Determination of Melting Sequences in DNA and DNA-Protein Complexes by Difference Spectra

A graphical formula is presented for determining the base ratio of melted DNA. By use of this formula, the composition of sequences which melt in different portions of the melting curves of Clostridium DNA, Escherichia coli DNA, and mouse DNA were determined. As the DNA melts, the per cent of adenine and thymine (AT) in the melted sequences decreases linearly with temperature. The average composition of sequences which melt in a given part of the melting curve is proportional to the base ratio of the DNA. The concentration and average composition of sequences were determined for three parts of the melting curves of the DNA samples, and a frequency distribution curve was constructed. The curve is symmetrical and has a maximum at about 56% AT. The distribution of GC-rich sequences on the E. coli chromosome was estimated by shearing, partially melting, and fractionating the DNA on hydroxylapatite. GC-rich sequences appear to occur every thousand base pairs, and have a maximum length of about 180 base pairs. The graphical formula was applied to the determination of the composition of sequences which melt in different parts of the melting curve of chromatin. Throughout the melting curve, the composition of the melting sequences is about 60% AT, which appears to suggest that relatively long sequences are melting simultaneously. Their melting temperature may be a function of the composition of the protein on different parts of the DNA. The problem of light scattering in DNA-protein and DNA was also investigated. A formula is presented which corrects for light scattering by relating the intensity of the scattered light to the rate of change of absorbance of DNA with wavelength.     

Characterization of nuclear DNA in 12 species of Chlorella (Chlorococcales, Chlorophyta) by DNA reassociation

Strains of 12 different species of the genus Chlorella were analyzed for amount, reiteration frequency and kinetic complexity of chromosomal DNA components by C0t analysis. The resulting C0t curves reveal at least two different DNA components consisting of single copy DNA (up to 95%) and of repetitive DNA with complexities of 4.1 x 10(3) base pairs (bp) to approximately 11.7 x 10(3) bp and a reiteration frequency of 100-760. The total amount of repetitive DNA is less than 9% of the nuclear genome and similar in all strains studied. In contrast, the total kinetic complexity varies in a wide range from 1.26 x 10(7) bp to 8.08 x 10(7) bp which is mainly due to differences in the size of single copy DNA. The genome sizes in Chlorella seem not to be correlated with biochemical and physiological characteristics and therefore are unlikely to be useful as a taxonomical marker. A comparison of thermal denaturation profiles showed that the melting points of repetitive and single copy DNA differ by approximately 7 degrees C which may result from base mismatch and/or from a distinct base composition of the repetitive DNA.     

Stacking energies in DNA

Variations in base mono- and dipoles result in variations in stacking energies for the 10 unique neighbor pairs in DNA. Stacking energies for pair M on N, expressed as TMN, were derived by matrix decomposition of a large set of linear algebraic expressions relating the measured Tm for subtransitions emanating from large polymeric DNAs, and the fractional neighbor frequencies, fMN, for the domains responsible for the transitions, Tm = sigma fMNTMN. Tm were determined for subtransitions that dissociate in approximately all-or-none fashion in high resolution melting profiles of partially deleted and recombinant forms of pBR322 DNA. Three different analytical maneuvers were undertaken to resolve subtransitions: site-specific cleavage of domains; deletion of domains; and addition of domains. Three dozen domains of widely divergent, quasi-random neighbor frequencies were identified and assigned, resulting in a unique set of values for TMN with standard deviation, sigma = +/- 0.23 degree C. The average difference between calculated and experimental Tm for domains is only +/- 0.17 degree C, indicating that the thermodynamic properties of these domains are not in any way unusual. Assuming delta S to be constant for all pairs, the corresponding delta HMN are found to have a precision of +/- 10 calories.mol-1 and an accuracy of +/- 606 calories.mol-1. TMN used to calculate melting curves by statistical mechanical analysis of sequences of the different plasmid specimens in this study were in quantitative agreement with observed curves for most sequences. These TMN differ significantly from those determined previously and also correlate poorly with values determined by quantum chemical analysis. Stabilities of neighbor pairs, expressed as the difference in free energy between that for a given pair (MN) and that for the average of like pairs (M, N), depend on the relationship of stacked purines and pyrimidines as follows. delta delta Gpu-py(-466 cal) greater than delta delta Gpu-pu(+52 cal) greater than delta delta Gpy-pu(+335 cal) Differences between experimental Tm and Tm calculated with TMN for the isolated neighbor pairs in the B-conformation are useful in the identification of altered structures and unusual modes of dissociation of helixes. A significantly higher Tm is observed for the highly biased repeated sequence synthetic helixes dA.dT, d(AGC).d(GCT), and d(GAT).d(ATC), reflecting auxiliary sources of stability such as bifurcated hydrogen bonds and/or altered structures for these helixes.     

Spectral analysis of high resolution direct-derivative melting curves of DNA for instantaneous and total base composition.

Derivative melting profiles of DNA have been obtained directly by recording the difference in absorbance between two identical solutions maintained at a small constant temperature differential. This deltaA is monitored continuously with increasing temperature in a ratio recording spectrophotometer. Resolution of complex hyperfine structure in the profiles of small homogeneous viral DNAs appears to be significantly better than has been produced by various numerical methods of differentiation. In addition, a spectral method has been modified that permits easy analysis for DNA base composition from the ratio of derivative melting curves obtained at 282 and 260 nm. Eight bacterial and three vertebrate DNAs have been analyzed for total base composition from the product of the instantaneous base composition at small temperature intervals (0.05 degrees C) throughout the entire melting region and the integrated area of the 282 nm profile. The results are in excellent agreement with values determined by traditional methods.     

DNA sequencing and helix–coil transition. III. DNA sequencing

We show that the fine oscillatory structure of the DNA melting curve can be used to determine explicitly the nucleotide composition and the order of certain domains within the DNA. If DNA is specifically fragmented, the order of fragments can be learned directly from a comparison of the differential melting curves of the nonfragmented and fragmented DNA. The indicated information may complement exact methods of DNA sequencing. The proposed analysis is applied to bacteriophage ?X-174, whose melting curve is known. Compared to the known ?X-174 DNA sequence, the results of the analysis are found to be very accurate.     

Differential scanning calorimetry of antitumor antibiotics-plasmid DNA interaction

Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) can detect stepwise melting of plasmid DNA along the molecular chain with high resolution. This method was applied to study interaction of some antitumor antibiotics with the plasmid pJL3-TB5 DNA (5277 base-pairs in length). Analysis of DSC curves of the plasmid DNA in the presence of, for example, adriamycin, an antitumor antibiotics of anthracycline group, together with theoretical analysis of the DNA melting curves obtained by calculation from the entire base sequence, led to the conclusion that adriamycin bound preferentially to the four particular regions with high G + C content. The DSC method would thus be useful for the study of properties of drugs which bind to DNA.     

Relationship between helix-coil transition and gene organization of ColE1 plasmid DNA. Differential scanning calorimetric and theoretical studies

Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) was carried out to analyze the transition of helix to coil state of DNA, using ColE1 DNA molecules digested with EcoRI. The DSC curves showed multimodal transition, consisting of nine to 11 peaks over a temperature range, depending on the ionic strength of the DNA solution. These DSC curves were essentially in good agreement with the optical melting curves of ColE1 DNA. The theoretical melting profiles of ColE1 DNA were predicted from calculations based on the helix-coil transition theory and the nucleotide sequence of the DNA. These profiles resembled the DSC curves and made it possible to assign the peaks seen in the DSC curves to the helix-coil transition of particular regions of the nucleotide sequence of ColE1. The helix-coil transition of each of the small genes gave rise to a single peak in the DSC curve, while the helix-coil transition of large genes contributed to two or more peaks in the DSC curve. This multimodal transition within a single coding region might correspond to the melting of individual segments encoding the different domains of the proteins. The helix-coil transition at the specific sites including ori, the origin of replication of ColE1, was also found to occur in a particular temperature range. DSC, a simple method, is thus useful for analyzing the multimodal helix-coil transition of DNA, and for providing information on the genetic organization of DNA.     

Comparison of SYTO9 and SYBR Green I for real-time polymerase chain reaction and investigation of the effect of dye concentration on amplification and DNA melting curve analysis

Following the initial report of the use of SYBR Green I for real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in 1997, little attention has been given to the development of alternative intercalating dyes for this application. This is surprising considering the reported limitations of SYBR Green I, which include limited dye stability, dye-dependent PCR inhibition, and selective detection of amplicons during DNA melting curve analysis of multiplex PCRs. We have tested an alternative to SYBR Green I and report the first detailed evaluation of the intercalating dye SYTO9. Our findings demonstrate that SYTO9 produces highly reproducible DNA melting curves over a broader range of dye concentrations than does SYBR Green I, is far less inhibitory to PCR than SYBR Green I, and does not appear to selectively detect particular amplicons. The low inhibition and high melting curve reproducibility of SYTO9 means that it can be readily incorporated into a conventional PCR at a broad range of concentrations, allowing closed tube analysis by DNA melting curve analysis. These features simplify the use of intercalating dyes in real-time PCR and the improved reproducibility of DNA melting curve analysis will make SYTO9 useful in a diagnostic context.     

Betaine structure and the presence of hydroxyl groups alters the effects on DNA melting temperatures

Betaine lowers the melting temperature of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) and decreases its dependence on base composition. The effects of synthetic betaine analogs on the melting of DNA samples with different GC content were measured. Since many polyhydroxy compounds also lower DNA melting temperatures, hydroxyl-substituted betaine analogs were included. Some synthetic sulfonate analogs of betaine lowered the DNA melting temperatures by twice as much at the same molar concentration. They were up to twice as effective at decreasing the base pair dependence. Some carboxylate homologs of betaine, substituted with hydroxyl groups, increased the melting temperature. This effect was greater with low GC content DNA. Sulfonate analogs of betaine with hydroxyl groups usually destabilize the DNA, while their carboxylate analogs stabilize the DNA. Distances between the charges of these synthetic zwitterionic solutes influence the effect on DNA, with the optimum separation being two or three methylene groups. A betaine with two hydroxyl groups on one N-alkyl group had a greater effect than an isomer with two hydroxyl groups on separate N-alkyl substituents. We suggest that the effect of these solutes depends on structuring the hydration water of DNA, as well as interactions with the DNA structure itself.     

Classification of DNA sequences based on thermal melting profiles

A new classification scheme based on the melting profile of DNA sequences simulated thermal melting profiles. This method was applied in the classification of (a) several species of mammalian - β globin and (b) α-chain class II MHC genes. Comparison of the thermal melting profile with the molecular phylogenetic trees constructed using the sequences shows that the melting temperature based approach is able to reproduce most of the major features of the sequence based evolutionary tree. Melting profile method takes into account the inherent structure and dynamics of the DNA molecule, does not require sequence alignment prior to tree construction, and provides a means to verify the results experimentally. Therefore our results show that melting profile based classification of DNA sequences could be a useful tool for sequence analysis.     

Cooperative lengths of DNA during melting

The mean cooperative length of domains of DNA, determined from the variance in (G + C) content in derivative melting curves of large bacterial DNAs, varies from 230 base pairs (bp) for (A ? T)-rich domains to 580 bp for (G ? C) domains. These values correspond to values for the cooperativity parameter of 2(±2) × 10^?5 and 3(±2) × 10^?6, respectively, and to +7.2 and +9.6 kcal for the free energy of helix interruption in those regions.     

Thermal stability of DNA.

Tij and Delta Hij for stacking of pair i upon j in DNA have been obtained over the range 0.034-0.114 M Na+from high-resolution melting curves of well-behaved synthetic tandemly repeating inserts in recombinant pN/MCS plasmids. Results are consistent with neighbor-pair thermodynamic additivity, where the stability constant, sij , for different domains of length N depend quantitatively on the product of stability constants for each individual pair in domains, sijN . Unit transition enthalpies with average errors less than +/-5%, were determined by analysis of two-state equilibria associated with the melting of internal domains and verified from variations of Tij with [Na+]. Enthalpies increase with Tij , in close agreement with the empirical function: Delta Hij = 52.78@ Tij - 9489, and in parallel with a smaller increase in Delta Sij . Delta Hij and Delta Sij are in good agreement with the results of an extensive compilation of published Delta Hcal and Delta Scal for synthetic and natural DNAs. Neighbor-pair additivity was also observed for (dA@dT)-tracts at melting temperatures; no evidence could be detected of the familiar and unusual structural features that characterize tracts at lower temperatures. The energetic effects of loops were determined from the melting behavior of repeating inserts installed between (G+C)-rich barrier domains in the pN/MCS plasmids. A unique set of values for the cooperativity, loop exponent and stiffness parameters were found applicable to internal domains of all sizes and sequences. Statistical mechanical curves calculated with values of Tij([Na+]) , Delta Hij and these loop parameters are in good agreement with observation.     

The thermal denaturation of DNA: average length and composition of denatured areas

A spectral study of melting curves of DNA ranging from 73 to 32% AT indicates that the base ratio of sequences melting within DNA are a linear function of temperature. A study of partially denatured DNA by electron microscopy, reversible renaturation and fractionation on hydroxylapatite suggests that the melting curve of DNA represents the melting of sequences which average 3-4 million daltons in length. These sequences appear to be a combination of two areas, one which is high in AT and denatures in the first three-quarters of the melting curve, and one which is high in GC and denatures in the final quarter. The length of these sequences appears to vary between 1.5-6 million daltons.     

The interaction of DNA with sperm-specific histones of the H1 family

We have studied the interactions of DNA with sperm-specific histones of the H1 family of sea urchin Strongylocentrotus intermedius, sea starfish Aphelasterias japonica and bivalve mollusk Chlamis islandicus using circular dichroism and DNA melting analysis. It was shown that echinoderm's sperm H1 protein has additional alpha-helical domains in its C-terminus and it demonstrates stronger DNA compaction. The differential melting curves of DNA-protein complexes have two peaks. The low temperature peak characterized the melting temperature of free DNA within the complex. The higher temperature peak characterizes the melting temperature of DNA bond to protein. DNA is found to be in the most stable state in the complexes with mollusk sperm H1 protein.     

Optimizing high-resolution melting analysis for the detection of mutations of GPR30/GPER-1 in breast cancer

G protein-coupled receptor 30/G protein estrogen receptor-1 (GPR30/GPER-1) is a novel membrane receptor for estrogen whose mRNA is expressed at high levels in estrogen-dependent cells such as breast cancer cell lines. However, mutations in GRP30 related to diseases remain unreported. To detect unknown mutations in the GPR30 open reading frame (ORF) quickly, the experimental conditions for high-resolution melting (HRM) analysis were examined for PCR primers, Taq polymerases, saturation DNA binding dyes, Mg(2+) concentration, and normalized temperatures. Nine known SNPs and 13 artificial point mutations within the GPR30 ORF, as well as single nucleotide variants in DNA extracted from subjects with breast cancers were tested under the optimal experimental conditions. The combination of Expand High Fidelity(PLUS) and SYTO9 in the presence of 2.0 mM MgCl(2) produced the best separation in melting curves of mutations in all regions of the GPR30 ORF. Under these experimental conditions, the mutations were clearly detected in both heterozygotes and homozygotes. HRM analysis of GPR30 using genomic DNA from subjects with breast cancers showed a novel single nucleotide variant, 111C>T in GPR30 and 4 known SNPs. The experimental conditions determined in this study for HRM analysis are useful for high throughput assays to detect unknown mutations within the GPR30 ORF.     

The effect of low ionic strength on the radiation chemistry and physical properties of calf thymus DNA

Studies of ultraviolet and circular dichroism spectra of aqueous solutions of calf thymus (CT) DNA confirm the tendency of DNA to change conformation at low ionic strength. The qualitative shape and transition width of 260 nm melting curves below 1 mM NaCl differed significantly from those previously published for DNA solutions containing 1 mM NaCl and above. Neutral aqueous solutions of CT DNA at low ionic strengths (0.1 mM-10 mM NaCl) were irradiated with low doses of gamma-rays. The melting temperature, Tm, of irradiated DNA samples increased below 1 mM NaCl suggesting interstrand crosslinking of the denatured DNA or formation of regions of more thermally stable DNA conformation. The magnitudes of these radiation responses were found to be a function of the time elapsed between salt concentration changes and irradiation as well as time after irradiation. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the purine and pyrimidine base chromophores in double stranded DNA are sheltered from radical attack by the sugar phosphate backbone. Low dose radiation studies (0.8-8.0 Gy) of CT DNA in 1 mM NaCl and below showed a split dose and dose rate dependence for the sample melting curves.     

Thermodynamics of the melting of PNA(2)/DNA triple helices.

Equilibrium melting curves were obtained for triplexes, formed by single stranded DNA containing an A10 target with bis-PNA consisting of two T10 decamers. Thermodynamic parameters of melting were determined for Na(+) concentrations 50, 200 and 600mM by two methods. The melting enthalpy Delta H degrees was evaluated from the width of the differential melting curves and from the concentration dependence of the melting temperature. The latter method allowed also evaluating the melting entropy Delta S degrees. The following results were obtained: Delta H degrees = - 137 kcal/M, Delta S degrees = - 368 cal/M.K, Delta G degrees (298)= - 27 kcal/M. No dependence of Delta H degrees, Delta S degrees and Delta G degrees (298) was observed upon ionic strength within the accuracy of the experiment (+/- 10%). The absolute values of Delta H degrees, Delta S degrees and Delta G degrees(298) are 2 to 3 times higher than the published values of corresponding melting parameters for decameric PNA/DNA duplexes of various nucleic base sequences. The origin of the extremely high stability of the triplexes is discussed.     

A microanalytical procedure for determination of the base composition of DNA

A new procedure for the determination of the percentage guanine plus cytosine (% G+C; mol/100 mol) values of microquantities of DNA is described. Its principle is a DNA-polymerase-I-directed nick translation of DNA in the presence of dGTP, dTTP, [3H]dCTP, and [alpha-32P]dATP. Kinetics experiments indicate that the plateau value is reached in about 20 min of incubation under our experimental conditions. Percentage G+C is obtained from the linear relation 1/(% G+C) = 0.01 K [32P]/[3H] + 0.01, where the ratio of trichloroacetic-acid-precipitable radioactivity is taken into account, the K value being determined for each experiment by using a few reference DNAs of known composition. This procedure has proven suitable for analysis of plasmidic, viral and cellular DNAs of different base composition (25-75% G+C), shape (linear and circular double-stranded DNA) and size (100-150 000 base pairs). Usual methods for % G+C analysis (buoyant density and melting temperature determinations) yield unreliable results in the presence of either modified or unusual bases: the double-labeling procedure is still valid under these conditions. The latter is, therefore, the method of choice for analysis or rare DNA species which are available in very small quantities (it requires amounts of DNA as low as 1 ng, i.e. several order of magnitude lower than those used for chromatographic analysis of DNA hydrolysates). Since the obtention of highly purified DNA is an essential prerequisite for the double-labeling procedure, a method for purification of bacterial DNA is detailed in the present work.     

The Use of EGFR Exon 19 and 21 Unlabeled DNA Probes to Screen for Activating Mutations in Non–Small Cell Lung Cancer

Activating mutations in epidermal growth factor receptor-1 (EGFR) are found in 10–15% of Caucasian patients with non–small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC). Approximately 90% of the mutations are deletions of several amino acids in exon 19 or point mutations in exon 21. Some studies suggest that these mutations identify patients that might benefit from targeted EGFR inhibitor therapy. DNA melting analysis of polymerase chain reaction products can screen for these mutations to identify this patient population. However, amplicon DNA melting analysis, although easily capable of detecting heterozygous mutations by heterodimer formation, becomes more difficult if mutations are homozygous or if the mutant allele is selectively amplified over wild type. Amplification of EGFR is common in NSCLC and this could compromise mutation detection by amplicon melting analysis. To overcome this potential limitation, we developed unlabeled, single-stranded DNA probes, complimentary to EGFR exon 19 and exon 21 where the common activating mutations occur. The unlabeled probes are incorporated into a standard polymerase chain reaction during the amplification of EGFR exons 19 and 21. The probe melting peak is easily distinguished from the amplicon melting peak, and probe melting is altered if mutations are present. This allows for easy identification of activating mutations even in homozygous or amplified states and is useful in the screening of NSCLC for the common EGFR activating mutations.