Evolution of DNA amounts across land plants (embryophyta)

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: DNA C-values in land plants (comprising bryophytes, lycophytes, monilophytes, gymnosperms and angiosperms) vary approximately 1000-fold from approx. 0.11 to 127.4 pg. To understand the evolutionary significance of this huge variation it is essential to evaluate the phylogenetic component. Recent increases in C-value data (e.g. Plant DNA C-values database; release 2.0, January 2003; http://www.rbgkew.org.uk/cval/homepage.html) together with improved consensus of relationships between and within land plant groups makes such an analysis timely. METHODS: Insights into the distribution of C-values in each group of land plants were gained by superimposing available C-value data (4119 angiosperms, 181 gymnosperms, 63 monilophytes, 4 lycophytes and 171 bryophytes) onto phylogenetic trees. To enable ancestral C-values to be reconstructed for clades within land plants, character-state mapping with parsimony and MacClade was also applied. KEY RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Different land plant groups are characterized by different C-value profiles, distribution of C-values and ancestral C-values. For example, the large ( approximately 1000-fold) range yet strongly skewed distribution of C-values in angiosperms contrasts with the very narrow 12-fold range in bryophytes. Further, character-state mapping showed that the ancestral genome sizes of both angiosperms and bryophytes were reconstructed as very small (i.e. < or =1.4 pg) whereas gymnosperms and most branches of monilophytes were reconstructed with intermediate C-values (i.e. >3.5, <14.0 pg). More in-depth analyses provided evidence for several independent increases and decreases in C-values; for example, decreases in Gnetaceae (Gymnosperms) and heterosperous water ferns (monilophytes); increases in Santalales and some monocots (both angiosperms), Pinaceae, Sciadopityaceae and Cephalotaxaceae (Gymnosperms) and possibly in the Psilotaceae + Ophioglossaceae clade (monilophytes). Thus, in agreement with several focused studies within angiosperm families and genera showing that C-values may both increase and decrease, it is apparent that this dynamic pattern of genome size evolution is repeated on a broad scale across land plants.     

Nuclear DNA Amounts in Pteridophytes

DNA amounts (C-value and genome size) are much-used biodiversitycharacters. A workshop held at Kew in 1997 identified majorgaps in our knowledge of plant DNA amounts, recommending targetsfor new work to fill them. Murray reviewed non-angiosperm plantsnoting that representation of pteridophyte species (approx.0.42%) was poor, while locating C-value data for them was verydifficult. The workshop confirmed the need to make data forother groups besides angiosperms accessible for reference purposes.This paper pools DNA C-values for 48 pteridophyte species fromeight original sources into one reference source, and fulfilsa key workshop recommendation for this group. Comparing thesedata shows that nuclear 1C-values in pteridophytes vary approx.1000-fold, from 0.055 pg in Selaginella species to about 55pg in Ophioglossum petiolatum. Genome size estimates for 25pteridophytes vary approx. 200-fold from 0.055 to 10.7 pg, andthe mean genome sizes in diploids and polyploids (5.15 and 4.59pg, respectively) are not significantly different. Wider comparisonsshow that ranges of genome sizes in the major groups of landplants are very different. Those in bryophytes and pteridophytesare narrow compared with those in gymnosperms and angiosperms.The data indicate that the origin of land plants possibly involveda first major increase in genome size in the evolution of vascularplants, while a second such increase occurred later in gymnosperms.C-values for pteridophytes remain very few, but conversely opportunitiesfor new work on them are many. Copyright 2001 Annals of BotanyCompany Pteridophyte DNA amounts, DNA C-values, nuclear genome sizes     

Nuclear DNA content in allopolyploid species and synthetic hybrids in the grass genus Paspalum

DNA content was estimated by flow cytometry in seventeen taxa from the Dilatata, Quadrifaria and Paniculata groups of Paspalum and five synthetic hybrids. Results were compared to known genome constitutions and phylogenetic relationships. DNA 2C-values ranged from 1.24 pg in diploid P. juergensii to 3.79 pg in a hexaploid biotype of P. dilatatum. The I genome of three Quadrifaria diploids is 1.2 to 1.5-fold larger than the J genome of P. juergensii (Paniculata). The 2C-values of the IIJJ tetraploids of the Dilatata group are lower than expected based on putative genome donors. Reduction of genome sizes could have occurred after the formation of the allopolyploids of the Dilatata group. The DNA content of all synthetic hybrids is in accordance with the sum of parental C-values. The interactions driving genome downsizing may operate differently during the transition from diploidy to polyploidy than on subsequent increases in ploidy level.     

Nuclear DNA amounts in Macaronesian angiosperms

Nuclear DNA contents for 104 Macaronesian angiosperms, with particular attention on Canary Islands endemics, were analysed using propidium iodide flow cytometry. Prime estimates for more than one-sixth of the whole Canarian endemic flora (including representatives of 11 endemic genera) were obtained. The resulting 1C DNA values ranged from 0.19 to 7.21 pg for Descurainia bourgeauana and Argyranthemum frutescens, respectively (about 38-fold difference). The majority of species, however, possessed (very) small genomes, with C-values <1.6 pg. The tendency towards small nuclear DNA contents and genome sizes was confirmed by comparing average values for Macaronesian and non-Macaronesian representatives of individual families, genera and major phylogenetic lineages. Our data support the hypothesis that the insular selection pressures in Macaronesia favour small C-values and genome sizes. Both positive and negative correlations between infrageneric nuclear DNA amount variation and environmental conditions on Tenerife were also found in several genera.     

NUCLEAR DNA CONTENT VARIATION WITHIN THE ROSACEAE

Nuclear DNA content has been estimated using flow cytometry for 17 species and eight cultivars of Malus and for 44 species of 29 other genera within the Rosaceae. Compared to other angiosperms, diploid genome sizes vary little within the family Rosaceae and within the genus Malus. C-values of genera within the subfamilies Spiraeoideae and Rosoideae are among the smallest of flowering plants thus far reported. In general, the Maloideae have the largest diploid genomes of the family, consistent with their higher chromosome numbers and presumed polyploid origin.     

Nuclear DNA and heterochromatin contents in theScilla hohenackeri group,S. persica,andPuschkinia scilloides (Liliaceae)

DNA contents (presented as 1C-values) have been determined cytophotometrically in 7 species of theScilla hohenackeri group (10.18 to 22.71 pg), and in the systematically more isolated taxaS. persica (21.02 pg) andPuschkinia scilloides (6.80 pg). The heterochromatin amount is not correlated with the nuclear DNA content. Euchromatin, therefore, is not a particularly conservative part of the genome. However, high C-values and large but few terminal heterochromatin bands, and lower C-values and numerous but smaller heterochromatin bands are found to be linked in theS. hohenackeri group. Obviously, numerous chromosomal changes have accompanied speciation in this group. DNA contents, and C-banded karyotypes are consistent with systematic affinities based on morphological similarities.Evolution ofScilla and Related Genera, III.     

Genome sizes for 71 species of Zamia (Cycadales: Zamiaceae) correspond with three different biogeographic regions

Nuclear DNA contents (2C‐value) are reported for 71 out of 76 accepted species of Zamia (Zamiaceae) using flow cytometry with propidium iodide. Nuclear DNA content in Zamia ranges between 33.7 and 45.7 pg. Despite this small range, the largest genome contains roughly 10¹⁰ more base pairs than the smallest genome. The results for Zamia point to two centers of biogeographic distribution: Mexico and Colombia. Nicaragua seems to be the biogeographic boundary for these two centres for Zamia. To the north, genome sizes of 33.7–38.0 pg (average 35.6 pg) are found and to the south (Costa Rica, Panama and South America) 41.2–45.7 pg (average 42.9 pg). Plants from the Caribbean islands (including Florida) have intermediate genome sizes with 37.3–40.9 pg (average 38.7 pg). Costa Rica and Panama are in a transition zone and its species can be divided into three subsections: four species with ‘Caribbean’ values of 38.4–39.5 pg (average 39.0 pg), six species with ‘South American’ values with 42.7–43.6 pg, (average 42.9 pg, and six species with intermediate values ranging between 40.1–41.0 pg (average 40.4 pg). The latter values are nearly absent in other areas, suggesting that they could be the products of (introgressive) hybridization. This study represents the first, nearly complete overview of the genome sizes of the genus Zamia and their relationship with biogeography.     

Conifer genome sizes of 172 species,covering 64 of 67 genera,range from 8 to 72 picogram

Nuclear genome size of conifers as measured by flow cytometry with propidium iodide was investigated, striving to collect at least a single species from each genus. 64 out of 67 genera and 172 species were measured. Of the 67 genera, 21 are reported here for the first time and the same is true for 76 species. This nearly doubles the number of measured genera and adds 50% to the number of analyzed species. Conifers have chromosome numbers in the range of n = (7)10–12(19). However, the nuclear DNA content (2C‐value) is shown here to range from 8.3 to 71.6 picogram. The largest genome contains roughly 6 × 10¹⁰ more base pairs than the smallest genome. Genome sizes are evaluated and compared with available taxonomic treatments. For the mainly (sub)tropical Podocarpaceae small genome sizes were found with a 2C‐value of only 8–28 pg, with 13.5 pg on average. For the Taxaceae 2C‐values from 23–60 pg were determined. Not surprisingly, the genus Pinus with 97 species (39 species measured here) has a broad range with 2C = 38–72 pg. A factor of 2 difference is also found in the Cupressaceae (136 species) with nuclear DNA contents in the range 18–35 pg. Apart from the allohexaploid Sequoia, ploidy plays a role only in Juniperus and some new polyploids are found. The data on genome size support conclusions on phylogenetic relationships obtained by DNA sequencing. Flow cytometry is applicable even to young plants or seeds for the monitoring of trade in endangered species.     

Nuclear DNA content estimates in green algal lineages: chlorophyta and streptophyta

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Consensus higher-level molecular phylogenies present a compelling case that an ancient divergence separates eukaryotic green algae into two major monophyletic lineages, Chlorophyta and Streptophyta, and a residuum of green algae, which have been referred to prasinophytes or micromonadophytes. Nuclear DNA content estimates have been published for less than 1% of the described green algal members of Chlorophyta, which includes multicellular green marine algae and freshwater flagellates (e.g. Chlamydomonas and Volvox). The present investigation summarizes the state of our knowledge and adds substantially to our database of C-values, especially for the streptophyte charophycean lineage which is the sister group of the land plants. A recent list of 2C nuclear DNA contents for isolates and species of green algae is expanded by 72 to 157. METHODS: The DNA-localizing fluorochrome DAPI (4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole) and red blood cell (chicken erythrocytes) standard were used to estimate 2C values with static microspectrophotometry. Key RESULTS: In Chlorophyta, including Chlorophyceae, Prasinophyceae, Trebouxiophyceae and Ulvophyceae, 2C DNA estimates range from 0.01 to 5.8 pg. Nuclear DNA content variation trends are noted and discussed for specific problematic taxon pairs, including Ulotrichales-Ulvales, and Cladophorales-Siphonocladales. For Streptophyta, 2C nuclear DNA contents range from 0.2 to 6.4 pg, excluding the highly polyploid Charales and Desmidiales, which have genome sizes of up to 14.8 and 46.8 pg, respectively. Nuclear DNA content data for Streptophyta superimposed on a contemporary molecular phylogeny indicate that early diverging lineages, including some members of Chlorokybales, Coleochaetales and Klebsormidiales, have genomes as small as 0.1-0.5 pg. It is proposed that the streptophyte ancestral nuclear genome common to both the charophyte and the embryophyte lineages can be characterized as 1C = 0.2 pg and 1n = 6. CONCLUSIONS: These data will help pre-screen candidate species for the on-going construction of bacterial artificial chromosome nuclear genome libraries for land plant ancestors. Data for the prasinophyte Mesostigma are of particular interest as this alga reportedly most closely resembles the 'ancestral green flagellate'. Both mechanistic and ecological processes are discussed that could have produced the observed C-value increase of >100-fold in the charophyte green algae whereas the ancestral genome was conserved in the embryophytes.     

Nuclear DNA content of some important plant species

Nuclear DNA contents of more than 100 important plant species were measured by flow cytometry of isolated nuclei stained with propidium iodide.Arabidopsis exhibits developmentally regulated multiploidy and has a 2C nuclear DNA content of 0.30 pg (145 Mbp/1C), twice the value usually cited. The 2C value for rice is only about three times that ofArabidopsis. Tomato has a 2C value of about 2.0 pg, larger than commonly cited. This survey identified several horticultural crops in a variety of families with genomes only two or three times as large asArabidopsis; these include several fruit trees (a pricot, cherry, mango, orange, papaya, and peach). The small genome sizes of rice and the horticultural plants should facilitate molecular studies of these crops.     

Nuclear DNA content estimates in multicellular green, red and brown algae: phylogenetic considerations

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Multicellular eukaryotic algae are phylogenetically disparate. Nuclear DNA content estimates have been published for fewer than 1 % of the described species of Chlorophyta, Phaeophyta and Rhodophyta. The present investigation aims to summarize the state of our knowledge and to add substantially to our database of C-values for theses algae. METHODS: The DNA-localizing fluorochrome DAPI (4', 6-diamidino-2-phenylindole) and RBC (chicken erythrocyte) standard were used to estimate 2C values with static microspectrophotometry. KEY RESULTS: 2C DNA contents for 85 species of Chlorophyta range from 0.2-6.1 pg, excluding the highly polyploidy Charales and Desmidiales with DNA contents of up to 39.2 and 20.7 pg, respectively. 2C DNA contents for 111 species of Rhodophyta range from 0.1-2.8 pg, and for 44 species of Phaeophyta range from 0.2-1.8 pg. CONCLUSIONS: New availability of consensus higher-level molecular phylogenies provides a framework for viewing C-value data in a phylogenetic context. Both DNA content ranges and mean values are greater in taxa considered to be basal. It is proposed that the basal, ancestral genome in each algal group was quite small. Both mechanistic and ecological processes are discussed that could have produced the observed C-value ranges.     

长三角及邻近地区138种草本植物DNA C-值测定及其生物学意义

为了评估DNA C-值和基因组大小(genome size)在植物入侵性评估中的价值,应用流式细胞仪测定了长三角及邻近地区138种草本植物的核DNA含量,其中111种为首次报道。在此基础上比较了不同植物类群这两个值的差异,特别是入侵性与非入侵性植物这两个值的差异。结果表明:(1)138种草本植物平均DNA C-值为1.55 pg,最大者是最小者的37.17倍。127个类群平均基因组大小为1.08 pg,最大者是最小者的34.11倍;(2)统计了菊科(Asteraceae)、禾本科(Poaceae)、石竹科(Caryophyllaceae)、十字花科(Brassicaceae)、玄参科(Scrophulariaceae)、蓼科(Polygonaceae)、唇形科(Labiatae)和伞形科(Umbelliferae)的DNA C-值和基因组大小,发现禾本科植物的这两个值显著地大于其他7个科(P0.01)。单子叶的DNA C-值和基因组极显著地大于双子叶植物(P0.01);(3)杂草比非杂草具有更低的DNA C-值(P0.01)和基因组大小(P0.001);与DNA C-值相比,基因组大小在这两个类群之间的差异更为明显(P0.001),这种现象也体现在菊科植物中。随着基因组(X1)和DNA C-值(X2)由大变小,植物的杂草性(入侵性,Y)由弱变强,两者关系分别符合:Y=2.2334-1.2847 ln(X1)(r=0.4612,P0.01)和Y=2.4421-0.7234 ln(X2)(r=0.2522,P0.01),DNA C-值和基因组大小可以作为植物入侵性评估的一个指标;(4)多倍体杂草的基因组极明显地小于二倍体杂草(P0.01),前者为后者的0.63倍。在非杂草中,多倍体基因组比二倍体的略小,前者仅为后者的0.84倍,差异不显著(P0.5)。菊科植物中多倍体杂草的基因组也显著地小于二倍体杂草(P0.1)。基因组变小和多倍体化相结合,进一步增强了植物的入侵性。在多倍体植物入侵性评估中,基因组大小比DNA C-值更有价值。     

Genome size variation in Macaronesian angiosperms: forty percent of the Canarian endemic flora completed

Genome sizes for 127 Macaronesian endemic angiosperms from 69 genera and 32 families were estimated using propidium iodide flow cytometry. Only about 30-fold variation in 1C-values was found, ranging from 0.32 pg in Echium bonnetii to 9.52 pg in Scilla dasyantha. Taxa with very small DNA amounts (1C 1.4 pg) were the most dominant group (71.7%), whereas the frequency of other categories was much lower (18.9% and 9.4% in taxa with small (1.41–3.50 pg) and intermediate 1C-values (3.51–14.00 pg), respectively). Comparisons of average C- and Cx-values between Macaronesian endemics and non-Macaronesian representatives always revealed significantly smaller amounts in the former group at various taxonomic levels (genus, family, major phylogenetic lineage). Potential relationship between nuclear DNA content and insular burst of speciation is suggested owing to the marked prevalence of very small genomes among angiosperms that underwent rapid adaptive radiation. Merging all the genome size data on Macaronesian angiosperms available shows that this flora represents the best covered plant assemblage from the phytogeographic point of view.     

Nuclear DNA contents of all species of Helleborus (Ranunculaceae) discriminate between species and sectional divisions

 Genome size (C-values) and pollen viability staining were applied as new criteria to investigate the species of the genus Helleborus Linnaeus (Ranunculaceae). All species have the same chromosome number (2n=32). However, the nuclear DNA content, as measured by flow cytometry with propidium iodide, could be demonstrated to range between 19 pg to 35.7 pg. The different genome sizes of the species coincided to a large extent with earlier determined section boundaries based on morphology. Flow cytometry can be a convenient method to discriminate between some species. Received April 17, 2001 Accepted May 7, 2001     

Genome sizes of all 19 Araucaria species are correlated with their geographical distribution

Nuclear genome size was determined to investigate the relationships between all 19 species of Araucaria de Jussieu. Species from the two other genera of Araucariaceae, Wollemia and Agathis, were also studied. The genome size of 17 out of the 19 species of Araucaria are reported here for the first time. All Araucariaceae have the same chromosome number 2n?=?26. However, the nuclear DNA contents (2C value) for Araucaria range from 31.3 to 45.4?pg. There is a good correlation between genome size and division in sections, and geographical distribution. The two species from South America have 44.7 and 45.4?pg, the two species from Australia have 35.7 and 44.4?pg and the two species from New Guinea 34.7 and 40.4?pg. All 13 species of New Caledonia and the one from Norfolk Island have a similar, if not identical, amount of nuclear DNA of, on average, 31.9?pg. This corroborates the identical DNA rbcL sequences found for the New Caledonian araucarias. It suggests that the species from New Caledonia diversified more recently and it questions their status as separate species. Compared with this 31.9?pg a strong increase seems to have occurred in the genome size of the “mainland” araucarias. Genome sizes are evaluated and compared with available taxonomic treatments and extant geographic spreading. The nuclear DNA contents found within the sections are close, making it possible to assign an unknown plant to a section. A difference of 1?pg, which amounts to a difference of 978?Mbp, far exceeds a single character. Nuclear DNA content, as measured by flow cytometry, may conveniently be used to produce systematic data. It is applicable even with young plants or seeds for monitoring the trade in endangered species.     

Quantification and characterization of nuclear genomes in commercial red seaweeds: Gracilariales and Gelidiales

Nuclear genome profiles were developed for representative species of the Gelidiales and Gracilariales using information from present and previous studies of cytogenetics, cytophotometry and DNA reassociation kinetics. Results indicate that species of Gracilaria and Gracilariopsis are characterized by distinct chromosome complements of n = 24 and n = 32, respectively, a narrow range of small genome sizes (2C = 0.35–0.45 pg) and a wide range of values for repeated and unique genome sequences. In contrast, the Gelidiales investigated are characterized by a wide range of chromosome complements, n = 6–29, a wider range of genome sizes (2C = 0.42–0.68 pg) and a large proportion of unique genome sequences. Nuclear genome sizes for species of the Gelidiales and Gracilariales are compared with estimates of other red algal orders including the Bangiales, Ceramiales and Gigartinales.     

Nuclear DNA C-values Complete Familial Representation in Gymnosperms

The gymnosperms are a monophyletic yet diverse group of woodytrees with approx. 730 extant species in 17 families. A recentsurvey showed that DNA C-values were available for approx. 16%of species, but for only 12 of the 17 families. This paper completesfamilial representation reporting first C-values for the fiveremaining families: Boweniaceae, Stangeriaceae, Welwitschiaceae,Cephalotaxaceae and Sciadopityaceae. C-values for nine Ephedraand two Gnetum species are also reported. C-values are now availablefor 152 (21%) species. Analysis confirms that gymnosperms arecharacterized by larger C-values than angiosperms (modal 1Cof gymnosperms = 15.8 pg compared with 0.6 pg in angiosperms)although the range (1C = 2.25–32.20 pg) is smaller thanthat in angiosperms (1C = 0.05–127.4 pg). Given completefamilial coverage for C-values and increasing consensus in gymnospermphylogeny, the phylogenetic component of C-value variation wasalso investigated by comparing the two datasets. This analysisrevealed that ancestral gymnosperms (represented by cycads and/orGinkgo; mean genome size = 14.71 pg) probably had larger genomes thanancestral angiosperms. Copyright 2001 Annals of Botany Company Gymnosperm DNA amounts, C-values, phylogeny, ancestral genome size, Cycadales, Ginkgo, Gnetales, conifers, Pinaceae     

Taxonomic implications of genome size for all species of the genus Gasteria Duval (Aloaceae)

Nuclear DNA content (2C) is used as a new criterion to investigate all species of the genus Gasteria Duval including the three recently described species Gasteria polita van Jaarsv., G. pendulifolia van Jaarsv. and G. glauca van Jaarsv.. The 122 accessions investigated have the same chromosome number (2n=2x=14), with exception of three tetraploid plants found. The nuclear DNA content of the diploids, as measured by flow cytometry with Propidium Iodide, is demonstrated to range from 32.8–43.2 pg. This implies that the largest genome contains roughly 10¹⁰ more base pairs than the smallest. Based on DNA content the species could be divided in five groups: G. rawlinsonii Oberm. with 32.8 pg, 13 mostly inland species with 34.3–36.0 pg, five coastal species with 36.5–39.0 pg and Gasteria batesiana Rowley with 43.2 pg. The thirteen species with 34.3–36.0 pg could be divided further, in a group of eight species occupying mainly very restricted areas with 34.3–35.1 pg and a second group of five species with 35.2–36.0 pg mainly occupying large areas. These five groups did not coincide very well with the two sections and four series of Gasteria based on a cladistic analysis by van Jaarsveld et al. (1994). Based on its long leafy branches, location in the centre of Gasteria species distribution and its by far lowest DNA content, G. rawlinsonii might be the most primitive member of the genus. Nuclear DNA content as measured by flow cytometry is shown to be relevant to provide additional information on the relationships between Gasteria species.     

First Nuclear DNA C-values for Another 25 Angiosperm Families

Nuclear DNA C-value is an important genomic biodiversity characterwith many uses. An international workshop sponsored by Annalsof Botany and held at the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, UK, in1997 identified major gaps in our knowledge of plant DNA C-valuesand recommended targets for new work. Improved taxonomic coveragewas highlighted as a key need for angiosperms, especially atthe familial level. In 1997 C-values were known for only approx.32% of angiosperm families; a goal of complete familial representationby 2002 was recommended. A review published in 2000 (Bennettet al.;Annals of Botany86: 859–909) noted poor progresstowards this aim: of the 691 first C-values for species only12 (1.7%) were for unrepresented families. We began new workto address this in 1999, reporting first DNA C-values for 25angiosperm families in 2001 (Hanson et al.;Annals of Botany87:251–258). Here we report first DNA C-values for a further25 angiosperm families, increasing familial coverage in angiospermsto approx. 45%. Such targeting remains essential to approachthe goal set by the 1997 workshop of familial coverage for angiospermswithin 5 years. The 4C DNA amounts presented here range from0.76 pg (similar toArabidopsis thaliana ) in Roridula gorgonias(Roridulaceae)to 29.74 pg in Gunnera manicata(Gunneraceae). 1C values were< 3.5 pg in 23 of the 25 families; these data provide furthersupport for the view that ancestral angiosperms almost certainlyhad small genomes (defined as 1C     

Nuclear DNA contents in the genusFicus (Moraceae)

Nuclear DNA contents in 15 species of large tropical hardwood genusFicus have been determined by cytophotometry. The 2 C-values are rather low and uniform, suggesting no appreciable changes during speciation. The small genome size is discussed in relation to woody habit.