Functional analysis of BamHI DNA cytosine-N4 methyltransferase

We show that the kinetic mechanism of the DNA (cytosine-N(4)-)-methyltransferase M.BamHI, which modifies the underlined cytosine (GGATCC), differs from cytosine C(5) methyltransferases, and is similar to that observed with adenine N(6) methyltransferases. This suggests that the obligate order of ternary complex assembly and disassembly depends on the type of methylation reaction. In contrast, the single-turnover rate of catalysis for M.BamHI (0.10s(-1)) is closer to the DNA (cytosine-C(5)-)-methyltransferases (0.14s(-1)) than the DNA (adenine-N(6)-)-methyltransferases (>200s(-1)). The nucleotide flipping transition dominates the single-turnover constant for adenine N(6) methyltransferases, and, since the disruption of the guanine-cytosine base-pair is essential for both types of cytosine DNA methyltransferases, this transition may be a common, rate-limiting step for methylation for these two enzyme subclasses. The similar overall rate of catalysis by M.BamHI and other DNA methyltransferases is consistent with a common rate-limiting catalytic step of product dissociation. Our analyses of M.BamHI provide functional insights into the relationship between the three different classes of DNA methyltransferases that complement both prior structural and evolutionary insights.     

The cytosine N4-methyltransferase M.PvuII also modifies adenine residues

Methylation of DNA occurs at the C5 and N4 positions of cytosine and N6 of adenine. The chemistry of methylation is similar among methyltransferases specific for cytosine-N4 and adenine-N6. Moreover these enzymes have similar structures and active sites. Previously it has been demonstrated that the DNA-(adenine-N6)-methyltransferases M.EcoRV, M.EcoRI, E. coli dam and both domains of M.FokI also modify cytosine residues at the N4 position [Jeltsch et al., J. Biol. Chem. 274 (1999), 19538-19544]. Here we show that the cytosine-N4 methyltransferase M.PvuII, which modifies the second cytosine in CAGCTG sequences, also methylates adenine residues in CAGATG/CAGCTG substrates in which the target cytosine is replaced by adenine in one strand of the recognition sequence. Therefore, adenine-N6 and cytosine-N4 methyltransferases have overlapping target base specificities. These results demonstrate that the target base recognition by N-specific DNA methyltransferases is relaxed in many cases. Furthermore, it shows that the catalytic mechanisms of adenine-N6 and cytosine-N4 methyltransferases are very similar.     

On the substrate specificity of DNA methyltransferases. adenine-N6 DNA methyltransferases also modify cytosine residues at position N4

Methylation of DNA is important in many organisms and essential in mammals. Nucleobases can be methylated at the adenine-N6, cytosine-N4, or cytosine-C5 atoms by specific DNA methyltransferases. We show here that the M.EcoRV, M.EcoRI, and Escherichia coli dam methyltransferases as well as the N- and C-terminal domains of the M. FokI enzyme, which were formerly all classified as adenine-N6 DNA methyltransferases, also methylate cytosine residues at position N4. Kinetic analyses demonstrate that the rate of methylation of cytosine residues by M.EcoRV and the M.FokI enzymes is reduced by only 1-2 orders of magnitude in relation to methylation of adenines. This result shows that although these enzymes methylate DNA in a sequence specific manner, they have a low substrate specificity with respect to the target base. This unexpected finding has implications on the mechanism of adenine-N6 DNA methyltransferases. Sequence comparisons suggest that adenine-N6 and cytosine-N4 methyltransferases have changed their reaction specificity at least twice during evolution, a model that becomes much more likely given the partial functional overlap of both enzyme types. In contrast, methylation of adenine residues by the cytosine-N4 methyltransferase M.BamHI was not detectable. On the basis of our results, we suggest that adenine-N6 and cytosine-N4 methyltransferases should be grouped into one enzyme family.     

Purification and characterization of DNA methyltransferases from Neisseria gonorrhoeae.

Three DNA methyltransferases, M.NgoAI, and M.NgoBI and M.NgoBII, free of any nuclease activities were isolated from Neisseria gonorrhoeae strains WR220 and MUG116 respectively. M.NgoAI recognizes the sequence 5' GGCC 3' and methylates the first 5' cytosine on both strands. M.NgoBI and M.NgoBII recognize 5' TCACC 3' and 5' GTAN5CTC 3' respectively. M.NgoBII methylates cytosine on only one strand to produce 5' GTAN5mCTC 3'.     

Structure of pvu II DNA-(cytosine N4) methyltransferase, an example of domain permutation and protein fold assignment.

We have determined the structure of Pvu II methyltransferase (M. Pvu II) complexed with S -adenosyl-L-methionine (AdoMet) by multiwavelength anomalous diffraction, using a crystal of the selenomethionine-substituted protein. M. Pvu II catalyzes transfer of the methyl group from AdoMet to the exocyclic amino (N4) nitrogen of the central cytosine in its recognition sequence 5'-CAGCTG-3'. The protein is dominated by an open alpha/beta-sheet structure with a prominent V-shaped cleft: AdoMet and catalytic amino acids are located at the bottom of this cleft. The size and the basic nature of the cleft are consistent with duplex DNA binding. The target (methylatable) cytosine, if flipped out of the double helical DNA as seen for DNA methyltransferases that generate 5-methylcytosine, would fit into the concave active site next to the AdoMet. This M. Pvu IIalpha/beta-sheet structure is very similar to those of M. Hha I (a cytosine C5 methyltransferase) and M. Taq I (an adenine N6 methyltransferase), consistent with a model predicting that DNA methyltransferases share a common structural fold while having the major functional regions permuted into three distinct linear orders. The main feature of the common fold is a seven-stranded beta-sheet (6 7 5 4 1 2 3) formed by five parallel beta-strands and an antiparallel beta-hairpin. The beta-sheet is flanked by six parallel alpha-helices, three on each side. The AdoMet binding site is located at the C-terminal ends of strands beta1 and beta2 and the active site is at the C-terminal ends of strands beta4 and beta5 and the N-terminal end of strand beta7. The AdoMet-protein interactions are almost identical among M. Pvu II, M. Hha I and M. Taq I, as well as in an RNA methyltransferase and at least one small molecule methyltransferase. The structural similarity among the active sites of M. Pvu II, M. Taq I and M. Hha I reveals that catalytic amino acids essential for cytosine N4 and adenine N6 methylation coincide spatially with those for cytosine C5 methylation, suggesting a mechanism for amino methylation.     

Dynamic modes of the flipped-out cytosine during HhaI methyltransferase-DNA interactions in solution.

Flipping of a nucleotide out of a B-DNA helix into the active site of an enzyme has been observed for the HhaI and HaeIII cytosine-5 methyltransferases (M.HhaI and M.HaeIII) and for numerous DNA repair enzymes. Here we studied the base flipping motions in the binary M. HhaI-DNA and the ternary M.HhaI-DNA-cofactor systems in solution. Two 5-fluorocytosines were introduced into the DNA in the places of the target cytosine and, as an internal control, a cytosine positioned two nucleotides upstream of the recognition sequence 5'-GCGC-3'. The 19F NMR spectra combined with gel mobility data show that interaction with the enzyme induces partition of the target base among three states, i.e. stacked in the B-DNA, an ensemble of flipped-out forms and the flipped-out form locked in the enzyme active site. Addition of the cofactor analogue S-adenosyl-L-homocysteine greatly enhances the trapping of the target cytosine in the catalytic site. Distinct dynamic modes of the target cytosine have thus been identified along the reaction pathway, which includes novel base-flipping intermediates that were not observed in previous X-ray structures. The new data indicate that flipping of the target base out of the DNA helix is not dependent on binding of the cytosine in the catalytic pocket of M.HhaI, and suggest an active role of the enzyme in the opening of the DNA duplex.     

Chemical mapping of cytosines enzymatically flipped out of the DNA helix

Haloacetaldehydes can be employed for probing unpaired DNA structures involving cytosine and adenine residues. Using an enzyme that was structurally proven to flip its target cytosine out of the DNA helix, the HhaI DNA methyltransferase (M.HhaI), we demonstrate the suitability of the chloroacetaldehyde modification for mapping extrahelical (flipped-out) cytosine bases in protein-DNA complexes. The generality of this method was verified with two other DNA cytosine-5 methyltransferases, M.AluI and M.SssI, as well as with two restriction endonucleases, R.Ecl18kI and R.PspGI, which represent a novel class of base-flipping enzymes. Our results thus offer a simple and convenient laboratory tool for detection and mapping of flipped-out cytosines in protein-DNA complexes.     

The colorful history of active DNA demethylation

Patterns of DNA cytosine methylation are subject to mitotic inheritance in both plants and vertebrates. Plants use 5-methylcytosine glycosylases and the base excision repair pathway to remove excess cytosine methylation. In mammals, active demethylation has been proposed to operate via several very different mechanisms. Two recent reports in Nature now claim that the demethylation process is initiated by the same enzymes that establish the methylation mark, the DNA methyltransferases DNMT3A and DNMT3B (Kangaspeska et al., 2008; Métivier et al., 2008).     

The M.AluI DNA-(cytosine C5)-methyltransferase has an unusually large, partially dispensable, variable region.

The DNA methyltransferase of the AluI restriction-modification system, from Arthrobacter luteus, converts cytosine to 5-methylcytosine in the sequence AGCT. The gene for this methyltransferase, aluIM, was cloned into Escherichia coli and sequenced. A 525-codon open reading frame was found, consistent with deletion evidence, and the deduced amino acid sequence revealed all ten conserved regions common to 5-methylcytosine methyltransferases. The aluIM sequence predicts a protein of M(r) 59.0k, in agreement with the observed M(r), making M.AluI the largest known methyltransferase from a type II restriction-modification system. M.AluI also contains the largest known variable region of any monospecific DNA methyltransferase, larger than that of most multispecific methyltransferases. In other DNA methyltransferases the variable region has been implicated as the sequence-specific target recognition domain. An in-frame deletion that removes a third of this putative target-recognition region leaves the Alu I methyltransferase still fully active.     

Isolation and Characterization of Site-Specific DNA-methyltransferases from Bacillus coagulans K

Two site-specific DNA methyltransferases, M.BcoKIA and M.BcoKIB, were isolated from the thermophilic strain Bacillus coagulans K. Each of the methylases protects the recognition site 5'-CTCTTC-3'/5'-GAAGAG-3' from cleavage with the cognate restriction endonuclease BcoKI. It is shown that M.BcoKIB is an N6-adenine specific methylase and M.BcoKIA is an N4-cytosine specific methylase. According to bisulfite mapping, M.BcoKIA methylates the first cytosine in the sequence 5'-CTCTTC-3'.     

AdoMet-dependent methyl-transfer: Glu119 is essential for DNA C5-cytosine methyltransferase M.HhaI

The role of Glu119 in S-adenosyl-L-methionine-dependent DNA methyltransferase M.HhaI-catalyzed DNA methylation was studied. Glu119 belongs to the highly conserved Glu/Asn/Val motif found in all DNA C5-cytosine methyltransferases, and its importance for M.HhaI function remains untested. We show that formation of the covalent intermediate between Cys81 and the target cytosine requires Glu119, since conversion to Ala, Asp or Gln lowers the rate of methyl transfer 10(2)-10(6) fold. Further, unlike the wild-type M.HhaI, these mutants are not trapped by the substrate in which the target cytosine is replaced with the mechanism-based inhibitor 5-fluorocytosine. The DNA binding affinity for the Glu119Asp mutant is decreased 10(3)-fold. Thus, the ability of the enzyme to stabilize the extrahelical cytosine is coupled directly to tight DNA binding. The structures of the ternary protein/DNA/AdoHcy complexes for both the Glu119Ala and Glu119Gln mutants (2.70 A and 2.75 A, respectively) show that the flipped base is positioned nearly identically with that observed in the wild-type M.HhaI complex. A single water molecule in the Glu119Ala structure between Ala119 and the extrahelical cytosine N3 is lacking in the Glu119Gln and wild-type M.HhaI structures, and most likely accounts for this mutant's partial activity. Glu119 has essential roles in activating the target cytosine for nucleophilic attack and contributes to tight DNA binding.     

Local chromatin microenvironment determines DNMT activity: from DNA methyltransferase to DNA demethylase or DNA dehydroxymethylase

Insights on active DNA demethylation disproved the original assumption that DNA methylation is a stable epigenetic modification. Interestingly, mammalian DNA methyltransferases 3A and 3B (DNMT-3A and -3B) have also been reported to induce active DNA demethylation, in addition to their well-known function in catalyzing methylation. In situations of extremely low levels of S-adenosyl methionine (SAM), DNMT-3A and -3B might demethylate C-5 methyl cytosine (5mC) via deamination to thymine, which is subsequently replaced by an unmodified cytosine through the base excision repair (BER) pathway. Alternatively, 5mC when converted to 5- hydroxymethylcytosine (5hmC) by TET enzymes, might be further modified to an unmodified cytosine by DNMT-3A and -3B under oxidized redox conditions, although exact pathways are yet to be elucidated. Interestingly, even direct conversion of 5mC to cytosine might be catalyzed by DNMTs. Here, we summarize the evidence on the DNA dehydroxymethylase and demethylase activity of DNMT-3A and -3B. Although physiological relevance needs to be demonstrated, the current indications on the 5mC- and 5hmC-modifying activities of de novo DNA C-5 methyltransferases shed a new light on these enzymes. Despite the extreme circumstances required for such unexpected reactions to occur, we here put forward that the chromatin microenvironment can be locally exposed to extreme conditions, and hypothesize that such waves of extremes allow enzymes to act in differential ways.     

M.HhaI binds tightly to substrates containing mismatches at the target base.

The (cytosine-5) DNA methyltransferase M.HhaI causes its target cytosine base to be flipped completely out of the DNA helix upon binding. We have investigated the effects of replacing the target cytosine by other, mismatched bases, including adenine, guanine, thymine and uracil. We find that M.HhaI binds more tightly to such mismatched substrates and can even transfer a methyl group to uracil if a G:U mismatch is present. Other mismatched substrates in which the orphan guanine is changed exhibit similar behavior. Overall, the affinity of DNA binding correlates inversely with the stability of the target base pair, while the nature of the target base appears irrelevant for complex formation. The presence of a cofactor analog. S-adenosyl-L-homocysteine, greatly enhances the selectivity of the methyltransferase for cytosine at the target site. We propose that the DNA methyltransferases have evolved from mismatch binding proteins and that base flipping was, and still is, a key element in many DNA-enzyme interactions.     

Cysteine of sequence motif VI is essential for nucleophilic catalysis by yeast tRNA m5C methyltransferase

Sequence comparison of several RNA m(5)C methyltransferases identifies two conserved cysteine residues that belong to signature motifs IV and VI of RNA and DNA methyltransferases. While the cysteine of motif IV is used as the nucleophilic catalyst by DNA m(5)C methyltransferases, this role is fulfilled by the cysteine of motif VI in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA m(5)C967 methyltransferase, but whether this conclusion applies to other RNA m(5)C methyltransferases remains to be verified. Yeast tRNA m(5)C methyltransferase Trm4p is a multisite-specific S-adenosyl-L-methionine-dependent enzyme that catalyzes the methylation of cytosine at C5 in several positions of tRNA. Here, we confirm that Cys310 of motif VI in Trm4p is essential for nucleophilic catalysis, presumably by forming a covalent link with carbon 6 of cytosine. Indeed, the enzyme is able to form a stable covalent adduct with the 5-fluorocytosine-containing RNA substrate analog, whereas the C310A mutant protein is inactive and unable to form the covalent complex.     

Binding of the EcoRII methylase to azacytosine-containing DNA.

Binding of DNA(cytosine-5)methyltransferases to azacytosine containing DNA is stimulated by the presence of S-adenosyl-methionine or its analogs sinefungin or S-adenosyl-L-homocysteine. Methylation of the DNA is therefore not necessary for binding to occur. There is no relationship between the affinity of the analog for the EcoRII enzyme and its ability to stimulate binding. The DNA-enzyme complex partially dissociates on incubation in 0.1% sodium dodecyl sulfate and 0.5 M ammonium acetate. Some of this DNA could again form a tight complex with enzyme, indicating that DNA-enzyme complex formation is reversible. Binding occurs when the second cytosine in the sequence CCAGG is substituted by azacytosine. This is the cytosine that would normally be methylated by the enzyme. The binding is therefore due to specific interaction of the methylase with azacytosine at the site it would normally methylate.     

The role of Arg165 towards base flipping, base stabilization and catalysis in M.HhaI

Arg165 forms part of a previously identified base flipping motif in the bacterial DNA cytosine methyltransferase, M.HhaI. Replacement of Arg165 with Ala has no detectable effect on either DNA or AdoMet affinity, yet causes the base flipping and restacking transitions to be decreased approximately 16 and 190-fold respectively, thus confirming the importance of this motif. However, these kinetic changes cannot account for the mutant's observed 10(5)-fold decreased catalytic rate. The mutant enzyme/cognate DNA cocrystal structure (2.79 A resolution) shows the target cytosine to be positioned approximately 30 degrees into the major groove, which is consistent with a major groove pathway for nucleotide flipping. The pyrimidine-sugar chi angle is rotated to approximately +171 degrees, from a range of -95 degrees to -120 degrees in B DNA, and -77 degrees in the WT M.HhaI complex. Thus, Arg165 is important for maintaining the cytosine positioned for nucleophilic attack by Cys81. The cytosine sugar pucker is in the C2'-endo-C3'-exo (South conformation), in contrast to the previously reported C3'-endo (North conformation) described for the original 2.70 A resolution cocrystal structure of the WT M.HhaI/DNA complex. We determined a high resolution structure of the WT M.HhaI/DNA complex (1.96 A) to better determine the sugar pucker. This new structure is similar to the original, lower resolution WT M.HhaI complex, but shows that the sugar pucker is O4'-endo (East conformation), intermediate between the South and North conformers. In summary, Arg165 plays significant roles in base flipping, cytosine positioning, and catalysis. Furthermore, the previously proposed M.HhaI-mediated changes in sugar pucker may not be an important contributor to the base flipping mechanism. These results provide insights into the base flipping and catalytic mechanisms for bacterial and eukaryotic DNA methyltransferases.     

Cytosine-to-Uracil Deamination by SssI DNA Methyltransferase

The prokaryotic DNA(cytosine-5)methyltransferase M.SssI shares the specificity of eukaryotic DNA methyltransferases (CG) and is an important model and experimental tool in the study of eukaryotic DNA methylation. Previously, M.SssI was shown to be able to catalyze deamination of the target cytosine to uracil if the methyl donor S-adenosyl-methionine (SAM) was missing from the reaction. To test whether this side-activity of the enzyme can be used to distinguish between unmethylated and C5-methylated cytosines in CG dinucleotides, we re-investigated, using a sensitive genetic reversion assay, the cytosine deaminase activity of M.SssI. Confirming previous results we showed that M.SssI can deaminate cytosine to uracil in a slow reaction in the absence of SAM and that the rate of this reaction can be increased by the SAM analogue 5’-amino-5’-deoxyadenosine. We could not detect M.SssI-catalyzed deamination of C5-methylcytosine (^m5C). We found conditions where the rate of M.SssI mediated C-to-U deamination was at least 100-fold higher than the rate of ^m5C-to-T conversion. Although this difference in reactivities suggests that the enzyme could be used to identify C5-methylated cytosines in the epigenetically important CG dinucleotides, the rate of M.SssI mediated cytosine deamination is too low to become an enzymatic alternative to the bisulfite reaction. Amino acid replacements in the presumed SAM binding pocket of M.SssI (F17S and G19D) resulted in greatly reduced methyltransferase activity. The G19D variant showed cytosine deaminase activity in E. coli, at physiological SAM concentrations. Interestingly, the C-to-U deaminase activity was also detectable in an E. coli ung ⁺ host proficient in uracil excision repair.     

DNA bending induced by DNA (cytosine-5) methyltransferases

DNA bending induced by six DNA (cytosine-5) methyltransferases was studied using circular permutation gel mobility shift assay. The following bend angles were obtained: M.BspRI (GG^m5CC), 46–50°; M.HaeIII (GG^m5CC), 40–43°; M.SinI (GGW^m5CC), 34–37°; M.Sau96I (GGN^m5CC), 52–57°; M.HpaII (C^m5CGG), 30°; and M.HhaI (G^m5CGC), 13°. M.HaeIII was also tested with fragments carrying a methylated binding site, and it was found to induce a 32° bend. A phase-sensitive gel mobility shift assay, using a set of DNA fragments with a sequence-directed bend and a single methyltransferase binding site, indicated that M.HaeIII and M.BspRI bend DNA toward the minor groove. The DNA curvature induced by M.HaeIII contrasts with the lack of DNA bend observed for a covalent M.HaeIII–DNA complex in an earlier X-ray study. Our results and data from other laboratories show a correlation between the bending properties and the recognition specificities of (cytosine-5) methyltransferases: enzymes recognizing a cytosine 3′ to the target cytosine tend to induce greater bends than enzymes with guanine in this position. We suggest that the observed differences indicate different mechanisms employed by (cytosine-5) methyltransferases to stabilize the helix after the target base has flipped out.     

On the evolutionary origin of eukaryotic DNA methyltransferases and Dnmt2

The Dnmt2 enzymes show strong amino acid sequence similarity with eukaryotic and prokaryotic DNA-(cytosine C5)-methyltransferases. Yet, Dnmt2 enzymes from several species were shown to methylate tRNA-Asp and had been proposed that eukaryotic DNA methyltransferases evolved from a Dnmt2-like tRNA methyltransferase ancestor [Goll et al., 2006, Science, 311, 395-8]. It was the aim of this study to investigate if this hypothesis could be supported by evidence from sequence alignments. We present phylogenetic analyses based on sequence alignments of the methyltransferase catalytic domains of more than 2300 eukaryotic and prokaryotic DNA-(cytosine C5)-methyltransferases and analyzed the distribution of DNA methyltransferases in eukaryotic species. The Dnmt2 homologues were reliably identified by an additional conserved CFT motif next to motif IX. All DNA methyltransferases and Dnmt2 enzymes were clearly separated from other RNA-(cytosine-C5)-methyltransferases. Our sequence alignments and phylogenetic analyses indicate that the last universal eukaryotic ancestor contained at least one member of the Dnmt1, Dnmt2 and Dnmt3 families of enzymes and additional RNA methyltransferases. The similarity of Dnmt2 enzymes with DNA methyltransferases and absence of similarity with RNA methyltransferases combined with their strong RNA methylation activity suggest that the ancestor of Dnmt2 was a DNA methyltransferase and an early Dnmt2 enzyme changed its substrate preference to tRNA. There is no phylogenetic evidence that Dnmt2 was the precursor of eukaryotic Dnmts. Most likely, the eukaryotic Dnmt1 and Dnmt3 families of DNA methyltransferases had an independent origin in the prokaryotic DNA methyltransferase sequence space.     

Structure of RsrI methyltransferase, a member of the N6-adenine beta class of DNA methyltransferases

DNA methylation is important in cellular, developmental and disease processes, as well as in bacterial restriction-modification systems. Methylation of DNA at the amino groups of cytosine and adenine is a common mode of protection against restriction endonucleases afforded by the bacterial methyltransferases. The first structure of an N:6-adenine methyltransferase belonging to the beta class of bacterial methyltransferases is described here. The structure of M. RSR:I from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, which methylates the second adenine of the GAATTC sequence, was determined to 1.75 A resolution using X-ray crystallography. Like other methyltransferases, the enzyme contains the methylase fold and has well-defined substrate binding pockets. The catalytic core most closely resembles the PVU:II methyltransferase, a cytosine amino methyltransferase of the same beta group. The larger nucleotide binding pocket observed in M. RSR:I is expected because it methylates adenine. However, the most striking difference between the RSR:I methyltransferase and the other bacterial enzymes is the structure of the putative DNA target recognition domain, which is formed in part by two helices on an extended arm of the protein on the face of the enzyme opposite the active site. This observation suggests that a dramatic conformational change or oligomerization may take place during DNA binding and methylation.