Structure,function, and aggregation of the zinc-free form of the p53 DNA binding domain

The p53 DNA binding domain (DBD) contains a single bound zinc ion that is essential for activity. Zinc remains bound to wild-type DBD at temperatures below 30 degrees C; however, it rapidly dissociates at physiological temperature. The resulting zinc-free protein (apoDBD) is folded and stable. NMR spectra reveal that the DNA binding surface is altered in the absence of Zn(2+). Fluorescence anisotropy studies show that Zn(2+) removal abolishes site-specific DNA binding activity, although full nonspecific DNA binding affinity is retained. Surprisingly, the majority of tumorigenic mutations that destabilize DBD do not appreciably destabilize apoDBD. The R175H mutation instead substantially accelerates the rate of Zn(2+) loss. A considerable fraction of cellular p53 may therefore exist in the folded zinc-free form, especially when tumorigenic mutations are present. ApoDBD appears to promote aggregation of zinc-bound DBD via a nucleation-growth process. These data provide an explanation for the dominant negative phenotype exhibited by many mutations. Through a combination of induced p53 aggregation and diminished site-specific DNA binding activity, Zn(2+) loss may represent a significant inactivation pathway for p53 in the cell.     

Kinetic partitioning during folding of the p53 DNA binding domain

The DNA-binding domain (DBD) of wild-type p53 loses DNA binding activity spontaneously at 37 degrees C in vitro, despite being thermodynamically stable at this temperature. We test the hypothesis that this property is due to kinetic misfolding of DBD. Interrupted folding experiments and chevron analysis show that native molecules are formed via four tracks (a-d) under strongly native conditions. Folding half-lives of tracks a-d are 7.8 seconds, 50 seconds, 5.3 minutes and more than five hours, respectively, in 0.3M urea (10 degrees C). Approximately equal fractions of molecules fold through each track in zero denaturant, but above 2.0M urea approximately 90% fold via track c. A kinetic mechanism consisting of two parallel folding channels (fast and slow) is proposed. Each channel populates an on-pathway intermediate that can misfold to form an aggregation-prone, dead-end species. Track a represents direct folding through the fast channel. Track b proceeds through the fast channel but via the off-pathway state. Track c corresponds to folding via the slow channel, primarily through the off-pathway state. Track d proceeds by way of an even slower, uncharacterized route. We postulate that activity loss is caused by partitioning to the slower tracks, and that structural unfolding limits this process. In support of this view, tumorigenic hot-spot mutants G245S, R249S and R282Q accelerate unfolding rates but have no affect on folding kinetics. We suggest that these and other destabilizing mutants facilitate loss of p53 function by causing DBD to cycle unusually rapidly between folded and unfolded states. A significant fraction of DBD molecules become effectively trapped in a non-functional state with each unfolding-folding cycle.     

Kinetic instability of p53 core domain mutants: implications for rescue by small molecules

Oncogenic mutations in the tumor suppressor protein p53 are found mainly in its DNA-binding core domain. Many of these mutants are thermodynamically unstable at body temperature. Here we show that these mutants also denature within minutes at 37 degrees C. The half-life (t(1/2)) of the unfolding of wild-type p53 core domain was 9 min. Hot spot mutants denatured more rapidly with increasing thermodynamic instability. The highly destabilized mutant I195T had a t(1/2) of less than 1 min. The wild-type p53-(94-360) construct, containing the core and tetramerization domains, was more stable, with t(1/2) = 37 min at 37 degrees C, similar to full-length p53. After unfolding, the denatured proteins aggregated, the rate increasing with higher concentrations of protein. A derivative of the p53-stabilizing peptide CDB3 significantly slowed down the unfolding rate of the p53 core domain. Drugs such as CDB3, which rescue the conformation of unstable mutants of p53, have to act during or immediately after biosynthesis. They should maintain the mutant protein in a folded conformation and prevent its aggregation, allowing it enough time to reach the nucleus and bind its sequence-specific target DNA or the p53 binding proteins that will stabilize it.     

Folding of Tetrameric p53: Oligomerization and Tumorigenic Mutations Induce Misfolding and Loss of Function

The physiologically active form of p53 consists of a tetramer of four identical 393-amino-acid subunits associated via their tetramerization domains (TDs; residues 325-355). One in two human tumors contains a point mutation in the DNA binding domain (DBD) of p53 (residues 94-312). Most existing studies on the effects of these mutations on p53 structure and function have been carried out on the isolated DBD fragment, which is monomeric. Recent structural evidence, however, suggests that DBDs may interact with each other in full-length tetrameric forms of p53. Here, we investigate the effects of tumorigenic DBD mutations on the folding of p53 in its tetrameric form. We employ the construct consisting of DBD and TD (amino acids 94-360). We characterize the stability and conformational state of the tumorigenic DBD mutants R248Q, R249S, and R282Q using equilibrium denaturation and functional assays. Destabilizing mutations cause DBD to misfold when it is part of the p53 tetramer, but not when it is monomeric. This conformation is populated under moderately destabilizing conditions (10 °C in 2 M urea, and at physiological temperature in the absence of denaturant). Under those same conditions, it is not present in the isolated DBD fragment or in the presence of the TD mutation L344P, which abolishes tetramerization. Misfolding appears to involve intramolecular DBD-DBD association within a single tetrameric molecule. This association is promoted by destabilization of DBD (caused by mutation or elevated temperature) and by the high local DBD concentration enforced by tetramerization of TD. Disrupting the nonnative DBD-DBD interaction or transiently inhibiting tetramerization and allowing p53 to fold as a monomer may be potential strategies for pharmacological intervention in cancer.     

Temperature-dependent switching between "wild-type" and "mutant" forms of p53-Val135

The p53 gene is a suppressor of abnormal cell growth but is also subject to oncogenic activation by mutation. The mutant allele p53-Val135, has recently been discovered to be temperature-sensitive and functions as an oncogene at 37 degrees C and as a tumor suppressor at 32.5 degrees C. In order to investigate the molecular mechanism underlying the temperature sensitivity of p53-Val135 rabbit reticulocyte lysate was used to translate the p53 mRNAs in vitro at 37 degrees C and at 30 degrees C. The immunoreactivity and T antigen binding of wild-type protein p53-Ala135 were unaffected by temperature and were similar to wild-type p53 expressed in vivo. In contrast, the mutant p53-Val135 protein was markedly affected by temperature. At 37 degrees C p53-Val135 showed reduced T antigen binding and did not react with monoclonal antibodies PAb246 and PAb1620. At 30 degrees C, p53-Val135 behaved as the wild-type p53. Temperature also exerted a post-translational effect on p53-Val135 with complete conversion from wild-type to mutant phenotype within two minutes of temperature shift from 30 degrees C to 37 degrees C. There was incomplete conversion from mutant to wild-type phenotype when the temperature was shifted down from 37 degrees C to 30 degrees C. We propose that the temperature dependent forms of p53-Val135 represent conformational variants of the p53 protein with opposing functions in cell growth control.     

Effects of hyperthermia on p53 protein expression and activity

Although p53 responses after DNA damage have been investigated extensively, p53 responses after heat shock, which exerts cytotoxic action by mechanisms other than direct induction of DNA damage, are less well characterized. We investigated, therefore, the effect of hyperthermic exposures on the levels and DNA-binding activity of p53. Experiments were carried out with U2OS and ML-1 cells, known to express wild-type p53 protein. Although heating at 41 degrees C for up to 6 h had only a small effect on p53 levels or DNA binding activity, exposure to temperatures between 42.5 and 45.5 degrees C caused an immediate decrease in protein levels that was associated with a reduction in DNA binding activity. This observation is compatible with a high lability of p53 to heat shock, or heat sensitivity of the pathway regulating p53 levels in non-stressed cells. When cells were heated to 42.5 degrees C and returned to normal temperatures, a strong p53 response associated with an increase in protein levels and DNA binding activity was observed, suggesting the production of p53-inducing cellular damage. At higher temperatures, however, this response was compromised in an exposure-time-dependent manner. The increase in DNA binding activity was more heat sensitive than the increase in p53 levels and was inhibited at lower temperatures and shorter exposure times. Thus, the pathway of p53 activation is itself heat sensitive and compromised at high levels of exposure. Compared to p53 activation after exposure to ionizing radiation, heat-induced activation is rapid and short lived. When cells were exposed to combined heat and radiation, the response observed approximated that of cells exposed to heat alone. Wortmannin at 10 microM inhibited p53 activation for up to 2 h after heat shock suggesting the involvement of wortmannin-sensitive kinases, such as DNA-PK and ATM. Heat shock causes phosphorylation of p53 at Serine-15, but there is no correlation between phosphorylation at this site and activation of the protein. The results in aggregate indicate p53 activation in the absence of DNA damage by a heat-sensitive mechanism operating with faster kinetics than radiation-induced p53 activation. The former response may induce pathways preventing other stimuli from activating p53, as heat-induced activation of p53 is dominant over activation of p53 by DNA damage in combined-treatment experiments. These observations suggest means for abrogating p53 induction after DNA damage with the purpose of potentiating response and enhancing cell killing.     

R248Q mutation—Beyond p53‐DNA binding

R248 in the DNA binding domain (DBD) of p53 interacts directly with the minor groove of DNA. Earlier nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies indicated that the R248Q mutation resulted in conformation changes in parts of DBD far from the mutation site. However, how information propagates from the mutation site to the rest of the DBD is still not well understood. We performed a series of all‐atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to dissect sterics and charge effects of R248 on p53‐DBD conformation: (i) wild‐type p53 DBD; (ii) p53 DBD with an electrically neutral arginine side‐chain; (iii) p53 DBD with R248A; (iv) p53 DBD with R248W; and (v) p53 DBD with R248Q. Our results agree well with experimental observations of global conformational changes induced by the R248Q mutation. Our simulations suggest that both charge‐ and sterics are important in the dynamics of the loop (L3) where the mutation resides. We show that helix 2 (H2) dynamics is altered as a result of a change in the hydrogen bonding partner of D281. In turn, neighboring L1 dynamics is altered: in mutants, L1 predominantly adopts the recessed conformation and is unable to interact with the major groove of DNA. We focused our attention the R248Q mutant that is commonly found in a wide range of cancer and observed changes at the zinc‐binding pocket that might account for the dominant negative effects of R248Q. Furthermore, in our simulations, the S6/S7 turn was more frequently solvent exposed in R248Q, suggesting that there is a greater tendency of R248Q to partially unfold and possibly lead to an increased aggregation propensity. Finally, based on the observations made in our simulations, we propose strategies for the rescue of R248Q mutants. Proteins 2015; 83:2240–2250. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Protein-DNA binding correlates with structural thermostability for the full-length human p53 protein

Full-length p53 protein purified from Escherichia coli in the unmodified, "latent" form was examined by several methods to correlate thermal stability of structure with functional DNA binding. Structure prediction algorithms indicate that the majority of beta-sheet structure occurs in the p53 core DNA binding domain. Circular dichroism spectra demonstrate that the intact protein is surprisingly stable with a midpoint for the irreversible unfolding transition at approximately 73 degrees C. Significant beta-sheet structural signal remains even to 100 degrees C. The persistent beta-sheet CD signal correlates with significant DNA binding (K(d) approximately nM range) to temperatures as high as 50 degrees C. These data confirm the ability of the DNA binding domain in the full-length "latent" protein to bind consensus dsDNA targets effectively in the absence of activators over a broad temperature range. In addition, we demonstrate that Ab1620 reactivity is not directly correlated with the functional activity of the full-length protein since loss of this epitope occurs at temperatures at which significant specific DNA binding can still be measured.     

Pliable DNA conformation of response elements bound to transcription factor p63

We show that changes in the nucleotide sequence alter the DNA conformation in the crystal structures of p63 DNA-binding domain (p63DBD) bound to its response element. The conformation of a 22-bp canonical response element containing an AT spacer between the two half-sites is unaltered compared with that containing a TA spacer, exhibiting superhelical trajectory. In contrast, a GC spacers abolishes the DNA superhelical trajectory and exhibits less bent DNA, suggesting that increased GC content accompanies increased double helix rigidity. A 19-bp DNA, representing an AT-rich response element with overlapping half-sites, maintains superhelical trajectory and reveals two interacting p63DBD dimers crossing one another at 120°. p63DBD binding assays to response elements of increasing length complement the structural studies. We propose that DNA deformation may affect promoter activity, that the ability of p63DBD to bind to superhelical DNA suggests that it is capable of binding to nucleosomes, and that overlapping response elements may provide a mechanism to distinguish between p63 and p53 promoters.     

Change of conformation of the DNA-binding domain of p53 is the only key element for binding of and interference with p73

Xenopus p53 has biological and biochemical properties similar to those of human p53, except for optimal temperature. The frog protein is fully active at 30 degrees C and inactive at 37 degrees C, leading to a temperature-sensitive behavior similar to that of the human mutant p53Ala(143) and the murine mutant p53Val(135). Using hybrid proteins between human and Xenopus expressed from artificial p53 minigenes, we have been able to demonstrate that change of conformation of the DNA-binding domain is the major determinant of this heat sensitivity. It has been reported that some human tumor-derived p53 mutants can engage in a physical association with p73, thus inhibiting its transactivating properties. The mechanism of this association remains to be elucidated. The nature of the mutant p53 that can engage in this association also remains controversial. Using the unique opportunity of the temperature sensitivity of Xenopus p53, we demonstrate that binding of and interference with p73 require a change of conformation in the p53 protein. This interaction occurs through the DNA-binding domain of p53 only when it is in a denatured state. These results reinforce the notion that mutant p53 with a conformational change can act as a down-regulator of the p73 pathway in human cancer and could confer a selective advantage to the tumor.     

Conversion of wild-type p53 core domain into a conformation that mimics a hot-spot mutant

The wild-type p53 protein can be driven into a conformation corresponding to that adopted by structural mutant forms by heterodimerization with a mutant subunit. To seek partially folded states of the wild-type p53 core domain (p53C) we used high hydrostatic pressure (HP) and subzero temperatures. Aggregation of the protein was observed in parallel with its pressure denaturation at 25 and 37 degrees C. However, when HP experiments were performed at 4 degrees C, the extent of denaturation and aggregation was significantly less pronounced. On the other hand, subzero temperatures under pressure led to cold denaturation and yielded a non-aggregated, alternative conformation of p53C. Nuclear magnetic resonance (1H15N-NMR) data showed that the alternative p53C conformation resembled that of the hot-spot oncogenic mutant R248Q. This alternative state was as susceptible to denaturation and aggregation as the mutant R248Q when subjected to HP at 25 degrees C. Together these data demonstrate that wild-type p53C adopts an alternative conformation with a mutant-like stability, consistent with the dominant-negative effect caused by many mutants. This alternative conformation is likely related to inactive forms that appear in vivo, usually driven by interaction with mutant proteins. Therefore, it can be a valuable target in the search for ways to interfere with protein misfolding and hence to prevent tumor development.     

Zn(2+)-dependent misfolding of the p53 DNA binding domain

The DNA binding domain (DBD) of p53 folds by a complex mechanism that involves parallel pathways and multiple intermediates, both on- and off-pathway. This heterogeneity renders DBD particularly susceptible to misfolding and aggregation. The origins of parallel folding mechanisms are not well understood. DBD folding heterogeneity may be caused by the presence of the single bound Zn2+. To test that hypothesis, we carried out kinetic folding studies of DBD in its Zn2+-free form (apoDBD) and in the presence of various concentrations of free Zn2+ and the Zn2+-nitrilotriacetate (NTA) complex. Folding kinetics of apoDBD and DBD are similar, although apoDBD folds faster than DBD at some urea concentrations. The principle consequence of Zn2+ removal is to accelerate unfolding and simplify it from two exponential phases to one. Metal binding interactions are therefore not responsible for the observed complexity of the folding reaction. A slight stoichiometric excess of free Zn2+ arrests folding and traps the protein in a misfolded state in which Zn2+ is bound to nonphysiological ligands. Folding can be rescued by providing metal ions in the form of the NTA-Zn2+ complex, which simultaneously protects against misligation and provides a source of Zn2+ for regenerating the functional protein. This chemical metallochaperone strategy may be an effective means for improving folding efficiency of other metal binding proteins. The findings suggest that, in vivo, DBD must fold in an environment where free Zn2+ concentration is low and its bioavailability is carefully regulated by cellular metallochaperones.