Analysis of factors restricting the use of binomial statistics for studying transmitter release in neuromuscular junctions

Binomial parameters of transmitter secretion were calculated on the basis of analysis of synaptic potentials in the frog sartorius muscle. Negative values of the parameter p were found in some synapses. This happened most often in low Ca²⁺ concentrations and with low amplitude of miniature end-plate potentials. The results were interpreted in terms of a model assuming spatial heterogeneity of probability of transmitter quantum release at different release points. Simulation of transmitter secretion by computer showed that the appearance of negative values of the parameter p and incorrect estimates of n experimentally are connected with the form of distribution of probability of transmitter quantum release in the synapse and with the amplitude of miniature potentials.S. V. Kurashov Kazan' Medical Institute, Ministry of Health of the RSFSR. Translated from Neirofiziologiya, Vol. 16, No. 2, pp. 182–189, March–April, 1984.     

Action of botulinum A toxin and tetanus toxin on synaptic transmission

Intracellular recordings of the spontaneous activity from mammalian spinal cord neurons in culture demonstrated different sensitivities of excitatory and inhibitory synaptic transmission for the action of tetanus toxin (Tetx) and botulinum toxin type A (Botx). The effects of Tetx and Botx on spontaneous and nerve-evoked transmitter release were compared under identical experimental conditions in experiments on in vitro poisoned mouse diaphragms. At 37 degrees C completely paralyzed endplates are characterized by a very low frequency of spontaneous miniature endplate potentials (m.e.p.p.s) and by a 100% failure to evoke endplate potentials (e.p.p.s) in response to single nerve stimuli. Striking differences in the action of both toxins have been observed when the very low transmitter release probabilities of paralyzed nerve-muscle preparations were increased by tetanic nerve stimulation and/or application of potent K+-channel blockers and/or by reduction of temperature to 25 degrees C. While Botx did not change the short latency between nerve impulse and postsynaptic response, Tetx produced a temporal dispersion of the quantal release suggesting that the toxins act at different sites in the chain of events that result in transmitter release. To find further evidence to support the different actions of the toxins the spontaneous transmitter release was studied in more detail. Tetx blocked preferentially the release of so-called large mode m.e.p.p.s without affecting the frequency of the small mode ones. In contrast, Botx strongly inhibited both the small and large mode m.e.p.p.s.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Multimodality in the amplitude distribution of miniature endplate potentials due to the action of spatially discrete areas of transmitter release

Miniature end plate potentials (MEPPs) were simultaneously recorded in frog sartorius muscle by two intracellular microelectrodes. Some isolated groups of points (clouds) were found on the diagram of MEPPs scatter. Several peaks each of which was composed of signals from certain clouds (or from several clouds) on the scatter diagram were found on the histograms of MEPPs amplitude distribution. It is assumed that the clouds on the scatter histogram and the peaks on the histogram of MEPPs amplitudes are formed at the cost of secretion of quantum acetylcholine from spatial separate areas of transmitter release. The data obtained do not correspond with the subquantum hypothesis of transmitter release in neuromuscular junctions.     

Probability of quantal transmitter release from nerve terminals: theoretical considerations in the determination of spatial variation

The release of transmitter occurs in discrete quantal units, such that the number released (m) is equal to the number available (n) times the average probability of release (p). Although a common method of estimating these parameters is to use simple binomial statistics, results may be biased if there is spatial or temporal variation in n and p (vars p, vart n, vart p). The problem arises in the simultaneous analysis of five variables, which is impractical due to the complexity and margin of error involved. The proposed solution is to eliminate two variables (vart n, vart p) by assuming stationarity and to obtain the required information from the first three moments of m. The resulting quadratic equation gives two solutions, p1 and p2. Computer simulation of quantal output as a function of vars p indicates that p1 is the better estimator of p when vars p is small, but that p2 is better when vars p is large. This changeover or "inflection" occurs at points which correspond to the maximum vars p obtainable by unimodal distributions of p (larger vars p being obtained by bimodal distributions). Comparison of the simulated histogram of m with those predicted by p1 and p2 shows that p1 provides the better fit, whether vars p is large or small. This discrepancy indicates that histogram analysis is unable to distinguish the appropriate estimate. The major limitations in the procedure can be met by assuming (1) stationarity (which can be attained and tested experimentally), and (2) normal distribution of p (since vars p is then less than "inflection" point, p1 will always be the correct estimate). The overall findings demonstrate that vars p and unbiased estimates of n and p may be calculated, provided reasonable assumptions are made. This in turn should allow the continued use of quantal parameters for describing transmitter release.     

Inhibitory Miniature Potentials in the Stretch Receptor Neurons of Crayfish

Intracellular microelectrodes inserted into the soma of crayfish stretch receptor neurons record frequent fluctuations of the membrane potential. Time course, amplitude, and interval distribution indicate that they are miniature potentials. At the average resting potential the polarity of the miniature potentials depends on the anion used in the microelectrode: KCl electrodes record depolarizing, K citrate or K₂SO₄ electrodes, hyperpolarizing miniature potentials. The inhibitory postsynaptic potentials (i.p.s.p.'s) show a similar polarity change. The reversal potentials of i.p.s.p.'s and miniature potentials are equal and within 10 mv of the resting potential, more negative with K citrate (or K₂SO₄), less negative with KCl electrodes. Reversal can be accomplished by changing the membrane potential by stretching or by current passing. Injection of Cl^- into the soma or replacement of external Cl by propionate results in an abrupt increase of the amplitude of the miniature potentials lasting for several minutes. The miniature potentials like the i.p.s.p.'s are reversibly abolished by the application of picrotoxin and γ-aminobutyric acid. They are not affected by tetrodotoxin, nor by acetylocholine, eserine, or atropine. It is concluded that the miniature potentials represent a spontaneous quantal release of transmitter substance from inhibitory nerve terminals, and that the transmitter substance predominantly increases the Cl^- permeability of the postsynaptic membrane. The effect of the spontaneously released transmitter on the behavior of the receptor neuron is considerable. The membrane conductance is increased by up to 36% and the excitability is correspondingly depressed.     

Effects of ethimizol on frog neuromuscular junction

The effects were studied of ethimizol, a substance activating memory processes, on features of synaptic transmission during experiments on frog cutaneous pectoris muscle. It was found that the presynaptic action of ethimizol consists of raising the frequency of miniature potentials, when used at a concentration of 0.5–10 mM, and modulating quantal content of synaptic transmission due to changes in binomial quantal release parameters p and n when 0.5–2 mM ethimizol was used. This substance facilitated transmission at synapses with a low initial level of transmitter release. This substance facilitated transmission at synapses with a low initial level of transmitter release. Ethimizol was also found to have a postsynaptic action, consisting of reducing amplitude at a concentration of 5–10 mM and prolonging synaptic currents and potentials when concentrations of 0.5–10 mM were used. The latter effect produced a considerable increase in the time integral of endplate potentials. The postsynaptic action of ethimizol is perhaps seen in its effects on features of postsynaptic ionic channels. The effects of ethimizol are discussed with a view to how it may act within the central nervous system as a nonspecific modulator.A. A. Zhdanov Leningrad State University. Translated from Neirofiziologiya, Vol. 17, No. 6, pp. 757–763, November–December, 1985.     

Influence of the Latency Fluctuations and the Quantal Process of Transmitter Release on the End-Plate Potentials' Amplitude Distribution

Spontaneous synaptic potentials and their relation to the end-plate potential (e.p.p.) are studied. It has been suggested earlier that the e.p.p. at a single nerve-muscle junction is built up statistically of small all-or-none units which are identical in size with the spontaneous miniature end-plate potentials (m.e.p.p.'s). In this paper, a more general theory is developed which takes into account latency fluctuations of the unit components. A general equation for e.p.p. amplitude probability distribution is derived. This probability distribution is a function of the latency distribution, m.e.p.p.'s pulse shape, m.e.p.p.'s amplitude distribution, and the mean quantal content. The time course of transmitter release, or latency distribution, is derived from a histogram of synaptic delays in a frog muscle, but obtained equations can be used for other distribution functions as well.     

Presynaptic potentials and facilitation of transmitter release in the squid giant synapse

Presynaptic potentials were studied during facilitation of transmitter release in the squid giant synapse. Changes in action potentials were found to cause some, but not all, of the facilitation during twin-pulse stimulation. During trains of action potentials, there were no progressive changes in presynaptic action potentials which could account for the growth of facilitation. Facilitation could still be detected in terminals which had undergone conditioning depolarization or hyperpolarization. Facilitation could be produced by small action potentials in low [Ca++]o and by small depolarizations in the presence of tetrodotoxin. Although the production of facilitation varied somewhat with presynaptic depolarization, nevertheless, approximately equal amounts of facilitation could be produced by depolarizations which caused the release of very different amounts of transmitter.     

Synaptic activation of presynaptic kainate receptors on hippocampal mossy fiber synapses

Kainate receptors (KARs) are a poorly understood family of ionotropic glutamate receptors. A role for these receptors in the presynaptic control of transmitter release has been proposed but remains controversial. Here, KAR agonists are shown to enhance fiber excitability, and a number of experiments show that this is a direct effect of KARs on the presynaptic fibers. In addition, KAR activation inhibits evoked transmitter release from mossy fiber synapses. Synaptic release of glutamate from either neighboring mossy fiber synapses or associational/commisural (A/C) synapses results in the activation of these presynaptic ionotropic KARs. These results, along with previous studies, indicate that KARs, through the endogenous release of glutamate, mediate excitatory postsynaptic potentials (EPSPs), alter presynaptic excitability, and modulate transmitter release.     

Mode of Operation of Ampullae of Lorenzini of the Skate, Raja

Ampullae of Lorenzini are sensitive electroreceptors. Applied potentials affect receptor cells which transmit synaptically to afferent fibers. Cathodal stimuli in the ampullary lumen sometimes evoke all-or-none "receptor spikes," which are negative-going recorded in the lumen, but more frequently they evoke graded damped oscillations. Cathodal stimuli evoke nerve discharge, usually at stimulus strengths subthreshold for obvious receptor oscillations or spikes. Anodal stimuli decrease any ongoing spontaneous nerve activity. Cathodal stimuli evoke long-lasting depolarizations (generator or postsynaptic potentials) in afferent fibers. Superimposed antidromic spikes are reduced in amplitude, suggesting that the postsynaptic potentials are generated similarly to other excitatory postsynaptic potentials. Anodal stimuli evoke hyperpolarizations of nerves in preparations with tonic activity and in occasional silent preparations; presumably tonic release of excitatory transmitter is decreased. These data are explicable as follows: lumenal faces of receptor cells are tonically (but asynchronously) active generating depolarizing responses. Cathodal stimuli increase this activity, thereby leading to increased depolarization of and increased release of transmitter from serosal faces, which are inexcitable. Anodal stimuli act oppositely. Receptor spikes result from synchronized receptor cell activity. Since cathodal stimuli act directly to hyperpolarize serosal faces, strong cathodal stimuli overcome depolarizing effects of lumenal face activity and are inhibitory. Conversely, strong anodal stimuli depolarize serosal faces, thereby causing release of transmitter, and are excitatory. These properties explain several anomalous features of responses of ampullae of Lorenzini.     

Transmitter release in botulinum-poisoned muscles

Examination of miniature end-plate potentials (m.e.p.ps) in rat skeletal muscle poisoned in vivo by botulinum toxin type A reveals the presence of two populations of potentials. One population which corresponds to m.e.p.ps in unpoisoned muscles and to quantal end-plate potentials. The frequency of these m.e.p.ps is greatly reduced by botulinum toxin. The second population of m.e.p.ps has quite different characteristics. These m.e.p.ps have a more variable, but generally much larger amplitude, and their time to peak is longer than normal m.e.p.ps. The frequency of these m.e.p.ps increases during poisoning and reaches 0.3-1 Hz after 10-14 days. In addition to the variability in amplitude and time-to-peak these m.e.p.ps differ from those at unpoisoned junctions by being unaffected by procedures which alter extra- or intracellular Ca2+ concentrations. The appearance of this Ca2+-insensitive spontaneous quantal secretion of acetylcholine is apparently not a direct effect of the toxin but secondary to blockade of impulse transmission since it also appears at unpoisoned end-plates when transmission is impaired for other reasons. Procedures which increase the intracellular Ca2+ concentration in nerve terminals restore transmitter release from botulinum toxin poisoned nerves. Furthermore, the block caused by the toxin is very temperature-dependent, a reduction in temperature relieving the block. Since presynaptic Ca2+ currents are unaltered by the toxin it is proposed that the block of transmission is due to a reduction in the calcium content of the nerve terminal to a level where the amount of Ca2+, which normally enters, is insufficient to activate transmitter release.     

On the origin of skewed distributions of spontaneous synaptic potentials in autonomic ganglia.

The histograms of spontaneous synaptic potentials at synapses in autonomic ganglia are described by distributions consisting of mixtures of Gaussians, rather than by single Gaussian distributions. The possible origin of these mixed distributions is investigated, using Monte-Carlo simulations of the action of spontaneously released units of transmitter. A single unit of acetylcholine of fixed size, released from an active zone with receptor patches both beneath and adjacent to the zone, does not give rise to the observed histograms. But if the unit is of variable size, consisting of integer multiples of smaller units, and release is from an active zone onto either the receptor patch beneath, or in addition onto adjacent patches, then the histogram is well described by a mixture of Gaussians. However, this explanation is unlikely to be correct as present evidence suggests that in most cases the released unit of transmitter saturates the postsynaptic receptor patch beneath the active zone. The final case considered is where a unit of transmitter is spontaneously released from an active zone, simultaneously with a unit in an adjacent zone less than one micron away. The histogram of potentials then conforms to those observed even when there are differences in the sizes of the receptor patches. It is suggested that this kind of release could provide an explanation for distributions of spontaneous potentials that are mixtures of Gaussians.     

Augmentation is a potentiation of the exocytotic process

Short-term synaptic enhancement is caused by an increase in the probability with which synaptic terminals release transmitter in response to presynaptic action potentials. Since exocytosed vesicles are drawn from a readily releasable pool of packaged transmitter, enhancement must result either from an increase in the size of the pool or an elevation in the fraction of releasable vesicles that undergoes exocytosis with each action potential. We show here that at least one major component of enhancement, augmentation, is not caused by an increase in the size of the readily releasable pool but is instead associated with an increase in the efficiency with which action potentials induce the exocytosis of readily releasable vesicles.     

Miniature End-plate Potentials at Mammalian Neuromuscular Junctions Poisoned by Botulinum Toxin

IT is generally accepted that botulinum toxin entirely blocks transmitter release from motor nerve terminals without affecting nerve conduction or the sensitivity of the muscle membrane to acetylcholine. In particular, it has been reported that with both acute and chronic intoxication with type A botulinum, miniature end-plate potentials (m.e.p.p.s.) disappear completely from a muscle at about the time that transmission is blocked^1,2. The action of botulinum toxin has been reinvestigated following acute application of toxin to the rat diaphragm in vitro and chronic paralysis of rat soleus muscle following a single intramuscular injection of toxin; miniature potentials have been observed to persist following blockade of neuromuscular transmission.     

Quantal Mechanism of Transmitter Release during Progressive Depletion of the Presynaptic Stores at a Ganglionic Synapse : The action of hemicholinium-3 and thiamine deprivation

In the present experiments we interfered with the mechanism of acetylcholine (ACh) synthesis in the rat superior cervical ganglion by impairing the supply of either the choline group (hemicholinium no. 3 [HC-3]treatment) or the acetyl group (thiamine deprivation). Under both conditions stimulation causes in the ganglion a progressive decline in ACh output associated with a depletion of transmitter tissue content. ACh release from the terminals of a single preganglionic fiber was estimated from the quantum content value of the evoked excitatory postsynaptic potentials (EPSP's) recorded intracellularly in the ganglion neuron under test. The present observations indicate that Poisson statistics describe transmitter release at either low or high release levels. Furthermore, the progressive decline in the rate of ACh output occurring during repetitive stimulation is shown to correspond to a progressive decrease in the number of transmitter quanta released per impulse and not to any modification in the size of individual quanta. Some 8,000 transmitter quanta proved to represent the presynaptic transmitter store initially present in those terminals on a neuron that are activated by stimulation of a single preganglionic fiber. Speculations are considered about synaptic efficacy and nerve connections in rat autonomic ganglia. It is suggested that six preganglionic fibers represent the mean input to a ganglion neuron.     

Facilitation, augmentation, and potentiation of synaptic transmission at the superior cervical ganglion of the rabbit

The effect of repetitive stimulation on synaptic transmission was studied in the isolated superior cervical ganglion of the rabbit under conditions of reduced quantal content. Excitatory postsynaptic potentials (EPSP) were recorded with the sucrose gap technique to obtain estimates of transmitter release. Four components of increased transmitter release, with time constants of decay similar to those observed at the frog neuromuscular junction at 20 degrees C, were found in the ganglion at 34 degrees C: a first component of facilitation, which decayed with a time constant of 59 +/- 14 ms (mean +/- SD); a second component of facilitation, which decayed with a time constant of 388 +/- 97 ms; augmentation, which decayed with a time constant of 7.2 +/- 1 s; and potentiation, which decayed with a time constant of 88 +/- 25 s. The addition of 0.1-0.2 mM Ba2+ to the Locke solution increased the magnitude but not the time constant of decay of augmentation. Ba2+ had little effect on potentiation. The addition of 0.2-0.8 mM Sr2+ to the Locke solution appeared to increase the magnitude of the second component of facilitation. Sr2+ had little effect on augmentation or potentiation. These selective effects of Ba2+ and Sr2+ on the components of increased transmitter release in the rabbit ganglion are similar to the effects of these ions at the frog neuromuscular junction. Although the effects of Ba2+ and Sr2+ are similar in the two preparations, the magnitudes of augmentation and the second component of facilitation after a single impulse were about 6-10 times greater in the rabbit ganglion than at the frog neuromuscular junction. These results suggest that the underlying mechanisms in the nerve terminal that give rise to the components of increased transmitter release in the rabbit ganglion and frog neuromuscular junction are similar but not identical.     

Multivesicular release at climbing fiber-Purkinje cell synapses.

Synapses driven by action potentials are thought to release transmitter in an all-or-none fashion; either one synaptic vesicle undergoes exocytosis, or there is no release. We have estimated the glutamate concentration transient at climbing fiber synapses on Purkinje cells by measuring the inhibition of excitatory postsynaptic currents (EPSCs) produced by a low-affinity competitive antagonist of AMPA receptors, gamma-DGG. The results, together with simulations using a kinetic model of the AMPA receptor, suggest that the peak glutamate concentration at this synapse is dependent on release probability but is not affected by pooling of transmitter released from neighboring synapses. We propose that the mechanism responsible for the elevated glutamate concentration at this synapse is the simultaneous release of multiple vesicles per site.     

Cyclic nucleotides and neuromuscular transmission.

A review of the research on cyclic nucleotides and neuromuscular transmission suggests that cAMP is involved in the release of transmitter from motor nerve endings. Lipid-soluble derivations of cAMP cause depolarization of unstimulated nerve endings and prolong the after potentials of stimulated nerve endings. They also increase the frequency of miniature end plate potentials and increase the quantal content of stimulus evoked end plate potentials. Similar effects are produced by compounds that activate adenylate cyclase or inhibit phosphodiesterase. The responses to the derivatives of cAMP and activators of cyclase are enhanced by inhibitors of phosphodiesterase and prevented by compounds that block the flux of calcium into nerve endings. There is no evidence that suggests that cyclic nucleotides are involved in the postjunctional response to transmitter. Thus, it seems likely that cAMP is involved in the regulation of calcium in motor nerve endings and the exocytosis of transmitter. Additional study should expand our knowledge of neuromuscular transmission and contribute to an understanding of the functions of cyclic nucleotides in other synapses.     

Discrepancies between spontaneous and evoked synaptic potentials at normal, regenerating and botulinum toxin poisoned mammalian neuromuscular junctions

Amplitudes and times to peak of spontaneous miniature endplate potentials (m.e.p.ps) and evoked quantal endplate potentials (e.p.ps) were compared at normal, regenerating and botulinum toxin poisoned neuromuscular junctions of the extensor digitorum longus muscle of the rat. At normal junctions the mean time to peak of m.e.p.ps was longer and more variable than that of similar-sized e.p.ps. At endplates where nerve regeneration was induced by mechanical crushing of the motor nerve the frequency of m.e.p.ps was reduced and their amplitude distribution was broader than normal. The distribution of times to peak of m.e.p.ps was considerably broader than that of quantal e.p.ps recorded at the same endplates. At neuromuscular junctions poisoned with botulinum toxin type A, spontaneous and evoked transmitter release were greatly reduced. The amplitude distribution of m.e.p.ps was wider than that of e.p.ps and the time to peak of e.p.ps was about twice as fast as and less variable than that of m.e.p.ps. To explain the observed differences in time to peak among m.e.p.ps and between m.e.p.ps and quantal e.p.ps we suggest that some m.e.p.ps, but not e.p.ps, originate from transmitter quanta released from sites at a greater distance from postsynaptic receptors or that the release or diffusion process for acetylcholine is more prolonged when producing some of the m.e.p.ps. Such mechanisms produce at normal junctions a small population of m.e.p.ps with prolonged times to peak, at regenerating junctions a greater proportion of such m.e.p.ps and in botulinum toxin poisoning a majority.     

Insect Neuromuscular Synapses

Miniature end-plate potentials were used in studying severalaspects of the neuromuscular systems in the cockroach femur.The similar sizes and time courses of miniatures associatedwith fast and slow type excitatory axons suggest that they employthe same transmitter. There is other evidence also indicatingthat the essential difference between these two excitatory systemsis in the number of packets of transmitter released per nerveimpulse rather than different transmitter substances. From theshapes of miniatures it was suspected that typical muscle fibersmight have a branching structure. This was confirmed by histologicalexamination, intracellular stimulation, and intracellular dyeinjection. That inhibitory transmission is quantal is indicatedby hyperpolarizing miniatures which occur at random time intervals.Inhibitory transmission can be made to fail and recover in astepwise manner by manipulating the Ca/Mg ratio. In studiesof toxins which affect transmitter release at vertebrate motorend-plates, botulinal toxin was found to be without effect ateither excitatory or inhibitory junctions in cockroach muscle.However, black widow spider venom acted as it does in vertebrates,promoting massive release of transmitters and then permanentinactivation of the junctions.