Self-organized patterns of airway narrowing

The behavior of respiratory diseases such as asthma and COPD may involve complicated interactions among multiple factors. Theoretical and experimental data suggest that interdependence among the airways of the bronchial tree leads to the emergence of self-organized patterns of airway narrowing, ventilation defects, and other phenomena when a tipping point is passed. Additionally, evidence from several studies shows that the behavior of an isolated airway is different from an identical airway embedded in the bronchial tree so that experimental results of isolated elements such as airways, airway smooth muscle, or inflammatory pathways may not explain the whole organ behavior. However, there may be factors in the isolated elements that can dramatically change the complex system's behavior. More effective strategies for prevention or recovery from a disease, such as asthma, will depend on our progress in identifying and understanding the essential parts of the self-organized behavior that is involved.     

Structural basis for exaggerated airway narrowing

Airway hyperresponsiveness, particularly the ability of airways to narrow excessively in response to stimuli that normally cause little airway narrowing in nonasthmatic subjects, is a characteristic feature of asthma and the basis of its symptoms. Although airway hyperresponsiveness may be partly the result of alterations in the contractile phenotype of the airway smooth muscle, there is evidence that it may also be caused by structural changes in the airway wall, collectively termed airway remodeling. Airway remodeling is defined as changes in composition, quantity, and (or) organization of cellular and molecular constituents of the airway wall. Airway wall remodeling that occurs in asthma can result in functional alterations because of quantitative changes in airway wall compartments, and (or) because of changes in the biochemical composition or material properties of the various constituents of the airway wall. This brief review summarizes the quantitative changes in the dimensions and organization of the airway wall compartments that have been described and explains how structural alterations may lead to the exaggerated airway narrowing.     

Effects of hemodynamic edema formation on peripheral vs. central airway mechanics

The mechanisms governing increased central (Rc) and peripheral airway resistance (Rp) during hemodynamic edema formation were studied in anesthetized dogs. Rc and Rp were measured by forced oscillation at 1 Hz by use of a retrograde catheter to partition resistance and a pleural capsule to detect alveolar pressure. After elevation of left atrial pressure to 30 cmH2O by inflation of the left atrial balloon, Rc gradually increased an average of 60% above control in approximately 100 min. Vagotomy had a small influence on the change. On the other hand, Rp with vagus nerves intact increased triphasically: first, it increased transiently by 160% above the control value within 15-20 min before returning to near base line. It then increased gradually for approximately 40 min and finally rose sharply up to five times the control value after approximately 100 min. With vagi cut, the initial phase disappeared, but the second gradual and final rapid phases were not affected. Several sequential mechanisms of increased Rp can be proposed: 1) transient bronchoconstriction mediated by vagal reflex; 2) gradual formation of peribronchial edema; and 3) a sharp increase in airway fluid and formation of bronchial froth. In addition, narrowing of the airways by vascular engorgement may have contributed to the increase of Rp throughout all stages.     

A model of the mechanics of airway narrowing

To examine the interaction between airway smooth muscle shortening and airway wall thickening on changes in pulmonary resistance, we have developed a model of the tracheobronchial tree that allows simulation of the mechanisms involved in airway narrowing. The model is based on the symmetrical dichotomous branching tracheobronchial tree as described by Weibel and uses fluid dynamic equations proposed by Pedley et al. to calculate inspiratory resistance during quiet tidal breathing. To allow for changes in lung volume, we used the airway pressure-area curves developed by Lambert et al. The model is easily implemented with a spreadsheet and personal computer that allows calculation of total and regional pulmonary resistance. At each airway generation in the model, provision is made for airway wall thickness, the maximal airway smooth muscle shortening achievable, and an S-shaped dose-response relationship to describe smooth muscle shortening. To test the validity of the model, we compared pressure-flow curves generated with the model with measurements of pulmonary resistance while normal subjects breathed air and 20% O2-80% He at a variety of lung volumes. By simulating progressive airway smooth muscle shortening, realistic pulmonary resistance vs. dose-response curves were produced. We conclude that this model provides realistic estimates of pulmonary resistance and shows potential for examining the various mechanisms that could produce excessive airway narrowing in disease.     

Distribution of airway narrowing during hyperpnea-induced bronchoconstriction in guinea pigs

Increasing minute ventilation of dry gas shifts the principal burden of respiratory heat and water losses from more proximal airway to airways farther into the lung. If these local thermal transfers determine the local stimulus for bronchoconstriction, then increasing minute ventilation of dry gas might also extend the zone of airway narrowing farther into the lung during hyperpnea-induced bronchoconstriction (HIB). We tested this hypothesis by comparing tantalum bronchograms in tracheostomized guinea pigs before and during bronchoconstriction induced by dry gas hyperpnea, intravenous methacholine, and intravenous capsaicin. In eight animals subjected to 5 min of dry gas isocapnic hyperpnea [tidal volume (VT) = 2-5 ml, 150 breaths/min], there was little change in the diameter of the trachea or the main stem bronchi up to 0.75 cm past the main carina (zone 1). In contrast, bronchi from 0.75 to 1.50 cm past the main carina (zone 2) narrowed progressively at all minute ventilations greater than or equal to 300 ml/min (VT = 2 ml). More distal bronchi (1.50-3.10 cm past the main carina; zone 3) did not narrow significantly until minute ventilation was raised to 450 ml/min (VT = 3 ml). The estimated VT during hyperpnea needed to elicit a 50% reduction in airway diameter was significantly higher in zone 3 bronchi [4.3 +/- 0.8 (SD) ml] than in zone 2 bronchi (3.5 +/- 1.1 ml, P less than 0.012).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Variable site of airway narrowing among obstructive sleep apnea patients

The purpose of this was to determine whether the site of physiological narrowing within the upper airway was uniform or differed among patients with obstructive sleep apnea. Inspiratory pressures were measured with an esophageal balloon catheter and three catheters located at different sites along the upper airway: supralaryngeal airway, oropharynx, and nasopharynx. Peak inspiratory pressure differences between catheters allowed assessment of pressure gradients across three airway segments: lungs-larynx-retroepiglottal airway (esophageal-supralaryngeal pressure), hypopharynx (supralaryngeal-oropharynx pressure), and transpalatal airway (oropharynx-nasopharynx pressure). In five patients, hypopharyngeal obstruction was present, and in four patients no hypopharyngeal obstruction existed. In these four patients the site of obstruction was located at the level of the palate. In a given subject, the site of obstruction was the same during repeated measurements. The presence or absence of hypopharyngeal narrowing during sleep was not predictable from gradients measured across different segments of the upper airway during wakefulness. We conclude that the site of physiological upper airway obstruction varies among patients with obstructive sleep apnea and is not predictable from pressure measured during wakefulness. We speculate that uvulopalatopharyngoplasty may not relieve obstructive apneas in patients with hypopharyngeal obstruction.     

Granulocyte-mediated airway edema in guinea pigs

To determine the role of polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs) in the airway edema that accompanies airway inflammation, we studied the effects of a 1-h exposure to 2 ppm toluene diisocyanate (TDI) on tracheal extravasation of Evans blue dye and on the concentration of PMNs in the tracheal wall. Tracheal Evans blue content was significantly increased by TDI exposure (53.6 +/- 8.0 micrograms/g tracheal tissue (mean +/- SE) for animals exposed to TDI and 16.3 +/- 2.0 for animals exposed to air, P less than 0.0025) as were both the intravascular and extravascular concentration of PMNs in tracheal sections (intravascular PMNs were 28.0 +/- 8.4 X 10(3) cells/mm3 for TDI and 1.5 +/- 1.5 X 10(3) for air, P less than 0.025, extravascular PMNs were 10.9 +/- 4.5 X 10(3) for TDI and 0 for air, P less than 0.05). PMN depletion with vinblastine or with hydroxyurea abolished both the increase in tracheal Evans blue extravasation and the increase in the concentration of intravascular and extravascular PMNs in animals exposed to TDI. PMN depletion with hydroxyurea did not significantly inhibit the increase in tracheal Evans blue extravasation caused by intravenous histamine. Administration of donor PMNs to animals depleted of PMNs with hydroxyurea reconstituted the TDI-induced increase in tracheal Evans blue extravasation (80.4 +/- 17.3 micrograms/g tissue (mean +/- SE) in animals exposed to TDI vs. 21.3 +/- 2.9 in animals exposed to air, P less than 0.025) and in the intravascular concentration of PMNs in tracheal sections [18.5 +/- 3.4 X 10(3) cells/mm3 (mean +/- SE) in animals exposed to TDI vs. 1.3 +/- 1.3 X 10(3) in animals exposed to air, P less than 0.0025].(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Total lung capacity does not change during methacholine-stimulated airway narrowing

The accurate measurement of changes in flow rates from partial flow-volume curves depends on their measurement at the same lung volume. This lung volume can be standardized from total lung capacity (TLC) if this does not change at the same time. We examined the effect of methacholine-stimulated maximal airway narrowing [change in mean forced expiratory volume in 1 s (delta FEV1) = 26.4%] on TLC, measured by whole-body plethysmography, in 10 normal subjects and of moderate airway narrowing (mean delta FEV1 = 34.9%) in 10 asthmatics. The TLC changed from 5.88 to 6.03 liters in normal subjects (P greater than 0.05) and from 6.92 to 6.95 liters (P greater than 0.5) in asthmatics. The results of this study suggest that TLC does not change significantly after methacholine-stimulated maximal airway narrowing in normal subjects and after moderate narrowing in asthmatics.     

Possible mechanism of pesticide toxicity-related oxidative stress leading to airway narrowing

The study was conducted to assess the magnitude of oxidative stress and lung function abnormalities in 34 male pesticide sprayers on exposure to pesticides in mango plantations. Biochemical studies on blood antioxidant enzymes revealed an unchanged glutathione level and increased level of malondialdehyde (P < 0.001), which indicates that pesticide sprayers may have suffered from oxidative stress. Decreased acetyl-cholinesterase levels (P < 0.001) in sprayers compared to the controls suggest inhibition of cholinesterase activity. The present study shows that pesticide toxicity might lead to oxidative stress and airway narrowing resulting in decreased peak expiratory flow rate.     

Activation of smooth muscle in the airway wall, force production, and airway narrowing.

Airway narrowing depends on smooth muscle force production and muscle shortening, but the structural and geometric properties exhibited by individual generations of the bronchial tree largely determine the extent and characteristics of airway narrowing. Properties of major importance include the nature and integrity of the epithelium, the structural and mechanical properties of the airway wall, as well as airway diameter. The influence of these properties on airway narrowing measured as flow or flow resistance in large and small diameter segments of airways from pig lung is described using a novel preparation, the perfused bronchial segment.     

Possible mechanism of pesticide toxicity-related oxidative stress leading to airway narrowing

Abstract

The study was conducted to assess the magnitude of oxidative stress and lung function abnormalities in 34 male pesticide sprayers on exposure to pesticides in mango plantations. Biochemical studies on blood antioxidant enzymes revealed an unchanged glutathione level and increased level of malondialdehyde (P < 0.001), which indicates that pesticide sprayers may have suffered from oxidative stress. Decreased acetyl-cholinesterase levels (P < 0.001) in sprayers compared to the controls suggest inhibition of cholinesterase activity. The present study shows that pesticide toxicity might lead to oxidative stress and airway narrowing resulting in decreased peak expiratory flow rate.     

Exaggerated airway narrowing in mice treated with intratracheal cationic protein.

Airway hyperresponsiveness in mice with allergic airway inflammation can be attributed entirely to exaggerated closure of peripheral airways (Wagers S, Lundblad LK, Ekman M, Irvin CG, and Bates JHT. J Appl Physiol 96: 2019-2027, 2004). However, clinical asthma can be characterized by hyperresponsiveness of the central airways as well as the lung periphery. We, therefore, sought to establish a complementary model of hyperresponsiveness in the mouse due to excessive narrowing of the airways. We treated mice with a tracheal instillation of the cationic protein poly-l-lysine (PLL), hypothesizing that this would reduce the barrier function of the epithelium and thereby render the underlying airway smooth muscle more accessible to aerosolized methacholine. The PLL-treated animals were hypersensitive to methacholine: they exhibited an exaggerated response to submaximal doses but had a maximal response that was similar to controls. With the aid of a computational model of the mouse lung, we conclude that the methacholine responsiveness of PLL-treated mice is fundamentally different in nature to the hyperresponsiveness that we found previously in mice with allergically inflamed lungs.     

Decreased airway narrowing and smooth muscle contraction in hyperresponsive pigs.

Increased smooth muscle contractility or reduced smooth muscle mechanical loads could account for the excessive airway narrowing and hyperresponsiveness seen in asthma. These mechanisms were investigated by using an allergen-induced porcine model of airway hyperresponsiveness. Airway narrowing to electric field stimulation was measured in isolated bronchial segments, over a range of transmural pressures (0-20 cmH(2)O). Contractile responses to ACh were measured in bronchial segments and in isolated tracheal smooth muscle strips isolated from control and test (ovalbumin sensitized and challenged) pigs. Test airways narrowed less than controls (P < 0.0001). Test pigs showed reduced contractility to ACh, both in isolated bronchi (P < 0.01) and smooth muscle strips (P < 0.01). Thus isolated airways from pigs exhibiting airway hyperresponsiveness in vivo are hyporesponsive in vitro. The decreased narrowing in bronchi from hyperresponsive pigs may be related to decreased smooth muscle contractility. These data suggest that mechanisms external to the airway wall may be important to the hyperresponsive nature of sensitized lungs.     

Relationship between airway microvascular leakage, edema, and baseline airway functions

Matheson, Melissa, Ann-Christine Rynell, Melissa McClean,and Norbert Berend. Relationship between airway microvascular leakage, edema, and baseline airway functions. J. Appl. Physiol. 84(1): 77-81, 1998.This study wasdesigned to examine the relationship among microvascular leakage,edema, and baseline airway function. Microvascular leakage was inducedin the airways of anesthetized, tracheostomized New Zealand Whiterabbits (n = 22) by using nebulized N-formyl-methionyl-leucyl-phenylalanine(10 mg) and was measured in the trachea by using the Evans blue dyetechnique. Airway wall thickness was assessed morphometrically in theright main bronchus after Formalin fixation at a pressure of 25 cmH₂O. Areas calculated includedthe mucosal wall area, the adventitial wall area, the total wall area,and the percentage of total wall area consisting of blood vessels. Aneutrophil count was also performed by analyzing numbers of cells inboth the mucosal wall area and the adventitial wall area. Airwayfunction was assessed before and 30 min after challenge withN-formyl-methionyl-leucyl-phenylalanineby determining airway resistance, functional residual capacity,specific airway resistance, and flow-volume and pressure-volume curves(after paralysis of the animals with suxamethonium). The concentration of Evans blue dye in tracheal tissue ranged from 31.3 to 131.2 µg.There was a significant correlation between this concentration and boththe adventitial wall area (P < 0.01)and mucosal neutrophil numbers (P < 0.005). There was no correlation between Evans blue concentration andeither blood vessel area or changes in respiratory physiologyparameters before and after challenge. There was no significantdifference between any respiratory physiology measurements before andafter challenge. We conclude that an increase in microvascular leakagecorrelates with airway edema in the adventitia; however, these airwaychanges have no significant effect on airway elastic or resistiveproperties.

     

Computational model of airway narrowing: mature vs. immature rabbit.

Immature rabbits have greater maximal airway narrowing and greater maximal fold increases in airway resistance during bronchoconstriction than mature animals. We have previously demonstrated that excised immature rabbit lungs have more distensible airways, a lower shear modulus, and structural differences in the relative composition and thickness of anatomically similar airways. In the present study, we incorporated anatomic and physiological data for mature and immature rabbits into a computational model of airway narrowing. We then investigated the relative importance of maturational differences in these factors as determinants of the greater airway narrowing that occurs in the immature animal. The immature model demonstrated greater sensitivity to agonist, as well as a greater maximal fold increase in airway resistance. Exchanging values for airway compliance between the mature and immature models resulted in the mature model exhibiting a greater maximal airway response than the immature model. In contrast, exchanging the shear moduli or the composition of the airway wall relative to the airway size produced relatively small changes in airway reactivity. Our results strongly suggest that the mechanical properties of the airway, i.e., greater compliance of the immature airway, can be an important factor contributing to the greater airway narrowing of the immature animal.     

Relationship between quasi-static pulmonary hysteresis and maximal airway narrowing in humans.

Two groups of subjects were studied: one with (group 1: 5 healthy and 4 mildly asthmatic subjects) and another without (group 2:9 moderately and severely asthmatic subjects) a plateau of response to methacholine (MCh). We determined the effect of deep inhalation by comparing expiratory flows at 40% of forced vital capacity from maximal and partial flow-volume curves (MEF40M/P) and the quasi-static transpulmonary pressure-volume (Ptp-V) area. In group 1, MEF40M/P increased from 1.58 +/- 0.23 (SE) at baseline up to a maximum of 3.91 +/- 0.69 after MCh when forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1) was decreased on plateau by 24 +/- 2%. The plateau of FEV1 was always paralleled by a plateau of MEF40M/P. In group 2, MEF40 M/P increased from 1.58 +/- 0.10 at baseline up to a maximum of 3.48 +/- 0.26 after MCh when FEV1 was decreased by 31 +/- 3% and then decreased to 2.42 +/- 0.24 when FEV1 was decreased by 46 +/- 2%. Ptp-V area was similar in the two groups at baseline yet was increased by 122 +/- 9% in group 2 and unchanged in group 1 at MCh end point. These findings suggest that the increased maximal response to MCh in asthmatic subjects is associated with an involvement of the lung periphery.     

Greater airway narrowing in immature than in mature rabbits during methacholine challenge

Shen, X., V. Bhargava, G. R. Wodicka, C. M. Doerschuk, S. J. Gunst, and R. S. Tepper. Greater airway narrowing in immature thanin mature rabbits during methacholine challenge. J. Appl. Physiol. 81(6): 2637-2643, 1996.It hasbeen demonstrated that methacholine (MCh) challenge produces a greaterincrease in lung resistance in immature than in mature rabbits (R. S. Tepper, X. Shen, E. Bakan, and S. J. Gunst.J. Appl. Physiol. 79: 1190-1198, 1995). To determine whether this maturational difference in the response to MCh was primarily related to changes in airway resistance (Raw) or changes in tissue resistance, we assessed airway narrowing in1-, 2-, and 6-mo-old rabbits during intravenous MCh challenge (0.01-5.0 mg/kg). Airway narrowing was determined frommeasurements of Raw in vivo and from morphometric measurements on lungsections obtained after rapidly freezing the lung after the MChchallenge. The fold increase in Raw was significantly greater for 1- and 2-mo-old animals than for 6-mo-old animals. Similarly, the degree of airway narrowing assessed morphometrically was significantly greaterfor 1- and 2-mo-old animals than for 6-mo-old animals. The foldincrease in Raw was highly correlated with the degree of airwaynarrowing assessed morphometrically(r² = 0.82, P < 0.001). We conclude that thematurational difference in the effect of MCh on lung resistance isprimarily caused by greater airway narrowing in the immature rabbits.

     

Relationship of airway narrowing, compliance, and cartilage in isolated bronchial segments.

Structural components of the airway wall may act to load airway smooth muscle and restrict airway narrowing. In this study, the effect of load on airway narrowing was investigated in pig isolated bronchial segments. In some bronchi, pieces of cartilage were removed by careful dissection. Airway narrowing was produced by maximum electrical field stimulation. An endoscope was used to record lumen narrowing. The compliance of the bronchial segments was determined from the cross-sectional area of the lumen and the transmural pressure. Airway narrowing and the velocity of airway narrowing were increased in cartilage-removed airways compared with intact control bronchi. Morphometric assessment of smooth muscle length showed greater muscle shortening to acetylcholine in cartilage-removed airways than in controls. Airway narrowing was positively correlated with airway compliance. Compliance and area of cartilage were negatively correlated. These results show that airway narrowing is increased in compliant airways and that cartilage significantly loads airway smooth muscle in whole bronchi.