Insights into structure and function of the active site of SoxAX cytochromes

SoxAX cytochromes catalyze the formation of heterodisulfide bonds between inorganic sulfur compounds and a carrier protein, SoxYZ. They contain unusual His/Cys-ligated heme groups with complex spectroscopic signatures. The heme-ligating cysteine has been implicated in SoxAX catalysis, but neither the SoxAX spectroscopic properties nor its catalysis are fully understood at present. We have solved the first crystal structure for a group 2 SoxAX protein (SnSoxAX), where an N-terminal extension of SoxX forms a novel structure that supports dimer formation. Crystal structures of SoxAX with a heme ligand substitution (C236M) uncovered an inherent flexibility of this SoxA heme site, with both bonding distances and relative ligand orientation differing between asymmetric units and the new residue, Met(236), representing an unusual rotamer of methionine. The flexibility of the SnSoxAX(C236M) SoxA heme environment is probably the cause of the four distinct, new EPR signals, including a high spin ferric heme form, that were observed for the enzyme. Despite the removal of the catalytically active cysteine heme ligand and drastic changes in the redox potential of the SoxA heme (WT, -479 mV; C236M, +85 mV), the substituted enzyme was catalytically active in glutathione-based assays although with reduced turnover numbers (WT, 3.7 s(-1); C236M, 2.0 s(-1)). SnSoxAX(C236M) was also active in assays using SoxYZ and thiosulfate as the sulfur substrate, suggesting that Cys(236) aids catalysis but is not crucial for it. The SoxYZ-based SoxAX assay is the first assay for an isolated component of the Sox multienzyme system.     

A recombinant diheme SoxAX cytochrome - implications for the relationship between EPR signals and modified heme-ligands

The multiheme SoxAX proteins are notable for their unusual heme ligation (His/Cys-persulfide in the SoxA subunit) and the complexity of their EPR spectra. The diheme SoxAX protein from Starkeya novella has been expressed using Rhodobacter capsulatus as a host expression system. rSoxAX was correctly formed in the periplasm of the host and contained heme c in similar amounts as the native SoxAX. ESI-MS showed that the full length rSoxA, in spite of never having undergone catalytic turnover, existed in several forms, with the two major forms having masses of 28687 +/- 4 and 28718 +/- 4 Da. The latter form exceeds the expected mass of rSoxA by 31 +/- 4 Da, a mass close to that of a sulfur atom and indicating that a fraction of the recombinant protein contains a cysteine persulfide modification. EPR spectra of rSoxAX contained all four heme-dependent EPR signals (LS1a, LS1b, LS2, LS3) found in the native SoxAX proteins isolated from bacteria grown under sulfur chemolithotrophic conditions. Exposure of the recombinant SoxAX to different sulfur compounds lead to changes in the SoxA mass profile as determined by ESI while maintaining a fully oxidized SoxAX visible spectrum. Thiosulfate, the proposed SoxAX substrate, did not cause any mass changes while after exposure to dimethylsulfoxide a +112 +/- 4 Da form of SoxA became dominant in the mass spectrum.     

The unusal redox centers of SoxXA, a novel c-type heme-enzyme essential for chemotrophic sulfur-oxidation of Paracoccus pantotrophus

The heterodimeric hemoprotein SoxXA, essential for lithotrophic sulfur oxidation of the aerobic bacterium Paracoccus pantotrophus, was examined by a combination of spectroelectrochemistry and EPR spectroscopy. The EPR spectra for SoxXA showed contributions from three paramagnetic heme iron centers. One highly anisotropic low-spin (HALS) species (gmax = 3.45) and two "standard" cytochrome-like low-spin heme species with closely spaced g-tensor values were identified, LS1 (gz = 2.54, gy = 2.30, and gx = 1.87) and LS2 (gz = 2.43, gy = 2.26, and gx = 1.90). The crystal structure of SoxXA from P. pantotrophus confirmed the presence of three heme groups, one of which (heme 3) has a His/Met axial coordination and is located on the SoxX subunit [Dambe et al. (2005) J. Struct. Biol. 152, 229-234]. This heme was assigned to the HALS species in the EPR spectra of the isolated SoxX subunit. The LS1 and LS2 species were associated with heme 1 and heme 2 located on the SoxA subunit, both of which have EPR parameters characteristic for an axial His/thiolate coordination. Using thin-layer spectroelectrochemistry the midpoint potentials of heme 3 and heme 2 were determined: Em3 = +189 +/- 15 mV and Em2 = -432 +/- 15 mV (vs NHE, pH 7.0). Heme 1 was not reducible even with 20 mM titanium(III) citrate. The Em2 midpoint potential turned out to be pH dependent. It is proposed that heme 2 participates in the catalysis and that the cysteine persulfide ligation leads to the unusually low redox potential (-436 mV). The pH dependence of its redox potential may be due to (de)protonation of the Arg247 residue located in the active site.     

Novel heme ligation in a c-type cytochrome involved in thiosulfate oxidation: EPR and MCD of SoxAX from Rhodovulum sulfidophilum

The SoxAX complex of the bacterium Rhodovulum sulfidophilum is a heterodimeric c-type cytochrome that plays an essential role in photosynthetic thiosulfate and sulfide oxidation. The three heme sites of SoxAX have been analyzed using electronic absorption, electron paramagnetic resonance, and magnetic circular dichroism spectroscopies. Heme-3 in the ferric state is characterized by a Large g(max) EPR signal and has histidine and methionine axial heme iron ligands which are retained on reduction to the ferrous state. Hemes-1 and -2 both have thiolate plus nitrogenous ligand sets in the ferric state and give rise to rhombic EPR spectra. Heme-1, whose ligands derive from cysteinate and histidine residues, remains ferric in the presence of dithionite ion. Ferric heme-2 exists with a preparation-dependent mixture of two different ligand sets, one being cysteinate/histidine, the other an unidentified pair with a weaker crystal-field strength. Upon reduction of the SoxAX complex with dithionite, a change occurs in the ligands of heme-2 in which the thiolate is either protonated or replaced by an unidentified ligand. Sequence analysis places the histidine/methionine-coordinated heme in SoxX and the thiolate-liganded hemes in SoxA. SoxAX is the first naturally occurring c-type cytochrome in which a thiolate-coordinated heme has been identified.     

SoxAX cytochromes, a new type of heme copper protein involved in bacterial energy generation from sulfur compounds

SoxAX cytochromes are essential for the function of the only confirmed pathway for bacterial thiosulfate oxidation, the so-called "Sox pathway," in which they catalyze the initial formation of a S-S bond between thiosulfate and the SoxYZ carrier protein. Our work using the Starkeya novella diheme SoxAX protein reveals for the first time that in addition to two active site heme groups, SoxAX contains a mononuclear Cu(II) center with a distorted tetragonal geometry and three to four nitrogen ligands, one of which is a histidine. The Cu(II) center enhanced SoxAX activity in a newly developed, glutathione-based assay system that mimics the natural reaction of SoxAX with SoxYZ. EPR spectroscopy confirmed that the SoxAX Cu(II) center is reduced by glutathione. At pH 7 a K(m) (app) of 0.19+/-0.028 mm and a k(cat) (app) of 5.7+/-0.25s(-1) were determined for glutathione. We propose that SoxAX cytochromes are a new type of heme-copper proteins, with SoxAX-mediated S-S bond formation involving both the copper and heme centers.     

Cytochrome complex essential for photosynthetic oxidation of both thiosulfate and sulfide in Rhodovulum sulfidophilum

Many photosynthetic bacteria use inorganic sulfur compounds as electron donors for carbon dioxide fixation. A thiosulfate-induced cytochrome c has been purified from the photosynthetic alpha-proteobacterium Rhodovulum sulfidophilum. This cytochrome c(551) is a heterodimer of a diheme 30-kDa SoxA subunit and a monoheme 15-kDa SoxX subunit. The cytochrome c(551) structural genes are part of an 11-gene sox locus. Sequence analysis suggests that the ligands to the heme iron in SoxX are a methionine and a histidine, while both SoxA hemes are predicted to have unusual cysteine-plus-histidine coordination. A soxA mutant strain is unable to grow photoautotrophically on or oxidize either thiosulfate or sulfide. Cytochrome c(551) is thus essential for the metabolism of both these sulfur species. Periplasmic extracts of wild-type R. sulfidophilum exhibit thiosulfate:cytochrome c oxidoreductase activity. However, such activity can only be measured for a soxA mutant strain if the periplasmic extract is supplemented with purified cytochrome c(551). Gene clusters similar to the R. sulfidophilum sox locus can be found in the genome of a green sulfur bacterium and in phylogenetically diverse nonphotosynthetic autotrophs.     

SoxAX binding protein, a novel component of the thiosulfate-oxidizing multienzyme system in the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum

From the photosynthetic green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum (pro synon. Chlorobaculum tepidum), we have purified three factors indispensable for the thiosulfate-dependent reduction of the small, monoheme cytochrome c₅₅₄. These are homologues of sulfur-oxidizing (Sox) system factors found in various thiosulfate-oxidizing bacteria. The first factor is SoxYZ that serves as the acceptor for the reaction intermediates. The second factor is monomeric SoxB that is proposed to catalyze the hydrolytic cleavage of sulfate from the SoxYZ-bound oxidized product of thiosulfate. The third factor is the trimeric cytochrome c₅₅₁, composed of the monoheme cytochrome SoxA, the monoheme cytochrome SoxX, and the product of the hypothetical open reading frame CT1020. The last three components were expressed separately in Escherichia coli cells and purified to homogeneity. In the presence of the other two Sox factors, the recombinant SoxA and SoxX showed a low but discernible thiosulfate-dependent cytochrome c₅₅₄ reduction activity. The further addition of the recombinant CT1020 protein greatly increased the activity, and the total activity was as high as that of the native SoxAX-CT1020 protein complex. The recombinant CT1020 protein participated in the formation of a tight complex with SoxA and SoxX and will be referred to as SAXB (SoxAX binding protein). Homologues of the SAXB gene are found in many strains, comprising roughly about one-third of the thiosulfate-oxidizing bacteria whose sox gene cluster sequences have been deposited so far and ranging over the Chlorobiaciae, Chromatiaceae, Hydrogenophilaceae, Oceanospirillaceae, etc. Each of the deduced SoxA and SoxX proteins of these bacteria constitute groups that are distinct from those found in bacteria that apparently lack SAXB gene homologues.     

Redox and Chemical Activities of the Hemes in the Sulfur Oxidation Pathway Enzyme SoxAX

SoxAX enzymes couple disulfide bond formation to the reduction of cytochrome c in the first step of the phylogenetically widespread Sox microbial sulfur oxidation pathway. Rhodovulum sulfidophilum SoxAX contains three hemes. An electrochemical cell compatible with magnetic circular dichroism at near infrared wavelengths has been developed to resolve redox and chemical properties of the SoxAX hemes. In combination with potentiometric titrations monitored by electronic absorbance and EPR, this method defines midpoint potentials (E_m) at pH 7.0 of approximately +210, −340, and −400 mV for the His/Met, His/Cys⁻, and active site His/CysS⁻-ligated heme, respectively. Exposing SoxAX to S₂O₄²⁻, a substrate analog with E_m ∼−450 mV, but not Eu(II) complexed with diethylene triamine pentaacetic acid (E_m ∼−1140 mV), allows cyanide to displace the cysteine persulfide (CysS⁻) ligand to the active site heme. This provides the first evidence for the dissociation of CysS⁻ that has been proposed as a key event in SoxAX catalysis.     

Chromophore interactions in flavocytochrome c552: a resonance Raman investigation

Resonance Raman spectra with both Soret and visible excitation have been obtained for Chromatium flavocytochrome c552 and its isolated diheme subunit under varying conditions of pH and inhibitor binding. The spectra are generally consistent with previously established classification schemes for porphyrin ring vibrations. The presence of covalently bound flavin in the protein was apparent in the fluorescent background it produced and in flavin-mediated photoeffects observed in heme Raman spectra obtained at high laser power. No flavin modes were present in the Raman spectra, nor was any evidence of direct heme-flavin interaction found by using this technique; however, a systematic perturbation of heme B1g vibrational frequencies was found in the oxidized holoprotein. The heme vibrational frequencies of c552 are compared to those of the diheme peptide and of other c-type cytochromes. They are consistent with an interpretation that involves pH-dependent changes in axial ligation and treats the hemes and flavin as isolated chromphores communicating via protein-mediated interactions.     

Structures and solution properties of two novel periplasmic sensor domains with c-type heme from chemotaxis proteins of Geobacter sulfurreducens: implications for signal transduction

Periplasmic sensor domains from two methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins from Geobacter sulfurreducens (encoded by genes GSU0935 and GSU0582) were expressed in Escherichia coli. The sensor domains were isolated, purified, characterized in solution, and their crystal structures were determined. In the crystal, both sensor domains form swapped dimers and show a PAS-type fold. The swapped segment consists of two helices of about 45 residues at the N terminus with the hemes located between the two monomers. In the case of the GSU0582 sensor, the dimer contains a crystallographic 2-fold symmetry and the heme is coordinated by an axial His and a water molecule. In the case of the GSU0935 sensor, the crystals contain a non-crystallographic dimer, and surprisingly, the coordination of the heme in each monomer is different; monomer A heme has His-Met ligation and monomer B heme has His-water ligation as found in the GSU0582 sensor. The structures of these sensor domains are the first structures of PAS domains containing covalently bound heme. Optical absorption, electron paramagnetic resonance and NMR spectroscopy have revealed that the heme groups of both sensor domains are high-spin and low-spin in the oxidized and reduced forms, respectively, and that the spin-state interconversion involves a heme axial ligand replacement. Both sensor domains bind NO in their ferric and ferrous forms but bind CO only in the reduced form. The binding of both NO and CO occurs via an axial ligand exchange process, and is fully reversible. The reduction potentials of the sensor domains differ by 95 mV (− 156 mV and − 251 mV for sensors GSU0582 and GSU0935, respectively). The swapped dimerization of these sensor domains and redox-linked ligand switch might be related to the mechanism of signal transduction by these chemotaxis proteins.     

Changing the heme ligation in flavocytochrome b 2: substitution of histidine-66 by cysteine

Substitution by cysteine of one of the heme iron axial ligands (His66) of flavocytochrome b2 (L-lactate:cytochrome c oxidoreductase from Saccharomyces cerevisiae) has resulted in an enzyme (H66C-b2) which remains a competent L-lactate dehydrogenase (kcat 272+/-6 s(-1), L-lactate KM 0.60+/-0.06 mM, 25 degrees C, I 0.10, Tris-HCl, pH 7.5) but which has no cytochrome c reductase activity. As a result of the mutation, the reduction potential of the heme was found to be -265+5 mV, over 240 mV more negative than that of the wild-type enzyme, and therefore unable to be reduced by L-lactate. Surface-enhanced resonance Raman spectroscopy indicates similarities between the heme of H66C-b2 and those of cytochromes P450, with a nu4 band at 1,345 cm(-1) which is indicative of cysteine heme-iron ligation. In addition, EPR spectroscopy yields g-values at 2.33, 2.22 and 1.94, typical of low-spin ferric cytochromes P450, optical spectra show features between 600 and 900 nm which are characteristic of sulfur coordination of the heme iron, and MCD spectroscopy shows a blue-shifted NIR CT band relative to the wild-type, implying that the H66C-b2 heme is P450-like. Interestingly, EPR evidence also suggests that the second histidine heme-iron ligand (His43) is displaced in the mutant enzyme.     

Cloning,expression, and physicochemical characterization of a new diheme cytochrome <Emphasis Type="Italic">c</Emphasis> from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Shewanella baltica</Emphasis> OS155

The 16-kDa diheme cytochrome c from the bacterium Shewanella baltica OS155 (Sb-DHC) was cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli and investigated through UV–vis, magnetic circular dichroism, and ¹H NMR spectroscopies and protein voltammetry. The model structure was obtained by means of comparative modeling using the X-ray structure of Rhodobacter sphaeroides diheme cytochrome c (Rs-DHC) (with a 37% pairwise sequence identity) as a template. Sb-DHC folds into two distinct domains, each containing one heme center with a bis-His axial ligation. Both secondary and tertiary structures of the N-terminal domain resemble those of class I cytochrome c, displaying three α-helices and a compact overall folding. The C-terminal domain is less helical than the corresponding domain of Rs-DHC. The two heme groups are bridged by Tyr26 in correspondence with the shortest edge-to-edge distance, a feature which would facilitate fast internal electron transfer. The electronic properties of the two prosthetic centers are equivalent and sensitive to two acid–base equilibria with pK _a values of approximately 2.4 and 5, likely corresponding to protonation and detachment of the axial His ligands from the heme iron and a pH-linked conformational change of the protein, respectively. Reduction potentials of −0.144 and −0.257 V (vs. the standard hydrogen electrode), were determined for the C- and N-terminal heme groups, respectively. An approach based on the extended Debye–Hückel equation was applied for the first time to a two-centered metalloprotein and was found to reproduce successfully the ionic strength dependence of E°′.     

The distinct heme coordination environments and heme-binding stabilities of His39Ser and His39Cys mutants of cytochrome b5

A gene mutant library containing 16 designed mutated genes at His39 of cytochrome b(5) has been constructed by using gene random mutagenesis. Two variants of cytochrome b(5), His39Ser and His39Cys mutant proteins, have been obtained. Protein characterizations and reactions were performed showing that these two mutants have distinct heme coordination environments: ferric His39Ser mutant is a high-spin species whose heme is coordinated by proximal His63 and likely a water molecule in the distal pocket, while ferrous His39Ser mutant has a low-spin heme coordinated by His63 and Ser39; on the other hand, the ferric His39Cys mutant is a low-spin species with His63 and Cys39 acting as two axial ligands of the heme, the ferrous His39Cys mutant is at high-spin state with the only heme ligand of His63. These two mutants were also found to have quite lower heme-binding stabilities. The order of stabilities of ferric proteins is: wild-type cytochrome b(5) > His39Cys > His39Ser.     

Role of calcium in metalloenzymes: effects of calcium removal on the axial ligation geometry and magnetic properties of the catalytic diheme center in MauG

MauG is a diheme enzyme possessing a five-coordinate high-spin heme with an axial His ligand and a six-coordinate low-spin heme with His-Tyr axial ligation. A Ca(2+) ion is linked to the two hemes via hydrogen bond networks, and the enzyme activity depends on its presence. Removal of Ca(2+) altered the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) signals of each ferric heme such that the intensity of the high-spin heme was decreased and the low-spin heme was significantly broadened. Addition of Ca(2+) back to the sample restored the original EPR signals and enzyme activity. The molecular basis for this Ca(2+)-dependent behavior was studied by magnetic resonance and M?ssbauer spectroscopy. The results show that in the Ca(2+)-depleted MauG the high-spin heme was converted to a low-spin heme and the original low-spin heme exhibited a change in the relative orientations of its two axial ligands. The properties of these two hemes are each different than those of the heme in native MauG and are now similar to each other. The EPR spectrum of Ca(2+)-free MauG appears to describe one set of low-spin ferric heme signals with a large g(max) and g anisotropy and a greatly altered spin relaxation property. Both EPR and M?ssbauer spectroscopic results show that the two hemes are present as unusual highly rhombic low-spin hemes in Ca(2+)-depleted MauG, with a smaller orientation angle between the two axial ligand planes. These findings provide insight into the correlation of enzyme activity with the orientation of axial heme ligands and describe a role for the calcium ion in maintaining this structural orientation that is required for activity.     

Crystal structure of Nitrosomonas europaea cytochrome c peroxidase and the structural basis for ligand switching in bacterial di-heme peroxidases.

The crystal structure of the fully oxidized di-heme peroxidase from Nitrosomonas europaea has been solved to a resolution of 1.80 A and compared to the closely related enzyme from Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Both enzymes catalyze the peroxide-dependent oxidation of a protein electron donor such as cytochrome c. Electrons enter the enzyme through the high-potential heme followed by electron transfer to the low-potential heme, the site of peroxide activation. Both enzymes form homodimers, each of which folds into two distinct heme domains. Each heme is held in place by thioether bonds between the heme vinyl groups and Cys residues. The high-potential heme in both enzymes has Met and His as axial heme ligands. In the Pseudomonas enzyme, the low-potential heme has two His residues as axial heme ligands [Fulop et al. (1995) Structure 3, 1225-1233]. Since the site of reaction with peroxide is the low-potential heme, then one His ligand must first dissociate. In sharp contrast, the low-potential heme in the Nitrosomonas enzyme already is in the "activated" state with only one His ligand and an open distal axial ligation position available for reaction with peroxide. A comparison between the two enzymes illustrates the range of conformational changes required to activate the Pseudomonas enzyme. This change involves a large motion of a loop containing the dissociable His ligand from the heme pocket to the molecular surface where it forms part of the dimer interface. Since the Nitrosomonas enzyme is in the active state, the structure provides some insights on residues involved in peroxide activation. Most importantly, a Glu residue situated near the peroxide binding site could possibly serve as an acid-base catalytic group required for cleavage of the peroxide O--O bond.     

Functional importance of tyrosine 294 and the catalytic selectivity for the bis-Fe(IV) state of MauG revealed by replacement of this axial heme ligand with histidine

The diheme enzyme MauG catalyzes the posttranslational modification of a precursor protein of methylamine dehydrogenase (preMADH) to complete the biosynthesis of its protein-derived tryptophan tryptophylquinone (TTQ) cofactor. It catalyzes three sequential two-electron oxidation reactions which proceed through a high-valent bis-Fe(IV) redox state. Tyr294, the unusual distal axial ligand of one c-type heme, was mutated to His, and the crystal structure of Y294H MauG in complex with preMADH reveals that this heme now has His-His axial ligation. Y294H MauG is able to interact with preMADH and participate in interprotein electron transfer, but it is unable to catalyze the TTQ biosynthesis reactions that require the bis-Fe(IV) state. This mutation affects not only the redox properties of the six-coordinate heme but also the redox and CO-binding properties of the five-coordinate heme, despite the 21 ? separation of the heme iron centers. This highlights the communication between the hemes which in wild-type MauG behave as a single diheme unit. Spectroscopic data suggest that Y294H MauG can stabilize a high-valent redox state equivalent to Fe(V), but it appears to be an Fe(IV)═O/π radical at the five-coordinate heme rather than the bis-Fe(IV) state. This compound I-like intermediate does not catalyze TTQ biosynthesis, demonstrating that the bis-Fe(IV) state, which is stabilized by Tyr294, is specifically required for this reaction. The TTQ biosynthetic reactions catalyzed by wild-type MauG do not occur via direct contact with the Fe(IV)═O heme but via long-range electron transfer through the six-coordinate heme. Thus, a critical feature of the bis-Fe(IV) species may be that it shortens the electron transfer distance from preMADH to a high-valent heme iron.