Mechanical unfolding pathways of the enhanced yellow fluorescent protein revealed by single molecule force spectroscopy

We used single molecule force spectroscopy to characterize the mechanical stability of the enhanced yellow fluorescent protein (EYFP) (a mutant form of the green fluorescent protein (GFP)) and two of its circularly permutated variants. In all three constructs, we found two main unfolding peaks; the first corresponds to a transition state placed close to the termini and the second to a transition state placed halfway through the molecule. We attribute the second transition state to the shear rupture of the beta1- and beta6-strands, which we verified by introducing a point mutation in this region. Although both unfolding peaks were observed in all three EYFP variants, their relative frequency of occurrence varied. Our results demonstrated that the mechanical unfolding pathways in EYFP could be deciphered through the use of circular permutation.     

A novel pattern recognition algorithm to classify membrane protein unfolding pathways with high-throughput single-molecule force spectroscopy

MOTIVATION: Misfolding of membrane proteins plays an important role in many human diseases such as retinitis pigmentosa, hereditary deafness and diabetes insipidus. Little is known about membrane proteins as there are only very few high-resolution structures. Single-molecule force spectroscopy is a novel technique, which measures the force necessary to pull a protein out of a membrane. Such force curves contain valuable information on the protein structure, conformation, and inter- and intra-molecular forces. High-throughput force spectroscopy experiments generate hundreds of force curves including spurious ones and good curves, which correspond to different unfolding pathways. Manual analysis of these data is a bottleneck and source of inconsistent and subjective annotation. RESULTS: We propose a novel algorithm for the identification of spurious curves and curves representing different unfolding pathways. Our algorithm proceeds in three stages: first, we reduce noise in the curves by applying dimension reduction; second, we align the curves with dynamic programming and compute pairwise distances and third, we cluster the curves based on these distances. We apply our method to a hand-curated dataset of 135 force curves of bacteriorhodopsin mutant P50A. Our algorithm achieves a success rate of 81% distinguishing spurious from good curves and a success rate of 76% classifying unfolding pathways. As a result, we discuss five different unfolding pathways of bacteriorhodopsin including three main unfolding events and several minor ones. Finally, we link folding barriers to the degree of conservation of residues. Overall, the algorithm tackles the force spectroscopy bottleneck and leads to more consistent and reproducible results paving the way for high-throughput analysis of structural features of membrane proteins.     

Pulling geometry-induced errors in single molecule force spectroscopy measurements

In AFM-based single molecule force spectroscopy, it is tacitly assumed that the pulling direction coincides with the end-to-end vector of the molecule fragment being stretched. By systematically varying the position of the attachment point on the substrate relative to the AFM tip, we investigate empirically and theoretically the effect of the pulling geometry on force-extension characteristics of double-stranded DNA. We find that increasing the pulling angle can significantly lower the force of the characteristic overstretching transition and increase the width of the plateau feature beyond the canonical 70%. These effects, when neglected, can adversely affect the interpretation of measured force-extension relationships. We quantitatively evaluate force and extension errors originating from this "pulling angle effect" and stress the need to correct the pulling geometry when stretching rigid molecules with an AFM.     

Discriminating small molecule DNA binding modes by single molecule force spectroscopy

Drugs may interact with double stranded DNA via a variety of binding modes, each mode giving rise to a specific pharmacological function. Here we demonstrate the ability of single molecule force spectroscopy to discriminate between different interaction modes by measuring the mechanical properties of DNA and their modulation upon the binding of small molecules. Due to the unique topology of double stranded DNA and due to its base pair stacking pattern, DNA undergoes several well-characterised structural transitions upon stretching. We show that small molecule binding markedly affects these transitions in ways characteristic to the binding mode and that these effects can be detected at the level of an individual molecule. The minor groove binder berenil, the crosslinker cisplatin and the intercalator ethidium bromide are compared.     

Minimizing pulling geometry errors in atomic force microscope single molecule force spectroscopy

In atomic force microscopy-based single molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS), it is assumed that the pulling angle is negligible and that the force applied to the molecule is equivalent to the force measured by the instrument. Recent studies, however, have indicated that the pulling geometry errors can drastically alter the measured force-extension relationship of molecules. Here we describe a software-based alignment method that repositions the cantilever such that it is located directly above the molecule's substrate attachment site. By aligning the applied force with the measurement axis, the molecule is no longer undergoing combined loading, and the full force can be measured by the cantilever. Simulations and experimental results verify the ability of the alignment program to minimize pulling geometry errors in AFM-SMFS studies.     

DNA base pair resolution by single molecule force spectroscopy

The forces that hold complementary strands of DNA together in a double helix, and the role of base mismatches in these, are examined by single molecule force spectroscopy using an atomic force microscope (AFM). These forces are important when considering the binding of proteins to DNA, since these proteins often mechanically stretch the DNA during their action. In AFM measurement of forces, there is an inherent instrumental limitation that makes it difficult to compare results from different experimental runs. This is circumvented by using an oligonucleotide microarray, which allowed a direct comparison of the forces between perfectly matched short oligonucleotides and those containing a single or double mismatch. Through this greatly increased sensitivity, the force contribution of a single AT base pair was derived. The results indicate that the contribution to forces from the stacking interactions is more important than that from hydrogen bonding.     

alpha-Synuclein misfolding: single molecule AFM force spectroscopy study

Protein misfolding and aggregation are the very first and critical steps in development of various neurodegenerative disorders, including Parkinson’s disease, induced by misfolding of α-synuclein. Thus, elucidating properties of proteins in misfolded states and understanding the mechanisms of their assembly into the disease prone aggregates are critical for the development of rational approaches to prevent protein misfolding-mediated pathologies. To accomplish this goal and as a first step to elucidate the mechanism of α-synuclein misfolding, we applied single-molecule force spectroscopy capable of detecting protein misfolding. We immobilized α-synuclein molecules at their C-termini at the atomic force microscope tips and substrate surfaces, and measured the interaction between the proteins by probing the microscope tip at various locations on the surface. Using this approach, we detected α-synuclein misfolded states by enhanced interprotein interaction. We used a dynamics force spectroscopy approach to measure such an important characteristic of dimers of misfolded α-synuclein as their lifetimes. We found that the dimer lifetimes are in the range of seconds and these values are much higher than the characteristics for the dynamics of the protein in monomeric state. These data show that compared to highly dynamic monomeric forms, α-synuclein dimers are much more stable and thus can serve as stable nuclei for the formation of multimeric and aggregated forms of α-synuclein. Importantly, two different lifetimes were observed for the dimers, suggesting that aggregation can follow different pathways that may lead to different aggregated morphologies of α-synuclein.     

Atomic force microscopy imaging and single molecule recognition force spectroscopy of coat proteins on the surface of Bacillus subtilis spore

Coat assembly in Bacillus subtilis serves as a tractable model for the study of the self-assembly process of biological structures and has a significant potential for use in nano-biotechnological applications. In the present study, the morphology of B. subtilis spores was investigated by magnetically driven dynamic force microscopy (MAC mode atomic force microscopy) under physiological conditions. B. subtilis spores appeared as prolate structures, with a length of 0.6-3 microm and a width of about 0.5-2 microm. The spore surface was mainly covered with bump-like structures with diameters ranging from 8 to 70 nm. Besides topographical explorations, single molecule recognition force spectroscopy (SMRFS) was used to characterize the spore coat protein CotA. This protein was specifically recognized by a polyclonal antibody directed against CotA (anti-CotA), the antibody being covalently tethered to the AFM tip via a polyethylene glycol linker. The unbinding force between CotA and anti-CotA was determined as 55 +/- 2 pN. From the high-binding probability of more than 20% in force-distance cycles it is concluded that CotA locates in the outer surface of B. subtilis spores.     

Atomic force microscope-based single-molecule force spectroscopy of RNA unfolding

Over the past 10 years, a growing field of research supporting the value of myeloperoxidase (MPO) as a prognostic indicator in acute cardiac pathophysiologies has emerged. The availability of a rapid and disposable MPO detection platform would enable research clinicians to more readily assess MPO indications for guiding therapy and also facilitate clinicians at the patient interface to readily adopt MPO testing and potentially drive more informed prognoses. Here we describe the isolation of a high-affinity avian MPO-specific recombinant antibody panel using phage display. Rapid isolation of a suitable single-chain variable fragment (scFv) antibody was facilitated using a surface plasmon resonance (SPR)-based “off-rate ranking” screening process. The selected scFv was then successfully incorporated into a rapid, simple, and sensitive one-step lateral flow immunoassay (LFIA) for the detection of MPO. This “one-step” feature of the developed assay was made possible by the scFv’s strong affinity for MPO, obviating the need for sandwich signal enhancement steps. The assay’s rapid performance was also further enhanced by exploiting the intrinsic enzymatic properties of MPO in its final detection. Use of the optimized LFIA facilitated the sensitive detection of MPO in MPO-depleted serum within clinically relevant reference ranges.     

Atomic force microscope-based single-molecule force spectroscopy of RNA unfolding

Single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) using the atomic force microscope (AFM) has emerged as an important tool for probing biomolecular interaction and exploring the forces, dynamics, and energy landscapes that underlie function and specificity of molecular interaction. These studies require attaching biomolecules on solid supports and AFM tips to measure unbinding forces between individual binding partners. Herein we describe efficient and robust protocols for probing RNA interaction by AFM and show their value on two well-known RNA regulators, the Rev-responsive element (RRE) from the HIV-1 genome and an adenine-sensing riboswitch. The results show the great potential of AFM–SMFS in the investigation of RNA molecular interactions, which will contribute to the development of bionanodevices sensing single RNA molecules.     

Membrane-based actuation for high-speed single molecule force spectroscopy studies using AFM

Atomic force microscopy (AFM)-based dynamic force spectroscopy of single molecular interactions involves characterizing unbinding/unfolding force distributions over a range of pulling speeds. Owing to their size and stiffness, AFM cantilevers are adversely affected by hydrodynamic forces, especially at pulling speeds >10 μm/s, when the viscous drag becomes comparable to the unbinding/unfolding forces. To circumvent these adverse effects, we have fabricated polymer-based membranes capable of actuating commercial AFM cantilevers at speeds ≥100 μm/s with minimal viscous drag effects. We have used FLUENT^®, a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software, to simulate high-speed pulling and fast actuation of AFM cantilevers and membranes in different experimental configurations. The simulation results support the experimental findings on a variety of commercial AFM cantilevers and predict significant reduction in drag forces when membrane actuators are used. Unbinding force experiments involving human antibodies using these membranes demonstrate that it is possible to achieve bond loading rates ≥10⁶ pN/s, an order of magnitude greater than that reported with commercial AFM cantilevers and systems.     

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy: molecular recognition at the single molecule level

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) is a fluorescence microscopy technique that allows the study of molecular interactions in extremely low volumes, at nanomolar concentrations, even when binding is not accompanied by a fluorescence change. It can be applied directly in living cells. FCS clearly considerably extends the possibilities of the classical techniques used in molecular recognition studies and can be considered to belong to a growing group of techniques that allow detection at the single molecule level. In this review, several applications of FCS, both in vitro and in vivo, will be discussed.     

Unfolding mechanics of multiple OspA substructures investigated with single molecule force spectroscopy

We investigated mechanical unfolding of Borrelia burgdorferi outer surface protein A (OspA), a Lyme disease antigen containing a unique single-layer beta-sheet, with atomic force microscopy (AFM). We mechanically stretched a monomeric unit, rather than a tandem repeat, by pulling it from its N and C-terminal residues without using intervening polymer as a spacer. We detected two peaks in the force-extension profile before the final rupture of a fully extended polypeptide, which we interpreted as unfolding of multiple substructures in OspA. The double-peaked unfolding curves are consistent with results of previous thermodynamic studies showing two cooperative units in OspA. The mechanical unfolding processes were reversible, and the two substructures refolded within one second. Mutations near the boundary of the two thermodynamic cooperative units reduced the height of the first unfolding peak to undetectable levels and marginally affected the second one, indicating that the boundary between the two mechanical substructures is related to that previously assigned between the thermodynamic cooperative units. Based on a "worm-like chain" analysis of our AFM data, we propose a model for mechanical unfolding of OspA, where nearly a half of the chain is stretched with minimal resistive force, followed by sequential breakdown of C-terminal and N-terminal substructures. Based on these results, we discuss similarities and differences between mechanical and thermodynamic unfolding reactions of OspA. This work demonstrates that AFM study of monomeric proteins can elucidate details of the intramolecular mechanics of protein substructures.     

Single molecule recognition between cytochrome C 551 and gold-immobilized azurin by force spectroscopy

Recent developments in single molecule force spectroscopy have allowed investigating the interaction between two redox partners, Azurin and Cytochrome C 551. Azurin has been directly chemisorbed on a gold electrode whereas cytochrome c has been linked to the atomic force microscopy tip by means of a heterobifunctional flexible cross-linker. When recording force-distance cycles, molecular recognition events could be observed, displaying unbinding forces of approximately 95 pN for an applied loading rate of 10 nN/s. The specificity of molecular recognition was confirmed by the significant decrease of unbinding probability observed in control block experiments performed adding free azurin solution in the fluid cell. In addition, the complex dissociation kinetics has been here investigated by monitoring the unbinding forces as a function of the loading rate: the thermal off-rate was estimated to be approximately 14 s(-1), much higher than values commonly estimated for complexes more stable than electron transfer complexes. Results here discussed represent the first studies on molecular recognition between two redox partners by atomic force microscopy.     

Covalent immobilization of recombinant fusion proteins with hAGT for single molecule force spectroscopy

A genetically modified form of the human DNA repair protein O⁶-alkylguanine-DNA-alkyltransferase (hAGT) was used to immobilize different recombinant hAGT fusion proteins covalently and selectively on gold and glass surfaces. Fusion proteins of hAGT with Glutathione S-Transferase and with tandem repeats of Titin Ig-domains, were produced and anchored via amino-polyethylene glycol benzylguanine. Anchoring was characterized and quantified with surface plasmon resonance, atomic force microscope and fluorescence measurements. Individual fusion proteins were unfolded by single molecule force spectroscopy corroborating the selectivity of the covalent attachment.     

Single molecule force spectroscopy in biology using the atomic force microscope

The importance of forces in biology has been recognized for quite a while but only in the past decade have we acquired instrumentation and methodology to directly measure interactive forces at the level of single biological macromolecules and/or their complexes. This review focuses on force measurements performed with the atomic force microscope. A general introduction to the principle of action is followed by review of the types of interactions being studied, describing the main results and discussing the biological implications.     

Detection of metal binding sites on functional S-layer nanoarrays using single molecule force spectroscopy

Crystalline bacterial cell surface layers (S-layers) show the ability to recrystallize into highly regular pattern on solid supports. In this study, the genetically modified S-layer protein SbpA of Lysinibacillus sphaericus CCM 2177, carrying a hexa-histidine tag (His₆-tag) at the C-terminus, was used to generate functionalized two-dimensional nanoarrays on a silicon surface. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) was applied to explore the topography and the functionality of the fused His₆-tags. The accessibility of the His₆-tags was demonstrated by in-situ anti-His-tag antibody binding to the functional S-layer array. The metal binding properties of the His₆-tag was investigated by single molecule force microscopy. For this purpose, newly developed tris–NTA was tethered to the AFM tips via a flexible polyethylene glycol (PEG) linker. The functionalized tips showed specific interactions with S-layer containing His₆-tags in the presence of nickel ions. Thus the His₆-tag is located at the outer surface of the S-layer and can be used for stable but reversible attachment of functional tris–NTA derivatives.     

Monte Carlo simulation for single RNA unfolding by force

Using polymer elastic theory and known RNA free energies, we construct a Monte Carlo algorithm to simulate the single RNA folding and unfolding by mechanical force on the secondary structure level. For the constant force ensemble, we simulate the force-extension curves of the P5ab, P5abc deltaA, and P5abc molecules in equilibrium. For the constant extension ensemble, we focus on the mechanical behaviors of the RNA P5ab molecule, which include the unfolding force dependence on the pulling speed, the force-hysteresis phenomenon, and the coincidence of stretching-relaxing force-curves in thermal equilibrium. We particularly simulate the time traces of the end-to-end distance of the P5ab under the constant force in equilibrium, which also have been recorded in the recent experiment. The reaction rate constants for the folding and unfolding are calculated. Our results show that the agreement between the simulation and the experimental measurements is satisfactory.     

Characterization of enhanced monovalent and bivalent thrombin DNA aptamer binding using single molecule force spectroscopy

Thrombin aptamer binding strength and stability is dependent on sterical parameters when used for atomic force microscopy sensing applications. Sterical improvements on the linker chemistry were developed for high-affinity binding. For this we applied single molecule force spectroscopy using two enhanced biotinylated thrombin aptamers, BFF and BFA immobilized on the atomic force microscopy tip via streptavidin. BFF is a dimer composed of two single-stranded aptamers (aptabody) connected to each other by a complementary sequence close to the biotinylated end. In contrast, BFA consists of a single DNA strand and a complementary strand in the supporting biotinylated part. By varying the pulling velocity in force-distance cycles the formed thrombin-aptamer complexes were ruptured at different force loadings allowing determination of the energy landscape. As a result, BFA aptamer showed a higher binding force at the investigated loading rates and a significantly lower dissociation rate constant, k_off, compared to BFF. Moreover, the potential of the aptabody BFF to form a bivalent complex could clearly be demonstrated.