Selection for intragenic suppressors of lethal 23S rRNA mutations in Escherichia coli identifies residues important for ribosome assembly and function

Mutations in several functionally important regions of the 23S rRNA of E. coli increase the levels of frameshifting and readthrough of stop codons. These mutations include U2555A, U2555G, ΔA1916 and U2493C. The mutant rRNAs are lethal when expressed at high levels from a plasmid, in strains also expressing wild type rRNA from chromosomal rrn operons. The lethal phenotype can be suppressed by a range of second-site mutations in 23S rRNA. However, analysis of the functionality of the double mutant rRNAs in heterogeneous ribosome populations shows that in general, the second site mutations do not restore function. Instead, they prevent the assembly, or entry of the mutant 50S subunits into the functioning 70S ribosome and polysome pools, by affecting the competitiveness of the mutant subunits for association with 30S particles. The second-site mutations lie in regions of the 23S rRNA involved in subunit assembly, intersubunit bridge formation and interactions of the ribosome with tRNAs and factors. These second site suppressor mutations thus define functionally important rRNA nucleotides and this approach may be of general use in the functional mapping of large RNAs.     

Study of the functional interaction of the 900 Tetraloop of 16S ribosomal RNA with helix 24 within the bacterial ribosome

The 900 tetraloop that caps helix 27 of 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) is amongst the most conserved regions of rRNA. This tetraloop forms a GNRA motif that docks into the minor groove of three base-pairs at the bottom of helix 24 of 16S rRNA in the 30S subunit. Both the tetraloop and its receptor in helix 24 contact the 23S rRNA, forming the intersubunit bridge B2c. Here, we investigated the interaction between the 900 tetraloop and its receptor by genetic complementation. We used a specialized ribosome system in combination with an in vivo instant evolution approach to select mutations in helix 24 compensating for a mutation in the 900 tetraloop (A900G) that severely decreases ribosomal activity, impairing subunit association and translational fidelity. We selected two mutants where the G769-C810 base-pair of helix 24 was substituted with either U-A or C x A. When these mutations in helix 24 were investigated in the context of a wild-type 900 tetraloop, the C x A but not the U-A mutation severely impaired ribosome activity, interfering with subunit association and decreasing translational fidelity. In the presence of the A900G mutation, both mutations in helix 24 increased the ribosome activity to the same extent. Subunit association and translational fidelity were increased to the same level. Computer modeling was used to analyze the effect of the mutations in helix 24 on the interaction between the tetraloop and its receptor. This study demonstrates the functional importance of the interaction between the 900 tetraloop and helix 24.     

Potential new antibiotic sites in the ribosome revealed by deleterious mutations in RNA of the large ribosomal subunit

The ribosome is the main target for antibiotics that inhibit protein biosynthesis. Despite the chemical diversity of the known antibiotics that affect functions of the large ribosomal subunit, these drugs act on only a few sites corresponding to some of the known functional centers. We have used a genetic approach for identifying structurally and functionally critical sites in the ribosome that can be used as new antibiotic targets. By using randomly mutagenized rRNA genes, we mapped rRNA sites where nucleotide alterations impair the ribosome function or assembly and lead to a deleterious phenotype. A total of 77 single-point deleterious mutations were mapped in 23 S rRNA and ranked according to the severity of their deleterious phenotypes. Many of the mutations mapped to familiar functional sites that are targeted by known antibiotics. However, a number of mutations were located in previously unexplored regions. The distribution of the mutations in the spatial structure of the ribosome showed a strong bias, with the strongly deleterious mutations being mainly localized at the interface of the large subunit and the mild ones on the solvent side. Five sites where deleterious mutations tend to cluster within discrete rRNA elements were identified as potential new antibiotic targets. One of the sites, the conserved segment of helix 38, was studied in more detail. Although the ability of the mutant 50 S subunits to associate with 30 S subunits was impaired, the lethal effect of mutations in this rRNA element was unrelated to its function as an intersubunit bridge. Instead, mutations in this region had a profound deleterious effect on the ribosome assembly.     

Gateway Role for rRNA Precursors in Ribosome Assembly

In Escherichia coli, rRNAs are initially transcribed with precursor sequences, which are subsequently removed through processing reactions. To investigate the role of precursor sequences, we analyzed ribosome assembly in strains containing mutations in the processing RNases. We observed that defects in 23S rRNA processing resulted in an accumulation of ribosomal subunits and caused a significant delay in ribosome assembly. These observations suggest that precursor residues in 23S rRNA control ribosome assembly and could be serving a regulatory role to couple ribosome assembly to rRNA processing. The possible mechanisms through which rRNA processing and ribosome assembly could be linked are discussed.     

Ribosomal RNAs are tolerant toward genetic insertions: evolutionary origin of the expansion segments

Ribosomal RNAs (rRNAs), assisted by ribosomal proteins, form the basic structure of the ribosome, and play critical roles in protein synthesis. Compared to prokaryotic ribosomes, eukaryotic ribosomes contain elongated rRNAs with several expansion segments and larger numbers of ribosomal proteins. To investigate architectural evolution and functional capability of rRNAs, we employed a Tn5 transposon system to develop a systematic genetic insertion of an RNA segment 31 nt in length into Escherichia coli rRNAs. From the plasmid library harboring a single rRNA operon containing random insertions, we isolated surviving clones bearing rRNAs with functional insertions that enabled rescue of the E. coli strain (Δ7rrn) in which all chromosomal rRNA operons were depleted. We identified 51 sites with functional insertions, 16 sites in 16S rRNA and 35 sites in 23S rRNA, revealing the architecture of E. coli rRNAs to be substantially flexible. Most of the insertion sites show clear tendency to coincide with the regions of the expansion segments found in eukaryotic rRNAs, implying that eukaryotic rRNAs evolved from prokaryotic rRNAs suffering genetic insertions and selections.     

Streptomycin-resistant and streptomycin-dependent mutants of the extreme thermophile Thermus thermophilus

We have isolated spontaneous streptomycin-resistant, streptomycin-dependent and streptomycin-pseudo-dependent mutants of the thermophilic bacterium Thermus thermophilus IB-21. All mutant phenotypes were found to result from single amino acid substitutions located in the rpsL gene encoding ribosomal protein S12. Spontaneous suppressors of streptomycin dependence were also readily isolated. Thermus rpsL mutations were found to be very similar to rpsL mutations identified in mesophilic organisms. This similarity affords greater confidence in the utility of the crystal structures of Thermus ribosomes to interpret biochemical and genetic data obtained with Escherichia coli ribosomes. In the X-ray crystal structure of the T. thermophilus HB8 30 S subunit, the mutated residues are located in close proximity to one another and to helices 18, 27 and 44 of 16 S rRNA. X-ray crystallographic analysis of ribosomes from streptomycin-resistant, streptomycin-pseudo-dependent and streptomycin-dependent mutants described here is expected to reveal fundamental insights into the mechanism of tRNA selection, translocation, and conformational dynamics of the ribosome.     

The central role of protein S12 in organizing the structure of the decoding site of the ribosome

The ribosome decodes mRNA by monitoring the geometry of codon–anticodon base-pairing using a set of universally conserved 16S rRNA nucleotides within the conformationally dynamic decoding site. By applying single-molecule FRET and X-ray crystallography, we have determined that conditional-lethal, streptomycin-dependence mutations in ribosomal protein S12 interfere with tRNA selection by allowing conformational distortions of the decoding site that impair GTPase activation of EF-Tu during the tRNA selection process. Distortions in the decoding site are reversed by streptomycin or by a second-site suppressor mutation in 16S rRNA. These observations encourage a refinement of the current model for decoding, wherein ribosomal protein S12 and the decoding site collaborate to optimize codon recognition and substrate discrimination during the early stages of the tRNA selection process.     

A functional relationship between helix 1 and the 900 tetraloop of 16S ribosomal RNA within the bacterial ribosome

The conserved 900 tetraloop that caps helix 27 of 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) interacts with helix 24 of 16S rRNA and also with helix 67 of 23S rRNA, forming the intersubunit bridge B2c, proximal to the decoding center. In previous studies, we investigated how the interaction between the 900 tetraloop and helix 24 participates in subunit association and translational fidelity. In the present study, we investigated whether the 900 tetraloop is involved in other undetected interactions with different regions of the Escherichia coli 16S rRNA. Using a genetic complementation approach, we selected mutations in 16S rRNA that compensate for a 900 tetraloop mutation, A900G, which severely impairs subunit association and translational fidelity. Mutations were randomly introduced in 16S rRNA, using either a mutagenic XL1-Red E. coli strain or an error-prone PCR strategy. Gain-offunction mutations were selected in vivo with a specialized ribosome system. Two mutations, the deletion of U12 and the U12C substitution, were thus independently selected in helix 1 of 16S rRNA. This helix is located in the vicinity of helix 27, but does not directly contact the 900 tetraloop in the crystal structures of the ribosome. Both mutations correct the subunit association and translational fidelity defects caused by the A900G mutation, revealing an unanticipated functional interaction between these two regions of 16S rRNA.     

Thiostrepton-resistant mutants of Thermus thermophilus

Ribosomal protein L11 and its associated binding site on 23S rRNA together comprise one of the principle components that mediate interactions of translation factors with the ribosome. This site is also the target of the antibiotic thiostrepton, which has been proposed to act by preventing important structural transitions that occur in this region of the ribosome during protein synthesis. Here, we describe the isolation and characterization of spontaneous thiostrepton-resistant mutants of the extreme thermophile, Thermus thermophilus. All mutations were found at conserved positions in the flexible N-terminal domain of L11 or at conserved positions in the L11-binding site of 23S rRNA. A number of the mutant ribosomes were affected in in vitro EF-G-dependent GTP hydrolysis but all showed resistance to thiostrepton at levels ranging from high to moderate. Structure probing revealed that some of the mutations in L11 result in enhanced reactivity of adjacent rRNA bases to chemical probes, suggesting a more open conformation of this region. These data suggest that increased flexibility of the factor binding site results in resistance to thiostrepton by counteracting the conformation-stabilizing effect of the antibiotic.     

Ribosome recycling revisited

Ribosome recycling involves the coordinated action of the ribosome recycling factor (RRF), elongation factor EF-G and initiation factor IF3 to disassemble the post-termination complex, recycling the components for the next round of translation. The crystal structure of domain I of RRF (RRF-DI) in complex with the large ribosomal subunit from the eubacteria Deinococcus radiodurans at high resolution reveals the nature and details of the interactions between this protein factor and rRNA/protein components of the ribosome. Universally conserved arginine residues within the RRF-DI establish important interactions with nuleotides of the 23S rRNA, explaining why mutations at these positions abolish factor binding. Furthermore, in conjunction with cryo-EM reconstruction, the X-ray analysis provides a structural complement to the recent biochemical data, offering additional insight into the mechanism of ribosome recycling.     

Saturation Mutagenesis of 5S rRNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

rRNAs are the central players in the reactions catalyzed by ribosomes, and the individual rRNAs are actively involved in different ribosome functions. Our previous demonstration that yeast 5S rRNA mutants (called mof9) can impact translational reading frame maintenance showed an unexpected function for this ubiquitous biomolecule. At the time, however, the highly repetitive nature of the genes encoding rRNAs precluded more detailed genetic and molecular analyses. A new genetic system allows all 5S rRNAs in the cell to be transcribed from a small, easily manipulated plasmid. The system is also amenable for the study of the other rRNAs, and provides an ideal genetic platform for detailed structural and functional studies. Saturation mutagenesis reveals regions of 5S rRNA that are required for cell viability, translational accuracy, and virus propagation. Unexpectedly, very few lethal alleles were identified, demonstrating the resilience of this molecule. Superimposition of genetic phenotypes on a physical map of 5S rRNA reveals the existence of phenotypic clusters of mutants, suggesting that specific regions of 5S rRNA are important for specific functions. Mapping these mutants onto the Haloarcula marismortui large subunit reveals that these clusters occur at important points of physical interaction between 5S rRNA and the different functional centers of the ribosome. Our analyses lead us to propose that one of the major functions of 5S rRNA may be to enhance translational fidelity by acting as a physical transducer of information between all of the different functional centers of the ribosome.     

Compensatory Evolution of a WW Domain Variant Lacking the Strictly Conserved Trp Residue

Replacement of conserved amino acid residues during evolution of proteins can lead to divergence and the formation of new families with novel functions, but is often deleterious to both protein structure and function. Using the WW domain, we experimentally examined whether and to what degree second-site mutations can compensate for the reduction of function and loss of structure that accompany substitution of a strictly conserved amino acid residue. The W17F mutant of the WW domain, with substitution of the most strictly conserved Trp residue, is known to lack a specific three-dimensional structure and shows reduced binding affinity in comparison to the wild type. To obtain second-site revertants, we performed a selection experiment based on the proline-rich peptide (PY ligand) binding affinity using the W17F mutant as the initial sequence. After selection by ribosome display, we were able to select revertants that exhibited a maximum ninefold higher affinity to the PY ligand than the W17F mutant and showed an even better affinity than the wild type. In addition, we found that the functional restoration resulted in increased binding specificity in selected revertants, and the structures were more compact, with increased amounts of secondary structure, in comparison to the W17F mutant. Our results suggest that the defective structure and function of the proteins caused by mutations in highly conserved residues occurring through divergent evolution not only can be restored but can be further improved by compensatory mutations.     

Identification of novel methyltransferases,Bmt5 and Bmt6, responsible for the m3U methylations of 25S rRNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

RNA contains various chemical modifications that expand its otherwise limited repertoire to mediate complex processes like translation and gene regulation. 25S rRNA of the large subunit of ribosome contains eight base methylations. Except for the methylation of uridine residues, methyltransferases for all other known base methylations have been recently identified. Here we report the identification of BMT5 (YIL096C) and BMT6 (YLR063W), two previously uncharacterized genes, to be responsible for m³U2634 and m³U2843 methylation of the 25S rRNA, respectively. These genes were identified by RP-HPLC screening of all deletion mutants of putative RNA methyltransferases and were confirmed by gene complementation and phenotypic characterization. Both proteins belong to Rossmann-fold–like methyltransferases and the point mutations in the S-adenosyl-l-methionine binding pocket abolish the methylation reaction. Bmt5 localizes in the nucleolus, whereas Bmt6 is localized predominantly in the cytoplasm. Furthermore, we showed that 25S rRNA of yeast does not contain any m⁵U residues as previously predicted. With Bmt5 and Bmt6, all base methyltransferases of the 25S rRNA have been identified. This will facilitate the analyses of the significance of these modifications in ribosome function and cellular physiology.     

Substrate binding analysis of the 23S rRNA methyltransferase RrmJ

The 23S rRNA methyltransferase RrmJ (FtsJ) is responsible for the 2'-O methylation of the universally conserved U2552 in the A loop of 23S rRNA. This 23S rRNA modification appears to be critical for ribosome stability, because the absence of functional RrmJ causes the cellular accumulation of the individual ribosomal subunits at the expense of the functional 70S ribosomes. To gain insight into the mechanism of substrate recognition for RrmJ, we performed extensive site-directed mutagenesis of the residues conserved in RrmJ and characterized the mutant proteins both in vivo and in vitro. We identified a positively charged, highly conserved ridge in RrmJ that appears to play a significant role in 23S rRNA binding and methylation. We provide a structural model of how the A loop of the 23S rRNA binds to RrmJ. Based on these modeling studies and the structure of the 50S ribosome, we propose a two-step model where the A loop undocks from the tightly packed 50S ribosomal subunit, allowing RrmJ to gain access to the substrate nucleotide U2552, and where U2552 undergoes base flipping, allowing the enzyme to methylate the 2'-O position of the ribose.     

Affinity purification of in vivo-assembled ribosomes for in vitro biochemical analysis

As it has become increasingly clear that the RNA components of the ribosome are central to its function, the in vitro analysis of mutations in the ribosomal RNAs has become an important tool for understanding the molecular details of ribosome function. However, the frequent dominant lethal phenotypes of mutations at interesting rRNA residues has long presented a hurdle to this analysis, as their lethality has rendered it impossible to generate pure populations of in vivo-derived ribosomes for study. We present here the details of a method for affinity purification of ribosomes bearing any mutation in the 16S or 23S rRNA and demonstrate that ribosomes purified using this technology are highly active in the several steps of translation we have examined.     

Evolutionary rates vary among rRNA structural elements

Understanding patterns of rRNA evolution is critical for a number of fields, including structure prediction and phylogeny. The standard model of RNA evolution is that compensatory mutations in stems make up the bulk of the changes between homologous sequences, while unpaired regions are relatively homogeneous. We show that considerable heterogeneity exists in the relative rates of evolution of different secondary structure categories (stems, loops, bulges, etc.) within the rRNA, and that in eukaryotes, loops actually evolve much faster than stems. Both rates of evolution and abundance of different structural categories vary with distance from functionally important parts of the ribosome such as the tRNA path and the peptidyl transferase center. For example, fast-evolving residues are mainly found at the surface; stems are enriched at the subunit interface, and junctions near the peptidyl transferase center. However, different secondary structure categories evolve at different rates even when these effects are accounted for. The results demonstrate that relative rates and patterns of evolution are lineage specific, suggesting that phylogenetically and structurally specific models will improve evolutionary and structural predictions.     

Isolation of temperature-sensitive mutants of 16 S rRNA in Escherichia coli

Temperature-sensitive mutants have been isolated following hydroxylamine mutagenesis of a plasmid containing Escherichia coli rRNA genes carrying selectable markers for spectinomycin resistance (U1192 in 16 S rRNA) and erythromycin resistance (G2058 in 23 S rRNA). These antibiotic resistance alleles, originally identified by Morgan and co-workers, enable us to follow expression of cloned rRNA genes in vivo. Recessive mutations causing the loss of expression of the cloned 16 S rRNA gene were identified by the loss of the ability of cells to survive on media containing spectinomycin. The mutations were localized by in vitro restriction fragment replacement followed by in vivo marker rescue and were identified by DNA sequence analysis. We report here seven single-base alterations in 16 S rRNA (A146, U153, A350, A359, A538, A1292 and U1293), five of which produce temperature-sensitive spectinomycin resistance and two that produce unconditional loss of resistance. In each case, loss of ribosomal function can be accounted for by disruption of base-pairing in the secondary structure of 16 S rRNA. For the temperature-sensitive mutants, there is a lag period of about two generations between a shift to the restrictive temperature and cessation of growth, implying that the structural defects cause impairment of ribosome assembly.     

Prediction of secondary structures of 16S and 23S rRNA fromEscherichia coli

Small and large subunits ofEscherichia coli ribosome have three different rRNAs, the sequences of which are known. However, attempts by three groups to predict secondary structures of 16S and 23S rRNAs have certain common limitations namely, these structures are predicted assuming no interactions among various domains of the molecule and only 40% residues are involved in base pairing as against the experimental observation of 60 % residues in base paired state. Recent experimental studies have shown that there is a specific interaction between naked 16S and 23S rRNA molecules. This is significant because we have observed that the regions (oligonucleotides of length 9–10 residues), in 16S rRNA which are complementary to those in 23S rRNA do not have internal complementary sequences. Therefore, we have developed a simple graph theoretical approach to predict secondary structures of 16S and 23S rRNAs. Our method for model building not only uses complete sequence of 16S or 23S rRNA molecule along with other experimental observations but also takes into account the observation that specific recognition is possible through the complementary sequences between 16S and 23S rRNA molecules and, therefore, these parts of the molecules are not used for internal base pairing. The method used to predict secondary structures is discussed. A typical secondary structure of the complex between 16S and 23S rRNA molecules, obtained using our method, is presented and compared Briefly with earlier model Building studies.     

The ribosomal RNA identity elements for ricin and for alpha-sarcin: mutations in the putative CG pair that closes a GAGA tetraloop.

alpha-Sarcin is a ribonuclease that cleaves the phosphodiester bond on the 3' side of G4325 in 28S rRNA; ricin A-chain is a RNA N-glycosidase that depurinates the 5' adjacent A4324. These single covalent modifications inactivate the ribosome. An oligoribonucleotide that reproduces the structure of the sarcin/ricin domain in 28S rRNA was synthesized and mutations were constructed in the 5' C and the 3' G that surround a GAGA tetrad that has the sites of toxin action. Covalent modification of the RNA by ricin, but not by alpha-sarcin, requires a Watson-Crick pair to shut off a putative GAGA tetraloop. Either the recognition elements for the two toxins are different despite their catalyzing covalent modification of adjacent nucleotides in 28S rRNA or there are transitions in the conformation of the alpha-sarcin/ricin domain in 28S rRNA and one conformer is recognized by alpha-sarcin and the other by ricin A-chain.     

Following the dynamics of changes in solvent accessibility of 16 S and 23 S rRNA during ribosomal subunit association using synchrotron-generated hydroxyl radicals

We have probed the structure and dynamics of ribosomal RNA in the Escherichia coli ribosome using equilibrium and time-resolved hydroxyl radical (OH) RNA footprinting to explore changes in the solvent-accessible surface of the rRNA with single-nucleotide resolution. The goal of these studies is to better understand the structural transitions that accompany association of the 30 S and 50 S subunits and to build a foundation for the quantitative analysis of ribosome structural dynamics during translation. Clear portraits of the subunit interface surfaces for 16 S and 23 S rRNA were obtained by constructing difference maps between the OH protection maps of the free subunits and that of the associated ribosome. In addition to inter-subunit contacts consistent with the crystal structure, additional OH protections are evident in regions at or near the subunit interface that reflect association-induced conformational changes. Comparison of these data with the comparable difference maps of the solvent-accessible surface of the rRNA calculated for the Thermus thermophilus X-ray crystal structures shows extensive agreement but also distinct differences. As a prelude to time-resolved OH footprinting studies, the reactivity profiles obtained using Fe(II)EDTA and X-ray generated OH were comprehensively compared. The reactivity patterns are similar except for a small number of nucleotides that have decreased reactivity to OH generated from Fe(II)EDTA compared to X-rays. These nucleotides are generally close to ribosomal proteins, which can quench diffusing radicals by virtue of side-chain oxidation. Synchrotron X-ray OH footprinting was used to monitor the kinetics of association of the 30 S and 50 S subunits. The rates individually measured for the inter-subunit contacts are comparable within experimental error. The application of this approach to the study of ribosome dynamics during the translation cycle is discussed.