBF(2) I49A mutant exhibited greatly increased cell-cell fusion relative to that for wild-type F. Additional substitutions at SV5 F I49 suggest that both side chain volume and hydrophobicity at this position are important in the folding of the metastable, prefusion state and the subsequent triggering of membrane fusion. The recently published prefusogenic structure of parainfluenza virus 5/SV5 F (H. S. Yin et al., Nature 439:38-44, 2006) places CBF(2) in direct contact with heptad repeat A. Our data therefore indicate that this conserved region plays a critical role in stabilizing the prefusion state, likely through interactions with heptad repeat A, and in triggering membrane fusion.     

Identification of a specific region in the e1 fusion protein involved in zinc inhibition of semliki forest virus fusion

The enveloped alphaviruses infect cells via a low-pH-triggered membrane fusion reaction mediated by the viral transmembrane protein E1. During fusion, E1 inserts into the target membrane and refolds to a hairpin-like postfusion conformation in which domain III (DIII) and the juxtamembrane stem pack against a central core trimer. Although zinc has previously been shown to cause a striking block in alphavirus fusion with liposome target membranes, the mechanism of zinc's effect on the E1 fusion protein is not understood. Here we developed a cell culture system to study zinc inhibition of fusion and infection of the alphavirus Semliki Forest virus (SFV). Inclusion of 2 mM ZnCl(2) in the pH 5.75 fusion buffer caused a decrease of ～5 logs in SFV fusion at the plasma membrane. Fusion was also inhibited by nickel, a chemically related transition metal. Selection for SFV zinc resistance identified a key histidine residue, H333 on E1 DIII, while other conserved E1 histidine residues were not involved. An H333N mutation conferred resistance to both zinc and nickel, with properties in keeping with the known pH-dependent chelation of these metals by histidine. Biochemical studies demonstrated that zinc strongly inhibits formation of the postfusion E1 trimer in wild-type SFV but not in an H333 mutant. Together our results suggest that zinc acts by blocking the fold-back of DIII via its interaction with H333.     

Mapping of Functional Elements in the Stem-Anchor Region of Tick-Borne Encephalitis Virus Envelope Protein E

Envelope protein E of the flavivirus tick-borne encephalitis virus mediates membrane fusion, and the structure of the N-terminal 80% of this 496-amino-acid-long protein has been shown to differ significantly from that of other viral fusion proteins. The structure of the carboxy-terminal 20%, the stem-anchor region, is not known. It contains sequences that are important for membrane anchoring, interactions with prM (the precursor of membrane protein M) during virion assembly, and low-pH-induced structural changes associated with the fusion process. To identify specific functional elements in this region, a series of C-terminal deletion mutants were constructed and the properties of the resulting truncated recombinant E proteins were examined. Full-length E proteins and proteins lacking the second of two predicted transmembrane segments were secreted in a particulate form when coexpressed with prM, whereas deletion of both segments resulted in the secretion of soluble homodimeric E proteins. Sites located within a predicted alpha-helical region of the stem (amino acids 431 to 449) and the first membrane-spanning region (amino acids 450 to 472) were found to be important for the stability of the prM-E heterodimer but not essential for prM-mediated intracellular transport and secretion of soluble E proteins. A separate site in the stem, also corresponding to a predicted alpha-helix (amino acids 401 to 413), was essential for the conversion of soluble protein E dimers to a homotrimeric form upon low-pH treatment, a process resembling the transition to the fusogenic state in whole virions. This functional mapping will aid in the understanding of the molecular mechanisms of membrane fusion and virus assembly.     

Structure of a Dengue Virus Envelope Protein Late-Stage Fusion Intermediate

The final stages of dengue virus fusion are thought to occur when the membrane-proximal stem drives the transmembrane anchor of the viral envelope protein (E) toward the fusion loop, buried in the target cell membrane. Crystal structures of E have lacked this essential stem region. We expressed and crystallized soluble mutant forms of the dengue virus envelope protein (sE) that include portions of the juxtamembrane stem. Their structures represent late-stage fusion intermediates. The proximal part of the stem has both intra- and intermolecular interactions, so the chain “zips up” along the trimer seam. The penultimate interaction we detected involves the conserved residue F402, which has hydrophobic contacts with a conserved surface on domain II. These interactions do not require any larger-scale changes in trimer packing. The techniques for expression and crystallization of sE containing stem reported here may allow further characterization of the final stages of flavivirus fusion.     

Pseudorevertants of a Semliki Forest Virus Fusion-Blocking Mutation Reveal a Critical Interchain Interaction in the Core Trimer

Semliki Forest virus (SFV) is an enveloped alphavirus that infects cells by a low-pH-triggered membrane fusion reaction mediated by the viral E1 protein. E1 inserts into target membranes and refolds to a hairpin-like homotrimer containing a central core trimer and an outer layer composed of domain III and the juxtamembrane stem region. The key residues involved in mediating E1 trimerization are not well understood. We recently showed that aspartate 188 in the interface of the core trimer plays a critical role. Substitution with lysine (D188K) blocks formation of the core trimer and E1 trimerization and strongly inhibits virus fusion and infection. Here, we have isolated and characterized revertants that rescued the fusion and growth defects of D188K. These revertants included pseudorevertants containing acidic or polar neutral residues at E1 position 188 and a second-site revertant containing an E1 K176T mutation. Computational analysis using multiconformation continuum electrostatics revealed an important interaction bridging D188 of one chain with K176 of the adjacent chain in the core trimer. E1 K176 is completely conserved among the alphaviruses, and mutations of K176 to threonine (K176T) or isoleucine (K176I) produced similar fusion phenotypes as D188 mutants. Together, our data support a model in which a ring of three salt bridges formed by D188 and K176 stabilize the core trimer, a key intermediate of the alphavirus fusion protein.Enveloped viruses contain a phospholipid bilayer that surrounds and protects the viral genome until fusion of the virus and host membranes delivers the genome into the cytoplasm. Fusion is mediated by transmembrane fusion proteins in the virus envelope. Viruses have evolved specific mechanisms to trigger membrane fusion upon interaction with the host cell (15, 42). For example, the fusion protein of the human immunodeficiency virus is triggered by receptor and coreceptor binding, while alphaviruses such as Semliki Forest virus (SFV) and flaviviruses such as dengue virus are triggered by exposure to acidic pH. The fusion trigger initiates the conversion of the fusion protein from the metastable prefusion state to the more energetically stable postfusion state (14, 15). The energy released during the refolding of the membrane fusion protein drives the merger of the viral and host membranes.Alphaviruses take advantage of the low-pH environment of the endocytic pathway to trigger membrane fusion during entry (37). E1 is the fusion protein and forms heterodimers with the E2 protein on the virus surface. These heterodimers are organized into trimers (E2/E1)₃ to form the icosahedral glycoprotein shell (21, 30, 43). Alphaviruses bind to cell surface receptors and are internalized by clathrin-mediated endocytosis and delivered to endosomes (16). Here, low pH induces E1/E2 heterodimer dissociation, E1 insertion into endosomal membranes, and the refolding of E1 to the final postfusion homotrimer conformation (16, 37). The resultant membrane fusion releases the viral RNA genome into the cytoplasm to initiate virus replication. During replication the envelope glycoproteins are translated in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), processed through the cellular secretory pathway, and delivered to the plasma membrane, where budding of virus particles occurs (20).The alphavirus membrane fusion protein E1 and the flavivirus membrane fusion protein E are structurally related. These proteins are often referred to as class II fusion proteins to distinguish them from the class I proteins (exemplified by influenza hemagglutinin [HA] and HIV gp41) and the class III proteins (exemplified by vesicular stomatitis virus G and baculovirus gp64) (reviewed in references 15, 19, and 42). Class II fusion proteins such as the SFV E1 protein are composed almost exclusively of β-sheets organized into three domains (DI to DIII) (22, 35). There is a central DI that connects to the elongated DII containing the hydrophobic fusion loop at the tip. The other side of DI connects to DIII, followed by the stem and transmembrane domain that anchors the protein to the viral membrane. Unlike the class I and class III proteins, the alphavirus and flavivirus fusion proteins are dimers in the prefusion state and homotrimers in the postfusion state. During the prefusion to postfusion transition, DIII moves approximately 37 Å toward the target membrane-inserted fusion loop. The resulting hairpin-like conformation brings the viral and host membranes together to mediate membrane fusion (4, 13, 31) (see Fig. ​Fig.11 for the SFV E1 homotrimer structure).Open in a separate windowFIG. 1.Location of revertants in the E1 trimer. (A) The crystal structure of the postfusion E1* homotrimer (PDB entry 1RER) is shown with two chains in light gray and one chain colored as follows: DI in red, DII in yellow, DIII in blue, the fusion loop in green, the DI-DIII linker in black, and the N-terminal region of the stem in purple. The C-terminal stem connects to the transmembrane domain (neither of these is present in the crystal structure). The E1 residues discussed in this work are labeled and are represented as sticks highlighted with colors for clarity. D188 on the g-h loop in DII is shown in cyan, K176 on the DII β-strand f is in pink, and P14 on the DI β-strand C₀ is in orange. (B) A view of the central trimer interface (fusion loops pointing toward the viewer) showing the positions of D188 and K176 in the crystal structure, with colors as in panel A but with oxygen shown in red and nitrogen in blue on the stick structures. A holmium atom (not shown) is coordinated by the three inwardly pointing D188 residues. This figure was prepared using PyMol (9).Alphavirus membrane fusion is a necessary step for virus infection and occurs rapidly and efficiently with a threshold pH of ∼6.2 (reviewed in reference 16). Mutations that block trimerization prevent virus fusion and infection (18, 29). Similarly, chemical inhibition of trimerization inhibits fusion in a virus-liposome system (8). Fusion and infection are also specifically inhibited by the addition of exogenous DIII, which binds a trimeric intermediate of E1 and prevents fold-back of endogenous DIII and formation of the final postfusion trimer (25).Although formation of the E1 homotrimer is crucial to membrane fusion, little is known about the residues that regulate the overall process and steps of trimerization. The dramatic effects of local environment on the pK_a of ionizable residues make it difficult to predict the key players that initiate and drive E1 refolding, despite the fact that it takes place in a physiological window between pH values of ∼5 and 7 (37). The postfusion structures of E1 and E show that DI and DII comprise the central region of the trimer and that DIII and the stem pack against this core to form the outer layer of the trimer (4, 13, 31). It was recently shown that a truncated version of SFV E1 containing only DI and DII forms a stable core trimer with biochemical features similar to those of the full-length trimer (38). This result suggests that important interactions exist within the alphavirus core trimer.Inspection of the E1 postfusion structure identified a conserved aspartate residue, D188, located in the central trimer interface. This residue was shown to play an important role in the initial events of trimerization (29). Mutation of D188 to lysine (D188K) blocks virus fusion and infection and prevents stable trimers from forming while having no effect on E2/E1 heterodimer dissociation or E1 membrane insertion. Here, we have selected and characterized viable revertants of the D188K mutant and used them to identify an important interaction of D188 with a lysine residue on the adjoining E1 chain. This ring of salt bridges acts to stabilize the E1 core trimer and helps to drive formation of an extended trimer intermediate.(The data in this paper are from a thesis to be submitted by C. Y. Liu in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Ph.D. in the Graduate Division of Medical Sciences, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Yeshiva University, New York, NY.)