Two variants of the assembly factor Surf1 target specific terminal oxidases in Paracoccus denitrificans

Biogenesis of cytochrome c oxidase (COX) relies on a large number of assembly proteins, one of them being Surf1. In humans, the loss of Surf1 function is associated with Leigh syndrome, a fatal neurodegenerative disorder. In the soil bacterium Paracoccus denitrificans, homologous genes specifying Surf1 have been identified and located in two operons of terminal oxidases: surf1q is the last gene of the qox operon (coding for a ba(3)-type ubiquinol oxidase), and surf1c is found at the end of the cta operon (encoding subunits of the aa(3)-type cytochrome c oxidase). We introduced chromosomal single and double deletions for both surf1 genes, leading to significantly reduced oxidase activities in membrane. Our experiments on P. denitrificans surf1 single deletion strains show that both Surf1c and Surf1q are functional and act independently for the aa(3)-type cytochrome c oxidase and the ba(3)-type quinol oxidase, respectively. This is the first direct experimental evidence for the involvement of a Surf1 protein in the assembly of a quinol oxidase. Analyzing the heme content of purified cytochrome c oxidase, we conclude that Surf1, though not indispensable for oxidase assembly, is involved in an early step of cofactor insertion into subunit I.     

Characterization of heme-binding properties of Paracoccus denitrificans Surf1 proteins

Biogenesis of cytochrome c oxidase (COX) is a highly complex process involving >30 chaperones in eukaryotes; those required for the incorporation of the copper and heme cofactors are also conserved in bacteria. Surf1, associated with heme a insertion and with Leigh syndrome if defective in humans, is present as two homologs in the soil bacterium Paracoccus denitrificans, Surf1c and Surf1q. In an in vitro interaction assay, the heme a transfer from purified heme a synthase, CtaA, to Surf1c was followed, and both Surf proteins were tested for their heme a binding properties. Mutation of four strictly conserved amino acid residues within the transmembrane part of each Surf1 protein confirmed their requirement for heme binding. Interestingly the mutation of a tryptophan residue in transmembrane helix II (W200 in Surf1c and W209 in Surf1q) led to a drastic switch in the heme composition, with Surf1 now being populated mostly by heme o, the intermediate in the heme a biosynthetic pathway. This tryptophan residue discriminates between the two heme moieties, apparently coordinates the formyl group of heme a, and most likely presents the cofactor in a spatial orientation suitable for optimal transfer to its target site within subunit I of cytochrome c oxidase.     

Two variants of the assembly factor Surf1 target specific terminal oxidases in Paracoccus denitrificans

Biogenesis of cytochrome c oxidase (COX) relies on a large number of assembly proteins, one of them being Surf1. In humans, the loss of Surf1 function is associated with Leigh syndrome, a fatal neurodegenerative disorder. In the soil bacterium Paracoccus denitrificans, homologous genes specifying Surf1 have been identified and located in two operons of terminal oxidases: surf1q is the last gene of the qox operon (coding for a ba₃-type ubiquinol oxidase), and surf1c is found at the end of the cta operon (encoding subunits of the aa₃-type cytochrome c oxidase). We introduced chromosomal single and double deletions for both surf1 genes, leading to significantly reduced oxidase activities in membrane. Our experiments on P. denitrificans surf1 single deletion strains show that both Surf1c and Surf1q are functional and act independently for the aa₃-type cytochrome c oxidase and the ba₃-type quinol oxidase, respectively. This is the first direct experimental evidence for the involvement of a Surf1 protein in the assembly of a quinol oxidase. Analyzing the heme content of purified cytochrome c oxidase, we conclude that Surf1, though not indispensable for oxidase assembly, is involved in an early step of cofactor insertion into subunit I.     

Sequence conservation from human to prokaryotes of Surf1, a protein involved in cytochrome c oxidase assembly, deficient in Leigh syndrome

The human SURF1 gene encoding a protein involved in cytochrome c oxidase (COX) assembly, is mutated in most patients presenting Leigh syndrome associated with COX deficiency. Proteins homologous to the human Surf1 have been identified in nine eukaryotes and six prokaryotes using database alignment tools, structure prediction and/or cDNA sequencing. Their sequence comparison revealed a remarkable Surf1 conservation during evolution and put forward at least four highly conserved domains that should be essential for Surf1 function. In Paracoccus denitrificans, the Surf1 homologue is found in the quinol oxidase operon, suggesting that Surf1 is associated with a primitive quinol oxidase which belongs to the same superfamily as cytochrome oxidase.     

Surf1, Associated with Leigh Syndrome in Humans, Is a Heme-binding Protein in Bacterial Oxidase Biogenesis

Biogenesis of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase (COX) relies on a large number of assembly factors, among them the transmembrane protein Surf1. The loss of human Surf1 function is associated with Leigh syndrome, a fatal neurodegenerative disorder caused by severe COX deficiency. In the bacterium Paracoccus denitrificans, two homologous proteins, Surf1c and Surf1q, were identified, which we characterize in the present study. When coexpressed in Escherichia coli together with enzymes for heme a synthesis, the bacterial Surf1 proteins bind heme a in vivo. Using redox difference spectroscopy and isothermal titration calorimetry, the binding of the heme cofactor to purified apo-Surf1c and apo-Surf1q is quantified: Each of the Paracoccus proteins binds heme a in a 1:1 stoichiometry and with K_d values in the submicromolar range. In addition, we identify a conserved histidine as a residue crucial for heme binding. Contrary to most earlier concepts, these data support a direct role of Surf1 in heme a cofactor insertion into COX subunit I by providing a protein-bound heme a pool.Leigh syndrome (LS)³ is an autosomal recessive inherited neurodegenerative disorder characterized by focal, bilateral lesions in one or more areas of the central nervous system (1). Symptoms start in early childhood, and the disease usually progresses rapidly. Although mutations in various mitochondrial enzymes can result in LS, its most frequent trigger is deficiency of cytochrome c oxidase (COX) caused by mutations in the SURF1 gene, as identified in LS patients (2, 3). Human SURF1, the first gene of the SURFEIT gene locus on chromosome 9, encodes a 30-kDa protein related to COX assembly (2, 3).Mitochondrial COX consists of up to 13 subunits (SU). The three core SU encoded by the mitochondrial genome carry all of the redox-active cofactors, two heme a moieties, and three copper ions. These three SU are highly conserved among different organisms and represent the main components of bacterial oxidase complexes as well (4, 5). The assembly process of mitochondrial COX is only marginally understood, involving the interplay of a large number of auxiliary proteins (6–9).Despite intensive efforts over more than a decade to unravel Surf1 function, its exact role in COX assembly still remains unclear. Surf1 is not strictly essential for COX assembly because patients with LS have residuals of assembled oxidase with remaining activity of approximately 10–20% in all tissues (2, 3). Located in the inner mitochondrial membrane, Surf1 is predicted to form two transmembrane helices connected by a long loop facing the intermembrane space (10, 11). Sequence alignments confirm the presence of Surf1 homologs in many eukaryotes and prokaryotes (12).One of the best studied Surf1 proteins is the yeast homolog Shy1p, which has been discovered and characterized in the context of pet mutants (10). Deletion of the gene leads to a strongly decreased COX level, although the residual enzyme appears fully functional. This points to a role of Shy1p in assembly or stabilization of COX (13), most likely during the formation of an early assembly intermediate consisting of the highly conserved core SU I and II (14).So far, only three bacterial homologs have been inspected in closer detail (15, 16). In Paracoccus denitrificans, two Surf1 homologs were identified and named Surf1c and Surf1q for their specific role in serving a heme aa₃-type COX and a related heme ba₃-type quinol oxidase, respectively (15). With the function of Surf1 in COX assembly still being speculative, a role in heme a insertion into COX SU I seemed conceivable (15, 16).Here we show that P. denitrificans Surf1c and Surf1q are able to bind heme a both in vivo and in vitro. This novel finding suggests that Surf1 proteins promote heme a insertion into SU I of either cytochrome c oxidase or quinol oxidase. In addition, Surf1 may modulate heme a synthase activity and provide a heme a cofactor pool in a safe, chelated form for COX SU I biogenesis.     

Assembly of cytochrome-c oxidase in the absence of assembly protein Surf1p leads to loss of the active site heme

Surf1p is a protein of the inner membrane of mitochondria that functions in the assembly of cytochrome-c oxidase. The specifics of the role of Surf1p have remained unresolved. Numerous mutations in human Surf1p lead to severe mitochondrial disease. A homolog of human Surf1p is encoded by the genome of the alpha-proteobacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides, which synthesizes a mitochondrial-like aa(3)-type cytochrome-c oxidase. The gene for Surf1p was deleted from the genome of R. sphaeroides. The resulting aa(3)-type oxidase was purified and analyzed by biochemical methods plus optical and EPR spectroscopy. The oxidase that assembled in the absence of Surf1p was composed of three subpopulations with structurally distinct heme a(3)-Cu active sites. 50% of the oxidase lacked heme a(3), 10-15% contained heme a(3) but lacked Cu(BB), and 35-40% had a normal heme a(3) -Cu(B) active site with normal activity. Cu(A) assembly was unaffected. All of the oxidase contained low-spin heme a, but the environment of the heme a center was slightly altered in the 50% of the enzyme that lacked heme a(3). Introduction of a normal copy of the gene for Surf1p on an exogenous plasmid resulted in a single population of normally assembled, highly active enzyme. The data indicate that Surf1p plays a role in facilitating the insertion of heme a(3) into the active site of cytochrome-c oxidase. The results suggest that maturation of the heme a(3)-Cu(B) center is a step that limits the association of subunits I and II in the assembly of mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase.     

Biogenesis and assembly of eukaryotic cytochrome c oxidase catalytic core

Eukaryotic cytochrome c oxidase (COX) is the terminal enzyme of the mitochondrial respiratory chain. COX is a multimeric enzyme formed by subunits of dual genetic origin which assembly is intricate and highly regulated. The COX catalytic core is formed by three mitochondrial DNA encoded subunits, Cox1, Cox2 and Cox3, conserved in the bacterial enzyme. Their biogenesis requires the action of messenger-specific and subunit-specific factors which facilitate the synthesis, membrane insertion, maturation or assembly of the core subunits. The study of yeast strains and human cell lines from patients carrying mutations in structural subunits and COX assembly factors has been invaluable to identify these ancillary factors. Here we review the current state of knowledge of the biogenesis and assembly of the eukaryotic COX catalytic core and discuss the degree of conservation of the players and mechanisms operating from yeast to human. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Biogenesis/Assembly of Respiratory Enzyme Complexes.     

A CMC1‐knockout reveals translation‐independent control of human mitochondrial complex IV biogenesis

Defects in mitochondrial respiratory chain complex IV (CIV) frequently cause encephalocardiomyopathies. Human CIV assembly involves 14 subunits of dual genetic origin and multiple nucleus‐encoded ancillary factors. Biogenesis of the mitochondrion‐encoded copper/heme‐containing COX1 subunit initiates the CIV assembly process. Here, we show that the intermembrane space twin CX₉C protein CMC1 forms an early CIV assembly intermediate with COX1 and two assembly factors, the cardiomyopathy proteins COA3 and COX14. A TALEN‐mediated CMC1 knockout HEK293T cell line displayed normal COX1 synthesis but decreased CIV activity owing to the instability of newly synthetized COX1. We demonstrate that CMC1 stabilizes a COX1‐COA3‐COX14 complex before the incorporation of COX4 and COX5a subunits. Additionally, we show that CMC1 acts independently of CIV assembly factors relevant to COX1 metallation (COX10, COX11, and SURF1) or late stability (MITRAC7). Furthermore, whereas human COX14 and COA3 have been proposed to affect COX1 mRNA translation, our data indicate that CMC1 regulates turnover of newly synthesized COX1 prior to and during COX1 maturation, without affecting the rate of COX1 synthesis.     

Transcription of yeast COX6, the gene for cytochrome c oxidase subunit VI, is dependent on heme and on the HAP2 gene

The COX6 gene encodes subunit VI of cytochrome c oxidase. Previously, this gene and its mRNAs were characterized, and its expression has been shown to be subject to glucose repression/derepression. In this study we have examined the effects of heme and the HAP1 (CYP1) and HAP2 genes on the expression of COX6. By quantitating COX6 RNA levels and assaying beta-galactosidase activity in yeast cells carrying COX6-lacZ fusion genes, we have found that COX6 is regulated positively by heme and HAP2, but is unaffected by HAP1. Through 5' deletion analysis we have also found that the effects of heme and HAP2 on COX6 are mediated by sequences between 135 and 590 base pairs upstream of its initiation codon. These findings identify COX6 as the fourth respiratory protein gene that is known to be regulated positively by heme and HAP2. The other three, CYC1, COX4, and COX5a, encode iso-1-cytochrome c, cytochrome c oxidase subunit IV, and an isolog, Va, of cytochrome c oxidase subunit V, respectively. Thus, it appears that the biogenesis of two interacting proteins, cytochrome c and cytochrome c oxidase, in the mitochondrial respiratory chain, are under the control of common factors.     

Cytochrome oxidase assembly in yeast requires the product of COX11, a homolog of the P. denitrificans protein encoded by ORF3.

The synthesis of cytochrome oxidase in Saccharomyces cerevisiae was recently shown to require a protein encoded by the nuclear gene COX10. This protein was found to be homologous to the putative protein product of the open reading frame ORF1 reported in one of the cytochrome oxidase operons of Paracoccus denitrificans. In the present study we demonstrate the existence in yeast of a second nuclear gene, COX11, whose encoded protein is homologous to another open reading frame (ORF3) present in the same operon of P. denitrificans. Mutations in COX11 elicit a deficiency in cytochrome oxidase. In this and in other respects cox11 and cox10 mutants have very similar phenotypes. An antibody has been obtained against the yeast COX11 protein. The antibody recognizes a 28 kd protein in yeast mitochondria, consistent with the size of the protein predicted from the sequence of COX11. The COX11 protein is tightly associated with the mitochondrial membrane but is not a component of purified cytochrome oxidase. An analysis of cytochrome oxidase subunits in wild type and in a cox11 mutant suggests that the COX11 protein is not required either for synthesis or transport of the subunit polypeptides into mitochondria. It seems more probable that COX11 protein exerts its effect at some terminal stage of enzyme synthesis, perhaps in directing assembly of the subunits.     

hCOA3 Stabilizes Cytochrome c Oxidase 1 (COX1) and Promotes Cytochrome c Oxidase Assembly in Human Mitochondria

Cytochrome c oxidase (COX) or complex IV of the mitochondrial respiratory chain plays a fundamental role in energy production of aerobic cells. In humans, COX deficiency is the most frequent cause of mitochondrial encephalomyopathies. Human COX is composed of 13 subunits of dual genetic origin, whose assembly requires an increasing number of nuclear-encoded accessory proteins known as assembly factors. Here, we have identified and characterized human CCDC56, an 11.7-kDa mitochondrial transmembrane protein, as a new factor essential for COX biogenesis. CCDC56 shares sequence similarity with the yeast COX assembly factor Coa3 and was termed hCOA3. hCOA3-silenced cells display a severe COX functional alteration owing to a decreased stability of newly synthesized COX1 and an impairment in the holoenzyme assembly process. We show that hCOA3 physically interacts with both the mitochondrial translation machinery and COX structural subunits. We conclude that hCOA3 stabilizes COX1 co-translationally and promotes its assembly with COX partner subunits. Finally, our results identify hCOA3 as a new candidate when screening for genes responsible for mitochondrial diseases associated with COX deficiency.     

Shy1p occurs in a high molecular weight complex and is required for efficient assembly of cytochrome c oxidase in yeast

Surf1p is a protein involved in the assembly of mitochondrial respiratory chain complexes. However its exact role in this process remains to be elucidated. We studied SHY1, the yeast homologue of SURF1, with an aim to obtain a better understanding of the molecular pathogenesis of cytochrome c oxidase (COX) deficiency in SURF1 mutant cells from Leigh syndrome patients. Assembly of COX was analysed in a shy1 null mutant strain by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (2D-PAGE). Steady-state levels of the enzyme were found to be strongly reduced, the total amount of assembled complex being approximately 30% of control. The presence of a significant amount of holo-COX in the SHY1-disruptant strain suggests that Shy1p may either facilitate assembly of the enzyme, or increase its stability. However, our observations, based on 2D-PAGE analysis of mitochondria labelled in vitro, now provide the first direct evidence that COX assembly is impaired in a Deltashy1 strain. COX enzyme assembled in the absence of Shy1p appears to be structurally and enzymically normal. The in vitro labelling studies additionally indicate that mitochondrial translation is significantly increased in the shy1 null mutant strain, possibly reflecting a compensatory mechanism for reduced respiratory capacity. Protein interactions of both Shy1p and Surf1p are implied by their appearance in a high molecular weight complex of about 250 kDa, as shown by 2D-PAGE.     

Functional alteration of cytochrome c oxidase by SURF1 mutations in Leigh syndrome

Subacute necrotising encephalomyopathy (Leigh syndrome) due to cytochrome c oxidase (COX) deficiency is often caused by mutations in the SURF1 gene, encoding the Surf1 protein essential for COX assembly. We have investigated five patients with different SURF1 mutations resulting in the absence of Surf1 protein. All of them presented with severe and generalised COX defect. Immunoelectrophoretic analysis of cultured fibroblasts revealed 85% decrease of the normal-size COX complexes and significant accumulation of incomplete COX assemblies of 90-120 kDa. Spectrophotometric assay of COX activity showed a 70-90% decrease in lauryl maltoside (LM)-solubilised fibroblasts. In contrast, oxygen consumption analysis in whole cells revealed only a 13-31% decrease of COX activity, which was completely inhibited by detergent in patient cells but not in controls. In patient fibroblasts ADP-stimulated respiration was 50% decreased and cytofluorometry showed a significant decrease of mitochondrial membrane potential DeltaPsi(m) in state 4, as well as a 2.4-fold higher sensitivity of DeltaPsi(m) to uncoupler. We conclude that the absence of the Surf1 protein leads to the formation of incomplete COX complexes, which in situ maintain rather high electron-transport activity, while their H(+)-pumping is impaired. Enzyme inactivation by the detergent in patient cells indicates instability of incomplete COX assemblies.     

Cytochrome c oxidase is required for the assembly/stability of respiratory complex I in mouse fibroblasts

Cytochrome c oxidase (COX) biogenesis requires COX10, which encodes a protoheme:heme O farnesyl transferase that participates in the biosynthesis of heme a. We created COX10 knockout mouse cells that lacked cytochrome aa3, were respiratory deficient, had no detectable complex IV activity, and were unable to assemble COX. Unexpectedly, the levels of respiratory complex I were markedly reduced in COX10 knockout clones. Pharmacological inhibition of COX did not affect the levels of complex I, and transduction of knockout cells with lentivirus expressing wild-type or mutant COX10 (retaining residual activity) restored complex I to normal levels. Pulse-chase experiments could not detect newly assembled complex I, suggesting that either COX is required for assembly of complex I or the latter is quickly degraded. These results suggest that in rapidly dividing cells, complex IV is required for complex I assembly or stability.     

Copper and manganese electron spin resonance studies of cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans

The two-subunit cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans contains two heme a groups and two copper atoms. However, when the enzyme is isolated from cells grown on a commonly employed medium, its electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectrum reveals not only a Cu(II) powder pattern, but also a hyperfine pattern from tightly bound Mn(II). The pure Mn(II) spectrum is observed at -40 degrees C; the pure Cu(II) spectrum can be seen with cytochrome c oxidase from P. denitrificans cells that had been grown in a Mn(II)-depleted medium. This Cu(II) spectrum is very similar to that of cytochrome c oxidase from yeast or bovine heart. Manganese is apparently not an essential component of P. denitrificans cytochrome c oxidase since it is present in substoichometric amounts relative to copper or heme a and since the manganese-free enzyme retains essentially full activity in oxidizing ferrocytochrome c. However, the manganese is not removed by EDTA and its EPR spectrum responds to the oxidation state of the oxidase. In contrast, manganese added to the yeast oxidase or to the manganese-free P. denitrificans enzyme can be removed by EDTA and does not respond to the oxidation state of the enzyme. This suggests that the manganese normally associated with P. denitrificans cytochrome c oxidase is incorporated into one or more internal sites during the biogenesis of the enzyme.     

Cytochrome c oxidase biogenesis: new levels of regulation

Eukaryotic cytochrome c oxidase (COX), the last enzyme of the mitochondrial respiratory chain, is a multimeric enzyme of dual genetic origin, whose assembly is a complicated and highly regulated process. COX displays a concerted accumulation of its constitutive subunits. Data obtained from studies performed with yeast mutants indicate that most catalytic core unassembled subunits are posttranslationally degraded. Recent data obtained in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae have revealed another contribution to the stoichiometric accumulation of subunits during COX biogenesis targeting subunit 1 or Cox1p. Cox1p is a mitochondrially encoded catalytic subunit of COX which acts as a seed around which the full complex is assembled. A regulatory mechanism exists by which Cox1p synthesis is controlled by the availability of its assembly partners. The unique properties of this regulatory mechanism offer a means to catalyze multiple-subunit assembly. New levels of COX biogenesis regulation have been recently proposed. For example, COX assembly and stability of the fully assembled enzyme depend on the presence in the mitochondrial compartments of two partners of the oxidative phosphorylation system, the mobile electron carrier cytochrome c and the mitochondrial ATPase. The different mechanisms of regulation of COX assembly are reviewed and discussed.     

COX10 codes for a protein homologous to the ORF1 product of Paracoccus denitrificans and is required for the synthesis of yeast cytochrome oxidase

Respiratory-defective mutants of Saccharomyces cerevisiae assigned to pet complementation group G19 lack cytochrome oxidase activity and cytochromes a and a3. The enzyme deficiency is caused by recessive mutations in the nuclear gene COX10. Analyses of cytochrome oxidase subunits suggest that the product of COX10 provides an essential function at a posttranslational stage of enzyme assembly. The wild type COX10 gene has been cloned by transformation of a mutant from complementation group G19 with a yeast genomic library. Based on the nucleotide sequence of COX10, the primary translation product has an Mr of 52,000. The amino-terminal 190 residues constitute a hydrophilic domain while the carboxyl-terminal region is hydrophobic and has nine potential membrane-spanning segments. The sequence of the carboxyl-terminal hydrophobic region is homologous to an unidentified protein encoded by a reading frame (ORF1) located in one of the cytochrome oxidase operons of Paracoccus denitrificans. The two proteins share 24% identical residues and exhibit very similar hydrophobicity profiles. The bacterial homolog, however, lacks the hydrophilic amino-terminal region of the yeast protein.