Thioflavin T interaction with amyloid fibrils as an instrument for their studying

Benzthiazole dye thioflavin T (ThT) is widely used to study the formation and structure of amyloid fibrils. Nevertheless, till now there is no common opinion concerning molecular mechanisms of ThT binding to amyloid fibrils and the reasons of dramatic increase in its fluorescence quantum yield on incorporation into amyloid fibrils. Our data prove that ThT molecules incorporate in the amyloid fibrils in the monomeric form and there is no ground to suppose the formation of ThT dimers, eximers, or micells. It was shown that the increase in the quantum yield of ThT incorporated in amyloid fibrils was caused by restriction of benzthiazole and aminobenzene rings torsion fluctuations relative to each other. The use of equilibrium microdialysis allowed determining the absorption spectrum, the number of binding modes of ThT with insulin amyloid fibrils and for each mode determining the binding constants and the number of binding sites for each mode.     

A New Trend in the Experimental Methodology for the Analysis of the Thioflavin T Binding to Amyloid Fibrils

The studies on the determination of the characteristics of the amyloid fibril interaction with the dye were based on the analysis of the dependence of the ThT fluorescence intensity on its concentration in the solution containing the amyloid fibrils. In the present work, we revealed that this intuitive approach provided erroneous data. We propose a new approach which provides a means for characterizing the interaction of thioflavin T (ThT) with amyloid fibrils and for determining the binding stoichiometry and binding constants, absorption spectrum, molar extinction coefficient, and fluorescence quantum yield of the ThT bound to the sites of different binding modes of fibrils. The key point of this approach is sample preparation by equilibrium microdialysis. The efficiency of the proposed approach is demonstrated via the examination of the ThT binding to insulin and Aβ42 fibrils as well as to the native form of the Electrophorus electricus acetylcholinesterase. We show that the peculiarities of ThT interaction with amyloid fibrils depend on the amyloidogenic protein and on the binding mode. This approach is universal and can be used for the analysis of binding mechanism of any dye that interacts with its receptor. Therefore, the proposed approach represents an important addition to the existing arsenal of means for the diagnostics and therapy of the neurodegenerative diseases.     

Detection and characterization of aggregates, prefibrillar amyloidogenic oligomers, and protofibrils using fluorescence spectroscopy

Transthyretin (TTR) is a protein linked to a number of different amyloid diseases including senile systemic amyloidosis and familial amyloidotic polyneuropathy. The transient nature of oligomeric intermediates of misfolded TTR that later mature into fibrillar aggregates makes them hard to study, and methods to study these species are sparse. In this work we explore a novel pathway for generation of prefibrillar aggregates of TTR, which provides important insight into TTR misfolding. Prefibrillar amyloidogenic oligomers and protofibrils of misfolded TTR were generated in vitro through induction of the molten globule type A-state from acid unfolded TTR through the addition of NaCl. The aggregation process produced fairly monodisperse oligomers (300-500 kD) within 2 h that matured after 20 h into larger spherical clusters (30-50 nm in diameter) and protofibrils as shown by transmission electron microscopy. Further maturation of the aggregates showed shrinkage of the spheres as the fibrils grew in length, suggesting a conformational change of the spheres into more rigid structures. The structural and physicochemical characteristics of the aggregates were investigated using fluorescence, circular dichroism, chemical cross-linking, and transmission electron microscopy. The fluorescent dyes 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonate (ANS), 4-4-bis-1-phenylamino-8-naphthalene sulfonate (Bis-ANS), 4-(dicyanovinyl)-julolidine (DCVJ), and thioflavin T (ThT) were employed in both static and kinetic assays to characterize these oligomeric and protofibrillar states using both steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence techniques. DCVJ, a molecular rotor, was employed for the first time for studies of an amyloidogenic process and is shown useful for detection of the early steps of the oligomerization process. DCVJ bound to the early prefibrillar oligomers (300-500 kD) with an apparent dissociation constant of 1.6 muM, which was slightly better than for ThT (6.8 muM). Time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy decay of ANS was shown to be a useful tool for giving further structural and kinetic information of the oligomeric aggregates. ThT dramatically increases its fluorescence quantum yield when bound to amyloid fibrils; however, the mechanism behind this property is unknown. Data from this work suggest that unbound ThT is also intrinsically quenched and functions similarly to a molecular rotor, which in combination with its environmental dependence provides a blue shift to the characteristic 482 nm wavelength when bound to amyloid fibrils.     

Direct observation of amyloid fibril growth monitored by thioflavin T fluorescence

Real-time monitoring of fibril growth is essential to clarify the mechanism of amyloid fibril formation. Thioflavin T (ThT) is a reagent known to become strongly fluorescent upon binding to amyloid fibrils. Here, we show that, by monitoring ThT fluorescence with total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (TIRFM), amyloid fibrils of beta2-microgobulin (beta2-m) can be visualized without requiring covalent fluorescence labeling. One of the advantages of TIRFM would be that we selectively monitor fibrils lying along the slide glass, so that we can obtain the exact length of fibrils. This method was used to follow the kinetics of seed-dependent beta2-m fibril extension. The extension was unidirectional with various rates, suggesting the heterogeneity of the amyloid structures. Since ThT binding is common to all amyloid fibrils, the present method will have general applicability for the analysis of amyloid fibrils. We confirmed this with the octapeptide corresponding to the C terminus derived from human medin and the Alzheimer's amyloid beta-peptide.     

Spectral properties of thioflavin T in solvents with different dielectric properties and in a fibril-incorporated form

The increase in the solvent polarity induces a significant shift of the long-wavelength absorption band of the thioflavin T (ThT) to the shorter wavelengths. This is due to the fact that the positive charge of the ThT molecule (Z = +1e) is unequally and very differently distributed between the benzthiazole and aminobenzene rings in the ground and excited states. Therefore, ThT ground state is stabilized by the orientational interactions of the polar solvent dipoles with the positively charged ThT fragments, whereas the configuration of the solvation shell of the ThT molecule in the excited Franck-Condon state is likely far from being equilibrium. ThT absorption spectrum has the shortest (412 nm) and the longest (450 nm) wavelengths in water and in water being incorporated to the amyloid fibrils, respectively. Intriguingly, the position of the ThT fluorescence spectrum depends on the polarity of solvent to a significantly lesser degree than its absorption spectrum: being excited at 440 nm, ThT has emission with maxima at 493 and 478 nm in water and fibrils, respectively. This can be due to the fact that, in the excited state, the rotational oscillations of the ThT fragments relative to each other prevent establishing equilibrium with the solvent and fluorescence occurs from the partially equilibrium excited stated to the partially equilibrium ground state. For the fibril-incorporated ThT, the maximum of the fluorescence excitation spectrum coincides with the maximum of the long wavelength absorption band (450 nm), whereas for ThT in aqueous and alcohol solutions, additional short-wavelength bands of fluorescence and fluorescence excitation spectra were described (Naiki et al. Anal. Biochem. 1989, 177, 244-249; Le Vine Methods Enzymol. 1999, 309, 274-284). These bands could result either from some fluorescent admixtures (including free benzthiazole and aminobenzene) or from the specific ThT conformers in which benzthiazole and aminobenzene rings, being oriented at phi angle close to 90 or 270 degrees, serve as independent chromophores. On the basis of the results of the quantum-chemical calculations, it is proposed that at phi = 90 degrees (270 degrees), the relatively low barrier (only 700 cm-1) of the internal rotation of the benzthiazole and aminobenzene rings relative to each other gives rise to a subpopulation of ThT molecules possessing a violated system of the pi-conjugated bonds of the benzthiazole and aminobenzene rings.     

Study on the binding of Thioflavin T to beta-sheet-rich and non-beta-sheet cavities

Amyloid fibril formation plays a role in more than 20 diseases including Alzheimer's disease. In vitro detection of these fibrils is often performed using Thioflavin T (ThT), though the ThT binding mode is largely unknown. In the present study, spectral properties of ThT in binding environments representing beta-sheet-rich and non-beta-sheet cavities were examined. Acetylcholinesterase and gamma-cyclodextrin induced a characteristic ThT fluorescence similar to that with amyloid fibrils, whereas beta-cyclodextrin and the beta-sheet-rich transthyretin did not. The cavities of acetylcholinesterase and gamma-cyclodextrin were of similar diameter and only these cavities could accommodate two ThT ions according to molecular modelling. Binding stoichiometry studies also showed a possible binding of two ThT ions. Thus, the characteristic ThT fluorescence is induced in cavities with a diameter of 8-9A and a length able to accommodate the entire length of the ThT ion. The importance of a cavity diameter capable of binding two ThT ions, among others, indicates that an excimer formation is a plausible mechanism for the characteristic fluorescence. We propose a similar ThT binding mode in amyloid fibrils, where cavities of an appropriate size running parallel to the fibril axis have previously been proposed in several amyloid fibril models.     

Binding mode of Thioflavin T in insulin amyloid fibrils

Amyloid fibrils share various common structural features and their presence can be detected by Thioflavin T (ThT). In this paper, the binding mode of ThT to insulin amyloid fibrils was examined. Scatchard analysis and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) showed at least two binding site populations. The binding site population with the strongest binding was responsible for the characteristic ThT fluorescence. This binding had a capacity of about 0.1 moles of ThT bound per mole of insulin in fibril form. The binding capacity was unaffected by pH, but the affinity was lowest at low pH. Notably, presence of a third binding process prior to the other processes was suggested by ITC. Binding of ThT resulted in only minor changes in the fibril structure according to the X-ray diffraction patterns, where a slightly more dominant equatorial reflection at 16A relative to the intersheet distance of 11A was observed. No change in the interstrand distance of 4.8A was observed. On the basis of our results, we propose that ThT binds in cavities running parallel to the fibril axis, e.g., between the protofilaments forming the fibrils. Such cavities have been proposed previously in insulin fibrils and several other amyloid fibril models.     

Identification of an amyloidogenic region on keratoepithelin via synthetic peptides

Mutations of keratoepithelin (KE) gene in human chromosome 5q31 have been linked with corneal epithelial or stromal dystrophies characterized by the abnormal deposits of amyloid fibrils and/or non-amyloid aggregations in corneal tissue. We report herein that synthetic peptide containing amino acid (a.a.) residues of 515-532 of native KE protein can readily form beta-sheet-containing amyloid fibrils in vitro. Amyloid fibrils formed in various conditions from short synthetic peptides (containing a.a. 515-532 and 515-525, respectively) were characterized by thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence assay, Congo red staining, electron microscopy (EM) and circular dichroism (CD). Triple-N-methylation of the synthetic peptides prevented the beta-sheet polymerization and related amyloid fibril formation. Comparison study with ThT fluorescence further demonstrated that synthetic peptides containing corneal dystrophy-related mutations within this region formed amyloid fibrils to various extents. Our results suggest that each individual dystrophy-related mutation by itself does not necessarily potentiate amyloid fibril formation of KE. Roles of these intrinsically amyloidogenic foci in abnormal KE aggregations and amyloid deposits of stromal corneal dystrophies await further investigation.     

Pitfalls associated with the use of Thioflavin-T to monitor anti-fibrillogenic activity

Thioflavin-T (ThT) is a cationic benzothiazole dye that displays enhanced fluorescence upon binding to amyloid fibrils. This property makes ThT the current reagent of choice for the quantification of amyloid fibrils. Herein, we investigate the main pitfalls associated with the use of ThT-based assays to monitor the fibrillation of α-synuclein (α-syn), a protein linked to Parkinson’s disease and other α-synucleinopathies. We demonstrated for the first time that ThT interacts with α-syn disordered monomer and accelerates the protein fibrillation in vitro. As a consequence, misleading conclusions may arise from the use of ThT-based real-time assays in the evaluation of anti-fibrillogenic compounds. Interestingly, NMR experiments indicated that C-terminal domain of α-syn is the main region perturbed by ThT interaction, similarly to that found for the pesticide paraquat, a well-documented accelerator of α-syn fibrillation. Moreover, we demonstrated that certain potent inhibitors of α-syn fibrillation, such as oxidized catecholamines and polyphenols, undergo spontaneous oxidation in aqueous solution, generating compounds that strongly quench ThT fluorescence. In light of these findings, we alert for possible artifacts associated to the measure of the anti-fibrillogenic activity based only on ThT fluorescence approach.     

Effect of amino acid variations in the central region of human serum amyloid A on the amyloidogenic properties

Human serum amyloid A (SAA) is a precursor protein of the amyloid fibrils that are responsible for AA amyloidosis. Of the four human SAA genotypes, SAA1 is most commonly associated with AA amyloidosis. Furthermore, SAA1 has three major isoforms (SAA1.1, 1.3, and 1.5) that differ by single amino acid variations at two sites in their 104-amino acid sequences. In the present study, we examined the effect of amino acid variations in human SAA1 isoforms on the amyloidogenic properties. All SAA1 isoforms adopted α-helix structures at 4 °C, but were unstructured at 37 °C. Heparin-induced amyloid fibril formation of SAA1 was observed at 37 °C, as evidenced by the increased thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence and β-sheet structure formation. Despite a comparable increase in ThT fluorescence, SAA1 molecules retained their α-helix structures at 4 °C. At both temperatures, no essential differences in ThT fluorescence and secondary structures were observed among the SAA1 isoforms. However, the fibril morphologies appeared to differ; SAA1.1 formed long and curly fibrils, whereas SAA1.3 formed thin and straight fibrils. The peptides corresponding to the central regions of the SAA1 isoforms containing amino acid variations showed distinct amyloidogenicities, reflecting their direct effects on amyloid fibril formation. These findings may provide novel insights into the influence of amino acid variations in human SAA on the pathogenesis of AA amyloidosis.     

On the binding of Thioflavin-T to HET-s amyloid fibrils assembled at pH 2

Amyloid fibrils are ordered β-sheet protein or peptide polymers. The benzothiazole dye Thioflavin-T (ThT) shows a strong increase in fluorescence upon binding to amyloid fibrils and has hence become the most commonly used amyloid-specific dye. In spite of this widespread use, the mechanism underlying specific binding and fluorescence enhancement upon interaction with amyloid fibrils remains largely unknown. Recent contradictory reports have proposed radically different modes of binding. We have studied the interaction of ThT with fibrils of the prion forming domain of the fungal HET-s prion protein assembled at pH 2 in order to try to gain some insight into the general mechanism of ThT-binding and fluorescence. We found that ThT does not bind to HET-s(218–289) fibrils as a micelle as previously proposed in the case of insulin fibrils. We have measured binding kinetics, affinity and stoichiometry at pH values above and below the pI of the HET-s(218–289) fibrils and found that binding is dramatically affected by pH and ionic strength. Binding is poor at acidic pH, presumably as a result of repulsive electrostatic interaction between the positively charged ThT molecule and the fibril surface. Finally, we found that ThT acquires chiral properties when it is fibril-bound. These results are discussed in relation to the different ThT-binding modes that have been proposed.     

K114 (trans,trans)‐bromo‐2,5‐bis(4‐hydroxystyryl)benzene is an efficient detector of cationic amyloid fibrils

Cationic amyloid fibrils found in human semen enhance the transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and thus, are named semen‐derived enhancer of virus infection (SEVI). The mechanism for the enhancement of transmission is not completely understood but it has been proposed that SEVI neutralizes the repulsion that exists between the negatively charged viral envelope and host cell membrane. Consistent with this view, here we show that the fluorescence of cationic thioflavin T (ThT) in the presence of SEVI is weak, and thus ThT is not an efficient detector of SEVI. On the other hand, K114 ((trans, trans)‐bromo‐2,5‐bis(4‐hydroxystyryl)benzene) forms a highly fluorescent, phenolate‐like species on the cationic surface of SEVI. This species does not form in the presence of amyloid fibrils from insulin and amyloid‐β protein, both of which are efficiently detected by ThT fluorescence. Together, our results show that K114 is an efficient detector of SEVI.     

Interaction of Thioflavin T with amyloid fibrils of apolipoprotein A-I N-terminal fragment: Resonance energy transfer study

Apolipoprotein A-I is amenable to a number of specific mutations associated with hereditary systemic amyloidoses. Amyloidogenic properties of apoA-I are determined mainly by its N-terminal fragment. In the present study Förster resonance energy transfer between tryptophan as a donor and Thioflavin T as an acceptor was employed to obtain structural information on the amyloid fibrils formed by apoA-I variant 1-83/G26R/W@8. Analysis of the dye-fibril binding data provided evidence for the presence of two types of ThT binding sites with similar stoichiometries (bound dye to monomeric protein molar ratio ∼10), but different association constants (∼6 and 0.1 μM⁻¹) and ThT quantum yields in fibril-associated state (0.08 and 0.05, respectively). A β-strand–loop–β-strand structural model of 1-83/G26R/W@8 apoA-I fibrils has been proposed, with potential ThT binding sites located in the solvent-exposed grooves of the N-terminal β-sheet layer. Reasoning from the expanded FRET analysis allowing for heterogeneity of ThT binding centers and fibril polymorphism, the most probable locations of high- and low-affinity ThT binding sites were attributed to the grooves T16_Y18 and D20_L22, respectively.     

l-Arginine reduces thioflavin T fluorescence but not fibrillation of bovine serum albumin

This work examines the effects of l-arginine (l-Arg) on the aggregation and amyloid fibrillation of bovine serum albumin (BSA). We demonstrate that l-Arg dose-dependently reduces thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence of BSA within the l-Arg concentration range used (0–1.4 M). However, as revealed by electron microscopy, size exclusion chromatography, and dynamic light scattering results, l-Arg does not prevent amyloid-like fibril formation by BSA. We conclude that l-Arg competes against ThT for binding sites on BSA amyloid-like fibrils, leading to biased results in ThT fluorescence measurements. Moreover, the use of ThT fluorescence assay to screen for potential inhibitors against amyloid fibrillation can give misleading results.     

Michler's hydrol blue: a sensitive probe for amyloid fibril detection

Michler's hydrol blue (MHB) is investigated with respect to photophysical properties in varied solvent environment and when bound to insulin and lysozyme fibrils. The MHB chromophore is shown to act like a molecular rotor and bind well to amyloid fibrils, where it exhibits a characteristic red-shift in its excitation spectrum and an increase in the emission quantum yield upon binding. MHB is more sensitive to environmental changes than Thioflavin T (ThT) and furthermore, in contrast to the latter amyloid probe, can differentiate between insulin and lysozyme fibrils by a more red-shifted excitation spectrum for insulin fibrils. To support the experimental observations, time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations were performed on MHB at several levels of theory. The predicted changes of spectral properties as a function of the environment are in good agreement with the experimental results. Linear dichroism (LD) is used to determine the orientation of the MHB within the fibrils. It was shown through LD and molecular modeling that MHB aligns itself preferentially parallel with the amyloid fiber at an angle of 14°-22° to the fibril axis and along the grooves of the β-sheet.     

Conformational changes during amyloid fibril formation of pancreatic thiol proteinase inhibitor: effect of copper and zinc

Pancreatic thiol proteinase inhibitor (PTPI), a variant of cystatin superfamily of cysteine protease inhibitors, has been isolated from pancreas of Capra hircus. In the present study, we examined the effects of acid denaturation and a co-solvent on PTPI with a focus on protein conformational changes and amyloid fibril formation. The results demonstrate that PTPI can form amyloid like fibrils. Acid denaturation as studied by CD and fluorescence spectroscopy showed that PTPI populates three partly unfolded species, a native like state at pH 3.0, a structured molten globule at pH 1.0 and partly unfolded species at pH 2.0, from each of which amyloid like fibrils grow as assessed by Thioflavin T (ThT) spectroscopy. Effect of trifluoroethanol (TFE) on acid induced states of PTPI was analyzed. TFE stabilized each of the three acid-induced intermediates at predenaturational concentrations (10%) and accelerated fibril formation. Morphology of the protein species at the beginning and end of reactions was observed using transmission electron microscopy. Solvent conditions were decisive for final fibril morphology. Biometals, Cu²⁺ and Zn²⁺ produced a concentration dependent decline in ThT fluorescence suggesting deaggregation of the fibrils. When added prior to amyloid fibril initiation 50 μM Cu²⁺ or 10 μM Zn²⁺ prevented any amyloid aggregation. Implications for therapeutics in view of Cu²⁺ and Zn²⁺ as essential micronutrients are suggested.     

Interference of low‐molecular substances with the thioflavin‐T fluorescence assay of amyloid fibrils

Abnormal fibrillization of amyloidogenic peptides/proteins has been linked to various neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease as well as with type‐II diabetes mellitus. The kinetics of protein fibrillization is commonly studied by using a fluorescent dye Thioflavin T (ThT) that binds to protein fibrils and exerts increased fluorescence intensity in bound state. Recently, it has been demonstrated that several low‐molecular weight compounds like Basic Blue 41, Basic Blue 12, Azure C, and Tannic acid interfere with the fluorescence of ThT bound to Alzheimers' amyloid‐β fibrils and cause false positive results during the screening of fibrillization inhibitors. In the current study, we demonstrated that the same selected substances also decrease the fluorescence signal of ThT bound to insulin fibrils already at submicromolar or micromolar concentrations. Kinetic experiments show that unlike to true inhibitors, these compounds did neither decrease the fibrillization rate nor increase the lag‐period. Absence of soluble insulin in the end of the experiment confirmed that these compounds do not disaggregate the insulin fibrils and, thus, are not fibrillization inhibitors at concentrations studied. Our results show that interference with ThT test is a general phenomenon and more attention has to be paid to interpretation of kinetic results of protein fibrillization obtained by using fluorescent dyes. Copyright © 2011 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Analyzing thioflavin T binding to amyloid fibrils by an equilibrium microdialysis-based technique

A new approach for the determination of the amyloid fibril - thioflavin T (ThT) binding parameters (the number of binding modes, stoichiometry, and binding constants of each mode) is proposed. This approach is based on the absorption spectroscopy determination of the concentration of free and bound to fibril dye in solutions, which are prepared by equilibrium microdialysis. Furthermore, the proposed approach allowed us, for the first time, to determine the absorption spectrum, molar extinction coefficient, and fluorescence quantum yield of the ThT bound to fibril by each binding modes. This approach is universal and can be used for determining the binding parameters of any dye interaction with a receptor, such as ANS binding to proteins in the molten globule state or to protein amorphous aggregates.     

Surface-modified magnetite nanoparticles affect lysozyme amyloid fibrillization

BackgroundThe surface of nanoparticles (NPs) is an important factor affecting the process of poly/peptides' amyloid aggregation. We have investigated the in vitro effect of trisodium citrate (TC), gum arabic (GA) and citric acid (CA) surface-modified magnetite nanoparticles (COAT-MNPs) on hen egg-white lysozyme (HEWL) amyloid fibrillization and mature HEWL fibrils.MethodsDynamic light scattering (DLS) was used to characterize the physico-chemical properties of studied COAT-MNPs and determine the adsorption potential of their surface towards HEWL. The anti-amyloid properties were studied using thioflavin T (ThT) and tryptophan (Trp) intrinsic fluorescence assays, and atomic force microscopy (AFM). The morphology of amyloid aggregates was analyzed using Gwyddion software. The cytotoxicity of COAT-MNPs was determined utilizing Trypan blue (TB) assay.ResultsAgents used for surface modification affect the COAT-MNPs physico-chemical properties and modulate their anti-amyloid potential. The results from ThT and intrinsic fluorescence showed that the inhibitory activities result from the more favorable interactions of COAT-MNPs with early pre-amyloid species, presumably reducing nuclei and oligomers formation necessary for amyloid fibrillization. COAT-MNPs also possess destroying potential, which is presumably caused by the interaction with hydrophobic residues of the fibrils, resulting in the interruption of an interface between β-sheets stabilizing the amyloid fibrils.ConclusionCOAT-MNPs were able to inhibit HEWL fibrillization and destroy mature fibrils with different efficacy depending on their properties, TC-MNPs being the most potent nanoparticles.General significanceThe study reports findings regarding the general impact of nanoparticles' surface modifications on the amyloid aggregation of proteins.