EFFECTIVENESS OF CATEGORY AND LINE SCALES TO CHARACTERIZE CONSUMER PERCEPTION OF FRUITY FERMENTED FLAVOR IN PEANUTS

Fruity fermented (FF) flavor is a common off‐flavor in peanuts resulting from high‐temperature curing. The 9‐point hedonic scale is the most widely used scale to determine consumer acceptance; however, research has indicated that line scales may provide equal reliability and greater sensitivity. The objectives of this study were to characterize consumer perception of FF flavor in peanuts and to compare the effectiveness of the two scale types. Consumers (n = 208) evaluated control (no FF), low‐intensity (1.0) FF and high‐intensity (3.0) FF peanut pastes for the strength/intensity of roasted peanut flavor (RPF), sweet taste (ST), fresh peanut flavor (FPF) and overall liking (OV) using randomly assigned ballots. Sensitivity in defining consumer perception of off‐flavor in peanuts was greater with use of line scales than with the hedonic scale. The line scale indicated that FF flavor in peanuts, even at low intensity, negatively impacted OV and further identified significantly lower RPF and FPF perception by consumers. The hedonic scale identified only a difference in FPF and was not sensitive enough to show a difference in OV.     

PERCEPTION OF FAT IN A MILK MODEL SYSTEM USING MULTIDIMENSIONAL SCALING

This study examined the contributions of stimulus fat content and flavor volatiles to the perception of fat in a milk model system. The model system was formulated by adding bland vegetable oil (0%, 5%, or 10% w/v) and natural cream flavor (0%, 0.5% or 1% w/v) to a skim milk base. Panelists judged pairs of samples for similarity on the basis of three attributes (fat content, mouthcoating and thickness) and the results were analyzed using a multidimensional scaling procedure. Two-dimensional solutions best represented the data. The stimulus spaces for fat content and mouthcoating were visually similar to each other and provided reasonable separation of the samples. Instrumental measures helped to define the underlying dimensions of the stimulus space for fat content. Dimension 1 related to texture and included the contributions of viscosity, and fat particle size and number distribution; dimension 2 related to flavor perception. The sample with a moderate fat content (5%) and the highest concentration of added cream flavor (1%) was perceived to be similar to the 10% fat samples with added flavor. Thus, the added flavor provided the sensation of higher fat content. These data suggest that flavor plays an important role in the preception of fat in dairy foods. A psychophysical model of fat perception in dairy foods is proposed which includes the contribution of viscosity, fat particle size and number distribution, and volatile flavor perceptions.     

COMPARISON OF ATTRIBUTE LIKING AND JAR SCALES TO EVALUATE THE ADEQUACY OF SENSORY ATTRIBUTES OF MILK DESSERTS

Just-about-right (JAR) scales and attribute liking questions are usually used to study consumer perception of the sensory characteristics of food products. The aim of the present work was to compare the performance of attribute liking and JAR scales to evaluate consumers' perceived adequacy of flavor and texture of milk puddings. Two groups of consumers were asked to evaluate eight milk desserts using (1) overall liking followed by attribute liking for texture and flavor and (2) overall liking followed by JAR scales for thickness, creaminess, sweetness and vanilla flavor. Overall liking scores were significantly different when JAR scales or attribute liking questions were considered. Texture, flavor and overall liking scores were highly correlated to each other, providing the same information. JAR scales correlated better with the intensity of sensory attributes evaluated by a trained sensory panel, being JAR percentages a reliable tool to study the adequacy of sensory attributes.

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS

Results from the present work showed that consumers might not be able to independently evaluate their liking of different sensory attributes of a product. For this reason, the use of attribute liking questions for studying the adequacy of sensory attributes in complex products would not be recommended. JAR scales were better indicators of the adequacy of sensory attributes. Consumers were able to independently evaluate texture and flavor attributes using JAR scales. However, the influence of JAR scales on overall liking scores should be taken into account when including these scales on consumer studies.     

THE EFFECTS OF SUGARS AND ACIDS ON CONSUMER ACCEPTABILITY OF KIWIFRUIT

A kiwifruit (Actinidia deliciosa (A Chev) Liang et Ferguson cv Hayward) pulp was made using fruit harvested immature to minimize the presence of aroma volatiles. This pulp was modified by incorporating sugars and acids to simulate kiwifruit with a range of Brix and acid levels. Using sensory evaluation, flavor acceptability was found to increase with increasing Brix. As expected, perceived " sweetness intensity" increased with increasing Brix. Acidity did not influence flavor acceptability. At high Brix, sugars were able to suppress the effects of variations in acidity. Changes in Brix did not influence " flavor intensity", suggesting that aroma volatiles may be important contributors to kiwifruit flavor intensity.     

DISSIMILARITIES IN COGNITION OF FLAVOUR TERMS RELATED TO VARIOUS SENSORY LABORATORIES IN A MULTIVARIATE STUDY

A study of dissimilarities in cognitive perception of 20 common flavor terms was carried out by the Sensory Group of Norway. An average cognitive pattern of the flavor terms was revealed from multidimensional scaling (MDS) and cluster analysis (CLU). In general, small but interesting deviations between different sensory laboratories working with various food products were found by a multivariate pattern recognition technique based on principal component analysis (PCA). Suggestions for finding general reference standards for flavor terms are discussed.     

ASSOCIATION OF STRAWBERRY YOGURT SENSORY PROPERTIES WITH PRODUCT COMPOSITION BY PROCRUSTES ANALYSIS

The flavor of eight samples of commercial strawberry yogurt was studied by Free-Choice Profile analysis (FCP). Generalized Procrustes Analysis (GPA) applied to FCP allowed differentiation between samples and highlighted flavor attributes responsible for the observed differences. The relation between sensory and physicochemical datasets was studied by means of GPA. Those samples with higher carbohydrate content were perceived as sweeter, having stronger strawberry flavor, and with more dairy and yogurt flavors. Samples with higher titratable acidity, ash and protein content were perceived as more acidic and higher in intensity of "faulty" or "defective" flavors. Higher moisture content was associated with lower intensity of "dairy" flavors (creamy, dairy, and yogurt) and greater intensity of rancid flavor. It is concluded that, though not often used to this end, GPA is a suitable method to study the relationship of sensory and instrumental measurements.     

A STUDY OF TEXTURE-FLAVOR INTERACTIONS USING FREE-CHOICE PROFILING

Interactions between perceptions of texture and volatile flavors were assessed by free-choice profiling using gelatin desserts as a model product. Gels were prepared with all combinations of 2 levels of gelatin, and 2 concentrations of 2 different flavors. A trained sensory panel profiled each sample for aroma, flavor, and oral and manual texture. Generalized Procrustes Analysis was carried out separately for each sensory modality. The results indicate that while gelatin concentration and flavor type both modified perception of flavor, flavor concentration did not. Gelatin content influenced instrumental, oral, and manual evaluations of texture; however, the type and level of flavoring had little influence on oral perception of texture.     

TEXTURE-FLAVOR INTERACTIONS IN LOW FAT STIRRED YOGURT: HOW MECHANICAL TREATMENT, THICKENER CONCENTRATION AND AROMA CONCENTRATION AFFECT PERCEIVED TEXTURE AND FLAVOR

The influence of thickening agent (0 and 7g/L), mechanical treatment (low and high) and flavoring agent concentration (2.2 to 63.2 μL/kg) on texture, taste and aroma of low fat stirred yogurts was investigated through sensory profiling by a panel of ten subjects trained on 13 attributes. Two assessment conditions were used: either in the presence or in the absence of olfactory perception (nostrils closed with nose clips). Sensory differences were greater for texture than for the other perception modalities. Olfactory perception enhanced yogurt astringency. If both thickener addition and mechanical treatment influenced texture attributes and rheology, the second factor had the strongest effect. Texture attributes were highly correlated with rheological parameters. Increasing flavoring agent concentration tended to decrease thickness and the addition of thickening agent depressed green apple notes and sweet taste, suggesting texture/flavor interactions.     

VOLATILE FLAVOR COMPOUNDS AFFECTING CONSUMER ACCEPTABILITY OF KIWIFRUIT

Sensory research on kiwifruit has shown that specific sugars and acids, and volatile flavor compounds have causative effects on "sweet" and "acid" aroma and flavor attributes. New Zealand consumers (n = 162) assessed the perceived flavor intensity and acceptability of three volatile flavor compounds (ethyl butanoate, E-2-hexenal and hexanal) at varying levels in a model base solution. Increasing levels of ethyl butanoate positively affected all the acceptability attributes ("overall liking,""liking of aroma,""liking of flavor") as well as increased the perceived intensity of "kiwifruit aroma" and "kiwifruit flavor." Increasing levels of E-2-hexenal negatively affected all the acceptability attributes but increased the perceived intensity of "kiwifruit aroma" and "acid flavor." An increase in hexanal increased perceived intensity of "kiwifruit aroma." Ethyl butanoate and E-2-hexenel at the levels tested had the most prominent effects on consumer perceived intensity and acceptability of the "kiwifruit flavor."     

Measurement of sensitivity to olfactory flavor: application in a study of aging and dentures

Olfaction involves a dual sensory process for perceiving odors orthonasally (through the nostrils) and retronasally (through the mouth). This investigation entailed developing a measure of sensitivity to an odor delivered in an orally sampled food (orange flavoring in a sucrose-sweetened gelatin) and examining sensitivity in the elderly. In experiment 1, olfactory flavor sensitivity was 49 times lower in elderly (n = 21) than in young (n = 28) subjects. In experiment 2, with 73 elderly women, higher olfactory flavor sensitivity correlated significantly with higher orthonasal perception (Connecticut Chemosensory Clinical Research Center test). Some women, however, exhibited low olfactory flavor sensitivity despite high orthonasal perception; none had high olfactory flavor sensitivity and low orthonasal perception. Those who wore complete or palatal covering dentures had lower olfactory flavor sensitivity than those who were dentate or wore dentures that did not cover the palate. Through multiple regression analysis, orthonasal perception and denture status were found to be independent contributors to predicting olfactory flavor sensitivity. In summary, elderly subjects showed depressed olfactory flavor sensitivity (i.e. retronasal sensitivity) that related to poor orthonasal olfactory perception and denture characteristic. Thus, while good orthonasal olfaction may be necessary for good olfactory flavor sensitivity, it is not sufficient. Other factors, some associated with oral conditions, may impede release and retronasal transport of odors from the mouth to the olfactory receptors.     

TIME INTENSITY PROFILES OF FLAVOR POTENTIATORS (MSG, IMP, GMP)

This research characterized the time-intensity (TI) profiles of monosodium glutamate (MSG), disodium 5'-inosinate (IMP), and disodium 5'-guanylate (GMP). Twenty subjects rated total taste intensity of single solutions of 2.5, 5 and 10 mM MSG, 0.63 and 2.5 mM IMP and GMP, and some of their mixtures, using the TI method. The profiles generated were atypical of other taste modalities. Time to maximum intensity waslong (16–20s), followed by a plateau at maximum intensity, and a persistent aftertaste (50–96s duration). Maximum intensities of the samples varied (p < 0.001), with mixtures of 10 and 5 mM MSG with 2.5 mM IMP or GMP yielding the highest intensities. Similar differences were found for total duration and area under the curve. These results indicate that flavor potentiators may increase total flavor during consumption. Synergism between flavor potentiators was demonstrated.     

TIME-INTENSITY MEASUREMENT OF MATRIX EFFECTS ON RETRONASAL AROMA PERCEPTION

A computerized time intensity procedure was used to evaluate the retronasal aroma intensity of vanillin and limonene in oil/water emulsion. The maximum perceived retronasal intensity of limonene was decreased as oil content in the emulsion increased, but temporal perception (time to maximum intensity and total duration of perception) was not affected. Total duration of vanillin retronasal aroma increased as oil content increased, and salivary flow rate had a significant effect on perception of vanillin aroma. These results suggest that time intensity measurements may be a valuable tool for evaluating the effects of matrix interactions on retronasal aroma intensity.     

EFFICIENCY OF A CYCLIC DESIGN AND A MULTIDIMENSIONAL SCALING SENSORY ANALYSIS TECHNIQUE IN THE STUDY OF SALT TASTE

Multidimensional scaling (MDS) procedures produce maps of stimulus points, the dimensions of which may be sensory and/or physicochemical attributes. Our objective was to test the efficiencies of a cyclic design and a MDS method in the study of saltiness perception. Two levels of NaCl (0.1% and 0.2%, w/v) were added to two nonionic and two ionic gum solutions prepared to two concentrations. Subjects scaled dissimilarities between pairs of solutions and rated each sample for flavor attributes. Solution pairs were selected using cyclic designs. Repeated measures ANOVA determined that added NaCl was the only significant factor affecting saltiness perception. In contrast, from KYST-2A MDS maps, we concluded that saltiness perception was influenced by gum property, gum concentration, presence of calcium and potassium, and related to binding of the sodium ion (Na⁺) as determined by ²³Na nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The MDS cyclic design successfully reduced the number of samples and subjects when using experienced subjects.     

FLAVOR THRESHOLD AS AFFECTED BY INTERACTION AMONG THREE DAIRY‐RELATED FLAVOR COMPOUNDS*

The hypothesis of the present study was that the presence of one or more flavor compounds in a matrix would alter the perception (either enhance or suppress) of individual compounds as compared to a single flavor compound in a matrix. Thresholds were established for the flavor compounds (diacetyl, hexanal and δ‐decalactone) within each matrix; for each compound in the presence of a second compound; and for each compound in the presence of the remaining two compounds. An ascending order 2‐alternative forced choice test with 12 panelists was used for the evaluations. Results showed that diacetyl in water was suppressed by the presence of hexanal, but the presence of δ‐decalactone with hexanal reversed the trend. In the binary skim milk solutions diacetyl perception was enhanced, while being suppressed in the ternary solution. The perception of hexanal was enhanced in water (binary and ternary solutions). Hexanal and δ‐decalactone were suppressed in skim milk (binary and ternary solutions). δ‐Decalactone showed similar trends as hexanal in water, except that it was suppressed in the presence of diacetyl.     

DEVELOPMENT OF A LEXICON FOR THE DESCRIPTION OF PEANUT FLAVOR

A lexicon of terms to describe desirable as well as undesirable flavors in peanuts has been developed. The lexicon and an intensity rating scale was developed by a 13 member panel of flavor and peanut specialists representing industry and the USDA-Agricultural Research Service. This system is intended to provide definitive, common terminology for use in communicating differences in peanut flavor variables among all phases of peanut research and industry.