Biochemical studies on Francisella tularensis RelA in (p)ppGpp biosynthesis

The bacterial stringent response is induced by nutrient deprivation and is mediated by enzymes of the RSH (RelA/SpoT homologue; RelA, (p)ppGpp synthetase I; SpoT, (p)ppGpp synthetase II) superfamily that control concentrations of the ‘alarmones’ (p)ppGpp (guanosine penta- or tetra-phosphate). This regulatory pathway is present in the vast majority of pathogens and has been proposed as a potential anti-bacterial target. Current understanding of RelA-mediated responses is based on biochemical studies using Escherichia coli as a model. In comparison, the Francisella tularensis RelA sequence contains a truncated regulatory C-terminal region and an unusual synthetase motif (EXSD). Biochemical analysis of F. tularensis RelA showed the similarities and differences of this enzyme compared with the model RelA from Escherichia coli. Purification of the enzyme yielded a stable dimer capable of reaching concentrations of 10 mg/ml. In contrast with other enzymes from the RelA/SpoT homologue superfamily, activity assays with F. tularensis RelA demonstrate a high degree of specificity for GTP as a pyrophosphate acceptor, with no measurable turnover for GDP. Steady state kinetic analysis of F. tularensis RelA gave saturation activity curves that best fitted a sigmoidal function. This kinetic profile can result from allosteric regulation and further measurements with potential allosteric regulators demonstrated activation by ppGpp (5′,3′-dibisphosphate guanosine) with an EC₅₀ of 60±1.9 μM. Activation of F. tularensis RelA by stalled ribosomal complexes formed with ribosomes purified from E. coli MRE600 was observed, but interestingly, significantly weaker activation with ribosomes isolated from Francisella philomiragia.     

Bacteria possessing two RelA/SpoT-like proteins have evolved a specific stringent response involving the acyl carrier protein-SpoT interaction

Bacteria respond to nutritional stress by producing (p)ppGpp, which triggers a stringent response resulting in growth arrest and expression of resistance genes. In Escherichia coli, RelA produces (p)ppGpp upon amino acid starvation by detecting stalled ribosomes. The SpoT enzyme responds to various other types of starvation by unknown mechanisms. We previously described an interaction between SpoT and the central cofactor of lipid synthesis, acyl carrier protein (ACP), which is involved in detecting starvation signals in lipid metabolism and triggering SpoT-dependent (p)ppGpp accumulation. However, most bacteria possess a unique protein homologous to RelA/SpoT (Rsh) that is able to synthesize and degrade (p)ppGpp and is therefore more closely related to SpoT function. In this study, we asked if the ACP-SpoT interaction is specific for bacteria containing two RelA and SpoT enzymes or if it is a general feature that is conserved in Rsh enzymes. By testing various combinations of SpoT, RelA, and Rsh enzymes and ACPs of E. coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Bacillus subtilis and Streptococcus pneumoniae, we found that the interaction between (p)ppGpp synthases and ACP seemed to be restricted to SpoT proteins of bacteria containing the two RelA and SpoT proteins and to ACP proteins encoded by genes located in fatty acid synthesis operons. When Rsh enzymes from B. subtilis and S. pneumoniae are produced in E. coli, the behavior of these enzymes is different from the behavior of both RelA and SpoT proteins with respect to (p)ppGpp synthesis. This suggests that bacteria have evolved several different modes of (p)ppGpp regulation in order to respond to nutrient starvation.     

“严谨反应”还是“严紧反应”?

“Stringent response”是指细菌在遭受营养饥饿与环境胁迫时,由代谢酶RelA/SpoT催化合成信号分子鸟苷四/五磷酸[(p)ppGpp],从而诱导细菌细胞关闭rRNA、tRNA及核糖体蛋白基因转录,停止多种蛋白质的翻译,严控大部分代谢活动的一系列适应性基因表达过程。“Stringent response”几乎是所有细菌应对逆境的重要调节机制。目前,国内文献对“stringent response”的中文翻译存在“严谨反应”和“严紧反应”混用的现象。基于此,本文对“stringent response”的调控机制、生理功能及字面含义进行了分析,认为“stringent response”翻译为“严紧反应”更为合理、准确。     

(p)ppGpp——“魔斑”核苷酸在细菌中的研究进展

鸟苷四磷酸（guanosine tetraphosphate,ppGpp）/鸟苷五磷酸（guanosine pentaphosphate,pppGpp）是细菌严谨反应的信号分子,其合成和水解由Rel/SpoT同系物（RelA/SpoT homologue,RSH）家族的蛋白质合成和水解活性控制。（p）ppGpp介导的严谨反应能够提高细菌对营养匮乏的适应能力和抗生素抗性。近年来发现（p）ppGpp与细菌生长和细胞分裂、抗生素合成等都密切相关,是细胞内重要的全局调控因子。（p）ppGpp在细菌细胞中有许多靶点,使其可以调节DNA复制、转录、细胞周期、核糖体生物合成以及抗生素合成基因簇的表达。然而,（p）ppGpp如何控制转录和其他代谢过程取决于细菌种类,并在不同的微生物中通过不同的机制调节相同的过程。因此,本文通过综述（p）ppGpp的合成/水解酶的种类和调节机制,（p）ppGpp对微生物代谢调控机制、对细胞周期的影响机制,以及（p）ppGpp对抗生素合成和耐受性的调控机制,为细菌耐药性研究和细胞生理学研究奠定基础。     

Fatty acid starvation activates RelA by depleting lysine precursor pyruvate

Bacteria undergoing nutrient starvation induce the ubiquitous stringent response, resulting in gross physiological changes that reprograms cell metabolism from fast to slow growth. The stringent response is mediated by the secondary messengers pppGpp and ppGpp collectively referred to as (p)ppGpp or ‘alarmone’. In Escherichia coli, two paralogs, RelA and SpoT, synthesize (p)ppGpp. RelA is activated by amino acid starvation, whereas SpoT, which can also degrade (p)ppGpp, responds to fatty acid (FA), carbon and phosphate starvation. Here, we discover that FA starvation leads to rapid activation of RelA and reveal the underlying mechanism. We show that FA starvation leads to depletion of lysine that, in turn, leads to the accumulation of uncharged tRNA^Lys and activation of RelA. SpoT was also activated by FA starvation but to a lower level and with a delayed kinetics. Next, we discovered that pyruvate, a precursor of lysine, is depleted by FA starvation. We also propose a mechanism that explains how FA starvation leads to pyruvate depletion. Together our results raise the possibility that RelA may be a major player under many starvation conditions previously thought to depend principally on SpoT. Interestingly, FA starvation provoked a ~100‐fold increase in relA dependent ampicillin tolerance.     

Regulation of cell growth during serum starvation and bacterial survival in macrophages by the bifunctional enzyme SpoT in Helicobacter pylori

In Helicobacter pylori the stringent response is mediated solely by spoT. The spoT gene is known to encode (p)ppGpp synthetase activity and is required for H. pylori survival in the stationary phase. However, neither the hydrolase activity of the H. pylori SpoT protein nor the role of SpoT in the regulation of growth during serum starvation and intracellular survival of H. pylori in macrophages has been determined. In this study, we examined the effects of SpoT on these factors. Our results showed that the H. pylori spoT gene encodes a bifunctional enzyme with both a hydrolase activity and the previously described (p)ppGpp synthetase activity, as determined by introducing the gene into Escherichia coli relA and spoT defective strains. Also, we found that SpoT mediates a serum starvation response, which not only restricts the growth but also maintains the helical morphology of H. pylori. Strikingly, a spoT null mutant was able to grow to a higher density in serum-free medium than the wild-type strain, mimicking the “relaxed” growth phenotype of an E. coli relA mutant during amino acid starvation. Finally, SpoT was found to be important for intracellular survival in macrophages during phagocytosis. The unique role of (p)ppGpp in cell growth during serum starvation, in the stress response, and in the persistence of H. pylori is discussed.     

A RelA-SpoT homolog (Cr-RSH) identified in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii generates stringent factor in vivo and localizes to chloroplasts in vitro

A gene encoding a putative guanosine 3′,5′-bispyrophosphate (ppGpp) synthase–degradase, designated Cr-RSH, was identified in the unicellular photosynthetic eukaryote Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. The encoded Cr-RSH protein possesses a putative chloroplast-targeting signal at its NH₂-terminus, and translocation of Cr-RSH into chloroplasts isolated from C.reinhardtii was demonstrated in vitro. The predicted mature region of Cr-RSH exhibits marked similarity to eubacterial members of the RelA–SpoT family of proteins. Expression of an NH₂-terminal portion of Cr-RSH containing the putative ppGpp synthase domain in a relA, spoT double mutant of Escherichia coli complemented the growth deficits of the mutant cells. Chromatographic analysis of ³²P-labeled cellular mononucleotides also revealed that expression of Cr-RSH in the mutant bacterial cells resulted in the synthesis of ppGpp. SpoT, which catalyzes (p)ppGpp degradation, is dispensable in E.coli only if cells also lack RelA, which possesses (p)ppGpp synthase activity. The complementation analysis thus indicated that Cr-RSH possesses both ppGpp synthase and degradase activities. These results represent the first demonstration of ppGpp synthase–degradase activities in a eukaryotic organism, and they suggest that eubacterial stringent control mediated by ppGpp has been conserved during evolution of the chloroplast from a photosynthetic bacterial symbiont.     

A charge reversal differentiates (p)ppGpp synthesis by monofunctional and bifunctional Rel proteins

A major regulatory mechanism evolved by microorganisms to combat stress is the regulation mediated by (p)ppGpp (the stringent response molecule), synthesized and hydrolyzed by Rel proteins. These are divided into bifunctional and monofunctional proteins based on the presence or absence of the hydrolysis activity. Although these proteins require Mg(2+) for (p)ppGpp synthesis, high Mg(2+) was shown to inhibit this reaction in bifunctional Rel proteins from Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Streptococcus equisimilis. This is not a characteristic feature in enzymes that use a dual metal ion mechanism, such as DNA polymerases that are known to carry out a similar pyrophosphate transfer reaction. Comparison of polymerase Polbeta and Rel(Seq) structures that share a common fold led to the proposal that the latter would follow a single metal ion mechanism. Surprisingly, in contrast to bifunctional Rel, we did not find inhibition of guanosine 5'-triphosphate, 3'-diphosphate (pppGpp) synthesis at higher Mg(2+) in the monofunctional RelA from Escherichia coli. We show that a charge reversal in a conserved motif in the synthesis domains explains this contrast; an RXKD motif in the bifunctional proteins is reversed to an EXDD motif. The differential response of these proteins to Mg(2+) could also be noticed in fluorescent nucleotide binding and circular dichroism experiments. In mutants where the motifs were reversed, the differential effect could also be reversed. We infer that although a catalytic Mg(2+) is common to both bifunctional and monofunctional proteins, the latter would utilize an additional metal binding site formed by EXDD. This work, for the first time, brings out differences in (p)ppGpp synthesis by the two classes of Rel proteins.     

The relA/spoT-Homologous Gene in Streptomyces coelicolor Encodes Both Ribosome-Dependent (p)ppGppSynthesizing and -Degrading Activities

Streptomyces coelicolor (p)ppGpp synthetase (Rel protein) belongs to the RelA and SpoT (RelA/SpoT) family, which is involved in (p)ppGpp metabolism and the stringent response. The potential functions of the rel gene have been examined. S. coelicolor Rel has been shown to be ribosome associated, and its activity in vitro is ribosome dependent. Analysis in vivo of the active recombinant protein in well-defined Escherichia coli relA and relA/spoT mutants provides evidence that S. coelicolor Rel, like native E. coli RelA, is functionally ribosome associated, resulting in ribosome-dependent (p)ppGpp accumulation upon amino acid deprivation. Expression of an S. coelicolor C-terminally deleted Rel, comprised of only the first 489 amino acids, catalyzes a ribosome-independent (p)ppGpp formation, in the same manner as the E. coli truncated RelA protein (1 to 455 amino acids). An E. coli relA spoT double deletion mutant transformed with S. coelicolor rel gene suppresses the phenotype associated with (p)ppGpp deficiency. However, in such a strain, a rel-mediated (p)ppGpp response apparently occurs after glucose depletion, but only in the absence of amino acids. Analysis of ppGpp decay in E. coli expressing the S. coelicolor rel gene suggests that it also encodes a (p)ppGpp-degrading activity. By deletion analysis, the catalytic domains of S. coelicolor Rel for (p)ppGpp synthesis and degradation have been located within its N terminus (amino acids 267 to 453 and 93 to 397, respectively). In addition, E. coli relA in an S. coelicolor rel deletion mutant restores actinorhodine production and shows a nearly normal morphological differentiation, as does the wild-type rel gene, which is in agreement with the proposed role of (p)ppGpp nucleotides in antibiotic biosynthesis.     

G-protein control of the ribosome-associated stress response protein SpoT

The bacterial response to stress is controlled by two proteins, RelA and SpoT. RelA generates the alarmone (p)ppGpp under amino acid starvation, whereas SpoT is responsible for (p)ppGpp hydrolysis and for synthesis of (p)ppGpp under a variety of cellular stress conditions. It is widely accepted that RelA is associated with translating ribosomes. The cellular location of SpoT, however, has been controversial. SpoT physically interacts with the ribosome-associated GTPase CgtA, and we show here that, under an optimized salt condition, SpoT is also associated with a pre-50S particle. Analysis of spoT and cgtA mutants and strains overexpressing CgtA suggests that the ribosome associations of SpoT and CgtA are mutually independent. The steady-state level of (p)ppGpp is increased in a cgtA mutant, but the accumulation of (p)ppGpp during amino acid starvation is not affected, providing strong evidence that CgtA regulates the (p)ppGpp level during exponential growth but not during the stringent response. We show that CgtA is not associated with pre-50S particles during amino acid starvation, indicating that under these conditions in which (p)ppGpp accumulates, CgtA is not bound either to the pre-50S particle or to SpoT. We propose that, in addition to its role as a 50S assembly factor, CgtA promotes SpoT (p)ppGpp degradation activity on the ribosome and that the loss of CgtA from the ribosome is necessary for maximal (p)ppGpp accumulation under stress conditions. Intriguingly, we found that in the absence of spoT and relA, cgtA is still an essential gene in Escherichia coli.     

The RelA/SpoT homolog (RSH) superfamily: distribution and functional evolution of ppGpp synthetases and hydrolases across the tree of life

RelA/SpoT Homologue (RSH) proteins, named for their sequence similarity to the RelA and SpoT enzymes of Escherichia coli, comprise a superfamily of enzymes that synthesize and/or hydrolyze the alarmone ppGpp, activator of the "stringent" response and regulator of cellular metabolism. The classical "long" RSHs Rel, RelA and SpoT with the ppGpp hydrolase, synthetase, TGS and ACT domain architecture have been found across diverse bacteria and plant chloroplasts, while dedicated single domain ppGpp-synthesizing and -hydrolyzing RSHs have also been discovered in disparate bacteria and animals respectively. However, there is considerable confusion in terms of nomenclature and no comprehensive phylogenetic and sequence analyses have previously been carried out to classify RSHs on a genomic scale. We have performed high-throughput sensitive sequence searching of over 1000 genomes from across the tree of life, in combination with phylogenetic analyses to consolidate previous ad hoc identification of diverse RSHs in different organisms and provide a much-needed unifying terminology for the field. We classify RSHs into 30 subgroups comprising three groups: long RSHs, small alarmone synthetases (SASs), and small alarmone hydrolases (SAHs). Members of nineteen previously unidentified RSH subgroups can now be studied experimentally, including previously unknown RSHs in archaea, expanding the "stringent response" to this domain of life. We have analyzed possible combinations of RSH proteins and their domains in bacterial genomes and compared RSH content with available RSH knock-out data for various organisms to determine the rules of combining RSHs. Through comparative sequence analysis of long and small RSHs, we find exposed sites limited in conservation to the long RSHs that we propose are involved in transmitting regulatory signals. Such signals may be transmitted via NTD to CTD intra-molecular interactions, or inter-molecular interactions either among individual RSH molecules or among long RSHs and other binding partners such as the ribosome.