Suppression of temperature-sensitive chromosome replication of an Escherichia coli dnaX(Ts) mutant by reduction of initiation efficiency

Temperature sensitivity of DNA polymerization and growth of a dnaX(Ts) mutant is suppressible at 39 to 40 degrees C by mutations in the initiator gene, dnaA. These suppressor mutations concomitantly cause initiation inhibition at 20 degrees C and have been designated Cs,Sx to indicate both phenotypic characteristics of cold-sensitive initiation and suppression of dnaX(Ts). One dnaA(Cs,Sx) mutant, A213D, has reduced affinity for ATP, and two mutants, R432L and T435K, have eliminated detectable DnaA box binding in vitro. Two models have explained dnaA(Cs,Sx) suppression of dnaX, which codes for both the tau and gamma subunits of DNA polymerase III. The initiation deficiency model assumes that reducing initiation efficiency allows survival of the dnaX(Ts) mutant at the somewhat intermediate temperature of 39 to 40 degrees C by reducing chromosome content per cell, thus allowing partially active DNA polymerase III to complete replication of enough chromosomes for the organism to survive. The stabilization model is based on the idea that DnaA interacts, directly or indirectly, with polymerization factors during replication. We present five lines of evidence consistent with the initiation deficiency model. First, a dnaA(Cs,Sx) mutation reduced initiation frequency and chromosome content (measured by flow cytometry) and origin/terminus ratios (measured by real-time PCR) in both wild-type and dnaX(Ts) strains growing at 39 and 34 degrees C. These effects were shown to result specifically from the Cs,Sx mutations, because the dnaX(Ts) mutant is not defective in initiation. Second, reduction of the number of origins and chromosome content per cell was common to all three known suppressor mutations. Third, growing the dnaA(Cs,Sx) dnaX(Ts) strain on glycerol-containing medium reduced its chromosome content to one per cell and eliminated suppression at 39 degrees C, as would be expected if the combination of poor carbon source, the Cs,Sx mutation, the Ts mutation, and the 39 degrees C incubation reduced replication to the point that growth (and, therefore, suppression) was not possible. However, suppression was possible on glycerol medium at 38 degrees C. Fourth, the dnaX(Ts) mutation can be suppressed also by introduction of oriC mutations, which reduced initiation efficiency and chromosome number per cell, and the degree of suppression was proportional to the level of initiation defect. Fifth, introducing a dnaA(Cos) allele, which causes overinitiation, into the dnaX(Ts) mutant exacerbated its temperature sensitivity.     

DnaA Protein of Escherichia coli: oligomerization at the E. coli chromosomal origin is required for initiation and involves specific N-terminal amino acids

Iterated DnaA box sequences within the replication origins of bacteria and prokaryotic plasmids are recognized by the replication initiator, DnaA protein. At the E. coli chromosomal origin, oriC, DnaA is speculated to oligomerize to initiate DNA replication. We developed an assay of oligomer formation at oriC that relies on complementation between two dnaA alleles that are inactive by themselves. One allele is dnaA46; its inactivity at the non-permissive temperature is due to a specific defect in ATP binding. The second allele, T435K, does not support DNA replication because of its inability to bind to DnaA box sequences within oriC. We show that the T435K allele can complement the dnaA46(Ts) allele. The results support a model of oligomer formation in which DnaA box sequences of oriC are bound by DnaA46 to which T435K then binds to form an active complex. Relying on this assay, leucine 5, tryptophan 6 and cysteine 9 in a predicted alpha helix were identified that, when altered, interfere with oligomer formation. Glutamine 8 is additionally needed for oligomer formation on an oriC-containing plasmid, suggesting that the structure of the DnaA-oriC complex at the chromosomal oriC locus is similar but not identical to that assembled on a plasmid. Other evidence suggests that proline 28 of DnaA is involved in the recruitment of DnaB to oriC. These results provide direct evidence that DnaA oligomerization at oriC is required for initiation to occur.     

Mutations in Escherichia coli dnaA which suppress a dnaX(Ts) polymerization mutation and are dominant when located in the chromosomal allele and recessive on plasmids.

Extragenic suppressor mutations which had the ability to suppress a dnaX2016(Ts) DNA polymerization defect and which concomitantly caused cold sensitivity have been characterized within the dnaA initiation gene. When these alleles (designated Cs, Sx) were moved into dnaX+ strains, the new mutants became cold sensitive and phenotypically were initiation defective at 20 degrees C (J.R. Walker, J.A. Ramsey, and W.G. Haldenwang, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79:3340-3344, 1982). Detailed localization by marker rescue and DNA sequencing are reported here. One mutation changed codon 213 from Ala to Asp, the second changed Arg-432 to Leu, and the third changed codon 435 from Thr to Lys. It is striking that two of the three spontaneous mutations occurred in codons 432 and 435; these codons are within a very highly conserved, 12-residue region (K. Skarstad and E. Boye, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1217:111-130, 1994; W. Messer and C. Weigel, submitted for publication) which must be critical for one of the DnaA activities. The dominance of wild-type and mutant alleles in both initiation and suppression activities was studied. First, in initiation function, the wild-type allele was dominant over the Cs, Sx alleles, and this dominance was independent of location. That is, the dnaA+ allele restored growth to dnaA (Cs, Sx) strains at 20 degrees C independently of which allele was present on the plasmid. The dnaA (Cs, Sx) alleles provided initiator function at 39 degrees C and were dominant in a dnaA(Ts) host at that temperature. On the other hand, suppression was dominant when the suppressor allele was chromosomal but recessive when it was plasmid borne. Furthermore, suppression was not observed when the suppressor allele was present on a plasmid and the chromosomal dnaA was a null allele. These data suggest that the suppressor allele must be integrated into the chromosome, perhaps at the normal dnaA location. Suppression by dnaA (Cs, Sx) did not require initiation at oriC; it was observed in strains deleted of oriC and which initiated at an integrated plasmid origin.     

The intrinsic ATPase activity of Mycobacterium tuberculosis DnaA promotes rapid oligomerization of DnaA on oriC

Oligomerization of the initiator protein, DnaA, on the origin of replication (oriC) is crucial for initiation of DNA replication. Studies in Escherichia coli (Gram-negative) have revealed that binding of DnaA to ATP, but not hydrolysis of ATP, is sufficient to promote DnaA binding, oligomerization and DNA strand separation. To begin understanding the initial events involved in the initiation of DNA replication in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Gram-positive), we investigated interactions of M. tuberculosis DnaA (DnaA(TB)) with oriC using surface plasmon resonance in the presence of ATP and ADP. We provide evidence that, in contrast to what is observed in E. coli, ATPase activity of DnaA(TB) promoted rapid oligomerization on oriC. In support, we found that a recombinant mutant DnaA(TB) proficient in binding to ATP, but deficient in ATPase activity, did not oligomerize as rapidly. The corresponding mutation in the dnaA gene of M. tuberculosis resulted in non-viability, presumably due to a defect in oriC-DnaA interactions. Dimethy sulphate (DMS) footprinting experiments revealed that DnaA(TB) bound to DnaA boxes similarly with ATP or ADP. DnaA(TB) binding to individual DnaA boxes revealed that rapid oligomerization on oriC is triggered only after the initial interaction of DnaA with individual DnaA boxes. We propose that ATPase activity enables the DnaA protomers on oriC to rapidly form oligomeric complexes competent for replication initiation.     

DnaA protein binding to individual DnaA boxes in the Escherichia coli replication origin, oriC.

The formation of nucleoprotein complexes between the Escherichia coli initiator protein DnaA and the replication origin oriC was analysed in vitro by band-shift assays and electron microscopy. DnaA protein binds equally well to linear and supercoiled oriC substrates as revealed by analysis of the binding preference to individual DnaA boxes (9-mer repeats) in oriC, and by a competition band-shift assay. DnaA box R4 (oriC positions 260-268) binds DnaA preferentially and in the oriC context with higher affinity than expected from its binding constant. This effect depends on oriC positions 249 to 274, is enhanced by the wild-type sequence in the DnaA box R3 region, but is not dependent on Dam methylation or the curved DNA segment to the right of oriC. DnaA binds randomly to the DnaA boxes R1, M, R2 and R3 in oriC with no apparent cooperativity: the binding preference of DnaA to these sites was not altered for templates with mutated DnaA box R4. In the oriC context, DnaA box R1 binds DnaA with lower affinity than expected from its binding constant, i.e. the affinity is reduced to approximately that of DnaA box R2. Higher protein concentrations were required to observe binding to DnaA box M, making this low-affinity site a novel candidate for a regulatory dnaA box.     

Analysis of the DNA-binding domain of Escherichia coli DnaA protein

The DNA-binding domain of the Escherichia coli DnaA protein is represented by the 94 C-terminal amino acids (domain 4, aa 374-467). The isolated DNA-binding domain acts as a functional repressor in vivo, as monitored with a mioC:lacZ translational fusion integrated into the chromosome of the indicator strain. In order to identify residues required for specific DNA binding, site-directed and random PCR mutagenesis were performed, using the mioC:lacZ construct for selection. Mutations defective in DNA binding were found all over the DNA-binding domain with some clustering in the basic loop region, within presumptive helix B and in a highly conserved region at the N-terminus of presumptive helix C. Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) analysis revealed different binding classes of mutant proteins. No or severely reduced binding activity was demonstrated for amino acid substitutions at positions R399, R407, Q408, H434, T435, T436 and A440. Altered binding specificity was found for mutations in a 12 residue region close to the N-terminus of helix C. The defects of the classical temperature sensitive mutants dnaA204, dnaA205 and dnaA211 result from instability of the proteins at higher temperatures. dnaX suppressors dnaA71 and dnaA721 map to the region close to helix C and bind DNA non-specifically.     

The box VII motif of Escherichia coli DnaA protein is required for DnaA oligomerization at the E. coli replication origin

Escherichia coli DnaA protein initiates DNA replication from the chromosomal origin, oriC, and regulates the frequency of this process. Structure-function studies indicate that the replication initiator comprises four domains. Based on the structural similarity of Aquifex aeolicus DnaA to other AAA+ proteins that are oligomeric, it was proposed that Domain III functions in oligomerization at oriC (Erzberger, J. P., Pirruccello, M. M., and Berger, J. M. (2002) EMBO J. 21, 4763-4773). Because the Box VII motif within Domain III is conserved among DnaA homologues and may function in oligomerization, we substituted conserved Box VII amino acids of E. coli DnaA with alanine by site-directed mutagenesis to examine the role of this motif. All mutant proteins are inactive in initiation from oriC in vivo and in vitro, but they support RK2 plasmid DNA replication in vivo. Thus, RK2 requires only a subset of DnaA functions for plasmid DNA replication. Biochemical studies on a mutant DnaA carrying an alanine substitution at arginine 281 (R281A) in Box VII show that it is inactive in in vitro replication of an oriC plasmid, but this defect is not from the failure to bind to ATP, DnaB in the DnaB-DnaC complex, or oriC. Because the mutant DnaA is also active in the strand opening of oriC, whereas DnaB fails to bind to this unwound region, the open structure is insufficient by itself to load DnaB helicase. Our results show that the mutant fails to form a stable oligomeric DnaA-oriC complex, which is required for the loading of DnaB.     

The DnaAcos allele of Escherichia coli: hyperactive initiation is caused by substitution of A184V and Y271H,resulting in defective ATP binding and aberrant DNA replication control

Chromosomal DNA replication is regulated at the level of commitment to this biochemical pathway. In Escherichia coli, DnaA protein appears to regulate this process. A mutant form, DnaAcos, carrying four amino acid substitutions, is apparently defective in responding to regulatory signals, because it induces hyperactive initiation from the bacterial replication origin (oriC). In this report, the phenotype of hyperactive initiation is shown to be the result of two specific amino acid substitutions. One (A184V) immediately adjacent to a Walker A box (P loop motif) causes a defect in ATP binding (Carr and Kaguni, 1996, Mol Microbiol 20: 1307-1318). The second amino acid substitution (Y271H) appears to stabilize the activity of the mutant protein carrying the A184V substitution. The mutant protein carrying both amino acid substitutions (A184V + Y271H) is defective in modulating the frequency of initiation from oriC, as demonstrated by marker frequency analysis of oriC and a locus near the replication terminus. These results indicate that a defect in ATP binding results in aberrant control of DNA replication.     

Mutant DnaAs of Escherichia coli that are refractory to negative control

DnaA is the initiator of DNA replication in bacteria. A mutant DnaA named DnaAcos is unusual because it is refractory to negative regulation. We developed a genetic method to isolate other mutant DnaAs that circumvent regulation to extend our understanding of mechanisms that control replication initiation. Like DnaAcos, one mutant bearing a tyrosine substitution for histidine 202 (H202Y) withstands the regulation exerted by datA, hda and dnaN (β clamp), and both DnaAcos and H202Y resist inhibition by the Hda-β clamp complex in vitro. Other mutant DnaAs carrying G79D, E244K, V303M or E445K substitutions are either only partially sensitive or refractory to inhibition by the Hda-β clamp complex in vitro but are responsive to hda expression in vivo. All mutant DnaAs remain able to interact directly with Hda. Of interest, both DnaAcos and DnaAE244K bind more avidly to Hda. These mutants, by sequestrating Hda, may limit its availability to regulate other DnaA molecules, which remain active to induce extra rounds of DNA replication. Other evidence suggests that a mutant bearing a V292M substitution hyperinitiates by escaping the effect of an unknown regulatory factor. Together, our results provide new insight into the mechanisms that regulate replication initiation in Escherichia coli.     

The dnaA initiator protein binds separate domains in the replication origin of Escherichia coli

After binding to its four 9-mer boxes in the 245-base pair Escherichia coli replication origin (oriC), dnaA protein effects the formation of an "open complex" in an adjacent region made up of three 13-mers (Bramhill, D., and Kornberg, A. (1988) Cell 52, 743-755). This open complex formation requires the ATP form of dnaA protein assisted by HU protein (Sekimizu, K., Bramhill, D., and Kornberg, A. (1987) Cell 50, 259-265). We now provide direct evidence that dnaA protein binds the 13-mers, sequences that bear no resemblance to the 9-mer box. The evidence is (i) displacement of dnaA protein from the open complex by oriC or by a synthetic oligonucleotide containing the 13-mers, but not by a mutant of oriC lacking the 13-mers; (ii) filter binding of the synthetic (13-mer) oligonucleotide by dnaA protein; and (iii) requirement for the ATP form of dnaA protein assisted by HU protein for temperature-dependent binding to the 13-mer region. Controlled proteolysis of dnaA protein results in a prompt loss of oriC binding; an NH2-terminal 30-kDa peptide contains the domain that binds ATP and phospholipids known to destabilize the tightly bound ATP.     

IHF redistributes bound initiator protein, DnaA, on supercoiled oriC of Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, initiation of chromosome replication requires that DnaA binds to R boxes (9-mer repeats) in oriC, the unique chromosomal replication origin. At the time of initiation, integration host factor (IHF) also binds to a specific site in oriC. IHF stimulates open complex formation by DnaA on supercoiled oriC in cell-free replication systems, but it is unclear whether this stimulation involves specific changes in the oriC nucleoprotein complex. Using dimethylsulphate (DMS) footprinting on supercoiled oriC plasmids, we observed that IHF redistributed prebound DnaA, stimulating binding to sites R2, R3 and R5(M), as well as to three previously unidentified non-R sites with consensus sequence (A/T)G(G/C) (A/T)N(G/C)G(A/T)(A/T)(T/C)A. Redistribution was dependent on IHF binding to its cognate site and also required a functional R4 box. By reducing the DnaA level required to separate DNA strands and trigger initiation of DNA replication at each origin, IHF eliminates competition between strong and weak sites for free DnaA and enhances the precision of initiation synchrony during the cell cycle.     

A comprehensive set of DnaA-box mutations in the replication origin, oriC, of Escherichia coli

We probed the complex between the replication origin, oriC , and the initiator protein DnaA using different types of mutations in the five binding sites for DnaA, DnaA boxes R1–R4 and M: (i) point mutations in individual DnaA boxes and combinations of them; (ii) replacement of the DnaA boxes by a scrambled 9 bp non-box motif; (iii) positional exchange; and (iv) inversion of the DnaA boxes. For each of the five DnaA boxes we found at least one type of mutation that resulted in a phenotype. This demonstrates that all DnaA boxes in oriC have a function in the initiation process. Most mutants with point mutations retained some origin activity, and the in vitro DnaA-binding capacity of these origins correlated well with their replication proficiency. Inversion or scrambling of DnaA boxes R1 or M inactivated oriC -dependent replication of joint replicons or minichromosomes under all conditions, demonstrating the importance of these sites. In contrast, mutants with inverted or scrambled DnaA boxes R2 or R4 could not replicate in wild-type hosts but gave transformants in host strains with deleted or compromised chromosomal oriC at elevated DnaA concentrations. We conclude that these origins require more DnaA per origin for initiation than does wild-type oriC . Mutants in DnaA box R3 behaved essentially like wild-type oriC , except for those in which the low-affinity box R3 was replaced by the high-affinity box R1. Apparently, initiation is possible without DnaA binding to box R3, but high-affinity DnaA binding to DnaA box R3 upsets the regulation. Taken together, these results demonstrate that there are finely tuned DnaA binding requirements for each of the individual DnaA boxes for optimal build-up of the initiation complex and replication initiation in vivo     

Negative control of DNA replication by hydrolysis of ATP bound to DnaA protein, the initiator of chromosomal DNA replication in Escherichia coli.

DnaA protein, the initiation factor for chromosomal DNA replication in Escherichia coli, is activated by ATP. ATP bound to DnaA protein is slowly hydrolyzed to ADP, but the physiological role of ATP hydrolysis is unclear. We constructed, by site-directed mutagenesis, mutated DnaA protein with lower ATPase activity, and we examined its function in vitro and in vivo. The ATPase activity of purified mutated DnaA protein (Glu204-->Gln) decreased to one-third that of the wild-type DnaA protein. The mutation did not significantly affect the affinity of DnaA protein for ATP or ADP. The mutant dnaA gene showed lethality in wild-type cells but not in cells growing independently of the function of oriC. Induction of the mutated DnaA protein in wild-type cells caused an overinitiation of DNA replication. Our results lead to the thesis that the intrinsic ATPase activity of DnaA protein negatively regulates chromosomal DNA replication in E. coli cells.     

The sequence requirements for a functional Escherichia coli replication origin are different for the chromosome and a minichromosome

We have developed a simple three-step method for transferring oriC mutations from plasmids to the Escherichia coli chromosome. Ten oriC mutations were used to replace the wild-type chromosomal origin of a recBCsbcB host by recombination. The mutations were subsequently transferred to a wild-type host by transduction. oriC mutants with a mutated DnaA box R1 were not obtained, suggesting that R1 is essential for chromosomal origin function. The other mutant strains showed the same growth rates, DNA contents and cell mass as wild-type cells. Mutations in the left half of oriC, in DnaA boxes M, R2 or R3 or in the Fis or IHF binding sites caused moderate asynchrony of the initiation of chromosome replication, as measured by flow cytometry. In mutants with a scrambled DnaA box R4 or with a modified distance between DnaA boxes R3 and R4, initiations were severely asynchronous. Except for oriC14 and oriC21, mutated oriCs could not, or could only poorly, support minichromosome replication, whereas most of them supported chromosome replication, showing that the classical definition of a minimal oriC is not valid for chromosome replication. We present evidence that the functionality of certain mutated oriCs is far better on the chromosome than on a minichromosome.