Genome-Wide DNA Methylation Profiles Indicate CD8+ T Cell Hypermethylation in Multiple Sclerosis

Objective

Determine whether MS-specific DNA methylation profiles can be identified in whole blood or purified immune cells from untreated MS patients.

Methods

Whole blood, CD4+ and CD8+ T cell DNA from 16 female, treatment naïve MS patients and 14 matched controls was profiled using the HumanMethylation450K BeadChip. Genotype data were used to assess genetic homogeneity of our sample and to exclude potential SNP-induced DNA methylation measurement errors.

Results

As expected, significant differences between CD4+ T cells, CD8+ T cells and whole blood DNA methylation profiles were observed, regardless of disease status. Strong evidence for hypermethylation of CD8+ T cell, but not CD4+ T cell or whole blood DNA in MS patients compared to controls was observed. Genome-wide significant individual CpG-site DNA methylation differences were not identified. Furthermore, significant differences in gene DNA methylation of 148 established MS-associated risk genes were not observed.

Conclusion

While genome-wide significant DNA methylation differences were not detected for individual CpG-sites, strong evidence for DNA hypermethylation of CD8+ T cells for MS patients was observed, indicating a role for DNA methylation in MS. Further, our results suggest that large DNA methylation differences for CpG-sites tested here do not contribute to MS susceptibility. In particular, large DNA methylation differences for CpG-sites within 148 established MS candidate genes tested in our study cannot explain missing heritability. Larger studies of homogenous MS patients and matched controls are warranted to further elucidate the impact of CD8+ T cell and more subtle DNA methylation changes in MS development and pathogenesis.     

Signals from CD28 induce stable epigenetic modification of the IL-2 promoter

CD28 costimulation controls multiple aspects of T cell function, including the expression of proinflammatory cytokine genes. One of these genes encodes IL-2, a growth factor that influences T cell proliferation, survival, and differentiation. Antigenic signaling in the absence of CD28 costimulation leads to anergy, a mechanism of tolerance that renders CD4+ T cells unable to produce IL-2. The molecular mechanisms by which CD28 costimulatory signals induce gene expression are not fully understood. In eukaryotic cells, the expression of many genes is influenced by their physical structure at the level of DNA methylation and local chromatin remodeling. To address whether these epigenetic mechanisms are operative during CD28-dependent gene expression in CD4+ T cells, we compared cytosine methylation and chromatin structure at the IL-2 locus in fully activated CD4+ effector T cells and CD4+ T cells rendered anergic by TCR ligation in the absence of CD28 costimulation. Costimulation through CD28 led to marked, stable histone acetylation and loss of cytosine methylation at the IL-2 promoter/enhancer. This was accompanied by extensive remodeling of the chromatin in this region to a structure highly accessible to DNA binding proteins. Conversely, TCR activation in the absence of CD28 costimulation was not sufficient to promote histone acetylation or cytosine demethylation, and the IL-2 promoter/enhancer in anergic cells remained completely inaccessible. These data suggest that CD28 may function through epigenetic mechanisms to promote CD4+ T cell responses.     

CD44 Reciprocally regulates the differentiation of encephalitogenic Th1/Th17 and Th2/regulatory T cells through epigenetic modulation involving DNA methylation of cytokine gene promoters, thereby controlling the development of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

CD44 is expressed by a variety of cells, including glial and T cells. Furthermore, in the demyelinating lesions of multiple sclerosis, CD44 expression is chronically elevated. In this study, we demonstrate that targeted deletion of CD44 attenuated myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein peptide-induced experimental autoimmune encephalitomyelitis (EAE) through novel regulatory mechanisms affecting Th differentiation. Specifically, by developing chimeras and using adoptive transfer experiments, we noted that CD44 deficiency on CD4(+) T cells, but not other cells, conferred protection against EAE induction. CD44 expression played a crucial role in Th differentiation, inasmuch as deletion of CD44 inhibited Th1/Th17 differentiation while simultaneously enhancing Th2/regulatory T cell differentiation. In contrast, expression of CD44 promoted Th1/Th17 differentiation. When osteopontin and hyaluronic acid, the two major ligands of CD44, were tested for their role in Th differentiation, osteopontin, but not hyaluronic acid, promoted Th1/Th17 differentiation. Furthermore, activation of CD44(+) encephalitogenic T cells with myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein peptide led to demethylation at the ifnγ/il17a promoter region while displaying hypermethylation at the il4/foxp3 gene promoter. Interestingly, similar activation of CD44-deficient encephalitogenic T cells led to increased hypermethylation of ifnγ/il17a gene and marked demethylation of il4/foxp3 gene promoter. Together, these data suggested that signaling through CD44, in encephalitogenic T cells, plays a crucial role in the differentiation of Th cells through epigenetic regulation, specifically DNA methylation of Th1/Th17 and Th2 cytokine genes. The current study also suggests that molecular targeting of CD44 receptor to promote a switch from Th1/Th17 to Th2/regulatory T cell differentiation may provide a novel treatment modality against EAE.     

Methods for analyzing the role of DNA methylation and chromatin structure in regulating T lymphocyte gene expression

Chromatin structure, determined in part by DNA methylation, is established during differentiation and prevents expression of genes unnecessary for the function of a given cell type. We reported that DNA methylation and chromatin structure contributes to lymphoidspecific ITGAL (CD11a) and PRF1 (perforin) expression. We used bisulfite sequencing to compare methylation patterns in the ITGAL promoter and 5′ flanking region of T cells and fibroblasts, and in the PRF1 promoter and upstream enhancer of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells with fibroblasts. The effects of methylation on promoter function were tested using regional methylation of reporter constructs, and confirmed by DNA methyltransferase inhibition. The relationship between DNA methylation and chromatin structure was analyzed by DNaseI hypersensitivity. Herein we described the methods and results in greater detail. Published: September 16, 2004.     

Down-regulation of IL-7Ralpha expression in human T cells via DNA methylation

IL-7 is critical for the development and survival of T cells. Recently, we found two subsets of human CD8+ T cells expressing IL-7Ralpha(high) and IL-7Ralpha(low) with different cell survival responses to IL-7. Although these CD8+ T cell subsets have differential IL-7Ralpha gene expression, the mechanism for this is unknown. DNA methylation is an important gene regulatory mechanism and is associated with the inactivation of gene expression. Thus, we investigated a role for DNA methylation in differentially regulating IL-7Ralpha gene expression in human CD8+ T cells and Jurkat T cells. IL-7Ralpha(high)CD8+ T cells had decreased methylation in the IL-7Ralpha gene promoter compared with IL-7Ralpha(low)CD8+ T cells and Jurkat T cells with low levels of IL-7Ralpha. Treating Jurkat T cells with 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine, which reduced DNA methylation, increased IL-7Ralpha expression. Plus, the unmethylated IL-7Ralpha gene promoter construct had higher levels of promoter activity than the methylated one as measured by a luciferase reporter assay. These findings suggest that DNA methylation is involved in regulating IL-7Ralpha expression in T cells via affecting IL-7Ralpha gene promoter activity, and that the methylation of this gene promoter could be a potential target for modifying IL-7-mediated T cell development and survival.     

Cancer genes hypermethylated in human embryonic stem cells

Developmental genes are silenced in embryonic stem cells by a bivalent histone-based chromatin mark. It has been proposed that this mark also confers a predisposition to aberrant DNA promoter hypermethylation of tumor suppressor genes (TSGs) in cancer. We report here that silencing of a significant proportion of these TSGs in human embryonic and adult stem cells is associated with promoter DNA hypermethylation. Our results indicate a role for DNA methylation in the control of gene expression in human stem cells and suggest that, for genes repressed by promoter hypermethylation in stem cells in vivo, the aberrant process in cancer could be understood as a defect in establishing an unmethylated promoter during differentiation, rather than as an anomalous process of de novo hypermethylation.     

CD4-CD8- T cells from mice with collagen arthritis display aberrant expression of type l K+ channels

Expression of voltage-gated K+ channels in mAb-defined T cell subsets from normal mice and mice with experimental autoimmune arthritis was studied with the patch-clamp whole-cell recording technique in combination with fluorescence microscopy. CD4+CD8- Th cells from DBA/1 LacJ mice with type II collagen arthritis expressed low levels of type n K+ channels, and CD4-CD8+ T cells (cytotoxic) showed small numbers of type l or n' K+ channels, like their phenotypic counterparts in normal mice. CD4-CD8-Thy-1.2+ (double negative or DN) T cells from the diseased mice, however, displayed an abundance of type l K+ channels compared to DN T cells in normal mice, or mice immunized with CFA. Furthermore, the aberrant expression of type l K+ channels correlated with the presence of active disease. DN T cells from mice with SLE, type-1 diabetes mellitus, and experimental allergic encephalomyelitis, also exhibited a high number of type l K+ channels. These results suggest that expression of numerous type l K+ channels may be a useful marker for DN T cells associated with these autoimmune disorders.     

CpG methylation of the IFNG gene as a mechanism to induce immunosuppression [correction of immunosupression] in tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes

The execution of appropriate gene expression patterns during immune responses is of eminent importance where CpG methylation has emerged as an essential mechanism for gene silencing. We have charted the methylation status of regulatory elements in the human IFNG gene encoding the signature cytokine of the Th1 response. Surprisingly, human naive CD4(+) T lymphocytes displayed hypermethylation at the IFNG promoter region, which is in sharp contrast to the completely demethylated status of this region in mice. Th1 differentiation induced demethylation of the IFNG promoter and the upstream conserved nucleotide sequence 1 enhancer region, whereas Th2-differentiated lymphocytes remained hypermethylated. Furthermore, CD19(+) B lymphocytes displayed hypomethylation at the IFNG promoter region with a similar pattern to Th1 effector cells. When investigating the methylation status among tumor-infiltrating CD4(+) T lymphocytes from patients with colon cancer, we found that tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes cells are inappropriately hypermethylated, and thus not confined to the Th1 lineage. In contrast, CD4(+) T cells from the tumor draining lymph node were significantly more demethylated than tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes. We conclude that there are obvious interspecies differences in the methylation status of the IFNG gene in naive CD4(+) T lymphocytes, where Th1 commitment in human lymphocytes involves demethylation before IFNG expression. Finally, investigations of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes and CD4(+) cells from tumor draining lymph node demonstrate methylation of regulatory regions within key effector genes as an epigenetic mechanism of tumor-induced immunosuppression.     

Cutting edge: stable epigenetic inheritance of regional IFN-gamma promoter demethylation in CD44highCD8+ T lymphocytes

Genomic DNA methylation patterns influence the development and maintenance of function during cellular differentiation. Methylation of regulatory sequences can have long-lasting effects on gene expression if inherited in an epigenetic manner. Recent work suggests that DNA methylation has a regulatory role in differential cytokine gene expression in primary T lymphocytes. Here we show, by clonal lineage analysis, that methylation patterns in the IFN-gamma promoter exhibit long term faithful inheritance in CD44highCD8+ T cells and their progeny, through 16 cell divisions and a clonal expansion of 5 orders of magnitude. Moreover, the demethylated IFN-gamma promoter is faithfully inherited following the withdrawal of T cell stimulation and the loss of detectable IFN-gamma mRNA, consistent with passive rather than active maintenance mechanisms. This represents a form of stable cellular memory, of defined epigenetic characteristics, that may contribute to the maintenance of T cell cytokine expression patterns and T cell memory.     

The role of epigenetic variation in the pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus

The focus of the present review is on the extent to which epigenetic alterations influence the development of systemic lupus erythematosus. Lupus is a systemic autoimmune disease characterized by the production of autoantibodies directed at nuclear self-antigens. A DNA methylation defect in CD4+ T cells has long been observed in idiopathic and drug-induced lupus. Recent studies utilizing high-throughput technologies have further characterized the nature of the DNA methylation defect in lupus CD4+ T cells. Emerging evidence in the literature is revealing an increasingly interconnected network of epigenetic dysregulation in lupus. Recent reports describe variable expression of a number of regulatory microRNAs in lupus CD4+ T cells, some of which govern the expression of DNA methyltransferase 1. While studies to date have revealed a significant role for epigenetic defects in the pathogenesis of lupus, the causal nature of epigenetic variation in lupus remains elusive. Future longitudinal epigenetic studies in lupus are therefore needed.     

Effector CD4+ T cell expression signatures and immune-mediated disease associated genes

Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) in immune-mediated diseases have identified over 150 associated genomic loci. Many of these loci play a role in T cell responses, and regulation of T cell differentiation plays a critical role in immune-mediated diseases; however, the relationship between implicated disease loci and T cell differentiation is incompletely understood. To further address this relationship, we examined differential gene expression in na?ve human CD4+ T cells, as well as in in vitro differentiated Th1, memory Th17-negative and Th17-enriched CD4+ T cells subsets using microarray and RNASeq. We observed a marked enrichment for increased expression in memory CD4+ compared to na?ve CD4+ T cells of genes contained among immune-mediated disease loci. Within memory T cells, expression of disease-associated genes was typically increased in Th17-enriched compared to Th17-negative cells. Utilizing RNASeq and promoter methylation studies, we identified a differential regulation pattern for genes solely expressed in Th17 cells (IL17A and CCL20) compared to genes expressed in both Th17 and Th1 cells (IL23R and IL12RB2), where high levels of promoter methylation are correlated to near zero RNASeq levels for IL17A and CCL20. These findings have implications for human Th17 celI plasticity and for the regulation of Th17-Th1 expression signatures. Importantly, utilizing RNASeq we found an abundant isoform of IL23R terminating before the transmembrane domain that was enriched in Th17 cells. In addition to molecular resolution, we find that RNASeq provides significantly improved power to define differential gene expression and identify alternative gene variants relative to microarray analysis. The comprehensive integration of differential gene expression between cell subsets with disease-association signals, and functional pathways provides insight into disease pathogenesis.     

DNA methylation and chromatin structure regulate T cell perforin gene expression

Perforin is a cytotoxic effector molecule expressed in NK cells and a subset of T cells. The mechanisms regulating its expression are incompletely understood. We observed that DNA methylation inhibition could increase perforin expression in T cells, so we examined the methylation pattern and chromatin structure of the human perforin promoter and upstream enhancer in primary CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells as well as in an NK cell line that expresses perforin, compared with fibroblasts, which do not express perforin. The entire region was nearly completely unmethylated in the NK cell line and largely methylated in fibroblasts. In contrast, only the core promoter was constitutively unmethylated in primary CD4(+) and CD8(+) cells, and expression was associated with hypomethylation of an area residing between the upstream enhancer at -1 kb and the distal promoter at -0.3 kb. Treating T cells with the DNA methyltransferase inhibitor 5-azacytidine selectively demethylated this area and increased perforin expression. Selective methylation of this region suppressed promoter function in transfection assays. Finally, perforin expression and hypomethylation were associated with localized sensitivity of the 5' flank to DNase I digestion, indicating an accessible configuration. These results indicate that DNA methylation and chromatin structure participate in the regulation of perforin expression in T cells.