A Mutation in Vicia faba Results in Ineffective Nodules with Impaired Bacteroid Differentiation and Reduced Synthesis of Late Nodulins

Although numerous reports have documented the effect of bacterially-inducedineffectiveness on root nodule structure, function, and plantgene expression, few studies have detailed the effect of theplant genome on similar parameters. In this report effective(N₂-fixing) broadbean {Vicia faba L.) and plant-controlled ineffective(non-N₂-fixing) broadbean recessive for the sym-1 gene werecompared for nodule structure, developmental expression of noduleenzyme activities, enzyme proteins, and mRNAs involved in Nassimilation, leghemoglobin (Lb) synthesis, and acetylene reductionactivity (ARA). During development of effective wild-type nodules,glutamine synthetase (GS), aspartate aminotransferase (AAT),phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) and NADH-glutamate synthase(GOGAT) activities and enzyme proteins increased coincidentwith nodule ARA. The increases in GS, AAT, and PEPC were associatedwith increased synthesis of mRNAs for these proteins. Synthesisof Lb polypeptides and mRNAs during development of effectivenodules was similar to that of GS, AAT, and PEPC. By contrast,ineffective sym-1 nodules displayed little or no ARA and hadneither the increases in enzyme activities nor enzyme proteinsand mRNAs as seen for effective nodules. The effect of the sym-1gene appeared to occur late in nodule development at eitherthe stage of bacterial release from infection threads or differentiationof bacteria into bacteroids. High in vitro enzyme activities,enzyme polypeptides, and mRNA levels in parental effective noduleswere dependent upon a signal associated with effective bacteroidsthat was lacking in sym-1 nodules. Nodule organogenesis didnot appear to be a signal for the induction of GS, PEPC, AAT,and Lb expression in sym-1 nodules. Key words: Vicia faba, mutation, sym-1 gene, nodules     

Physiological Role of Leghaemoglobin Heterogeneity in Pea Root Nodule Development

Disk-gel-electrophoresis of the leghaemoglobin isolated frompea root nodules revealed two major (Lb I and Lb IV) and threeminor components. The ratio of the two major components (LbI/Lb IV) decreased with increasing age. This ratio was higherin the distal than in proximal region when nodules were cutinto distal and proximal sections. In young nodules, the incorporationof radioactive leucine into Lb I was much higher than into LbIV. In older nodules, the radioactivities were much higher inLb IV than in Lb I. These data suggest that the change in thisratio is due mainly to differences in the rates of biosynthesis. Two major components (Lb I and Lb IV) which were isolated separatelyhad different O₂-binding affinities. The O₂-binding affinityof the component synthesized mainly in older nodules (Lb IV)was higher than that of the component synthesized mainly inyoung nodules (Lb I). These results indicate that changes inthe relative contents of leghaemoglobin during nodule developmentcontribute to more effective nitrogen fixation which is mediatedby changes in the capacities of oxygen transport. (Received July 7, 1981; Accepted November 2, 1981)     

Nodulin gene expression in effective root nodules of white sweetclover (Melilotus alba Desr.) and in ineffective nodules elicited by mutant strains of Rhizobium meliloti

Fifteen nodulins and several nodule-stimulated gene productswere expressed in effective, nitrogen-fixing root nodules ofwhite sweetclover (Melilotus alba Desr. cv. U389), as determinedby two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of in vitro translationproducts. The number and gel position of eight leghaemoglobin(Lb) products, as well as a product tentatively identified asnodule-stimulated glutamine synthetase (GS), was similar toprevious reports of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L. cv. Iroquois)nodulins. Three mutants of Rhizobium meliloti, including anexoH mutant, a lipopolysaccharide mutant, and a nifH mutant,elicited ineffective sweetclover nodules blocked at empty (bacteria-free),partially infected, or fully infected stages of nodule development,respectively. In these ineffective nodules, the nodulin Nma30and nodule-stimulated NSTma42 were expressed early in development,while a group of four nodulins and two nodule-stimulated productswere intermediate in order of expression. Lb, GS and the latenodulin Nmal2a were expressed later, following infection. TheexoH mutant, Rm7154, appeared to be a leaky mutant, as a smallpercentage of the plants developed nitrogen-fixing nodules about4 weeks after inoculation. The sequential expression of a largenumber of nodulins and nodule-stimulated products, as well asthe availability of sweetclover nodulation mutants indicatesthat sweetclover is a useful diploid system for analysis ofhost genes essential to the Rhizobium/legume symbiosis. Key words: Nitrogen fixation, nodulation mutants, nodulins     

Nitrogen Assimilating Enzyme Activities and Enzyme Protein during Development and Senescence of Effective and Plant Gene-Controlled Ineffective Alfalfa Nodules

Effective (N₂-fixing) alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) and plant-controlled ineffective (non-N₂-fixing) alfalfa recessive for the in₁ gene were compared to determine the effects of the in₁ gene on nodule development, acetylene reduction activity (ARA), and nodule enzymes associated with N assimilation and disease resistance. Effective nodule ARA reached a maximum before activities of glutamine synthetase (GS), glutamate synthase (GOGAT), aspartate aminotransferase (AAT), asparagine synthetase (AS), and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) peaked. Ineffective nodule ARA was only 5% of effective nodule ARA. Developmental profiles of GS, GOGAT, AAT, and PEPC activities were similar for effective and ineffective nodules, but activities in ineffective nodules were lower and declined earlier. Little AS activity was detected in developing ineffective nodules. Changes in GS, GOGAT, AAT, and PEPC activities in developing and senescent effective and ineffective nodules generally paralleled amounts of immunologically detectable enzyme polypeptides. Effective nodule GS, GOGAT, AAT, AS, and PEPC activities declined after defoliation. Activities of glutamate dehydrogenase, malate dehydrogenase, phenylalanine ammonia lyase, and caffeic acid-o-methyltransferase were unrelated to nodule effectiveness. Maximum expression of nodule N-assimilating enzymes appeared to require the continued presence of a product associated with effective bacteroids that was lacking in in₁ effective nodules.     

A new method to detect the presence of continuous gas-filled pathways for oxygen diffusion in legume nodules

A new method is presented which evaluates the contribution ofgas-filled and water-filled pathways across the barrier whichrestricts O₂ diffusion into infected cells of nodules. SinceO₂ will move through air about 104 times faster than throughwater any continuous gas-filled pathways which traverse thecortex would form a major route for O₂ transport. However, microscopicevidence for the existence of such direct connections is ambiguous. On theoretical grounds, O₂ should diffuse through a He atmosphereabout 3.7 times faster than through air or Ar, but O₂ flux acrossa liquid barrier should be unaffected by changes in the backgroundmixing gas. Thus, if O₂ influx to the infected cells is increasedwhen the ambient gas phase is changed from air to He/21% O₂this is evidence for a continuous pathway of gas-filled poresacross the whole width of the cortical barrier. This theoreticalapproach was validated by measuring the rates of diffusion ofO₂ through milli-pore filters in background atmospheres of eitherair, Ar or He. These membranes were used dry, to simulate the‘open pore’ model for nodule diffusion, or wettedwith water or gum Arabic (which is similar to the glycoproteinsassociated with the barrier) to simulate the ‘closed pore’situation. Knowing the diffusion constants for the gas- and water-filledpathways that may be involved in the nodule barrier, we thenevaluated the contribution of these components to the totaldiffusion resistance by examining the effect of Ar/O₂ and He/O₂gas mixtures on H₂ production and respiration of nodules. Theresults indicate that, in unstressed soyabean nodules, abouthalf of the O₂ flux to infected cells is via inter-connectedgas-filled pores, which ‘close’ to produce a liquid-filledbarrier as the diffusion resistance increases in response tostress. In unstressed lupin nodules all of the O₂ flux crossesa liquid-filled barrier. Key words: Oxygen diffusion, nodules, nitrogen fixation     

Nitrogen Fixation, Assimilation and Transport During the Initial Growth Stage of Phaseolus vulgaris L

In nodulated common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.), there is typicallya period of N stress between 15 and 20 d after emergence (DAE),due to a lack of synchronization between the depletion of Nin the cotyledons and the beginning of N² fixation and transport.Screening trials identified some Rhizobium leguminosarum bv.phaseoli strains with which symptoms of N deficiency were notvisible (‘precocious’ strains). Cultivar Negro Argelwas then inoculated with two ‘traditional’ strains(C-05 and CIAT 727) and two ‘precocious’ strains(CNPAF 146 and CNPAF 512), and plants were harvested from 8to 30 DAE. There were no differences between the two groupsof strains in nodule dry weight or in the acetylene reductionrates between 8 and 16 DAE. However, nodules induced by the‘precocious’ strains showed earlier onset of glutaminesynthetase (GS) (EC 6.3.1.2 [EC] ) and glutamate synthase (GOGAT)(EC 1.4.1.14 [EC] ) activities, and ureide synthesis. The N concentrationin the nodules formed by ‘precocious’ strains variedfrom 4.2 to 4.5%, whereas with the ‘traditional’strains, it increased from 3.2% at 8 DAE to 65% at 18 DAE, atwhich time plants exhibited N-deficiency symptoms. By 21 DAE,GS and GOGAT activities in ‘traditional’ noduleswere increased, as well as the ureide-N-concentration in thexylem sap, nodule N content declined to 4.5% and the leavesbecame green. These results suggest that the N stress with ‘traditional’strains is not a limitation in early N² fixation activity butrather in the rates of expression of the processes of N assimilationand transport. Key words: Glutamate synthase, glutamine synthetase, nitrogen fixation, Phaseolus vulgaris, Rhizobium     

Anatomy, physiology and biochemistry of root nodules of Sprint-2 Fix-, a symbiotically defective mutant of pea (Pisum sativum L.)

A plant-determined pea mutant Sprint-2 Fix^– and the parentalline Sprint-2 were compared for selected physiological and biochemicalparameters. The Fix^– mutation prevented differentiationof Rhizobium leguminosarum bacteria into bacteroids and producedlarge, white, non-fixing nodules. These lacked nitrogenase-linkedrespiration, but had a background rate of CO₂ evolution similarto the normal Fix⁺ nodules. The cortical structure of the ineffectivenodules suggests the existence of an oxygen diffusion barrierand this was supported by a low oxygen concentration in thecentral region (0.5–3.0%), measured using an O₂ sensitivemicro-electrode. Sucrose and starch contents were similar innormal and ineffective nodules while ononitol content was about15 times lower in the Fix^– nodules. The distribution ofstarch was also different in the two nodule types. The activitiesof glutamine synthetase (GS), sucrose synthase (SS), phosphoenolpyruvatecarboxylase (PEPC) and alanine pyruvate aminotransferase (APAT)were markedly higher in Fix⁺ nodules while the activities ofpyruvate decarboxylase (PDC), alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) andglutamate dehydrogenase (GDH) were higher in Fix^– nodules.The data from immunodetection of host nodule proteins confirmedthe reduced levels of sucrose synthase and the almost completeabsence of glutamine synthetase and leghaemoglobin in mutantnodules. There was no significant difference in the amount ofnitrogenase component 1 extracted from the microsymbiont ofnormal and ineffective nodules, but component 2 was hardly detectablein the Fix^– mutant. Key words: Pisum sativum, Fix^– mutant, nodules     

Effects of Leghaemoglobin Components on Nitrogen Fixation and Oxygen Consumption

The effects of purified oxyleghaemoglobin components added toa suspension of bacteroids from soybean and pea root noduleprepared anaerobically were studied in terms of nitrogen fixationand oxygen consumption. Soybean leghaemoglobin components (Lba and Lb c) and pea leghaemoglobin components (Lb I and Lb IV)have different O₂-binding affinities. Lb a and Lb IV showedhigher O₂-binding affinities than Lb c and Lb I. When anaerobicallyprepared bacteroids were incubated with these leghaemoglobincomponents separately under low oxygen tension and in the presenceof a reduction system, Lb a and Lb IV were more effective forboth nitrogen fixation and oxygen consumption than Lb c andLb I. These results suggest that leghaemoglobin components participatein more effective nitrogen fixation by controlling oxygen transportto bacteroids. (Received July 7, 1981; Accepted November 2, 1981)     

Nodule-specific host proteins in effective and ineffective root nodules of Pisum sativum

Nodule-specific root proteins – so called nodulins – were identified in root nodules of pea plants by an immunological assay. Nodulin patterns were examined at different stages of nodule development. About 30 nodulins were detectable during development. Some were preferentially synthesized before nitrogen fixation started, whereas the majority were synthesized concomitantly with leghaemoglobin. Some of the nodulins were located within the peribacteroid membrane. Ineffective Rhizobium strains (a natural nod⁺fix^- and a pop ^-fix^-) appeared to be useful in studying the expression of nodulin genes. Synthesis of some nodulins was repressed in ineffective root nodules, indicating that nodulins are essential for the establishment of nitrogen fixation. In both types of ineffective root nodules, leghaemoglobin synthesis was not completely repressed. Low amounts of leghaemoglobin were always detected in young ineffective root nodules whereas in old nodules no leghaemoglobin was present.     

The Effect of Defoliation on Carbohydrate, Protein and Leghaemoglobin Content of White Clover Nodules

Single white clover plants grown in pots of Perlite in a controlledenvironment and completely dependent on N₂ fixation were defoliatedto various degrees (46–85 per cent of shoot weight removed).The soluble protein content of nodules declined by about 20per cent and leghaemoglobin content by 50 per cent in the first4–7 d after defoliation but increased again to controllevels as new leaf tissue appeared. In the short term (2–3h) carbohydrate content of nodules declined to different extentsdepending on the severity of defoliation. The initial declinein N₂ fixation and the respiration associated with it, appearednot to be related to the instantaneous carbohydrate contentof nodules but rather to the supply of current photosynthatefrom the shoot. After 24–48 h, however, the carbohydratecontent of nodules had declined to low levels, regardless ofthe severity (46 or 71 per cent shoot removed) of defoliation.As new leaf tissue appeared carbohydrate levels in all partsof the plant gradually recovered towards control levels. Microscopic examination of nodule sections indicated that onlyafter very severe defoliation (80–85 per cent shoot removed)was nodule deterioration evident. Even here, as the plant establishednew leaves, the damage to nodules was repaired and no noduleloss was apparent. Trifolium repens, white clover, defoliation, carbohydrate, protein, leghaemoglobin     

Appearance of a novel form of plant glutamine synthetase during nodule development in Phaseolus vulgaris L.

The activities of glutamine synthetase (GS), nitrogenase and leghaemoglobin were measured during nodule development in Phaseolus vulgaris infected with wild-type or two non-fixing (Fix^-) mutants of Rhizobium phaseoli. The large increase in GS activity which was observed during nodulation with the wild-type rhizobial strain occurred concomitantly with the detection and increase in activity of nitrogenase and the amount of leghaemoglobin. Moreover, this increase in GS was found to be due entirely to the appearance of a novel form of the enzyme (GS_n1) in the nodule. The activity of the form (GS_n2) similar to the root enzyme (GS_r) remained constant throughout the experiment. In nodules produced by infection with the two mutant strains of Rhizobium phaseoli (JL15 and JL19) only trace amounts of GS_n1 and leghaemoglobin were detected.Abbreviations DEAE-Sephacel diethylaminoethyl-Sephacel - GS glutamine synthetase     

Defoliation-Induced Stress in Nodules of White Clover: I. CHANGES IN PHYSIOLOGICAL PARAMETERS AND PROTEIN SYNTHESIS

Nodule function and protein synthesis were studied in defoliationstressed white clover plants. Uncut control plants (C) werecompared with plants from two defoliation treatments: (1) continuousdefoliation (CD) where all leaves and petioles were removedeach day; and (2) defoliated/recovered (DR) where, after removalof all leaves and petioles, new leaves were then allowed toregrow. After a single defoliation N₂ fixation (acetylene reductionactivity) and nitrogenase-linked respiration declined by morethan 80% within 3 h and by nearly 100% by 24 h. DR plants beganto fix nitrogen again at a very low level 3 d later and thereafterrose to control levels by 15 d. Continuously defoliated plantsnever recovered N₂ fixation capacity. Nodule protein complementwas assessed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Major changesoccurred in buffer soluble protein band patterns by 6 d in CDplants, but few changes were evident in SDS soluble proteins.By 9 and 14 d significant disruption of all proteins was evident.The prominent host plant protein, leghaemoglobin (Lb) had disappearedby 14 d. In DR plants the intensity of staining was reducedbut no major changes in band patterns were evident and by 21d nodules were rejuvenated. [³⁵S]-labelled methionine was incorporated into nodule proteinsfrom all treatments throughout the experiment. However, continuousdefoliation caused increasing variability between replicatesin the labelled band patterns. By 21 d CD, much of the labelledprotein was present as amorphous low M_r material which suggestseither disruption of the protein synthesizing machinery or rapidhydrolysis by proteolytic enzymes. Surprisingly [³⁵S]-methionine was never found in Lb from nodulesof any treatment. It is possible that white clover Lb does notcontain any methionine residues or that no synthesis of Lb occurred. Key words: Trifolium repens, white clover, defoliation, protein synthesis, nodules     

Defoliation in White Clover: Nodule Metabolism, Nodule Growth and Maintenance, and Nitrogenase Functioning During Growth and Regrowth

In two experiments, the functioning and metabolism of nodulesof white clover, following a defoliation which removed abouthalf the shoot tissue, were compared with those of undefoliatedplants. In one experiment, the specific respiration rates of nodulesfrom undefoliated plants varied between 1160 and 1830 µmolCO₂ g^–1h^–1, of which nodule ‘growth and maintenance’accounted for 22 ± 2 per cent, or 27 ± 3.6 percent, according to method of calculation. Defoliation reducedspecific nodule respiration and nodule ‘growth and maintenance’respiration by 60–70 per cent, and rate of N₂ fixationby a similar proportion. The original rate of nodule metabolismwas re-established after about 5 d of regrowth; during regrowthnodule respiration was quantitatively related to rate of N₂,fixation: 9.1 µmol CO₂ µmol^–1N₂. With the possible exception of nodules examined 24 h after defoliation,the efficiency of energy utilization in nitrogenase functioningin both experiments was the same in defoliated and undefoliatedplants: 2.0±0.1 µmol CO₂ µmol^–1 C₂H₄;similarly, there was no change in the efficiency of nitrogenasefunctioning as rate of N₂ fixation increased with plant growthfrom 1 to 22 µmol N₂ per plant h^–1. Exposure of nodulated white clover root systems to a 10 percent acetylene gas mixture resulted in a sharp peak in rateof ethylene production after 1.5–2.5 min; subsequently,rate of ethylene production declined rapidly before stabilisingafter 0.5–1 h at a rate about 50 per cent of that initiallyobserved. Regression of ‘peak’ rate of ethyleneproduction on rate of N₂ fixation indicated a value of 2.9 µmolC₂H₄ µmol^–1 N₂, for rates of N₂ fixation between1 and 22 µmol N₂ per plant h^–1. The relationshipsbetween nitrogenase respiration, acetylene reduction rates andN₂ fixation rates are discussed. Trifolium repens, white clover, defoliation, nodule respiration, N₂, fixation, nitrogenase     

Sequential expression of two late nodulin genes in the infected cells of alfalfa root nodules.

The Nms-22 and leghemoglobin (Lb) genes are expressed exclusively in the infected cells of alfalfa root nodules. Expression of these two late nodulin genes originated at distinct cellular boundaries within the symbiotic region of the nodule. The Nms-22 gene was expressed in all infected cells, including those just adjacent to the meristematic region. Lb gene expression was induced in older infected cells and was most prominent in the mature region of the nodule. Despite this temporal separation of gene expression, both the Nms-22 and Lb genes were expressed in nodules elicited by bacA mutants in which bacteroid development has been blocked just after release from the infection thread.     

Expression of lupin nodulin genes during root nodule development

Seven lupin cDNA clones were used to study the expression of corresponding genes during nodule development by Northern blots analysis. They include six nodulin cDNAs: pLLb (lupin leghemoglobin), pLN 13, pLN 21–27, pLN 281, pLN 50, pLNGS (nodule form of glutamine synthetase GS_n and root form of GS: pGS. The appearance of nodulin mRNAs during lupin nodule development showed that the nodulin sequences analysed represent a group of plant genes involved in the nitrogen fixation process rather than formation of nodule. This is based on the observation that they are activated at the time when the nodule has already been formed, prior to the onset of nitrogenase activity. The products of Lb, nodulin 21–67, the nodulin coded by pLN13 and the nodulin 281 genes appeared between 11 and 13 days after infection, whereas the nodulion coded by pLN50 and the nodule form of GS appeared 18 days after inoculation. Twenty-one days post-infection a dramatic increase in the transciption rates of all nodulin genes is observed. This phenomenon may be related to the onset of nitrogenase activity. The possible mechanism of two-step activation of nodulin genes is discussed.     

Nodulin gene expression in effective alfalfa nodules and in nodules arrested at three different stages of development

Nodulin gene expression was analyzed in effective and ineffective root nodules of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L. cv Iroquois) elicited by three different Rhizobium meliloti mutants: an exoB mutant having defective acidic exopolysaccharide that does not fluoresce on plates containing the fluorescent brightener Calcofluor; fix21, a spontaneous mutant that has defective lipopolysaccharide and is Calcofluor bright; and a Rhizobium mutant resulting from a Tn5 insertion in the nifH gene of the nif operon. The ineffective nodules elicited by these various mutant rhizobia are blocked at different stages of nodule development and have unique phenotypes. A distinctive pattern of nodulin gene expression as determined by in vitro translations of total nodule RNA characterizes each nodule phenotype. Seventeen nodulins are found in effective nodules including five leghemoglobins. Only one nodulin gene is expressed in the bacteria-free nodules elicited by the exoB mutant. Other nodulin genes (leghemoglobin and nine others) are expressed in fix21-induced nodules. The genes for nodule-enhanced glutamine synthetase as well as for all the other nodulins are expressed in nodules induced by the nifH mutant. The expression of genes for the nodulins, including leghemoglobin, is independent of the nitrogen-fixing ability of the nodule and appears to correlate with the differentiation of densely cytoplasmic host cells in the nodule and, to some extent, with bacterial release from infection threads.     

Effects of Water Stress on the Respiratory and Nitrogen-fixing Activity of Soybean Root Nodules

Seventy-five per cent of the N₂-fixing activity (measured asthe reduction of C₂H₂ to C₂H₄) and 50 per cent of the respiratoryactivity of detached soybean root nodules was lost when thewater potential () of the nodules was lowered from approximately–1 ? 105 Pa (turgid nodules) to –9 ? 105 Pa (moderatelystressed nodules). Severely stressed nodules ( = –1.8? 10⁶ Pa) showed almost total loss of N₂-fixing activity andup to 80 per cent loss of respiratory activity. Increasing theoxygen partial pressure (PO₂) from 10⁴ to 10⁵ Pa completelyrestored both N₂-fixation and respiration in moderately stressednodules, but only partial recovery was possible in severelystressed nodules. The activity of the stressed nodules was verylow at low PO₂ (5 ? 10³ and 10⁴ Pa). The C₂H₂-reducing activityof nodule slices, nodule breis, and bacteroids from turgid andmoderately stressed nodules was almost identical but some activitywas lost in the breis and bacteroids from severely stressednodules. Calculations showed that at low PO₂ (10⁴ and 2 ? 10⁴Pa), the rate of O₂ diffusion into severely stressed noduleswas ten times lower than that for turgid nodules, but only fourtimes lower at a higher PO₂ (4 ? 10⁴ Pa). Carbon monoxide inhibitionof C₂H₂ reduction was slower in stressed nodules than in turgidnodules. The results are discussed in view of the possible developmentof a physical barrier to gaseous diffusion and/or the possiblealtered affinity of the nodule leghaemoglobin for O₂ in thewater-stressed nodules.