Development of functional sex differences in the larynx of Xenopus laevis

Three laryngeal properties associated with the production of masculine song--laryngeal muscle tension, fiber twitch type, and fiber recruitment--are markedly sexually dimorphic in adult Xenopus laevis frogs. To elucidate the pattern of sexual differentiation, tension and fiber recruitment in male and female larynges and fiber twitch type in male larynges were examined throughout postmetamorphic development. Masculinization of male laryngeal properties begins early in postmetamorphic development and continues until adulthood. In contrast, tension and fiber recruitment in females do not change after the end of metamorphosis. Laryngeal muscle tension and fiber type are gradually and progressively masculinized; the temporal pattern of masculinization is very similar for these properties. Fiber recruitment, on the other hand, appears to masculinize in a stepwise manner. Masculinization of all three properties is highly correlated with larynx weight in males. We have used this relation to divide postmetamorphic development into seven stages associated with key events in sexual differentiation. This staging scheme provides an important experimental tool for studying the hormonal regulation of sexual differentiation, the subject of the accompanying paper.     

Neuroeffectors for vocalization in Xenopus laevis: hormonal regulation of sexual dimorphism

South African clawed frogs use sex-specific vocalizations during courtship. In the male, vocalizations are under the control of gonadal androgen. Though females have moderate levels of circulating androgen, they do not give male-typical mate calls. Both muscles of the vocal organ and neurons of the central nervous system (CNS) vocal pathway are sexually dimorphic and androgen-sensitive. Recent studies suggest that the failure of androgen to masculinize adult females results from a male-specific, androgen-regulated developmental program. At metamorphosis the larynx is sexually monomorphic and feminine in morphology, muscle fiber number and androgen receptor content. During the next six months, under the influence of increasing androgen titers and high receptor levels, myoblasts proliferate in the male and muscle fibers increase at an average rate of 100/day. Females have much lower hormone levels, receptor values decline and they display no net addition of fibers. At metamorphosis, both males and females have approximately 4000 muscle fibers. By adulthood, males have eight times the female fiber number. In the CNS, adult laryngeal motor neurons are more numerous with larger somata and dendritic trees in males than in females. Certain connections of neurons in the vocal pathway are also less robust in females. Unlike the periphery, motor neuron number does not appear to be established by androgen-induced proliferation. Our current hypothesis is that androgen acts at the level of laryngeal muscle to produce more muscle fibers and thus provide more target for motor neurons in the male. This process could regulate cell number by ontogenetic cell death. In the CNS, androgen-target neurons become capable of accumulating hormone shortly before metamorphosis. Androgen receptor in laryngeal motor neurons may permit the dendritic growth characteristic of males by increasing sensitivity to afferent stimuli. Such a process could account for the observed differences in CNS vocal "circuitry" in X. laevis and thus behavioral differences between the sexes.     

Laryngeal muscle and motor neuron plasticity in Xenopus laevis: Testicular masculinization of a developing neuromuscular system

In Xenopus laevis, the sexual differentiation of the neuromuscular system responsible for courtship song is controlled by testicular androgen secretion. To explore the sensitivity of this system to androgenic stimulation, male and female frogs were gonadectectomized and given testis transplants at seven different developmental stages between the end of metamorphosis and adulthood, grown to sexual maturity, and the laryngeal muscle fibers and motor axons were counted. Muscle fiber and axon numbers in males were not affected by the testicular transplant at any stage. In females, testicular transplants at all developmental stages increased muscle fiber numbers in adulthood. Values attained were, however, significantly less than those of adult intact or testis-transplanted males. Testis transplantation increased laryngeal axon numbers in females to levels equivalent to those of intact males; this effect was obtained at every stage of postmetamorphic development including adulthood. To further explore androgen regulation in adults, males and females were gonadectomized and implanted with silicone tubes containing testosterone propionate for 1.5–3 years and laryngeal muscle fibers and axon numbers compared to those of gonadectomized or sham-operated adult controls. Neither treatment with exogenous androgen nor gonadectomy had any effect on laryngeal muscle fiber or axon number in either males or females; values did not differ from those of sham-operated controls. We conclude that testicular secretions can induce laryngeal muscle fiber and axon addition in females throughout postmetamorphic life. This degree of plasticity, exhibited after the period when adult values are normally attained, stands in contrast to the effects of administration of synthetic androgen and suggests that the degree of plasticity in adult females may be underestimated if exogenous hormones rather than testicular transplants are provided. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Sexually dimorphic expression of a laryngeal-specific, androgen-regulated myosin heavy chain gene during Xenopus laevis development.

Masculinization of the larynx in Xenopus laevis frogs is essential for the performance of male courtship song. During postmetamorphic (PM) development, the initially female-like phenotype of laryngeal muscle (slow and fast twitch fibers) is converted to the masculine form (entirely fast twitch) under the influence of androgenic steroids. To explore the molecular basis of androgen-directed masculinization, we have isolated cDNA clones encoding portions of a new Xenopus myosin heavy chain (MHC) gene. We have detected expression of this gene only in laryngeal muscle and specifically in males. All adult male laryngeal muscle fibers express the laryngeal myosin (LM). Adult female laryngeal muscle expresses LM only in some fibers. Expression of LM during PM development was examined using Northern blots and in situ hybridization. Males express higher levels of LM than females throughout PM development and attain adult levels by PM3. In females, LM expression peaks transiently at PM2. Treatment of juvenile female frogs with the androgen dihydrotestosterone masculinizes LM expression. Thus, LM appears to be a male-specific, testosterone-regulated MHC isoform in Xenopus laevis. The LM gene will permit analysis of androgen-directed sexual differentiation in this highly sexually dimorphic tissue.     

Androgen directs sexual differentiation of laryngeal innervation in developing Xenopus laevis

In adult Xenopus laevis, innervation of the vocal organ is more robust in males than in females. This sex difference originates during tadpole development; at stage 56, when the gonads first differentiate, the number of axons entering the larynx is the same in the sexes, but by stage 62, innervation is greater in males. To determine if androgen secretion establishes sex differences in axon number, we treated tadpoles with antiandrogen or androgen beginning at stage 48 or 54 and counted laryngeal nerve axons at stage 62 using electron microscopy. When male tadpoles were treated with the antiandrogen hydroxyflutamide, axon numbers were reduced to female-typical values; axon numbers in females were unaffected by antiandrogen treatment. When female tadpoles were treated with the androgen DHT (dihydrotestosterone), axon numbers were increased to male-like values. These findings suggest that endogenous androgen secretion during late tadpole stages in males is required for the sexual differentiation of laryngeal innervation observed from stage 62 on. Because androgen treatment and laryngeal innervation affect myogenesis in postmetamorphic frogs, numbers of laryngeal dilator muscle fibers were determined for hormonally manipulated tadpoles. At stage 62, vehicle-treated males had more laryngeal axons than females; laryngeal muscle fiber numbers did not, however, differ in the sexes. Both male and female tadpoles, treated from stage 54 with DHT, had more muscle fibers at stage 62 than vehicle-treated controls. Thus, while endogenous androgen secretion during late tadpole stages is subthreshold for the establishment of masculinized muscle fiber numbers, laryngeal myogenesis is androgen sensitive at this time and can be increased by suprathreshold provision of exogenous DHT. A subgroup of tadpoles, DHT treated from stage 54 to 62, was allowed to survive, untreated, until postmetamorphic stage 2 (PM2: 5 months after metamorphosis is complete). Androgen treatment between tadpole stages 54 and 62 does not prevent the ontogenetic decrease in axon numbers characteristic of laryngeal development. In addition, the elevation in stage 62 axon numbers produced by DHT-treatment at late tadpole stages was not associated with elevated numbers of laryngeal muscle fibers at PM2. Juvenile males normally maintain elevated axon numbers (relative to final adult values) through PM2 and the presence of these additional axons may result from-rather than contribute directly to—laryngeal muscle fiber addition. 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Androgen-induced myogenesis and chondrogenesis in the larynx of Xenopus laevis

We investigated a possible role for testosterone-induced cell proliferation in the development of sexual dimorphism in the larynx of South African clawed frogs, Xenopus laevis. Androgen-induced cell proliferation was studied using [3H]thymidine autoradiography. Nuclei of cartilage, perichondrium, and muscle were labeled in the larynx of sexually immature frogs of both sexes but not in adults. Cell proliferation did not occur with estradiol treatment nor was it seen in nonlaryngeal muscle or cartilage. Electron microscopic/autoradiographic studies of laryngeal muscle indicate that testosterone stimulates satellite cell division which later results in formation of myonuclei. We conclude that testosterone induces both chondrogenesis and myogenesis in juvenile larynx and that this process may contribute to the pronounced sexual dimorphism of the adult vocal organ.     

Prolactin opens the sensitive period for androgen regulation of a larynx-specific myosin heavy chain gene

The larynx of Xenopus laevis is a sexually differentiated vocal organ in which male muscle is entirely fast twitch and expresses high levels of a fast twitch myosin heavy chain gene, LM. Female muscle, however, is mostly slow twitch and expresses little LM. Androgen is unable to induce expression of LM until after metamorphosis is complete. The expression of LM during metamorphic and early postmetamorphic development parallels secretion and expression of the pituitary hormone prolactin. Here, we show that exposure to prolactin is necessary to allow androgen-induced LM expression in postmetamorphic froglets. In prolactin-deprived animals, androgen-induced changes in the contractile properties of laryngeal muscle are blocked, which prevents the rapid rates of muscle contraction required for males to produce courtship songs. Thus, prolactin opens the sensitive period for androgen-induced LM expression in the larynx and controls the ability of male sex hormones to masculinize the vocal system both at the level of gene expression and vocal organ physiology.     

Hormone-sensitive stages in the sexual differentiation of laryngeal muscle fiber number in Xenopus laevis

The number of muscle fibers in the vocal organ of the adult male African clawed frog, Xenopus laevis, exceeds that of adult females. This sex difference is the result of rapid fiber addition in males between the end of metamorphosis, post-metamorphic stage 0 (PM0) and PM2. At PM0, male and female frogs have similar numbers of laryngeal muscle fibers. Males then add more muscle fibers than females and achieve an adult value that is 1.7 times the female number. Males castrated at PM0 have the same fiber number as females. Ovariectomy at PM0 does not alter muscle fiber addition in females. Gonadectomy at PM2 has no effect on fiber addition in either sex. Females attain masculine muscle fiber number if their ovaries are replaced with a testis at metamorphosis. Exogenous testosterone treatment at PM0 significantly increases fiber number in females but not in males. Exogenous testosterone given at PM2 has no effect on fiber number in females but decreases fiber number in males. We conclude that the testes are necessary for the marked addition of laryngeal muscle fibers seen in male X. laevis between PM0 and PM2. The masculine pattern of muscle fiber addition can be induced in females provided with a testis. Androgen secretion from the testes most probably accounts for masculinization of laryngeal muscle fiber number. After PM2, androgens are no longer necessary for muscle fiber addition and cannot increase fiber number in females.     

Sexual differentiation and hormonal regulation of the laryngeal synapse in Xenopus laevis

In Xenopus laevis frogs, sex differences in adult laryngeal synapses contribute to sex differences in vocal behavior. This study explores the development of sex differences in types of neuromuscular synapses and the development and hormone regulation of sex differences in transmitter release. Synapses in the juvenile larynx have characteristics not found in adults: juvenile muscle fibers can produce subthreshold or suprathreshold potentials in response to the same strength of nerve stimulation and can also produce multiple spikes to a single nerve stimulus. Juvenile laryngeal muscle also contains the same synapse types (I, II, and III) as are found in adult laryngeal muscle. The distribution of laryngeal synapse types in juveniles is less sexually dimorphic than the distribution in adults. Analysis of quantal content indicates that laryngeal synapses characteristically release low amounts of transmitter prior to sexual differentiation. Quantal content values from male and female juveniles are similar to values for adult males and are lower than values for adult females. When juveniles are gonadectomized and treated with exogenous estrogen, quantal content values increase significantly, suggesting that this hormone may increase transmitter release at laryngeal synapses during development. Gonadectomy alone does not affect quantal content of laryngeal synapses in either sex. Androgen treatment decreases quantal content in juvenile females but not males; the effect is opposite to and smaller than that of estrogen. Thus, muscle fiber responses to nerve stimulation and transmitter release are not sexually dimorphic in juvenile larynges. Transmitter release is strengthened, or feminized, by the administration of estradiol, an ovarian steroid hormone. © 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Prolactin opens the sensitive period for androgen regulation of a larynx‐specific myosin heavy chain gene

The larynx of Xenopus laevis is a sexually differentiated vocal organ in which male muscle is entirely fast twitch and expresses high levels of a fast twitch myosin heavy chain gene, LM. Female muscle, however, is mostly slow twitch and expresses little LM. Androgen is unable to induce expression of LM until after metamorphosis is complete. The expression of LM during metamorphic and early postmetamorphic development parallels secretion and expression of the pituitary hormone prolactin. Here, we show that exposure to prolactin is neccessary to allow androgen‐induced LM expression in postmetamorphic froglets. In prolactin‐deprived animals, androgen‐induced changes in the contactile properties of laryngeal muscle are blocked, which prevents the rapid rates of muscle contraction required for males to produce courtship songs. Thus, prolactin opens the sensitive period for androgen‐induced LM expression in the larynx and controls the ability of male sex hormones to masculinize the vocal system both at the level of gene expression and vocal organ physiology. © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 41: 443–451, 1999     

Attaining and maintaining strong vocal synapses in female Xenopus laevis

Synaptic efficacy at the laryngeal neuromuscular synapse differs markedly in adult male and female Xenopus laevis. Here, we examined the relation between circulating estrogen and synapse strength in developing and adult female frogs. Circulating estrogen levels in males and females during juvenile and adult stages were measured using radioimmunoassays. Synaptic strength was determined by quantal analysis in isolated female larynges. In males, estrogen levels are low (<40 pg/mL) throughout development. In females, estrogen levels are similar to those in males until 9 months after metamorphosis is complete and then increase throughout development. Female laryngeal synapses have low quantal contents until 24 months; quantal content increases significantly between 24 and 26 months, and high quantal contents are maintained thereafter. Measures of reproductive maturation, ovary, and oviduct weights, are strongly and positively correlated with estrogen level in 16- to 26-month females, while oocyte maturation is age dependent. Estrogen level and quantal content are not well correlated in these females. Ovariectomy at 24 months prevents the expected increase in quantal content and ovariectomy at 28 months results in a decrease in quantal content. Thus, the sex difference in efficacy of the laryngeal synapse develops under the influence of the ovary and requires the ovary for maintenance of strong synapses in adulthood. While the influence of the ovary is most likely due to estrogen secretion, the pattern of estrogen secretion required for maturation of the synapse in females is not known. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 37: 441–448, 1998     

The postnatal ontogeny of the sexually dimorphic vocal apparatus in goitred gazelles (Gazella subgutturosa)

This study quantitatively documents the progressive development of sexual dimorphism of the vocal organs along the ontogeny of the goitred gazelle (Gazella subgutturosa). The major, male‐specific secondary sexual features, of vocal anatomy in goitred gazelle are an enlarged larynx and a marked laryngeal descent. These features appear to have evolved by sexual selection and may serve as a model for similar events in male humans. Sexual dimorphism of larynx size and larynx position in adult goitred gazelles is more pronounced than in humans, whereas the vocal anatomy of neonate goitred gazelles does not differ between sexes. This study examines the vocal anatomy of 19 (11 male, 8 female) goitred gazelle specimens across three age‐classes, that is, neonates, subadults and mature adults. The postnatal ontogenetic development of the vocal organs up to their respective end states takes considerably longer in males than in females. Both sexes share the same features of vocal morphology but differences emerge in the course of ontogeny, ultimately resulting in the pronounced sexual dimorphism of the vocal apparatus in adults. The main differences comprise larynx size, vocal fold length, vocal tract length, and mobility of the larynx. The resilience of the thyrohyoid ligament and the pharynx, including the soft palate, and the length changes during contraction and relaxation of the extrinsic laryngeal muscles play a decisive role in the mobility of the larynx in both sexes but to substantially different degrees in adult females and males. Goitred gazelles are born with an undescended larynx and, therefore, larynx descent has to develop in the course of ontogeny. This might result from a trade‐off between natural selection and sexual selection requiring a temporal separation of different laryngeal functions at birth and shortly after from those later in life. J. Morphol. 277:826–844, 2016. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Sexual Dimorphism of the Larynx of the Mongolian Gazelle (Procapra gutturosa Pallas, 1777) (Mammalia, Artiodactyla, Bovidae)

The larynges (except for the epiglottis) of two adult Mongolian gazelles, one male and one female, were dissected. This species is characterized by a pronounced sexual dimorphism of the larynx. Dimorphism with regard to the size of the entire larynx and of the thyroid cartilage is about 2:1 whereas the difference of mean body mass is about 1.3:1 between males and females. Unexpectedly, and in contrast to other bovids, the larynx of the male Mongolian gazelle has a paired lateral laryngeal ventricle. However, in contrast to horse, dog, pig and many primate species also possessing such a paired ventricle, its rostral opening in the Mongolian gazelle is situated lateral to the corniculate process of the arytenoid cartilage. The neck of the laryngeal ventricle is embraced by the bifurcated cuneiform process of the epiglottis. Despite the enlarged laryngeal cartilages, the vocal process of the male arytenoid cartilage is relatively shorter than that of the female. The male thyroarytenoid muscle is clearly separated into a rostral ventricular muscle and a caudal vocal muscle whereas the female's, as in other bovids, is almost uniform. The lateral sac of the two-chambered laryngeal ventricle in the male projects laterally between the ventricular and the vocal muscle. As in the domestic bovids and in many other artiodactyls the larynx of the male Mongolian gazelle is lacking any rostrally directed membraneous portion of the vocal fold. Instead, the thick and tough bow-like vocal fold projects caudally into the infraglottic cavity and is supported by a peculiar pan-like fibroelastic pad. This resilient element, situated medial to the bipartite thyroarytenoid muscle, might be a homologue of the vocal ligament, eventually including lateral portions of the elastic cone. A fibroelastic pad is absent in the female. The resilient floor of the laryngeal vestibulum, ventral to the fibroelastic pad, is rostrally and caudally subducted by tube-like spaces. Evolutionary enlargement of the male larynx, including the vocal folds, and of the caudal portions of the vocal tract may have shifted the fundamental and formant frequencies to a lower register. The paired lateral laryngeal ventricle might produce an amplitude increase of the vocalizations assisted by differential action of the bipartite thyroarytenoid muscle. In addition, the peculiar shape, size and tough consistency of the male vocal folds may, as in roaring felids, assist in producing high amplitude and low frequency vocalizations. Perhaps the biological role of the enlarged male larynx of Procapra gutturosa has evolved in relation to its mating system. In the rutting season, dominant males establish individual territories and maintain harems. During prolonged courtship prior to mating, these males perform an acoustic display uttering loud and guttural bellows. In addition, the bulging ventral neck region of males may serve as an optical attractant for the females. Thus, the evolution of the enlarged larynx of the male Mongolian gazelle may have been favoured by sexual selection.     

Analysis of the sternotrachealis muscle fibers in some Anseriformes: histochemistry and sex differences

Histochemical characteristics and sizes of the fibers of the sternotrachealis (ST) muscle have been investigated in some Anseriformes (mallard, Pekin duck, Muscovy duck, and goose) of both sexes. A sexual dimorphism has been shown in the muscle of the species examined. In the mallard and Pekin duck, the male ST muscle shows type IIIA fibers in addition to the type I, IIA, and IIB fibers observed also in the female. In the Muscovy duck, the male muscle has only type I and IIA fibers, whereas the female muscle presents type I fibers and both types IIA and IIB fibers. Moreover, the mean frequencies for each fiber type were significantly different between males and females. In the goose, both male and female muscles present only type I and IIA fibers. In all the species examined, the mean areas of each fiber type are significantly different between male and female, being always larger in the male muscles. The anatomical sexual dimorphism observed in the ST muscle is discussed in relation to function.     

Sexual Dimorphism in the Hindlimb Muscles of the Asiatic Toad(Bufo gargarizans)in Relation to Male Reproductive Success

In many anurans, the forelimb muscles of males are used to grasp females and are often heavier than those of females despite the larger female body size. Such sexual dimorphism in forelimb musculature is thought to result from sexual selection. In addition, the hindlimbs of frogs and toads play an important role in the reproductive process as amplectant males can expel rivals with robust hindlimbs through kicking. In this study, the sexual dimorphism in dry mass for six hindlimb muscles of the Asiatic toad(Bufo gargarizans) was investigated. The results showed that, when controlled for body size, the hindlimb muscle mass of males significantly exceeded that of females for every muscle. The hindlimb muscle mass of amplectant males was also significantly larger than that of non-amplectant males. These results suggested that if strong hindlimb muscles could improve mating success of males, sexual selection would promote the evolution of dimorphism in this character.     

Cardiac morpho-dynamics in Rana esculenta: influence of sex and season

Morpho-dynamic aspects of the frog (Rana esculenta) heart were correlated to seasonal and sexual traits. The statistical analysis of the data (696 frog specimens: 448 males and 248 females), collected during 8 years of routine research on frog cardiac physiology, indicated that cardiac biology is characterised by sexual dimorphism. The relative cardiac weight of males was higher than that of females of similar size. With respect to the males of similar size, female frogs revealed an increased relative ventricular weight and ventricular contractile capacity. The morphometric analysis showed that the ventricular growth was achieved through significant myocardial enlargement accompanied by a reduction of the lacunary spaces. This is more pronounced in females during the breeding period. The correlation between sexual maturity and ventricular morpho-functional changes revealed that in male frogs sexual maturity correlates with a remarkable increment of the ventricular weight associated with higher values of pulse pressure. This data indicate that sex and season-related factors influence cardiac morpho-dynamics in R. esculenta.     

Sexually distinct development of vocal pathways in Xenopus laevis

Deterministic rules, rather than experience, are thought to regulate the development of simple behaviors in vertebrates and invertebrates. We revisited this issue through examination of the sexually distinct vocalizations of African clawed frogs (Xenopus laevis), a reproductive behavior used by sexually mature males and females. We discovered that, as expected for simple behavior, female vocalizations develop through deterministic rules. The rare calls of juvenile females are indistinguishable from those of adult females. The vocal pathways of juvenile females, as measured by the contractile properties of the laryngeal muscles (the vocal muscles) and the laryngeal motoneuron somata (vocal motoneurons) size, are the developmental default and do not differentiate as they mature. Male Xenopus, in contrast, produce extensive vocalizations with rudimentary acoustic structure before reaching sexual maturity. Moreover, the functional properties of the vocal central pattern generator mature before muscle fibers and motoneuron size are fully masculinized. The results suggest that neuronal activity during development may be important in organizing the contractile properties of the muscle fibers in male, but not in female Xenopus. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Develop Neurobiol 70: 862–874, 2010     

Temporal constraints on androgen directed laryngeal masculinization in Xenopus laevis

Temporal constraints on androgen regulated masculinization of three sexually dimorphic laryngeal properties--tension, fiber type, and fiber recruitment--were examined in Xenopus laevis frogs. Endocrine state was manipulated at PM0 when the larynx is similar in males and females, at PM2 when the larynx begins sexual differentiation, and at PM6 when sexual differentiation is complete. Removing the testes in developing males (PM0 or PM2) completely arrests laryngeal masculinization. Masculinization resumes when testosterone is replaced later in development (PM2 or PM6, respectively). Thus, testicular secretions, in particular androgens, are required for laryngeal masculinization. The ability of androgens to masculinize tension, fiber type, and fiber recruitment in developing and adult larynges was also determined. Five weeks of testosterone treatment in PM0 or PM2 males and females completely masculinizes laryngeal tension and fiber type, but only partially masculinizes fiber recruitment. However, fiber recruitment can be fully masculinized in PM6 males castrated at PM2. We conclude that androgen induced masculinization of tension and fiber type are not temporally constrained but that androgen induced masculinization of fiber recruitment is. Prolonged androgen treatment can override the temporal constraints on masculinization of the larynx. Testosterone treatment for more than 6 months fully masculinizes fiber recruitment in developing (PM0 or PM2) females. In addition, prolonged treatment (greater than 9 months) completely masculinizes tension, fiber type, and fiber recruitment in adult females; these properties were not fully masculinized by shorter (1-3 months) treatments in adult females. Testosterone induced masculinization in females is maintained for up to 8 months following testosterone removal; thus androgen effects are long lasting and possibly permanent.     

Sexual size dimorphism is not associated with the evolution of parental care in frogs

Sex differences in parental care are thought to arise from differential selection on the sexes. Sexual dimorphism, including sexual size dimorphism (SSD), is often used as a proxy for sexual selection on males. Some studies have found an association between male‐biased SSD (i.e., males larger than females) and the loss of paternal care. While the relationship between sexual selection on males and parental care evolution has been studied extensively, the relationship between female‐biased SSD (i.e., females larger than males) and the evolution of parental care has received very little attention. Thus, we have little knowledge of whether female‐biased SSD coevolves with parental care. In species displaying female‐biased SSD, we might expect dimorphism to be associated with the evolution of paternal care or perhaps the loss of maternal care. Here, drawing on data for 99 extant frog species, we use comparative methods to evaluate how parental care and female‐biased SSD have evolved over time. Generally, we find no significant correlation between the evolution of parental care and female‐biased SSD in frogs. This suggests that differential selection on body size between the sexes is unlikely to have driven the evolution of parental care in these clades and questions whether we should expect sexual dimorphism to exhibit a general relationship with the evolution of sex differences in parental care.     

Sexually dimorphic muscles in the forelimb of the Japanese toad,Bufo japonicus

During the breeding season, male anurans display clasping behavior by holding females with their forelimbs. This behavior is peculiar to males, and may require specializations in forelimb musculature. The present study revealed that five kinds of forelimb muscles were heavier in the male Japanese toad than in the female: the flexor carpi radialis (FCR), the flexor antibrachii medialis caput superius (FAMsup), the abductor indicis longus (AIL), the extensor carpi radialis caput superius (ECRsup), and the flexor antibrachii lateralis superficialis caput superius (FALSsup). In addition, one breast muscle, the coracoradialis (CR), was also heavier in males than in females. A quantitative analysis of muscle fibers processed for myosin ATPase activity showed that, in such “sexually dimorphic muscles” of the female, both fast (twitch) and slow (tonic) muscle fibers were of smaller diameter than in other forelimb muscles of both sexes (all male muscles plus “nondimorphic muscles” of the female). Moreover, both types of fibers were less numerous than in the corresponding muscles of the male. These results suggest that the “sexually dimorphic muscles” are used especially for clasping by the male and are degenerative or subnormal in the female. Slow muscle fibers were neither peculiar to, nor abundant in, these clasping muscles, although they may well be necessary for tonic and prolonged contractions of the forelimb muscles during clasping. The mechanism of sexual dimorphism may be a direct action of androgens on clasping muscles or an indirect action on clasping muscles via the innervating motoneurons.