A mass spectrometry-based probe of equilibrium intermediates in protein-folding reactions

Described here is a mass spectrometry- and H/D exchange-based approach for the detection of equilibrium intermediate state(s) in protein-folding reactions. The approach utilizes the stability of unpurified proteins from rates of H/D exchange (SUPREX) technique to measure the m value (i.e., delta DeltaG/delta [denaturant] value) associated with the folding reaction of a protein. Such SUPREX m-value analyses can be made over a wide range of denaturant concentrations. Thus, the described approach is well-suited for the detection of high-energy intermediates that might be populated at low denaturant concentrations and hard to detect in conventional chemical denaturation experiments using spectroscopic probes. The approach is demonstrated on four known non-two-state folding proteins, including alpha-lactalbumin, cytochrome c, intestinal fatty acid binding protein (IFABP), and myoglobin. The non-two-state folding behavior of each model protein system was detected by the described method. The cytochrome c, myoglobin, and IFABP systems each had high-energy intermediate states that were undetected in conventional optical spectroscopy-based studies and previously required other more specialized biophysical approaches (e.g., nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy-based methods and protease protection assays) for their detection. The SUPREX-based approach outlined here offers an attractive alternative to these other approaches, because it has the advantage of speed and the ability to analyze both purified and unpurified protein samples in either concentrated or dilute solution.     

Accuracy and precision of a new H/D exchange- and mass spectrometry-based technique for measuring the thermodynamic properties of protein-peptide complexes

A new H/D exchange- and MALDI mass spectrometry-based technique, termed SUPREX, was used to characterize the thermodynamic properties of a series of model protein-peptide complexes of the Abelson tyrosine kinase SH3 domain (abl-SH3) and the S-Protein (S-Pro). The SUPREX technique was employed to evaluate the folding free energies (DeltaG(f) values) of each model protein in the absence and in the presence of a series of different peptide ligands. Ultimately, these SUPREX-derived DeltaG(f) values were used to calculate dissociation constants (K(d) values) for each of the nine protein-peptide complexes in this study. As part of this work, we describe a new data collection and analysis method that allows the accurate and precise determination of protein folding m-values in the SUPREX experiment. The m-values that we determined for the abl-SH3 domain and the S-Pro system were in good agreement with those determined by conventional techniques. Our results also indicate that the SUPREX-derived K(d) values for the protein-peptide complexes in this work were in reasonably good agreement with those determined by conventional techniques.     

SUPREX (Stability of Unpurified Proteins from Rates of H/D Exchange) analysis of the thermodynamics of synergistic anion binding by ferric-binding protein (FbpA), a bacterial transferrin

SUPREX (stability of unpurified proteins from rates of H/D exchange) is a H/D exchange- and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI)-based technique for characterizing the equilibrium unfolding/refolding properties of proteins and protein-ligand complexes. Here, we describe the application of SUPREX to the thermodynamic analysis of synergistic anion binding to iron-loaded ferric-binding protein (Fe(3+)FbpA-X, X = synergistic anion). The in vivo function of FbpA is to transport unchelated Fe(3+) across the periplasmic space of certain Gram-negative bacteria, a process that requires simultaneous binding of a synergistic anion. Our results indicate that Fe(3+)FbpA-X is not a so-called "ideal" protein system for SUPREX analyses because it does not exhibit two-state folding properties and it does not exhibit EX2 H/D exchange behavior. However, despite these nonideal properties of the Fe(3+)FbpA-X protein-folding/unfolding reaction, we demonstrate that the SUPREX technique is still amenable to the quantitative thermodynamic analysis of synergistic anion binding to Fe(3+)FbpA. As part of this work, the SUPREX technique was used to evaluate the DeltaDeltaG(f) values of four synergistic anion-containing complexes of Fe(3+)FbpA (i.e., Fe(3+)FbpA-PO(4), Fe(3+)FbpA-citrate, Fe(3+)FbpA-AsO(4), and Fe(3+)FbpA-SO(4)). The DeltaDeltaG(f) value obtained for Fe(3+)FbpA-citrate relative to Fe(3+)FbpA-PO(4) (1.45 +/- 0.44 kcal/mol), is in good agreement with that reported previously (1.98 kcal/mol). The value obtained for Fe(3+)FbpA-AsO(4) (0.58 +/- 0.45 kcal/mol) was also consistent with that reported previously (0.68 kcal/mol), but the measurement error is very close to the magnitude of the value. This work (i) demonstrates the utility of the SUPREX method for studying anion binding by FbpA, (ii) provides the first evaluation of a DeltaDeltaG(f) value for Fe(3+)FbpA-SO(4), -1.43 +/- 0.17 kcal/mol, and (iii) helps substantiate our hypothesis that the synergistic anion plays a role in controlling the lability of iron bound to FbpA in the transport process.     

Quantitative protein stability measurement in vivo

The equilibrium between the native and denatured states of a protein can be key to its function and regulation. Traditionally, the folding equilibrium constant has been measured in vitro using purified protein and simple buffers. However, the biological environment of proteins can differ from these in vitro conditions in ways that could significantly perturb stability. Here, we present the first quantitative comparison between the stability of a protein in vitro and in the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli using amide hydrogen exchange detected by MALDI mass spectrometry (SUPREX). The results indicate that the thermodynamic stability of monomeric lambda repressor within the cell is the same as its stability measured in a simple buffer in vitro. However, when the E. coli are placed in a hyperosmotic environment, the in vivo stability is greatly enhanced. The in vivo SUPREX method provides a general and quantitative way to measure protein stabilities in the cell and will be useful for applications where intracellular stability information provides important biological insights.     

Ex vivo analysis of synergistic anion binding to FbpA in Gram-negative bacteria

Ferric binding protein, FbpA, is a member of the transferrin superfamily whose function is to move an essential nutrient, iron, across the periplasm and into the cytosol through formation of a ternary complex containing Fe (3+) and a synergistic anion, X. Here we utilize SUPREX ( stability of unpurified proteins from rates of H/D exchange) to determine the identification and distribution of the synergistic anion in FeFbpA-X species in periplasmic preparations from Gram-negative bacteria. SUPREX is a mass spectrometry-based technique uniquely suited for thermodynamic analyses of protein-ligand complexes in complex biological mixtures such as periplasmic preparations. Model binary mixtures of FeFbpA-Cit and FeFbpA-PO 4 were initially characterized by SUPREX due to the likely presence of citrate and phosphate ions in the periplasm. Ex vivo SUPREX analyses were performed on FeFbpA-X species overexpressed in an Escherichia coli cell line and on endogenous FeFbpA-X species in Neisseria gonorrheae. Detected in the E. coli periplasmic extract were two distinct populations of FbpA, including one in which the protein was unliganded (i.e., apoFbpA) and one in which the protein was bound to iron and the synergistic anion, phosphate (i.e., FeFbpA-PO 4). FeFbpA-PO 4 was the only population of FbpA molecules detected in the N. gonorrheae periplasmic extract. This work provides the first determination of the identity of the in vivo anion bound to FeFbpA-X in the periplasm and substantiates the hypothesis that the synergistic anion plays a structural and functional role in FbpA-mediated transport of iron across the periplasm and into the cytosol.     

Sequential binding and sensing of Zn(II) by Bacillus subtilis Zur

Bacillus subtilis Zur (BsZur) represses high-affinity zinc-uptake systems and alternative ribosomal proteins in response to zinc replete conditions. Sequence alignments and structural studies of related Fur family proteins suggest that BsZur may contain three zinc-binding sites (sites 1-3). Mutational analyses confirm the essential structural role of site 1, while mutants affected in sites 2 and 3 retain partial repressor function. Purified BsZur binds a maximum of two Zn(II) per monomer at site 1 and site 2. Site 3 residues are important for dimerization, but do not directly bind Zn(II). Analyses of metal-binding affinities reveals negative cooperativity between the two site 2 binding events in each dimer. DNA-binding studies indicate that BsZur is sequentially activated from an inactive dimer (Zur(2):Zn(2)) to a partially active asymmetric dimer (Zur(2):Zn(3)), and finally to the fully zinc-loaded active form (Zur(2):Zn(4)). BsZur with a C84S mutation in site 2 forms a Zur(2):Zn(3) form with normal metal- and DNA-binding affinities but is impaired in formation of the Zur(2):Zn(4) high affinity DNA-binding state. This mutant retains partial repressor activity in vivo, thereby supporting a model in which stepwise activation by zinc serves to broaden the physiological response to a wider range of metal concentrations.     

Lambda repressor mutants that are better substrates for RecA-mediated cleavage

RecA-mediated cleavage of the bacteriophage lambda repressor results in inactivation of the protein and leads to induction of the lambda prophage. Here, we report the identification of three mutations in lambda repressor that significantly increase the rate of RecA-mediated cleavage. These mutations were isolated as intragenic second-site suppressors of a mutation (ind-) which prevents cleavage. Purified repressor proteins that contain both the ind- mutation and one of the second-site mutations undergo cleavage at near wild-type rates. Purified repressors that contain the second-site mutations in otherwise wild-type backgrounds undergo RecA-mediated cleavage at significantly faster rates than wild-type, and form dimers more poorly than the wild-type protein. In related experiments, we found that other repressor mutants that dimerize poorly are also better substrates for RecA-mediated cleavage. Conversely, we show that a covalent disulfide-bonded repressor dimer is resistant to cleavage. These results support a model in which repressor monomers are the only substrate in the cleavage reaction.     

Role of protein--protein interactions in the regulation of transcription by trp repressor investigated by fluorescence spectroscopy.

In the present work, we have characterized the protein--protein interactions in the trp repressor (TR) from Escherichia coli using fluorescence spectroscopy. The steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy of repressor labeled with 5-(dimethylamino)naphthalene-1-sulfonamide (DNS) was used to monitor subunit equilibria in the absence and presence of corepressor. In the absence of tryptophan, the repressor is in equilibrium between tetramers and dimers in the concentration range studied (approximately 0.04-40 microM in dimer). Binding of corepressor resulted in a marked destabilization of the tetramer. The beginning of a dimer-monomer dissociation transition was observed by monitoring the decrease in the intrinsic tryptophan emission energy upon dilution below 0.1 microM in dimer, indicating an upper limit for the dimer-dissociation constant near 1 nM. DNA titrations with a 26 base pair sequence containing the trp EDCBA operator performed in the absence and presence of the corepressor are consistent with a 1:1 dimer/operator stoichiometry in the presence of tryptophan, while the aporepressor binds with TR dimer/DNA stoichiometries greater than one and which depend upon both the concentration of protein and that of the operator. Using the multiple observable parameters available in fluorescence, we have thus carried out a thorough investigation of the coupled equilibria in this bacterial repressor. Our results are consistent with a physiologically relevant thermodynamic role for tetramerization in the regulatory function of the trp repressor. The present results which have brought to light novel protein--protein interactions in the trp repressor system indicate that fluorescence spectroscopic methods could prove quite useful in the study of the role of protein--protein interactions in eukaryotic systems as well.     

Tubulin-associated nucleoside diphosphokinase.

Microtubule protein, prepared by cycles of polymerisation and dissociation, contained a nucleoside diphosphokinase (NDP kinase) activity (EC 2.7.4.6). This activity was not intrinsic to the tubulin dimer or the so-called microtubule-associated proteins. The NDP kinase had the following properties. (1) The enzyme existed in a low-molecular-weight form and in association with the complex of microtubule-associated proteins and tubulin (i.e. multimeric tubulin). (2) The low-molecular-weight species was also formed by dissociation of multimeric tubulin by salt or by removal of microtubule-associated proteins on phosphocellulose. (3) GDP bound to the exchangeable site of multimeric tubulin and also GDP derived from the E site of the tubulin dimer was a substrate for the NDP kinase. (4) The NDP kinase showed a 7-fold increase in activity during ATP-dependent microtubule assembly. On the basis of these properties, it is proposed that microtubule protein contains an NDP kinase specifically associated with tubulin and its functions.     

Probing the topological tolerance of multimeric protein interactions: evaluation of an estrogen/synthetic ligand for FK506 binding protein conjugate

Bivalent small molecules composed of a targeting element and an element that recruits endogenous proteins have been shown to block protein-protein interactions in some systems. We have attempted to apply such an approach to disrupt the interaction of the estrogen receptor α with either its associated coactivators or its dimerization partner (i.e., another estrogen receptor). We show here that a conjugate capable of simultaneously binding both the estrogen receptor and a recruited protein (FK506 Binding Protein 12 kDa) is, however, incapable of disrupting the multimeric estrogen receptor dimer/coactivator complex both in vitro and in cell-based reporter gene assays. We postulate why it may not be possible to disrupt this particular protein-protein complex-as well as other systems having high topological tolerance-with such bivalent inhibitors.     

Analysis of the stability of multimeric proteins by effective DeltaG and effective m-values

Analyzing the stability of a multimeric protein is challenging because of the intrinsic difficulty in handling the mathematical model for the folded multimer-unfolded monomer equilibrium. To circumvent this problem, we introduce the concept of effective stability, DeltaGeff (= -RTlnKeff), where Keff is the equilibrium constant expressed in monomer units. Analysis of the denaturant effect on DeltaGeff gives new insight into the stability of multimeric proteins. When a multimeric protein is mostly folded, the dependence of effective stability on denaturant concentration (effective m-value) is simply the m-value of its monomeric unit. However, when the protein is mostly unfolded, its stability depends on denaturant concentration with the m-value of its multimeric form. We also find that the effective m-value at the Cm is a good approximation of the apparent m-value determined by fitting the equilibrium unfolding data from multimeric proteins with a two-state monomer model. Moreover, when the m-value of a monomeric unit is estimated from its size, the effective stability of a multimeric protein can be determined simply from Cm and this estimated m-value. These simple and intuitive approaches will allow a facile analysis of the stability of multimeric proteins. These analyses are also applicable for high-throughput analysis of protein stability on a proteomic scale.     

M-TASSER: an algorithm for protein quaternary structure prediction

In a cell, it has been estimated that each protein on average interacts with roughly 10 others, resulting in tens of thousands of proteins known or suspected to have interaction partners; of these, only a tiny fraction have solved protein structures. To partially address this problem, we have developed M-TASSER, a hierarchical method to predict protein quaternary structure from sequence that involves template identification by multimeric threading, followed by multimer model assembly and refinement. The final models are selected by structure clustering. M-TASSER has been tested on a benchmark set comprising 241 dimers having templates with weak sequence similarity and 246 without multimeric templates in the dimer library. Of the total of 207 targets predicted to interact as dimers, 165 (80%) were correctly assigned as interacting with a true positive rate of 68% and a false positive rate of 17%. The initial best template structures have an average root mean-square deviation to native of 5.3, 6.7, and 7.4 Å for the monomer, interface, and dimer structures. The final model shows on average a root mean-square deviation improvement of 1.3, 1.3, and 1.5 Å over the initial template structure for the monomer, interface, and dimer structures, with refinement evident for 87% of the cases. Thus, we have developed a promising approach to predict full-length quaternary structure for proteins that have weak sequence similarity to proteins of solved quaternary structure.     

LexA repressor forms stable dimers in solution. The role of specific dna in tightening protein-protein interactions

Cooperativity in the interactions among proteins subunits and DNA is crucial for DNA recognition. LexA repressor was originally thought to bind DNA as a monomer, with cooperativity leading to tighter binding of the second monomer. The main support for this model was a high value of the dissociation constant for the LexA dimer (micromolar range). Here we show that the protein is a dimer at nanomolar concentrations under different conditions. The reversible dissociation of LexA dimer was investigated by the effects of hydrostatic pressure or urea, using fluorescence emission and polarization to monitor the dissociation process. The dissociation constant lies in the picomolar range (lower than 20 pM). LexA monomers associate with an unusual large volume change (340 ml/mol), indicating the burial of a large surface area upon dimerization. Whereas nonspecific DNA has no stabilizing effect, specific DNA induces tightening of the dimer and a 750-fold decrease in the K(d). In contrast to the previous model, a tight dimer rather than a monomer is the functional repressor. Accordingly, the LexA dimer only loses its ability to recognize a specific DNA sequence by RecA-induced autoproteolysis. Our work provides insights into the linkage between protein-protein interactions, DNA recognition, and DNA repair.