Molecular identification of Rab7 (ApRab7) in Aiptasia pulchella and its exclusion from phagosomes harboring zooxanthellae

The establishment and maintenance of the intracellular association between marine cnidarians and their symbiotic microalgae is essential to the well being of coral reef ecosystems; however, little is known concerning its underlying molecular mechanisms. In light of the critical roles of the small GTPase, Rab7, as a key regulator of vesicular trafficking, we cloned and characterized the Rab7 protein in the endosymbiosis system between the sea anemone, Aiptasia pulchella and its algal symbiont, Symbiodinium spp. The Aiptasia homologue of Rab7 proteins, ApRab7 is 88% identical to human Rab7 protein and contains all Rab-specific signature motifs. Results of EGFP reporter analysis, protein fractionation, and immunocytochemistry support that ApRab7 is located in late endocytic and phagocytic compartments and is able to promote their fusion. Significantly, the majority of phagosomes containing live symbionts that either have taken long residency in, or were newly internalized by Aiptasia digestive cells did not contain detectable levels of ApRab7, while most phagosomes containing either heat-killed or photosynthesis-impaired symbionts were positive for ApRab7 staining. Overall, our data suggest that live algal symbionts persist inside their host cells by actively excluding ApRab7 from their phagosomes, and thereby, establish and/or maintain an endosymbiotic relationship with their cnidarian hosts.     

Molecular cloning of Rab5 (ApRab5) in Aiptasia pulchella and its retention in phagosomes harboring live zooxanthellae

The intracellular association of symbiotic dinoflagellates (zooxanthellae) with marine cnidarians is the very foundation of the highly productive and diversified coral reef ecosystems. To reveal its underlying molecular mechanisms, we previously cloned ApRab7, a Rab7 homologue of the sea anemone Aiptasia pulchella, and demonstrated its selective exclusion from phagosomes containing live zooxanthellae, but not from those containing either dead or photosynthesis-impaired algae. In this study, Rab5 was characterized, due to its key role in endocytosis and phagocytosis acting upstream of Rab7. The Aiptasia Rab5 homologue (ApRab5) is 79.5% identical to human Rab5C and contains all Rab-specific signature motifs. Subcellular fractionation study showed that ApRab5 is mainly cytosolic. EGFP reporter and phagocytosis studies indicated that membrane-associated ApRab5 is present in early endocytic and phagocytic compartments, and is able to promote their fusion. Significantly, immunofluorescence study showed that the majority of phagosomes containing either resident or newly internalized live zooxanthellae were labeled with ApRab5, while those containing either heat-killed or photosynthesis-impaired algae were mostly negative for ApRab5 staining whereas the opposite was observed for ApRab7. We propose that active phagosomal retention of ApRab5 is part of the mechanisms employed by live zooxanthellae to: (1) persist inside their host cells and (2) exclude ApRab7 from their phagosomes, thereby, establishing and/or maintaining an endosymbiotic relationship with their cnidarian hosts.     

Endosymbiosis in Hydra and the Evolution of Internal Defense System

Certain species of Chlorella have exploited an intracellularhabitat and occur naturally as cytobionts in Hydra viridissima.The algae evoke phagocytosis by Hydra digestive cells and aresequestered in individual phagosomes that migrate to the baseof the host cells and resist fusion with lysosomes. The abilityto resist digestion is closely correlated with release of extracellularcarbohydrate (maltose) by the algae. The established populationof algae grows at an average rate equal to or greater than thatof the host and a constant population density is maintained.The host regulates algal population density by expelling ordigesting excess algae, or by controlling algal cell division.The control mechanism is unknown but can be breached by additionof inorganic ions to the Hydra culture medium with the resultthat the algae overgrow the Hydra. The Hydra-Chlorella symbiosis is probably mutually beneficial,but conditions such as prolonged darkness (with or without feeding)can reduce the competitive fitness of the host since this conditionresults in heterotrophy by the algae at the expense of selectedhost substrates. The evolution of selective permeability toorganic substrates is a major feature of the successful colonizationof the intracellular habitat by symbiotic Chlorella.     

Symbiotic <Emphasis Type="Italic">Chlorella variabilis</Emphasis> strain, 1 N,can influence the digestive process in the host <Emphasis Type="Italic">Paramecium bursaria</Emphasis> during early infection

The association between the ciliate Paramecium bursaria and symbiotic Chlorella spp. is mutually beneficial. However, this relationship is facultative mutualism because both the host and the symbiotic algae can grow by themselves. This association is easily re-established by mixing the two species together. Following algal mixing, some algae become enclosed in the digestive vacuole membrane of the paramecia to which both acidosomes and lysosomes fuse. To establish endosymbiosis, some algae acquire temporal resistance to the host lysosomal enzymes in the digestive vacuoles. We examined whether the algae influence the differentiation of the host digestive process using LysoSensor staining to evaluate the acidification of the digestive vacuoles. Furthermore, to assess lysosomal fusion with the digestive vacuole, Gomori’s staining was conducted. Acidification and lysosomal fusion occurred later in digestive vacuoles containing living algae than in those containing boiled algae or latex spheres. This phenomenon was observed when the living algae were maintained under a constant light condition. These results suggest that the algae release some unknown factor in response to light exposure, and the factor may be associated with the alteration of the host digestive process, indicating that the living algae can influence the host digestive processes during early algal infection.     

Intracellular digestion and symbiosis in Paramecium bursaria

Electron microscopic cytochemical methods reveal that acid phosphatase activity appears exclusively in vacuoles containing recently ingested bacteria or inert particles such as carmine, Celkate or latex spheres, and not in the vacuoles surrounding established symbionts. Although newly ingested symbiotic algae are digested in large numbers, some remain to reestablish the symbiosis. Since symbiotic algae are able to delay the digestion of heat-killed algae when they coexist in a phagosome, we propose that symbiotic Chlorella actively interfere with an early event in the host digestive process.     

ApRab11, a cnidarian homologue of the recycling regulatory protein Rab11, is involved in the establishment and maintenance of the Aiptasia-Symbiodinium endosymbiosis

Endosymbiotic association of the Symbiodinium dinoflagellates (zooxanthellae) with their cnidarian host cells involves an alteration in the development of the alga-enclosing phagosomes. To uncover its molecular basis, we previously investigated and established that the intracellular persistence of the zooxanthella-containing phagosomes involves specific alga-mediated interference with the expression of ApRab5 and ApRab7, two key endocytic regulatory Rab proteins, which results in the selective retention of the former on and exclusion of the later from the organelles. Here we examined the role of ApRab11, a cnidarian homologue of the key endocytic recycling regulator, Rab11, in the Aiptasia-Symbiodinium endosymbiosis. ApRab11 protein shared 88% overall sequence identity with human Rab11A and contained all Rab-specific signature motifs. Co-localization and mutagenesis studies showed that EGFP-tagged ApRab11 was predominantly associated with recycling endosomes and functioned in the recycling of internalized transferrin. In phagocytosis of latex beads, ApRab11 was quickly recruited to and later gradually removed from the developing phagosomes. Significantly, although ApRab11 immunoreactivity was rapidly detected on the phagosomes containing either newly internalized, heat-killed zooxanthellae, or resident zooxanthellae briefly treated with the photosynthesis inhibitor DCMU, it was rarely observed in the majority of phagosomes containing either newly internalized live, or healthy resident, zooxanthellae. It was concluded that through active exclusion of ApRab11 from the phagosomes in which they reside, zooxanthellae interfere with the normal recycling process required for efficient phagosome maturation, and thereby, secure their intracellular persistence, and consequently their endosymbiotic relationship with their cnidarian hosts.     

Selectivity in phagocytosis and persistence of symbiotic algae in the scyphistoma stage of the jellyfish Cassiopeia xamachana

We have investigated whether interactions between cell-surface macromolecules play a role in cellular recognition leading to specificity in the establishment of intracellular symbiosis between dinoflagellates and the polyp (scyphistoma) stage of the jellyfish Cassiopeia xamachana. All strains of the symbiotic dinoflagellate Symbiodinium microadriaticum were phagocytosed by the endodermal cells of the scyphistomae when presented to them as cells freshly isolated from their respective hosts. The rates of phagocytosis of such cells were high, and were directly correlated with the presence of a membrane, thought to be the host cell vacuolar membrane that surrounds the freshly isolated algae. Cultured algae lack this membrane. All cultured algae, even those that proliferate in host tissues, were phagocytosed at very low or undetectable rates. Freshly isolated algae treated with reagents that removed the host membrane were phagocytosed at low rates. The endodermal cells of the scyphistomae of the non-symbiotic medusa Aurelia aurita also phagocytosed freshly isolated algae, but did not phagocytose cultured algae. Phagocytosis of algae and carmine particles was found to be a competitive process in scyphistomae of C. xamachana. No correlation was observed between the surface electrical charge on algae and their phagocytosis by host endodermal cells. Neither was there any correlation between phagocytosis and persistence. We conclude that the specificity in symbioses between marine invertebrates and dinoflagellates appears to be regulated by processes that occur after potential algal symbionts are phagocytosed.     

The Establishment of the Hydra-Chlorella Symbiosis: Recognition of Potential Algal Symbionts

The epithelial cells lining the gastric cavity of the freshwater hydra, Hydra viridis, harbor unicellular algal symbionts of the genus Cblorella. It has long been known that these hydra cells can readily phagocytose algal cells and will sequester those algae that have the potential to form a symbiotic association. In this paper the evidence is discussed for when and how recognition of potential symbionts by hydra cells occurs, i.e. during phagocytosis or during the subsequent intracellular events leading to sequestration of algal symbionts.     

Localization of attachment area of the symbiotic Chlorella variabilis of the ciliate Paramecium bursaria during the algal removal and reinfection

Chlorella spp. and ciliate Paramecium bursaria share a mutual symbiosis. However, both alga-removed P. bursaria and isolated symbiotic algae can grow independently. Additionally, mixing them experimentally can cause algal reinfection through host phagocytosis. Although the symbiotic algal localization beneath the host cell cortex is a prerequisite phenomenon for maintenance of the relationship of their endosymbiosis, how and where the algae locate beneath the host cell cortex remains unknown. To elucidate this phenomenon, algal distribution patterns during algal removal and reinfection were observed. During algal removal, algae at the host anterior cortex were easier to remove than at the posterior and ventral or dorsal cortex areas. During algal reinfection, the algae after separation from the host digestive vacuoles tended to localize beneath the host ventral or dorsal cortex more readily than that at other cortices. Algae that reinfected trichocyst-removed paramecia didn’t show this localization. Trichocyst-discharge experiments clarified that trichocysts of the anterior cortex are difficult to remove. In 14 strains of P. bursaria, some of the paramecia lacked their symbiotic algae at the anterior cortex. These observations demonstrate that symbiotic algae of P. bursaria are difficult to localize at the anterior cortex and that they are easy to remove from the area.     

Inhibition of lysosomal fusion with symbiont-containing vacuoles in Paramecium bursaria

Paramecium bursaria harbors several hundred intracellular Chlorella symbionts which remain undigested at the same time that the host cell phagocytizes and digests other organisms. Using electron microscopy and thorotrast labelling, we have shown that secondary lysosomes fuse with food vacuoles, but do not fuse with vacuoles containing symbiotic algae. From these and other data we suggest that the symbiotic algae alter the membrane of the vacuole which surrounds them, thus inhibiting fusion with secondary lysosomes.     

Delay in migration of symbiotic algae in Hydra viridis by inhibitors of microtubule protein polymerization

An English strain of the fresh water symbiotic coelenterate Hydra viridis was experimentally "bleached" of its Chlorella algae and maintained indefinitely by feeding. The algal symbiosis could be re-established by injecting other symbiotic algae into aposymbionts. Although algal uptake and recognition were not affected by microtubule protein polymerization inhibitors, these compounds i.e., podophyllotoxin, beta-peltatin and vinblastine had delaying effects on the migration of the algae through the host digestive cells. Picropodophyllotoxin did not delay migration. The rates, the reversibility and the sensitivity of algal migration to low concentrations of drugs known to bind tubulin suggests the symbionts migrate somehow via labile polymerization of host hydra tubulin into microtubules.     

Expulsion of Symbiotic Algae during Feeding by the Green Hydra – a Mechanism for Regulating Symbiont Density?

Background

Algal-cnidarian symbiosis is one of the main factors contributing to the success of cnidarians, and is crucial for the maintenance of coral reefs. While loss of the symbionts (such as in coral bleaching) may cause the death of the cnidarian host, over-proliferation of the algae may also harm the host. Thus, there is a need for the host to regulate the population density of its symbionts. In the green hydra, Chlorohydra viridissima, the density of symbiotic algae may be controlled through host modulation of the algal cell cycle. Alternatively, Chlorohydra may actively expel their endosymbionts, although this phenomenon has only been observed under experimentally contrived stress conditions.

Principal Findings

We show, using light and electron microscopy, that Chlorohydra actively expel endosymbiotic algal cells during predatory feeding on Artemia. This expulsion occurs as part of the apocrine mode of secretion from the endodermal digestive cells, but may also occur via an independent exocytotic mechanism.

Significance

Our results demonstrate, for the first time, active expulsion of endosymbiotic algae from cnidarians under natural conditions. We suggest this phenomenon may represent a mechanism whereby cnidarians can expel excess symbiotic algae when an alternative form of nutrition is available in the form of prey.     

Host-symbiont associations of polycystine Radiolaria: epifluorescence microscopic observation of living Radiolaria

In all 29 polycystine radiolarian species were obtained from surface seawater on May 28, 1999, using a plankton-net at one station (Site 990528; 26°37′18″N, 127°47′35″E) approximately 5 km northwest of Okinawa Island, Japan. In most polycystine radiolarians of the orders Nassellarida and Spumellarida symbiotic algae were observed under light microscopy. The light microscopic (LM) images of the symbionts, however, varied in clarity among individuals because of the variations in microanatomy of the host radiolarian cells. On the other hand, epifluorescence microscopic (EFM) observation easily detected and confirmed the existence of the algal symbionts within the host cytoplasm even in radiolarians such as Dictyocoryne truncatum (Ehrenberg) that include algal symbionts in the depth of the cytoplasm. The chloroplasts of the algal symbionts emitted autofluorescence in ultraviolet irradiation and they appeared red. That is, the autofluorescence images of the chloroplasts can be used to recognize the existence of the algal symbionts within the host radiolarians. Moreover, staining of the symbiont cells with 4′,6-diamido-2-phenylindle permitted visualization of the nucleus in the center of the symbiont cell, confirming the existence of living endosymbiotic algae within the polycystine radiolarians. Both the LM and EFM observations of eight polycystine radiolarian species revealed the specific patterns of various host-symbiont associations. (1) The investigated polycystine radiolarians all possess algal symbionts, except for one species, i.e. Dictyocoryne profunda Ehrenberg. (2) The size of the algal symbionts depends on the radiolarian species. The symbionts are largely classified into two types based on the size of their diameters, i.e. about 8–10 μm for the larger group and about 5 μm for the smaller one. (3) The algal symbionts show a variety of locations within the host radiolarian cytoplasm. The types of distribution of algal symbionts may be a useful characteristic for radiolarian taxonomy.     

Timing of perialgal vacuole membrane differentiation from digestive vacuole membrane in infection of symbiotic algae Chlorella vulgaris of the ciliate Paramecium bursaria

Each symbiotic Chlorella of the ciliate Paramecium bursaria is enclosed in a perialgal vacuole derived from the host digestive vacuole to protect from lysosomal fusion. To understand the timing of differentiation of the perialgal vacuole from the host digestive vacuole, algae-free P. bursaria cells were fed symbiotic C. vulgaris cells for 1.5min, washed, chased and fixed at various times after mixing. Acid phosphatase activity in the vacuoles enclosing the algae was detected by Gomori's staining. This activity appeared in 3-min-old vacuoles, and all algae-containing vacuoles demonstrated activity at 30min. Algal escape from these digestive vacuoles began at 30min by budding of the digestive vacuole membrane into the cytoplasm. In the budded membrane, each alga was surrounded by a Gomori's thin positive staining layer. The vacuoles containing a single algal cell moved quickly to and attached just beneath the host cell surface. Such vacuoles were Gomori's staining negative, indicating that the perialgal vacuole membrane differentiates soon after the algal escape from the host digestive vacuole. This is the first report demonstrating the timing of differentiation of the perialgal vacuole membrane during infection of P. bursaria with symbiotic Chlorella.     

Endosymbiosis of Chlorella species to the ciliate Paramecium bursaria alters the distribution of the host’s trichocysts beneath the host cell cortex

Each symbiotic Chlorella of the ciliate Paramecium bursaria is enclosed in a perialgal vacuole membrane derived from the host digestive vacuole membrane. Alga-free paramecia and symbiotic algae can grow independently. Mixing them experimentally can cause reinfection. Earlier, we reported that the symbiotic algae appear to push the host trichocysts aside to become fixed beneath the host cell cortex during the algal reinfection process. Indirect immunofluorescence microscopy with a monoclonal antibody against the trichocysts demonstrates that the trichocysts change their locality to form algal attachment sites and decrease their density beneath the host cell cortex through algal reinfection. Transmission electron microscopy to detect acid phosphatase activity showed that some trichocysts near the host cell cortex are digested by the host lysosomal fusion during algal reinfection. Removal of algae from the host cell using cycloheximide recovers the trichocyst's arrangement and number near the host cell cortex. These results indicate that symbiotic algae compete for their attachment sites with preexisting trichocysts and that the algae have the ability to ensure algal attachment sites beneath the host cell cortex.     

Isolation and characterization of the mycobacterial phagosome: segregation from the endosomal/lysosomal pathway

Mycobacteria have the ability to persist within host phagocytes, and their success as intracellular pathogens is thought to be related to the ability to modify their intracellular environment. After entry into phagocytes, mycobacteria-containing phagosomes acquire markers for the endosomal pathway, but do not fuse with lysosomes. The molecular machinery that is involved in the entry and survival of mycobacteria in host cells is poorly characterized. Here we describe the use of organelle electrophoresis to study the uptake of Mycobacterium bovis bacille Calmette Guerin (BCG) into murine macrophages. We demonstrate that live, but not dead, mycobacteria occupy a phagosome that can be physically separated from endosomal/lysosomal compartments. Biochemical analysis of purified mycobacterial phagosomes revealed the absence of endosomal/lysosomal markers LAMP-1 and β-hexosaminidase. Combining subcellular fractionation with two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, we found that a set of host proteins was present in phagosomes that were absent from endosomal/lysosomal compartments. The residence of mycobacteria in compartments outside the endosomal/lysosomal system may explain their persistence inside host cells and their sequestration from immune recognition. Furthermore, the approach described here may contribute to an improved understanding of the molecular mechanisms that determine the intracellular fate of mycobacteria during infection.     

Amino acids as a nitrogen source for Chlorella symbiotic with green hydra

Supply of amino acids may be important in controlling cell division of Chlorella symbiotic with green hydra. Freshly isolated symbionts display characteristics of N-limited algae, and low pH in perialgal vacuoles and high levels of host glutamine synthetase (GS) limit uptake of ammonium. Movement of tritiated amino acids from host to algal pools suggests that symbiotic algae utilize amino acids derived from host digestion of prey. Amounts are significant in relation to host and algal amino acids pools. During host starvation, glutamine produced by host GS may be important as a nitrogen supply to the algae, which take up this amino acid at high rates at low pH.     

Value of the Hydra model system for studying symbiosis

Green Hydra is used as a classical example for explaining symbiosis in schools as well as an excellent research model. Indeed the cosmopolitan green Hydra (Hydra viridissima) provides a potent experimental framework to investigate the symbiotic relationships between a complex eumetazoan organism and a unicellular photoautotrophic green algae named Chlorella. Chlorella populates a single somatic cell type, the gastrodermal myoepithelial cells (also named digestive cells) and the oocyte at the time of sexual reproduction. This symbiotic relationship is stable, well-determined and provides biological advantages to the algal symbionts, but also to green Hydra over the related non-symbiotic Hydra i.e. brown hydra. These advantages likely result from the bidirectional flow of metabolites between the host and the symbiont. Moreover genetic flow through horizontal gene transfer might also participate in the establishment of these selective advantages. However, these relationships between the host and the symbionts may be more complex. Thus, Jolley and Smith showed that the reproductive rate of the algae increases dramatically outside of Hydra cells, although this endosymbiont isolation is debated. Recently it became possible to keep different species of endosymbionts isolated from green Hydra in stable and permanent cultures and compare them to free-living Chlorella species. Future studies testing metabolic relationships and genetic flow should help elucidate the mechanisms that support the maintenance of symbiosis in a eumetazoan species.     

Cellular growth of host and symbiont in a cnidarian-zooxanthellar symbiosis

The hydroid Myrionema ambionense, a fast-growing cnidarian (doubling time = 8 days) found in shallow water on tropical back-reefs, lives in symbiosis with symbiotic dinoflagellates of the genus Symbiodinium (hereafter also referred to as zooxanthellae). The symbionts live in vacuoles near the base of host digestive cells, whereas unhealthy looking zooxanthellae are generally located closer to the apical end of the host cell. Cytokinesis of zooxanthellae occurred at night, with a peak in number of symbionts with division furrows (mitotic index, MI = 12%-20%) observed at dawn. The MI of zooxanthellae decreased to near zero by the middle of the afternoon and remained there until the middle of the next night. Densities of live zooxanthellae living inside of host digestive cells peaked following cytokinesis, whereas densities of unhealthy looking symbionts were highest just before the division peak. Mitosis of host digestive cells was highest in the evening, also preceding the peak in zooxanthellar MI. This is the first study relating phased host cell division to diel zooxanthellar division in marine cnidarians. Food vacuoles were prevalent inside of digestive cells of field-collected hydroids within a few hours after sunset and throughout the night, coinciding with digestion of captured demersal plankton. Laboratory experiments showed that food vacuoles appeared in digestive cell cytoplasm within 2 h of feeding with nauplii of Artemia. The number and size of food vacuoles per digestive cell and the percentage of digestive cells with food vacuoles all decreased 5-7 h following feeding in laboratory experiments, and by mid-day in field-collected hydroids. Light and external food supply were important in maintaining phased division of the symbionts, with a lag in response time to both parameters of 11-36 h. Altering light and feeding during the night did not influence the level of the peak MI the next morning, though in one experiment the absence of light slowed final separation of daughter cells at the end of cytokinesis. In another experiment, hydroids starved for 3-7 d and "pulse-fed" Artemia nauplii for 1 h at the beginning of the dark period showed continued low symbiont division (< 5%) after 11 h, whether maintained in constant light or darkness, implying that most algal division is set more than 24 h prior to actual cytokinesis. Transferred to a 14:10 h light:dark cycle for another 24 h (36 h after feeding), the same hydroids exhibited a "normal" peak MI (ca. 15%) at dawn, but zooxanthellae from hydroids kept in constant darkness still showed a low MI. These results show that mitosis of symbiotic dinoflagellates requires three factors: external food; a minimum period of time following feeding (11-36 h), presumably for digestion; and a period of light following feeding, presumably to provide carbon skeletons necessary for completing cytokinesis.     

Phylogenetic placement of "zoochlorellae" (Chlorophyta), algal symbiont of the temperate sea anemone Anthopleura elegantissima

At northern latitudes the sea anemones Anthopleura elegantissima and its congener A. xanthogrammica contain unidentified green chlorophytes (zoochlorellae) in addition to dinophytes belonging to the genus Symbiodinium. This dual algal symbiosis, involving members of distinct algal phyla in one host, has been extensively studied from the perspective of the ecological and energetic consequences of hosting one symbiotic type over the other. However, the identity of the green algal symbiont has remained elusive. We determined the phylogenetic position of the marine zoochlorellae inhabiting A. elegantissima by comparing sequence data from two cellular compartments, the nuclear 18S ribosomal RNA gene region and the plastid-encoded rbcL gene. The results support the inclusion of these zoochlorellae in a clade of green algae that form symbioses with animal (Anthopleura elegantissima), fungal (the lichen genus Nephroma), and seed plant (Ginkgo) partners. This clade is distinct from the Chlorella symbionts of Hydra. The phylogenetic diversity of algal hosts observed in this clade indicates a predisposition for this group of algae to participate in symbioses. An integrative approach to the study of these algae, both within the host and in culture, should yield important clues about how algae become symbionts in other organisms.