Isolation, Crystallization, and Investigation of Ribosomal Protein S8 Complexed with Specific Fragments of rRNA of Bacterial or Archaeal Origin

The core ribosomal protein S8 binds to the central domain of 16S rRNA independently of other ribosomal proteins and is required for assembling the 30S subunit. It has been shown with E. coli ribosomes that a short rRNA fragment restricted by nucleotides 588-602 and 636-651 is sufficient for strong and specific protein S8 binding. In this work, we studied the complexes formed by ribosomal protein S8 from Thermus thermophilus and Methanococcus jannaschii with short rRNA fragments isolated from the same organisms. The dissociation constants of the complexes of protein S8 with rRNA fragments were determined. Based on the results of binding experiments, rRNA fragments of different length were designed and synthesized in preparative amounts in vitro using T7 RNA-polymerase. Stable S8–RNA complexes were crystallized. Crystals were obtained both for homologous bacterial and archaeal complexes and for hybrid complexes of archaeal protein with bacterial rRNA. Crystals of the complex of protein S8 from M. jannaschii with the 37-nucleotide rRNA fragment from the same organism suitable for X-ray analysis were obtained.     

Isolation of Euglena gracilis chloroplast 5S ribosomal RNA and mapping the 5S rRNA gene on chloroplast DNA.

Ribosomal RNA (5S) from Euglena gracilis chloroplasts was isolated by preparative electrophoresis, labeled in vitro with 125I, and hybridized to restriction nuclease fragments from chloroplast DNA or cloned chloroplast DNA segments. Euglena chloroplast 5S rRNA is encoded in the chloroplast genome. The coding region of 5S rRNA has been positioned within the 5.6 kilobase pair (kbp) repeat which also codes for 16S and 23S rRNA. There are three 5S rRNA genes on the 130-kbp genome. The order of RNAs within a single repeat is 16S-23S-5S. The organization and size of the Euglena chloroplast ribosomal repeat is very similar to the ribosomal RNA operons of Escherichia coli.     

RNA-protein interactions in the ribosome. I. Characterization and ribonuclease digestion of 16 S RNA-ribosomal protein complexes

Proteins from the 30 S ribosomal subunit of Escherichia coli were fractionated by column chromatography and individually incubated with 16 S ribosomal RNA. Stable and specific complexes were formed between proteins S4, S7, S8, S15 and S20, and the 16 S RNA. Protein S13 and one or both proteins of the $\text{S}\text{16}\text{S}\text{17}$ mixture bound more weakly to the RNA, although these interactions too were apparently specific. The binding of $\text{S}\text{16}\text{S}\text{17}$ was found to be markedly stimulated by proteins S4, S8, S15 and S20. Limited digestion of the RNA-protein complexes with T₁ or pancreatic ribonucleases yielded a variety of partially overlapping RNA fragments, which retained one or more of the proteins. Since similar fragments were recovered when 16 S RNA alone was digested under the same conditions, their stability could not be accounted for by the presence of bound protein. The integrity of the fragments was, however, strongly influenced by the magnesium ion concentration at which ribonuclease digestion was carried out. Each of the RNA fragments was characterized by fingerprinting and positioned within the sequence of the 1600-nucleotide 16 S RNA molecule. The location of ribosomal protein binding sites was delimited by the pattern of fragments to which a given protein bound. The binding sites for proteins S4, S8, S15, S20 and, possibly, S13 and $\text{S}\text{16}\text{S}\text{17}$ as well, lie within the 5′-terminal half of the 16 S RNA molecule. In particular, the S4 binding site was localized to the first 500 nucleotides of this sequence while that for S15 lies within a 140-nucleotide sequence starting about 600 nucleotides from the 5′-terminus. The binding site for the protein S7 lies between 900 and 1500 nucleotides from the 5′-terminus of the ribosomal RNA.     

Interaction of ribosomal proteins S6, S8, S15 and S18 with the central domain of 16 S ribosomal RNA from Escherichia coli

The co-operative interaction of 30 S ribosomal subunit proteins S6, S8, S15 and S18 with 16 S ribosomal RNA from Escherichia coli was studied by (1) determining how the binding of each protein is influenced by the others and (2) characterizing a series of protein-rRNA fragment complexes. Whereas S8 and S15 are known to associate independently with the 16 S rRNA, binding of S18 depended upon S8 and S15, and binding of S6 was found to require S8, S15 and S18. Ribonucleoprotein (RNP) fragments were derived from the S8-, S8/S15- and S6/S8/S15/S18-16 S rRNA complexes by partial RNase hydrolysis and isolated by electrophoresis through Mg2+-containing polyacrylamide gels or by centrifugation through sucrose gradients. Identification of the proteins associated with each RNP by gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate demonstrated the presence of S8, S8 + S15 and S6 + S8 + S15 + S18 in the corresponding fragment complexes. Analysis of the rRNA components of the RNP particles confirmed that S8 was bound to nucleotides 583 to 605 and 624 to 653, and that S8 and S15 were associated with nucleotides 583 to 605, 624 to 672 and 733 to 757. Proteins S6, S8, S15 and S18 were shown to protect nucleotides 563 to 605, 624 to 680, 702 to 770, 818 to 839 and 844 to 891, which span the entire central domain of the 16 S rRNA molecule (nucleotides 560 to 890). The binding site for each protein contains helical elements as well as single-stranded internal loops ranging in size from a single bulged nucleotide to 20 bases. Three terminal loops and one stem-loop structure within the central domain of the 16 S rRNA were not protected in the four-protein complex. Interestingly, bases within or very close to these unprotected regions have been shown to be accessible to chemical and enzymatic probes in 30 S subunits but not in 70 S ribosomes. Furthermore, nucleotides adjacent to one of the unprotected loops have been cross-linked to a region near the 3' end of 16 S rRNA. Our observations and those of others suggest that the bases in this domain that are not sequestered by interactions with S6, S8, S15 or S18 play a role involved in subunit association or in tertiary interactions between portions of the rRNA chain that are distant from one-another in the primary structure.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

RNA-protein interactions in the ribosome. II. Binding of ribosomal proteins to isolated fragments of the 16 S RNA

Specific fragments of the 16 S ribosomal RNA of Escherichia coli have been isolated and tested for their ability to interact with proteins of the 30 S ribosomal subunit. The 12 S RNA, a 900-nucleotide fragment derived from the 5′-terminal portion of the 16 S RNA, was shown to form specific complexes with proteins S4, S8, S15, and S20. The stoichiometry of binding at saturation was determined in each case. Interaction between the 12 S RNA and protein fraction $\text{S}\text{16}\text{S}\text{17}$ was detected in the presence of S4, S8, S15 and S20; only these proteins were able to bind to this fragment, even when all 21 proteins of the 30 S subunit were added to the reaction mixture. Protein S4 also interacted specifically with the 9 S RNA, a fragment of 500 nucleotides that corresponds to the 5′-terminal third of the 16 S RNA, and protein S15 bound independently to the 4 S RNA, a fragment containing 140 nucleotides situated toward the middle of the RNA molecule. None of the proteins interacted with the 600-nucleotide 8 S fragment that arose from the 3′-end of the 16 S RNA.When the 16 S RNA was incubated with an unfractionated mixture of 30 S subunit proteins at 0 °C, 10 to 12 of the proteins interacted with the ribosomal RNA to form the reconstitution intermediate (RI) particle. Limited hydrolysis of this particle with T₁ ribonuclease yielded 14 S and 8 S subparticles whose RNA components were indistinguishable from the 12 S and 8 S RNAs isolated from digests of free 16 S RNA. The 14 S subparticle contained proteins S6 and S18 in addition to the RNA-binding proteins S4, S8, S15, S20 and $\text{S}\text{16}\text{S}\text{17}$. The 8 S subparticle contained proteins S7, S9, S13 and S19. These findings serve to localize the sites at which proteins incapable of independent interaction with 16 S RNA are fixed during the early stages of 30 S subunit assembly.     

RNA--protein interactions in the ribosome. IV. Structure and properties of binding sites for proteins S4, S16/S17 and S20 in the 16S RNA

Proteins S4, S16/S17 and S20 of the 30 S ribosomal subunit of Escherichia coli+ associate with specific binding sites in the 16 S ribosomal RNA. A systematic investigation of the co-operative interactions that occur when two or more of these proteins simultaneously attach to the 16 S RNA indicate that their binding sites lie near to one another. The binding site for S4 has previously been located within a 550-nucleotide RNA fragment of approximately 9 S that arises from the 5′-terminal portion of the 16 S RNA upon limited hydrolysis with pancreatic ribonuclease. The 9 S RNA was unable to associate with S20 and S16/S17, however, either alone or in combination. A fragment of similar size and nucleotide sequence, termed the 9 S¹ RNA, has been isolated following ribonuclease digestion of the complex of 16 S RNA with S20 and S16/S17. The 9 S¹ RNA bound not only S4, but S20 and S16/S17 as well, although the fragment complex was stable only when both of the latter protein fractions were present together. Nonetheless, measurements of binding stoichiometry demonstrated the interactions to be specific under these conditions. A comparison of the 9 S and 9 S¹ RNAs by electrophoresis in polyacrylamide gels containing urea revealed that the two fragments differ substantially in the number and distribution of hidden breaks. Contrary to expectation, the RNA in the ribonucleoprotein complex appeared to be more accessible to ribonuclease than the free 16 S RNA as judged by the smaller average length of the sub-fragments recovered from the 9 S¹ RNA. These results suggest that the binding of S4, S16/S17 and S20 brings about a conformational alteration within the 5′ third of the 16 S RNA.To delineate further the portions of the RNA chain that interact with S4, S16/S17 and S20, specific fragments encompassing subsequences from the 5′ third of the 16 S RNA were sought. Two such fragments, designated 12 S-I and 12 S-II, were purified by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis from partial T₁ ribonuclease digests of the 16 S RNA. The two RNAs, which contain 290 and 210 nucleotides, respectively, are contiguous and together span the entire 5′-terminal 500 residues of the 16 S RNA molecule. When tested individually, neither 12 S-I nor 12 S-II bound S4, S16/S17 or S20. If heated together at 40 °C in the presence of Mg²⁺ ions, however, the two fragments together formed an 8 S complex which associated with S4 alone, with S16/S17 + S20 in combination, and with S4 + S16/S17 + S20 when incubated with an un fractionated mixture of 30 S subunit proteins. These results imply that each fragment contains part of the corresponding binding sites.     

Isolation of ribosomal protein-RNA complexes by nitrocellulose membrane filtration: equilibrium binding studies.

E. coli ribosomal proteins are retained by nitrocellulose filters. In contrast, 16S RNA passes through nitrocellulose filters. We have found that specific protein-RNA complexes involving single proteins also pass through nitrocellulose filters. Thus, by utilizing radioactively labeled r-proteins, nitrocellulose filtration can be used to study directly and sensitively the stoichiometry of r-protein-RNA association. The filtration process maintains near equilibrium conditions, making it applicable to weak as well as strong protein-RNA associations. We have used nitrocellulose filtration to obtain saturation binding curves for the association of proteins S4, S7, S8 and S20 with 16S RNA. In each case, the stoichiometry of binding was one mole of protein or less per mole of RNA. The stoichiometry of protein S8 binding to 16S RNA measured by filtration is comparable to that observed by sucrose gradient centrifugation. Association constants for the binding of proteins S4, S8 and S20 to 16S RNA have been determined by analysis of the saturation binding curves and were found to range from .3-6 X 10(7)M-1.     

Apparent association constants for E. coli ribosomal proteins S4, S7, S8, S15, S17 and S20 binding to 16S RNA.

We have previously reported the development of a technique utilizing nitrocellulose filters, which rapidly separates ribosomal protein-ribosomal RNA complexes from unbound protein. We have used this technique to obtain binding data for the association of proteins S4, S7, S8, S15, S17, and S20 with 16S RNA. With the exception of protein S17, the association behavior for each of these proteins exhibits a single binding site with a unique binding constant. The apparent association constants have been calculated and have been found to have a range from 1.6 x 10(6) M-1 for protein S7 to 7.1 x 10(7) M-1 for protein S17. The Scatchard plot for the protein S17 binding data is biphasic, suggesting that within the RNA population two different binding sites exist, each with a different apparent association constant.     

DNA-hybridization electron microscopy tertiary structure of 16 S rRNA

Seven regions of 16 S rRNA have been located on the surface of the 30 S ribosomal subunit by DNA-hybridization electron microscopy. This information has been incorporated into a model for the tertiary structure of 16 S rRNA, accounting for approximately 40% of the total 16 S rRNA. A structure labeled the platform ring is proposed for a region of rRNA within the central domain. This structure rings the edges of the platform and includes regions 655-751 and 769-810. Another region, the recognition complex, consists of nucleotides 500 to 545, and occupies a region on the exterior surface of the subunit near the elongation factor Tu binding site. Ribosomal proteins that have been mapped by immunoelectron microscopy are superimposed onto the model in order to examine possible regions of interaction. Good correlation between the model locations of ribosomal proteins, and regions of rRNA protected by ribosomal proteins provide independent support for this model.     

Location and characteristics of ribosomal protein binding sites in the 16S RNA of Escherichia coli.

Specific binding sites for five proteins of the Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunit have been located within the 16S RNA. The sites are structurally diverse and range in size from 40 to 500 nucleotides; their functional integrity appears to depend upon both the secondary structure and conformation of the RNA molecule. Evidence is presented which indicates that additional proteins interact with the RNA at later stages of subunit assembly.     

Independent binding sites in mouse 5.8S ribosomal ribonucleic acid for 28S ribosomal ribonucleic acid

Limited digestion of mouse 5.8S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) with RNase T2 generates 5'- and 3'-terminal "half-molecules". These fragments are capable of independently and specifically binding to 28S rRNA, so there exist at least two contacts in the 5.8S rRNA for the 28S rRNA. The dissociation constants for the 5.8S/28S, 5' 5.8S fragment/28S, and 3' 5.8S fragment/28S complexes are 9 x 10(-8) M, 6 x 10(-8) M, and 13 x 10(-8) M, respectively. Thus, each of the fragment binding sites contributes about equally to the overall binding energy of the 5.8S/28S rRNA complex, and the binding sites act independently, rather than cooperatively. The dissociation constants suggest that the 5.8S rRNA termini from short, irregular helices with 28S rRNA. Thermal denaturation data on complexes containing 28S rRNA and each of the half-molecules of 5.8S rRNA indicate that the 5'-terminal binding site(s) exist(s) in a single conformation while the 3'-terminal site exhibits two conformational alternatives. The functional significance of the different conformational states is presently indeterminate, but the possibility they may represent alternative forms of a conformational switch operative during ribosome function is discussed.     

A chemical interference study on the interaction of ribosomal protein L11 from Escherichia coli with RNA molecules containing its binding site from 23S rRNA.

The interaction between ribosomal protein L11 from Escherichia coli and in vitro synthesized RNA containing its binding site from 23S rRNA was characterized by identifying nucleotides that interfered with complex formation when chemically modified by diethylpyrocarbonate or hydrazine. Chemically modified RNA was incubated with L11 under conditions appropriate for specific binding of L11 and the resulting protein-RNA complex was separated from unbound RNA on Mg(2+)-containing polyacrylamide gels. The ability to isolate L11 complexes on such gels was affected by the extent of modification by either reagent. Protein-bound and free RNAs were recovered and treated with aniline to identify their content of modified bases. Exclusion of RNA containing chemically altered bases from L11-associated material occurred for 29 modified nucleotides, located throughout the region corresponding to residues 1055-1105 in 23S rRNA. Ten bases within this region did not reproducibly inhibit binding when modified. Multiple bands of RNA were consistently observed on the nondenaturing gels, suggesting that significant intermolecular RNA-RNA interactions had occurred.     

Hydroxyl radical footprinting of ribosomal proteins on 16S rRNA.

Complexes between 16S rRNA and purified ribosomal proteins, either singly or in combination, were assembled in vitro and probed with hydroxyl radicals generated from free Fe(II)-EDTA. The broad specificity of hydroxyl radicals for attack at the ribose moiety in both single- and double-stranded contexts permitted probing of nearly all of the nucleotides in the 16S rRNA chain. Specific protection of localized regions of the RNA was observed in response to assembly of most of the ribosomal proteins. The locations of the protected regions were in good general agreement with the footprints previously reported for base-specific chemical probes, and with sites of RNA-protein crosslinking. New information was obtained about interaction of ribosomal proteins with 16S rRNA, especially with helical elements of the RNA. In some cases, 5' or 3' stagger in the protection pattern on complementary strands suggests interaction of proteins with the major or minor groove, respectively, of the RNA. These results reinforce and extend previous data on the localization of ribosomal proteins with respect to structural features of 16S rRNA, and offer many new constraints for three-dimensional modeling of the 30S ribosomal subunit.     

Localization of the binding site for protein S4 on 16 S ribosomal RNA by chemical and enzymatic probing and primer extension

We have examined the effect of binding ribosomal protein S4 to 16 S rRNA on the susceptibility of the RNA to a variety of chemical and enzymatic probes. We have used dimethyl sulfate to probe unpaired adenines (at N-1) and cytosines (at N-3), kethoxal to probe unpaired guanines (at N-1 and N-2) and cobra venom (V1) ribonuclease as a probe of base-paired regions of 16 S rRNA. Sites of attack by the probes were identified by primer extension using synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides. Comparison of probing results for naked and S4-bound rRNA shows: Protein S4 protects a relatively compact region of the 5' domain of 16 S rRNA from chemical and enzymatic attack. This region is bounded by nucleotides 27 to 47 and 394 to 556, and has a secondary structure characterized by the junction of five helical elements. Phylogenetically conserved irregular features (bulged nucleotides, internal loops and flanking unpaired nucleotides) and helical phosphodiester bonds of four of the helices are specifically protected in the S4-RNA complex. We conclude that this is the major, and possibly sole region of contact between 16 S rRNA and S4. Many of the S4-dependent changes mimic those observed on assembly of 16 S rRNA into 30 S ribosomal subunits. Binding of S4 causes enhanced chemical reactivity coupled with protection from V1 nuclease outside the S4 junction region in the 530, 720 and 1140 loops. We interpret these results as indicative of loss of structure, and suggest that S4 binding causes disruption of adventitious pairing in these regions, possibly by stabilizing the geometry of the RNA such that these interactions are prevented from forming.     

A short fragment of 23S rRNA containing the binding sites for two ribosomal proteins, L24 and L4, is a key element for rRNA folding during early assembly

Previously we described an in vitro selection variant abbreviated SERF (in vitro selection from random rRNA fragments) that identifies protein binding sites within large RNAs. With this method, a small rRNA fragment derived from the 23S rRNA was isolated that binds simultaneously and independently the ribosomal proteins L4 and L24 from Escherichia coli. Until now the rRNA structure within the ternary complex L24-rRNA-L4 could not be studied due to the lack of an appropriate experimental strategy. Here we tackle the issue by separating the various complexes via native gel-electrophoresis and analyzing the rRNA structure by in-gel iodine cleavage of phosphorothioated RNA. The results demonstrate that during the transition from either the L4 or L24 binary complex to the ternary complex the structure of the rRNA fragment changes significantly. The identified protein binding sites are in excellent agreement with the recently reported crystal structure of the 50S subunit. Because both proteins play a prominent role in early assembly of the large subunit, the results suggest that the identified rRNA fragment is a key element for the folding of the 23S RNA during early assembly. The introduced in-gel cleavage method should be useful when an RNA structure within mixed populations of different but related complexes should be studied.     

Yeast ribosomal protein L25 binds to an evolutionary conserved site on yeast 26S and E. coli 23S rRNA.

The binding site of the yeast 60S ribosomal subunit protein L25 on 26S rRNA was determined by RNase protection experiments. The fragments protected by L25 originate from a distinct substructure within domain IV of the rRNA, encompassing nucleotides 1465-1632 and 1811-1861. The protected fragments are able to rebind to L25 showing that they constitute the complete protein binding site. This binding site is remarkably conserved in all 23/26/28S rRNAs sequenced to date including Escherichia coli 23S rRNA. In fact heterologous complexes between L25 and E. coli 23S rRNA could be formed and RNase protection studies on these complexes demonstrated that L25 indeed recognizes the conserved structure. Strikingly the L25 binding site on 23S rRNA is virtually identical to the previously identified binding site of E. coli ribosomal protein EL23. Therefore EL23 is likely to be the prokaryotic counterpart of L25 in spite of the limited homology displayed by the amino acid sequences of the two proteins.