The endoderm of the mouse embryo arises by dynamic widespread intercalation of embryonic and extraembryonic lineages

The cell movements underlying the morphogenesis of the embryonic endoderm, the tissue that will give rise to the respiratory and digestive tracts, are complex and not well understood. Using live imaging combined with genetic labeling, we investigated the cell behaviors and fate of the visceral endoderm during gut endoderm formation in the mouse gastrula. Contrary to the prevailing view, our data reveal no mass displacement of visceral endoderm to extraembryonic regions concomitant with the emergence of epiblast-derived definitive endoderm. Instead, we observed dispersal of the visceral endoderm epithelium and extensive mixing between cells of visceral endoderm and epiblast origin. Visceral endoderm cells remained associated with the epiblast and were incorporated into the early gut tube. Our findings suggest that the segregation of extraembryonic and embryonic tissues within the mammalian embryo is not as strict as believed and that a lineage previously defined as exclusively extraembryonic contributes cells to the embryo.     

Cell lineage analysis demonstrates an endodermal origin of the distal urethra and perineum

Congenital malformations of anorectal and genitourinary (collectively, anogenital) organs occur at a high frequency in humans, however the lineage of cells that gives rise to anogenital organs remains poorly understood. The penile urethra has been reported to develop from two cell populations, with the proximal urethra developing from endoderm and the distal urethra forming from an apical ectodermal invagination, however this has never been tested by direct analysis of cell lineage. During gut development, endodermal cells express Sonic hedgehog (Shh), which is required for normal patterning of digestive and genitourinary organs. We have taken advantage of the properties of Shh expression to genetically label and follow the fate of posterior gut endoderm during anogenital development. We report that the entire urethra, including the distal (glandar) region, is derived from endoderm. Cloacal endoderm also gives rise to the epithelial linings of the bladder, rectum and anterior region of the anus. Surprisingly, the lineage map also revealed an endodermal origin of the perineum, which is the first demonstration that endoderm differentiates into skin. In addition, we fate mapped genital tubercle ectoderm and show that it makes no detectable contribution to the urethra. In males, formation of the urethral tube involves septation of the urethral plate by continued growth of the urorectal septum. Analysis of cell lineage following disruption of androgen signaling revealed that the urethral plate of flutamide-treated males does not undergo this septation event. Instead, urethral plate cells persist to the ventral margin of the tubercle, mimicking the pattern seen in females. Based on these spatial and temporal fate maps, we present a new model for anogenital development and suggest that disruptions at specific developmental time points can account for the association between anorectal and genitourinary defects.     

Pattern formation in a pentameral animal: induction of early adult rudiment development in sea urchins

We investigated adult rudiment induction in the direct-developing sea urchin Heliocidaris erythrogramma microsurgically. After removal of the archenteron (which includes presumptive coelomic mesoderm as well as presumptive endoderm) from late gastrulae, larval ectoderm develops properly but obvious rudiments (tube feet, nervous system, and adult skeleton) fail to form, indicating that coelomic mesoderm, endoderm, or both are required for induction of adult development. Recombination of ectoderm and archenteron rescues development. Implanted endoderm alone or left coelom alone each regenerate the full complement of archenteron derivatives; thus, they are uninformative as to the relative inductive potential of the two regions. However, in isolated ectoderm, more limited regeneration gives rise to larvae containing no archenteron derivatives at all, endoderm only, or both endoderm and left coelom. Adult nervous system begins to develop only in the latter, indicating that left coelom is required for the inductive signal. Isolated ectoderm develops a vestibule (the precursor of adult ectoderm) and correctly regulates vestibular expression of the ectodermal territory marker HeET-1, indicating that the early phase of vestibule development occurs autonomously; only later development requires the inductive signal. Another ectodermal marker, HeARS, is regulated properly in the larval ectoderm region, but not in the vestibule. HeARS regulation thus represents an early response to the inducing signal. We compare HeARS expression in H. erythrogramma with that in indirect developers and discuss its implications for modularity in the evolution of developmental mode.     

Developmental fates of larval tissues after metamorphosis in the ascidian, Halocynthia roretzi

Cell lineages during ascidian embryogenesis are invariant. Developmental fates of larval mesodermal cells after metamorphosis are also invariant with regard to cell type of descendants. The present study traced developmental fates of larval endodermal cells after metamorphosis in Halocynthia roretzi by labeling each endodermal precursor blastomere of larval endoderm. Larval endodermal cells gave rise to various endodermal organs of juveniles: endostyle, branchial sac, peribranchial epithelium, digestive organs, peripharyngeal band, and dorsal tubercle. The boundaries between clones descended from early blastomeres did not correspond to the boundaries between adult endodermal organs. Although there is a regular projection from cleavage stage and larval stage to juvenile stage, this varies to some extent between individuals. This indicates that ascidian development is not entirely deterministic. We composed a fate map of adult endodermal organs in larval endoderm based on a statistical analysis of many individual cases. Interestingly, the topographic position of each prospective region in the fate map was similar to that of the adult organ, indicating that marked rearrangement of the positions of endodermal cells does not occur during metamorphosis. These findings suggest that fate specification in endoderm cells during metamorphosis is likely to be a position-dependent rather than a deterministic and lineage-based process. Received: 16 June 1999 / Accepted: 16 August 1999     

Patterning the endoderm: the importance of neighbours

The endodermal germ layer gives rise to the inner epithelial lining of the gastrointestinal tract, while that of the mesoderm gives rise to the outer smooth muscle layer. Much of the work in chick shows that the mesoderm plays an important role in endodermal differentiation, and recent results in Xenopus have begun to elucidate the factors involved in establishing endodermal cell fate. However, little is know about the signals responsible for the initial specification and pattern of the endoderm. In a recent paper, Wells and Melton have investigated the importance of early mesectodermal-endodermal interactions in the initial specification of the early mouse endoderm.(1) They demonstrate that the initial specification and differentiation of the endoderm does not occur cell-autonomously, but requires signals released from the mesectoderm.     

FGF signaling is necessary for establishing gut tube domains along the anterior-posterior axis in vivo

At the end of gastrulation in avians and mammals, the endoderm germ layer is an undetermined sheet of cells. Over the next 24-48 h, endoderm forms a primitive tube and becomes regionally specified along the anterior-posterior axis. Fgf4 is expressed in gastrulation and somite stage embryos in the vicinity of posterior endoderm that gives rise to the posterior gut. Moreover, the posterior endoderm adjacent to Fgf4-expressing mesoderm expresses the FGF-target genes Sprouty1 and 2 suggesting that endoderm respond to an FGF signal in vivo. Here, we report the first evidence suggesting that FGF4-mediated signaling is required for establishing gut tube domains along the A-P axis in vivo. At the gastrula stage, exposing endoderm to recombinant FGF4 protein results in an anterior shift in the Pdx1 and CdxB expression domains. These expression domains remain sensitive to FGF4 levels throughout early somite stages. Additionally, FGF4 represses the anterior endoderm markers Hex1 and Nkx2.1 and disrupts foregut morphogenesis. FGF signaling directly patterns endoderm and not via a secondary induction from another germ layer, as shown by expression of dominant-active FGFR1 specifically in endoderm, which results in ectopic anterior expression of Pdx1. Loss-of-function studies using the FGF receptor antagonist SU5402 demonstrate that FGF signaling is necessary for establishing midgut gene expression and for maintaining gene expression boundaries between the midgut and hindgut from gastrulation through somitogenesis. Moreover, FGF signaling in the primitive streak is necessary to restrict Hex1 expression to anterior endoderm. These data show that FGF signaling is critical for patterning the gut tube by promoting posterior and inhibiting anterior endoderm cell fate.     

Fate and plasticity of the endoderm in the early chick embryo

In vertebrates, the endoderm is established during gastrulation and gradually becomes regionalized into domains destined for different organs. Here, we present precise fate maps of the gastrulation stage chick endoderm, using a method designed to label cells specifically in the lower layer. We show that the first population of endodermal cells to enter the lower layer contributes only to the midgut and hindgut; the next cells to ingress contribute to the dorsal foregut and followed finally by the presumptive ventral foregut endoderm. Grafting experiments show that some migrating endodermal cells, including the presumptive ventral foregut, ingress from Hensen's node, not directly into the lower layer but rather after migrating some distance within the middle layer. Cell transplantation reveals that cells in the middle layer are already committed to mesoderm or endoderm, whereas cells in the primitive streak are plastic. Based on these results, we present a revised fate map of the locations and movements of prospective definitive endoderm cells during gastrulation.     

Molecular analysis of the determination of developmental fate in the small intestinal epithelium in the chicken embryo

Determination of the developmental fate in the small intestinal epithelium of the chicken embryo has not been fully analyzed up to the present. This study was carried out to analyze the determination time of the developmental fate of the small intestinal epithelium under the influence of other mesenchymes. The small intestinal epithelium reassociated and cultivated with the proventricular or gizzard mesenchyme or the dermis expressed chicken intestinal fatty acid binding protein, sucrase and CdxA as occurs during the normal development of the small intestinal epithelium. The presumptive intestinal endoderm taken from an earlier stage embryo and associated and cultivated with the proventricular or gizzard mesenchyme, showed gene expression patterns which were the same as those found in normal development. However, when the dermis was associated, the epithelium expressed sonic hedgehog, but never expressed intestinal epithelial- or stomach epithelial-markers. These results indicate that the determination of the developmental fate in the small intestinal epithelium and acquisition of autodifferentiation potency occur at the early stage of the gut development. Moreover the presumptive intestinal endoderm needs the supportive influence of the gut mesenchyme in order to differentiate fully into the intestinal epithelium.     

A fate map of the murine pancreas buds reveals a multipotent ventral foregut organ progenitor

The definitive endoderm is the embryonic germ layer that gives rise to the budding endodermal organs including the thyroid, lung, liver and pancreas as well as the remainder of the gut tube. DiI fate mapping and whole embryo culture were used to determine the endodermal origin of the 9.5 days post coitum (dpc) dorsal and ventral pancreas buds. Our results demonstrate that the progenitors of each bud occupy distinct endodermal territories. Dorsal bud progenitors are located in the medial endoderm overlying somites 2-4 between the 2 and 11 somite stage (SS). The endoderm forming the ventral pancreas bud is found in 2 distinct regions. One territory originates from the left and right lateral endoderm caudal to the anterior intestinal portal by the 6 SS and the second domain is derived from the ventral midline of the endoderm lip (VMEL). Unlike the laterally located ventral foregut progenitors, the VMEL population harbors a multipotent progenitor that contributes to the thyroid bud, the rostral cap of the liver bud, ventral midline of the liver bud and the midline of the ventral pancreas bud in a temporally restricted manner. This data suggests that the midline of the 9.5 dpc thyroid, liver and ventral pancreas buds originates from the same progenitor population, demonstrating a developmental link between all three ventral foregut buds. Taken together, these data define the location of the dorsal and ventral pancreas progenitors in the prespecified endodermal sheet and should lead to insights into the inductive events required for pancreas specification.     

Intestinal lineage commitment of embryonic stem cells

Generating lineage-committed intestinal stem cells from embryonic stem cells (ESCs) could provide a tractable experimental system for understanding intestinal differentiation pathways and may ultimately provide cells for regenerating damaged intestinal tissue. We tested a two-step differentiation procedure in which ESCs were first cultured with activin A to favor formation of definitive endoderm, and then treated with fibroblast-conditioned medium with or without Wnt3A. The definitive endoderm expressed a number of genes associated with gut-tube development through mouse embryonic day 8.5 (Sox17, Foxa2, and Gata4 expressed and Id2 silent). The intestinal stem cell marker Lgr5 gene was also activated in the endodermal cells, whereas the Msi1, Ephb2, and Dcamkl1 intestinal stem cell markers were not. Exposure of the endoderm to fibroblast-conditioned medium with Wnt3A resulted in the activation of Id2, the remaining intestinal stem cell markers and the later gut markers Cdx2, Fabp2, and Muc2. Interestingly, genes associated with distal gut-associated mesoderm (Foxf2, Hlx, and Hoxd8) were also simulated by Wnt3A. The two-step differentiation protocol generated gut bodies with crypt-like structures that included regions of Lgr5-expressing proliferating cells and regions of cell differentiation. These gut bodies also had a smooth muscle component and some underwent peristaltic movement. The ability of the definitive endoderm to differentiate into intestinal epithelium was supported by the vivo engraftment of these cells into mouse colonic mucosa. These findings demonstrate that definitive endoderm derived from ESCs can carry out intestinal cell differentiation pathways and may provide cells to restore damaged intestinal tissue.     

Epiblast and primitive-streak origins of the endoderm in the gastrulating chick embryo

Gastrulation is characterized by the extensive movements of cells. Fate mapping is used to follow such cell movements as they occur over time, and prospective fate maps have been constructed for several stages of the model organisms used in modern studies in developmental biology. In chick embryos, detailed fate maps have been constructed for both prospective mesodermal and ectodermal cells. However, the origin and displacement of the prospective endodermal cells during crucial periods in gastrulation remain unclear. This study had three aims. First, we determined the primitive-streak origin of the endoderm using supravital fluorescent markers, and followed the movement of the prospective endodermal cells as they dispersed to generate the definitive endodermal layer. We show that between stages 3a/b and 4, the intraembryonic definitive endoderm receives contributions mainly from the rostral half of the primitive streak, and that endodermal movements parallel those of ingressing adjacent mesodermal subdivisions. Second, the question of the epiblast origin of the endodermal layer was addressed by precisely labeling epiblast cells in a region known to give rise to prospective somitic cells, and following their movement as they underwent ingression through the primitive streak. We show that the epiblast clearly contributes prospective endodermal cells to the primitive streak, and subsequently to definitive endoderm of the area pellucida. Finally, the relationship between the hypoblast and the definitive endoderm was defined by following labeled rostral primitive-streak cells over a short period of time as they contributed to the definitive endoderm, and combining this with in situ hybridization with a riboprobe for Crescent, a marker of the hypoblast. We show that as the definitive endodermal layer is laid down, there is cell-cell intercalation at its interface with the displaced hypoblast cells. These data were used to construct detailed prospective fate maps of the endoderm in the chick embryo, delineating the origins and migrations of endodermal cells in various rostrocaudal levels of the primitive streak during key periods in early development.     

Archenteron elongation in the sea urchin embryo is a microtubule-independent process

Earlier studies using colchicine (L. G. Tilney and J. R. Gibbins, 1969, J. Cell Sci. 5, 195-210) had suggested that intact microtubules (MTs) are necessary for archenteron elongation during the second phase of sea urchin gastrulation (secondary invagination), presumably by allowing secondary mesenchyme cells (SMCs) to extend their long filopodial processes. In light of subsequently discovered effects of colchicine on other cellular processes, the role of MTs in archenteron elongation in the sea urchin, Lytechinus pictus, has been reexamined. Immunofluorescent staining of ectodermal fragments and isolated archenterons reveals a characteristic pattern of MTs in the ectoderm and endoderm during gastrulation. Ectodermal cells exhibit arrays of MTs radiating away from the region of the basal body/ciliary rootlet and extending along the periphery of the cell, whereas endodermal cells exhibit a similar array of peripheral MTs emanating from the region of the apical ciliary rootlet facing the lumen of the archenteron. MTs are found primarily at the bases of the filopodia of normal SMCs. beta-Lumicolchicine (0.1 mM), an analog of colchicine which does not bind tubulin, inhibits secondary invagination, indicating that the effects previously ascribed to the disruption of MTs are probably due to the effects of colchicine on other cellular processes. The MT inhibitor nocodazole (5-10 micrograms/ml) added prior to secondary invagination does not prevent gastrulation or spontaneous exogastrulation, even though indirect immunofluorescence indicates that cytoplasmic MTs are completely disrupted in drug-treated embryos. Transverse tissue sections indicate that a comparable amount of cell rearrangement occurs in nocodazole-treated and control embryos. Significantly, SMCs in nocodazole-treated embryos often detach prematurely from the tip of the gut rudiment and extend abnormally large broad lamellipodial protrusions but are also capable of extending long slender filopodia comparable in length to those of control embryos. These results indicate that cytoplasmic MTs are not essential for either filopodial extension by SMCs or for the active epithelial cell rearrangement which accompanies elongation during sea urchin gastrulation.     

Novel gene expression domains reveal early patterning of the Xenopus endoderm

The endoderm gives rise the respiratory and digestive tract epithelia as well as associated organs such as the liver, lungs and pancreas. Investigations examining the molecular basis of embryonic endodermal patterning and organogenesis have been hampered by the lack of regionally expressed molecular markers in the early endoderm. By differentially screening an arrayed cDNA library, combined with an in situ hybridization screen we identified 13 new genes regionally expressed in the early tailbud endoderm of the Xenopus embryo. The putative proteins encoded by these cDNAs include a cell surface transporter, secreted proteins, a protease, a protease inhibitor, an RNA-binding protein, a phosphatase inhibitor and several enzymes. We find that the expression of these genes falls into one of three re-occurring domains in the tailbud embryo; (1). a ventral midgut, (2). posterior to the midgut and (3). in the dorsal endoderm beneath the notochord. Several of these genes are also regionally expressed at gastrula and neurula stages and appear to mark territories that were previously only predicted by the endoderm fate map. This indicates that there is significant positional identity in the early endoderm long before stages 28-32 when regional specification of the endoderm is thought to occur. These new genes provide valuable tools for studying endodermal patterning and organogenesis in Xenopus.     

Distinct populations of endoderm cells converge to generate the embryonic liver bud and ventral foregut tissues

The location and movement of mammalian gut tissue progenitors, prior to the expression of tissue-specific genes, has been unknown, but this knowledge is essential to identify transitions that lead to cell type specification. To address this, we used vital dyes to label exposed anterior endoderm cells of early somite stage mouse embryos, cultured the embryos into the tissue bud phase of development, and determined the tissue fate of the dye labeled cells. This approach was performed at three embryonic stages that are prior to, or coincident with, foregut tissue patterning (1-3 somites, 4-6 somites, and 7-10 somites). Short-term labeling experiments tracked the movement of tissue progenitor cells during foregut closure. Surprisingly, we found that two distinct types of endoderm-progenitor cells, lateral and medial, arising from three spatially separated embryonic domains, converge to generate the epithelial cells of the liver bud. Whereas the lateral endoderm-progenitors give rise to descendants that are constrained in tissue fate and position along the anterior-posterior axis of the gut, the medial gut endoderm-progenitors give rise to descendants that stream along the anterior-posterior axis at the ventral midline and contribute to multiple gut tissues. The fate map reveals extensive morphogenetic movement of progenitors prior to tissue specification, it permits a detailed analysis of endoderm tissue patterning, and it illustrates that diverse progenitor domains can give rise to individual tissue cell types.